American Insurance v. Yearick

78 Ind. 202

• Court: Indiana Supreme Court
• Decided: November 15, 1881
• Docket: No. 7716
• Status: Published

Opinion

Woods, J.

At the November term, 1877, of the circuit court, ■a demurrer was sustained to the appellant’s complaint. No exception was noted or taken to the ruling at the time when it was made, and no further step taken in the case until the following •September term, when the following order-book entry was made: “Come again the parties by counsel, and the plaintiff says he will not amend his complaint, but abides the demurrer, and ■excepts to the ruling of the court in sustaining the demurrer.”

The court thereupon gave judgment for the appellee, from which the plaintiff has appealed, and insists that the ruling upon the' demurrer was erroneous. The appellee, however, claims that an exception to the ruling has not been saved; and in this view we are constrained to concur. The rule of the code, R. S. 1881, section 626, is explicit, that an exception to any ruling of the court must be taken “at the time the decision is made and, reading sections 343 and 345 together, it is plain .that the rule is, in this respect, the same, whether the exception must be saved by a bill of exceptions, or by “ causing it to be noted at the end of the decision.”

However technical the rule may seem to be as applied to the case in hand, it is nevertheless the rule, and, in its general ■application, unquestionably salutary; and we can not undertake to create and define exceptions to it. ^

The judgment is affirmed, with costs.