Caballero v. Kogan

73 P.R. 617
CourtSupreme Court of Puerto Rico
DecidedAugust 18, 1952
DocketNo. 10544
StatusPublished

This text of 73 P.R. 617 (Caballero v. Kogan) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Puerto Rico primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Caballero v. Kogan, 73 P.R. 617 (prsupreme 1952).

Opinions

Mr. Justice Snyder

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This is a suit for the specific performance of a contract in which, according to the plaintiffs, the defendant obligated himself to purchase two farms belonging to the plaintiffs. After a trial on the merits, the district court entered a judgment in favor of the plaintiffs from which the defendant has appealed.

The case arose out of a document reading as follows:

[619]*619“OPTION OF SALE OF FARMS
“In the city of San Juan, Puerto Rico, on the fourth day of January 1949,
“There appear
' “As PARTY OF THE FIRST PART: HARRY M. BESOSA, of age, married to Margaret Nance, Attorney at Law and resident of Hato Rey, Municipality of Río Piedras, who appears in this public instrument representing the Sucesión of Harry F. Be-sosa, composed of Maria Caballero and her heirs and children Harry M. Besosa, Nydia M. Besosa and Howard M. Besosa.
“As PARTY of THE second part : Saul Kogan, of age, married to Aida Huberman, merchant and resident of Santurce of this city.
“The parties state that they have agreed to the execution of a contract of option of sale of farms which they put into effect by this instrument pursuant to the following facts:
“1. Harry M. Besosa states that the Sucesión of Harry F. Besosa is the owner in fee simple of two farms situated in Barrio Beatriz, known as Las Cruces, Insular Highway No. 1, in the Municipality of Cayey, which have an approximate area of forty-two cuerdas and eight cuerdas and are adjacent to each other. The following buildings are located on the larger property: Two small frame houses, one with a cardboard roof and the other with a zinc roof, used as dwellings; a third dwelling, with a concrete foundation and a zinc roof; a triple wooden garage, with a zinc roof; a” frame house for laborers with a zinc roof; a large shed of zinc and a stable with a zinc roof. These buildings have a water system which obtains water from a spring on the property with an electric pump.
“2. The party of the first part states that from the property of forty-two cuerdas described in the preceding paragraph a parcel of approximately three cuerdas and eighty-seven hundredths was segregated at the northeasterly point of said property which segregation was made by the decedent Harry F. Besosa, who gave this parcel to his son Howard M. Besosa as a gift. The party of the first part explains that no legal document has been heretofore executed for this segregation and there is therefore no record of said segregation in the Registry of Property of Guayama.
“3. The aforesaid larger property is mortgaged to the Federal Land Bank of Baltimore and there is at present a balance [620]*620of approximately One Thousand One Hundred Dollars ($1,100), in favor of the latter, and there are also two small houses occupying two small lots of said property which are occupied and owned by two persons without any title and with the mere permission of the decedent. That, furthermore, one of the houses which stands on the extreme east of said property known as Howard’s house, is at present under a lease subject to termination and surrender within a period of ninety days after the sale of said property and is occupied by Mr. Harry Keller.
“4. The parties of the first and second part state that the Sucesión of Harry F. Besosa, through Harry M. Besosa, their legal, representative and party hereto, has agreed with the party of the second part, Saul Kogan, to the sale of both farms with all the buildings and improvements thereon, .but after deducting from the larger property the parcel physically segregated and granted to Howard M. Besosa. The parties state that all the terms and conditions of said contract • of sale have been agreed to but since the testamentary proceedings in connection with the estate of Harry F. Besosa have not yet been completed, the Sucesión is not in a position definitely to execute formally the contract of sale agreed to,' and since it is the wish of the party of the second part to take immediate possession of the properties the sale of which has been agreed to, the parties have decided to make at this time this contract of option of sale with the following clauses:
“First: The Sucesión of Harry F. Besosa hereby agrees and binds itself to sell to the party of the second part the two farms described in this document with all its buildings and improvements, after deducting therefrom,a parcel of 3.87 cuerdas which has been physically segregated from the larger property, and to transfer and convey said properties entirely free of any lien or encumbrance.
“Second: The sale of these properties will be made upon payment of the agreed price of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) which will be paid in cash at the time of the execution of the deed of sale.
“Third: The party of the second part agrees and binds himself to purchase the properties mentioned in the first clause for the price stipulated in the second clause.
“Fourth: The parties shall proceed to the execution of the deed of sale and to the performance of the respective oblig[621]*621ations which both parties have assumed in this deed within ninety (90) days from this date.
“Fifth: The party of the second part hereby delivers to the party of the first part at the time of the execution of this document, as consideration for the option granted herein, the sum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) in money of legal tender, for which sum the party of the first part gives a receipt to Mr. Kogan. It is understood and agreed that said sum of one thousand dollars ($1,000) will be credited to the party of the second part as part of the purchase price of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) which he shall pay when the deed of sale is executed, and that, if the party of the second part fails to comply with the obligation contracted by him to purchase the farms for the price and other conditions stated herein, the said amount of one thousand dollars ($1,000) shall be retained by the Suce-sión of Harry F. Besosa as indemnity for said nonperformance of contract and as compensation for the use of the farm for the period of time between this date and said nonperformance.
“Sixth: The party of the second part will take immediate possession of the properties involved in this option, it being agreed, however, that Mr. Keller, who is now a tenant, may continue occupying the house in which he is living until the date of the execution of the deed of sale and that the rent he pays for the use of said house shall belong from this moment to the party of the second part.
“Seventh: The party of the second part will be obligated to restore possession of the aforesaid properties to the Sucesión of Harry F. Besosa if for any reason said party fails to comply with the obligation of purchase contracted by him by means of the execution of this option.
“Eighth: The party of the second part agrees to purchase the aforesaid properties without imposing on the Sucesión of Harry F.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
73 P.R. 617, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/caballero-v-kogan-prsupreme-1952.