Attorney General v. Gutierrez

Opinion

7 e* r- Il j I i-ri t ! I l::'"'- 'r l'fJ cr tf.,;-i'' iiii" --lr- 1-l."-iLir 1

illJt .t t rii,.;1 ,ll- i_iii-*?l

-. r.-if n. 'l 7 -.r1i-' !1':i -.- ;:i L' n'

1 i-:r'-ii:ii

2 i,l1...-"'-

7 Attorney General of Guam, 8 CASE NO. CVO166.O3 Plaintiff, 9

10 DECISION AND ORDER re: clerical errors ll Carl T.C. Gutierrez; Davina M. Lujan; t2 Sob"{ H. Kono; Phillip J. Tydingco; Bqooks Lynch Tydingco & Quan, L-Lp: 13 Vivien Baytoyan-Sagisi; and Does A-M, t4 Defendant. l5 t6 Having reviewed the court's June 4, 2009, Findings of Fact and Conclusions of law I7 in this matter the court recognizes that it inadvertently made four clerical errors on page 19. 18 Pursuant to Rule 60(a) of the Guam Rules of Civil Procedure the court has corrected page 19 I9 of its Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law. 20 So ordered this June 2l I5oon. 22

23 ffi,ffi-*ffi Richard H. Benson 24 Judge Pro Tempore, Superior Court of Guam JUN O B zOOg

25 ffie#*# I includes particular language in one section but omits it in another it is generally presumed

2 that the legislature acts intentionally and purposely in the disparate inclusion or exclusion). a J PlaintifPs fourth cause of action is therefore dismissed.

5 For the above reasons and pursuant to the mandates of Sections 7102 and,7103 of the

6 Guam Code. Plaintiffis entitled to a personal judgment against Defendant Gutierrez for

7 $300,000.00 and Defendant Lujan for $100,000.00, for a total judgment of $300,000.00 to

8 be paid to the Government Guam as of the date of this order. Defendant Lujan and

9 Defendant Gutierrez are jointly and severally liable for $100,000.00 of the $300,000.00

l0 judgment. Plaintiffshall prepare and file a judgment, which has been approved as to form

ll by Defendants, within the next 14 days.

t2 13 So oRDERED, this June 3!,2oos. t4 l5 t6 Judge Pro Tempore, Superior Court of Guam

t7 18

l9 20

2L

24 JUN 0 B zrol

Esther Uf Pinauh 25

Page 19 of 19