Box Board & Lining Co. v. John H. Wiemers, Inc.

108 N.Y.S. 662

• Court: Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York
• Decided: February 7, 1908
• Status: Published

Opinion

SEABURY, J.

In our judgment the costs imposed as a condition of allowing the amendment to the complaint were entirely inadequate. The answer contained not only a general denial, but a counterclaim. The plaintiff had once taken the defendant’s default, and the defendant was permitted to have this default opened only upon payment of $55.97 costs, in addition to the payment of the sheriff’s charges and the giving of an undertaking in the sum of $2,000 to secure any judgment that might be rendered against the defendant. The action came on for trial, and after the trial had been' in progress five hours the plaintiff was permitted to withdraw a juror and apply to the Special Term for leave to amend. The permission to withdraw a juror was granted, without the imposition of any costs, which was itself "an indulgence to which the plaintiff was not entitled. Thereafter the plaintiff moved at Special Term to amend its complaint, and the motion was granted, upon the payment of a trial fee and $10 costs. From this order the defendant appeals.

The plaintiff invited the defendant to join issue upon the original complaint. The defendant not only accepted the issue which the plain.tiff tendered, but pleaded a counterclaim. The motion by the plaintiff for the withdrawal of a juror and for leave to apply to amend its complaint was a confession that it could not recover upon the issue which it had tendered. The granting of this motion not only permitted the plaintiff to apply to amend its complaint, but prevented the defendant from trying its counterclaim until a new issue should be joined, while during all of this time the defendant’s obligation on the undertaking, which it had filed, continued. Under the circumstances disclosed, the' motion should have been granted only upon the payment of taxable costs and disbursements to date. Bates v. Salt Springs National Bank, 43 App. Div. 321, 60 N. Y. Supp. 313; Palazzo v. Degnon-McLean Contracting Co., 115 App. Div. 172, 100 N. Y. Supp. 172; Hayes v. Kerr, 39 App. Div. 529, 57 N. Y. Supp. 323.

The order appealed from is reversed, with $10 costs and disbursements, and the plaintiff’s motion to amend its complaint is granted, upon the payment of the taxable costs and disbursements to date, together with $10 costs of this motion. All concur.