Bradbury v. Harvey

2016 Ark. App. 538

• Court: Court of Appeals of Arkansas
• Decided: November 9, 2016
• Docket: CV-16-97
• Status: Published

Opinion

Cite as 2016 Ark. App. 538

ARKANSAS COURT OF APPEALS DIVISION IV No. CV-16-97

Opinion Delivered November 9, 2016

RALPH BRADBURY APPEAL FROM THE PULASKI APPELLANT COUNTY CIRCUIT COURT, SIXTH DIVISION V. [NO. 60CV-2011-5472]

EDWARD HARVEY; BONNIE HONORABLE CHRISTOPHER HARVEY; and MARVIN JONES CHARLES PIAZZA, JUDGE APPELLEES APPEAL DISMISSED WITHOUT PREJUDICE; MOTION TO DISMISS MOOT

BRANDON J. HARRISON, Judge

Ralph Bradbury appeals two Pulaski County Circuit Court summary-judgment

orders. We must dismiss this appeal without prejudice because there is no final order in the

circuit court.

Whether an order is final and therefore appealable is a jurisdictional question that this

court will raise on its own. Kowalski v. Rose Drugs of Dardanelle, Inc., 2009 Ark. 524, 357

S.W.3d 432. The orders that Bradbury has appealed are not final because they do not

resolve Edward Harvey’s and Bonnie Harvey’s counterclaim against Bradbury for an alleged

breach of fiduciary duty. See City of Corning v. Cochran, 350 Ark. 12, 14, 84 S.W.3d 439,

441 (2002) (pending counterclaim destroys finality).

1 Cite as 2016 Ark. App. 538

We take this opportunity to remind Bradbury that, should he appeal again, his

addendum must include all papers that are essential to confirm our jurisdiction. Arkansas

Supreme Court Rule 4-2(a)(8)(A) (2015).

A final point. The Harveys moved to dismiss Bradbury’s appeal because “the claims

against the John Doe defendants are not adjudicated and continue to exist” and that an order

dismissing two defendants from the case was entered after Bradbury had filed his notice of

appeal. Based on our finality decision, the motion is moot.

Appeal dismissed without prejudice; motion to dismiss moot.

VIRDEN and BROWN, JJ., agree.

Jack Nelson Jones, P.A., by: Randy Coleman, for appellant.

Barber Law Firm PLLC, by: Robert L. Henry III, for appellees Edward Harvey and

Bonnie Harvey.

Watts, Donovan & Tilley, P.A., by: David M. Donovan, for appellee Marvin Jones.