Buszkiewic v. State

424 P.3d 1272
CourtWyoming Supreme Court
DecidedAugust 23, 2018
DocketS-17-0293
StatusPublished
Cited by18 cases

This text of 424 P.3d 1272 (Buszkiewic v. State) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Wyoming Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Buszkiewic v. State, 424 P.3d 1272 (Wyo. 2018).

Opinion

KAUTZ, Justice.

[¶1] A jury found Jacob Alan Buszkiewic guilty of two counts of strangulation of a household member. Mr. Buszkiewic asserts the prosecutor made several statements during closing argument that amounted to misconduct and deprived him of a fair trial.

[¶2] Finding no error, we affirm.

ISSUES

[¶3] Mr. Buszkiewic states the following issues on appeal:

I. Did the prosecutor's repeated use of the "golden rule" argument subvert the objectivity of the jury and materially prejudice Mr. Buszkiewic?
II. Did the prosecutor's repeated reference to the complaining witness as being the "victim," referring to the defense theory as "victim blaming," and referring to what the defendant didn't say to police, and didn't explain, result in cumulative error and materially prejudice Mr. Buszkiewic?

FACTS

[¶4] Mr. Buszkiewic and Sarah Oakland were involved in an on-again-off-again romantic relationship. In April 2016, Ms. Oakland, who resided in Sheridan, Wyoming, spent a couple of weeks with Mr. Buszkiewic at his house in Laramie, Wyoming. On April 29, 2016, the couple visited several bars, with their final stop of the night being Bud's Bar in West Laramie. They stayed at the bar after it closed and played cards with the bartender until approximately 5:00 a.m. on April 30, 2016.

[¶5] When Mr. Buszkiewic and Ms. Oakland returned to Mr. Buszkiewic's house, he accused her of flirting with the bartender. He forced her into the bedroom where he placed her on the bed and slapped her several times. Mr. Buszkiewic then let her up, and she tried to reason with him. The same thing happened a few more times, with Mr. Buszkiewic taking Ms. Oakland into the bedroom, placing her on the bed, slapping her and then letting her up. During two of the slapping incidents, he also put his hands around her throat and squeezed, cutting off her airway and causing pressure in her eyes, nose and head.

[¶6] Ms. Oakland eventually ran out the front door and flagged down a neighbor who was pulling his car out of his driveway. She told the neighbor that someone was after her and she needed to get away. Mr. Buszkiewic left the house when Ms. Oakland did, so she asked the neighbor to take her back to the house to get her things. Mr. Buszkiewic returned to the house about the same time as Ms. Oakland. The neighbor initially parked in the driveway of Mr. Buszkiewic's house to wait for Ms. Oakland, but then decided it was not safe to remain there, so he drove away and called 911. In the meantime, Mr. Buszkiewic took Ms. Oakland to the bedroom one more time and slapped her. She was able to gather her belongings and leave after the *1276last incident. Ms. Oakland stopped at a convenience store for gas, and the attendant noticed that she looked frightened and watchful as she pumped the gas.

[¶7] Laramie police officers responded to the 911 call. They asked Mr. Buszkiewic what happened, and he said that he and his girlfriend had an argument but denied it had turned physical. The officers learned that Ms. Oakland had contacts in Sheridan, so they asked the authorities there for assistance in locating her.

[¶8] Ms. Oakland drove to Sheridan and went to an urgent care facility. A physician's assistant took her history and examined her. Ms. Oakland had injuries to her face, eardrum and head, and bruising on her arms. Her voice was hoarse and she had petechiae in one eye, which the physician assistant found consistent with Ms. Oakland's report that she had been strangled. The medical staff contacted law enforcement, and Sheridan police officers interviewed Ms. Oakland and took photographs of her injuries.

[¶9] The Sheridan authorities reported the results of their investigation to the Laramie police, and Mr. Buszkiewic was arrested. At the time of his arrest, Mr. Buszkiewic admitted that his altercation with Ms. Oakland had turned physical, but claimed she struck him first and he had merely retaliated. The Albany County prosecutor charged Mr. Buszkiewic with two counts of strangulation of a household member in violation of Wyo. Stat. Ann. § 6-2-509(a)(i) (LexisNexis 2017). The matter was tried to a jury, which found him guilty of both counts. After the district court sentenced Mr. Buszkiewic, he appealed to this Court.

STANDARD OF REVIEW

[¶10] Mr. Buszkiewic claims the prosecutor committed several instances of misconduct during her closing argument to the jury. Because he did not properly object to the prosecutor's statements during trial, our appellate review is limited to a search for plain error. Hamilton v. State, 2017 WY 72, ¶ 7, 396 P.3d 1009, 1011 (Wyo. 2017) (citing Watts v. State , 2016 WY 40, ¶ 6, 370 P.3d 104, 106 (Wyo. 2016) ). To establish the district court committed plain error, Mr. Buszkiewic must show: "1) the record is clear about the incident alleged as error; 2) the district court transgressed a clear and unequivocal rule of law; and 3) he was denied a substantial right resulting in material prejudice." Sindelar v. State, 2018 WY 29, ¶ 16, 416 P.3d 764, 768 (Wyo. 2018). See also , Johns v. State , 2018 WY 16, ¶ 12, 409 P.3d 1260, 1264 (Wyo. 2018).

[¶11] This Court generally hesitates to find plain error in closing argument because the trial court should not be placed in " 'a position of having to sua sponte challenge remarks of counsel when there is otherwise no objection thereto.' " Webb v. State, 2017 WY 108, ¶ 28, 401 P.3d 914, 925 (Wyo. 2017) (quoting Solis v. State , 2013 WY 152, ¶ 40, 315 P.3d 622, 632 (Wyo. 2013) ). However, even though prosecutors are given wide latitude in arguing their cases, there are boundaries. Carroll v. State , 2015 WY 87, ¶ 32, 352 P.3d 251, 259 (Wyo. 2015).

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Andrew Lee Boyer v. The State of Wyoming
2025 WY 100 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2025)
William Corey Holliday v. The State of Wyoming
2025 WY 44 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2025)
William Frederick Patterson v. The State of Wyoming
2025 WY 30 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2025)
Monique Huia Sullivan v. The State of Wyoming
2025 WY 5 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2025)
Ronald Leroy King v. The State of Wyoming
2023 WY 36 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2023)
Terry Dean Anderson v. The State of Wyoming
2022 WY 119 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2022)
Bradley Dean Jackson v. The State of Wyoming
2021 WY 92 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2021)
Hunter Lee Hicks v. The State of Wyoming
2021 WY 2 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2021)
Charles Alfred Armajo v. The State of Wyoming
2020 WY 153 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2020)
Amber R. Shields v. The State of Wyoming
2020 WY 101 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2020)
Jesse James Hartley v. The State of Wyoming
2020 WY 40 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2020)
Mark Daniel Byerly v. The State of Wyoming
2019 WY 130 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Sean Wayne Weston v. The State of Wyoming
2019 WY 113 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Farrow v. State
437 P.3d 809 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Dockter v. State
436 P.3d 890 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Larkins v. State
429 P.3d 28 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2018)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
424 P.3d 1272, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/buszkiewic-v-state-wyo-2018.