Calton, Allen Fitzgerald

Texas Supreme Court·Decided August 26, 2015·No. WR-65,590-18·Published

Opinion

This document contains s pages that are of poor quality at the time of Imaging.

RECEIVED IN

COURT OF CRiMINAL APPEALS

AUG 2 6 2015

A~Aoos\a, C'er~

.!\. \\ -tl\. "f'' CC{_t.\o(\ 4-\ \:t1'c~0 ~~\eJ ~~ J ~0 'f IV\ 3S \ Y 6~"'\ ;-r.)(- t l{ 0 s- ~(f)~

C\') A\\ e.tl '' ~" C~l \u11 :#- \ \ ). 3 ~ 8D & \·, \-e.s. ~:-\-

3 D(oo vM ~s l~ (1~\- ;\)(. 11{05

C:lJ *\)e. s~{\\eJ'

L<':t: 0 "6 CJ 0 j L0Do 6 ~ \• A,t~-\-ur'\ 0x- -z0al~ · ke.ct \ 0 o.r-'t r t\ ..:rrtw e.~\-s ~o.r\e.s M. Wktl\f,n ~i e\ 0 \- ~. A~pell ~ Sec.-\1UJ A (\~~\-GA.\ ~ir-Jna.( 0\~\nc\- AJ.A-or(\{ 4.o\ <..AJ • B.e-\~~ ~\;. \==a<'\-- w1> ~-YV\ ;Jx. . I i..p I<{~

('-/) j-\.vf"\ ~~\S E. ~-~vJI\S:

0 Gt ~ g..e_ ?.\3\h a i~\t\ c-\ GcvJ'..\ L{ 0 l g -e.-\~~

\_A) . s.-\--

~9-\- '-UDf~ ,1)(. I~ jq ~

i:t

\)e~~of'\ ~S' COC"'~\ B-t- r'vlO/l~i ~~ l

'I~~~/~ ~ \>OS'\\~~ 0 0 0 • ~-- \

\a-'o\~ -t>·f Co~\~ .. (\ ~ I ~g\\ ""·~~'/-.. b.\- A-c~<'\.\1 es '

0 0

~ ~ . ~- \v .::C ~\-cA~ €!\\: 0-C. ·\hL L4£L ~ ~ ~,\

'>

0
0

\\ b.\-t:t~eA\ b.\- ~us\~ ~\c\;of\ 0 . p.Y .... 0' J ~. t{

0 • f' l-\ :3[ Ac SU/V'\-0\\ 0-/\~ ~r;~1 o d 0 < p.7

(A) ~e {(~a s~ C\>~ eC-\ ~ ~- n~ ~\ 0/\6 Otf'c\ o-\ Q-Mf ev0 o cr ' p.7 \_g) ~\W"\dooJ'~ b{ Q~1 M fUr f"V\tY\~~ ~e.\)\ eW t=Ds C{\' M-1 Act { L~ rvt etA- \.v' ..s "'

- f· ~

Cc) Qe;\c;,\-o_r \-\ct,'b A \L\sh-\- \ o A~u\G1u'el\* P-e- u::>('6 ol\ Ae~.eq\ ~..cz)nj ri\~6 " a ., - P" ll

m An ~~\~V\~~ ~-\tA\-~H'( Q/l~ ILt.ih A~<\~:\- (e)(l~~-' .

6).. 1~ h\ \b .A c.:u~\.e\-e. ev-.6 .s~u eA\ ~~on Afp.ecc l ~~ weH e ~~c.6tt ~l~ecL f·l J..

~e.~-\-l~uf\ ~ ( CD··" t.t ({) ~ MU-1 c\CM-<-{.\ r·t~t "

,i 3J ~\- \L-~\t.z\vr~ ~ '--tS.~..\\a~\..Q_ £)(.'\)\CV14hbr\ \>rQ_~ A La.~~ w c;UU<..r 0v1 ,~lor ~ -e~l.Q__ o o o -- P· \~

q

Cu~-\ ?c..KQ.s.

A~ cwr '-l ~ ~~ I,\')... 1-w J-~ I L'l C\e~ CSv"" ~ \ ~ t~ ) · ., o ... r·'q At"'\~ 5on \J ('-~ ~~ ~ e-\Jet\ ~C)(·{\\s ~t:J..e S-wlb l ~~ t\ei-- \'111 ) 0 d \'.l\ If\. \ e,_ ~ a h (') ::Lo .s w ~d. ~(a-:;- C/\e ~. Af f ·' t=V.r+ wo!'--\1A) Goci~ ~ fb(.Q.Q.~~ C> 'II ... t: '~· ~4A\~ \J g~~ !o'1~ J ~~ d-SS C\e~.~-(.~~ L J4~ 0> '~-\-l \7~s) Cor1j ~( oul~;~) ., r;- .,

~as(\-e.~ '\) s~ ~ 1d.. lwJ,~ 4~1.{ l:\ex A~Q.SCl/\AA~l\i() \9~) L - p .7 (S~V..QJ' \) L.Vt'nj b

~\'(' ~ 'V ~e. ~-o.\e_ <l' \ tt s v0:2.. 6 2v2.. CT e'i..~p. \).)G,UJ Vt11) ~ - \)· 7

~ovt\l.A'-() \J~q\4 to]lo )v0"),~5<t.o C.\-c'f.-.~p.~~~\-o i'l'bl)~. p.)O {S <' \ \\- v N 1::10~ Lo-ro\A nQ 'i Oi..\ u.~. :1 )..~ (I~ l J) 'tl <7 .~ • ~· iS1 J(p .

~ VJ\\; ~ '\J \-\o.r ("''f\ ~:tI s w?..~ Li Y S" C\e}.. rs,~ ~~- \'1 <t J.. J ., . . p. <f Go~ ~'6~ ·'-.J ~\\.e~ S~ J!oq US.L\J~ ( \1<p.l) " 0

S \~ \J ~\ ~'1 s- J w).d '{ 'i'l f:Ve'l- ~f~J.X;= \'ltJ C-or-\~ ~ (()LQ.i ~~1) 0 q- u d "p .10

(__ (0(\Q/\ \J s "'""' ~ ~ \").. ~ w J. ~ lo 9 ( \'e'j._ A(>p \-k~..t~~ L\~·\- \) \)-\--] \1tJJ) ( ur1'j e.o~\~~) Cl 0 G c. • f·~ '

~-e~·\;o(\ ~.r (.A)s-,-\-'bf M~ ~ ~j T ab\..L o{- A-t\'\....oN\-le-1 ~. \\J

f>Ci 3 eJ

S\Gl\-e. -e~ (~\ Cw-,~ "Jl!o -~-..v-~~ \').S: L"7\e)(Gv~,A(>~.\qf7J o ~\Cf ~e...le..o~-.~ \),~\-Me\ C..\V"'Y- lt.l, Sw3d Co/3 C\e~,CJ'-'""'-A..fp,JooW"' ,~J1 ~t:.

0o'o'o~ vl..OJ.A~ \.\:1 S.G\: ~3 S Ll'1ttJJ c; t:-1 c , ~-_.l\ \)oVL~\cw ~ c_~'-'G-o((\\C!_ 11.2.._ u.~- lS.J (l9<olJ o e7 J • f-ltotl?

.r"'

D<'~ v Wet~~'0Jk ~\lu.S. L{.~( (\'1Co3J o e/ c. ~,IJ 1 !~1 lS c "'\s ~n~v- \.J ::::Lov.ju.._ ~~ \.eu -~.I L{~ ( ltt(p/) ; P· IS,tlo £ \J\~~ -J Lu~ vos- ~-L~ "'t ~o C\<1~ sj " . . P· IJ,I(p1(7 c c p- 1s1 14> G-~Vt{( ~r& Cor-'\> '-' £v(ns ""63oJ-vv~ 6 3 s S"' t. \-ci-- ..APP· C-or<> c..(~ UN-1~\-\. l q ~ J. )Cor[~ Q roLQ.Qdt_'~) .. (:s..(, \0("\ v .::c-t\~ (\ ~\ s. 1> .$1 \...{. ~- i?._ ( l£t 5 CoJ 0 0

0

G-f'D~ \J G,..-ou\~ l o;).. .(IA.)-:z,~ 1}\Ll,tJllto CI~~-C\v.Afp. 'ffi.s' NOf'~ l 910 1 f\ v~ n't ) c <7 , - r. Jl)

~·ne_s v 'i-tJ.f'JVU' 4 QL( u.~ . . S" 1~ Ct <t 1 AJ c v . f>·7

l-\a.0~~ 'J t.M\k ~ J~ 31~ uS. :1_ I I C\1~J,. . . p, J] (o ~ ~ \) rt>t.r2L~~) o cY (, ..

\ a 'o\e 0\ ~~~\i-e ~ C q ~ .e...s pa g....e.l \4-u-{)Q/)6-ez_ \J ~-\~ I ~~ S\.1))_ ~ "6).$"" (Te'f-_ Cs v~ J\-fp 19~0) or • (J· l 7 .s \-M Cf..... ~t 1-\-t \\ \J Q ~-f'\-\e ~I S"W~ 1.. '1-1. \ ("!C't.. es; 1"1.-Ai{J 197'~) • e~3 c. l~ o.f- r'"' ~I.e~ , \.e "-::s-b h n J V/1 S :r1 sw.;, ~ 11..1 &"' CTe i..A'(Jp (o.rp~J ~~\1 ~<i/0 God~ (?\6~~-"jJ o ,. _ a- c- ~ fA' tO

X"- ~- x" \:.\-,'niM'lo/1~ l-01 J·~J ~ <.o£1 (.·rei--.~(J. ~r{w<>.r-fC.r .2.oU:J (_,0 n'~ ~ \0~ ~ 0,3 ) ., •· o ao .,_ ., -- e)~ 1 .).If?.]

L ~S ~ cd--e._ v IJ lllcwo\ ( "& \.5 s.v J, ~ \ "i 7 CT~ . f-W{J . 1-kl..{ ~.J.dl L I !(~ () IJ\- J I t:t q I I {\A) p-et J 0

0

IV\ttr'i Of"\ v L.oc.\(.~~-\- 1\l{ S-v...J~cb. .J._Jtp C\~i-.1 <?J ~J (0 - • p.t't fV\ ~ fl/' v G ~-\ t) .c _Ap(U ·d.r L/ ~ ~ u J' . t-f;)., ( ( J9 g ~j a G ~- f· }{p ~Uvf") V Kri..{Ji/1 1?/~ J 1.0~6_ 1 ( ~ CTe~ )9) '{) ·rs ., ~ ~,I_S

0 ((~viD \) J.~ q I~ JwJ..~ S \ 9, S':.2.S 1'\·"6 CT~.Cr1'fV\~. 1q 7b)" P' ~

...::c 1'\ ('€_ ~~ \ ~ l '1 () J vJ J d, ~ ~3 (T~i-.. Arr. \for\- v.J)/'~ ~ j .. .P· ? 0

K'hQCMA r 'i- J j ~c.v-0 (', :J_ c S--0.ld- :171 (_ ~ ~ CJ ' \ 91> w~ -r' q p (\' ~ ~ !-p~"\1 }Q ?)"' ___L <; ~w-]- Q, -1) -->0-"> J<>j. 1/l 'I~0 e >?

01 d Cso()c ·~ .J .; "v..\V) ·1- ;hl_) & s £ t \"CV' s \ ~ ' JO \)~ ,)_L ~ 0'0 a'1-;

L; d I' ,) (QcY>r' CD? M ~~ i-~l) 0 h 0 \ fe""'-f ~ r J 0 ] ~ j_~ v_::::r:::-

J I I d- ~ :? [.~L b\ "' __l_) );h ~ Ci). ~ 'f\"' s 0)~ > ~ \) b \A), (\ JQV~~ -\-~~ b~9 1_so,O) ~fC'0 S"O)L. \'f!-0 l\ 1~~-J

1

QJ & '"\h2.bJ ·1'1-N·f\.'?'i-a-_.4

_5 (' d - p .:? = 0 CL~b') ~ #2,' cs.) rr OJ~ <i: vc\ft\\:? ~ (\ -\;·YJ?d)

Q -e· ~ ,(LQ.()~ "~-.;~__L) CPh ~ l'C"" r 0) C!." o7· CJ \ _;;)_L) \~'8 1J f"O\"'~ Vv\~Q ) 0"' v~

bId Jl [lib I -(}J.:y W\J) '1-:;J._L:) h'i L \\~""'J ~ 'CL 1\ ')D\_i {\ '1f'-vv) L_J ·~ · " <:> " pco-e) f>S'fJ · s·n ~--e 5 Yu~ ~~ f'. ~·~ S' / r-c J , -= o o ... ( OV~~Q b~J<Y) (Sbbl ~~~~ rno-}<?7 ·d<J-v·'f-'d_LJ [L\ ~t0r tJb ~ (\ -zrrvos 't-r'te'&t·d "'(.&.Q<;rr. ~JC(Y)\JO:;:!l 'od-v·"~-~_j_) ~O)L zrCY\5 &n-c a-'\Ms~o-o -(N v.::::c [1 1Ct .J. ~ -:> r:oor rJJV· w.,ry"f.a_L) b L 't' ~f~f~" ~? f\ )\t7cno--d

-~ ,J · p C' ' \ J'lll~mQ.)~ F'.l...JO·J ( ~6bt ()_~~ Vo) · ~ov· r-?~)

fr,O) t''e ()-)fb")9:,. -\-:> -\:~(0 ) 0 '!'1·~~"'~ 1--rl ~~ f'\o ~7 )~1))70 d\'~~~

I'C' c) J " fJ-;;- 'i b I ~?.J.:.J d) L. 'f '{0'"\...f'l L. L -:) ~- 1 O""'S IJ 0 ~v3 ~ vrn~ () C\ ) J0.~~

b ·d ·" (U~ 1dJv v--lJ)J.;JbL.t'c ~ r~rh c_d"p1ZJoW f\ -z_(f(\d'~~ )'U) ~ ~\~ s-o~l?d

so-So-")

S'd ~~0~ J0 ?'\'\ 1?__L.

;

#

I

f>4f~

::r' A ~ Lt..\JU'-J i-y_s. £-ervl . .:.:Cf"\L .?-:H Sw3'd.- J 3 l (\~;.... \<J'9<(] o .,. • f· I"& \J I W.ct 2> or.--.e 2- ~ve~~M ~1\:.J 1L LC. v V\11. 4 fe€ ;;. q L{ J w 1 ~ (, "b (

CT~i-. A~(>.;:,£+ ~•j+ ') '-k~...t~l"\ .?--00~) " t7 .., - ... - P· 1:2

..::::Ct~-· ~ \Jl~ MJ ~ .::Ii)c_ \<72_ JwJ ~ I s-1 CT--e-L .ld~~ .. p- ;z 0

..s \-Ct\..e ·-e. K r-e\ VJ er6R- \j MCV-(J (Q<( 7 \ -wl& ~c;J (Te'J.._ ~Af? I ~'tl).r9

~\L.\~. \.) ::)0(\.Qi 9 '2./ f J_~ 5 ~ .l_( y;- ~ Ct\r 197Jj "' 0 , • QJ-;.2 0 vJ\) otis ·v ~\-vON! L 9?.6 J w::2 -~.II 9 (Tee~. Cor ~j ~~-h 1 o.l't'_J p c D(J2..Q ~""~ ) O\)Q/'\uJs b o/"\ ~ ~~~ \-r ~ c w-i ~ J ..... b (\-<)Y\. · (3 ('1·~ fC.~ ~- ) R~~)~ i +''1 L \J lh e..\~~ Co~- -o-C .A:--we-q(_r CJ :L7 J ..J:2. ~ 4 L{ 0 ( T ~-(. I <j·~j c r , · ~ · 7 i '8

2 wvi j 'i 11 2 Ul\4, f c; I '!. JWJ l.. '1 1'1> CTej.._.Af~ So.-. ~ i\) 1 9'19_\ , . ~7

R~QJ'a{ Gn.!~~\1orv;A A~~

r r-- \7

I

l\

£e.lv--al ~~1 ;Gc\e.i &16 ~eJ

·;J_ ~ u .s.~c · <.:s .21 s ~

0

.- f· J b/ I{

c. f·l D

\ e'l--- \\-.A~-~·~. ~ 11. Lk' c

c

\e.'}... ~- ~q. ~, ~ Jt.\,l_o c

t.

(? ,e-\,~ol\ ~-- w ....:\- 0~ MGob<M<AJT«~ Of A..-\1...u-t~e..', f.\ '1\..

:L

~\o..\~er\\ O.C Th.e. ( ctSQ.

OA \h-e. C)\~'n\ o\- <..\ -:z...J- "!::):;,1.. ~e... ",-~-\-\<'<"\ £..,ere\ \.e Glno.r\.es. A." ~\e ~q ~ ~~~ ~-\\e~Q ~ \ -\\ri\l~~ \~~('~()1 ~~~cd\ ~lf\Q~ -to~~ ~~h-\ lf-\-~\S cv\J\e-~e~ s nt~i{ ~\'~ <'~'\' ..s'h-u-Q • -('-t·v:t.-\- ....J6\.i 'neue~ ct\- \tt\s. \eJ\cltll~ o...A· \ /~l( w \~~a/1 Av-IL, ~\'\w~r~ '7fassW\\ C.OWI.-\.r 1\Q ~s. ., ~Q/) c. ct'\ ~n ~ u. \\ e ~ 1J'\) ~ ~ \J 1c~ IV\1 r-e .i \ ~.QI\~ ~- -\-v..Jo 411 eJt? ~ Iy M

e_" ~ q ~ Q ~ \ f'\ C\ 'o ~\ e-t G::>!\ -JQJ"__s q \i on .. ~ -J i ~"" ...Jai J h-u-\- OA.2. -\-{ f'l'-.('

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Calton, Allen Fitzgerald, (Tex. 2015).

Calton, Allen Fitzgerald (Calton, Allen Fitzgerald) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Penley v. Collin County Texas
446 F.3d 572 (Fifth Circuit, 2006)
Reger v. Walker
312 F. App'x 624 (Fifth Circuit, 2009)
Reginald DeKeith Mims v. Linda A. Farr
350 F. App'x 351 (Eleventh Circuit, 2009)
Stump v. Sparkman
435 U.S. 349 (Supreme Court, 1978)
Pulliam v. Allen
466 U.S. 522 (Supreme Court, 1984)
Forrester v. White
484 U.S. 219 (Supreme Court, 1988)
Mireles v. Waco
502 U.S. 9 (Supreme Court, 1991)
Heck v. Humphrey
512 U.S. 477 (Supreme Court, 1994)
Magwood v. Patterson
561 U.S. 320 (Supreme Court, 2010)
In Re: Shane McClaine Cain, Movant
137 F.3d 234 (Fifth Circuit, 1998)
Ex Parte Jarrett
891 S.W.2d 935 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1995)
Ex Parte Drake
883 S.W.2d 213 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1994)
Rowell v. State
66 S.W.3d 279 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 2001)
Ex Parte Banks
769 S.W.2d 539 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1989)
Ex Parte Wilson
956 S.W.2d 25 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1997)
Bonham State Bank v. Beadle
907 S.W.2d 465 (Texas Supreme Court, 1995)
Ex Parte Bravo
702 S.W.2d 189 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1982)
Twilligear v. Carrell
148 S.W.3d 502 (Court of Appeals of Texas, 2004)
Ex Parte Gardner
959 S.W.2d 189 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 1998)