Brooks, Ronnie Ray

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: January 5, 2015
• Docket: WR-12,444-13
• Status: Published

Opinion

'-•

Ji:.o./X ~,9//k-· /C/JAIAII~hiJt.d/LLJ~.I!t C!. //.f.£. /'h. 2. JUJ5" C...f.-?'!ltb:s 11.:1. r'I)IJm :lA£ 2.91) ~ DLfiJ~Uel ~--_r~p1'iiA_s 11£~A/2. C~JiJAI1ii_J 7ZX~

IL-7:/.;T;,; J/)/6 i.JJ12J7;)1H/,~ch/JWS" t::;Ai! 1/nd/JilA~I£. fudgED/ ..1Htcl L!d.uAI -~ Nod~ tJM£S..i /(ofi~£ ~AY.t1&1J/(_s;·h£~Aik72 1&/~JLiJh/JJf-M-4 7'£Man£/fj di.ME ~:inJI.t£ Y.fflrd ./lAid AI:U~£.ud /!;811/S.£, ILJ £L%Jd.I.ES'I--~/~ .1/i;~M...tdk· C;w_d-- . 3hil'l~#iil' ~£khLJYI A~ h.JAJrLJ_/J /JU#Am.us_j ~AJd i.JfJu/d.71v'Juf'J}JJJ2IIA£12£1JJ':~ "TAnLJJ . ~ .

·1Ji/J.t.IIJ£ Jl£.ohhLJ.N'6Z hA.Y__/ldkmJJ/m ~t::r.bJMJ-5-f-A// JI/Jk .&/J1/EdJ£s' .bY J',hN'B JJ ~~LJ/11 ~~£J~ .tt.J/k:/LJJ j/J:J.IJ.I£Ji:? LllJULL'i /J.tii-AK. tll dAY n} ./ev£mktl 1-LJ/4:~ d.Ju:IJJ .IkE ftoAJ CiJu./2tl-.;.s-IIIjs L!...4-.LL"f.E'.J ..L/:,A~·. ILE._9f)f2dJd!i lA~ Ifl£.3;;/ d.tdEIV'hoAI fJ/ lA-£ ~~lr/a~.£1)- .:zr . -11/At £11.£t:lli1E :J-iu5 dAlE.. t.hkmi>£/4 ,tJ, 2-IJJI/. ~ k:I/LJ/.i hJJs> A~ .hP.E:AI iJN'~A£ ..t?e:h#tJAI~ ./ fJd-hlJAIJ'LJt2 t.J/b/. .tJI /.h.iJr.I)S1 f!.odiJ!ff. ~· h/:?r!JJI£~ AA-2 LJ/hdi#d.d.J ~~k.£Sh ILl~ .d:U~C.IA/ ..b=.v/£.L,_)_,. k/-/.;Ade h/A/L: iJLit/1:/---" 1iJJ /)~~ :IIJ£ /LhhBd.f_ ~g d-'tit1fJ/&J.M/.a:/.wriJ Ej/e.JJ-5- - .u/l£. J JIJJ~~jl£ £:..£Ju#--Llh// iJ£. AAI£ -ft'J /..ELJ.ldri/U£ :/h/S ~.£ :zJ/kA/J.J.iJ.IJIJ/1 d".s;/~~.£d .IIJL 2ffh1Ai£.h9h/ ciE.MtJ~-- ·"' -iluJIL.d .iJY rh'£ ~/Ad ~([).u./2.19 rPJ.! ~.lA/ f!.LJ.Lldl.:5' ~ ..J£1'.4L Lllu//f}, -fii.s4g ; · . · RECEIVED IN COURT OF CRIMINAL APPEALS

(1) Abei Acosta, G~t:(k .::az ffiAil-AE:. hihiNill LLllli _j.l!l(~li ~h..£: :2 ?~y lJ~ :flf/J.tJ:-mAtM. · ·tt>~5 /JJt /A£ .Jh;.dLJAA~/£ ..;e-dg_£ iJI.M£ . .Z9JJ fA. ~~;AI r:J£sil£/D~L!.:~bi2Ti)/)£xA£ ·C£JIL/j/y_,/Pi/i5 ·;..b R ~/8 LJ~f.3} J'E/};f.I7JI'iAI·£ tfi}/lf.LJffPAHi»£1# dP !2tb.M/N/JI .fLL.:!hc~ 1715h·lu.kl1# L)1vLf/£J~ ./1J.Ii M.G' /J/fJLAfj'£ .tJ/ Je...XUA/v /?SS/h//1- /'A£ fl£/;h/J~££ }As ,j

..f£1fvrd .fiJJE.ItJ YnLr 5.~£.A~f£A/t:L_;.sr£.~12.#e..IK 11t~ /_g JJ£J:J;JJ~ .g IJJ teJ tJ.II-A£ 1b.#.f. . t!)JciE til' C~/H~;,;j/fJ~t~e- .- Eci..LJit£~ . . 7SL

IJAi'o£c.Lm.I.Jil /~ 1.8/¥ uti:ML= /~d#'bb{//£U,Aih/&u'At#/£.. -ai~ .Z: /2£CLJJI.£.d ~ ~f'/h.c.A.h-LJu' ZJ~c/.e./2 .bA~.# /~iJ./12/J /JIY ..197.9... f!l2-/!!.8/.- . . .iJ£.·. {j,/JSJ£ J~ rfg~,t. . .I~~P .d/./J!Y/J1f#A.Lfl. d.~ Ltu~J~ r1? llu~. ;;;;;Js!D.. JfL.I/.t::;.t/.!1/ E/N'd.Jd9JJ/ Filf2k #AI:::J f,'oJv'C/Uj?J /~ ir!Z.J~t:.A/2C~Mcf-5Li@/ll JiJ//JifliJN/ gJI/2 ;//) J.. t/ f.JIIIf~ t!.LJMA~i//uL/11) f2A.IL~£ :d /.Kjl/;1~?-gl-/-l'llJ /iJold A I/.5J fr~/2-.S~i:!.£ .LJi,c:.i·/s ~_/!2.~1!)/~ ~J..9h/-·.. UtJ/;;H.tJA!' 11 I'DJLJ£ ~fJJmci!:s~ IJ~UtJuiJI£~i!IJJJd~ dli£0au.U£ Je1JA1J~ 12/Au.:]~ IJII-A£ Ut/rht-d 5hl-.~t1 l.!o.N's-1;~/;r;;!) /l/2o0.ciK5. #J~· . H£J 1£/lifJd 5hA-.// Ll£ h-/..b~.tt::!Ed .1-JJ ~LiJJe£ iJA~d_!j ~..~:;~· 1)/2. hm~ dll 7£l'JflA/P..ti.J Ia~ li£5Am£B/'/Mr. J.Zs, f)Alsr- /Jm£.ttid,JZ "1Jii} e.J'Ausr A~i!:k-~A/A/}P:.'ILJA-3£/llJAicl fJJt!J.5££LJhtJAI f.tJ;( lA~ SAM£ iJ//YI..!lr //.1/P:.a ./L0.u//:h~ fi)Jl JgfJA/d fJ/ifJ.5ilY.UbJJ# //J~ /iK S'AI'YJiiC IJ~.J(dr 1Jik12 [!~;/0eho.N.) /l;lc/{3JIJ1ulilfll£ /Ju/1/Jif.m/£//is liJI2 IAL.IJI'Pd5E. .. u/'hld SMs.v/L)/w~SLJ9 LJ,s~ /r;gjjLI:,9S--9bLL~9:tJ6&/l/i.#~JJ/I~ 77'~XU2.d-. . lo ~ J.1 ~2'1 (1£i~8hmJA/A /9YgJ" . ,, •' I 2J) .5UJIUYJ"£/b //);. 2-tll~ L PIJ,/~£ ~} A/loiJ~ LJ~., 3£#1-- II 1-//IJWS c:tJLI.AIIY JA_,/ ~JJ/J_ :!'A£ LJIJ'.EN:r£'£J~{jJ_f_~./lu/rl-.-­ ,~ 11h~-IY .. d!/u/df .uJ.h/e.h n/A:J /l {: IAJ:J A M:!c/OV£'AAIJI(J. 11Ncl.z t!CJ.d£ /id/i)AYJ'{#c)..f.LJAYS' £:A£d,~ 5J!iAI.Ed .IJ)' 1/,:C' 11-tJililfJ/VJ .61£. wd'JL J"64tl, 5 fJt JfL) L1AIll- r/1LJ B#ef CA.s,c,_u; i '1I 7 'ItJ 9/; 1~;J) ~ l:DuAIIY ,..1;;; f:.ZJJJ.t!lrA?LA!/ /!),.;;}. C/£12/~ .II. A?AA71/Vrz. ,

. LJ;,//1/'~//:2¥-t.ll.-'f' //d/JIM~k~E:fitkc J'./3~. SIEAl-hulc..Ed IJ:J£ :1-t:J l/5 j Y.trAU25'' J: 0; c; .:t: ~t:J./L rfAG. . VJfJ!AI-Ifl.t/i).;- C.,0/ t.&m'/Y./..~~liT~J/e~ usJA· ~B/A'hVAI tJI mY L/,.5'.. t/J.A~Sr_,;A?£/Id Y~ C.A~£· 1:1J /3·/f.~/2.2-%4- c/2 · .LfJS -&. Ju.thuAI £J/s.fiile~ /J{gAVJIJ/ifniY ~fJo...JLV.~/J'j;y.IJ~

~/I'J£/)j ~ 2LJ£J5~ L LIJAS. tAAJ2BJZd .IJ./Ia{S'~EL:/ ~ /2_j YII:.Aff ;(LJ,c ~ ..r 1'~/l M£ /l#ZA/7£ ll~3£YJ!/A/ kA-u/1 o/ / .//JJY /).//L/~!/1/ht)d z::.. . k Ai/JL4.lt!A#~ LJJA.s' /11)./4d.d.loAisA t>AI' .A~.i 191/'1- c /2...- Jl./$ I. A.Aid J}.N'LJ.It rAM M£ /J)d.J M.s £.iAAi9eo' ~Mn .fwd 1-h~ YLJu thY#/- /;AI£ k r/./1 .JPE'.9Jsi~AhtJAJ .hJJL£ !-A·£At.#/;LJJ IJJI/1)11/AIY ttJiJ..S .. tYl~ 1/#2.~ /6'_) JI£/J/29 ~LYu/11 . /lliAui.J LAS4z .LtJ..dg ~~ !dMIJAb.2A ~AI:/NbMM-1//Jf£ -~ d/d,VJ-· ~~&.LJ ~~ z:; /;I)J/JZ.~LJ /b£!i,sl£iJ /15' AJ£i Jl'.4-.1i!e?t~ J.e£ / £x fJA~ /(1/.t/.E tJ/!E .LJL 1//J 2. 414 It; :12l:k, t'/2/./Jf. .1

A~JJ, ~0£?-.:J J • E-¥ fJAILf£. ~5:0.ur-z J W09 il)i.. !9iJ/)-S//lJ 71£, t;/bmut//A ~tJ/J9.J. dAiol£/li'IJAI·I_f-/.11/£.~ /i:L J:.tU,Jci '11~ '/fl; tm.m~~~:l14 ~tJo&J,. eK'/#Illi£ IIL9A,t~ ~lJ!J% WL :JL,'~ 1~£) tliil~II/At;.. ~~2tJLJfJ)~.

L.3) ' ....~

JlfJfJ!J~JAAII /S E/1,1;1/Ac!/-o khd~~sa:JJJAJ'~J.~v _.4~ !JJl ./Ius L~.s~ A££l/Ju~£ ; / ~h~ L:/J:~JA-9£.2 /EHl0N'.G' .4...!3A/-ir/ . /1 cJ~)£Jii.#AirnAr LJUJAJ!J d(;sLJ/#L·L£!~)'; M4· etJ.o~.H~.r ..!z:J~LJ.Ed lA£ OM£:12 b);//AILYdb/.MS'£ IJAiiAA;/(i)A-J ~tJA1./t/dA/EAI/ A1';//:Y/Y£AJ:/~ L'bh LJ/AlrLJ/1/~ ~.o YAff . .YA.t=./1~//g/'_/i£ ~£lu~ zrl Y~/£JJ/-A.£ floL.bY/.J kt::A/&/ 1/A/d h :fA£ lle:/Jd LJ~ :1-i~ hi!-/1./J t2J//J ~{!£. J}!I#Jvf~a f}P/i£ ~.u.fh.h£;;· iu:/lM.b#·:flM.!!LIHd .M//ch_qe.J;.JJ.!i£ M~ d~)4fld~~~- .Dik 4£ LA/1£ ?J)-&r 3.~.r/1//P·_A;.A_ ~E kMAJs'Jt'LJ/lh#LJAI, :/iii L?L7d.t= .. {J/1/At~P'bJtJ_~AJAJ,/Lk~~-& ~11'2. t;rlJ;~ ~12~1!/;e£ !],Lhdd' C/biH;U~IIJR~f!#t'E' llJc/ Vl41Llc£du/l£ 1!9, 1:,6 2 U.'//_59'; ' ' '

-IIUY£L , JJ;,c&;/&A£) ~~JJ!ILJP;;J~Ys li£ L!o.uu t.AA-Aii- .JJ;s BA9.110L. ltoJtJJJJ£/!AY A/lLJj}k ~ ~£ Lt/sL;h-:#.M£d lnum :M..~:t :dl£SA/ ~M/t1AJ/ UJi#L?s £d -L.C6Y ~9?)-* LJt~YI&~/~ou~ .

2~D££ 1/}11 li'ls ~/£. - -dt;; tJI- f.c_;./f illl/11£ ILJ 11£ Jlc~&/ .dd&divls ~1i&iJ~£ &uliJ!d.

&AAv~------·-------- ~£U} -------

r

.J;;;j~£ --:IALS/~.dJ L.Y)

'' 't

~~~~~ r:J£LJh/ti.Jpi/J;t/ .. z:· /t>A~.III~ ~J.Aa/Jd~ .. d#.hY£AdJJ>.I}£;ai//J Ht# .J· tzu£ ~.A/'d !Jt:J/tii£L?.:I e£JIY I!?J :lA£ ./ltiJL7V'£ · IJAid F'LJ/2£.9LJ/JV5 /[kh?Ll/~.A>/-J' ~7/LJA) -'UJ/IUJ/4&1 . AY d/A){!~cl 5~/J<'./~. /#~:~/~ .h"Jgh_g€; ,/J&ls£eJ.IhJJJ_!j ~.fJd' J;;;/_g6 LJ~ :1!££ .zto~· rD/~I!.R !Jcd.tar-5'/IJJ //f)~/LJJ ~- . . . . 7%205

1t,/AJ/£L~y ~~ /227&_&9 '/2.,. .Jf....--:i.J!J/4 /-luAl6-lh//£ .~ L£,;/7--- .K/5 /.2 J# ..JtiL££J HuvLs6//t::J ~- ~7':1-'7".t_,

{!5)