American Life League, Inc. v. Reno

47 F.3d 642, 1995 WL 55677
Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit·Decided February 13, 1995·No. No. 94-1869·Published·Cited by 56 cases

Opinion

Affirmed by published opinion. Judge MICHAEL wrote the opinion, in which Judge HALL and Senior Judge CHAPMAN joined.

OPINION

MICHAEL, Circuit Judge:

Plaintiffs, the American Life League, Inc. and five individuals, all actively opposed to abortion, appeal from a judgment upholding the validity of the Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (the Access Act or Act), Pub.L. No. 103-259, 108 Stat. 694 (1994) (to be codified at 18 U.S.C. § 248). We affirm.

In affirming we first conclude that the Access Act is within the commerce power of Congress and that congressional action here was not barred by principles of federalism. Second, we decide that the Act does not violate the First Amendment’s Free Speech Clause. The Act targets unprotected activities, such as violence and clinic blockades. However, to the extent that the Act might incidentally proscribe some conduct with expressive elements (such as peaceful but obstructive picketing), we examine it under the First Amendment. Because we find that the Act is content and viewpoint neutral, we subject it to intermediate scrutiny. Under that level of scrutiny we conclude that the Act serves substantial government interests, that it is not aimed at expression, and that it is narrowly tailored. We also conclude that the Act is neither overbroad nor vague. The Act’s liquidated damages provision also withstands the First Amendment challenge. Third, we conclude that the Act does not violate the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause or the Religious Freedom Restoration Act (RFRA), 42 U.S.C. §§ 2000bb to 2000bb-4.

I.

On May 26, 1994, the same day the President signed the Access Act into law, plaintiffs filed this action to challenge it in the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia.

Plaintiffs allege the following in their second amended complaint. Plaintiff American Life League, Inc. (ALL) conducts educational and legislative activities “relating to the human rights of persons born and unborn.” The five individual plaintiffs, Antoinette C. Cleary, David G.P. Englefield, Patricia Loh-man, Patricia Savino and the Reverend Gerald Weymes, all oppose abortion “upon theological, moral and other grounds.” The Reverend Mr. Weymes has often prayed near clinics that perform abortions. The other individual plaintiffs and some ALL members have “demonstrated, prayed and sidewalk-counseled within the vicinity of abortion clinics.” Plaintiffs’ activities have been peaceable, and they do not condone “nonpeaceable or violent conduct.” Their actions, however, have physically obstructed access to abortion clinics.

Plaintiffs also allege that their continuing anti-abortion activities put them in jeopardy of violating the Access Act. They claim that the Act, by outlawing their activities, violates the Constitution and RFRA.

Plaintiffs brought this action against Janet Reno, Attorney General of the United States. The district court allowed five additional defendants to intervene: the National Abortion Federation; the National Organization for Women; Commonwealth Women’s Clinic and Capitol Women’s Center, two reproductive health clinics that provide counseling, birth control advice, contraceptives, medicine, prenatal care and abortions; and Dr. George Tiller and Dr. Susan Wickland, two physicians who perform abortions. The district [646]*646court accepted (as did we) an amicus brief from the American Civil Liberties Union and the ACLU Foundation of Virginia.

On June 1, 1994, five days after the complaint was filed, the Attorney General filed a motion to dismiss under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(b)(6). The district court acted with dispatch, holding a hearing on June 10, 1994, and issuing an opinion and order dismissing the second amended complaint with prejudice on June 16, 1994. See American Life League, Inc. v. Reno, 855 F.Supp. 137 (E.D.Va.1994). Plaintiffs now appeal that order.

II.

Congress passed the Access Act in response to protracted and nationwide violence and access obstruction at facilities providing abortions. Between 1977 and early 1993, more than 1,000 acts of violence against abortion providers and more than 6,000 clinic blockades were reported in the United States. S.Rep. 117, 103d Cong. 1st Sess. 31 (1993); H.R.Rep. No. 306, 103d Cong.2d Sess. 6-7 (1993) reprinted in 1994 U.S.C.C.A.N. 699, 703-704. “These acts included at least 36 bombings, 81. arsons, 131 death threats, 84 assaults, two kidnappings, 327 clinic invasions, and one murder.” Id. Congress concluded that state and local law enforcement agencies were often unable and sometimes unwilling to protect the patients and staffs of these clinics from violence and severe disruption. S.Rep. No. 117 at 3, 18-21; H.R.Rep. No. 306 at 10, 1994 U.S.C.C.A.N. 707.

The Access Act aims to protect and promote public safety and health “by establishing Federal criminal penalties and civil remedies for certain violent, threatening, obstructive and destructive conduct that is intended to injure, intimidate or interfere with persons seeking to obtain or provide reproductive health services.” Act, § 2. To that end the Act provides criminal and civil penalties against anyone who:

(1) by force or threat of force or by physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates or interferes with or attempts to injure, intimidate or interfere with any person because that person is or has been, or in order to intimidate such person or any other person or any class of persons from, obtaining or providing reproductive health services; ... or
(3) intentionally damages or destroys the property of a facility, or attempts to do so, because such facility provides reproductive health services....

Act, § 3(a).1

The Access Act defines its key terms. Act, § 3(e). The term “interfere with” means “to restrict a person’s freedom of movement.” “Intimidate” means “to place a person in reasonable apprehension of bodily harm to him- or herself or to another.” “Physical obstruction” means “rendering impassable ingress to or egress from a facility that provides reproductive health services ..., or rendering passage to or from such a facility ... unreasonably difficult or hazardous.” “Reproductive health services” means “reproductive health services provided in a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility, and includes medical, surgical, coun-selling or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including services relating to pregnancy or the termination of a pregnancy.”

The Act also provides a rule of construction: “[n]othing in this section shall be construed — (1) to prohibit any expressive conduct (including peaceful picketing or other peaceful demonstration) protected from legal prohibition by the First Amendment to the Constitution.” Act, § 3(d).

The criminal penalties prescribed by the Act vary with the nature of the violation. For example, a first offense involving only a nonviolent physical obstruction carries a penalty of imprisonment for not more than six months or a fine of not more than $10,000. An offense resulting in death carries a penal[647]

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

American Life League, Inc. v. Reno, 47 F.3d 642, 1995 WL 55677 (4th Cir. 1995).

47 F.3d 642 (American Life League, Inc. v. Reno) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.

Related

O'Brien v. United States Department of Health & Human Services
894 F. Supp. 2d 1149 (E.D. Missouri, 2012)
United States v. Chester
628 F.3d 673 (Fourth Circuit, 2010)
Stormans, Inc. v. Selecky
571 F.3d 960 (Ninth Circuit, 2009)
Booth v. Maryland
327 F.3d 377 (Fourth Circuit, 2003)
United States v. Lindh
212 F. Supp. 2d 541 (E.D. Virginia, 2002)
Booth v. Maryland
207 F. Supp. 2d 394 (D. Maryland, 2002)
Young v. Saunders
34 F. App'x 925 (Fourth Circuit, 2002)
Roe v. Aware Woman Center for Choice, Inc.
253 F.3d 678 (Eleventh Circuit, 2001)
United States v. Daniel J. Balint and James A. Ketchum
201 F.3d 928 (Seventh Circuit, 2000)
Planned Parenthood Of The Blue Ridge v. Camblos
155 F.3d 352 (Fourth Circuit, 1998)
United States v. George L. Wilson and Colin L. Hudson
154 F.3d 658 (Seventh Circuit, 1998)
Clarence Hines John Cooke Wilson Orlando Brinson Khalil Kasson Ali Al-Munin Coy S. Gunter Lumumba Mumia Tafari-I A/K/A Lummie Hearns Malik Baqi Tahrim Supreme C. Jihad Kenneth Washington Salaam A. Hakim A/K/A Michael Bailey Zakariya Abdul Shahid Ray Charles Degraffenreid Maurice Livingston Demarcus Marshall Hakim Sabur Muhammad Ras Kolonji Muata Kafele Willie James Asbury Mustafa Abdullah A. Al-Mujahid John Michael Gladney Davis Young Bruce Scott Chris Lefever Dashel Strobert Vincent Kemp Larry Bobean Royce Maurice Collins John Brinson Gary L. Moore Jame A. Khaliq Lester Young Philip H. Tanner Michael Landry Donchell Wade Blatch William R. Smith Mark T. Larsen Kahim Khamil Muhammad Adrian Hicks Matin Abdul Ali Muntaqim A/K/A Marshall L. Land Yusuf Ahmad Abdullah Muhammad Heyward Harrison, Jr. Barry Alan Fowler Raheem Abdullah Al-Raqib James B. Patterson Don Eric Robertson Tyrone Mitchell Omar Abdel Al Numit A/K/A John James Bell Cecil Allen Simmons Joseph T. Jackson Willie Gary Kojo Soweto Ameen Malcom Omawale Abdullah Gerald Garner Quash A. Abbass A/K/A Charles James Lee A/K/A Rush Abdul B. Ali Abu Abbass Gregory L. Fennell Ras Kolonji Mutata Kafele Edward Bull Freddie Green Utamu Mfume Curtis A. Nicholas Jimmy L. Belton Kevin Smith Ras Njonjo Afi Khafre Frank J. Burgess Eddie L. Hall Steven Phillips Theodore Harrison, Jr. Kevin Smith Roderick Dennis Folks Llewellyn Nelson Lummie Hearins Shaka MacUmba Zulu X A/K/A Michael W. Montgomery Gregory Campbell Gregg L. Ray Rufus Muldrow Khayri Abdullah Muhammad Derrell Edwards Donald Lloyd Timothy C. Baker Ahmad M. Mujihadin A/K/A Robert Frost Tafara Moyenda A/K/A Robert Frost Jerome Williams Elvis C. Taylor Everton Bin Crosby William J. Copeland Owen Henderson Charles Sergio Hagler, Jr. Colville Brissett Ahmad Kans Abdul Sattar Marchs A. Joseph Mikail Abdullah Ronnie Brightman Terry Michael Cassell, and Tommy E. Blackmon William Whaley Reginald R. Ferguson Michael Campbell Van Tyler, Jr. Ismail Abdur Rashid Mack Allen Davis, and United States of America, Intervenor v. South Carolina Department of Corrections State of South Carolina David Beasley, Governor Michael Moore, Director, South Carolina Department of Corrections Omar Shaheed Terry Brooks Ralph Medlock Edsel T. Taylor, Warden Robert Ward, Warden Susan Hilton John W. Porter Ray Reese Yohance Moyenda Lt. Fnu Sgt. Fitts Deputy Warden McCants Warden Montgomery Bernard Walker, Deputy Warden Marvin T. Jarrett Riley James Ricardo Grant Yasin Abdul-Hakim Abreham Peoples James D. Robinson, Asu Supervisor Geraldine Miro, Warden Laurie Bessinger, Warden Chaplain Scotland J.P. Hall Glynn Sherman, Chaplain Jim Beam, Warden Oscar Faulkenberry C.J. Cepak, Warden Vaughn Jackson William Weldon, Warden William Davis, Warden George Martin, Iii, Warden Tony Strawhorn Sam D. O'Kelley Milan O'BradOvich Elaine Robinson, Deputy Warden Joseph Black, Deputy Warden Philip McLeod Larry Batson Clarence Benjamin R. Woodberry Fred Thompson Officer Martin N. McLendon Irc Brown R. Adams Morris Elmore John Pate Paul Butler John Maxey J.D. Wessinger Frank Maddox Sergeant Casey T. White Correctional Officer Manigo W. Richardson E. Spigner R. Rice P. Little Correctional Officer Lee S. Chisholm N. McFadden S. Muhammad Gary Butts Six Unknown Correctional Officers, in "Riot" Unit Bobby Rutherford James Savage Richard Bundrick Natalie Williams William Martin Terrel Cannon, Sr. W. Richardson Reggie Rouse Dr. Boolware, Clarence Hines John Cooke Wilson Orlando Brinson Khalil Kasson Ali Al-Munin Coy S. Gunter Lumumba Mumia Tafari-I A/K/A Lummie Hearns Malik Baqi Tahrim Supreme C. Jihad Kenneth Washington Salaam A. Hakim A/K/A Michael Bailey Zakariya Abdul Shahid Ray Charles Degraffenreid Maurice Livingston Demarcus Marshall Hakim Sabur Muhammad Ras Kolonji Muata Kafele Willie James Asbury Mustafa Abdullah A. Al-Mujahid John Michael Gladney Davis Young Bruce Scott Chris Lefever Dashel Strobert Vincent Kemp Larry Bobean Royce Maurice Collins John Brinson Gary L. Moore Jame A. Khaliq Lester Young Philip H. Tanner Michael Landry Donchell Wade Blatch William R. Smith Mark T. Larsen Kahim Khamil Muhammad Adrian Hicks Matin Abdul Ali Muntaqim A/K/A Marshall L. Land Yusuf Ahmad Abdullah Muhammad Heyward Harrison, Jr. Barry Alan Fowler Raheem Abdullah Al-Raqib James B. Patterson Don Eric Robertson Tyrone Mitchell Omar Abdel Al Numit A/K/A John James Bell Cecil Allen Simmons Joseph T. Jackson Willie Gary Kojo Soweto Ameen Malcom Omawale Abdullah Gerald Garner Quash A. Abbass A/K/A Charles James Lee A/K/A Rush Abdul B. Ali Abu Abbass Gregory L. Fennell Ras Kolonji Mutata Kafele Edward Bull Freddie Green Utamu Mfume Curtis A. Nicholas Jimmy L. Belton Kevin Smith Ras Njonjo Afi Khafre Frank J. Burgess Eddie L. Hall Steven Phillips Theodore Harrison, Jr. Kevin Smith Roderick Dennis Folks Llewellyn Nelson Lummie Hearins Shaka MacUmba Zulu X A/K/A Michael W. Montgomery Gregory Campbell Gregg L. Ray Rufus Muldrow Khayri Abdullah Muhammad Derrell Edwards Donald Lloyd Timothy C. Baker Ahmad M. Mujihadin A/K/A Robert Frost Tafara Moyenda A/K/A Robert Frost Jerome Williams Elvis C. Taylor Everton Bin Crosby William J. Copeland Owen Henderson Charles Sergio Hagler, Jr. Colville Brissett Ahmad Kans Abdul Sattar Marchs A. Joseph Mikail Abdullah Ronnie Brightman Terry Michael Cassell, and Tommy E. Blackmon William Whaley Reginald R. Ferguson Michael Campbell Van Tyler, Jr. Ismail Abdur Rashid Mack Allen Davis, and United States of America, Intervenor-Appellee v. Edsel T. Taylor, Warden Robert Ward, Warden James Robinson, Asu Supervisor Geraldine Miro, Warden Laurie Bessinger, Warden Chaplain Scotland J.P. Hall Glynn Sherman, Chaplain Jim Beam, Warden Oscar Faulkenberry C.J. Cepak, Warden Vaughn Jackson William Weldon, Warden William Davis, Warden George Martin, III Tony Strawhorn Sam D. O'Kelley Milan O'BradOvich Elaine Robinson, Deputy Warden Joseph Black, Deputy Warden Philip McLeod Larry Batson Clarence Benjamin R. Woodberry Fred Thompson Officer Martin N. McLendon Irc Brown R. Adams Morris Elmore John Pate Paul Butler John Maxey J.D. Wessinger Frank Maddox Sergeant Casey T. White Correctional Officer Manigo W. Richardson E. Spigner R. Rice P. Little Correctional Officer Lee S. Chisholm N. McFadden S. Muhammad Gary Butts Six Unknown Correctional Officers in "Riot" Unit Bobby Rutherford James Savage Richard Bundrick Natalie Williams William Martin Terrel Cannon, Sr. W. Richardson Reggie Rouse Dr. Boolware Susan Hilton John W. Porter Ray Reese Yohance Moyenda Lt. Fnu Sgt. Fitts Deputy Warden McCants Warden Montgomery Bernard Walker, Deputy Warden Marvin T. Jarrett Riley James Ricardo Grant Yasin Abdul-Hakim Abreham Peoples, and South Carolina Department of Corrections State of South Carolina David Beasley, Governor Michael Moore, Director, South Carolina Department of Corrections Omar Shaheed Terry Brooks Ralph Medlock
148 F.3d 353 (Fourth Circuit, 1998)
Hines v. South Carolina Department of Corrections
148 F.3d 353 (Fourth Circuit, 1998)
In re: Civil Rights v.
Fourth Circuit, 1998
Greenhut v. Hand
996 F. Supp. 372 (D. New Jersey, 1998)
Columbia Union College v. Clarke
988 F. Supp. 897 (D. Maryland, 1997)