Breen v. Oregon Transportation Commission

Court of Appeals of Oregon

Breen v. Oregon Transportation Commission

782 P.2d 952, 99 Or. App. 473

CourtCourt of Appeals of Oregon

DecidedNovember 22, 1989

Docket88C 10070; CA A49551

StatusPublished

This text of 782 P.2d 952 (Breen v. Oregon Transportation Commission) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Oregon primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook

Breen v. Oregon Transportation Commission, 782 P.2d 952, 99 Or. App. 473 (Or. Ct. App. 1989).

Pincite

Opinion

DEITS, J.

In this action challenging the selection process for the design of Oregon’s graphic license plates, plaintiffs appeal from a judgment entered on defendant Oregon Transportation Commission’s motion for summary judgment. We dismiss the appeal as moot.

The 1987 legislature created a design contest for new vehicle license plates. ORS 803.510. The Commission conducted the contest and, in January, 1988, selected a winner. Plaintiffs, whose entries were not selected, filed an action in circuit court challenging the selection process. They alleged that it was improper, because not all of the entries were considered and the winning design violated the statutory criteria. Plaintiffs sought a judgment that would invalidate the Commission’s selection and require it to consider all of the entries. However, plaintiffs did not seek a recall and replacement of license plates already issued.

The Commission moved for summary judgment, arguing that plaintiffs’ complaint was not timely filed under the Administrative Procedures Act, ORS ch 183. The trial court granted the motion, and plaintiffs appealed. The Commission moved to dismiss the appeal, arguing that the case has become moot by the enactment of legislation altering the color scheme of the graphic plate design.

The pertinent legislation is Oregon Laws 1989, chapter 742, section 4, which provides:

“Registration plates chosen by the commission pursuant to section 1, chapter 572, Oregon Laws 1987, shall have the colors chosen by the commission except that the sky shall be blue.”

That legislation ratified and modified the license plate design selected by the Commission. It does not require the Commission to conduct a new contest to implement the design that the legislature has chosen. Therefore, because plaintiffs only contest the issuance of plates in the future, a challenge to the procedures used in the original selection process is moot. See Mid-County Future Alternatives v. City of Portland, 95 Or App 556, 559, 770 P2d 604, rev allowed 308 Or 315 (1989).

Appeal dismissed.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

DEITS, J.

In this action challenging the selection process for the design of Oregon’s graphic license plates, plaintiffs appeal from a judgment entered on defendant Oregon Transportation Commission’s motion for summary judgment. We dismiss the appeal as moot.

The 1987 legislature created a design contest for new vehicle license plates. ORS 803.510. The Commission conducted the contest and, in January, 1988, selected a winner. Plaintiffs, whose entries were not selected, filed an action in circuit court challenging the selection process. They alleged that it was improper, because not all of the entries were considered and the winning design violated the statutory criteria. Plaintiffs sought a judgment that would invalidate the Commission’s selection and require it to consider all of the entries. However, plaintiffs did not seek a recall and replacement of license plates already issued.

The Commission moved for summary judgment, arguing that plaintiffs’ complaint was not timely filed under the Administrative Procedures Act, ORS ch 183. The trial court granted the motion, and plaintiffs appealed. The Commission moved to dismiss the appeal, arguing that the case has become moot by the enactment of legislation altering the color scheme of the graphic plate design.

The pertinent legislation is Oregon Laws 1989, chapter 742, section 4, which provides:

“Registration plates chosen by the commission pursuant to section 1, chapter 572, Oregon Laws 1987, shall have the colors chosen by the commission except that the sky shall be blue.”

That legislation ratified and modified the license plate design selected by the Commission. It does not require the Commission to conduct a new contest to implement the design that the legislature has chosen. Therefore, because plaintiffs only contest the issuance of plates in the future, a challenge to the procedures used in the original selection process is moot. See Mid-County Future Alternatives v. City of Portland, 95 Or App 556, 559, 770 P2d 604, rev allowed 308 Or 315 (1989).

Appeal dismissed.

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)

782 P.2d 952, 99 Or. App. 473, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/breen-v-oregon-transportation-commission-orctapp-1989.

Opinion

Related

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack