Application of George P. Moran, Frank A. Fedosh and Carl A. Maxwell

394 F.2d 595, 55 C.C.P.A. 803
Court of Customs and Patent Appeals·Decided December 28, 1967·No. Patent Appeal 7851·Published

Opinion

KIRKPATRICK, Judge.

This appeal is from the decision of the Board of Appeals of the Patent Office affirming the rejection on prior art of claims 1 through 4 of application serial No. 296,629, filed July 22, 1963, for “Shell and Tube Heat Exchangers.” No claim is allowed.

*596 The invention relates to a head portion of a heat exchanger for feedwater heaters. The structure is shown in the single figure of the application drawing:

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

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Application of George P. Moran, Frank A. Fedosh and Carl A. Maxwell, 394 F.2d 595, 55 C.C.P.A. 803 (ccpa 1967).

394 F.2d 595 (Application of George P. Moran, Frank A. Fedosh and Carl A. Maxwell) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

United States v. Adams
383 U.S. 39 (Supreme Court, 1966)
Application of Philip A. Shaffer, Jr
229 F.2d 476 (Customs and Patent Appeals, 1956)