Andrews v. State

• Court: Supreme Court of Delaware
• Decided: June 11, 2021
• Docket: 289, 2020
• Status: Published

Opinion

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF DELAWARE

EDWIN ANDREWS, § § No. 289, 2020 Defendant Below, § Appellant, § § v. § Court Below–Superior Court § of the State of Delaware STATE OF DELAWARE, § § Cr. ID No. 1407000163 (N) Plaintiff Below, § Appellee. § §

Submitted: April 22, 2021 Decided: June 11, 2021

Before VAUGHN, TRAYNOR, and MONTGOMERY-REEVES, Justices.

ORDER

After careful consideration of the appellant’s opening brief, the State’s motion

to affirm, and the record below, it appears to the Court that:

(1) Edwin Andrews appeals the Superior Court’s August 25, 2020 order

denying his motion for sentence modification. The State has filed a motion to affirm

the judgment below on the ground that it is manifest on the face of Andrews’ opening

brief that his appeal is without merit. We agree and affirm.

(2) The record reflects that Andrews pleaded guilty in January 2015 to two

counts of second-degree robbery and one count of possession of a deadly weapon

during the commission of a felony. Following a presentence investigation, the Superior Court sentenced Andrews to an aggregate of fifteen years of Level V

incarceration, suspended after twelve years for six months of Level IV supervision.

Andrews did not appeal his convictions or sentence.

(3) On July 27, 2020, Andrews filed a motion for sentence modification

under Superior Court Criminal Rule 35(b). On August 25, 2020, the Superior Court

denied the motion, finding that Andrews’ sentence remained appropriate for the

reasons stated at sentencing and that no additional information had been provided to

the court to warrant its reduction or modification. This appeal followed.

(4) We review the Superior Court’s denial of a Rule 35(b) motion for abuse

of discretion.1 Rule 35(b) provides that a motion for sentence modification filed

after ninety days will only be considered in extraordinary circumstances or under 11

Del. C. § 4217.2 “In order to uphold the finality of judgments, a heavy burden is

placed on the defendant to prove extraordinary circumstances when a Rule 35

motion is filed outside of ninety days of imposition of a sentence.”3

(5) On appeal, Andrews argues, as he did below, that his numerous medical

issues leave him unusually susceptible to the dangers posed by COVID-19.

1 Benge v. State, 101 A.3d 973, 976-77 (Del. 2014). 2 Super. Ct. Crim. R. 35(b). 3 State v. Culp, 152 A.3d 141, 145 (Del. 2016) (internal quotation marks and citation omitted). 2 Andrews also claims for the first time on appeal that this increased risk implicates

the Eighth Amendment. Andrews’ arguments are unavailing.

(6) First, we have previously determined that the question of whether the

early release of any particular prisoner is warranted in light of the dangers posed by

COVID-19 is best left to the discretion of the Department of Corrections, which may

move for the modification of any offender’s sentence for good cause—including the

offender’s medical illness or infirmity—under 11 Del. C. § 4217.4 And Andrews’

reliance on the United States Supreme Court case Helling v. McKinney5 to support

his Eighth Amendment claim is misplaced. In Helling, the United States Supreme

Court considered whether prison officials could face civil liability for placing a

prisoner in a situation that poses an unreasonable risk of serious damage to his future

health; the case does not relate to or address the reduction or modification of a

prisoner’s sentence. Accordingly, we conclude that the Superior Court did not abuse

its discretion in denying Andrews’ untimely motion for sentence modification.

4 Johnson v. State, 2020 WL 5626231, at *2 (Del. Sept. 18, 2020) (recognizing that Section 4217 is the statutory vehicle available to a defendant seeking sentence modification for medical reasons). 5 509 U.S. 25 (1993). 3 NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the motion to affirm

is GRANTED and the judgment of the Superior Court is AFFIRMED.

BY THE COURT:

/s/ Gary F. Traynor Justice