Barnes, Michael Wayne

CourtCourt of Appeals of Texas
DecidedJuly 8, 2015
DocketWR-73,300-12
StatusPublished

This text of Barnes, Michael Wayne (Barnes, Michael Wayne) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Court of Appeals of Texas primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Barnes, Michael Wayne, (Tex. Ct. App. 2015).

Opinion

RC>\BKL“\ Q>°? §/>2:§\\\‘;&&\\, Q\Q/\>‘C%\i?

Q\YQ“§‘L\\\ ~ “<'E‘»<\A@

RE`.\Y wm

T\; wm .\O, \©"\ ‘g>>\\\\‘_ §§ . 300 -\\' RE©EWED&N ` @@UWOF cma/imm ¢\@PEALS JuL. 08 2015 ' _ _ …¢@;:~.:-.1 U\_QX\LQX\Q m§\\Q/%Qx\\@ \/Q\Q§ 0§;(>{ me `

Q>'\&"A_P\M w ‘Q€~_\“rx M>:\\*\;cs\z uz/\m `c>¥ Y<\\A\S©©\<\\\)@

' \~\(\\%\\%O`§\ \D:%U M§> . .~x'.’\>&°.§ “`§_’b‘?& \\\?>‘BU%Q~ %/©Y,\\\"© Q\\§, b"\\“< \\ch\ ‘x:w\ F>\%D

\>\\b_\\‘)\¢bw`\\\l "Q\{~ *V\%“\?> &`/@\LO>» "\5\`@ 5 \ .' "l

. T?$§>:<“;%€;

‘€\§\VQT\®E\ v \\N\®<\S<@MB w\m’%w <\@;D "TTD&,§ rle §§ \\\Z>QBO%Q, w>;\;\\\¢@ Q><\Q Q\\\>< \\oC\"\ \? w\ O\Q)o \><\>\~<\»-@§\\\Q “<\< “\“\70\\?>

Q‘Ef:>’\><)\\\®\€,\m\ \-\U~\DK\ \l<\<§@f@b€\ sir , €\ mQ, §,Q/\\§QX \’l$>\ "CX.{:)\Q/ \Q 00 \3<00<~>©<\ "’\`/\ ‘°'\“’\ 00 3d \°\‘6%

’Ql€` $(<\C\»Q,\o“§. %\\L\»\m

\\

~v\f<\§,® §)‘E §£>;§“< mm § “\O§€\L’\“l%§ _ . '*'\'\>\%\>1 §§ §§§’\§Me x . "-YQQ,~\,; Q>Y §\>’\§\cz/\`c;~<’»@% § `%'\? \ §§ §5>(&

:~/\\>< @Q<\§§ \ §§ `BQ\C::§'©:§;\®)\¢ .` i>§\)§ § ;~b Q”\?\L%\/\A\\€w \ §§ “< &\U%

Q®\§M<\\@\\>‘/ \RW ‘>~\>’\‘(\WL'S:K wade WQ\\)~;:\L <§) _\L \<,`% '\:L\E,?

§;\U\l':< “5.`? §§©z’€ §)’\? §§ \L\\.'s,§!/ mmi

"TQ/\Q»LE §>`\€ Q\D"'\ §\O’\\<<;Y ‘_1"6%

\\,z:§.&.§»\\<`z. Qw\§<\d\ \`\\§\\ ' "T§>L. \)DCXQ, M\§\\.(Q<@§/‘Qr»<_ \\ .®“\% "“YQ>L. mg \§'\\\\./\7~;1>§,. @\©c- \\. Q“\CS §\’\} "’\`Q>l. \lv<\€?< Q(§. \Q"§<>’bj?>o» .A\C\ xc)\\\A \‘9.,

mm §§ §)>\§`§%

/%\/<>A\\ \s %\Q>x\>\\c>x\d CB>?; §§>< \\O\\\ §\Rw%\

=\\W \\ §m§ w 4 \@ w \Q»§@ w\\@mcm ww§<;:p iuz>@\) ‘€»LQM>Q §QA&>Q> %O\ %\»o:m\ li),\u>\§§>@ 3:\ §’\Q>¢ §x\v<\ W\)Q 'M>§\\ \,QmQ/\\\<\

R \<>»§\m@>\ ¢®<>\§‘)_é\ "\Q\\Q we \:\W §X\m §@.\‘>\C\;).\ \-`&\c»x&c\\\\\ w<\\\<\ l§ §@§A’\\Q) ®JD L”\Q>L.§mc\\ ©Q’\) ‘lQ>OOD

¢\~\\\

67<&“\€%\§\\/\ §§ ‘/\\-\€. U\<§Q

`_,\\<\Q`, ‘(Q>\Qéqc>{ \(\c>:@ SL\K\Q\_.Q)&\§<\\\` " %S

‘\ \l<>\(§ \D\\\'»\Q,>'<\@<\" C><\\>\ ->\\“k § \i\@ \D<"\*‘® §§ \\Q»§Qc),c\/`V MQ<'/\J\)¢S §§>‘ov<\`\swz& Q>\~ AQ>®Q`A w %0\3@0.<>\\`)®‘\>& \Q\>\ &€'ma. (\7\@3@0<\<`>\0)\\»&@. _ ' `

l `;L<\ ~>?\_\Q, `\\\¢:>>< w\§< \,QS`€,Q/ M\Q <'Q,<-~;§Q o\\d®\\é; '@\'\c\v*§ i‘,-\\`\x>}<\ K.Q\w_‘;<\;\><\\\ vQ.Q\o\@ 39\\@5\ ¢>?\\Q <`e,'“iq>x` QJO§/. ©\<>< \\ `%"\"2> \D\€\>< § \\Q;)QQu-s WDv \OQ, ®¢:>\\`\\¢Q@Qé wax Qr`\\f 0\00¢@ n QDV QQ§)\\O?<\”\)\\\

\p`\><\\ c>f\<\£z, €\QS<\)~‘\/\>\5\¢$\@<\/@ @Q>< Q_\>\'><\\ `\<\ §¥v'><.\\;,- &Y\%L\>\\ mm k\`\ w x‘)v\‘

L"V` A?‘<`\\< G§\ ;`\\\<\~ 5<\\@, Q\G< \\.\Y\?; \S'QY‘\)< @Q‘ \\®QQ@€> w`b®oe w\@> Y_OG\\ c§ Sé<\m\`] \\w@, \OQ,Q><\ QB`A%» U\%Qéx 0~< >:)¢QQ dwsz "\@ \\D as\>;>\@a;\€\@<\ @Qg» q./`\Q\Q,Q\,\\o\ ~<\'\G\AQ, §@( ;\.>\\Q Q»©<_ \\.©'\OQ \z><`\>< c\x\é. ¢\><\Q /Q><,\v\a Q>CQ/ A$\><@%@, §§ 3<\\<:.-3< &<\d c>x@,

` 1

’>Q>\\ QO:>\\\\\%¢L)v`\>¢'_

`;'<\\D, /Q\Q§\C»§\o< \\Q@@ §\Q>AQ)C'\<)QQ><\ (Q>S \wazé> <><\ A><\Q, YAQ>(`\>\¢b § \\`A@ Q>\c;,\<<\ dea ¢S\O\ Q»§\@ "\m\@(§;\¢<\m_

._’1,_0\>?>

"I_‘Zfs\>?/ \J'":>U /\:’

"V§:";€:\>‘Q/ Q>\\*z/‘_ "'\\<\Q, %>§\ \<\<)d §>\w;\») Q)(_ Qf@@mc§ \<)\>\_¢>SQQ YQ%Q@<\AQ>©< T\\v_.%\\iw<\\@ f\©<_xs¥ ¢€<\Q \‘5 wa 03\0\)0@_& \Q\\ §>\QS\QQ, ;b\¢ ¢>x\\?, €i-\<:S\§z °

451 w@v<\\zm< Q>Y< “~?§Awe>

"/\\<\`Q, <`€L\Q>S\o\c_`@ '\B QSNQQ<> \bcsr’@ %\QQ\ c>~\\ >s» w\v \€. j

"’Y\\Q %><<>S\/`\%\<\Q> Q<<\Q\>>QK \% Q\c»z\<;<> \@ ~ \%/ \6 , ><\\@3\@ ~ )M>Q>©\\>\Q><\$>V dm>\% %\\L p@¢:>>\ \/0\<\®<§ maé<\@<`\z@,é\" \<)\>\ ‘QXG§

§

§Q\\A\)Q<\£§/\ (»\\\,’\D Q\\\;’\~e©/\L/:;’\ fi“@€>

4 '\/B&U>v®\\\ ><© »\("<\Q “/\Q>;. §;Dé\% §'M’\v\`_/PWLR<>< . \'\.R“\~~ Q`% rb K\O\ ¥l¢ §§ (Q£<)<\XOS<`\\\©V §§ A><\Q ":`JXQS\Q, U\\\)\\<\Q\% \’5 §`m>\% `\<\ \,\>\<`\\©\\ w UL%§)A\\A brb ¢€\<\Q < QRG§©<% Q<\f>\. \\&>“\”Q \)O‘<"\°v §§ \<\ 05le w

"Y\\Q 6_°<®§\)%&2. AQQQ: \\v>v €>>QQ&\QX\A‘¢ wq_.>q> \<>Q/ Q,\LQ)\Q`€>~Q,&\%<\\ ¢S<\Q \’5 Acm\ U>O\\S\ down m\d ¢A\Q, `<;L@~\?O<\L\Qk\ \\c»§> A® QMO%\» COG< )€<\©.' Q)Qo\f u<\d ,\>\\ws>\& \Omsoo§z 0§ b?<\@ SX~OS<\)>\Q QN \\`y@ \w\`x * Q\`\V\ \\§\U>é\\\ \\~ \c\(>>€\\\\<\\ w ’>.\D';KA“\\%' w \_“\Q>L.Q)I"\K\\.~

\BQQ~M)©®\`)_ ' , ` .9,&%-

Q(\< . /z~<\<\`\><\\@` i>\c&&% %w`\cx\<\c& §<<\@\DQ>< `\@ \<>'\d QL>< ;<>',\\\>~\/<> w'cw\;\\>\ \>>\¢¢\<\ ‘@\Q,S\Q\Q§i `~ , 4

`IS;%\>Q “\`\>J© `- */\\\@\ Q`<~\` \\.b`/\% \)J\r`\>< @Q\\Q>\;QC© M>YQ\F@`\<\

W<\`§\>&\§S€\\v<\. \§o`\>(\<\ 5<\\\1 ®~\C)S\O(‘¢ \\<>'\d %A§)\®}\©K\ Q w ;\)<\' L§Q>?<\Q,\\B\O\>\ %X\IO\C %J§>Q;'§QAQQ> §\>QSZO\M <0\"\\\¢\\. 4

€'<<>rv€ wwa csx “<;<>\M°;z

' "T\\.Q, C€>%v<§_ \,`Q~°\e\ 03<'\\& `\<\\~/\3\\<\\<2_<©\@<§\ €>Q>\\@S\<;/@Q\\\ \\\\\ `\,\>\\'\©<\ U\Q$\SQ@>_ ~¥\\\L"\Q>L. M>&<<\, §§ _R%\<<\.(@M §X~<\ '.`\\b“\ \0\>\ %\Q\<§\&\~ Q<©v~. \\ .©“\"5 c>v\exq §\)K\\K %@\Q\\m \BO\”`\¥< ‘\>Q\N`\Q><\ ~x~m>\@ QQ§QU Q>\\ §ng wmx ’\,%A ama Q>»\@\>s\\\%w\ 0\§5\> @\\o»\\§ »<1> €>N>>\\Q>\c\?\\Q ev`/\ Q><\>`<\@'\m \A>\c\<\w \>QQS ><\v w<\d\@< \§m\ l \<\M». ` ‘ `

§k\‘>&\\)_v\x\s“\ wm Q\)’\Y\Q>/\@/\~:@©

"'i\<\Q, (v\\<>§. \\.%“\?z\§b~€\>` §§ \>\Q®QC@> Y@@@@ §<<5<. “ \ \_©Vx<§,\._\x§§\\ U\\ ` \)>R¢; m>\ `O\\\o£>\ c\`)©\¢z \)\9&\\ ‘¢@Q\ \)5\\\<)<\ C»®\\)c»§“\\z\ ©\@QY\QBQ A<\> \5<1><.\\.©’\ %\\\\\,\§ .

“"F\>Y><\\QM<\MQ/ A/\\g YQ>`QS\<>\c>-V- Q»><\\B\®€\<><\ `\'; \£0'\<§ ®QQ, w O\ Q\)\\€>Q><<\Qx\&o& Qx\k©v`f '._/»<\ »\?<\9,_ `\<\ss\<>x\>< *Q\,Q>€QQ, ~B¢\\Q, %S\`/`\C\K\X

' m ¢€\\Q TQ>Q<\\)\ Qm\ol,\\\\x C\e`<\&-X ®m>x `\§\c>\`\<\€\m\\<\~ Q/<\><\ \\\cx®. wm c<\@@@z\@> g>\ QM\QM@ mm ®ae:\w m

'?> GCQ>

(Q£?Q>l@<\uz >® ¢?\\Q_ AQL\Q><\§<`§\Q,. Q>¢Q>C<\`\<\<>§:\©<\ § >m>c> uQ/\_ ' \ Q\>.K\@`€\ ~W@\ ®\Q~" Sld\~\ .`\<>Q/` \\§<'\§;\QQ\ L\Q<\Q, K;z>\g;i\c Q\<> ~>'<\<\s;>w /QQ;*\DQ° _` ->><\Q, Q\>\\Q` 316 §§ Q)\\€Q» .'/\33¥<><§\\\‘- U<>\< ¢\\<>*\C\ ,CP/-%§Q>< \\°\\>\ L\C\\o“o¥

.""Y\\QYQXC><\>\ M>Yx 61©<29= \\9)><- §®%\‘§;o\ ce>\\€sk`\>\>¢%\©<\@§\ 'C%o\o\¢$\\@o @\`~ a C><\c>s< ~"\\\ gx"\v€£; `\\'\ ®\L_')\\\ QQ\%L ?§\05\2>`(\<1§\ \-%S9<\\33 ¢?\\2, ¢(€\cb\ ®UQ\“< \\Q€:> w '§\>é\@§;\®%\c><\ @\Qx A><\Q <:A3:;5€> fc@;cg*§ m UC¢:`T'.\ `\/\Qc\é\m~\.»c»i> \- 'i> M“X Q)L.M\Q<\_Qc>'\\\d.%>&&>~. \><<\'\QMR.\\\ \\\ .

‘;\>A>\\Q>cv<\@<@ ~l(\/\sz `\»> \\b \ C>b<>¢b\>\\>§@§»\ <\© Q>`>\Ao)m>, w SGQ%><@L>\\~>`<\@\Q, <\>U @\QAQ,U\\¥Q \\AMM `\<\ ¢><\©$\\‘\ §M\\Q\<)L\\\R . c>< >\QN€\ \\\b&\\\ C)S\ 3<<\0\\ '\)b\')\c§c\`\a> Q;A\Q.>\ 'c>\ w@\;o\e@m, w@\a§\>e>cswwx\f\bwmme>\%O\@.\>oz& Q/L\ m 'g_/§d'\g » Q_"\ \,"'i .Q.~r`\cf\. QQQ ‘),O©\\. \ n

KQ\)<\S&?K\Q>Q\'}\Q>\ Qx\/D‘( §§ \)QQ)»\ C>J=`> & \|<>`\A\D\\\I\QS€\O`<\ QC\J\ \<>Q OS<>YO»Q>¢\.QQ\ 03< w\\>\ ~>r`\v<\Q/ w\d QM\\\@)§ \QQ \)Qc§x\s@é\..

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack