Brown, Robert Ford III

Texas Supreme Court·Decided March 11, 2015·No. WR-71,460-04·Published

Opinion

NO. 05~3©"7»-{;<3'7'7@ 4 4 quo »0L14 C>< 004¢+< §§ 1~ 102 aw"»‘: “5'00100\

Q040Qf4 390me § 55+{ C.\` CD\)¢+ er 1 '

H@NALAPP;EALS MAR;12015 4 WAM, 000 ©@jGQT:@p‘ 5 40 S 4 /\T€' 5 9’\0'\`104~.4 / ‘T'O _1$..€AL,-

V § ,'4)-3»44 404~\50/4 COW\'

3404& 99 T€>

TO 74/\€- Nonofabe Q01)9.4

,, N0w C_<>MQS QOMA 9000232 400 Qw~@ 40 dew

BVOQV\ LLL 41D.C 434 398ch Qnd

‘4LQ 540~\23 |`“\cv’r bn 90 Seo\` ~§Lq 904 ..1CQ 9`0()0(4 409 419 \O\Y`\SGV\ C00f44/3AUS`4 4/4 400 4“CQ` bepl+ .

` 4 . ,.\ ,w_, _ _,_.' .~.. g" .7 ';`~. \4-' ,, , ;, , ~¢ .., . .. . 4 _. ': -. = " . wk_;-, ' m 14 . . . " ; y 1¢ 4 . " .»"’ -"" ..,-*’ ' 14 ; “" _ .` , ,-;'" 4 v 4 ' 14 .~ .-‘ § 2 .' -'. x _¢‘. ~ ‘ "_ ,' 14 41 '1 \- ~< - ~ v -' . ','. ~ 4 1' '.- " . ~ .1`_¢ ...~ -. 4 _,1 11_ |. \~, _..¢' ~ '.. ' ' \ ‘

»; .. 1 1 1 - .~.;.\ 4 _1.; § -; __ - .1 .,14 . ~ _-,_~ 1 , .,,, , ,,.~~ w _ 4.. .-_. ____.15- '4 l`..r,~ <"

49\@ SJFO\*`Q 3 P{\{“\Q/\t QSSQ(">\OV\ \S -GLG`+ ~€LQ fQFO/t_j 00404 5€.»’\34% \/0 60+0 \»>Q\\ 0\\ 440 004<1 \S known 90 419 b`QQQ\)SQ \000~40 604\ was 45\1 9404\§2 Q\)QM\,/\ 9404/40>0 Aas+r\g( 4,00<,2. 454 542€ 5003 54§ c\lej bg \_\ 044/43 005 … 410+4£¢14\)44>0> 910 05 JCLQ_ AQ+Q 0£ b\r~\Ls 0004¢ 3+0+00 00 de 92¢0(& `74\Q O`L)QSMA

OL)\A 996 \»34/7\§ \:1"5 `94€ 4540\‘\`€ nOL)~) 794(\5'(\3 to \(\\/O]§€ w §> q \Dgézgj \\` \{m(s C\HQ( 942 904@4 'IS \>V \MQG-US'Q' mg A 0 Y\@@ 444:+ 1 40__0\/@ O\ wgn 'LMIQ 1\0 0\3)¢103¢ fmi \<(w: Q\% x`\ V\S \% m JCLO§)L 9000(+5 \L\Q SM 9\ 350 § 49\0:\ @\)Q(\-} r\ 9\06 949\/99 r*\(/\Q\Q 0\940440_( Q\Q 51 @»€ :n;i:`CQ/,; 99 :& Q\/\ \A b\\ 904/\40€4 49%9090 j 3005 ~(Loi

00 \\O\§? iLC ,4\\)59 n 904\(€21§€§\54 94<;>_40\%_ “_4.`4<>-4> FQP®H~ '~' \~2093

"_l':f \{0\) re¥er {c> MLL Jc.v".`( nl`. AJC€ sinai (Uu§S-ell )~{un+ 355 pfe¢+!,;&\ holes `\’r .‘>+CK*QS*AUS+"'“ §O\‘CQM'Q*"`O€€%C‘QF "Qh@'fl€#§d<>er \Om\§ M.`AQ\\Q SQ.\/)o@\¢ @\)QM#\(\;~,"__B_..b'D\/§ §§X\)g_\l\"_ §§go\@\~\,¢é @SQ}\OD(\ 50` H~Q’c_ QVD\/Q.S (`\57;¥ '%L.Qr>e_ Jgk>€v 0\ ,\”Q{Q`Of¥ Q__XAI§A“ §OI“[PL\>Y\~Q(Q§ M,,\ ‘.£ 3109 few w <(

' %Q\((`Qf\' K\)\V\M `\`,\€\QQ;§,-\§ `f\*l/\Q'¢’\ \V»€.:{$»Qf ”"!c> CKIZ \Ll.~q'@‘ LH)'\`/\( NL){\-(' Oj{(€<_l ®.\SQ|M\,A do \[Do \UDQ wym_~¥ \,;\`1;,`~3,*¢@\4\<\03_ A\)ou+ ov\`+t,o\+g£m(: ®\)_Q/r*'~'\/\/€>St \\\\)v\."\-\»b\”@\*'\§ \“\_'Q +°”Wm§ Q’b°°`t` 3 Q`\}QM`H` W,)"P/\._ m §O@)§MQ {<> 111 v\<>€€¥*@~\*@$?’° 09%‘~13';~‘1“\" 5*°"’.*~¢\"€\1 »'Y@»>\é : l

' wng Q,»\Q\<'s€s» \>\W‘*' @‘“**5‘,> '“" ?<<'"@ A"Q*.""“'_°-if.,. ‘:°'v few F‘:@ <€@,HY"',’°,{.*"’SN>P”Y:;*@ l

~ SM.Q§ ~H;O¢ GO\NQD (\>\D">‘&`.A 09 05"\`"3*““`1€@"”‘+@ °:"""?W€’ '

lB\lfm*"\c)\/\t'>. '_Th{ MUHU 'go\)\c]v\`* Cor~/\`Q!':.'§.){>: 'pj".+L_.;O\n»(;'OjQ {-L(j:$

\>~c\\es.$, Q\)I;Mkn wl;l, her +L;S.,- * 1 l » § |¢ ` '/ /",'

M

' ‘ '_T)qe` 3+<:3~€} 56 WQLO( J<"`}j?h§%<>` SQQ§\.+L€ reca;rc{§' l munoz U~€-_¢( `\UO\~`>;PZ~§§\ 953 ‘\\X Om-\L bbd'§ ..Jco Wc>\/e M ~QQ,-\§Q:,`: W\Qj~\ S¥\<\\ ."\m.Q~’X\f\'~uj\i `;\m$b,+;(d .\{\Y\O_@z/\w1 [\/\B\f\\.‘ThQ/.\ "_{Z;"\{Ob ?(Q¥U 450 Qp/QL@(+Q \/5",\"€><@:3'; Be.@_¢jr\w\%o£*¢q¢\g\\\= 0an

1 O@+Q.@+.\/e S.QMCQS. -L¢:>@:»;l T`»<. Aq>p L>

gm

"r@; AQ!~\: n _ C@¢l£ § 700 .3,@3"€'3) -=’Y® “WY“°S+Z<; b<»p'+ Up¢>'n o` properly 505@++€4 reaves-§ %<> wa}¢\€ 00@@55 fm QO/\-F.'§Q_w\¥\&\ ‘\.\f\\/'QS§§§G*.;\D”\'("Q`C.©Yé3 H+_O _C\f\ "\-Y\Q\"'\/\’§UM

who o\m% Q\\QSQQ <>f 6@€*5 V\»<>\*FQS\ \0\\ §Ll'/_\a¥l,‘>~\,

')3 a pmm\. @ML-e Q\\.Q§Qé \)1 Q,+'\… Of<>\/iéev\ £Lv@\g

_m_ (MM QSAQS<:/\\»Qa w Sw\ 1@_<>@@‘~‘ "<>¢:).»»L»z +’MQ S@€tL,-.Q \),A"S -.`0@¥1@~@. S?~@L>\Jb‘l ‘/~Q\A ¥D +\Yé SU'L . S§~Qr_\écm§§\ 'W\Qm"\!\ W \’{3"\ 5®3¢\ ‘;)QS +\\sz`i/\Q@\'\ Q<;)\3@,0¥\%\€§* +'D'+LQ vepcojf§$ calm/13 he biU‘> 503/15 t<> Q.G\l, WCW §.1'\<>_¢{» `TY\Q V€COY§‘§ 45§'}\¢:>@);1-§`\/&.

' AQ\/W bQ;Q`/‘ (M_C:“HM '*`(\ 'MQ Y:'m¢l\/\§ ©-@ Y:c§c+§_ § 'Ca`>»/jg_\u§\oni 0¥ Lo\~> bQ~Cm>~ze; wm tom »{¢_Lq Cw(..+_ \ CDM{_, §§ q ,¥c£yr AQCHSK`OV\ w'\-*v'Loo+/Q\\ ila ¥c-,C)rg bQM/§J +LQ'»\~ “’\.QW\‘"§ °\» \>“\"“Qd°"‘*€§ VQ~”S"‘<>‘/\._ @>l? fda P@{~;QQ ,Q.Q..QDWC$. ,' . g " ` "

MQ(QWLD{QH }\Qpl'.c_c>\(\§-' \Ofo_\( +`quc flsa ‘CQ\)(§ di§m`\,@§ fLQ v

S+Q+<: z M@*'\O‘~ *O -SQ@\\

S\)L M ¥QA

:Q@S QQ+\F " / l _i._.....

l w>béri, l/ém,>n WO~S€

w`\(’ 043 §e(\/. Q,.Q,r¢.~€~\ -J~Q… w mma k\i`§a@»@`& wl @c HQ _j l€w¢j.¢<…$ we §§ wm w L,`\$Q.Ew¢ ¢\'~d< ads G%rs¢~+ML/)< ' "z%'§;n wm \S*C\Q€§ ‘“\Q-"~\\ ' g §§ j }/,B )

39§3 . v § {

C<'>.U§e /1)0‘ 043737@7<1<377@ €><~ ~191_,:11~1€. § "1'“ 3111 377+1 413111<~1 ~ ` _ §§ COUH 045 7 7054'1104 6“5°'11’1545 §§ 1313»"441'12111:;01~1 4110/1171 T€)

/\B' NT>\M "41:> V\‘/ w03(`17`;“[041$ 194 741/§

»-_..,_..'_, ----»»~»..~....,. _~~_,.__

49 ‘;,,,013/;§/;1§1)111%> _O/'<`; 061/l

-Ȣ~_......,`__`_

»- _’____-',,.._-°"

”" _.1"(_(’_ 17 1;

4. 14~~@ :>4<<31.~4’€ 1:4c41'111_ A1111'~1 1401 1311€1'11111 1'1111<~? 411/1691 ’1111 B€€G~<.’<’ 61€<1111./, :@ w 34,4;/~ x 04{1@.1'131\.1“ {3111>:11'¢@\?1301@<(/&191111411.11.1»-@32) 5 :7` %11111< § 1§`\/" 541° 0311\"/`4 141-145 343"".4‘ (5?£ f{"§‘? 331::€1 1904 4.'11°1?" 4<’ 55 1§34” 54“€1'411"‘ “511@1/§ \'1’>1111»

Q\SS(),§_,)\§'Q.< f\) \O 1,\} 4’~}€1'€ 13 'Jf//`q; 1"‘£`/'/3‘4f

40111.19 "13"11‘1': <4041’1?51‘5 34

'~

Q<`,"}Gf /€ }

114 4@01@1 11 n 1 3 111111 1594/§ 1177/1119 140 429 `,,»,,,L 594 1419 1313> »A. “~'MW’&:ZLW >L)D}S'O?w '1'”41> 1"1'$4/)141/1,-;) ,)( SCLWO\ wanij 411:9,~.¢\ 451?13»3 19 4 .¢4<11 §1/.110? 4’.:~:" lay ._:~"`@,/ @. 4 ,AM b_)_`§l ¢(3§;1’;’ \Q(;(_;1_~41g 431/4§/514(‘)&(4.\.?‘1?//1".)/4';1”;,'4'41.;\,

ll

v __ j j 441'0'"' '.";~1) § 31\1“.11.,.;1 5’43 3.1"1€.142_11" 01‘1»1?' 1.~3'€ '.S~‘:»’,L`)€?~11/411:?1‘ 415'1",1' 544 // _ 5 \\,4\7(.4¥’4!‘4' § ]/44>/./~5 Uz" j \€ S'IO+~Q 1)\)\4

b 1 ).'?01 1€5-`}’>5)11141.’~19 ',1{,. C:‘(`J\A`z!\’\, I“i’ 45 f`}_£\‘{,;\{ ;'7\1\1"~+]`0_ \r: ri\ic!! 134"}

~ 1’.`}”7 143 5 G/’)@/> 4 l"l" . s"J,OuJ (4">1?‘> /‘1:§}'/‘113,!“4? 44‘~])"1"41!: 4)1,1 ':*1!, § -'0 i(é: §3,.,€ hug {\);q`/ WC,M,.{_Q (_`;§1,‘_4 C/r.~.; 201 /!Zn+ ; 1..00(__` j{/\j 11()}17€, /05 40 4)":' )‘:4143‘ 145 134-34 510le C£)L.)4C_4 {"{ ;`,4') 5114)1§" 4`1/1/ U`D`),L/ ':.(,> 11 111 ;1:1@111111 111»111.»11>111@314111».1 11,.,,,/1…,¢ _ '1,'4 {\4411( 4./.&;4 \1\1 641/11’,.. L‘U 4'(.‘44¢ 40 ,n'v/p°,?` umw/l ~3' .. 439;,1;! »`~:}3(`.11.;4' 7401)€/1?$', ;,$11'14 §11/01 19111))1)) 0 ,_1/~-.1`1 -/444 01 ~+4$,; 1‘3 401141114’<2"41’~ /F<§§ 4~41$14/

,1' 004 @ 61 ""L 1'11'€'""&~ 1/, /@1’11414117 1145/1105

;“`.¢("

i'v(./’l 431" 519§(`,: }f ;Ul ,1-~;» (1¢?(\¢/<; 140 /`1€ /)5‘§‘4§(;3

" »“~'>‘*i'~‘.§¢~\ `\_

.-"“°”""

}'01£3

__ ____ _ ._.__ _

o? 514 \/<>0 11:€1 49 §_44$_._MC.9.-1115 q[:/@FOA%’ 35 +L/….! 194?»`)95 41 510\11§ <-4~§)914€9§$ 499€§'114'5:/1'./.~\/_€\0/9

__,.__--- .. ._.,...,.-

_'~____,._......~.-.~ - ---

47043€- vemon 5/\‘<1 1394 ’_355"~"55’547 5’33 345 45<4 414»0441"11§4 034 f>"r "»411)/'“».9 ~44'?@~"'7 '/3 534 CC`S€ 4/"( h 534/250 €@" `)V("J_S@ (/_JG_S 1304 445 "4’1” 51 3*354\ 35 C“ nw mac 4‘"5':“`3 5”`3}55

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Brown, Robert Ford III, (Tex. 2015).

Brown, Robert Ford III (Brown, Robert Ford III) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.