Cain v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

United States Court of Federal Claims·Decided June 25, 2026·No. 22-0739V·Unpublished

Opinion

58ÿ93 01ÿ345ÿ6173 3 5 ÿ 3ÿÿ585 ÿÿÿ ÿ  ÿ 7  ÿ !"#ÿ%%&'()*ÿ ÿ +ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-./012-ÿ2.1!3ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ 456767"8593ÿÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ 2:75;ÿ<=5>7?@ÿA?B659ÿ2"9>"9?8ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ C#ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ .=97@ÿ%%3ÿ%D%Eÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ <-20-/.0FÿGHÿI-.J/Iÿÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿÿ .!KÿILA.!ÿ<-0*12-<3ÿÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ +ÿ ÿ ÿ 05B="8M586#ÿÿ ÿ +ÿ +ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿ+ÿÿ ÿ NOPQRSTÿVWTXÿYRZST[\Z3ÿ,?B5@]"BÿJ?^ÿH79_3ÿ4JJ23ÿ53ÿg?B:78h6"83ÿK23ÿ;"9ÿ05B="8M586#ÿ ÿ ijÿijkÿjÿlkmÿ ÿ ÿ G8ÿf]@nÿo3ÿ%D%%3ÿ,5?697>5ÿ2?78ÿ;7@5Mÿ?ÿ=56767"8ÿ;"9ÿ>"_=58B?67%"8ÿ]8M59ÿ6:5ÿ!?67"8?@ÿ *?>>785ÿ18p]9nÿ2"_=58B?67"8ÿ49"h9?_3ÿq%ÿL#<#2#ÿr(DD??&mD3ÿSsÿZStuÿv6:5ÿw*?>>785ÿ.>6xy#ÿ 456767"859ÿ?@@5h5Mÿ6:?6ÿB:5ÿB];;595Mÿ?ÿ@5;6ÿB:"]@M59ÿ78p]9nÿ95@?65Mÿ6"ÿC?>>785ÿ?M_787B69?67"8ÿ vw<10*.xyÿ?Bÿ?ÿ95B]@6ÿ";ÿ?8ÿ78;@]58z?ÿC?>>785ÿ?M_787B6595Mÿ"8ÿ<5=65_{59ÿm3ÿ%D%m#ÿ456767"8ÿ?6ÿm#ÿ -8676@5_586ÿ^?Bÿ>"8>5M5Mÿ78ÿ!"C5_{59ÿ%D%(3ÿ?8Mÿ?ÿ9]@78hÿ7BB]5Mÿ78ÿ456767"859|Bÿ;?C"9ÿ^:7@5ÿ6:5ÿ _?6659ÿ^?BÿB67@@ÿ=58M78hÿ78ÿ6:5ÿw<=5>7?@ÿ49">5BB78hÿL876xÿv6:5ÿw<4Lxy#ÿ05B="8M586|Bÿ0]@5ÿqv>yÿ 05="96ÿv-2Hÿ!"#ÿq}y~ÿ0]@78hÿ"8ÿ-8676@5_586ÿv-2Hÿ!"#ÿq)y#ÿÿ ÿ K5B=765ÿ6:579ÿ5;;"96B3ÿ6:5ÿ=?9675Bÿ>"]@Mÿ8"6ÿ78M5=58M586@nÿ95B"@C5ÿM?_?h5B3ÿ?8Mÿ6:5ÿ>?B5ÿ^?Bÿ 69?8B;5995Mÿ"]6ÿ";ÿ<4Lÿ78ÿA?9>:ÿ%D%qÿ;"9ÿ95B"@]67"8ÿ";ÿM?_?h5Bÿ{nÿ?8"6:59ÿB=5>7?@ÿ_?B659#ÿG9M59ÿ 05?BB7h878hÿ2?B53ÿ7BB]5MÿA?9#ÿo3ÿ%D%qÿv-2Hÿ!"#ÿE(y#ÿ.;659ÿ{"6:ÿB7M5Bÿ58h?h5Mÿ78ÿM?_?h5B& mÿ,5>?]B5ÿ6 ÿ :7Bÿ0]@78hÿ>"86?78Bÿ?ÿ95?B"85Mÿ5€=@?8?67"8ÿ;"9ÿ6:5ÿ?>67"8ÿ6?58ÿ78ÿ6:7Bÿ>?B53ÿ76ÿ_]B6ÿ{5ÿ_?M5ÿ=]{@7>@nÿ ?>>5BB7{@5ÿ?8Mÿ^7@@ÿ{5ÿ="B65Mÿ"8ÿ6:5ÿL8765Mÿ<6?65Bÿ2"]96ÿ";ÿH5M59?@ÿ2@?7_B‚ÿ^5{B7653ÿ?8Mƒ"9ÿ?6ÿ :66=B„ƒƒ^^^#h"C78;"#h"Cƒ?==ƒ>"@@5>67"8ƒ]B>"]96Bƒ8?67"8?@ƒ>";>3ÿ78ÿ?>>"9M?8>5ÿ^76:ÿ6:5ÿ-&"C598_586ÿ.>6ÿ";ÿ%DD%#ÿ qqÿL#<#2#ÿrÿ(oDmÿ8"65ÿv%Dm}yÿvH5M59?@ÿA?8?h5_586ÿ?8Mÿ49"_"67"8ÿ";ÿ-@5>69"87>ÿ"C598_586ÿ<59C7>5By#ÿ†‡ˆÿ‰Š‹Œˆÿ †ŠÿŽ‡Œÿ‘‡ÿ’Šÿ‹“‹‡‹’Šÿ”ÿ‹Œ•”ŒŠÿ‘‡†ÿ‹––Šˆˆÿ”ÿ†Šÿ‡ŒŠ—ŒŠ#ÿ18ÿ?>>"9M?8>5ÿ^76:ÿ*?>>785ÿ0]@5ÿm}v{y3ÿ456767"859ÿ :?BÿmqÿM?nBÿ6"ÿ7M5867;nÿ?8Mÿ_"C5ÿ6"ÿ95M?>6ÿ_5M7>?@ÿ"9ÿ"6:59ÿ78;"9_?67"83ÿ6:5ÿM7B>@"B]95ÿ";ÿ^:7>:ÿ^"]@Mÿ>"8B676]65ÿ?8ÿ ]8^?99?865Mÿ78C?B7"8ÿ";ÿ=97C?>n#ÿ1;3ÿ]="8ÿ95C75^3ÿ1ÿ?h955ÿ6:?6ÿ6:5ÿ7M5867;75Mÿ_?6597?@ÿ;76Bÿ^76:78ÿ6:7BÿM5;78767"83ÿ1ÿ^7@@ÿ 95M?>6ÿB]>:ÿ_?6597?@ÿ;9"_ÿ=]{@7>ÿ?>>5BB#ÿ ÿ% ÿ!?67"8?@ÿ2:7@M:""Mÿ*?>>785ÿ18p]9nÿ.>6ÿ";ÿm)}E3ÿ4]{#ÿJ#ÿ!"#ÿ))&EED3ÿmDDÿ<6?6#ÿ('oo#ÿI59578?;6593ÿ;"9ÿ5?B5ÿ";ÿ>76?67"83ÿ ?@@ÿB5>67"8ÿ95;5958>5Bÿ6"ÿ6:5ÿ*?>>785ÿ.>6ÿ^7@@ÿ{5ÿ6"ÿ6:5ÿ=59678586ÿB]{=?9?h9?=:ÿ";ÿq%ÿL#<#2#ÿrÿ(DD??ÿv%Dm}y#ÿ ÿ 2334562789ÿ963548 ÿ6596ÿ68ÿ528ÿ283ÿ786ÿ96378ÿ4588989ÿ74ÿ686ÿ29ÿ2ÿ74 92ÿ92283ÿ826ÿ89ÿ6ÿ488ÿ00ÿ278ÿ65ÿ78ÿ38562ÿ2378ÿ63389ÿ2ÿ6ÿ4ÿ 92283ÿ4ÿ25ÿ0ÿ00ÿ!"#ÿ4ÿ$%ÿ78ÿ&'2283ÿ(6)ÿ*27ÿ6ÿ83489ÿ26ÿ29ÿ 386ÿ23ÿ8ÿ23ÿ2ÿ696692963789ÿ528ÿ63383ÿ7ÿ87ÿ348ÿ62ÿ63383ÿ4ÿ78ÿ27683ÿ 74ÿ299833ÿ'2283ÿ(6ÿ27ÿ$$+ÿ ÿ ,78ÿ78ÿ633258ÿ4ÿ78ÿ'2283ÿ(6ÿ78ÿ678 86ÿ876887ÿ4ÿ78ÿ29-965276ÿ 38562ÿ2378ÿ83789ÿ6ÿ78ÿ7238ÿ4ÿ78ÿ2778ÿ25.ÿ74ÿ8ÿ/98ÿ(823366ÿ"238ÿ63389ÿ 2ÿÿ00ÿ!"#ÿ4ÿ$0ÿ*8ÿ27683ÿ78ÿ689ÿ2ÿ1467ÿ27273ÿ(847ÿ38776ÿ47ÿ786ÿ62ÿ 4367643ÿ4ÿ58726ÿ83489ÿ92283ÿ52784683ÿ4ÿ68ÿ528ÿ22334562%789ÿ528ÿ838383ÿ455ÿ 75859:;;<ÿ1467ÿ27273ÿ(847ÿ689ÿ, ÿ$ÿ00ÿ!"#ÿ4ÿ$+ÿ&12()ÿ=84ÿ>ÿ387ÿ47ÿ ÿ 9878627643ÿ4ÿ78ÿ62ÿ92283ÿ544873ÿ74ÿ8ÿ83489ÿ ÿ ÿ ?@ÿ BCDEFGFGHÿJEDEHCKÿ?KKLCKÿ ÿ ÿ *8ÿ27683ÿ69876689ÿ3882ÿ92283ÿ544873ÿ727ÿ78ÿ28ÿ88ÿ28ÿ74ÿ8348ÿ 6ÿ78ÿ2.8ÿ4ÿ78ÿ'2283ÿ(6ÿ8678ÿ85238ÿ78ÿ'2283ÿ(6ÿ23ÿ3687ÿ23ÿ74ÿ3856653ÿ 4ÿ&654878ÿ23ÿ74ÿ54373ÿ8M85ÿ29ÿ92764ÿ4ÿ92283)ÿ12(ÿ27ÿ$ÿ29ÿ28ÿ234ÿ 8ÿ387ÿ47ÿ786ÿ4367643ÿ4ÿ825ÿ ÿ ,ÿ O3652ÿ*82ÿPÿ'62437653ÿ ÿ ÿ O8767648ÿ8M8373ÿ54832764ÿ4ÿ%0ÿ3833643ÿ4ÿ3652ÿ782ÿ&O*)ÿ22ÿ76ÿ 28ÿÿ3-857ÿ74ÿ63258ÿ98957683ÿ29ÿ54373ÿ24ÿ67ÿM278ÿO*ÿ88227643ÿ29ÿ 82ÿ72349ÿ626ÿ4ÿ8ÿ285789ÿ3498ÿ48ÿ78ÿ328ÿ8649ÿ12(ÿ27ÿ$ÿ=2389ÿ4ÿ 642ÿ54652764ÿ67ÿ78ÿ64ÿ38562ÿ2378ÿ247ÿ763ÿ8887ÿ4ÿ92283ÿO8767648ÿ 5252789ÿ78ÿ247ÿ88989ÿ23ÿ2ÿ6882ÿ267ÿ365687ÿ74ÿ548ÿQ00ÿ8ÿ82ÿ 29-3789ÿ4ÿ62764ÿRSTÿ27ÿ0ÿO8767648ÿ267263ÿ(834987ÿ88ÿ52889ÿ78ÿ889ÿ4ÿ 763ÿ78ÿ528ÿ5437ÿ983678ÿ98ÿ44767ÿ29ÿ26ÿ4ÿ78ÿ38562ÿ2378ÿ4ÿ727ÿ63.ÿ29ÿ 78848ÿ2689ÿ78ÿ67ÿ74ÿ94ÿ34ÿ4ÿ29ÿ727ÿ78ÿ'2283ÿ(6ÿ8546U83ÿ78ÿ446ÿ 278ÿ4ÿO8767648V3ÿ2>(W,ÿRSTÿ27ÿ%ÿO8767648ÿ234ÿ8M8373ÿ2ÿ29967642ÿQX0ÿ8ÿ82ÿ48ÿ 78ÿ328ÿ6882ÿ76828ÿ29ÿ29-3789ÿ4ÿ62764ÿ4ÿM278ÿO*ÿ8822764ÿ 2467873ÿ29ÿQ0X+$ÿ8ÿ82ÿ29-3789ÿ4ÿ62764ÿ4ÿ626Y72349ÿ962437653ÿRSTÿ ÿ ÿ (834987ÿ963783ÿ727ÿO*ÿ3833643ÿ29ÿ82789ÿ88227643ÿ88ÿ22989ÿ29ÿ88ÿ6ÿ 78ÿ349ÿ28ÿ88ÿ22989ÿM837643ÿ27ÿ786ÿ5437ÿ8M85ÿ29ÿ92764ÿ349ÿ8ÿRSÿ (834987ÿ78ÿ267263ÿ63ÿ68ÿ528ÿ28ÿ969ÿ8376278ÿ2ÿ22ÿ5437ÿ4ÿ7838ÿ838383ÿ %ÿ ÿ O8767648ÿ234ÿ689ÿ29967642ÿ278623ÿ278ÿ78ÿ92283ÿ826ÿ29ÿ446ÿ78ÿ633258ÿ4ÿ78ÿ'2283ÿ (6ÿ727ÿ88ÿ8678ÿ8M83789ÿ4ÿ2746U89ÿ6596ÿ2ÿ38872ÿ68ÿ689ÿ,6ÿ0$ÿ00ÿ!"#ÿ4ÿ $0ÿ8678276ÿ4367643ÿ387ÿ47ÿ6ÿ78ÿ12(ÿ 0ÿ ÿ 23245678ÿ9 00ÿ3ÿ4ÿ6785ÿ4ÿÿ62678ÿ2ÿ32ÿ3ÿ44ÿ3ÿ ÿ!42!ÿ"ÿ# ÿ #$#%ÿ65!ÿ4ÿÿ&ÿ&ÿ3ÿ'$(ÿ42ÿ#(ÿ)7!ÿ2*6ÿ+ÿ,35!ÿ-6ÿ6747ÿ4!.2+72ÿ4ÿ,55ÿ /ÿ42ÿ%ÿ ÿ 0ÿ 254+436*ÿ254252ÿ47.2637ÿ5226(ÿ ÿ ÿ 2262637ÿ+4672467ÿ2*42ÿ*ÿ6ÿ72625!ÿ23ÿ3+742637ÿ3ÿ2*6ÿ737324!6263745ÿ242+72%ÿ ,*6*ÿ6ÿ732ÿ37!ÿ8ÿ*ÿ6747ÿ9"ÿ42ÿ%3ÿ"*ÿ453ÿ732ÿ2*42ÿ*ÿ,35!ÿ-6ÿ3 74542637ÿ,*6*ÿ,35!ÿ8ÿ37!ÿ8ÿ*ÿ6747(ÿ3ÿ2*ÿ762ÿ3ÿ22ÿ67.2637ÿ83ÿ 4*ÿ4!+676242637ÿ47!ÿ,*65ÿ2*ÿ:4+48ÿ5678ÿ776637!ÿ6ÿ67.2637ÿ477455ÿ3ÿ;$ÿ4ÿ 2*ÿ6+5678ÿ-7ÿ47!ÿ!42637ÿ3ÿ2*ÿ374542637(ÿ62ÿ!6!ÿ732ÿ6ÿ2*ÿ32ÿ3ÿ2*ÿ 43642!ÿ374542637ÿÿ42ÿ3<ÿ:4+48ÿ5678ÿ42ÿ;ÿÿ ÿ 2262637ÿ73,ÿ=ÿ!4+48ÿ3ÿ22ÿ374542637ÿ2*42ÿ74ÿ37ÿ4ÿ2734ÿ63!ÿ 37267872ÿ37ÿ,*2*ÿ2>ÿ6ÿ453ÿ4,4!!ÿ4ÿ832*ÿ4ÿ8.2ÿ23ÿ*ÿ!!2685ÿ47!ÿ36747ÿ 9"ÿ42ÿ3ÿ"*ÿ453ÿ=ÿ546642637ÿ3ÿ2*ÿ32ÿ3ÿ2*ÿ4245ÿ22ÿ242+72ÿ4ÿ52!ÿ67ÿ 2*ÿ:4+48ÿ5678ÿ?*65ÿ2262637ÿ242ÿ2*42ÿ2*ÿ645ÿ+42ÿ*4!ÿ67!642!ÿ4ÿ,6556787ÿ23ÿ 3+742ÿ6ÿ22ÿ67.2637ÿ4*ÿ4ÿ3ÿ;$ÿ4ÿ42ÿ4ÿ32ÿ3ÿ9'$$ÿÿ67.2637ÿ2*ÿ:4+48ÿ 5678ÿ4,4!!ÿ4ÿ5ÿ+ÿ9$$ÿÿ67.2637(ÿ:4+48ÿ5678ÿ42ÿ;ÿÿ ÿ 2262637ÿ2*ÿ56ÿ37ÿ"2+8ÿ;$ÿ#$#ÿ8655678ÿ3!ÿ3ÿ4ÿ9$$$$ÿ53242672ÿ 3!6ÿ5ÿ9 $$ÿ67ÿ4!!6263745ÿ*48ÿ3ÿ47ÿ53242672ÿ3!6(ÿ,*65ÿ4=73,5!8678ÿ 67ÿ*ÿ46!4762ÿ2*42ÿ*ÿ376!@ÿ8655678ÿ*4ÿ87ÿ537678ÿ47!ÿ673762726ÿ47!ÿ2*42ÿ*ÿ5A*4ÿ 87ÿ*48!Bÿ9$$ÿ3ÿ2*ÿ22ÿ67.2637ÿ625ÿ7ÿ2*ÿ9 ÿ2*ÿ546+!ÿ62ÿ,35!ÿ86ÿÿ'0ÿ 65!ÿC2ÿÿ#$#ÿ&ÿ3ÿ;%$3(ÿ42ÿ3Dÿ45242637ÿ67ÿ3686745(<ÿÿ'$ÿ"5+7245ÿ)6!4762ÿ 65!ÿC2ÿÿ#$#ÿ&ÿ3ÿ;%$3#(ÿ42ÿ#ÿ>*ÿ:4+48ÿ5678ÿ67!642ÿ2*42ÿ2*ÿ545ÿ32ÿ3ÿ22ÿ 67.26376ÿ,4ÿ67ÿ2*ÿ478ÿ3ÿ9$$ÿ23ÿ9%;##ÿ47!ÿ*7ÿ9$$ÿ,4ÿ4ÿ46ÿ26+42637ÿ:4+48ÿ 5678ÿ42ÿ;<ÿEFFÿGFHFIJKKLÿÿ%ÿ54742637ÿ3ÿ0762(ÿ65!ÿ947ÿ#'ÿ#$#%ÿ&ÿ3ÿ'3#(ÿ 52678ÿ9%;##ÿ,4ÿ67!ÿ3ÿ76(<ÿÿ'$ÿ42ÿ#((ÿ2262637ÿ33ÿ2*6ÿ4+372ÿ 5+2ÿ8ÿ67326ÿ67ÿ568*2ÿ3ÿ242+72ÿ2262637ÿ422682ÿ23ÿ2*ÿ645ÿ+42ÿ63ÿ23ÿ647ÿ 3ÿ2*ÿ:4+48ÿ5678ÿ9"ÿ42ÿ%ÿ ÿ %ÿ ÿ 22ÿÿ23ÿ4ÿ242+72ÿ677357678ÿ2*ÿ377242637ÿ3ÿ54252ÿ3+ÿ4ÿ42672@ÿ3,7ÿ8533!ÿ,*6*ÿ6ÿ2*7ÿ67.2!ÿ 6723ÿ42!ÿ26ÿ23ÿ32ÿ*45678ÿ47!ÿ!ÿ6754++42637ÿ4ÿ!68!ÿ67ÿ2*ÿ!4+48ÿ*4678ÿ226+37ÿ3ÿ N577ÿ?*622!ÿO:ÿ>

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI