Central Laborers' Pension Fund v. Signature Demolition Services Inc.

N.D. Illinois

Central Laborers' Pension Fund v. Signature Demolition Services Inc.

DecidedJanuary 20, 2021

Docket1:20-cv-01656

StatusUnknown

This text of Central Laborers' Pension Fund v. Signature Demolition Services Inc. (Central Laborers' Pension Fund v. Signature Demolition Services Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court, N.D. Illinois primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Central Laborers' Pension Fund v. Signature Demolition Services Inc., (N.D. Ill. 2021).

Pincite

Opinion

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION

CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, ) CENTRAL LABORERS’ WELFARE FUND (ACTIVES & ) RETIREES), ) CENTRAL LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ) HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND (“NC Welfare”), ) NORTHERN ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND ) (“NI Annuity”), ) ILLINOIS LABORERS AND CONTRACTORS JOINT ) APPRENTICESHIP & TRAINING TRUST FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION FOUNDATION FOR FAIR ) CONTRACTING (“MRFFC”), ) CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY ADVANCEMENT FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL LABORERS-EMPLOYERS ) COOPERATION AND EDUCATION TRUST, ) MARKET PROMOTION FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE, ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ VACATION FUND, and the ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ DISTRICT COUNCIL ) WORKING DUES CHECK OFF FUND ) ) Plaintiffs, ) v. ) Case No. 20-Cv-1656 ) SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., ) Judge Edmond E. Chang an Illinois corporation, ) ) Defendant. )

PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT

Plaintiffs CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, et al., by their attorneys and pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 55(b) and 54, respectfully move this Court to enter a default judgment in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., and in support of their motion Plaintiffs state as follows: 1. This is an ERISA action by fringe benefit funds to, inter alia, recover fringe benefit contributions owed to Plaintiffs. (See, e.g., Docket Entry # 1 – Complaint.) 2. Plaintiffs filed their amended complaint on March 7, 2020. (Docket Entry # 4.) The amended complaint was served on May 5, 2020. (Docket Entry # 13.) 3. In a court order entered on December 11, 2020, (Docket Entry # 28), Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC. was ordered to answer the amended complaint. The order further stated that “[i]f no answer is filed on time, then the Defendant is deemed to be in default, and the Plaintiffs shall file a motion for default judgment in a sum certain.” (Docket Entry # 28.) 4. Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC. has not filed an appearance, answer, other responsive pleading or motion.

5. Plaintiffs are entitled to a default judgment against all Defendants on the underlying claim, in an amount not less than $1,442.20, for delinquent fringe benefit contributions, work dues, liquidated late payment assessments for delinquent fringe benefit contributions, and audit costs. In support, Plaintiffs attach the Affidavit of Plaintiffs’ Employer Contributions Department Director Larry Sciortino as Exhibit A. 6. ERISA provides that upon recovery of unpaid benefit contributions by a fiduciary of a benefit plan, “the court shall award the plan…reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of the action, to be paid by the defendant.” 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g)(2)(D) (emphasis added). An award of attorneys' fees under this section is non-discretionary. Plumbers' Pension Fund v. Domas Mech. Contractors, Inc., 778 F.2d 1266, 1271 (7th Cir. 1985); Laborers' Pension Fund v. Blackmore

Sewer Const., Inc., 298 F.3d 600, 608 (7th Cir. 2002). The Seventh Circuit flatly rejected the notion that the fees must be calculated proportionally to damages, opining that “it is absolutely permissible to spend $100,000 litigating what is known to be a $10,000 claim if that is a reasonable method of achieving the result.” Anderson v. AB Painting, 578 F.3d 542, 546 (7th Cir. 2009). 7. With entry of default judgment, Plaintiffs are entitled to an award of reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs pursuant to § 1132(g)(2)(D). 8. Plaintiffs expended $605.00 in court filing fees, process server fees, deposition services, and related costs in this action. (See Exhibit B.) 9. Plaintiffs expended not less than $3,602.50 in attorney’s fees in this action. (See Exhibit B.) 10. In support of an additional money judgment in the amount of $4,207.50 for costs ($605.00) and attorneys’ fees ($3,602.50) to date, Plaintiffs attach a fees and costs affidavit as Exhibit B.

11. The total judgment amount will therefore be $5,649.70 ($1,442.20 + $4,207.50). WHEREFORE, pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 55(b) and 54, Plaintiffs respectfully ask that the Court enter a default judgment in an amount not less than $5,649.70 in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC.

Respectfully submitted, CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, et al.

By: /s/ Richard A. Toth Richard A. Toth DALEY AND GEORGES, LTD. Attorneys for Plaintiffs 20 S. Clark St., Suite 400 Chicago, IL 60603-1835 (312) 726-8797 rtoth@daleygeorges.com UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, ) CENTRAL LABORERS* WELFARE FUND (ACTIVES & } RETIREES), } CENTRAL LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ) HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND (“NC Welfare”), ) NORTHERN ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND ) (“NI Annuity”), ) TLLINOIS LABORERS AND CONTRACTORS JOINT } APPRENTICESHIP & TRAINING TRUST FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION FOUNDATION FOR FAIR ) CONTRACTING (“MREFC’, } CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY ADVANCEMENT FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL LABORERS-EMPLOYERS } COOPERATION AND EDUCATION TRUST, } MARKET PROMOTION FUND, } MIDWEST REGION ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE, ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ VACATION FUND, and the } GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ DISTRICT COUNCIL } WORKING DUES CHECK OFF FUND } ) Plaintiffs, ) v. ) Case No, 20-Cy-1656 ) SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., ) Judge Edmond E. Chang an Illinois corporation, ) ) Defendant. ) AFFIDAVIT OF LARRY SCIORTINO ! I, Larry Sciortino, affiant, being first duly sworn on oath, depose and say as follows: I am presently the Employer Contributions Department Director of the CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND and affiliated fringe benefit funds (the “Funds”). By virtue of my authority in that position I have direct personal knowledge of all facts stated in this Affidavit and if called as a witness could give testimony with respect thereto. Zs Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC. owes the Funds not less than $1,442.20, consisting of audited delinquent fringe benefit contributions, participant work dues, late payment assessments for delinquent fringe benefit contributions and audit costs (but exclusive of attorney fees and court costs), The original, total amount owed was not less than $13,829.17, however $12,386.97 has been paid to date, leaving a balance due of $1,442.21. Ihave attached to my affidavit a schedule detatling the original outstanding contributions and penalties due, marked Sciortino Exhibit 1 and made a part hereof. (The schedule does not reflect the $12,386.97 paid to date.)

Exhibit A Page A-1

5, A copy of the underlying audit report (with employee social security numbers redacted) is attached as Sciortino Exhibit 2. 4, A copy of the audit invoice, which has been paid by Plaintiffs, is attached as Sctortino Exhibit 3. 5. The Trustees of the CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND and affiliated fringe benefit funds have retained the law firm of Daley and Georges, Ltd., 20 S. Clark Street, Chicago, Illinois, to pursue the collection of the above-stated delinquent contributions and assessment penalties and have made payments to that law firm for legal fees incurred in the collection of the assessments.

Ee SCIORTINO Subscribed and sworn to before me this January \9 , 2021.

NOTARY PUBLIC J OFFICIALSEAL notAn rome

Exhibit A Page A-2

SCIORTINO EXHIBIT 1

Revised 7/27/20 Signature Demolition Services, Inc, 7548 W 83rd Pl.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION

CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, ) CENTRAL LABORERS’ WELFARE FUND (ACTIVES & ) RETIREES), ) CENTRAL LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ) HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND (“NC Welfare”), ) NORTHERN ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND ) (“NI Annuity”), ) ILLINOIS LABORERS AND CONTRACTORS JOINT ) APPRENTICESHIP & TRAINING TRUST FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION FOUNDATION FOR FAIR ) CONTRACTING (“MRFFC”), ) CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY ADVANCEMENT FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL LABORERS-EMPLOYERS ) COOPERATION AND EDUCATION TRUST, ) MARKET PROMOTION FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE, ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ VACATION FUND, and the ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ DISTRICT COUNCIL ) WORKING DUES CHECK OFF FUND ) ) Plaintiffs, ) v. ) Case No. 20-Cv-1656 ) SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., ) Judge Edmond E. Chang an Illinois corporation, ) ) Defendant. )

PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR DEFAULT JUDGMENT

Plaintiffs CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, et al., by their attorneys and pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 55(b) and 54, respectfully move this Court to enter a default judgment in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., and in support of their motion Plaintiffs state as follows: 1. This is an ERISA action by fringe benefit funds to, inter alia, recover fringe benefit contributions owed to Plaintiffs. (See, e.g., Docket Entry # 1 – Complaint.) 2. Plaintiffs filed their amended complaint on March 7, 2020. (Docket Entry # 4.) The amended complaint was served on May 5, 2020. (Docket Entry # 13.) 3. In a court order entered on December 11, 2020, (Docket Entry # 28), Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC. was ordered to answer the amended complaint. The order further stated that “[i]f no answer is filed on time, then the Defendant is deemed to be in default, and the Plaintiffs shall file a motion for default judgment in a sum certain.” (Docket Entry # 28.) 4. Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC. has not filed an appearance, answer, other responsive pleading or motion.

5. Plaintiffs are entitled to a default judgment against all Defendants on the underlying claim, in an amount not less than $1,442.20, for delinquent fringe benefit contributions, work dues, liquidated late payment assessments for delinquent fringe benefit contributions, and audit costs. In support, Plaintiffs attach the Affidavit of Plaintiffs’ Employer Contributions Department Director Larry Sciortino as Exhibit A. 6. ERISA provides that upon recovery of unpaid benefit contributions by a fiduciary of a benefit plan, “the court shall award the plan…reasonable attorney’s fees and costs of the action, to be paid by the defendant.” 29 U.S.C. § 1132(g)(2)(D) (emphasis added). An award of attorneys' fees under this section is non-discretionary. Plumbers' Pension Fund v. Domas Mech. Contractors, Inc., 778 F.2d 1266, 1271 (7th Cir. 1985); Laborers' Pension Fund v. Blackmore

Sewer Const., Inc., 298 F.3d 600, 608 (7th Cir. 2002). The Seventh Circuit flatly rejected the notion that the fees must be calculated proportionally to damages, opining that “it is absolutely permissible to spend $100,000 litigating what is known to be a $10,000 claim if that is a reasonable method of achieving the result.” Anderson v. AB Painting, 578 F.3d 542, 546 (7th Cir. 2009). 7. With entry of default judgment, Plaintiffs are entitled to an award of reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs pursuant to § 1132(g)(2)(D). 8. Plaintiffs expended $605.00 in court filing fees, process server fees, deposition services, and related costs in this action. (See Exhibit B.) 9. Plaintiffs expended not less than $3,602.50 in attorney’s fees in this action. (See Exhibit B.) 10. In support of an additional money judgment in the amount of $4,207.50 for costs ($605.00) and attorneys’ fees ($3,602.50) to date, Plaintiffs attach a fees and costs affidavit as Exhibit B.

11. The total judgment amount will therefore be $5,649.70 ($1,442.20 + $4,207.50). WHEREFORE, pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure 55(b) and 54, Plaintiffs respectfully ask that the Court enter a default judgment in an amount not less than $5,649.70 in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC.

Respectfully submitted, CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, et al.

By: /s/ Richard A. Toth Richard A. Toth DALEY AND GEORGES, LTD. Attorneys for Plaintiffs 20 S. Clark St., Suite 400 Chicago, IL 60603-1835 (312) 726-8797 rtoth@daleygeorges.com UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, ) CENTRAL LABORERS* WELFARE FUND (ACTIVES & } RETIREES), } CENTRAL LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ) HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND (“NC Welfare”), ) NORTHERN ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND ) (“NI Annuity”), ) TLLINOIS LABORERS AND CONTRACTORS JOINT } APPRENTICESHIP & TRAINING TRUST FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION FOUNDATION FOR FAIR ) CONTRACTING (“MREFC’, } CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY ADVANCEMENT FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL LABORERS-EMPLOYERS } COOPERATION AND EDUCATION TRUST, } MARKET PROMOTION FUND, } MIDWEST REGION ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE, ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ VACATION FUND, and the } GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ DISTRICT COUNCIL } WORKING DUES CHECK OFF FUND } ) Plaintiffs, ) v. ) Case No, 20-Cy-1656 ) SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., ) Judge Edmond E. Chang an Illinois corporation, ) ) Defendant. ) AFFIDAVIT OF LARRY SCIORTINO ! I, Larry Sciortino, affiant, being first duly sworn on oath, depose and say as follows: I am presently the Employer Contributions Department Director of the CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND and affiliated fringe benefit funds (the “Funds”). By virtue of my authority in that position I have direct personal knowledge of all facts stated in this Affidavit and if called as a witness could give testimony with respect thereto. Zs Defendant SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC. owes the Funds not less than $1,442.20, consisting of audited delinquent fringe benefit contributions, participant work dues, late payment assessments for delinquent fringe benefit contributions and audit costs (but exclusive of attorney fees and court costs), The original, total amount owed was not less than $13,829.17, however $12,386.97 has been paid to date, leaving a balance due of $1,442.21. Ihave attached to my affidavit a schedule detatling the original outstanding contributions and penalties due, marked Sciortino Exhibit 1 and made a part hereof. (The schedule does not reflect the $12,386.97 paid to date.)

Exhibit A Page A-1

5, A copy of the underlying audit report (with employee social security numbers redacted) is attached as Sciortino Exhibit 2. 4, A copy of the audit invoice, which has been paid by Plaintiffs, is attached as Sctortino Exhibit 3. 5. The Trustees of the CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND and affiliated fringe benefit funds have retained the law firm of Daley and Georges, Ltd., 20 S. Clark Street, Chicago, Illinois, to pursue the collection of the above-stated delinquent contributions and assessment penalties and have made payments to that law firm for legal fees incurred in the collection of the assessments.

Ee SCIORTINO Subscribed and sworn to before me this January \9 , 2021.

NOTARY PUBLIC J OFFICIALSEAL notAn rome

Exhibit A Page A-2

SCIORTINO EXHIBIT 1

Revised 7/27/20 Signature Demolition Services, Inc, 7548 W 83rd Pl. Bridgewiew, IL 60455-1703 Acct #; 15526 Audit Llabllitles (06/01/2016-05/31/2020) Pension $2,460.32 PSUPP 2,693.04 Welfare 1,546,20 RTREW 85.40 NC Welfare 1,076.80 Annuity 1,100.50 Training 299.20 CELECET 68.16 NC LECET 25,24 Cl MRFFC 24,40 NC MRFFC 14.84 CIBIAF 69.62 CI LEGAL 14.40 NC LPL 5.90 NC Mktpres . 177,82, Cl Checkoff 31.50 SC Vacation 542.00 NC Vacation 109.60 Cl Work Dues 505.64 NC Work Dues 220.14 Subtotal $11,070.72 Liquidated Damages 1,107,07 Audit Cost 1,651,383 Total $13,829.17 $13,829.17 - Grand Total Due $13,829.17 □

Exhibit A Page A-3

. SCIO

- TINO EXH IBIT

ee ee as rail 23 Pa Egeatae as

a peli, ES Wee

4 egbeck ao o

z nein - Be gs

2s eeetes g lH

a a2 Eeeos £5 i Ha

Es ego8 guge38 2 : He

pichebalade □□□ z 32 Peece

dnl 22% Be 2s S50Ss

3 a5 ppeg ices 2523 ge ;

Boe sre’ £5 Zgae 25 H HH

Bolg Bake q 2° gé& ees

By HOU set: 5s 5 ESESRE

| ag 228 Sess aE > Bp E .

palltnis 55 e2 Seegte

silt z Bo93 ae se eeEiss

Bees fs57e8 She a 5 Bs ne

SS 323 2 23 ES eebees

Seer B8e52e gage 2 sila

Setsosteeet BeBe — &s Es 6 □

au bees 3 BE88 a &= as BoEaas

anu Eege 2 Se RES

iblests Bee #& Bes epee!

a beatae 3B 3 ao 5 Eos eg

3 aEEEG PERS baie a8 en

egceeue8y § offs 2 gf fl ne

esefagbis! =eS8 & Ban Sfiebe

BSe> 5 gage eas bs. □□

Ue ge gees Sykes E*ee & nee att eid

Se Te Egbg 2 i ee

we Ez een HE □ i ti

pg a358 siyibiri B58 5 85 eee ee, 3

2s SP5ags oz ga & as5¢ eas sEeess

al iy ug a5 50 £ ef5 eae G2 ac

O32 Bag = ef25pze gs 2 e838 2a § selaa;

| Ht] inl Baas E Bea £.8 252d3%

Oz o§ =e geese ages £ Boe BE

5 I HEH eee? 2st Sia a

i au 2! g 8 SEE ew? Buses og

: Hl a si-8 8 SESE a SEB ebrEtt:

rE 3s gf Sies oD £ 283 : : na

CY ae s2EPeess ce gupg a cus □□ eee

Erepeds ° 8 gs 8 □□□ oP B52

g28355 gr 3. segeeee He i <5 2 B3o2 = ee Ssgee

ae 2es a coy Ses ; se!

ee Ese! i £2 age Be

sti 5 Be ese suseeee

a Oo ces Bas 5 pogo)

: Bae ass Beeeeel

_ £E5 STE Ssksees sa

ge Zz See gg osu 2 pabuer pcre S2m5% ga 2 Se2e za eshs oSg2bcuE couiners gayt ise gees zeee Eseope & nye i □ BS & 9 8s 2 \ i ' t

eA age A-4

= a ow 5 28 5 2 3 a 8 <8 BRB oF os 8 € 2 a 2 3S = Se Qu 3 3 - & & Qe □ oo BS ¢ $3 3 8&8 8 &€ = EF e@ ¢ § 8B «= 5 a o = = 2 ae 5 oC 56s ‘a w ze @ bE ag; 3 eee gs 2 § € £8 58 a 225 = #3 8 # o € 3 2 $a L xe § RE bos 3 6G 5 2 = = 5 © os 2 = 2 2 x8 £ 5 5 £8 £ a uw ‘9 s a“ 8 5 2 SR o£ D2 o § © o ef 2 iz S$ 52 @ ee oc > » © 2 82 § S88 □ 2 @2 £ 25 □□ B $2 5 BE 2 5885 oe Gy ge 2 £ 2 = @ 6 = oe 38 o 5°43 & & oa = > of DTD ER 88 Pf gs ato & 6 @ 5a § OS Ge oS B 3 3S fps = 2 38 □ E38 gs o¢ Oo = a ? S25 3B z= g a ae 56 & > & 3 8 ERa 8 S se $2 5 88 fe BB bt & £ #2 85 "Ec 2 ze 2£ £2 € y® 82 pS + £ 6 23s E B 2 Bu > EB Ge 3 £ § San z 3 9 gf 3 BE 29 8% = a =D fs 3 2 282 e2eg 8 2 22 2 22 £8 88 & s§ S EF ov $88 2288 2 § 8B 526 ss Se € 8 & Seo ssfze 8 2 BE BESS 28 G2 = 5 = £ = 5 o 8 & 5 8288 ge58 2, P 28 S250 $3 58 25 8s a £€8cs 2888 Sh 8 $5 23 TE = se a Effeacseee BS go ES BLES Bo fs 3 a8 @ g§8SZe552,882 sR 8 ss Baye §2 3% o «© 8 BesesSSezeSQRSRB2 285 & Bu ES eo a 2 af SG. V2a8—5RSESS55 2a v oS ESas S23 88 iz oie Gsoureg eae oo 8 8 ge BE Egsceagesege av — gc softs Ee as #5 ge fobScaosmusd 83 L BZ dE6se 33 a8 Of OO co 0 v00 sooo FS o £28 2 © mea Ga = oa oi +

: Ge 52 OG Se 50 a6 ge 8 — 43 i s Ba i2| 8 o 8 ca - os “aon 28 £5 J = 63 oC { ee ean fz = Se ao _i £3 a2 £ <3 u oe (4 Ze 2 a2 NE is ge £m -_ bz, Nal age 83 g22 22.8

ege eeee sa8S fae eoas

Exhibit A Page A-5

□□ el zrololt S$ |9eeoL $|oO00rea S$ Seizlz $i - $! - | | wiol | = es saree yobs Siogoz. S| - □□ - $! [| _9N Sand = sist = ${ ${-_.. __15 SANG WHOM! oyeol siorse $loni $ioces 3: - $ $ | ON NOLLWOVA joozre $l oombS S| □ —_—_$| ____| _gsnouvowa fee | | 19 dad BHO! woul} $ | face gee 4 £3. | Susana = $[ = $ Sete tee zgeo PO's eros S| □□ □□ S$) Aviad} fer Smee § coe oe = $$ Orr S| - $lors 3 - $s] - gS west Slope [00D Sherr, □ □□ $ geo S| $iere - $ 1913931 war —— Sunn ogool Slorcs zrzze Sl eczel S| ALINNNY ogero'r $logie slocze slovecos ¢ [2-- $e | ON SEW 1SAA forse og] = Slorse os) | | MaMLY jocers: - glovops: $) - - - $ ___ ava} Wasege $0rest _${vouv2 | opts _$| = S| = $ ddN§ NOISNAd zeoor'z $loroci alice: $|oossr | - 3] = $[ NOISNad fWwioL jozoz—feboz —[aLoz ALOZ Shoe ps esd ft oo ozoz “pe Ae) =—OL groz‘baunr oe BNGSLNNOWV AO ANVWINS TVlOL “Ul SAD1Alag Oleg aunyeubis

o 9 es □ of 5a zs 2 o =_ = — Bgipese Eg sf 2 ERE 8 eeSseo2 ct eg 3S § 3B 8S 5 oper 28 Sée 8 ce a 2esg 2B Bf og = w 5 x = =z zB Beestiscts ff, Bef 8 2 Bg □□ SqgkShagoe □□ 0 2 & 3 3 & BESSoREESZ —E8> s 5 5&5 sf8eae 95 £52 3 5 $a 8 & SGEELASRcas BES SFR 2 2 & So =Pfat.s E2 sa o 9 8 6 = PEaobuesgeee2 fog Eqs a o9 & © FeepesecgS elo ER F SF Ff SE B eeS-Sece88$5 ses Pol □□ □□ 2 Boas®Fssse gig 58 § 5 §& 8 2B Beesetscez Bo 385 5 5 5 & @ Be Bqeoisess2 2a 26 2 ee fe ge 2803857583 225 2 3 2 333 a Enea ea23 Q= & £ fs £O£: eises betes 8 ge See tb USB gays Ba 38520 28% 5 © 2 OSt goa> Yo S@Efot Sass wf o® rt €BS teeo fe op LEGEag ey SoS 9985 89 Sus 8428S sae 2 LSEsssegses 883 285 GS Ss SEE SOBs □□ 5 eesfatus Ses g 5 c = Exs5ueeied gon 2 gsecipieisy gio cis ; 28e8sa32 z = =f ! SEZ doepsessree Seq 328 2,2 □□ su2'22 o = a eex 2 gSesess Bes Fc ofessslesses WES EF posesst esse Fes 252 ySpezosezeze en3 2 Bosse Be soe BUEHSESHE RB Be Qo5 = phtavssebss 68 SS= Sein 3F3g S SSeseSseqomn 38 = osososoetota® 2 aa eseakas B35 □□□ Pueueasarus > weess Te®Beo FoS aS BEPEVSBVSSSHBE poe wn B5aea □□□ eee Bes BESS=EB8e88 8588 = 5 a E GOR SESPece sees 285 gee 5 ae assrosoee%2 oe 28 x 8 aor 7 FaSsEsae eos 228 ces & = 3 Suu YW SPER okas ge 222 & E o 6 Sos 5 £eeseessees Ess 8 sek B25 Z F@sstsntso2 nee cle F fF &ePR B

Exhibit A Page A-6

oot 00% 000% 0007 One ‘tOOe coe coor ono oane OS NCLLYOVA oars pore: oOzz ouzz COEz ze wz ooze Ore nee onze ore 495300 aYOM caro ogFo . coro aD onto ero cero alo oro ao ao one swig core ooro on pale oalo oro cole oOo ‘OOLo ooo oor corn pou pero oazo ero azo azo oro csr oarp OBZ 0 b1393T ooe"o 0080 ooro como 0080 oso coro coro ooeD oo8'o ONIN ‘o0sE ooge pe post one nee bose o08"E BEE Te ze RTE ALTNNY OSe°0 oseo oro ost0 osEo osEQ oto oso 0° oseD osteo ost'o MaULYE are oases ore oes □□□ Eo osEo oes 68s ses 056s awa, Ole ose ose. ows oe ose os OL ores, Onerh ore's ‘Ore's dd NS NOISNAd one ores we oh ors ore ore orcs one wre NOISNSd sry ts ooos ones on'ts oes cous ores Ber 1S coos: oot ooDs ones onos -AUNGEN TROL □□ RLIS ores ooos 008 ones oo'sLs ooos: ooot ovos ooos OS NOLLYD LENS oo0s ooros oo0s ous wot Orzls 00's: ooros: cous ons ns 19 S3N0 SHOMA pros oooF wos go'os co's 000s Pros 000s ooos: coos ooos oros: dviEId cass ores orcs ores ores wos 000g orgst ogos ogos: oot ooos ons” Hosa *ORLS ‘oos coos cous ons o0'Os we'as 00'os oo0s: wt ooos ores 1943981 ooos coos opus ooos 00°08. orers ooros oo'os 00's ores: onos SONNE oeeozs ooos ovot ores ages ‘oot oor oveizs oot ooos oo'oe ooos onos AJLINNNY ofoes ovos op'os woe ooos ooos ores o70s oous cont eos Maa oreoEs oot ooot cous OOF or Bess onus 00'0F OOos oon oros auWITAM ‘as'Sths oot coos or 0s ors sere eros ooog oo os coo oars: ddfS NOISNEd tests ‘00s coos oo'os ovos os: canes ous oo0s op Os cons ores NOISNSd ooas ooo oro oo oo oro oes ooo oD 000 ooo nD UNO} sanéiay poyodeun = oes wo oo nO ooo ore oo oo'es oo oo oro ooo oOo cava ‘SusaNnys Jequeceg] = BqWARON — JOqUIED vequaydeg yeniny Aor unr fay Indy ue Kenge; enuer 4AR[-BS] :]E907 GLOZILEIZ} - GLOZ/L/L Popad 404 SuNO} JEINGey peyodaupy

Pa a peptone OT i i oe ba aaa Ber) S| - Slerore') $ = $s] - $ gn WWLOL opzee $| - $logv, S| - $i] - §| $ 19 SING WOM org) $| - $/oro § I 2 - SCS] 2S NOLLYOVA - Siero S| $[ = st { —__ Aviad) os $|- Sloss □□ Bye $ 19 944K -eol $| - $ = si - □□ 1918931 [orev = = S| OF ov $i - $| $ _____ ONINIVSL oreo S| = some $i: § ALIN foroz S| - Sforor sf s|- pelle MaaLy orase ¢ ores - $s] - al ae... __.__ assey $ essey | - f= tl $ __dd NOISN2d weose = woe S| - $$) = $f = $y ___NOISN3d| TWLOL 6102 S102 £102 $L0e 4. Pd Te ft : ozoz ‘re AEM) OL hoz ‘Reun IWOOT ~ 3NG SLNNOWY 40 AYNVAINS seal “SU ‘Sed|AIEg OWE eunjeubig

ope Exhibit A Page A-7

oon 00% oanz onaz 000% a00z 00% 900% ooo care cave 28 NOLLVOVA ore oe wee ooze owe ee ooze wore wore once ouzz wore to Sang OM. ono oaLo oho geo osro oaro oo oo aro oro awed oor coro ooo gore 0019 □□□ oro oro oor oon Noadu □□□ aero pao oeza oaz'D oezo osza aera oszn oeca ea397 oo8"o ons" oor ‘oog'O □□□ oorg coro oso coro coro ‘ONIN oe oe were oes care ost ove ore OBrE cSze □ AUDNNW osco ecco oo ofeo oro 0560 oseD oo ose'D osr'o ose'o Ose'O MALY osee ose'8 O56°8 oe ose'o ose's ‘OSes one's □□□ aevaTam os Ok ose One Ose ows o1ss ose ove'o ores one's Ores dd NS NOISNSd one □□□ one oreo ore Ores oe ore ores ore oree NOISNGd sry opzrees = on'Os ones oor0s ores cons Ossels arses ooros oo ezzs: coos Aen mo. orgies oot coos ojos ooo ones o07Os cots oo □□□ oot 00'Os COOLS oOts 3S NOLLWOWA oo zees ores onas opros ons ones 00S oozeLs ooest onus op Ets □□□ 19 84a OM erers = nos ones oxos woot e008 os ae at cons ones ss swe! orors = oves ovos ops woos ones oo'os ores ones oves pong ewes ovat IS agHr □□ □□□ ooos oat oooe ous ares ooas ores Olle coos □□ ors owes 43931 ores = □□□ aos ones aves cous overs = oozes os ones ores oves ‘ONINIVELL ‘CE aRES onus oros ooros oot od'os opps Lies Os rrlt onos wears ones ALSINNG OsZEs onos oo'Ds corns: o0'es oo0s ores wos Ooos: oes ores MLL oozeos onos ao'os ooos o0'os ones coos oOOLeSS Oo'rset ooros oorat: Os tet oo'et Suva ‘TLSORS ooos ooros ons ooros: Ones o9'osrs orodss ores terse gous NOISNSd ee ees oo'os ooos ooos: boos ooos coos Or vars op ses coos ores ets ‘os NOISNSd oo'8o} ooo ooo ooo oo ono ooo ooor ooo oO coe ooo SUNDH 2hINBeY PaHOcUN OgnE oo wo oot ooo ooo ono oo'oe 000 ono oe oo oro ‘SIMON ‘HLINS: = orae ooo o0'0 an‘o oo'0 ooo ano ooroe 000, 900 ooo oD ooo NYSHOW ‘T1ssnY ae OOee ooo ooo ore 000 ooo ooo ooo oor O70 oro oe oro ‘SHBA = ooo ooo ooo ooo ooo ooo oo oo wor ooo ora ooo oot NYida ‘YSAN0 OL J2qUETAN QUAN Jagdeo saquindag jenny Apr sun coy tach duet Aenged — Aisnver UODEUEgS, 28907 GhOZ/LCIZ) - GLOZ/LI) Poyied 104 ssinoy senBey peyodaiuy AVM 1D - "DUI ‘SaD|Aleg Oued almjeubis

a —_{__ Se ee ooze § opeze $[ = = sy = sg) ana ; | pee ey ogee 8) $losvee | = 8) $j - 8 to |___19 SANG OO'OLZ $ = $ | oo'glz $ □ iS $ = $s! 35 NOLLVOVA 2 — ~ 34 [2s Nouv SSR Pa Sa | Te ee pee ee oro) et □□□ Se ee □□□ $= Sede gs | ss go ores s| = Sjoves os] =e sn wees = - zeose - $s] - $i - OB Ze $ = $! op Ze SF 8S □□ ogzeg $ | - $i oszg ¢| - $] - $ Bae) $) - $lesop - $]/ - □□□ - dans NOISNSd $| - Slew $) - $(_= ${ - gt ___ NOISNAd| viol lozoz ab0z a eer ee 1 = po ze Aen fone UOdeW TYD071 ~ ANd SLNNOWY 40 ANVINIANS oe "SU ‘Saa[Ales Ouleg eamjeubig

ope Exhibit A Page A-&

ooro 02'0 ooo ooo boro ozo 020 Lo ool oO 0026 ‘ON NOWYOVA O6e"h Beh gel OSE ose CET Det OSE) ON S3ueL LW oso’o oso'o ogoo os0°0 oso os00 oro osoo soo osoo ON sro 84D OSLO Cale o6LD oero oto oo oro one Amat ono OO oro oO ono ore oro oro oro polo Oro ooo on Ogu obo n66'0 □□□ □□□ □□□ sr BLO ero oslo oaLo orn ogra ON 45081 ooo o08'0 ana"o ogo o08'o eo ono 0080 ooo oos'0 ‘OMINEWELL est ose ose ose oEs'e oce2 ofcz mre O8lz oe ALDNNY oe ore ote ore 002s ore wore Doe. oor, ooere ore ON AYVITM o0’e OOL'o o0L'e ool oore Ore oss oss oss oss ddltS NOISNEE 00's o00'9 00's 900d 00's ‘00'S O93 corre, bOO'S coos. oo0'e NOISNSd see gr'ces'l$ orot ooos oo'os erses'ls □ ones cous 000s ores oro coos nous Aarqer] ROL Oc ess oo0s ous wos oress ores ooos oous coos 000s □□ □□ oot ON NOLLVOVA, yercolt oros on'os: oo pesOle oo'0s ovos coos os ogas orDs coos oot ON Sadi ores eo'os ores ores ores ovos cous cous oo'os oo'oe os ON GT pres on'os oo'Ds br Pls orcs ooos coos oo: os 0s ooos coos awe oE'BS ooos os o0'Os ret ones ovos coor aos ores ooos oor ON Sat pris poo oorot □□□ ooos oos ops: ores oo'os coos os nN 13937 □□□ eros bores 00s obo: on0s Orns ous ooos: ores ops was ‘SNINIVEL sels oot oo'os opos sc teis ooos ooo oes oo'os: ores ovos cons: wos AUNNNY OrEZes prot ‘oOs cons oe czos ores coos ons oor ores coos ones: OOF ON SUYs1aM Oo ooos coos ooros; on tars oo'os ones oor0s ooros boos ‘oo'os O's ous dd NOISNSd DORSeS oos: ooros OOOSrS eons 00s cons: ooes coos os: coos NOISNSd i a a ee ee eng Sumouny owe oo oso ovo ores ooo oop ooo oro oon ooo oro oso SinoH 2enBay pspodevur) 7 ‘o0'ee 000 oon one apres ooo 000 ooo oon ooo 0o'0 coro ooo “Wived "SVIWOHL = 0O'Bs 000 oo ooo ores oOo ooo ooo oo oon ooo oo oro Agu ‘ASSOVIN ro JRqWECEG QURAN BQORO saquendeg endo Ane eunt fa dy Uae fusruge4 AIBNUET ze e307 BLOZLEIZL - SLOzIL/L poued Joy . sunoy seindsy payodauy AVMd 19 - *3u] ‘seqyueg OWag aunjzeUBig

Exhibit A Page A-9

pote ons’ ooz'a cou’ caso coro ooo 000 oop coz" coxa ON NOLLVS¥A □□□ nee’! ee", ert ose nee" ose's o8eh 08s ‘ON S3etLW oso oso'o □□□ 0800 og0'0 oso ns00 esgD osa'o ooo ON 787 Bizo azo ozo ozo ozo ozo azo 0510 9510 aio ovo WIBID eet orto ozie ecto ozo ono oD ouvo ono ‘ON O4:aN 02D ozo onz'o or ooze enzo woo oso sto oau'o ero OW 43931 0080 one". ooe'D pogo” ons'o coB'o 0050 evra sore ons‘ ONINIVELL 008% ooez oz oust mos cone oesz ose ANN n0r'8 nore core ooF'e 08 bap's core core ore oaze gaze ooze ON 0028 oor aoa one'a ooze cua core core ore core oore dafis NOISNEd o09'8 8009 o00'9 ono'e eae o00'8 coore 00's Ono's 00's. onge NoIsnaa i a ovis ooo ores ooros onos cores orizus vos coro: orrns ooros ous □□□ ~ Aa OL ones ons onros oe'ag oo'o8 oo'es oorles ooras coos ovas oros ooros coos” ON NOWLYOWA. Ores ones: ovas ooras ores Og ies oorns toot cos oo'os ogres o'os ON See oss ones: 0008 ovos oor coor ols ares pons ores ons ones vorok ores ones: pros ooras oot coos: ores porns porot ores ores ons woe svar ores oo'os: nous ous ooos ooos ogres ooos ooros oot ovos ogos oo0s OR OSIM oores agus: onus onus ov'os coos noes ooros ooras eos ones ooros oovos 9NJ39R1 ooezs ooos cores onos poros oor ogos cores ogas ooras ooos ONINIVEL oorras ooros: ones oorns ooor boos bores cores ooros coos gos ogros ooras AUNnNNY cozszs «= actos: pores ons 200s ooros oozzs = ogos cores opos: corns ooros ooros ON SeWTaMA eons = DoD orras: oras poos ons oozes owas covet oons onas dd tS NOISNS noose = go's ores ones bora ogre eo'ols = as oorot eos: corns ooros ooros NOrSNE eta ttt ee ESR ac aienee eT ee ooo ogo wo mon oooE wo oo ooo oro ooo ooo Soy sens y PALOBeuy) □□□ 00 ovo ooo ooo ooo one oro ooo oo oon ooo oro OWAWOH ‘TLLNYD: OL Jequizceg §=JaquanON = JeqORID Rquewdeg pniny Ang fey ey yaueyy dergey = Apnuer zee *yeo07 GHOZ/LENZL - BLOZILL pOLed 404 uno} seinBey papodaruy AVM 1 ‘Saayiag aanyeuBys mee ee eae

oss mOsS moss moss 6089 Kors 0s'§ 405s yore moss wang BUDOM, ey oepzis on'os ‘ores Opezis anos oros oo0s ooros ooos ores o0'os Amnoer 08 Orszié = US wos: ont ogszi¢ = og De ono vos ogos ovot ovos ooros 008 sang Buppoyn, eng sumomy oseez'es coos □□□ ones Opeez'zs = DoOs ooras 20'oe coos ons ooos 36ey4 seuip rae, payodauuy Oster □□ 00°0S ores: anos ors Nos ons over ogot oon wos “W¥d “SVOHL = Os LbL'Ls = do's oo0s e0'0s OBES ones ovat ooras oons ogag oo'os ooras AQ “ABSOVIN TOL JeqUEneC) «= AQWEADH Jaquades yeniny Ane aun fey ay yey henge, =| kere Ze :Je907 SLOZILEIEL ~ SLOZ/LIE Poed 104 soBeqa S015 popodaun AVAd'T9 * 3u] ‘sezjeg aunyeuBis

Exhibit A

moss mors e0s"s 5605'S 05'S mass Kose 0's was's mass OS'S “bang BunpoNy Sour vst ones anos Oo'0s ones oros weesd ‘o'Os ous oros oes wot ARETE OL, rss oores oous coos ones ooros vs'rss coos cos ogres ones opos ‘sang Buon, ang srmeury svloss = ovat oo'0s wot bo'ot o's seteds = po'0s ooos ones ons aos anos 28am Ssarg feIO1 Payodaruy) sv 168s ones agos ooo coos SrLees = ODS oo'os 90°0s ones ons: coves OusWwoH ‘AINYD Fao seqUIEZeg | FAQUBAON = leqUPO seqwades jsniny for heya iedy ey Aengqed Arenuer :1E907 GLOZ/LEIZL - G2LOZIL/L Pouad 104 sabe ssaig payodauy 19 - “9u] ‘Seo]Nag OWSY cuNjeUBys Rey Lies ee et ee Oe eel eect ee ee Se ee cee eet ee

oo00 ono ooo'a o00'0 000 cone once 0000 cao’ e009 ON NOWLWSWA. on0'e noo 000 sooo e000 nope o00'b cone ooo'o nooo coon e000 ON Sau ooo oon’ oon 000 e000 e000 poerg ore. 900'0 cooe onoo ON TdT oro e000 000° pogo boo'a oonra cosa oo'e o00'0 aWIBID 0000 oo0'o ooo coro nooo ooo ooo ona'o o00'o ooore e000 ON OUsuA ooo ooo'o coo" o00'D e000 neo poo'o vo0'o ooo ceo’ e000 ‘ON W951 ono8 0000 woo 000’ □□□ wore ooge oon oo 00'0 ‘SONINIVELL ouee: onez ore cee wee woe oorz poe eee oeee ose AUINNN ooo ooo sooo ooo nooo core oog'o □□□ e090 oot ON SEVSTEM, D0 ooo" oo0'o 000°0 00'6 ooera ooo onoo ono’. 000 NOIGNSd 0000 ooo'0 ooo'o ovo 00 poo cove cone ooo oo 0000 coro NOISN3d oes pores: ope o0'0s ons poos ores os oo'ns aoros oo'as poet co'ot Augen yao. ones ores =" ooos coos Do's: ons onos oarns poros oorot ops, ‘ON NOLLWOWA boos Ogos ops oros 000s oorns 008 000s oo'os ooras cous oot ON SSH on'o$. oyos onr0s ones bots ores ones og'os o0'0s once cons: ONT ones ones cos ooas ovas ons over onus ones on'og og'te ‘pone ¥IEIg ones eoos arog ooas ores Coot oot ores: ones gros coos ON ovat os ons ooros ooos coros cos ogos oes aos oos □□□ pot ‘ON 13937 ores boos aot ooos ovos Ocoee ones o's bods OCs onros ‘SONINWAL ores nos oo'os oon ooos ores ooo coos: cous onus 20s coos ALNNY boot ogos ones ooras coos ones cores: ones o00F ooros ONSYWITEM ores ons oo‘os oros onos ooros poo anos: onns oor cons ooros oars NOISNSd ores oD08 ones ooas oovs coos ‘Dot 200k corns oo'os oons oo'os ones NOISHSd ang Sunouny cot ooo ooo ooo ooo oot wo ooo o0'0 oon oro sunsy suH8KG paHodaiun, ot oro 0070 ove oe ooo one ooo oro ooo ore ooo ove ONSWOH ‘NLLNWO eo Jequaceg JequendR = seqoIng saqueydag — ysnfing Ane aunt Few ae Henge Kenuer ge +jB07 GhOZ/LEPEL - GLOZ/L/L PoHied SUNOH SUWeAD powodauy AVMd19 - ‘saa1uag omeg eameusis

core core. DOE Core: ore coore: oore core: 000 ocoe oO0e t OS NOLLYOWA, oar oor or} mz oso} Ofok O80 oso os oooh oso} ofo") 19430 XOSHD elo oro oslo ole ono ao ost'D obo oo ato oD eoL'D coro ooro wo oro ooro ooo ooo o0Fo org ooo 203°D 13 Oda oazo oar sz ozo azo mero oro cazD oso seo ose0 413957 0080 0080 oo coro oso pos'o oo ogo ooso 0080 ‘SONINIVELL ones ole Oe Ore ore oe Ore Owe are OE oR0e 0eo'e AUNINNY seo ose0 neo Ose eo ost'o oseo ose'o O80 oseD Ose0 wae osrs ose8 ao oe OgE'9 oe osre Os8's Oge's ones 098s ‘seyvs73aM ore one owe oss □□□ ose oe owe ora's oreo ores one's NOISNId ores orcs ono oreo one owes ores ores one oe oreo One's NOISNI¢ ey oleses O00: a0'os ros ooo ores ooo OL eess 00°0s owocs ores on0s Aguero oroes ooo: aout os ops: ores oro oo'oss ovros: onus ores os ovos ‘OS NOLLYOVA OF Les nos cout eros: ooOe ores ores Os Les 00s ooos oos ooos “ooUr 1 □□□ 4OSHD OoPst ores ores oon oo0s ovos OP ss cous oooe oo0s ones swgio: ooes ooos aoos □□□ avs ores moos ones: ons ovos ons cores ores ogau ores □□□ oes onos ones ores ores 00'Os ons ovos onus coos s913970 ones coos: anos oros oros ooo onos ooees boos aos ores ooos ooos ONINTWAL OrzDS «= □□□ ovos anes ones cores ooros orzoLe anos ons pos ones ALIINNY oral cos aves oo'os gos oot ore$ aS OL oros onus oo os gous oot MoU OS°O6LS coos ovat ooos os ooos on'os ‘O¢'6elt ook oons ones oa Oe Seva oeszes ovrot onrok vos ovos ores = ages os ones agus oaos dlls NOISNEd orzozs cos BOCs ones oons oons oros orzors ooUs o0'os wot aoros bons NOISNEd I ee ON, 0 oo | oro ooo oo0 ono O0'oE 000 oo ont oon oD SUNG} peLodauuy) = oone □□□ □□ oro os'D oro ooo. aoe coo ooo oo 60'0 ooo CUWMAIOP "NTT sequeceg Jequiancy JegoRO equeides yantiny Ap Any Wwdhy ui Aronugay —_fvanuer suya-zip e007 GLOZILE/ZL - GLOZ/ LL poled 404 sano} 2einBey payodaruy, SVAId19 - ‘sao|ueg owe eunjeubig = & es : 7 _

——| fo Et i we ——— ——— lee jt weses $) Siegsee S$) - si oe ers ‘aNd TWwio1! | 5 erp len [rrze $| - $7 - $ "sf ___ 49 SNC oo0e $7 - $ | 9008 $|- $|_- $ __ 9S NOLLWOVA ose $ | OS Le $= $| - $ 5 |____19 4430 WOSH3| ors ric= slors S| ST avigio oo'e □□ □ $ | 00-€ $I $| - □□ $ 19 94suI) Ore = □ □ ore $[ - $| - $| - $ _ 19 13937 $] - $| oor - $| - $ t+—— ONINIVEL OEZOL $ a $| $ □ $i - $ □□ $ AUNNNY| osoL oro, [T= $[ = Sf ra osoer gloss: $| - os] suvdTaM| □ □ $loesee ¢| - $| -. $¢) - $ 1 NOISNad| ovzoz $| - oewoe - $ Se ___${ - $ NOISNAd| TWLOL ozoz ss ghoz— LOZ Clb ioe... _ at i | — = [i ozoz ‘beAew, 91 ounr SHUD-Z2¥ WI071 - SLNNOWY JO ANVIANWINS ‘ouj ‘seovueg Owed suneUnIg

Exhibit A Page A-12

ho } ne [merce ee dpll i wil Ss! - § {+-—s{ ~__§1 BNnG W1OL [| pT —__ love $/ - s/oogr S$ = os} = S| 19 sand WHOM loooz, $| - 8 ooow $= 8) = Ss) BS NOLO eeet 5} $e _$} —__$} —___#} __#}___|— 3 a S| lvoe TT \___avigIIS wer $s] - os] $|- 8 ovee os] = Slovee Binva| forse os} - oomee Ay fore, □ $[ - □□ foee, SPT ee loypor §| = Slopme SSP ST | | WTA) woo, $| - preoy St - $ ee jzrese $s = ST sf NOISNSd WILL 6102 8102 L102 gb0z PT pT _ PW OL _|9b0e ‘) WEUStOL TWW3I01 - SLNNOWY4O AMVININS “DU] ‘S8olAleg Cwag ammeubls

OS's OSE MSE KOE wOS'e HOSE ROE 05° ‘OSE Ore Ose □□ gong Suppo oaeH wees ooros oro o0'os bous OOS ooos brats ooos anos ooes ovat ares Ameen on pezet ooos: o0'os oros oot O00F vraeS orcs ores ons sang Buppoan x ong Sunouny LF RAS op'os: ‘oo'os ooos oros oous EB RES oot oyot boos o0'oe ‘eBem S809 FOL payodaiuy es 2926s: ores oF one cous ores coos UES oros oct on'os oorns ooras Ouvadsor “NaTTY ree saquieseg — Jeqwency seqeng = ssquweidag penny Ane aunp en ue dene Alene SUUSLLy :Je007, GLOZ/LEIZL - BLOZIL/E polied 10g sefeaq ssoig payodauy '9u] ‘Seoueg oweg eumeubls ee i

Exhibit A Page A-13

SCIORTINO EXHIBIT 3

& ASSOCIATES, LLC 1700 W. LUTHY DRIVE, PEORIA IL 61615 CERTIFIED PUBLIC ACCOUNTANTS PHONE 309.682.2001 ¢ FAX 309.682.2045 « romolocpa.com

July 9, 2020 Central Laborers P,W&A Fund P.O. Box 1267 Jacksonville, IL 62651 Invoice # 28078 For professional services rendered in connection with the fringe benefit payroll compliance examination on behalf of the:

Central Laborers Pension, Welfare & Annuity Funds for Signature Demo Services, Inc. for the period June 1, 2016 through May 31, 2020: Scheduling 75.00 Field Work 1,237.50 Processing 175.00 Mileage (285 mi. @ $.575) 163.88

Ge => ee ak = fit yi ee EIVE | I. iii JUL 23 2020 uu

PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT TETAS $ 1,651.38

ES 02

Exhibit A Page A-14

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS EASTERN DIVISION CENTRAL LABORERS’ PENSION FUND, ) CENTRAL LABORERS’ WELFARE FUND (ACTIVES & ) RETIREES), ) CENTRAL LABORERS’ ANNUITY FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL ILLINOIS LABORERS’ ) HEALTH AND WELFARE FUND (“NC Welfare”), ) NORTHERN ILLINOIS LABORERS” ANNUITY FUND ) CNI Annuity”), ) ILLINOIS LABORERS AND CONTRACTORS JOINT ) APPRENTICESHIP & TRAINING TRUST FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION FOUNDATION FOR FAIR CONTRACTING (“MRFFC”), 5) CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY ADVANCEMENT FUND, ) NORTH CENTRAL LABORERS-EMPLOYERS ) COOPERATION AND EDUCATION TRUST, ) MARKET PROMOTION FUND, ) MIDWEST REGION ORGANIZATION COMMITTEE, ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ VACATION FUND, and the ) GREAT PLAINS LABORERS’ DISTRICT COUNCIL ) WORKING DUES CHECK OFF FUND ) ) Plaintiffs, ) Vv. ) Case No. 20-Cv-1656 ) SIGNATURE DEMOLITION SERVICES INC., ) Judge Edmond E. Chang an Illinois corporation, ) ) Defendant. ) AFFIDAVIT REGARDING FEES AND COSTS I, Richard A. Toth, affiant, duly sworn on oath, depose and say as follows: 1. I am of legal age, without disability to render testimony and understand that I make this affidavit under an obligation to state truthfully the matters set forth in this affidavit. 2. Tam an attorney, licensed since 1994 to practice law in the State of Illinois, U.S. District Court for the Northern District of Illinois, and U.S. District Court for the Central District of Illinois. I am Plaintiffs’ attorney of record in this case. lam employed as an attorney by the law firm of Daley and George, Ltd., 20 S. Clark, Chicago, Illinois. In that employment I have represented local unions and ERISA funds since 1994, including but not limited to work for a Sheet Metal Workers’ International Association local union and its affiliated ERSIA funds, International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers’ affiliated ERISA funds, and Laborers’ International Union of North America affiliated ERISA funds. 4. The law firm of Daley and George, Ltd. bills Plaintiffs in this case at the rate of $275 per hour. This rate is lower than the firm’s (and my own) standard hourly rate. I have been paid at the same or

Exhibit B Page B-1]

higher rate in other cases before U.S. District Courts. The hourly rate charged is more than fair and reasonable given my level of experience. 3D: The attached breakdown (“Exhibit 1”) of costs is correct and such costs have been necessarily incurred in the case. The attached breakdown also lists hours actually worked in this case and the services for which fees have been charged were actually and necessarily performed. The time spent by this firm was worked in the course of collection of delinquent contributions, liquidated damages, and interest pursuant to Section 1132 of ERISA. Plaintiffs have paid all invoices submitted to them.

Liha tk, Richard A. Toth Subscribed and sworn to before me this January 20, 2021.

NOTARY PUBLIC OFFICIAL SEAL. eo OF tos TARY PUBLIC - STATE ! COMMISSION EXPIRES:04/30/23

Exhibit B Page B-2

Toth Exhibit 1 FEES 03/02/20 Receive and review initial referral materials from Fund Office; research 0.30 corporate status of employer; open file; related follow up. 03/03/20 Draft complaint for audit. 0.60 03/03/20 Prepare civil action cover sheet, appearance and summons. 0.20 03/07/20 Finalize complaint; file complaint, civil cover sheet and appearance; update 0.50 case report; related follow up. 03/11/20 Receive and review complaint and summons to be sent to process server; 0.30 submit court documents to ABC Legal for service of process related to same. 03/11/20 Receive and review e-mail and judge assignments from court clerk; prepare 0.30 summonses; prepare and transmit e-mail and summons to court clerk for issuance. 03/11/20 Receive and review e-mail and issued summonses from court clerk; prepare 0.10 materials for process server. 03/16/20 Receive and review court minute order. 0.10 03/26/20 Receive and review court minute order; calendar court date; update status 0.10 report, 03/26/20 Respond to issues regarding employer address and status of service of 0.10 process. 03/27/20 Receive and review e-mail notice from ABC Legal Services regarding status 0.10 of service of process. 04/30/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail with summons and complaint for service of 0.20 process to L. Mota for service against Signature Demolition. 05/01/20 Prepare and submit alias summons to Northern District clerk for Signature 0.10 Demolition; transmit e-mail to L. Mota at Integrity Process Service regarding same. 05/01/20 Receive and review court notice. 0.10 05/06/20 Receive and review court minute order, calendar court dates; update status 0.10 report. 05/07/20 Receive and review affidavit of service for Signature Demolition from L. 0.10 Mota at Integrity Process Service. 05/13/20 Receive and file affidavit of service for summons and complaint against 0.30 Signature Demolition. 05/18/20 Review court docket and third general order regarding requirement to file 0.10 status report based on entry date of last court order.

Exhibit B Page B-3

05/22/20 Telephone conference with employer representative J. Roderick, confirm 0.10 company's new address; prepare and transmit e-mail and auditor contact information to J. Roderick; prepare and transmit e-mail and court minute order to J. Roderick; prepare and transmit e-mail and update employer address to Fund Office: update case status report. 05/26/20 Receive and review court minute order; calendar court date; update status 0.10 report. 06/02/20 Research, prepare and file initial court status report. 0.50 06/15/20 Receive and review court minute order; calendar court date; update status 0.10 report. 06/22/20 Review court docket; telephone conference with auditor regarding scheduled 0.10 audit. 06/26/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to A. Onysio of Romolo and Associates 0.10 inquiring about status of audit. 06/26/20 Receive and review e-mail from A. Onysio confirming completion of audit; 0.10 prepare and transmit reply e-mail regarding timing. 06/29/20 Prepare and file court status report; related follow up. 0.50 06/30/20 Receive and review court minute order, calendar court date; update status 0.10 report. 07/02/20 Prepare court status report. 0.30 07/31/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to A. Onysio of Romolo and Associates 0.10 regarding status of audit. 07/31/20 Receive and review e-mail from A. Onysio regarding completion of draft 0.10 audit report; prepare and transmit follow up e-mail to Fund Office team regarding status of audit. 08/05/20 Prepare materials for motion for default judgement. 0.30 08/05/20 Receive and review e-mail from employee representative J. Roderick 0.10 regarding acceptance of audit. 08/06/20 Prepare summary of costs and fees; prepare and transmit e-mail and claim 0.30 amounts for costs and fees to employer representative J. Roderick. 08/07/20 Prepare and file court status report and notice of filing; related follow up. 0.50 08/11/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to employer representative J. Roderick 0.10 regarding payment of claim. 08/11/20 Receive and review court minute order; calendar court date; update status 0.20 report. Receive and review e-mail from employer. 08/13/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to employer representative regarding pending 0.20 litigation and payment of claims. Exchange various follow up e-mails with employer representative regarding payment of claim.

Exhibit B Page B-4

08/14/20 Telephone conference with employer representative J. Roderick regarding 0.30 settlement payment; prepare and transmit follow up e-mail to Fund Office. 08/24/20 Research regarding lawsuits filed against employer by Chicago Laborers 0.20 Funds. Prepare and transmit e-mail to Fund Office regarding employer's request for installment payment plan. 08/24/20 Receive and review e-mail from L. Sciortino regarding payment plan; 0.90 prepare and transmit follow up e-mail to employer representative. Receive and review e-mail from employer representative J. Roderick approving payment plan. Prepare and file court status report. 08/25/20 Receive and review court minute order, calendar court date; update status 0.10 report. 08/27/20 Investigation regarding payment of imtial settlement installment. 0.10 08/28/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to employee representative J. Roderick 0.10 regarding non-payment of settlement amount. 08/31/20 Prepare motion for attorney's fees; prepare affidavit for Fund Office for use 0.60 with motion; prepare and transmit follow up e-mail and affidavit to L. Sciortino; related follow up. 09/01/20 Receive and review settlement installment payment from employer. Confirm 0.20 payment amount. Calendar dates for future payments. Prepare and transmit letter and payment to L. Sciortino of Fund Office. Update case status report. 09/11/20 Receive and review e-mail from employer representative J. Roderick 0.10 regarding installment payment; prepare and transmit reply e-mail. 09/17/20 Exchange e-mails with judge's clerk regarding status hearing and filing of 0.20 notice of voluntary dismissal. Receive and review court minute order, calendar court date; update status report. 09/18/20 Prepare and file Rule 41 notice of dismissal; prepare and transmit follow up 0.40 e-mail and notice to judge's clerk; related follow up. Receive and review court minute order; calendar court date; update status report. 09/30/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to employer representative J. Roderick 0.10 regarding installment payment due date. 11/04/20 Prepare and transmit demand letter to employer regarding delinquent 0.10 settlement payment. 11/09/20 Prepare motion to reinstate. Receive and review installment payment; 0.30 prepare and transmit letter and installment payment to L. Sciortino. 11/30/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to employer regarding installment payment. 0.10 12/08/20 Prepare and transmit e-mail to employer representative J. Roderick 0.10 regarding settlement payment.

Exhibit B Page B-5

12/11/20 Coordinate mailing of motion and notice of filing. Receive and review court 0.20 minute order; calendar court date; update status report. 01/11/21 Prepare motion for default judgment. 1.00 01/20/21 Receive and review signed affidavit from client; finalize and file motion for 0.40 default judgment. Total hours: 13.10 TOTAL FEES (@ $275/hour): $3,602.50

COSTS 03/09/20 U.S. District Court Filing Fee. $400.00 03/27/20 ABC Legal Service of Process Fee. $60.00 05/14/20 Service Fees $145.00 TOTAL COSTS:[___ $605.00] TOTAL FEES AND COSTS:| $ 4,207.50

Exhibit B Page B-6

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

Central Laborers' Pension Fund v. Signature Demolition Services Inc., Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/central-laborers-pension-fund-v-signature-demolition-services-inc-ilnd-2021.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack