Baynard, Cling Mark

Texas Supreme Court·Decided January 7, 2015·No. WR-82,404-01·Published

Opinion

l ` 19 ~8:9.:,1¢/1@-‘/»: O:l, 4 (;<;)\;;MQ CQ'/R?"/‘/l'$‘*(l)

§ .Tu Tl\<» D\%Tf`§<‘..\' daur'r E)< Par'f`<_, § 1 C'§~jM“'/( B&Y~W § sz@’ anml 015-nm App);€a”+ ` § `H"~Jaja CoM?:/, ?('e'>ms

. ¢ u°l;-N Op Fa@fS`[ OL ctcop_$ T:J Sra{'é,$ pl 25 4 dGLT‘ A/d 515ng u$-E@NS G'p La m// duval RLC¢JMM e/\/ 0

T TA¢,H`@_Nmz,/¢ cwn’ cf Cr¢‘w~@' W@'F?

M’-`& /<@Q Q"°l '~`PI`O ge Ap/J/»Ica,u'r \"’ C@*;e$ ~€/':a.)r- C',:g)#£;$f/`;CT COY)/;`)‘lr$ add 1415 ap -QQC,TS/ c |Nj' O"J’€C/" z)J(a-w v Re/EOMMc/Vda_+r'o,-U gal/01 O[*c/p/{\ """"'.Z:',:"`§:.:J cogsa +@ Ap@ /:'¢4»%$-_w»1j0~€¢;:§eas g;l`;w$ &F.t' /[¢07‘ ReS/)QaT'-'p.;'//y dsk.a)¢.u,~,uj .»,S #5,`,@¢\@6[¢ cau/\`?L 7`/\3 'Qa//éu.)¢A/j c

A ww+' w 1'<~<‘@ J“Y: §’::€;‘;:;Z“”?,F:i§ " -l;$ Tk¢ €}~ol:"’§ ap ‘P“° fpa _H\Q 934/wl recital ola:(`)o./\/ O`.AJO{ 0/`0{@!` A {`O’M`.R‘A@ 75(;[('9(2) :}e:’éM/":(e~@\$+ric'f'@ourf pul`$ua-r-()T@ 7:_(_ é.-@ c[~<.,.$j 1 d v icc ,,' 10 '["'Ae ._€i)pol§p § o ` d`(’, Aj N f nos T(.z" Oé)`j eb-‘,_ ; I`CCLG»MMe;_/u £>L§,"{`}@A/, \/\/A~c{/\ b&a$ ‘Q{I;¢_£k 0 La“-)"SOA;L(( §§ ~e,¢]@@/‘e~?;;`l L)/Jvolj€ De'€,`_’ 7 No“`)"“{%§:§@{‘/ /D¢Cl"<§ inan al> [Q § /4' [§»'Ca»/;q(`:c;:/\/; v or " ` " " 1 To e<'»"" ' a `\ ~ " Iq,wk»ck web l-».M_, ` _ -[L)§:. ;:l)d :)`:+Ious Pvf`§$va~`t"‘f@ 'L'H.A.F, 73.L(CL)Q).

F)'Mal;)\!`g]~ U‘p FacT n ' ' ’ a ) a{'e a)g 01 _LL> App)fp,¢w‘/' does Ne»'t' O£>_)e¢,+ + 5+ S sz) g

0 , , ` ' g . ariz 0/\/@‘ Tl\@ '~O('JM w RE El \LOB.;°H,‘U§ 50 g {)QC+ l couHT oF galv\/l/l‘r§\)gL"\/ijEALS '\/| 0 d c JAN 07 2015

1 ` Abel Acosta, caerk

.Q_b

’ l" L‘ev{`$z Ou S'?La{es ftc,ooseol cluqu O‘Q pac'i' # 'Two/" ];T S`/"a{`€$ \\T/`O@p@/` Wa$ dfl`ec‘{`e¢:>! §§ §_u}‘/`/o.‘/'e_ 61 5’+@;> ajal~§T¢epp//aa,u'i's female é»e¢:

_ WA:!@ .-'~ fm m you /¢»..»>mr fmc/mw 5+,1+'¢,“,,+ £R~/? P,|S. L Il*lé. e>@\"“`_`Tkey

TO':.! M€ T‘\C i"£¢l$c>;d$ Wk>/ I A/eep[g¢,l Ta» Ma[(c Tl\e, ST'OF,

Bu`r T`kq. disc.¢~c’.`t`c`c').u `Te> p}uo! Tl'\e, />[“oéal:)le gauge was U'G `IbO Me:{ 7"/£5 S,‘fa.‘f€_Mc,¢J`/' i'.~ T/Le federal p/‘m,‘e£ §{'a"'é 7‘7@@,¢\@»~ la¢/~1 T`o S‘{`¢»p \/¢A-"¢/e, whe/¢ O-O`Ofcer ,:‘,Ile¢[ Vek$<~.l»¢ @u@,/‘ usl.uj exT'7‘¢\ Vf@/Q{`"@»U 010 ?"'e¥“.s 5{'4'1"¢ Lav-/, 560- ll.§_ `\AM.`II@/~ /‘{é F3vt @Aélji;$:‘/I WA»'cL\ M,'{\;/‘~@rs g,l.\pl§c,a.u{"$ C¢Lsg/ C'Ho/J}uj \\ S/Nc.e }\aV/,uj 0\ Tul‘,u S,F$N“,.( OAJ w§','\'\@u+ 1'\21`»3~ §§ N°T g_\/,'@[q,`[",`@,u G-P +e.>c/]ole CDZ>Jec.lL,`\/e éaS}S »perpr‘oé¢.é{¢ Co.'usc Ju.sT/~p)/;Nj S+'o/A ap \/e,k\c,le,) _

Al§@l L¢j¢,,( J‘v,¢,l\';@.`(,a+\`o.u ',M,y$`l(' 176 @£J¢ec`,’.'¢~¢i\/ 'Pov~»l@-c{, S¢ei \A/l')f\g.g Hé $gr@l77if{; S"-@ “[S‘”/ `?§¢WAW:~ v J@lws.,~ 132 1534 141,173 Q;W~&»/€‘f&),'\`§@ I@Nj q_S a ha~‘p-D.`C. law /f/\pr&éf"¢`@/J fA“fwav/d Aavé, @é_jec`[’:vzl Jus`f'{'€.‘¢ol Tl\e. S'/'a/o 7'\@..)1 '{"al(€uplac.e, fhe, .FJA¢‘{' l\.a»`{"j"lxe- f>a[/CC 0-{)-¢7.`€ e/\ __MR}/ hai/6 Ma¢{e S‘{"¢./¢ P,,/~ /`€a$e~._u'$ 07‘/12,» i'Ae,u fha OcCu/`eA/C€ ap 1" &_ frap@;c_ ,[¢JQ/`A.¢+ir@/\J ;5 ;ffe[eV@y+-(Sf /)i)/`PQS(_’. ah `li'l'\,e. -C)@w~“t'k AM€NJM¢y+//(€M/)Aasfs 519(0/@,,,[),.7/¢»¢/

iva/v T'k»{'_kw/,»j a vw §i ,~a,l ¢,u ,"s M»'/'a v,’@/af‘bu

(i~c `f'e>(a$ law N@ §§ @¢`H\/€, BQS}‘S 1030 p/\@ éaé[o_ C&USO. JQS`{’§~?/c¢)l ‘/’/1,.¢ Sf¢/M per ca, pan cou?L/'A)UU¢M 0-@ law @~ "f’he 50 J¢c,{' (/$;,uj S?“af¢/ (3<»,¢[@,/~@,/(§'7‘ Cirféultj,~ duval §upr~eMe, Cou/\?" Case, /`a¢.u,v$ce hip/fka haée.as CO/`pv$ MeMa/wwdu,u drjuMe/-'?‘L?>)a~ol("/),

ON' 5`{'&1’€5 f)/`OFO$'~’/'=( p/uou/uj 0‘(>€0.¢+ #771/`&9-/. GUTH`)/ -n'/u;JP./o_$ lay Jur>/ 165 Oév}eus,

GN 5+0.`['£$ pfopo$e.bl pl~.#ou/u§ op pac+ »#- poupi /('fpel(a`{'c C@u,use,l glad au AM cycl€@( AA/J€(‘S l-:)N"¢»p /.»/ g,@o>h'oa~f$ Co»$é., Af(¢)//wy'{` GLJ<¢¢+$/ phole O_p cac-fs ;NC¢:»M }<»,+C, becau$€- 91`)3;410~‘ Lr}e'p lack 7 eu`|"op }O Re,~u£s§+e.$ ap Br§e-p 7:£./¥.?‘ `33»/ §e_c exh.`£¢"f'

ON S`):a'['e`:% Prwpc)$col “F’/m&§,u§ e-P PAcTs # ~p}ve, Afj)ga/ av£’\[)/'FM£J //$ déV/¢>U_S’,

O,AJ §+a,{"e§ pf`o/>o$eo( pldrl;¢*-’j o"p`@a'c"r§ # S"‘X /;/>p/;'ca,./‘l"§ f(‘@) Se. )Oa`/'i'+.’e/u 1000 B;Scre f/a,u¢L/*}/ /"€V/f£u/ Wa$ !`e-@usepl §§ Ol>v§

(5)1./ S“+a'fc."'$ pfa'po$¢zol p)NoU/.Hj’§ @‘O p¢c+§#§eVeA-/ .M¢WO[@+¢'» i_SSUcal is 651/foust

UN 5"‘/,2:‘/`65 pi‘epo§e.a( pinol}A/j ops@~c{'$ #'e'e I\T er' of habeas pr@$ duval Meu¢)/‘a,u¢lu,v ~C’f[`¢o[j a,v JvNc»‘,"Q"/"' QOIL{ `M/;'?LL j§$‘ue\$ I"*§ is oévj¢>ds

@N S+g{`¢‘g loroposeo! nudle o-()-()o.cf'$ »# A///A/€ Co».~‘¢"awl erea»( applfea»i’.s 'f'/Mc».( C.’ou~s¢l To faspo,v@& 779 ;SSU€S raised by way op apf,"@lavi‘/’ ar Ie§a/ docuMe,~/`h AP;J/i`cd,u?"@£ ecf$ o\~d W}/( SAa>w 771/5 Cour`l"i/.S}',vj 7`@7¢¢//7£/ €v}a/e/\/<:¢ ,'AJ 7'/¢@, {‘@@@/\0/ @Nol perp@,»./J@/*a:,uc¢ ap /¢2¢.¢) /H'S /aw>/e/* 'Wa$ vu/`co.$o/~/aé»/¢ ami `/'¢1€ H@/ £va+ Qéuse@/ H`$ discrc‘l'/a/J'oh) /’SSo/e§' /\a¢'$eol,

?¢_@

O,u g+a+£\$ PI`O FGS¢J 'O),upl/'vj

0 wl , 22:.

§qp/¢'Mu+ 03 ¢' ea`('$: ,op[l'ca»'(` acl/ed 0~ \A/I‘l+ op /7[4£5¢1.$ Corpu$ our

11107,. bu}"i"k 5 (‘£,`Vc) S+l`uc,`{'c)c.,( auo( CoA/$fi??"`u‘h'@.d)al §Sjue,$ all ap which K'e_ proves /N }\/5 wri{'a~'ol ,MeMo/‘aw(¢/M al@~ w.`"i'h Tk§ fecc»»rai’,

S`i'v*vc`t'¢»'¢~l o.~r§ Co..u$‘/’;?('u`f'/Oua,( ef"f`@r$ af "h""al €N'/'i'+)e app/.'c,d,.fl" 7'@ rel/cf iff/covey fp wf`f'f' O~p /\o.b¢a.s forva A#'('//,@`?, App//ca/./?L-»p//e/ § §§Sde`$ fha?La/‘e. Prove,,\) wl+l}\ Cu»~r~¢~'(’ CeMp¢Te.vf'/aw §’L~ci fide feca/wl /’A/ /\/S wm'{'a,.,.@l MeM@/‘a/uo{¢./M¢ /H( 5 cir‘i`e»r\'$ owe agafvs'/` C/ear/y €S?"@é//_skeo( pea/oral O\/u¢;)( gupr\€_,M.e, Cavr»`('/a,“;, §e,a/ 7"/‘,’¢,/ ffu_,u$c/'//>e$,. er' o‘p haéed,$ Co/“/>U'S, awol /14£/4 0/`¢{/\/0(¢).¢" ‘\C:»/‘ fom,‘+/ cf C:rcuMs{'a/uwsiA,¢p/`,'¢a»wé¢e¢+s,

ar ‘ + 5 +S' O,U S+a`f'e$ proposal gouo(v§s`o.d ap auJ # TW@. 7¢;€'/`€ C/d./(MS aia/l/l/Cd~% eX¢)/`€$S_ ly w"‘H\¢l/`€W )`\;5 S'UP/\O/~+ gram `/'/L¢M@“f,`e,u 1b 5`/'/‘5/<¢ JUl\o/~#`71@o/ Cause. a,ud has ¢`A.'Ie¢;l 73 pfe.$<:l`v‘¢ ‘i'k¢jw¢,-,wl '@o'v" l`eview, Tkis .`5 T@‘f'a//y crm/v eau$, Sea l`ea@m@,RR\/,S, P,-H\, Ll$"'l§,.

A'P,o///£a¢,uf'$ w/‘r"‘f’ CaMp/afy$ op 670.5 \7_Ul`0f éo‘n*\ way`$ Aév$e op 055<‘_"<`(/"¢/~/ of ?’A¢, Cov/~T' Aljumeui' '.#’O/~/€,/ a~ol IA/¢P¢Pec+/‘VC A'SS',`¢S‘/'A,ua@, o.p Cp¢/,u$a.l ’ lrsume~{’#'j'u{o, _ ~

'/\/@ where iu rational 0/` éy wa e-@ Wa:\V@../` allot app{i¢»w+"e><¢>vessly wz+k@loew h;s Suppo»r¢,¢ MO,L,.‘W ‘TO 51'/\,’/{€ Jvrw/`/f Af,o//ca,v`lv /`eli¢ol o/~) Cou/¢Jg¢,,] ‘/'@ pf`@?"ejc+' }\]3 guam/pl l‘/T" U`S, Ca~s'lc, A'M¢mj. awol 72)(. Ca,~)s+, lyl@, 1.1'5 za~o( l.lq» _

?

l

1115 ).'w,/+ mm @1~1.~@1$ ~r'A;S cw+ n ksz 13111,113~2$ €Xl/\»E'.' 443 /- Wf`i{'op habeas forpus dual/llema/au@(¢¢“

wum_e~f#l Aéase`p{‘¢l.'scre ?L¢'Lw awol A'/jum e.v'?"#g~ IA/e-Fwec,‘f`;ve /{'$S f-S"/;a,vce G-() £o/u.vSe/, ~F)e».~ a C¢AJ+/'/uc/'UM ap law ¢’>A) 'H\e Su[¢)`je¢`l",

' 7.1\§$ Ju'm/~ was aug u:»,(§-Pi'e.l as a /vta?""f'cr 0-@ /aw; .See, LtCA.' Gav"`(' Cople €=l. l®$'§'/l: T¢Xi C¢J&,Cr$M.DM€-'r gm 3551¢ Q,>® gang cc)ca); game 1 ¢~s uswa 35;' swai& S'Q~EE¢XCNM ap

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Baynard, Cling Mark, (Tex. 2015).

Baynard, Cling Mark (Baynard, Cling Mark) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

Anders v. California
386 U.S. 738 (Supreme Court, 1967)
Holmes v. State
248 S.W.3d 194 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 2008)
Swain v. State
181 S.W.3d 359 (Court of Criminal Appeals of Texas, 2005)