Berger v. Mayfield Heights

Opinion

5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH 

(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21  )(' $SS 3 WK &LU )LOH 1DPH DS

81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB

6$1)25' s %(5*(5 ; 3ODLQWLII$SSHOODQW    1R Y  !  &,7< 2) 0$<),(/' +(,*+76  HWDO  'HIHQGDQWV$SSHOOHHV   1

$SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW IRUWKH1RUWKHUQ'LVWULFWRI2KLRDW7ROHGR 1Rn'DYLG$.DW]'LVWULFWsXGJH $UJXHG0DUFK 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG6HSWHPEHU %HIRUH1255,6DQG'$8*+75(<&LUFXLWsXGJHV =$7.2))'LVWULFWsXGJH

7KH +RQRUDEOH /DZUHQFH 3 =DWNRII 8QLWHG 6WDWHV 'LVWULFW sXGJH IRU WKH (DVWHUQ 'LVWULFW RI 0LFKLJDQ VLWWLQJ E\ GHVLJQDWLRQ

  %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 1R

BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ $5*8('  $P\ 6 *OHVLXV (/)9,1  %(66(5 &OHYHODQG 2KLR IRU $SSHOODQW  / %U\DQ &DUU &$55 )(1(/,  &$5%21( 0D\ILHOG +HLJKWV 2KLR IRU $SSHOOHHV21%5,()$P\6*OHVLXV%UXFH%(OIYLQ %DUEDUD.D\H%HVVHU(/)9,1 %(66(5&OHYHODQG2KLR IRU $SSHOODQW  / %U\DQ &DUU /HRQDUG ) &DUU &$55 )(1(/,  &$5%21( 0D\ILHOG +HLJKWV 2KLR IRU $SSHOOHHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 23,1,21 BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB 0$57+$&5$,*'$8*+75(<&LUFXLWsXGJH7KLV FDVHLVEHIRUHXVRQDSSHDOIRUWKHVHFRQGWLPH7KHSODLQWLII 6DQIRUGs%HUJHUVXHGWKH&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWV2KLR DQG VHYHUDO LQGLYLGXDO GHIHQGDQWV IRU YLRODWLRQ RI KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDOULJKWVLQDGLVSXWHZLWKWKH&LW\FRQFHUQLQJWKH PDLQWHQDQFHRISURSHUW\WKDWKHRZQHGLQ0D\ILHOG+HLJKWV 7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWJUDQWHGVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWLQIDYRURIWKH GHIHQGDQWVDQGGLVPLVVHGWKHSODLQWLIIjVDFWLRQ2QDSSHDO ZH UHYHUVHG WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV MXGJPHQW KROGLQJ WKDW WKH PXQLFLSDO RUGLQDQFH XQGHU ZKLFK %HUJHU KDG EHHQ FLWHG YLRODWHGWKH'XH3URFHVVDQG(TXDO3URWHFWLRQ&ODXVHVRIWKH )RXUWHHQWK$PHQGPHQWWRWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV&RQVWLWXWLRQ2Q UHPDQG %HUJHU PRYHG IRU DWWRUQH\Vj IHHV SXUVXDQW WR 86&†7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHQLHG%HUJHUjVPRWLRQ KROGLQJ WKDW KH KDG SUHYDLOHG RQ mD VLPSOH FRQVWLWXWLRQDO FKDOOHQJHWRWKH&LW\jVRUGLQDQFHlQRWD86&† FODLP  %HUJHU QRZ DSSHDOV WKH GHQLDO RI DWWRUQH\Vj IHHV LQVLVWLQJWKDWKHLVDmSUHYDLOLQJSDUW\lXQGHU†:H DJUHH DQG ZH WKHUHIRUH FRQFOXGH WKDW WKH PDWWHU PXVW EH UHPDQGHGIRUDGHWHUPLQDWLRQRIUHDVRQDEOHDWWRUQH\VjIHHV 1R %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 

)$&78$/$1'352&('85$/%$&.*5281' $GHWDLOHGKLVWRU\RIWKLVFDVHFDQEHIRXQGLQRXUSUHYLRXV RSLQLRQ6HH%HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWV)G WK&LU,QUHOHYDQWSDUWWKHIDFWVUHIOHFWHGWKHUH LQGLFDWHWKDWSODLQWLII%HUJHUDQGRQHRIKLVQHLJKERUVJRWLQWR DGLVSXWHFRQFHUQLQJWKHPDLQWHQDQFHRI%HUJHUjVLQWHUYHQLQJ YDFDQWORWZKLFKWRWKHGLVPD\RIKLVQHLJKERUKHNHSWLQ DmQDWXUDOVWDWHl7KHQHLJKERUVXFFHHGHGLQVROLFLWLQJWKH 0D\ILHOG +HLJKWV &LW\ &RXQFLO WR DPHQG DQ RUGLQDQFH WR UHTXLUHRZQHUVRIYDFDQWORWVZLWKIHHWRUOHVVRIVWUHHW IURQWDJHWRmWRWDOO\FXWlWKHLUORWVWRDKHLJKWRIQRPRUHWKDQ HLJKW LQFKHV  1RW VXUSULVLQJO\ %HUJHUjV YDFDQW ORW FRQWUDYHQHGWKHRUGLQDQFHEXWKHUHIXVHGWRFRPSO\ZLWKWKH &LW\jVGHPDQGWRFOHDUFXWKLVORWUHVXOWLQJLQKLVFLWDWLRQIRU DFULPLQDOYLRODWLRQ ,QUHVSRQVHWRWKHFLWDWLRQ%HUJHUVXHGWKH&LW\DQGFHUWDLQ RWKHU GHIHQGDQWV LQ D FRXQW FRPSODLQW  7KH ILUVW WZR FRXQWVDOOHJHGFRQVWLWXWLRQDOYLRODWLRQVDVIROORZV &RXQW,7KDWWKHDPHQGHGRUGLQDQFHLVQRWVXEVWDQWLDOO\ UHODWHG WR WKH SXEOLF KHDOWK VDIHW\ DQG ZHOIDUH RI WKH &LW\ YLRODWHV 2KLR 5HY &RGH †  DQG LV XQUHDVRQDEOHDQGDUELWUDU\FRQVWLWXWLQJDVXEVWDQWLYHGXH SURFHVVYLRODWLRQXQGHUWKH)RXUWHHQWK$PHQGPHQW &RXQW ,,  7KDW WKH DPHQGHG RUGLQDQFH LV XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDORQHTXDOSURWHFWLRQJURXQGVEHFDXVHLW WUHDWV VLPLODUO\ VLWXDWHG ODQGRZQHUV GLIIHUHQWO\ EDVHG VROHO\RQWKHVTXDUHIRRWDJHRIWKHLUSURSHUWLHV ,Q WKH MXULVGLFWLRQDO VWDWHPHQW RI KLV FRPSODLQW %HUJHU SUHGLFDWHGMXULVGLFWLRQRQWKHEDVLVRIm86&†† DQGDVZHOODV86&††DQGDQG HWVHTl%HUJHUVRXJKWUHOLHIDPRQJRWKHUUHPHGLHVLQ WKH IRUP RI FRPSHQVDWRU\ GDPDJHV DJDLQVW WKH &LW\ FRPSHQVDWRU\ DQG SXQLWLYH GDPDJHV DJDLQVW WKH RWKHU GHIHQGDQWV DQ LQMXQFWLRQ DJDLQVW FULPLQDO SURVHFXWLRQ IRU YLRODWLRQ RI WKH RUGLQDQFH D GHFODUDWRU\ MXGJPHQW WKDW WKH RUGLQDQFHYLRODWHGWKHIHGHUDODQG2KLRFRQVWLWXWLRQDO(TXDO  %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 1R 1R %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 

3URWHFWLRQDQG'XH3URFHVV&ODXVHVDQGDWWRUQH\jVIHHVDQG FLUFXPVWDQFHV D GLVWULFW FRXUW QRW PHUHO\ µPD\j EXW PXVW FRVWV7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWJUDQWHGDWHPSRUDU\UHVWUDLQLQJRUGHU DZDUGIHHVWRWKHSUHYDLOLQJSODLQWLIIjl0RUVFRWW,QFY DJDLQVWFULPLQDOSURVHFXWLRQDQGWKH&LW\FRQVHQWHGWRKROG &LW\ RI &OHYHODQG  )G  WK &LU  TXRWLQJ LQ DEH\DQFH WKH FULPLQDO SURVHFXWLRQ DQG LWV PDQLFXUH RI ,QGHSHQGHQW )HGHUDWLRQ RI )OLJKW $WWHQGDQWV Y =LSHV  %HUJHUjVYDFDQWORWSHQGLQJILQDOUHVROXWLRQRIWKHOLWLJDWLRQ 86  $IWHUWKHRWKHUGHIHQGDQWVZHUHHLWKHUGLVPLVVHGE\%HUJHURU IRXQG LPPXQH IURP OLDELOLW\ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW JUDQWHG ,WZLOORIFRXUVHEHXSWRWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWRQUHPDQGWR VXPPDU\ MXGJPHQW LQ IDYRU RI WKH &LW\ RQ DOO FRXQWV RI GHWHUPLQHWKHDPRXQWRIDWWRUQH\VjIHHVWRZKLFKWKHSODLQWLII %HUJHUjVFRPSODLQW LV HQWLWOHG  6HH +HQVOH\ Y (FNHUKDUW  86   m,IDSODLQWLIIKDVDFKLHYHGRQO\SDUWLDORUOLPLWHG 2QDSSHDOZHUHYHUVHGWKHJUDQWRIVXPPDU\MXGJPHQWWR VXFFHVV WKH SURGXFW RI KRXUV UHDVRQDEO\ H[SHQGHG RQ WKH WKH &LW\ RQ &RXQWV  DQG  ILQGLQJ XQGHU D OLWHUDO OLWLJDWLRQDVDZKROHWLPHVDUHDVRQDEOHKRXUO\UDWHPD\EHDQ LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ WKDW WKH RUGLQDQFH YLRODWHV ERWK WKH 'XH H[FHVVLYHDPRXQW7KLVZLOOEHWUXHHYHQZKHUHWKHSODLQWLIIjV 3URFHVV DQG (TXDO 3URWHFWLRQ &ODXVHV RI WKH )RXUWHHQWK FODLPV ZHUH LQWHUUHODWHG QRQIULYRORXV DQG UDLVHG LQ JRRG $PHQGPHQWDQGXQGHUDOHVVFRQVWUDLQHGLQWHUSUHWDWLRQWKDW IDLWKlVHHDOVR*UDQ]HLHU)GDWGLVWULFWFRXUWGLG LWYLRODWHVWKH(TXDO3URWHFWLRQ&ODXVH%HUJHU)GDW QRW DEXVH LWV GLVFUHWLRQ LQ DZDUGLQJ SODLQWLII UHGXFHG   )ROORZLQJ UHPDQG WR WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW %HUJHU DWWRUQH\jVIHHVGXHWRSDUWLDOVXFFHVVRQFLYLOULJKWVDFWLRQ SHWLWLRQHG IRU DQ DZDUG RI DWWRUQH\Vj IHHV SXUVXDQW WR  86&†DQGWKH&LW\ILOHGDFURVVPRWLRQIRUDQDZDUG &21&/86,21 RIDWWRUQH\VjIHHVSXUVXDQWWR†DQG86&† DQGIRUVDQFWLRQVDJDLQVW%HUJHUSXUVXDQWWR)HGHUDO5XOHRI )RUWKHUHDVRQVVHWRXWDERYHZH5(9(56(WKHMXGJPHQW &LYLO3URFHGXUH7KHGLVWULFWFRXUWGHQLHGERWKSHWLWLRQV RIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDQG5(0$1'WKHFDVHIRUGHWHUPLQDWLRQ RIDWWRUQH\VjIHHVLQIDYRURIWKHSODLQWLII ',6&866,21 $†&ODLP %HUJHUDUJXHVWKDWWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWHUUHGZKHQLWGHQLHG KLPDQDZDUGRIDWWRUQH\VjIHHV8QGHUJLUGLQJ%HUJHUjVFODLP IRUIHHVLV86&†ZKLFKSURYLGHV ,Q DQ\ DFWLRQ RU SURFHHGLQJ WR HQIRUFH D SURYLVLRQ RI VHFWLRQVDDQGRIWKLV WLWOH    WKH FRXUW LQ LWV GLVFUHWLRQ PD\ DOORZ WKH SUHYDLOLQJ SDUW\ RWKHU WKDQ WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV D UHDVRQDEOHDWWRUQH\jVIHHDVSDUWRIWKHFRVWV :H UHYLHZ WKH GHQLDO RI DWWRUQH\Vj IHHV IRU DEXVH RI GLVFUHWLRQ3KHODQY%HOO)GWK&LU FLWLQJ3HURWWLY6HLWHU)GWK&LU  m$EXVH RI GLVFUHWLRQ LV GHILQHG DV D GHILQLWH DQG ILUP  %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 1R 1R %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 

.QR[&RXQW\6FK@)G>@>WK&LU@ FRQYLFWLRQ WKDW WKH WULDO FRXUW FRPPLWWHG D FOHDU HUURU RI FLWLQJ 7H[DV 6WDWH 7HDFKHUV $VV Q Y *DUODQG MXGJPHQWl/RJDQY'D\WRQ+XGVRQ&RUS)G ,QGHSHQGHQW6FKRRO'LVW866&W  WK &LU  FLWLQJ %DODQL Y ,PPLJUDWLRQ DQG   /(GG     5DWKHU D SDUW\ ZKR 1DWXUDOL]DWLRQ6HUYLFH)GWK&LU m$Q SDUWLDOO\SUHYDLOVLVHQWLWOHGWRDQDZDUGRIDWWRUQH\ VIHHV DEXVHRIGLVFUHWLRQH[LVWVZKHQWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDSSOLHVWKH FRPPHQVXUDWHWRWKHSDUW\ VVXFFHVV,G ZURQJOHJDOVWDQGDUGPLVDSSOLHVWKHFRUUHFWOHJDOVWDQGDUGRU UHOLHVRQFOHDUO\HUURQHRXVILQGLQJVRIIDFWl)LUVW7HFKQRORJ\ *UDQ]HLHUY0LGGOHWRQ)GWK&LU 6DIHW\6\VWHPVY'HSLQHW)GWK&LU TXRWLQJ3KHODQY%HOO)GWK&LU  $OWKRXJK WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DFNQRZOHGJHG WKDW %HUJHU %HUJHUjVDFWLRQUHVXOWHGLQDVLJQLILFDQWFKDQJHLQWKHOHJDO VXFFHVVIXOO\ FKDOOHQJHG WKH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ RI WKH &LW\jV UHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHSDUWLHV$VLQGLFDWHGSUHYLRXVO\WKH RUGLQDQFHLWGHQLHG%HUJHUDQDZDUGRIDWWRUQH\VjIHHVZLWK &LW\ LQLWLDWHG D FULPLQDO FLWDWLRQ DJDLQVW %HUJHU IRU QRW WKHIROORZLQJH[SOLFDWLRQ WULPPLQJKLVYDFDQWORWSXUVXDQWWRWKHDPHQGHGRUGLQDQFH ,QPXQLFLSDOFRXUW%HUJHUILOHGPRWLRQVWRGLVPLVVVXSSUHVV $FRQVWLWXWLRQDOFKDOOHQJHWRDVWDWXWHRURUGLQDQFHLVQRW DQGTXDVKLQUHVSRQVHWRWKHFULPLQDOFKDUJH%HUJHU KRZHYHUFRQILQHGWRDQDFWLRQXQGHU†&OHDUO\D )GDW7KHPRWLRQVZHUHGLVPLVVHGE\WKHPXQLFLSDO GLVWULFWFRXUWKDVMXULVGLFWLRQXQGHU86&†WR FRXUW WKXV VXEMHFWLQJ %HUJHU WR WKH SURVSHFW RI FULPLQDO HQWHUWDLQ VXFK FRQVWLWXWLRQDO FKDOOHQJHV  1HLWKHU WKH SURVHFXWLRQ$OWKRXJKWKHSURVHFXWLRQZDVKHOGLQDEH\DQFH SDUWLHVjEULHIVWKLV&RXUWVjV0HPRUDQGXP2SLQLRQVQRU SHQGLQJ UHVROXWLRQ RI KLV IHGHUDO FRXUW FODLPV %HUJHU DQ WKH6L[WK&LUFXLWjVGHFLVLRQFKDUDFWHUL]HWKLVFDVH DVD DWWRUQH\KLPVHOIIDFHGWKHJULPUHDOLW\RIDGMXGLFDWLRQDQG µFLYLOULJKWVjDFWLRQ,WLVTXLWHVLPSO\DFRQVWLWXWLRQDO SXQLVKPHQW IRU YLRODWLRQ RI WKH DPHQGHG RUGLQDQFH DQG FKDOOHQJHWRDFLW\RUGLQDQFH86&†LVPHUHO\ SHUKDSV GLVFLSOLQH E\ WKH 2KLR 6WDWH OHJDO EDU IRU D DYHKLFOHZKHUHE\DOLWLJDQWPD\DVVHUWDFRQVWLWXWLRQDO PLVGHPHDQRUFULPLQDOFRQYLFWLRQ7KDW%HUJHUHVFDSHGVXFK YLRODWLRQ(YHQDVVXPLQJ3ODLQWLIISOHGDFDXVHRIDFWLRQ GLUH FRQVHTXHQFHV GXH WR KLV VXFFHVV EHIRUH WKH FRXUW XQGHU †  KH GLG QRW SUHYDLO RQ KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO GHPRQVWUDWHVDVXEVWDQWLDOUHYHUVDOLQKLVOHJDOUHODWLRQVKLS FKDOOHQJHWKURXJK†6HH%UDOH\Y&LW\RI3RQWLDF ZLWKWKH&LW\ )GWK&LU†µFUHDWHVDULJKW RIDFWLRQIRUWKHYLQGLFDWLRQRIFRQVWLWXWLRQDOJXDUDQWHHV 7KH&LW\DWWHPSWVWRFLUFXPYHQWDILQGLQJWKDW%HUJHULVD IRXQGHOVHZKHUHj7KHEDVLVXSRQZKLFKMXGJPHQWZDV SUHYDLOLQJ SDUW\ ZLWK IDXOW\ DUJXPHQWV  )LUVW WKH &LW\ JUDQWHGWR'HIHQGDQWDQGWKHQXOWLPDWHO\UHYHUVHGE\ UHPLQGV WKH FRXUW WKDW  RI %HUJHUjV  FRXQWV ZHUH WKH6L[WK&LUFXLWZDVEDVHGXSRQDFRQVWLWXWLRQDODQDO\VLV GLVPLVVHG7KHLPSOLFDWLRQRIWKLVREVHUYDWLRQWKDW%HUJHU DQGWKHUHLVQRPHQWLRQRI86&†LQHLWKHURI GLG QRW REWDLQ VXEVWDQWLDO UHOLHI GLUHFWO\ FRQWUDGLFWV WKH WKRVHGHFLVLRQV7KXV3ODLQWLIIjVVXFFHVVLQFKDOOHQJLQJ ILQGLQJWKDW%HUJHULVDSUHYDLOLQJSDUW\ WKH RUGLQDQFHjV FRQVWLWXWLRQDOLW\ ZDV QRW EDVHG XSRQ †DQG3ODLQWLIIFDQQRWEHFRQVLGHUHGDµSUHYDLOLQJ 7KH&LW\DOVRDUJXHVWKDWDQDZDUGRIDWWRUQH\jVIHHVH[LVWV SDUW\j IRU SXUSRVHV RI DWWRUQH\V IHHV XQGHU  86& ZLWKLQWKHVRXQGGLVFUHWLRQRIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWEXWWKLVSRLQW †E DGGV QRWKLQJ WR WKH DQDO\VLV HVSHFLDOO\ VLQFH ZH KDYH SUHYLRXVO\REVHUYHGWKDWDOWKRXJKmWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDV :H FDQQRW HQGRUVH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV UHDVRQLQJ ZKLFK KHOGLWLVZLWKLQWKHGLVWULFWFRXUW VGLVFUHWLRQWRDZDUG DSSHDUV WR WXUQ RQ WKH QRWLRQ WKDW %HUJHUjV FDVH ZDV QRW D DWWRUQH\ VIHHVXQGHUVHFWLRQµLQWKHDEVHQFHRIVSHFLDO  %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 1R 1R %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 

mFLYLO ULJKWVl DFWLRQ DQG WKXV LW ZDV QRW D †  DFWLRQ WKH &LW\ GHSULYHG %HUJHU RI KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKWV E\ HQWLWOLQJ WKH SODLQWLII WR DQ DZDUG RI DWWRUQH\Vj IHHV XQGHU FULPLQDOO\ FLWLQJ KLP IRU YLRODWLRQ RI WKH RUGLQDQFH D †   7KLV GLVWLQFWLRQ KRZHYHU KDV EHHQ H[SUHVVO\ GHSULYDWLRQ WKDW ZDV UHPHGLHG E\ WKH FRXUW LQ LWV SULRU UHMHFWHG E\ WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW LQ0DLQH Y 7KLERXWRW  GHFLVLRQRQWKLVFDVH6HH%HUJHU)GDWm%HUJHU 86 ZLOOREWDLQIXOOUHOLHIE\WKHQHZVHFWLRQVRIWKHRUGLQDQFHLQ TXHVWLRQ EHLQJ GHFODUHG QXOO DQG YRLG EHFDXVH WKH SDUWLHV 7KHUH WKH &RXUW ZDV DVNHG WR GHFLGH ZKHWKHU †  V DJUHHGWRKROGLQDEH\DQFHWKHFULPLQDOSURVHFXWLRQDQGWKH SURVFULSWLRQDJDLQVWWKHYLRODWLRQRIIHGHUDOmODZVlVKRXOGEH FXWWLQJGRZQRIWUHHVRQ%HUJHUjVORWXQWLOWKLVDSSHDOZDV OLPLWHG WR D VXEVHW RI ODZV  7KH UHVSRQGHQWV LQ7KLERXWRW GHFLGHGl7KHUHIRUH%HUJHUjVUHOLDQFHXSRQ†IRU EURXJKWD†DFWLRQLQVWDWHFRXUWFODLPLQJWKDWWKH6WDWH MXULVGLFWLRQ DQG KLV SUHVHQWDWLRQ RI VXEVWDQWLDO )RXUWHHQWK RI 0DLQH KDG YLRODWHG WKH 6RFLDO 6HFXULW\ $FW  7KH\ $PHQGPHQW FODLPV IRU ZKLFK †  SURYLGHV D UHPHG\ SUHYDLOHGXSRQWKHLU†FODLPEXWWKHVWDWHFRXUWGHQLHG FRPSHODILQGLQJWKDWKHLVHQWLWOHGWRDQDZDUGRIDWWRUQH\Vj DQ DZDUG RI DWWRUQH\jV IHHV VRXJKW E\ WKH UHVSRQGHQWV IHHVSXUVXDQWWR† SXUVXDQWWR†8SRQUHYLHZWKH6XSUHPHsXGLFLDO&RXUW RI 0DLQH FRQFOXGHG WKDW WKH UHVSRQGHQWV ZHUH HOLJLEOH IRU %3UHYDLOLQJ3DUW\ DWWRUQH\jVIHHVSXUVXDQWWR†7KLERXWRW86DW 2QFHUWLRUDULWRWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV6XSUHPH&RXUWWKHVWDWH ,QUXOLQJRQWKHSODLQWLIIjVPRWLRQIRUDWWRUQH\VjIHHVWKH DUJXHGWKDWWKH6RFLDO6HFXULW\$FWGLGQRWFRQVWLWXWHD† GLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWGHFLGHZKHWKHU%HUJHUZDVDmSUHYDLOLQJ µODZj ZKRVH YLRODWLRQ HQWLWOHV DQ DJJULHYHG OLWLJDQW WR WKH SDUW\lZLWKLQWKHDPELWRI†:HWKLQNWKDWWKHUHFDQEH DZDUGRIDWWRUQH\jVIHHVXQGHU†,GDW OLWWOHTXHVWLRQWKDW%HUJHUTXDOLILHVDVVXFK 7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW DIWHU UHFRJQL]LQJ WKDW WKH SODLQ 7KHVWDQGDUGIRUGHWHUPLQLQJDmSUHYDLOLQJSDUW\lLVZHOO ODQJXDJH RI †  mXQGRXEWHGO\ HPEUDFHVl D FODLP IRU HVWDEOLVKHGZLWKLQWKLVFLUFXLW YLRODWLRQRIWKH6RFLDO6HFXULW\$FWUHIHUUHGWRSULRUFDVHVWR LOOXVWUDWH WKH UHVROXWLRQ WKDW WKH †  UHPHG\ mEURDGO\ m7REHDµSUHYDLOLQJSDUW\jDSDUW\PXVWµVXFFHHGRQDQ\ HQFRPSDVVHV YLRODWLRQV RI IHGHUDO VWDWXWRU\ DV ZHOO DV VLJQLILFDQWLVVXHLQOLWLJDWLRQZKLFKDFKLHYHVVRPHRIWKH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOODZl,GDWFLWLQJ0RQHOOY1HZ† @ ZDV LQWHQGHG WR SURYLGH D /(GGTXRWLQJ1DGHDXY+HOJHPRH UHPHG\WREHEURDGO\FRQVWUXHGDJDLQVWDOOIRUPVRIRIILFLDO )GVW&LU ,Q)DUUDUY+REE\ YLRODWLRQ RI IHGHUDOO\ SURWHFWHG ULJKWVl *UHHQZRRG Y  86    6 &W   /(GG  3HDFRFN86XQGHU†VWDWH  WKH &RXUW H[SODLQHG WKDW mD SODLQWLII µSUHYDLOVj mRIILFHUVPD\EHPDGHWRUHVSRQGLQGDPDJHVQRWRQO\IRU ZKHQDFWXDOUHOLHIRQWKHPHULWVRIKLVFODLPPDWHULDOO\ YLRODWLRQV RI ULJKWV FRQIHUUHG E\ IHGHUDO HTXDO FLYLO ULJKWV DOWHUVWKHOHJDOUHODWLRQVKLSEHWZHHQWKHSDUWLHVLQD ODZV EXW IRU YLRODWLRQV RI RWKHU IHGHUDO FRQVWLWXWLRQDO DQG ZD\WKDWGLUHFWO\EHQHILWVWKHSODLQWLIIVl,G86DW VWDWXWRU\ ULJKWV DV ZHOOl  VHH DOVR /RVFKLDYR Y &LW\ RI >  6 &W @  6HH &LWL]HQV $JDLQVW 7D[ 'HDUERUQ  )G   WK &LU  IHGHUDO :DVWHY:HVWHUYLOOH&LW\ 6FKRRO>'LVW%GRI(GXF@ UHJXODWLRQVLQSDUWLFXODUUHJXODWLRQVSURPXOJDWHGSXUVXDQWWR  )G   WK &LU   7KH 6XSUHPH WKH&DEOH&RPPXQLFDWLRQV3ROLF\$FWRIKDYHWKHIRUFH &RXUW KDV UHMHFWHG D mFHQWUDO LVVXH WHVWl ZKLFK ZRXOG RIODZDQGWKXVPD\FUHDWHHQIRUFHDEOHULJKWVSURWHFWHGXQGHU UHTXLUH D SDUW\ WR VXFFHHG RQ WKH PDLQ LVVXH RI WKH OLWLJDWLRQWREHFRQVLGHUHGmSUHYDLOLQJl.ULFKLQVN\>Y  %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 1R 1R %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 

DFFRUG MXULVGLFWLRQ WR D OLWLJDQW †  GRHV SURYLGH †7KH&RXUWKHOGWKDW†UHOLHILVQRWOLPLWHGWR MXULVGLFWLRQIRUD†FODLP%HFDXVH%HUJHUDOOHJHGDQG WKHYLRODWLRQRIFLYLOULJKWVDQGHTXDOSURWHFWLRQODZV SUHYDLOHGRQFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLPVVHWRXWLQ&RXQWVDQGRI KLV FRPSODLQW LW LV FOHDU WKDW KLV †  FODLP DYHUULQJ )XUWKHUPRUH WKH &RXUW FRQFOXGHG WKDW VLQFH WKH SODLQ FRQVWLWXWLRQDO YLRODWLRQV PD\ SURSHUO\ UHVW XSRQ †  ODQJXDJH RI †  mVWDWHV WKDW IHHV DUH DYDLODEOH LQ DQ\ MXULVGLFWLRQ+HQFHDOWKRXJKWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWDSSHDUHGWR †DFWLRQ>@l†DSSOLHGWRWKHUHVSRQGHQWVj† DVVHUW WKDW WKH FRQVWLWXWLRQDO FKDOOHQJH UHVWHG RQ †  VXLWIRUYLRODWLRQRIWKH6RFLDO6HFXULW\$FW,GDW7KLV MXULVGLFWLRQ%HUJHUjV†FODLPRIFRQVWLWXWLRQDOYLRODWLRQV KROGLQJZDVHFKRHGLQ0DKHUY*DJQH86 VDWLVILHGWKHFULWHULDIRU†MXULVGLFWLRQ7RFRPSOHWHWKH DFDVH EURXJKWE\WKH6WDWHRI&RQQHFWLFXWREMHFWLQJWRDQ DQDO\VLVZHSUHVXPHWKDW%HUJHULQYRNHG†LQRUGHU DZDUGRIDWWRUQH\jVIHHVWRDOLWLJDQWZKRKDGSUHYDLOHGRQKHU WR HVWDEOLVK GLVWULFW FRXUW MXULVGLFWLRQ RYHU KLV †  †FODLPIRUYLRODWLRQRIWKH6RFLDO6HFXULW\$FW FRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLPVHVSHFLDOO\JLYHQWKHIDFWWKDW† LVWKHMXULVGLFWLRQDOFRXQWHUSDUWRI† 3HWLWLRQHUjVILUVWDUJXPHQWLVWKDW&RQJUHVVGLGQRWLQWHQG WRDXWKRUL]HWKHDZDUGRIDWWRUQH\jVIHHVLQHYHU\W\SHRI )XUWKHUPRUH ZH KDUN EDFN WR WKH FRXUWjV UXOLQJ LQ †DFWLRQEXWUDWKHUOLPLWHGWKHFRXUWVjDXWKRULW\WR $PHULFDQV8QLWHGWKDWm>W@KHPHUHIDLOXUHWRSOHDGRUDUJXH DZDUG IHHV WR FDVHV LQ ZKLFK †  LV LQYRNHG DV D UHOLDQFHRQ†LVQRWIDWDOWRDFODLPIRUDWWRUQH\jVIHHVLI UHPHG\IRUDFRQVWLWXWLRQDOYLRODWLRQRUDYLRODWLRQRID WKH SOHDGLQJV DQG HYLGHQFH    SUHVHQW D VXEVWDQWLDO IHGHUDOVWDWXWHSURYLGLQJIRUWKHSURWHFWLRQRIFLYLOULJKWV )RXUWHHQWK$PHQGPHQWFODLPIRUZKLFK†SURYLGHVD RUHTXDOULJKWV,Q0DLQHY7KLERXWRW86 UHPHG\DQGWKLVFODLPLVUHODWHGWRWKHSODLQWLIIVjXOWLPDWH 6&W/(GGGHFLGHGWKLVGD\ZH VXFFHVVl,GDW  7KH EDVLFUHTXLUHPHQWVRID† KROGWKDW†DSSOLHVWRDOOW\SHVRI†DFWLRQV FODLPLQFOXGHDVKRZLQJWKDWDSHUVRQDFWLQJXQGHU LQFOXGLQJ DFWLRQV EDVHG VROHO\ RQ 6RFLDO 6HFXULW\ $FW FRORURIVWDWHODZGHSULYHGWKHSODLQWLIIRIDIHGHUDOULJKW YLRODWLRQV 6HH6RSHUY+REHQ)GWK&LUFHUW GHQLHG 6RSHU H[ UHO 6RSHU Y +REHQ  86   ,G DW   +HQFH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHWHUPLQDWLRQ WKDW 6&WFLWLQJ*RPH]Y7ROHGR86 †  UHOLHI PD\ EH DFFRUGHG RQO\ IRU mFLYLO ULJKWVl   YLRODWLRQVKDVEHHQH[SUHVVO\UHMHFWHGE\WKH6XSUHPH&RXUW ,WIROORZVWKDW†IHHVDUHDYDLODEOHIRUDSDUW\VXFFHHGLQJ %HUJHUjV FODLP VDWLVILHV WKHVH UHTXLUHPHQWV  7KH &LW\ LV RQDQ\W\SHRI†FODLP FRQVWUXHGDVDSHUVRQIRUSXUSRVHVRIIHGHUDOODZDQGRQH PD\QRWVHULRXVO\GHQ\WKDWWKHFULPLQDOFLWDWLRQILOHGDJDLQVW :HOLNHZLVHFDQQRWHQGRUVHWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVDOWHUQDWLYH %HUJHU FRQVWLWXWHV DQ DFWLRQ XQGHU FRORU RI VWDWH ODZ  6HH UXOLQJWKDWHYHQLI%HUJHUSOHDGHGD†FDXVHRIDFWLRQ 0DUWLQ0DULHWWD &RUSRUDWLRQ Y %HQGL[ &RUSRUDWLRQ  UHOLHIZDVJUDQWHGSXUVXDQWWRDFRQVWLWXWLRQDODQDO\VLVQRWRQ )GWK&LULQD†DFWLRQDJDLQVWWKH WKH PHULWV RI D †  FODLP  ,Q $PHULFDQV 8QLWHG IRU 6WDWH RI 0LFKLJDQ WR UHPHG\ DOOHJHG YLRODWLRQV RI WKH 6HSDUDWLRQRI&KXUFKDQG6WDWHY6FKRRO'LVWULFWRIWKH&LW\ 6XSUHPDF\DQG&RPPHUFH&ODXVHVWKHFRXUWH[SODLQHGWKDW RI *UDQG 5DSLGV  )G  WK &LU  ZH ZHUH m>L@WLVDFDGHPLFWKDWWKH6WDWHRI0LFKLJDQZKLFKLQVWLWXWHG DVNHGWRGHFLGHZKHWKHUSODLQWLIIVZKRKDYHSUHYDLOHGDJDLQVW WKHVWDWHFRXUWHQIRUFHPHQWSURFHHGLQJV>DJDLQVWWKHSODLQWLII VWDWHDXWKRULWLHVRQFRQVWLWXWLRQDOJURXQGVPXVWSOHDGDQGUHO\ FRUSRUDWLRQ@SXUVXDQWWR>0LFKLJDQODZ@LVDFWLQJXQGHU VSHFLILFDOO\ XSRQ †  LQ RUGHU WR VHFXUH DWWRUQH\jV IHHV FRORURIVWDWHODZl:LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHWKLUGUHTXLUHPHQW XQGHU†,GDW7KHSODLQWLIIVLQ$PHULFDQV8QLWHG KDG SUHYDLOHG DJDLQVW WKH 6WDWH RI 0LFKLJDQ LQ DQ DFWLRQ  %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 1R 1R %HUJHUY&LW\RI0D\ILHOG+HLJKWVHWDO 

DOOHJLQJYLRODWLRQRIWKH(VWDEOLVKPHQW&ODXVHRIWKH)LUVW SURYLGHV MXULVGLFWLRQ DQG ERWK VHFWLRQV DUH FRQVWUXHG $PHQGPHQWWRWKHIHGHUDOFRQVWLWXWLRQ7KHGLVWULFWFRXUW LGHQWLFDOO\jl$PHULFDQV8QLWHG)GDWTXRWLQJ KRZHYHU GHQLHG WKH SODLQWLIIVj PRWLRQ IRU DWWRUQH\jV IHHV /\QFKY+RXVHKROG)LQDQFH&RUSRUDWLRQ86 REVHUYLQJWKDWWKHSODLQWLIIVEURXJKWWKHLUDFWLRQSXUVXDQWWR DQGQFLWDWLRQVRPLWWHG 7KLVDQDO\VLVLVEXWWUHVVHG WKH'HFODUDWRU\sXGJPHQW$FWQRWmµWRHQIRUFHDSURYLVLRQ E\ WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUWjV H[SOLFDWLRQ FRQFHUQLQJ WKH RIjl †  DQG QRWLQJ SDUWLFXODUO\ WKDW WKH SODLQWLIIV KDG UHODWLRQVKLSRI†WR† IDLOHGVSHFLILFDOO\WRSOHDGDSSOLFDWLRQRIWKHVWDWXWH,GDW :HFRQFOXGHG >6HFWLRQ @ VSHFLILFDOO\ OLPLWV GLVWULFW FRXUW MXULVGLFWLRQ WR FDVHV LQ ZKLFK WKH SODLQWLII DOOHJHV D >6HFWLRQ@  LV FRQFHUQHG ZLWK WKH VXEVWDQFH RI D YLRODWLRQRIDULJKWVHFXUHGE\WKH&RQVWLWXWLRQRUE\D SUHYDLOLQJSDUW\jVDFWLRQUDWKHUWKDQWKHIRUPLQZKLFKLW IHGHUDO VWDWXWH µSURYLGLQJ IRU HTXDO ULJKWVj RU µFLYLO LVSUHVHQWHG7KHPHUHIDLOXUHWRSOHDGRUDUJXHUHOLDQFH ULJKWVj,QDVPXFKDVLWGRHVQRWFUHDWHVXEVWDQWLYHULJKWV RQ†LVQRWIDWDOWRDFODLPIRUDWWRUQH\jVIHHVLIWKH DWDOOEXWPHUHO\SURYLGHVDUHPHG\IRUWKHYLRODWLRQRI SOHDGLQJV DQG HYLGHQFH GR SUHVHQW D VXEVWDQWLDO ULJKWV FRQIHUUHG E\ WKH &RQVWLWXWLRQ RU RWKHU VWDWXWHV )RXUWHHQWK$PHQGPHQWFODLPIRUZKLFK†SURYLGHV †  GRHV QRW IDOO ZLWKLQ WKH FDWHJRU\ RI VWDWXWHV D UHPHG\ DQG WKLV FODLP LV UHODWHG WR WKH SODLQWLIIVj SURYLGLQJ IRU HTXDO ULJKWV RU FLYLO ULJKWV  7KHUHIRUH XOWLPDWHVXFFHVV WKHUH LV QRW DXWRPDWLFDOO\ IHGHUDO MXULVGLFWLRQ XQGHU †ZKHQHYHUDSODLQWLIIILOHVD†FODLPUDWKHU ,G DW  VHH DOVR &RQVROLGDWHG )UHLJKWZD\V &RUS Y WKHFRXUWPXVWORRNWRWKHXQGHUO\LQJVXEVWDQWLYHULJKW .DVVHO)GWK&LUDEURJDWHGRQRWKHU WKDW ZDV DOOHJHGO\ YLRODWHG WR GHWHUPLQH ZKHWKHU WKDW JURXQGVE\'HQQLVY+LJJLQV86m>7@KH ULJKW ZDV FRQIHUUHG E\ WKH &RQVWLWXWLRQ RU E\ D FLYLO IDFWWKDWDSDUW\SUHYDLOVRQDJURXQGRWKHUWKDQ†GRHV ULJKWVVWDWXWH QRW SUHFOXGH DQ DZDUG RI DWWRUQH\jV IHHV XQGHU †   ,I †ZRXOGKDYHEHHQDQDSSURSULDWHEDVLVIRUUHOLHIWKHQ 0DKHU86DWQHPSKDVLVDGGHG &RQVROLGDWHGLVHQWLWOHGWRDWWRUQH\jVIHHVXQGHU†HYHQ WKRXJK UHOLHI ZDV DFWXDOO\ DZDUGHG RQ DQRWKHU JURXQGl 2XU VHFRQG REVHUYDWLRQ IRFXVHG RQ SDUDJUDSK  RI WKH FLWLQJ0DKHU86DWQm7KHOHJLVODWLYHKLVWRU\ SODLQWLIIVjFRPSODLQWZKLFKFRQWDLQHGDOOHJDWLRQVVXIILFLHQW PDNHV LW FOHDU WKDW &RQJUHVV LQWHQGHG IHHV WR EH DZDUGHG WRVWDWHDFDXVHRIDFWLRQXQGHU†DOWKRXJKWKHFODLPGLG ZKHUHDSHQGHQWFRQVWLWXWLRQDOFODLPLVLQYROYHGHYHQLIWKH QRW VSHFLILFDOO\ UHO\ XSRQ WKDW VWDWXWH  ,G DW   :H VWDWXWRU\ FODLP RQ ZKLFK WKH SODLQWLII SUHYDLOHG LV RQH IRU XOWLPDWHO\ KHOG WKDW WKH SODLQWLIIV KDG VDWLVILHG WKH ZKLFKIHHVFDQQRWEHDZDUGHGXQGHU>†@ UHTXLUHPHQWVRI†EHFDXVHWKH\SUHYDLOHGLQDQDFWLRQWR HQIRUFH †  DQG ZH LQVWUXFWHG WKH SDUWLHV WKDW mWKH 5HO\LQJXSRQWZRREVHUYDWLRQVZHFRQFOXGHGLQ$PHULFDQV OHJLVODWLYHKLVWRU\RI†µPDNHVLWSHUIHFWO\FOHDUWKDW 8QLWHG WKDW WKH SODLQWLIIV ZHUH HQWLWOHG WR DQ DZDUG RI >†@ZDVLQWHQGHGWRDSSO\WRDQ\DFWLRQIRUZKLFK† DWWRUQH\jV IHHV XQGHU †   )LUVW ZH QRWHG WKDW WKH SURYLGHVDUHPHG\jl,GDWTXRWLQJ0DKHU86 SODLQWLIIVSOHDGHGMXULVGLFWLRQXQGHU†D WKDWmWKH DWQ 6XSUHPH &RXUW GHVFULEHG †  DV WKH µMXULVGLFWLRQDO FRXQWHUSDUWj RI † l DQG WKDW mµ>G@HVSLWH WKH GLIIHUHQW $SSO\LQJ $PHULFDQV 8QLWHG WR WKH PDWWHU DW KDQG ZH ZRUGLQJRIWKHVXEVWDQWLYHDQGMXULVGLFWLRQDOSURYLVLRQVZKHQ REVHUYHWKDW%HUJHUVWDWHGLQKLVFRPSODLQWWKDWMXULVGLFWLRQ WKH†FODLPDOOHJHVFRQVWLWXWLRQDOYLRODWLRQV† RYHUKLVFDVHZDVFRQIHUUHGE\DPRQJRWKHUVWDWXWHV† DQG86&††DQG$OWKRXJK†GRHVQRW