Carder v. Tyler Bank & Trust Co.

132 F. Supp. 495, 1954 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2241
CourtDistrict Court, E.D. Texas
DecidedJuly 15, 1954
DocketCiv. A. No. 1691
StatusPublished
Cited by5 cases

This text of 132 F. Supp. 495 (Carder v. Tyler Bank & Trust Co.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering District Court, E.D. Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Carder v. Tyler Bank & Trust Co., 132 F. Supp. 495, 1954 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2241 (E.D. Tex. 1954).

Opinion

SHEEHY, Chief Judge.

The Plaintiffs instituted this suit in this Court seeking to recover from the Defendant the sum of $10,250, the aggregate amount of four drafts which will hereinafter be described and designated.

The Plaintiffs, and each of them, are residents and citizens of the State of Arkansas. The Defendant is a banking corporation duly incorporated under the laws of the State of Texas with its.principal place of business in Tyler, Smith County, Texas.

The Court has jurisdiction of this cause under the provisions of Title 28 U.S.C.A. § 1332.

The pertinent facts, as found, are as follows:

During all times pertinent hereto the Plaintiffs, Frank Carder, Sr. and Frank Carder, Jr. were doing business in the name of “Carder Motor Company” and “Carder Buick Company” with their place of business located in Searcy, Arkansas. During all times pertinent hereto the Plaintiffs, Frank Carder, Sr., Frank Carder, Jr. and Ben Scroggin, Jr., were doing business in' the names of “Ben Scroggin Motors”, “Ben Scroggin Mercury” and “Ben Scroggin Mercury Company” with the place of business located in Searcy, Arkansas. During all times pertinent hereto up to, on or about September 21, 1953 one Johnny T. Camp, hereinafter referred to as Camp, was engaged" in the business of buying and selling automobiles and operated said business under the name of “J-C Motors” with the office and sale lot of said, business being located in Tyler, Texas. From sometime in 1952 up to, on or about September 21, 1953 Camp carried an account under the name of “J-C Motors” with the Defendant Bank, which bank will be hereinafter referred to, unless otherwise designated, as the Tyler Bank. During all times pertinent hereto Frank Carder, Sr. and Frank Carder, Jr. were customers of and carried an account with the Searcy Bank at Searcy, Arkansas, hereinafter referred to as the Searcy Bank, under the name of Carder Motor Company. During all times pertinent hereto the Plaintiffs, Frank Carder, Sr., Frank Carder, Jr. and Ben Scroggin, Jr. were customers of the Searcy Bank and carried an account with that bank under the name of Ben Scroggin Mercury. The Worthen Bank and Trust Company of Little Rock, Arkansas, hereinafter referred to as the Worthen Bank was during all of the year 1953 the regular correspondent bank of the Searcy Bank. The Tyler Bank is not a correspondent bank of either the' Worthen Bank or the Searcy Bank and at no time pertinent hereto did eithér the Searcy Bank or the Worthen Bank have an account, with the Tyler Bank or did the Tyler Bank have an account with either the Worthen Bank or the Searcy Bank. Over a period of several years prior to September, 1953 Camp had from time to time purchased automobiles from the Plaintiffs and over that period of time purchased a rather large number of automobiles from the Plaintiffs. Generally speaking, the purchase of automobiles by Camp from the Plaintiffs was handled substantially in the following manner: Camp would contact one of the Plaintiffs by telephone or otherwise and agree to purchase a given automobile. This automobile was then delivered by Plaintiffs to either Camp or one of Camp’s employees together with Plaintiffs’ invoice showing the sale of [497]*497said automobile to Camp and an executed bill of sale of said automobile from Plaintiffs to Camp. Either simultaneously with the delivery of the automobile by Plaintiffs to Camp or within a short time thereafter Camp would either deliver to Plaintiffs a draft similar to the drafts herein involved, and which will be hereinafter described, signed by Camp payable to Plaintiffs in the amount of the purchase price of the automobile and drawn on the bank with which Camp had an account, which bank from sometime in 1952 up through the dates of the transactions herein involved was the Tyler Bank, or one of the Plaintiffs, with authority from Camp to. so do, would draw a draft payable to Plaintiffs in the amount of the sale price of the automobile on Camp’s bank, which draft would be signed J-C Motors by the Plaintiff who drew the particular draft. The Plaintiffs would then take the draft, with title papers, including the manufacturer’s certificate of title, to the Searcy Bank for deposit to their account. The Searcy Bank would credit the Plaintiffs’ account with the amount of the draft and then forward same, with the title papers attached, to the Worthen Bank. The Worthen Bank, upon receipt of said draft, would credit the Searcy Bank’s account with the amount of the draft and would then forward the draft, with title papers attached, by mail to Camp’s bank for collection. Upon receipt of the draft by Camp’s bank Camp would be notified by his bank and Camp would then inspect the title papers attached to said draft and if same were found to be in order, he would then pay said draft by giving his bank a check on his account in his bank for the amount of said draft.

On or about August 24, 1953 in a telephone conversation between Camp and Frank Carder, Sr. Camp agreed to purchase from Ben Scroggin Mercury a 1953 Mercury automobile for the sum of $2,-400. This Mercury automobile was delivered by Plaintiffs to an employee of Camp at Searcy, Arkansas on August 25, 1953 and simultaneously with the deliv-' ery of said automobile to Camp’s said employee a signed copy of Ben Scroggin Mercury Invoice No. 2239, dated August 25, 1953, reflecting the sale of said Mercury automobile to Camp by Ben Scrog-gin Mercury and a bill of sale from Ben Scroggin Mercury to Camp covering said automobile were delivered to Camp’s employee. Either simultaneously with the delivery of the said Mercury automobile by Plaintiffs to Camp’s employee or shortly thereafter, the exact time not being shown by the evidence, Camp delivered or caused to be delivered to Plaintiffs a draft signed by Camp in the amount of $2,400, which draft was dated August 24, 1953. This draft was in the form of an envelope that was subject to being sealed and on the outside of the envelope was a printed-form draft designated as “Customer’s Draft”. The draft showed on its face it was for a 1953 Mercury automobile and was payable to the order of Ben Scroggin Motors in the amount of $2,400, and designated Tyler Bank as the drawee bank. The drawer of the draft was shown to be J-C Motors (written by typewriter) with Camp’s personal signature under the words “J-C Motors”. This draft was introduced in evidence as Plaintiffs’ Exhibit P-5 and for convenience will be hereinafter referred to as Draft P-5.

After receiving Draft P-5 the Plaintiffs placed in the draft envelope the manufacturer’s certificate of title and the original signed invoice of Ben Scroggin Mercury showing the transfer of said automobile to Camp and then sealed the draft envelope. On September 11, 1953 the Plaintiffs presented said draft to the Searcy Bank and the Searcy Bank immediately credited the account of Ben Scrog-gin Mercury with $2,400, the face amount of the draft. On the same day the Searcy Bank forwarded said draft to the Worthen Bank. This draft was received by the Worthen Bank on September 12, 1953 and, upon receipt of said draft, the Worthen Bank immediately credited the account of the Searcy Bank with the face amount of said draft.

[498]*498On or about August 31, 1953 in a telephone conversation between Camp and Frank Carder, Sr. it was agreed that Plaintiffs would sell and Camp would buy a 1953 Mercury automobile for the sum of $2,450. Plaintiffs delivered this automobile to Camp or one of his employees in Searcy, Arkansas on August 31, 1953 and simultaneously with the delivery of said car the Plaintiffs delivered to either Camp or Camp’s employee a signed Invoice No.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Exchange Bank & Trust Co. v. Pure Ice & Cold Storage Co.
415 S.W.2d 897 (Texas Supreme Court, 1967)
Tyler Bank & Trust Company v. Saunders
317 S.W.2d 37 (Texas Supreme Court, 1958)
Tyler Bank & Trust Co. v. Saunders
308 S.W.2d 90 (Court of Appeals of Texas, 1957)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
132 F. Supp. 495, 1954 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 2241, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/carder-v-tyler-bank-trust-co-txed-1954.