Boyd, Michael v. Revel Logging, LLC

2015 TN WC 99
CourtTennessee Court of Workers' Compensation Claims
DecidedAugust 18, 2015
Docket2015-07-0053
StatusPublished

This text of 2015 TN WC 99 (Boyd, Michael v. Revel Logging, LLC) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Tennessee Court of Workers' Compensation Claims primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Boyd, Michael v. Revel Logging, LLC, 2015 TN WC 99 (Tenn. Super. Ct. 2015).

Opinion

IN THE COURT OF WORKERS' COMPENSATION CLAIMS AT JACKSON

Michael Boyd, ) ) Docket No.: 2015-07-0053 Employee, ) v. ) State File No.: 96497-2014 ) Revel Logging, LLC, ) ) Date of Injury: December 2, 2014 Employer, ) And ) Judge: Phillips ) Forestry Mutual Ins. Co., ) ) Insurance Carrier. )

EXPEDITED HEARING ORDER FOR MEDICAL BENEFITS

THIS CAUSE came to be heard before the undersigned Workers' Compensation Judge on July 20, 2015, upon the Request for Expedited Hearing filed by Michael Boyd (Mr. Boyd), the Employee, on June 18, 2015, pursuant to Tennessee Code Annotated section 50-6-239 (2014) to determine if the Employer, Revel Logging (Revel) is obligated to provide medical benefits. Considering the positions of the parties, the applicable law, and all of the evidence submitted, the Court concludes that Mr. Boyd is entitled to some of the requested benefits.

ANALYSIS

Issues

1. Whether Mr. Boyd has established, under the applicable evidentiary standard, that he sustained a vascular injury to his left leg;

2. Whether Mr. Boyd is entitled to payment of medical bills related to treatment of the alleged vascular condition;

1 3. Whether Mr. Boyd is entitled to further evaluation of his alleged vascular condition; and, 4. Whether Mr. Boyd is entitled to further evaluation of his lumbar spine injury.

Evidence Submitted

The Court admitted into evidence the exhibits below:

1. Medical Records of Dr. Andrew Lundberg; 2. Medical Records of Dr. Ronnie Outen; 3. Medical Records ofDr. Stephen Waggoner; 4. Medical Records of Henry County Medical Center; 5. Medical Records of Orthoworks Therapy; 6. Causation opinion letters to and from Dr. Stephen Waggoner; 7. Causation opinion letter from Dr. Andrew Lundberg; 8. Wage Statement; and, 9. Choice of Physician Form (C-42).

The Court designated the following as the technical record:

• Petition for Benefit Determination (PBD), March 24, 2015; • Dispute Certification Notice (DCN), April29, 2015; and, • Request for Expedited Hearing, June 18, 2015.

The Court did not consider attachments to the above filings unless admitted into evidence during the Expedited Hearing. The Court considered factual statements in the above filings or any attachments thereto as allegations unless established by the evidence.

Mr. Boyd provided in-person testimony.

History of Claim

Mr. Boyd is a forty-seven-year-old resident of Henry County, Tennessee. He works for Revel as a cutting machine operator. On December 2, 2014, Mr. Boyd was loading his cutting machine onto a trailer to move it to another job site. In the process of loading, he missed a step while climbing onto the machine, and his left foot hit the ground from an approximate height of two and one-half feet. He felt immediate pain in his lower back and a sensation of his left leg being "frozen." No one witnessed the accident.

Mr. Boyd completed loading the machine. He then informed his supervisor, Jeff Bryant, that he injured himself and "needed to go to the doctor." He told Mr. Bryant that he felt pain in his back and left leg, and that his left leg felt "frozen." Mr. Bryant

2 telephoned Revel's office to advise that he was carrying Mr. Boyd to the emergency room. Revel's owner, Gary Revel, called Mr. Boyd to say that Mr. Boyd, "would have less of a wait" if he went to the East Wood Clinic (East Wood). Mr. Bryant and Mr. Boyd then proceeded to East Wood after carrying the equipment to the other job site.

Mr. Boyd testified Mr. Bryant told the staff at East Wood that Mr. Boyd was injured while "trying to get onto a machine" and "was having trouble with his leg and lower back." Mr. Bryant also told the East Wood staff that he was a "supervisor," and that Revel would cover Mr. Boyd's treatment under workers' compensation.

Mr. Boyd saw Dr. Ronnie Outen, to whom he reported pain in his "left low back" that "radiates to the left leg." He claimed to have reported his leg was cool but, on cross- examination, could not explain why East Wood's record did not indicate such complaint.

On examination, Dr. Outen found tenderness in the left-lower back and limited range of motion of the back. He diagnosed a lumbar strain and sciatica. Dr. Outen discharged Mr. Boyd and prescribed anti-inflammatory and pain medications. Mr. Boyd testified that Dr. Outen performed "really no testing as if I had gone to a medical center," and Mr. Boyd believed a medical center "would have had more knowledge" about his condition.

The next day, December 3, 2014, Mr. Boyd's wife visited Revel's office. On behalf of her husband, she chose Dr. Waggoner from a panel of physicians. Mr. Boyd testified that she chose Dr. Waggoner because he provided the quickest appointment.

Mr. Boyd first saw Dr. Waggoner on December 5, 2014. He advised Dr. Waggoner that he had "been having trouble with his back since an injury at work on 12/3/2014" when he was "trying to get up into a cutting machine." Mr. Boyd complained of "weakness in the left leg as well as numbness and tingling." Dr. Waggoner diagnosed a lumbar strain and lumbar radiculopathy, and recommended an MRI of the lumbar spine.

Mr. Boyd underwent the MRI and saw Dr. Waggoner on December 11, 2014. Dr. Waggoner noted the MRI showed "no abnormalities." He also noted that Mr. Boyd still complained of low-back pain radiating into the left leg "with numbness and tingling in his left calf." Dr. Waggoner maintained his diagnosis of a lumbar strain and recommended physical therapy.

Mr. Boyd attended an initial physical therapy evaluation on December 16, 2014, and complained of "constant" lower-back pain that radiates to the left foot. He described the pain as a "constant toothache" in the left knee, cramping in the left calf and severe pain in the left foot.

Dr. Waggoner's records indicate that he spoke with Mr. Boyd on December 18,

3 2014, and agreed to "send referral to WC for second opinion with a neurosurgeon." (Ex. 3 at 34.)

Mr. Boyd returned to Dr. Waggoner on December 22, 2014, and stated he was "not any better." He complained of severe left-leg pain "in a stocking glove distribution" and also complained "of a cool feeling in the leg." (Ex. 3 at 36.) Dr. Waggoner noted the coolness of the leg and found it "very difficult to palpate a pulse" in the arteries of the leg. He immediately referred Mr. Boyd to the emergency department of Methodist Hospital in Memphis for evaluation of what he described as a vascular condition.

Mr. Boyd presented to the emergency department as recommended. However, he testified he felt the hospital was "dirty" and he questioned whether he would receive an objective opinion regarding the vascular condition because of comments made by the nurse case manager at Dr. Waggoner's office. Specifically, Mr. Boyd testified that the case manager made clear workers' compensation would cover only the lower-back injury. Thus, he returned to his home in Henry County. Mr. Boyd did testify that he received a voicemail message from the carrier, who stated that the carrier indeed would cover the vascular testing and that the nurse case manager would contact Mr. Boyd regarding scheduling. The case manager did contact Mr. Boyd to advise that the testing would occur in McKenzie, Tennessee on December 26.

On December 25, 2014, Mr. Boyd awoke in the night with extreme pain in his leg. His wife rushed him to Henry County Medical Center. Vascular testing revealed blockage of the left femoral and iliac arteries. Dr. Lundberg performed surgery on December 27, 2014, to remove the blockages. Since that time, Mr. Boyd complains of numbness in his "inner thigh" and down his shin. He walks favoring the left leg.

Following this treatment for the left leg, Mr. Boyd returned to Dr. Waggoner on January 19, 2015.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

UPTAIN CONSTRUCTION COMPANY v. McClain
526 S.W.2d 458 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1975)
Bond v. American Air Filter
692 S.W.2d 638 (Tennessee Supreme Court, 1985)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
2015 TN WC 99, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/boyd-michael-v-revel-logging-llc-tennworkcompcl-2015.