Amer Federation of State County & Municipal Employees Council 93 v. City of South Portland

• Court: Superior Court of Maine
• Decided: September 5, 2014
• Docket: CUMcv-14-271
• Status: Unpublished

Opinion

f NI { RE0 SEP 2 3 2014

STATE OF MAINE SUPERIOR COURT CUMBERLAND, ss. CIVIL ACTION Docket No. CV-14-271

AMERICAN FEDERATION OF CUf'Vl---WW- ~ -D5-1 Y. STATE, COUNTY AND MUNICIPAL EMPLOYEES COUNCIL 93

Plaintiff

v. ORDER

CITY OF SOUTH PORTLAND,

Defendant

Before the court is a motion by plaintiff AFSCME Council 93 to confirm an arbitration

award entered against the City of South Portland.

There is no dispute between the parties that AFSCME prevailed in the arbitration. In its

decision the arbitration panel ruled that that AFSCME's grievance was granted and that the City

"shall post available overtime opportunities in the PWD [Public Works Department]" 1 and that

the City "shall provide training to interested bargaining unit members on the preparation and

grooming functions at Wainwright Athletic fields." Maine Board of Arbitration and Conciliation

Award dated May 12, 2013. However, the arbitration decision did not award any back pay or

other monetary relief.

AFSCME's motion to confirm seeks a proceeding "to judicially confirm the Union's

calculation of back pay" or to remand the case back to the Board for it to independently calculate

the amount of back pay.

The City correctly argues that AFSCME is not seeking the court to confirm the

arbitration award but is actually seeking to have the court modify the award to include a

1 It is apparent from the arbitration decision that the overtime opportunities that must be posted involve overtime opportunities at the Wainwright Athletic Field. monetary remedy that, for whatever reason, the arbitration panel did not award. This conclusion

is supported by the fact that on September 30, 2013 - approximately 141 days after the

arbitration decision was issued - AFSCME submitted a request to the arbitration panel to clarify

its May 12, 2013 award to include monetary relief. That request was denied by the Board on the

ground that AFSCME had not sought to clarify the award within the 20 day period specified in

14 M.R.S. § 5935, nor had it moved to modify or correct the award within the 90 days specified

in 14 M.R.S. § 5939(1).

Where the arbitration panel has expressly declined to modify or "clarify" its award to

include monetary relief, the court has no authority to substitute its judgment .for that of the

arbitration panel. Maine State Employees Ass'n Local 1989 v. State Department of Corrections,

593 A.2d 650, 653 (Me. 1991). Moreover, while the court can remand a decision to an arbitration

panel for clarification if an arbitration award is ambiguous, the award in this case is not

ambiguous- it clearly sets forth the non-monetary relief awarded and clearly omits any back pay

or other monetary relief.

The entry shall be:

Plaintiffs motion to confirm the arbitration award is granted in part and denied in part.

Plaintiffs motion to confirm the arbitration award by adding monetary relief in the form of back

pay is denied. The arbitration award is confirmed as entered, and the court therefore orders:

1. that the City of South Portland shall post available overtime opportunities at the

Wainwright Athletic Fields in the Public Works Department.

2. that the City shall provide training to interested bargaining unit members on the

preparation and grooming functions at the Wainwright Athletic fields.

The clerk is directed to incorporate this order in the docket by reference pursuant to Rule 79(a).

2 Dated: September s-, 2014 ~homasD~VV~en Justice, Superior Court

3 CLE~K OF COURTS Cumberland County 205 Newbury Street, Gmund Floqr Portlard, ME 041 01

SHAWN SULLIVAN ESQ LAW OFFICES OF SHAWN SULLIVAN 9) C...~ "'.;·, ~ ~ ~~ 10 FERRY STREET BOX 12 SUITE 317 CONCORD NH 03301

CLERK. OF COURTS Cumberland County 205 Newbury Street, Ground Floor Portland, ME 041 01

CHRISTOPHER TAINTOR ESQ . ~~()o\a_"t·~ NORMAN HANSON & DETROY '-/ PO BOX 4600 PORTLAND ME 04112-4600