Boehm v. Cody Country Chamber of Commerce

748 P.2d 704, 1987 Wyo. LEXIS 569, 1987 WL 29074
CourtWyoming Supreme Court
DecidedDecember 31, 1987
Docket87-23
StatusPublished
Cited by127 cases

This text of 748 P.2d 704 (Boehm v. Cody Country Chamber of Commerce) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Wyoming Supreme Court primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Boehm v. Cody Country Chamber of Commerce, 748 P.2d 704, 1987 Wyo. LEXIS 569, 1987 WL 29074 (Wyo. 1987).

Opinion

BROWN, Chief Justice.

Appellants, David and Penny Boehm, contend that appellees Cody Country Gunfighters Club (Club), the Cody Country Chamber of Commerce (Chamber), the City of Cody (City), the Irma, Inc. (Irma), David Bermingham, as an individual and as president of the Club, and Club members Tim Ward, Todd Darr, and John Does I-X, are liable to them in tort for injuries sustained by David Boehm during a mock gunfight that took place in Cody, Wyoming, on July 18, 1983, and for loss of consortium resulting from those injuries. The district court granted summary judgment in favor of ap-pellees. Appellants base their appeal on the following three issues:

“I. Did the district court commit reversible error in granting summary judgment based upon a purported release where there is a genuine issue of material fact as to whether the parties to the agreement were in an employment relationship?
“II. Does the purported release in question violate public policy?
“HI. Did the district court commit reversible error in granting summary judgment based upon a release where a genuine issue of material fact existed as to whether the parties relying upon the release, committed acts of willful and wanton misconduct?”

This court may decide a case “upon any point which in [our] opinion the ends of justice may require.” State Highway Commission v. Triangle Development Co., Wyo., 371 P.2d 408 (1962). Further, we may affirm a district court judgment on any legal ground appearing in the record. Weyerhauser Co. v. Walters., Wyo., 707 P.2d 733, 737 (1985); cf. Mentock v. Mentock, Wyo., 638 P.2d 156, 160 (1981). Based on these precedents we will address this case using the following six issues:

I
Whether appellants are entitled to maintain a negligence action against the Club, Tim Ward, Todd Darr, other Club members and David Bermingham as Club president?
II
Whether appellants are entitled to maintain a negligence action against the City *707 of Cody under §§ 1-39-101 through 1-39-120, W.S.1979 (Cum.Supp.1983).
III
Whether summary judgment favoring David Bermingham as an individual was proper?
IV
Whether summary judgment enforcing the release in question as not violating public policy was proper?
V
Whether summary judgment favoring appellees concerning alleged willful and wanton misconduct was proper?
VI
Whether summary judgment favoring appellees concerning the alleged existence of an employment relationship between the parties was proper?
We will affirm.

Appellant David Boehm became a member of the Club in late 1981 or early 1982. The Club’s only activity was staging regularly scheduled mock gunfights at the Irma Hotel and on 12th Street in Cody to help promote summer tourism. At the beginning of the 1982 membership year, and again in early 1983, Mr. Boehm signed a membership application. Both the 1982 and 1983 application forms contained an exculpatory clause which read:

“I furthermore understand that I shall perform as a Gunfighter entirely at my own risk and shall hold harmless and release the Cody Chamber of Commerce, its agents and employees, the Cody Country Gunfighters Club, its members, and the Irma Hotel, or any other location^) sanctioned by the club from any and all claims and damages which said participant may incur from participation in any and all activities sanctioned by the Cody Country Gunfighters Club.”

David Boehm testified that he read and understood the applications and the Club safety rules before he signed. David Boehm’s duties in the Club during 1983 included serving as Club Secretary and Chairman of the Safety Committee. As Club Secretary he was responsible for having all Club members fill out and sign the membership applications. As Chairman of the Safety Committee he helped in modifying club safety rules and generally overseeing the safety of the performances.

The 1983 performances took place four times a week, and were sponsored indirectly by Irma and other Chamber members, who contributed money to the Chamber for civic causes. This money was divided into separate accounts and distributed by the Chamber. Irma helped the Club by allowing use of the hotel fpr performances and meetings. Irma also held an annual dinner for the Club and offered each member one free drink after every performance.

The Club used a portion of 12th Street in Cody for the mock gunfights without ever getting express permission from the City to do so. The Chamber, Irma and the City, on a few occasions, made suggestions to Club members regarding performances and policies. These suggestions were discussed and acted upon by the Club membership or through its committees.

Appellee Bermingham was President of the Club from late 1980 through 1983. Ap-pellees Ward, Darr and John Does I-X were 1983 club members. The Club itself was a loosely organized unincorporated association run by majority vote of its members and through committees. Club members were not paid for their participation in the performances through the 1983 summer season.

The performance script called for each mock gunfight to start when a group of “bandits,” including David Boehm, would stage a fake robbery of the Irma Hotel. The “sheriff” (played by Bermingham) and his “good guys” would descend upon the forces of evil leading to an all out gunfight. The shooting would begin on the porch of the Irma Hotel, reaching a dramatic climax on 12th Street where hay bale props had been set up by Club members in a roped-off area. During the exchange of blank gunfire, David Boehm would rise up from be *708 hind a hay bale and fire two shots in the direction of the “deputy sheriff” (played by Ward). The deputy would “die” from the shots and David Boehm would be gunned down in return fire. Eventually, the sheriff would blast the last bad guy, “Butch Cassidy” (played by David Boehm’s brother), and emerge as the sole survivor to recover Irma’s money.

During a July 18, 1983, performance, David Boehm received a severe injury to his right eye from a projectile of unknown origin. Speculation was that the object was either hardened glue used to seal the blank cartridges or a rock from the street propelled into Boehm’s eye by the discharge of a pistol too close to the ground.

Appellants sued appellees 1 claiming damages based on theories of negligence, culpable negligence and willful and wanton misconduct. 2

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Kaufman v. Rural Health Dev., Inc.
442 P.3d 303 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Rammell v. Mountainaire Animal Clinic, P.C.
442 P.3d 41 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Mantle v. N. Star Energy & Constr. LLC
437 P.3d 758 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2019)
Dimick v. Hopkinson
422 P.3d 512 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2018)
Gordon v. State
413 P.3d 1093 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2018)
Bogdanski v. Budzik
2018 WY 7 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2018)
White v. Wheeler
2017 WY 146 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2017)
Bear Peak Resources, LLC v. Peak Powder River Resources, LLC
2017 WY 124 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2017)
Cunningham v. Jackson Hole Mountain Resort Corp.
673 F. App'x 841 (Tenth Circuit, 2016)
Amos v. Lincoln County School District No. 2
2015 WY 115 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2015)
Steven A. Johnson and Karen Johnson, Husband and Wife
2015 WY 42 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2015)
Morrow v. Xanterra Parks & Resorts
925 F. Supp. 2d 1231 (D. Wyoming, 2013)
Creel v. L & L, Inc.
2012 WY 124 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2012)
Davison v. Wyoming Game & Fish Commission
2010 WY 121 (Wyoming Supreme Court, 2010)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
748 P.2d 704, 1987 Wyo. LEXIS 569, 1987 WL 29074, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/boehm-v-cody-country-chamber-of-commerce-wyo-1987.