Brown v. Pool Depot, Inc.

853 So. 2d 181, 2002 Ala. LEXIS 360, 2002 WL 31845904
CourtSupreme Court of Alabama
DecidedDecember 20, 2002
Docket1011032
StatusPublished
Cited by4 cases

This text of 853 So. 2d 181 (Brown v. Pool Depot, Inc.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Supreme Court of Alabama primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Brown v. Pool Depot, Inc., 853 So. 2d 181, 2002 Ala. LEXIS 360, 2002 WL 31845904 (Ala. 2002).

Opinion

853 So.2d 181 (2002)

David BROWN
v.
The POOL DEPOT, INC.

1011032.

Supreme Court of Alabama.

December 20, 2002.

Stan Brobston of Brobston & Brobston, P.C., Bessemer, for appellant.

James A. Kee, Jr., Angela C. Shields, and Olivia S. Matuszak of Kee & Selby, L.L.P., Birmingham, for appellee.

JOHNSTONE, Justice.

The plaintiff David Brown appeals the order of the trial court compelling him to arbitrate his tort claims against the defendant The Pool Depot, Inc. Brown argues that, because Pool Depot, a foreign corporation, was not qualified to do business in Alabama at the time Pool Depot contracted to sell and to install an aboveground pool at Brown's Alabama residence, Alabama's door-closing statute, § 10-2B-15.02, Ala.Code 1975, voids the pool contract and bars Pool Depot from enforcing *182 the pool contract and its arbitration provision. We agree.

On February 29, 2000, a representative of Pool Depot, a Georgia corporation, approached Brown, an Alabama resident, to solicit Brown's purchase of an aboveground pool to be installed by Pool Depot at Brown's Alabama residence. On that day Brown executed a contract for the purchase and installation of the aboveground pool. The contract reads in part:

"The Pool Depot Incorporated Of Georgia "Date: 2-29-00 "Over 20,000 Pools Installed "Florida License, Tennessee License, Virginia License, Maryland License "120 Interstate North Parkway East * Suite 426 * Atlanta, Georgia 30339 (Local) XXX-XXX-XXXX * (Out of Area) 800-788-9832 * www.pooldepot.net "Purchasers affidavit: I (We) Attest that I (We) have Legal Ownership of the listed real property below: "Name: David Brown "Address: 1713 Neil Road County: Jefferson "City: Birmingham State: AL Zip: 35214 "Phone______ "Section A) Pool Package includes: Purchase Price $9495.00 "1-1/2H.P. Pump, 150 lbs. capacity "sand filter system, automatic timer, "underwater light, automatic pool sweep, Deposit Received $ 200.00 "25 GA sparkle print virgin vinyl liner "with tile border, automatic pool Balance Due $9295.00 "purification system, in-wall skimmer "chemical start-up kit, wall mounted fountain, "solar blanket winter cover "Section B) Pool Size & Type "[x]24'Round [ ]27'Round [ ]Oval "[ ]A-frame ladder (to be used without a deck) "[x]In-pool ladder (to be used only with a deck) "Section C).... "Section D).... "Section E) Completely Installed: A leveling of plain dirt is included in the contract price. Any dig over 2 feet purchaser agrees to pay $8 per inch directly to the installation crew at the time of installation. The 2-foot dig does not include digging down into level ground to bury the pool, hauling in dirt, or any type of rock removal. These require additional charges and should purchaser [Brown] require dealer [Pool Depot] to perform such services, purchaser agrees to pay these additional charges to the dealer. Installation normally takes one or more days. Installation crew will supply approximately 2 tons of sand and concrete blocks (if deemed necessary by the installation crew). Installers use various types of equipment depending on the difficulty of installation. *183 "Section F) Completion: Dealer [Pool Depot] and Purchaser [Brown] agree that the pool is completed when the pool is assembled. Dealer will not be expected to wait until purchaser's pool is filled with water to receive payment. (It has been our experience that this can take 2 or 3 days.) All monies due at completion are to be paid directly to the installation crew (½ at the commencement of work, the balance upon completion of work) unless specified otherwise. Dealer cannot be held responsible for installation if not installed by dealer." (Emphasis added.)

The contract also includes an arbitration provision. The contract states further that the purchaser can cancel the contract within three days of execution.

On March 16, 2002, Brown telephoned Pool Depot to cancel the contract. Thereafter, Pool Depot sent Brown a document entitled "Official Document, Lien Notice, Illegal Cancellation," which reads, in part:

"What is Illegal Cancellation? According to Section K, Number 15, `I(we) understand agree that no Verbal, Telephone, or Facsimile transmitted cancellation of this contract can be accepted and that no penalty or fee may be assessed by dealer if proper cancellation notification is given as defined by the 3-Day "Buyers Right to Cancel". I(we) agree that this agreement cannot be cancelled for any reason after the 3-Day "Buyer's Right to Cancel" has expired unless the entire purchase price is paid to dealer.' YOU DID NOT PROVIDE A LEGAL CANCELLATION NOTIFICATION AS DEFINED BY THE 3-DAY `BUYERS RIGHT TO CANCEL', THEREFORE YOU CANCELLED ILLEGALLY. You now owe us the Full Purchase Price.
"If you do not work out this problem by calling 1-800-788-1831, Ext 1. (ask for Mr. Clark), within 10 days we may, at our option, file the attached lien against your personal residence and/or any other personal property that you may own, including but not limited to your personal residence, checking or savings account, retirement account, car, furniture, etc., that will accrue interest at 1-and-½% per month, (18% per year), until the lien is paid in full....
"If you choose not to work this problem out with us after we file the lien and disagree with our legal position, we will be glad to go to Binding Arbitration as contained on the front of the Pool Contract you signed (See Pool Contract Section G Binding Arbitration Agreement). Neither you nor us can file a lawsuit as, according to the Arbitration agreement, the only option is to go to Binding Arbitration in Cobb County, Georgia. If we lose, (we have never lost an arbitration hearing), we will release the lien. If we win, the arbitrator will order you to pay us.
"Most consumers are surprised [ (this emphasis added) ] to find out in a legal proceeding, such as an arbitration hearing, the written Pool Contract always rules the outcome. What a salesperson or company representative allegedly says has no bearing on how an arbitrator rules....

"Sincerely,

"Mr. Clark

"P.S. Let's be reasonable. Why pay the FULL PURCHASE PRICE OR OUR ATTORNEY FEES (under Section N, `Attorney Fees: Purchaser agrees to pay Pool Depot's attorney fees necessary to defend any disputes and/or allegations arising in any manner relating to this agreement'), and your ATTORNEY FEES and still not have a pool to swim in?
"P.S. We also TAPE RECORDED the sale. Remember President Clinton paid Paula Jones approximately $900,000 and *184 got fined an additional $85,000 by the judge for testifying different from what was on the tape. The new Independent Counsel, after Kenneth Starr, also has the option to indict President Clinton for `PERJURY' after he leaves office. I think you will agree `PERJURY' is a serious offense."

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Kelley v. Nawas International Travel Service, Inc.
68 So. 3d 823 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 2011)
Andrews v. CENTRAL PETROLEUM, INC.
63 So. 3d 650 (Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama, 2010)
TRADEWINDS ENVIRONMENTAL RESTORATION, INC. v. Brown Bros. Constr., LLC
999 So. 2d 875 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 2008)
DecisionQuest, Inc. v. Hayes
863 So. 2d 90 (Supreme Court of Alabama, 2003)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
853 So. 2d 181, 2002 Ala. LEXIS 360, 2002 WL 31845904, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/brown-v-pool-depot-inc-ala-2002.