Cases Appealed to Supreme Court of Virginia

Opinion

DATE: July 7, 2026

The following cases in which the Court of Appeals issued published opinions have been appealed to the Supreme Court:

1. Martin Monroe v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 0937-24-2 Opinion rendered by Judge Athey on April 28, 2026

2. Blake Darvin Hughes, a/k/a Blake Darin Hughes v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 1617-24-1 Opinion rendered by Judge Athey on May 12, 2026

3. Steven McCalla v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 1630-24-4 Opinion rendered by Judge Lorish on May 12, 2026

4. Daquan Hinton v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 0077-25-4 Opinion rendered by Judge Beales on May 12, 2026

5. Precision & Performance Auto Care, LLC, et al. v. James River Petroleum, Inc. Record No. 0846-25-2 Opinion rendered by Chief Judge Decker on May 12, 2026

6. Carrie Susanne Davis, s/k/a Carrie Ann Davis v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 0434-25-3 Opinion rendered by Judge Callins on May 26, 2026

7. New Hope Wellness, LLC v. Sentara Health Plans Record No. 0792-25-2 Opinion rendered by Judge Ortiz on May 26, 2026

The following cases in which the Court of Appeals issued published opinions have been disposed of by the Supreme Court:

1. Rasheem Watts v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 1132-22-1 En banc opinion rendered by Judge Chaney on November 6, 2024 Judgment of Court of Appeals reversed and final judgment entered by order entered on June 3, 2026 (241105)

2. Bhagavan Kevin Antle v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 1906-23-4 Opinion rendered by Judge Beales on February 4, 2025 Judgment of Court of Appeals affirmed in part, reversed in part, and final judgment entered by opinion rendered on June 4, 2026 (250174)

3. Brian Fayne, s/k/a Brian Latrell Fayne v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 1675-23-1 Opinion rendered by Judge Raphael on March 4, 2025 Judgment of Court of Appeals reversed and final judgment entered by opinion rendered on April 23, 2026 (250359)

4. Atlantic Korean American Presbytery v. Shalom Presbyterian Church of Washington, Inc., et al. Record No. 1930-23-4 Opinion rendered by Judge Athey on March 11, 2025 Judgment of Court of Appeals reversed and remanded by opinion rendered on June 4, 2026 (250303)

5. Reston Anesthesia Associates, P.C., et al. v. Elizabeth S. Bandy Record No. 1792-23-4 Opinion rendered by Judge Friedman on October 7, 2025 Refused (251089)

6. Michael Foster v. Susan McNamara Record No. 0996-24-2 Opinion rendered by Senior Judge Clements on October 14, 2025 Refused (251109)

The Supreme Court issued opinions in the following cases, which had been appealed from this Court:

1. Alsharrief Malik Mahoney v. Commonwealth of Virginia Record No. 0454-24-3 Memorandum opinion rendered by Senior Judge Petty on May 6, 2025 Judgment of Court of Appeals reversed and final judgment entered on June 11, 2026 (250487)