Bekendam, Stephanie Lynn

• Court: Court of Appeals of Texas
• Decided: December 30, 2014
• Docket: WR-79,585-02
• Status: Published

Opinion

am /L/ 732c /

:‘? 505 00 /0 DLM Mm 6000/600 ' _'_ _/4%5€/(_ AC®§W-} _________ ___` 7/§0*0`§“ " " 2 ‘AQWW\ 7513/0203§’0

___;j 1 _ 1 1000 20;5 "

480 1020/ ‘2)2*02_20200/£22@_; 4 020/t _ /£OW£S§,OM»L mM/C%/Q '_ 0202;60<_02 640:0*\&___ 0/”/”/‘0¢,<0\_____ - HLVMA& @0_>2_0__7_>_203002_®01_">)0____ _ ________ 7~'2,45(20+(01 /¢? 070/§ . NO_ 40\(>;_7€ 656 002 /D/& /V&fw 600 20:000*`0 6000/77

000 /“<2;22_ /0 ”2§/300 500/0 000/000 0/~ `. " P~/;s 600 7>00‘©000; 420>00 _ ,

Mkwv

70 02 72424\2 502/202 600 @r C/ZZW 720/04 0222043

3004.42 222 )§ ' 00 232 70 S§§ 042

72770?202_ 212 773/1 1239 /5

.%7/00'*37~)1)70", _

203 602 00 310 /02 [9;,)3 04 /"422_, 3021‘23 2 13 2 /0<03 7>577»232/3 000 222320226 7\2203 _/¢7644432 62_@2_2,2 23.i 302 722 140474/ ' 7201/12 632/100 4)3 077/609 6£66_ §\ 72 A?"l"/ @JL/ 624/570 3375§ 623 ‘ ' _ §QU-z 10707/1 /"‘/@L,{DB 7//22\‘72402/42336243 //)47/3/ (307\23"2:2 722/2 ' 7022 472-43 231 `5437:726 ‘6041273 000/2020 3402 20 32022/70 73 2200 /”72107\ 073 .:3022 722 720 4000 002/070§(0>/723 S/W\Z_ /0”\23 ££60(246 X/LQ§€/GOLQJ )'\> f 7§ 2227\_ 73220442 22403704447 47\272:32>14/3 / 12042./ 020 6000/2223 6224270020 577/42022_ f27203222772323[20/+€3 _2542§2§ 7206 /2400!\ '

r_`-Al:

7372:4722 2/>7733 3144413 932 2770-12 4243 257 /444 7231)4®22 "\ 327 /2)237 07 75@’3 /~2)/4 607*77>44711)272 g /@ L[)¢;/E/+{>L 73<344437'763 2477 042 404/44 6242\4 47"912>3 AS 43444 1543 1719/1756 Ql>i/l 73017347‘/6_ 67'~2/<)442 &[/7/2443 /4>43/3@!33 };@CU@ /7‘{&4777\} 736/4061 ;/927'."`§ 2479/§ ©L¢ . 72`44~.3 “/7.73 /2/)4’4 524 475 212 74477245 951/2711 Imw~ 474 27 047/52 6743347722 444 4;)717427)221/ 3220 2012/3 211/1277 12- 7 42 4001>(>122)1/> 4/0"2217 1-€~';7)27\4273/22 3227-' 434 694/17 _ 2307/1144 024 70772/2423 244/2343 044 73 344/3 /*192277112>271223 . ~ _ ~ ~ 24447 473 537-023 _ 01 /`1/£44 @Lf / 734/946& \31§?6402£&::[&/ 334442% 603 7347,74@ 2040 4422/722;3 727/1404 2317 2>472 §240172771/ /2773 574473 442 /79774417/422;07423 232 /7722, 232 214-1_;.~»42, mag 724/44 334242223 274 712/1244 74 /2@(12,/722 03 Z?- 232 /_1124 322 420»2,0744 234'71734/3 I' 3 772<7233707/77 2420773427,4773 242>-204 277220477742 / 4244247"» 7*/)7\ 62742 273 2)27 //41€3 347 /961/971"47'7 /23 627 54467"-" /2')09€4279 732/723 PQ;:222> 79252771 x 2044<)30@771734773 //1)347/ \/2417 222470‘“" /27'2/6, 292 72/023070/7334473 247>:7'\27773 07 214 237/646 j 2344')7" 2>/ 611/2477 //8/0¢43/0@"\4/3 73‘~_10714.1'717'6 2 2227 /@ 407)22327)77}3 §§3:> /1237041)72313>1214

. 102 212 /1§3,»3613 0543757357004273 9521>2571 2740/64 3245-4473 757174 54'- »:3213 553 /01266525 \LJ<§C0022{1:63 COM'=J?J”£D (JO/QB (90/35 5¢1¢1>7603 47 1203 320764 730’$.4# M7776 074 32044 025214 7044 724/34 70 2272702 74 7257\ 2153 677570/717 374/5 4 v ~ » 51;'744 6002)47 ~ 1023 73 2500 70 2720504 743/2 544 31200674 7)0472>24\ 7 7203 70 3742 474 1926 1250 711 . 34214 7 554/24 [0000§/7114427713 002/2 0743 602 744 71 1043706(1173721220044 (/C;§`J)\ 7 1470 426/54 §4,577 4742/77;50,6 292 /1/+14\,23 920 922182:7274702. @0744/,4,4; 07 /\€4 §§6§ ~ /0 '3474§) 607/3 6047\072; 4§,12042570 2275-10 771/445 570 77024 2`4<7\0226/»4620455270 1 » ` W623 0666226v [900;3> 900<7\° ' ' 592 10 2903571619421371£1{4 @7763!776@0~1?3”©4~7 71-~7 77/124 7106 202 5000 22555 .. 10 52 /7704 720201 740/453 344/74 1505 2092/205 126/2043 10 /0112(10'2 2702 0424§073/) 24 41202424~ 704'1"`0342 612;77 214710,22& fu/~11,.7477'074S /'7'07"\ 1403 631/72224 2714/1404 221472,420 70 2004 502 202 _5713 LOP&\U€?S\ 139/1454 7421/14 70654, §5531)42/70'7 102 064 1554/3 477 1355/4704 649 47>712,52 054

9214;614/2;64/710002 736 140 75$71/50/7¢2/7

` (/3 / 1133 1213/031100 /00133»111/010 2010/101 - * 10 61153111 1011 7211161/101>»001/10>01112 , 001>013310113 /1 300-1011 1310 310133 .. (;2\ /}0,3 1111 111 610 1303 /20010 /1 1130 6 - ' 150 /0111330 /11133 31011\1 61111: 3130311 1110113 /1 311/313 /3101301‘20~ 6016§ (3\ 00011 0110./:36 c350 532 536 531 0/" 1100 " @1 1401/33 606@03 // 0 5 (601 / 110 131 C'C/# j 112 73 313 03)(/0;1/3 130/33 /‘633:30 51011370 531 010/1100 000233 6000-3 200 010/311 51>110112/0' /[1)0°3 6213 , 10101133 1011 - 63\ 523/331 6601 1366 1016121 610 1010 {0101133 /13 513-13 1106 113 011/1110 7' 6021”0131160 2035120/3/035/36 ~ 513 316/116 1300 3 2321 /11110% 11 /1 6011113/1 1111 110 6603100 [01, /'1:11 102 631>6 111/360 110 6 /2 00 020

' f 1313 1166 21 110 666 //3//> §§

655 §)~”10¢1/01///’)6/5/7’040/6` /`10'~/03 C;»£/” /1 3120/3010 5316/63631 01 511?236120211 501/3663 611 73.1160 531 /10016/3 120/3 600/01 000 C611…111 1110 `

11 53 '

/O 6§6>" 777766 ?DZPME, 657 766 5567>7<>7§ 016 76:75256776/6 / 7>6/7/67~;§ 767-66 ,;4'777 6§667 656 967<576666 567/73 ./6667;77766 07 67636{86 /§§

77*57"57757/»)76 /57>,265727 65¢6 657 3676676 /?7

1566 777/26 Wc6766677 7777676776

/:767> 6775772 676/576 L/~wzw 72 677 677

756/66 057/76 ML.J`M 7212 §775{26,1 660 5617,66 71/57559<7 737/536 757 776 25 3

. - 66 757/607 6”/57/)) 1756\

@) CL555 6565776 776 /65”7>77775277/ 657 667.77566 766 776/575 /767'177'257:7€ 725 66»7567766 1575 6566:1 772 775..77556/576 66667,(5/3 07

_ /4{/6 SUTZZ§“&W C(_/)T,W 5 gi rhde 656/65 756 656 6676 726 767667766 761

555 ®6767:7¢56 776/56 6727,(675 575§>76 767-766 757 /8267'67766 776776/6\ 276 . 7\65;@76 73767,26 766 566/772 7577/7/776

7/4L7{5 /”M%L%/'P£!W 07 L,CMSZL /76

KJ\GC 7?7?6¢77SI 7466 CM,J\ /@/LD CQWM ~ 727/526 777726/66 777/2676 -

6”\67‘7 6656 766/775le QZ/KL 776 676/76666&6¢7 WQA 42656 737 56£666 /DMW/\ 777 766 737666 776 676 767 756 ,

_‘D; 766 761>60§ 567wa 630/6 5 011- » C/zz/"M /7§/>266§ ~

MG/IOA Z;§Z 6/§?6}0275 60717>§,,{ 3536.0.6/6 -

GQZZAUQ§ 2362 71\~0§/ 686?66©02 2606£2 "

2556/8 )@6@62§7"§ 076326§ 763 6 175 3§601)6116§ C0666361 § \6063666 b§6/1 §§ 266/mak 306666110 27,6'7,3721>©77“73 … ’2,:!§§§@ ' /66§@ 666 7>-1 1366 //66; 01 766 566 C:;v 01 66661/1 FALL§ 706:6 "" 737/6701\661 52 23566 610 7266§ 7664/§ 2103-§ 760 26§1?6‘66’WO6 716/8 §§/77866 § 614/77 63 60.:6/"60 (7‘177666 /~5 19630§§ 606 761/6 @UM5€,/”7"M.9 / 69 G/CZ/HU€, 16/ ’D<~W@*§ {, 61:/\661 363/66 /) @61>1 /3 9010)- ~11“72!1616/3 366 7`67‘16 6666@6;6/ 0660€6/` (/:66/20’)176<1 967 900@”) 336 /\1078~56 '

` W-'

b PATZ@ 326 /§ 1690/0 , b .,

,v 171 ALW& wm m ~"Z)F"vi ""”"'_'

C/z:/*»M A®P¢/M,&

‘ T¢m:@AQ , ~; 1/_};117@ $&§T'O:? 71 113 /9551/);2§ ~ , § 323

` 6\@@:0»2. 770 3111 M

~._Mm 221me 01 312 .-=~%;... v

mbi/262 366 65\ 5

%”LT©16/2 1363 661/61 75 W§ A 3106111 715 L/§~f€/`QQM* _U\S€S 72><1)& » M/MV*MT" 01 ,@6151:2 361de 7§_/3- G»B /36/;157'/+121*\217' 01 QQJ:M.S 6122156 613 m 665 611/1\>/26 7/7*\6121?3@1/»1211" 13 mg O!fv:~fe ..Z“A/L_ :/51/ (C(`/.l§ LJZV€ 355 'O»l ¢ 716 fig `/6§,.- 00/5)» - 1 *(1>) 116 216 @/:.,61+131;61¢1666 pmawa 1123 7; 666166. 1252/2123 156 2166 1216 .31'#/1~12, .Z'" 1661/fw 1651 6 /Qma£& ' - .(O 11%§,,-/166653 C@MW,EM.L/V 753 § Eama¢¢ 11 190655111;> &W 1;~'0_. - CL2136 636w CQ)L/°°" (/"/> ' " "

‘RMQ mms / 110/161 b:§c/amw:r@/\/ ` 7'612_:2:`/?)12:6>1\ \

, ' ry ` ` ccommg ‘ _those prejudices e`Ven when the_`y’ re ré- ' vealed Illm '

MQM© 1113% 290/6 262 23 $§2_0._2__._23226_@/£12¢2

\

6__&__!_€2);1.>12_2_626_2@_626._____~_,,____,_ __:______________________[66/1\_ <,5_;) ,/2; §6;2;22 /621>_11 -

151 6162§72222212-@11:2/5675@/

%6 6212 1412 2662 05 321/2668 262 ?2@32611@/3§

, 13 662166 06 21 _//“2<)11/ 1661:@16__1212;__¢@2612)6::______6 75<62» 1136 "/" 12611666__622172 1322/126 75 7>/)11 52 6212/§ 931%U_EAOC§M"'9/%0_@6__62_________ 115 26606 261 316/111411/66 126._1_1122120§2>61@266 __

. /2:/161>2216 02 262 @1262; 622 /@~2/2 62222§___

2315 6622@61@2 12226;1<66/166_11/)661

_ /O 126221\2222 1122262211<\ 112 13 621/2116 .

2____2~__;6.__\§6//)___2___93_/2§&66> 5222621262 L&GAM?@A @Q_/S)______

`,___PL/h;/QKQVM& 52 936@5660/1'6>67221€7%775@262_& 612/2 1212 1202/6 210 1162,_6‘2<;_6_662@2@222§@661 1216 32116 2121/06211" `720@62_75__9/321_1©1¢75<‘/?11_;__,_______

262 1167 321 113 /2712©62@”7 _;/§Lz 371;;_@__/;12;_@§3~_~ 1223 922<)6:162§ /§2122 WMMM 261 12 » /6226>/3©22’21/2736 1116 21722634& 413/2163 -@/;__M__~_v __ @12>5662162\ 30 1216 ?M 26';22 1107 2666/1172 6212/1922 162 226§662162116 1166@22322/~

_ 352 3<12\ //;6’>14116122: /166122 1113 C@mm'@_

/'H)

2833 /;3 €;3\ 2322 320201_1;32 252 3302 M23\

____'2 530 /013\ 02200:1_02 /0 202 ‘0:3_0_'2_030225 232<)005 4 203\ )0(3<;\ @202:007; %0207102 232/2205 / /<20 903 2201/332 620/03 2000 ___ _

6…2155 -D§z 23200"302 21030222: A§ 222 0026

230 1002 20 '3';`030020 2100/2233 20 /21’30201/ 220 320002_/0022 0:,//\

__ __050_____§222022 32232_ _ { .`0_/1\33_ ’> 3

____7932 62203§223 _072_ 002/1202022607 7000@_

2 3< 22002123002 02031211110220§22 §2203) 02 201 138 C1/

72000- 000 222 § 222 002 0 WMEB@C)ML - /\©\/35%&326_ 095_3_0_£ 02 __‘/__3___

0_;)32___ 22 § 73//917&;©/ 4_6{ '\J ______ //22:02 022/2221'_- ' __0256§021

___0: _2020100 62 10 3000 2020/m 2222/000 _ ~ 2323 2003 "~002»123112 722/20213/»\ &22020202

_ » 02201_02: 00 0000 ~ "_2_6__:5__64220/_ 702 Mx@ 1:0/1106/ 02 ______3/21002 mi% 210/§§ /0/2/220 0231;;020 2022

__5_17!01_£5_0@5_ @MMMV / 23 /17125 52/3222§§/0 122 930022 01 222 2302/1105 /0

_ 020 23 /0 101210_00/0 _ 20 321 3

A

" __)/ 0770>12:0§07220@1;61067210§::/10§670 26 020§1063 %2)06

§6>2)006/- 040 101626 2000/0 §MQ,§ .L'_ 20326

__.__ €,- -_

6610' 7066 306__2) //6616600 1000 07A §/0..., 106000 210 060<16 173 060 1210 § 36 010

___7‘,_.._,\62666__0_76,60126020§§ 566 /3\06 0§106 660§6§ 3

002/7 772/1§7®;6165066 __@21600621 0 610 600\//76/71£§ 2161)§ 702/050 C060 700/0 37 016/166 1016~0"1§`1 006§ 710770<000 " 276`0 317/m 2060 7206/006 M©/Z;/‘z:§/M 0__ :~00601010;66:06 ;/'-)66 600§ 70607,~) 2000 2162§16»307\:.\26 2070 0t 216 60113<2»02'1 216 " ` //16/ 207 066 2006/1720 210 106 01 266 . _ 'Z>X)J,f;z/§M&M 000/300 ,______'1§__16-1§ 06 060 0621'0; 0 630/606 700§ 0 2500 1103 3000 22 216 606/012 06 216 66060 §602/01/-)0 731226 710/136 /110/1760 07 @6/ 22020/73\<322: /_027%17 0__67022100/ 272076:0/2)7106 2200/60sz 630/06 _/2 7%07\ 32th 02

13 0

/§15 755555715§ 7?7>/1:5:11115 1 5 55 155 5 5/@§` 771 &’/Mw 75555;71555 755 /_3:'::5 1503 ~

7775:.3157 7131&. 771<3>555&§315 753/553 77117:715\~ ~ 7701 757/013 755577 _ \/;315§ ~///"U/z,/ 5 §§5 (7777&5 /’> ;1_;2/_§__.__ 7 /7£>2)3”5 or §3;113715 ` [O? /0; 02/§ PEGU& (/705/ <7;5§?§6@\15712557 mo 73 “7727)77 571 mm/ 35537/(7550:@3/353/

§§55@57~1511 75155 3315/§ 1 7/35'3 3333 /5155 5555§ 635557577~1 657-752 13 1305 5 /0 /X§

C/MM 3 (1'5@5)5 : 521/151 151 35 557 »<1_§__1_._.'_`1`.‘_"_':_:'_`_;

7 "15/»,315155/35,5@71 333

5 IHMMW§ 735 /5531;7:33 3 73555

_,__3731<711155553_73\;3153@5735155517/ 553733)15 73515 5§§’ MT@@A?SE §57155@ 755(:155 9 73§@1‘73‘1 I`S*”FMZ>§ § I3:3 FM35 33 33?1521)“525§53 533 @£@15/ 13

/FM 613 944 322 M 1”12>m42x21113 442/2273 601\41224__/12@1\§2 §2122”22 21241§111€4`§ 12113 9124_2_4_ 2__§1§1`<4&1§21`3111\1;1 2431/11`@12§ __ . 0\;24>12211 0140>/221441& 1412/12 1412>£& 3422222,

2 212 §22:1>2 714©1§4£20§ 214113__ 1120 J\ FM__Q_/:' 732£2;7“ _____,_§24: 1401 _.__4_.___"_:2 2312 7?424;129 1240/22 §/1)113/ 341 _ _, f 412144<4 0 324/22 1412/1242 1842421 291/2>§

1242 1244 03 /1122./24/122/1§12/121»\214"§2;<2§ _2___22_2_____2,41_43241,2/9@§2/<1®121€§<118§?4§ 1@1®/*\173/%32_4 '

Mw§ 1222 ____;2§ 1222 72124222\ __....__,/1_£9_.§1:4\241£!2 1302 12331€12213212/1133 7212 70 _.______444_4.442414:4___22 732 §2 022/1203 A222)21/'/)13124 _

324 §224 012 222 624 §241241>§ 471224<4222 10 _.__._2___@_0§2___7§/1§1;41741:) 921412 514/1452 0_1_?/12:2_,

1121/411 944 752 9412 124‘21122)24§ 34131>2/\24<4:§ __7:

/144*\2_4923 10~4_1_43 1932><¢2: 124/2241/1201042403

131)’1' 1120 3wax& 922/1624712 022 //2<4"2013 12140 1322:4_222 122 1522)1\9342

..~=..,». .,..,._.... M »M»-....._“

1114 132 7122 2229 §3_41§__24~ 942 1422/202

12 1112 02<§2 2113/1224 242 _ M@WM 7 __73&01‘/ / /9' 1 24__ _.~_..“1_ 4®_9.9.§_.__________ 2102 161\ ’ 616 w

13123 1322/w 7§292)/‘1 §1221:>11224314(32@2@24\

6454'12'641'°57"31/51:212'

IC;PIT'F¢/ 54 644 615413442 1543 1‘\4:1115_3 ____ 754 622;§4/ 61/133 113 @31466//55411/~@1111>216_ ____2_4_6_6612.6.§_ 24 3__ _7?12366<)52 1614_5__11 1124112-3 _ _/1<1:1`4'7;0_,45"39 WLOL£3/3)D1L'3 621/735 /0 M[£_LI// 531223 ________ _____21_112_1_6__6) ____/473 6114: /@ 753715:1’511'<<_1415_/‘1)4\__ fbozz_§ 43 6226_5<.1113/;'1 54134:5_6_ 63_ 7_5_16/4615__ 111613345€/ 511 16 1414/5664" 3~/4'6§ __:_ 1541 644511 713 3145 651_>_:13 61 553 154411_2___ /336 462 1523/1213 A’@_ /“OL,LOL`)§ "

_______l)__§ (36(3/4277*\1/5 Q_}-j~_ 3631'7'6 22 763 32325112_ 613 2€12111'611 415 351)3H,> /656”1111341!/%7'/4 422 15113112161/2)1 75 6 14656/

_ _C°/o» 3121`111 11 %@43 /74<111516112 _, 621-2145 1115@13 443_2151)11_6¢1 ____ ____ 4 37415455 722/4 GS~ 3145/1423

1/111>,\ 61111_@2_/\: 1251 751/1115 _ ~ 62661 1452

_ /,/ 663111_`\'/1<:6150____ __ 455225_ 711<1)3 751/501

' ‘ _,.~- ._. 12 . ~..- ... ..~_<5_‘..--. ..,\-_»-J.._

féw@ 3%52 /%(2 /7 35‘:62 333/7333¢~1/3< 333/3622 _ %11231>1>5125 1415 35111.15“£7<1 mMz%/A&_M_ 1\161515 455 541 71/1_3@_1_ fm 10 1511 4

k

172 701 3637736§~ 706 9006 724026027:7> 714704172)40

500262'02‘2<'1/6\ 334 606/2021 302/026 &

§ GAA 7237/664 663 __6603§_ 363 07377\2)7020 7000__ -

6672:4 606_§0663 ._7::1__724§ A.z; /?1_:\20 747/770 4044

700224 544 600 6074 7)210226720 40

726/00§ 3047 00001.4/§~ 627077)1173:44 7&-)1"\60674 3:

/

320/132 70446\ ~/>&'7// 668<§/

c~\\\,>

.x ._~._»war,.‘.~._ -_»mm-.~. -_. ~.;»“~.~._n--..-~»¢.

00200~ 306 622606027/ Zz; 720400/062462:20 4 10040 207 702 4244 10 024 472 0024022_4 721§

//06'0 626 677-4 61 636667>§7\642 62/07272‘\ / 46647 60 602/4 7):7221‘0643

2402/422 2744/10 674 330 6 2 ,`

6 7B6&M4H)M 701 70062?2 67 3\7_‘\4»7/7‘/ 2 6 752/064 I 6040 04701 602 \//042`0 2022 0 04021420221 602/_27_2020 /0 42000720 1012 ___&27\0461 7407090 772 /6604702

3002 6 602215@ 90 3ij 37706431 00/ 10 /07’~ 0772221 75 2006132 779090 640/694 7

..M..___W_._....- _______

66667771 ”6)6~<3“1/ 07 717/66 1010/ 6:6:6:00 ,

7\//7( @ __¢<>L/Jr\ L76 '?0/ 1711>7_1? 106100\ 0 7677111:170_: _ 70010§7301‘1'1 7606711___/11760’:71 3007 676

666/010 1126/0 0673716 766 /6010710071 /7‘\6 1/1_11;061060 2071/1 1 §00 777 5)"'£°1`11`;1£00761960

66amy7) 767/6 7106 L7160’6 71 66

7106 160/3661 611 011616 1/7~6'17 /71@1\9/_) /M 006 7617709/ 160071 725/30017 :\/'1061 076/im /CZ,[L‘€[E

703 %1‘7/1 76673771161/07/6 600M16" 761 . 3)“7?,£7176/102766 761 601/111617111 l 751111'6/171€1 1606/fcia _ 51;4111 773691 776/110/616 0671 17 1/

1.__7_"_61_66611:;6616 16 11 906 111 166/1601 6 616 7?/877171736 172 61071/16 676 606 70 100 _ 111 611/911 7699;167111 560 7701 1111 7071;<111 7101 1071€117)7`\177%;1/ 136‘)’ 01/3,/77\1(111671@76%16 610 10 771 1166 16<1;16 7 411 6700617

EMDM 7_’2`77` 76/77 0/:761&/*\(01£ 160/77 __ 1_,,__1_,,_ %¢BULQL;M~QW