Bonner, Don Anthony

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: February 9, 2015
• Docket: WR-30,410-05
• Status: Published

Opinion

•. ' 3TI- ,trlD -os fA/ ~£ ~ar o /' C/L/#'7//VflYI 4tf;a4-'tr e ?' I£ ~;r-.s

~Jl)A-tTJf.., /)ow ~IJ#7 ~NNM s T fJ CS No. I 8 I 7 bJ 71 Je.4'ToA., s v. . s S ~r CLf2-V..v.J-li;

f£?t-Toil--S /l(ofro~ 4Jf- UtAvfi- 1-o .4/ft. w~'J- o ,L' M~d~us.

'

'Jo f/J~ l.f.ot-LP~(L. :fvc/y~ o /J s~~ c~~~·

f.£ tA-ro,(.. 1 IJoN ~t/{,)Jy 13o;~VN"AA. / /-'A-<7-SA... · ·f/U?.4--F y41{ . k//az<.v/~7 : - .../. L·

&.krr~ /J-~~,.'4- Y4n-/- IJn. ;..~ ' CON' .h;_,~Z- p/ f'U/L.S u H/4'/ ./o -/4/z.. C6JNVt''c-//OA-r o~ CIAI~k/ jJO.s'..J'/lS'.S/0~ (9LJ A kd ~" ~ . . . ~V~ t.£44-oA UNT~/..s ~//-~ hLJ . CoN' £,.".v~~ /$ C;Af!~//,1 ~

(I) ,· If •

r}·'· ~I. I.• l}/, .. '

~(/)A_ )J 7~'-oltpkA4'/ ~

bo~ Ct.M-J::- ~..._() c~~r ~o;t_TM- ~ ~;,_/ 6t~ ~~- ~sC/1..-t~k u..,;;;4tfl-ur A.J2.-Sr'o#c.rA- .. ~ -/4JU,t. _ ll./l...Mo/\L"S · /::b-0 ..:r/V"J';V<.~/ o L' -~~~ ,_~ %.A.P ·'-f4Jff. . dv..I'Tt

~

o/ /J11JJ.-t dAh-YtLd wl¢, $/Ct''IZ/ --/A/ Sv;'J,.d&J.-<-T /1ee..<9YM/}/9-N/;(RJ' ' -~. '-f4/J IJio fr-o / \ f ~ t/£/f!V.;{. • . :; ·. , .. ' .

0 /L~~d Mfi./' . ., ".,..- I /' ./"' /- ..... -- . . , L' P · - :{i~s:fl'1/f::tfi- ~ / ;u:;A.~-rriL~ a_-fJ-V,~/ .c

(/) . /4A-f ~ kyt cllhu'·-h~ h~Nf Ot

,_(~.J ... ~/ /J1~d~u.r ~~A._.t:.7 /-J?-.,<1 /1-// e:4'AA __··,.lf~t~·,r~~,LOtyU.,.r;i. · #;;;_/ 4A- ~~/ 4c~ ~,.Pl ....;·. . :~·r~ .~ :-..-: . .. .. cr··~·:~-s-~;fJ/.4,:·· ...: ' t;A.:t .,

:{f:' 1 li>l~.): ·~:tf;:;~'

· l!o.sf!kr£1/y Sr.JM,/1&1 tillorv a &dlMt!A./ ... .... 1,.' . . .:. .., ~:~,~· ~J;; IJoN ~,L,4t1N'f /5oN~ TlJC--:5 No·. 18/9637. fJ/UJ ?""'st£ c~} .. , C.Mfl£~1/o:U of SM.vr'uz_

· f, OoAr ~&NC, .8o;VNM ~ h~.67 cd::-c. IA-iJ rf..a cl..f.A./C.. oC A;/1~/ .CeG/p(...T. ~/Ls.cA./h.4c/ ~/Z~ ;:

/&..s~/1-CT L:;/lcz .Sv6;~-n4/Mc/ C.UU../c tJ t Cct2U-t.--T . ~/ ak~i40__.). A-IJ~t. &0-1 7 r1 ~ /JoN ~ad~ 8oe~?~AA Co..u4r o c Cu~.. h/lLA-/..1 11)c ::r. /{{(). /·g /9 b .3 7 t:JL 7A.><¥/ jJ, () .t (}JC ld·3o8 c., r, '7?zAA;£_ // C/P2/ ;L CJ'¥),/-o L S 1/m o;v h;;;v !; - 13 oo r::: lr! 6 crs- !Go S ~,IJA_,e/'--r f/~ ?/l.J9~ //f.o-- S£

{_]) ·'

·- /'llr;n-?: Do..v ;J,v/ito,v1 . If ow~M ·row Alo. 181?63'7 c , r. 11tvu.. // azjf .. 13 oo r:. M. 6u:-s- R.c~~~~:, ~/T-:1'. '? /F8:?

To ; ,46,£{_ /!eo! /.141 CL/~L . Ctl..u~T ot:l ~~~~a--/ /)pj'JM-l.J o£' rk~ P. 0 ~ D>L /g.-3 o B c~,J-o I .S'llr/7()/v ltu.t!/N VX · 70'7/1

f.ft.: lv~f. oL 41~c//!h-nu-J U, cr. A.fo. I:;J. b7'/(J(;D ~DIVN/ZA. {/ . ..Sr~/L_

Dfi4-L 11-f"l.. /le. o.s 1/9 r.C~/c o L' Ct~LU~7 £'-t'c/o.s/i.. c/ ,&~A.. ~..:,/ o A/h.. . 0---1./7', ~4--/ Lst.,~rcn.. s Mol7o~t£ ~ UtAV/L tf:.o. tC;/n_ tA../A../1- o L: · /J'/~/.~C.t'J ONA- f!:h.t9/~A-/ /J!oht:?;~ ~ w;v'/- o i:. /1/~d~u..t JtJNA... &A.../9/~A-/ ./J/'4'c/;¢v/l- o L:.. VPA/ A.,~"A£7 .t1d/VfV'{A .2A./~IJ,:j,~ -4? ~~ C~nr ~X /f-.-£1 CoJ r 4.. /t.Lc!XdJ:.

~/M'A- ~A V4MA- ,/J7J7Jft.A-~ ~ .6.-v;;.7 rh:. ~n.. //Lo~//­ -4-~h~/:.r o£ ¢4A- C~?, _g7 Ccy1 oL. ~// Cbv~ 7 U#'vc.. , ..T ~ ~~c/',.-~ C'....VA. Co,.e? y ~ /Jt(>.fi.oAf, -1-o hk'l C'lfl.--U'~?'~A ci.A.A-L ~ ...J~ &r'o ?~ #p,J14A-G'n-/X. '-t'dl-UA. ·~ P---o &,.r41'r/'77vr·/'/'v ~// 4?/?--/7/t.-t ~ h~W

!t&..u cbh.. .bAd l£.vt:J.

' My A1'11vl?~ ~J Ao~ ~/4u,v7 /Jd'N~M.. ,. r A'h-1 ~y~ lw~T7 , 19NJA- y~ o~ A?~,. tJL:..s~Ar;; ,.w/~t:l',~~u_ o~ /h/fle~ ~u ,#,/4e/;at/,:J~ ~o /'M..J't>.A#-4-//$- k8 u;4:?;.,~c/ IV-iftz 'f4.A- ~ AM/Lr~ sr~~ .2' ~ .Jf?A./LS //.-,_. ~ A -Z/0· rm/9-?'/£.. Ce>,1.,; hN,z. '1--" ~ c.,r· /~/ Vn/1- DL. #/! ~· £J¥;J(}o-£P~/£-c.,;~ oLP ~/'1?- ,:V.cvl ju.J itc/f ( T/JCS ) LeJ~P-/ /l:r kJj~AA-t?~· 1/fpH'. .z~ Ui-fMdf ~ /J~~ /&8"~/L£'/·~ ~ ~~ Z-lc~ J!J4~ '

~~/ ~s c.v~k . ' /A./ ~/i NO. /.;}.6?/!Jtd!J .. ..r do hi'VuL6 7 c:#ze4tA..., d~ ~~04t'./J/L €J£: -"?y /-'WY~T7 ~LJ · J/VICJ7J·1_;~t7A./ /;__,. {TiJC.3" J ...? ~~v.A- No /14J"ON?' ..7/:h--1. ~&r ~&., 1-o ,£~ ~ h~~d't?l- /1t'o/V~ ~~//;.z_ k)Jl-/~7 4 ..:T/Vn-1P1?A.. //~ (TLJC..TJ , --T ~ U,(./"./9'4'Ce_ rk _.4~ C.t>4 T ~ f'/?p~ Cof'//t_t o£' '>/4/z_ -t-u~ /tA_ceA..d/ ~t:J LtO-UA-r LA:...,/)t~4-/"'/t-U' ~CoA.~n-~4 ~s~)ik (_ J f . h-4V.rt. )..LO b~~/c_ /J-t!Ct!?V/Vr C!JA... /bv'?' S/oc./::1.

:L (),vL.y /lA..'CG.Nh.. A .Sm/1--// ~~VA/T oL' .4.,~d.{ 4 fJtt~chM/t-. Nh- C/l.Sclhi£.1' tvfJF!h- //~ ;;u:SoAfa

(I) .~ ./Jo"-r A-N~t1N''7 /So!VU"~ c:/'A.. c~ 67' #h- J".&A./~/4 ()£ fJIVf-JU~ #h-,L- 'l-4/z-. ~?Dr>;,.;T /J 4-vA- ~A(} C~er. E~k.cuti£d C>'N" d;.J b dry ~£·;:-/£.6;1.0/f ·~~ ..

DoAf /bvl4 o ALC? 11CJtVA.rA--! r~c.:::r No. /8/~63 ?'

(2.) ·- ·-, ·.-·... : -_~:~.-.r~ -. . '.'":.·"-.. ' . -.7.v 7J,n. Ou.,;t_,r o ~ c!U»~t~'-YI ~J-,:J1Mi1' el' ti>!~

E'l'p~rh..; OoAt AIVI-4C¥Jr k~A/M­ J A/ fltA... 'IJcJ ~""' 0;,.. / £.h-ro/L.. IJ;-5·i~u CtJLu,~r o·,/: · V· S T.IJf,f o /! 'U y I'J-:£" ·TA-~r c~;V'r7 !h.~

fla.sfJtJN c/11..~~ S 'ltz. Cl-. Alo · l~b 91 86 D .s s ~.<:. WIV'I- o~ /11Pnvc/~u.t fk!t'a./' '· &~ro~~s /Jfub-o,v

'70 7ltn.. /~1Vo~t-+6bi.. Ju~,f..f o C .S/47/J G11.u~ : N"ow ~M Oox:,· ~~o,v 7 fio~VA/AA. 1 !tA_t

/£. Wro--t- t'..i ,q· ..IJ<£.P1-14-/A- /)/Lo cAft. «/~9 /lA-o -..S'A. )n_~ u.//;o.iJ -7NtV·~~~/ U/;f4~T ~;yd'.J k j}~ C&J.UAr c~.&r~--.o ~.s ~.. ~k.ri-QA., cA7._ 6~ t.oc-rKc/ ~·r ~~ c, r- 'llvvtk/1 f/n/f 13 oo 7: h4. 6S.J ~A<--D~ ·77z_~ /?S'fj~ ..

• D1~cr /J.p!J~·Ar t. .:z/(..,7 09&..-t No. fl /) - 0'7 Ob -IV .8.o/V"/Vk 1.: v. S/~Th.. ~LJ PIJ/!. ~ll'£d M~ .Jf!J 20/V. ., 1

(I) ..~ : ···. '·: . . .. ~.

!.o.v:. ·, !},~ ~r s&J.U 9 1.f k 6,.z.. c;~~~ tt£. / /.r h"~'Af'..sl/vU~/ . f.tol olts~.~;;~4~·. ·>,v 'kn-k~" ·?kY:/1:! :,tufh_J: o·,C f{r:lltLCI.Arh- . I'~CA..dult.A--S ~!liS · 3 ~~ £ .. /fr-4 ~i.r·M-'ifv/:U. :-fh4- . c..Ctvt.ic. l'h-.a.. cilb~i~ IU:~RA-. ·r~-o fJ/to v,~A.. +4n.. ,A-1-~~ '(;1/IU, oL, ~,;_(·~-sCA-~~ .,HM- ,4-r.,.(J c~~r ·lu..c;/Lf4 ·lo ·A- ~J~· ·dr7/U~7 ~ ~d~ SM/~_,.;,9 A,::l/f!)k-~1 /J-7-LJ /o..fr CoNV'~~l7o;'-' LA-.t?/;_~.5-Aft.. _rg~,;;h(J v . ..ztl;.v-os;J ?6 se-r. /Oo ./'b~

o/1 /·; ?c) se-r. //6 tr- /97~~ 'l/z_)£d ~,;t?h'-C.~/~ ~~ . .:Jlf~ b ~va ..ss-.. . r.· ·-IV.., .

·-=> >

.. . ~:.· ........ ~.: ~ .

.. ·.111k.. .:as;:u~r· 4~·~rk<. . Nt'Tn?/1.-~ ~~~ uy/0/(_ toe.~/· . Jr-f . 'IE?t . {d~r /341"-N~ sr/l./EA.-7 /;_,.. ~r c.t./o-~'#-7 'k-1-iJ:I' . . ~~e· ,0/..S/rt-e'c.;- c{fi.A_/c. TJ-zo,/1:1" 4-~ . w:l~A...<. ~~ fi,~E1~. c~·A-e/4 C<9U~T (5)~~~ A/J-4 /M' ·.·~· ··du-T'y · fhA'A..d'U~T t-o·~/~ ..5~ ~ ~4 Sf l'· 14 ~LJ · r4~ :. ~(/~~/'(, ~ DL' · v.,-7//nd s~ft_R :·k- /)d.LJVI;;A-· /U_~A-. G_uj~· 4-/- .. ~A_ . trJfi,/h.

..MA-. o;,/u· -~-·L' ·~/{·. CG1-uA-; ~ti2A,TM- ltto1JA4 cit£SC!.A.Jb~.d b/2t0-t'.J ~A C~rl..-r ~Cd'Adf:

:.~ c6)lj;~r :t:t;J~ac_ .: 4-c~.-f -.·

(i J '\!o/, i ·. MMrt&A- .. .j~·CJ!L~. :·.~ co..sr .. ·~ . .,t/f,.s-o c_-2 > Vol~ ;;.· 1uAAt v'eJ,;;_ o;UL ··cc9.Jr< ', . .11 J..Jt: o o (3 > Vol- 3 ·1uA-I oN IJ/~ht tosr ~ 1:' .-I.3{,?, 9o .... (¥J . vo;. '-1 ·r/U 4-l () ~ M-Mfl=t c.s11.r .. #- •• ..t-t}~g__, o:o ~ . . . . .• '1A4~/ o~ ·. /14M.Jh

. Cl"J. Vol; 6 .·Vd.l'~/-·(;~- ~vA/~4·~/!~T ca.trr. ·, . .-,1 7~ eo ('IJJ Vol· "7 · £'~;6;1-· ;.~«~~ ·c..o~r.. ·,.-.1 ?, etJ • ••• t ;. :/

~ ·" .

. . Ct.hz_/L aco~c/J ~ Av/4-/46Vz._ /J-~ . &:J /)/vc.. /'ft.-*?~ /b-.() ,6_~ 'h;A:i' .· /l..s2..!J-e-'1"W'7'/£ c/ A H~/ taC 22.. jJTJ-tA-f ~ 'f4;,_ CLAA-k 19b;CA_ ..

'.

L£4.ft:11--1- tA./~ i'-';..;f., /k. ~ -~ jJ,vW'&,c.-/- .4- /17~~/~s41 WA.•;,J- ~/-' C'k:~ho~"n ~--$() ~~·1- D~ AA-6/lA-S ~ A ' ~ / • /? A r/ _/ r.c!J.d} r DY,.vo\(ft,T/oA..f ·I!A.-tlk-~ J Fp.;.,d'' yq/L t:ZO~r14?t6~7=1" /P-.£J UC/::JAdJ· c/n_SCA.•/~/( /9-6ov£ ~ .£SS~/'/~/ k. ~ · to M-V/~ ~ /U.s~ ~,z_ 4~~ ~ .~~- ~.:5'~/;/f tv.hr·d . f.·j· v/'k-/ ~ ,dh~/- ' -~~ h~c/A ~p~/ wt-U '/4h... LA_cc;~~. tu-,-f4~r . ...

~,{. ,· Uc~~ ./&4-r~ 49~~ A/J C?cJP~//Tu/?u~~/ ~&94k t-vi//. /Jh. Y/~~/'/£ c/ ~JO w~/~ jJ/[/Z_V~? u~~ . ~. ,r.Ju<-f-~/;:,:9 /{)-:· ~~.,;~?~/·/lp~/ ~~ /t!>d'~ C&.v V'-;_,7/o~ - . . /U-//~/1 ~p_ ..k ~A- ~o£ d'1 f4,A.- &p(;Xr//{A.s. /!kc{!)Adt.. ~~ ·lJ£/~5- G~ ~ -'14A- Le~s ~.._o -m~~~C)A./J h~L'/ ~AJ~~ v.4A.. YJ,sw'c,t ~ cfM_,/L ~;(J . ot9-U~T ·/12-p~« khrAA- hM ~llA- :kv~/7' (Jt.Ff- ¥-4~~ . C) ,c4.&#k . O?~ .ALe ,k_ Gh- ,

(3) . fJu~A. S~ £-0,'6; t {~J . 1-t£//M. .S /b--o IGzS(JoNS·/L A.o~ 1-u~I .. CUtdc ; /1lYm:4£c:Y ~ ·f-tfA- ~~~~)c ot2 -#~j /Hoh~~-- /..

\ll /~~~ fkt~/ . . :

WQAM- ~ ~~ ~ D-C Ju-t·//~ ~,'// b/L S&zV;£d

.6r M/f- /kAe~~&_ ·3ua7~-P oC .;4£J · ~ ly ?~~~ y4;J '~u/V~;: 0 c 1//h-d~u.r ~e:/~;.,7 ~/f. IJJi;r;u.~/ CUA./c../ -1lt&IWI/)-:$' /.1-. 0///M- ~:0 Co.u.q-lt.ef'07A-rJYt- /Jtr. ~9~/L ?Ay~ k ~~~~~ ·Mif.. tU!h-:roA- tv/f.~: A~ Co,tJy oC -f-4/L ~~/ .Ctfl-U;<--r· Cu.dc. MC6#t.dr /!-?'~ ~ . _1-A..e_/J..I_. c~~r, CtP-u.,cf U/)tu,JM- ~~~/'.& M #&S~~ I~ f-4;J /Jtoho~ 0/L t/:o.- Lo/9-IV'. ~£. !L~61A- ~- CeJr'y at ~/£.. ~A-1 btco-r.Lt·, ~ ~.s~~k 4.- (6b) d~ hy St£~f'4;,.7 #A- 4fi_COA..A /0. #/£ C4-U4 'oL'

'fill- {111 i"-j. wMJI~ /} f 7711{_ c ,. r- i7LAAA.// t/n /'f./ , iloo fm. bS'-J- llo~~A/ 16-~n-::f, 7)sa~. So /1- . 'iJ 1~/&.c/., - ~J£cr017 sl/~~~~ .4hA< ~1/

Cft:) . PM-- ..51£ -~ Do;v· ~f4t,N'-? 11oNNM / RA..ItrT?JA. o6, hMA- ~ cdtc/~ i4~f- -+4/L. ~ 9'D/~7~/L /J ~.0 ~£:_~.,- ... _r &.t~~/IA- ~SAAi~ /A,srf M 4-rtJX- J w/L;''f " L /1~. ~,..,4!-f w~ ..SM..y~c/ ON- M/z. c~ . o f L(JLvFt-/ ~ Cdl-U4/'. !Vz_;J~1nA- IJ'/ /)~/"v 5 . v-4,_ s~A. /~ A-cr, f. /1J.{r- rrf Ml'h! ~o~ .liy;h..cu?kq/ .PA.r #iJ h/ c/4:J oL /i6. . ::L&!rr' /J.//~r.f tJ.o '-MA. /1-/ks.r/E.J' b.sr4~ b/!/9-4./ e

~.un~~d? .h6h7,~ ·r~r CttLu,..,fy ctwc_ ~d-~rhc-c/' 7JtoMM /1. tui/c/A.A Dt1/V 4N./4oN''J' .tJ o..vA/~. 'EO! WtuT 8!!/Lut¥-J .S'T. . T!Jc::s A/o. /819637 C ~ r. Tl'fAA.A/1 t/n/f. ~ tu(JA..-tt, , rr~ ?617" . I 3 Oo F /11• 6..Js- /los4~Ar I ~ ?)11/.3

..IJ&.t. /k ·~ 1A:/ cttu._k Ctlu-1.?"' oL' Ct., I'V1 /A/A-·/ 4'fJ/£4LJ t9C 1/iy:l?:f .. /J. Oilox . · /2.308 C~lh L STI'J-7/oA../ ·

/J.uJr/;_/ , rT/z- r./J:::f 7 87 I I