Bone v. Judah (In Re Josey)

195 B.R. 511, 1996 Bankr. LEXIS 494, 1996 WL 260755
CourtUnited States Bankruptcy Court, N.D. Georgia
DecidedApril 16, 1996
Docket14-65664
StatusPublished
Cited by7 cases

This text of 195 B.R. 511 (Bone v. Judah (In Re Josey)) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering United States Bankruptcy Court, N.D. Georgia primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Bone v. Judah (In Re Josey), 195 B.R. 511, 1996 Bankr. LEXIS 494, 1996 WL 260755 (Ga. 1996).

Opinion

*512 ORDER

JOYCE BIHARY, Bankruptcy Judge.

This matter came before the Court for hearing on April 11, 1996, pursuant to the Court’s Order and Notice entered March 6, 1996. The Order and Notice recited that plaintiff has alleged a complaint of professional misconduct by defendant David L. Judah within the meaning of LR 110-6(b), NDGa. LR 110-6, NDGa., is the Local Rule for the federal District Court for the Northern District of Georgia dealing with discipline of attorneys by the Court. LR 110-6 is made applicable to bankruptcy proceedings by LR 705-1, NDGa.

The Order and Notice stated that plaintiff requests that defendant David L. Judah be suspended from practice before the United States Bankruptcy Court in the Northern District of Georgia. Plaintiff James H. Bone, the Chapter 13 Trustee, was present at the April 11,1996 hearing, as was Heidi A. Fein-man on behalf of the United States Trustee. Defendant David L. Judah failed to appear at the hearing, and he was not represented by counsel.

Immediately prior to the hearing, the Court received a faxed affidavit from an attorney, Douglas Lee Price. Mr. Price practices in Eatonton, Georgia, and he identified himself as an old law school friend of Mr. Judah’s. Mr. Price indicates that Mr. Judah is ill and unable to properly handle his cases or meet his obligations to his clients without the assistance of another lawyer acting on his behalf. Mr. Price states that in late March of 1996, he had “every known article of Mr. Judah’s law practice” moved to Mr. Price’s office in Eatonton, Georgia, and that Mr. Judah’s telephone calls and mail are being forwarded to Mr. Price’s office. On April 6, 1996, Mr. Price took all of Mr. Judah’s active files and recently dismissed bankruptcy case files to the law offices of Berry, Heller & Wilson. The affidavit describes Mr. Price’s efforts to have bankruptcy counsel handle all of Mr. Judah’s active files and recently dismissed files. Mr. Price believes Mr. Judah is out of the state, but he does not know where.

Mr. Bone announced at the hearing that he had been in recent communication with Mr. Price and with the General Counsel’s office of the State Bar of Georgia. Mr. Bone announced that he believed Mr. Judah’s current pending bankruptcy caseload would be handled by attorneys who would be responsive to Mr. Judah’s clients. However, Mr. Bone was concerned that Mr. Judah not be allowed to file any more bankruptcy eases, or be permitted to take any more fees from the public for filing bankruptcy cases, pending resolution of disciplinary proceedings against him by the State Bar of Georgia. To that end, Mr. Bone presented both documentary evidence and the testimony of a number of witnesses. After considering the evidence, the Court makes the following findings of fact.

In In re Beverly C. Josey, Case No. 92-70816, Mr. Judah took monies from his client in trust, did not use the funds for the purpose intended, and had no justification for his improper handling of these funds. Many of the facts regarding this matter are set forth in the Court’s Order of March 6,1996. Additional evidence regarding this matter was presented at the hearing on April 11, 1996.

Ms. Josey filed her petition on June 30, 1992, and her Chapter 13 plan was confirmed on September 1, 1992, calling for monthly payments of $510.00 to the Chapter 13 Trustee. 1 In mid-1995, debtor contacted Mr. Judah to obtain a payoff amount to pay her case in full and obtain her discharge. Ms. Josey testified that Mr. Judah told her she needed $13,179.38 to pay off her debts. On June 1, 1995, after receiving a disbursement from a 401(k) account with her former employer, Ms. Josey purchased a cashier’s check, No. 061043, from Trust Company Bank in the amount of $13,179.38. (Plaintiffs Ex. 4.) The check was made payable to the order of “Chapter 13 Trustee.” Debtor gave the check to Mr. Judah to give to the Chapter 13 Trustee to pay off the Chapter 13 plan. Notwithstanding the fact that the cashier’s check was made payable to the Chapter 13 Trustee, Mr. Judah endorsed the *513 cheek himself and deposited it into one of his bank accounts at First Union Bank, account number 2080000181633. Instead of paying off the balance due under debtor’s plan, Mr. Judah made only three small payments to the Chapter 13 Trustee: one in the amount of $1,630.00 on June 21, 1996; $700.00 five months later on November 21, 1995; and $700.00 on February 23,1996.

In February of 1996, Ms. Josey received a notice from the Chapter 13 Trustee’s office that her case was in arrears and would be dismissed. Ms. Josey contacted the Chapter 13 Trustee’s office and learned that the Trustee’s office had never received Ms. Jo-sey’s $13,179.38 cashier’s check from Mr. Judah.

Mr. Judah testified at the March 5, 1996 hearing in this matter that the remaining proceeds of Ms. Josey’s cashier’s check ($10,-149.38) were on deposit in his IOLTA 2 account at First Union Bank. (3/5/96 Hr’g Tr. at 13.) Gene O’Neal, Supervisor of Records at First Union Bank, testified on April 11, 1996 that Ms. Josey’s cashier’s check had been deposited in one of Mr. Judah’s accounts at First Union, account number 2080000181633, on June 8, 1995. This account was one of five accounts Mr. Judah maintained at First Union, and this was described by the witness as an IOLTA account. However, in July of 1995, the minimum balance in that account was $2,333.79, and the minimum balance continued to fall during the next three months until Mr. Judah withdrew $427.70 and closed the IOLTA account on October 16, 1995. Thus, Mr. Judah appears to have depleted the trust fund account into which Ms. Josey’s funds were deposited by October 16,1995.

In the March 6, 1996 Order, the Court ordered Mr. Judah to disgorge $10,149.38, and Mr. Bone reports that Mr. Judah did comply with that direction. However, the March 6,1996 Order also required Mr. Judah to disgorge the attorney’s fees that he had received in Ms. Josey’s case which the Chapter 13 Trustee calculated at $475.00. Since Mr. Judah appeared to question the figure supplied by the Chapter 13 Trustee, the Court gave him until March 11, 1996, to respond in writing if he disputed the amount and to disgorge all fees paid to him in the case by paying Ms. Josey that amount in certified funds. The record reflects that Mr. Judah has not filed any response, and Ms. Josey credibly testified on April 11,1996 that Mr. Judah has not disgorged her attorney’s fees.

In the March 6,1996 Order, the Court also ordered Mr. Judah to prepare a report fist-ing all pending bankruptcy cases in this district where he represented the debtor. For each ease, he was to set forth the name and social security number of the debtor, the bankruptcy case number, and a complete disclosure and explanation of the amount and date of any and all payments he received from, or on behalf of, the debtor, debtor’s relatives, or any entity owned by the debtor, as attorney’s fees in the particular bankruptcy case or for any other purpose. Mr. Judah was ordered to file this report in this adversary proceeding and serve Mr. Bone, Regina Thomas, Chapter 13 Trustee, and the United States Trustee. The record reflects no such report being filed with the Court or served on the required parties.

There are a number of bankruptcy cases in the Northern District of Georgia where Mr.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

In re Ortiz
496 B.R. 144 (S.D. New York, 2013)
Dignity Health v. Seare (In re Seare)
493 B.R. 158 (D. Nevada, 2013)
In Re Babies
315 B.R. 785 (N.D. Georgia, 2004)
Sheridan v. Michels (In Re Sheridan)
362 F.3d 96 (First Circuit, 2004)
In Re Johnson
291 B.R. 462 (D. Minnesota, 2003)
O'Connell v. Mann (In Re Davila)
210 B.R. 727 (S.D. Texas, 1996)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
195 B.R. 511, 1996 Bankr. LEXIS 494, 1996 WL 260755, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/bone-v-judah-in-re-josey-ganb-1996.