Centrello v. Basky

164 Ohio St. (N.S.) 41
CourtOhio Supreme Court
DecidedJuly 13, 1955
DocketNo. 34293
StatusPublished

This text of 164 Ohio St. (N.S.) 41 (Centrello v. Basky) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Ohio Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Centrello v. Basky, 164 Ohio St. (N.S.) 41 (Ohio 1955).

Opinion

Zimmerman, J.

To gain a fair perspective of this case and of the factors which apparently influenced the jury in returning its verdict for the defendants, an outline of parts of the evidence is necessary.

At the time of his injury on the afternoon of April 9, 1952, plaintiff was 10 years of age. He was in the fourth grade of school, received good marks, was a Cub Scout and had won a number of merit awards. At the trial he testified on direct [44]*44examination that, as he was walking around the concrete mixer, he slipped on the sand, and “I made a grab for the machine with my hand, slipped off the edge of it and went in.” This was the only evidence offered by plaintiff as to how the injury occurred.

On the cross-examination of plaintiff, the following transpired :

“Q. You could hear this mixer running the day the accident happened, couldn’t you, as you came up the sidewalk? A. Yes.
“Q. And you knew that cement was being mixed inside of it? A. I didn’t know it was being mixed inside.
“Q. But you knew the mixer was running? A. Yes.
“Q. 'And you knew that it would be dangerous to put your hand into it, didn’t you? A. I don’t understand.
“Q. Well, you knew that with the machine like that running it might be dangerous if you put your hand into or against that machine, didn’t you? A. Yes.
< Í * # *
“Q. When you fell, Ronald, how did you fall, could you kind of show us ? A. I don’t recall.
“Q. You don’t recall how you did fall? A. No.
“Q. Well, would you be good enough to come down here just a minute, please. (Witness leaves the stand.)
U * # *
“Q. If you will please, pretend you are walking up the sidewalk like this, and then just show us how you walked around the mixer. Pretend that chair is the mixer. Just come over here. Just show us, if you will please, on which side of the mixer you walked? A. I walked on this side.
“Q. You walked over to the right of the mixer. Where were you when you fell? Pretend this chair is a mixer? A. I don’t recall.
“Q. Were you a little bit past the mixer or right alongside of the mixer? A. I don’t know.
. “Q. You don’t know? A. No.
“Q. Can you show us how you fell? A. No. It happened so fast I don’t know.”

On the day the injury occurred, James Basky was laying ■ [45]*45bricks in the building of a chimney. Joseph J. Basky was in charge of operating the concrete mixer and was engaged in carrying concrete in buckets from the mixer to his brother. He testified that he was never away from the mixer for more than a few minutes at any time.

The blades which caused plaintiff’s injury were on the inside of a metal drum into which sand, concrete and water were poured. Extending outward from the opening of the drum was a flange or lip some three or four inches wide, designed to prevent the mixture from slopping out of the drum.

During the construction work, a number of children of all ages and sizes frequented the premises. They were chased away repeatedly by defendants and other workmen and were told to stay away. Plaintiff’s father had warned him to stay away from the new house and not go around any house that was being built.

Neither the defendants nor three witnesses they produced actually saw the injury. The three witnesses were a real estate dealer, a lumber salesman and a carpenter-contractor.

James Basky testified:

“I heard a thump and then I turned. * * * I seen Ronnie Centrello by the mixer # * I started to come down * * # I heard Ronnie Centrello holler, ‘My God, I cut off my finger.’ ”

After he got out of his automobile and as he was approaching the house under construction by the Baskys, the real estate dealer saw two children “playing in front of the concrete mixer.” As Joseph Basky and the three witnesses referred to were talking in a driveway near the concrete mixer they heard a scream, looked and saw plaintiff standing at the far end of and facing the mixer and holding one hand with the other. Plaintiff then started to run away.

Joseph Basky, who ran and caught up with him, testified as follows:

“Well, I caught him and I asked him where he lived. I said, ‘Come on, I will take you over to your mother,’ and he said, ‘I don’t want to go home’; he said, ‘My father will give me a licking.’ So I said, ‘Well, where do you live anyway?’ and he told me the house number. * * * He said, ‘That house over there.’ I had him by the hand in the meantime, around [46]*46his wrist. I put my handkerchief over it. 1 didn’t know whether the kid would faint or not, so I thought it would be best if he didn’t see. I took him over to the house. I knocked on the front door. There was a radio or something playing there. I knocked quite loud. I got no response there, and me being a little upset myself I thought to myself: the only thing to do now is go around to the back. We come off the porch there and started around in their driveway back to the house, back to the back door. That is when Ronald’s mother came out.

“Q. You then went with Ronald and his father to the hospital? A. Yes, I did.
“Q. What did Mr. Centrello say when he first came out? A. He said ‘Ronald,’ he said, ‘It wasn’t five minutes ago I told you not to go up there,’ and he said, ‘Look and see what you done,’ he said, ‘I told you,’ and he kept saying that as we were in the car going down to the hospital.”

The carpenter-contractor testified:

“Well, after the accident he started going towards the curb of the street. Joe was more active than the rest of us. He took after the boy, grabbed his hand there, like put a tourniquet on it, I imagine, started taking the boy towards his home. The boy was crying there, started to scream. He didn’t want to go home. I think he said he didn’t want to get a licking.”

The real estate dealer, who drove plaintiff, his father and Joseph Basky to the hospital, testified:

“Q. Who went with you to the hospital? A. Mr. Centrello went along.
“Q. And Ronald and Joe Basky? A. That is right.
“Q. Did you hear Mr. Centrello make any statement, did he say anything just shortly after he got into your car? A. Yes. He said he told him not five minutes before not to go up to the new house.”

The plaintiff’s father denied he said that.

Defendants offered as a witness a seven-year old boy, named Eddie Whittaker. The court examined him and declined to allow him to testify on the ground that he appeared too young to appreciate the nature and significance of an oath. Defendants then made a proffer of the testimony the witness would give if permitted to testify, which was to the effect that [47]

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Porter v. Cornett
206 S.W.2d 83 (Court of Appeals of Kentucky (pre-1976), 1947)
Loop v. . Litchfield
42 N.Y. 351 (New York Court of Appeals, 1870)
Mudrich v. Standard Oil Co.
90 N.E.2d 859 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1950)
Masters v. New York Central Rd.
70 N.E.2d 898 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1947)
Knisely v. Community Traction Co.
180 N.E. 654 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1932)
Youngstown Municipal Ry. Co. v. Mikula
1 N.E.2d 135 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1936)
Leonardi v. A. Habermann Provision Co.
56 N.E.2d 232 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1944)
Fries v. Cincinnati Street Ry. Co.
37 N.E.2d 193 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1941)
Bradley v. Cleveland Ry. Co.
146 N.E. 805 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1925)
Bush v. Harvey Transfer Co.
67 N.E.2d 851 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1946)
Porter v. Toledo Terminal Rd.
90 N.E.2d 142 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1950)
Limbaugh v. Western Ohio Railroad
113 N.E. 687 (Ohio Supreme Court, 1916)
Tosty v. Morgan Co.
139 N.W. 402 (Wisconsin Supreme Court, 1913)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
164 Ohio St. (N.S.) 41, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/centrello-v-basky-ohio-1955.