Barnes v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

United States Court of Federal Claims·Decided March 26, 2026·No. 22-1708V·Unpublished

Opinion

01ÿ345ÿ617358ÿ 93ÿ3ÿ 5 ÿ ÿ  3ÿÿ5ÿ 85   ÿ 7 !"#ÿ$$%&'()*ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ÿ ,-./012ÿ3045167ÿ .K;9Lÿ6I9M;NOÿ,NH:9>ÿ.<>M<>N=ÿÿ ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ89:;:;<=9>7ÿ ÿ ?@ÿ D;O9JPÿD9Q>RN>SÿTU7ÿTVTWÿ ÿ 61.41A04BÿCDÿ/102A/ÿ05Eÿÿ /F,05ÿ614G-.167ÿ ÿ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ49HI<=J9=:@ÿ ÿ ÿ XYZ[ÿ]^ÿ_`Yab[cÿdZ[[e`ÿ_`Yab[cÿffXcÿg`ehie`cÿXjcÿkl`ÿXembmblne`^ÿ ÿ j[ohhYÿd^ÿXem̀lkkcÿp^q^ÿgerY`msenmÿlkÿtZhmbuecÿvYhibnwmlncÿgxcÿkl`ÿ]ehrlnyenm^ÿ ÿ {!|ÿ!ÿ!!}ÿ ÿ C=ÿ5ÿ}7ÿTVTT7ÿ,;MKN9Oÿ3N>=9HÿL;O9JÿNÿ89:;:;<=ÿL<>ÿM<~I9=HN:;<=ÿRT=J9>ÿ :K9ÿ5N:;<=NOÿGNMM;=9ÿ-=€R>Sÿ.<~I9=HN:;<=ÿ8><>N~7ÿ‚TÿF@6@.@ÿƒUVVNN„}V7ÿemÿhe ^ÿ†:K9ÿ ‡GNMM;=9ÿ0M:ˆ‰@ÿ89:;:;<=9>ÿNOO99Hÿ:KN:ÿK9ÿHRLL9>9JÿNÿANQO9ÿHKÿ;=€R>Sÿ>9ON:9Jÿ:<ÿ ?NMM;=9ÿNJ~;=;H:>N:;<=ÿ†‡6-4G0ˆ‰ÿL9M9;I:ÿÿW7ÿTVT}@ÿ89:;:;<=ÿN:ÿ}@ÿÿ ÿ D<>ÿ:K9ÿ>9NH<=HÿH9:ÿL<>:KÿQ9O<Š7ÿN=JÿNL:9>ÿK;=ÿ<=ÿ:K9ÿ J;HIR:9Jÿ;HHR97ÿ-ÿL;=Jÿ:KN:ÿ89:;:;<=9>ÿ;Hÿ9=:;:O9Jÿ:<ÿM<~I9=HN:;<=ÿL<>ÿNÿ6-4G0ÿANQO9ÿ;=€R>S@ÿ ÿ }ÿ ÿ 39MNRH9ÿ:K;Hÿ>RO;=ÿM<=:N;=HÿNÿ>9NH<=9Jÿ9ŒION=N:;<=ÿL<>ÿ:K9ÿNM:;<=ÿ:N9=ÿ;=ÿ:K;HÿMNH97ÿ;:ÿ~RH:ÿQ9ÿ~NJ9ÿ IRQO;MOSÿNMM9HH;QO9ÿN=JÿŠ;OOÿQ9ÿI:ÿNOÿ.ON;~HŽÿŠ9QH;:97ÿN=J<>ÿ N:ÿÿK::IHPŠŠŠ@:H=N:;<=NOMJN=M9ÿŠ;:Kÿ:K9ÿ1„=~9=:ÿ 0M:ÿNOÿ,N=N9~9=:ÿN=Jÿ8><~<:;<=ÿ<=;Mÿ=~9=:ÿ 69>?;M9H‰@ÿ’“”ÿ•–—˜”ÿ™’–ÿš›œ“˜ÿž“œœÿŸ–ÿ— —“œ—Ÿœ–ÿ™"ÿ—˜¡"˜–ÿž“™’ÿ—¢¢–””ÿ™"ÿ™’–ÿ“˜™–š˜–™#ÿ-=ÿNMM<>JN=M9ÿ Š;:KÿGNMM;=9ÿ4RO9ÿ}†Q‰7ÿ89:;:;<=9>ÿKNHÿ}‚ÿJNSHÿ:<ÿ;J9=:;LSÿN=Jÿ~9JNM:ÿ~9J;MNOÿ<>ÿ<:K9>ÿ;=L<>~N:;<=7ÿ :K9ÿJ;HMO


9ÿ>N=:9Jÿ;=?NH;<=ÿ;?NMS@ÿ-L7ÿRI<=ÿ>9?;9Š7ÿ-ÿN>99ÿ:KN:ÿ :K9ÿ;J9=:;L;9Jÿ~N:9>;NOÿL;:HÿŠ;:K;=ÿ:K;HÿJ9L;=;:;<=7ÿ-ÿŠ;OOÿ>9JNM:ÿHRMKÿ~N:9>;NOÿL><~ÿIRQO;MÿNMM9HH@ÿ ÿT ÿ5N:;<=NOÿ.K;OJK<Sÿ0M:ÿ9;=NL:9>7ÿL<>ÿ9NH9ÿ 9L9>9=M9Hÿ:<ÿ:K9ÿGNMM;=9ÿ0M:ÿŠ;OOÿQ9ÿ:<ÿ:K9ÿI9>:;=9=:ÿHRQIN>N>NIKÿ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

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Barnes v. Secretary of Health and Human Services, (uscfc 2026).

Barnes v. Secretary of Health and Human Services (Barnes v. Secretary of Health and Human Services) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.