Alley v. Bell
Opinion
5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH
(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21 )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
YLUWXDOO\ QR SUHSDUDWLRQ IDLOHG WR SUHVHQW DQ\ RI WKLV )LOH 1DPH DS
LQIRUPDWLRQDW*OHQQjVVHQWHQFLQJKHDULQJDQGIDLOHGHYHQWR UHTXHVWDSSRLQWPHQWRIPHGLFDOH[SHUWVXQWLOQLQHGD\VEHIRUH *OHQQjVKHDULQJ,GDW ,QWKHSUHVHQWFDVH$OOH\jV 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 ODZ\HUVHQJDJHGLQH[WHQVLYHSUHSDUDWLRQDQGLQYHVWLJDWLRQ )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 LQFOXGLQJWHVWLQJ$OOH\IRURUJDQLFEUDLQGDPDJH DQGWKH\ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB IRXQGDQGSUHVHQWHGDJUHDWGHDORIHYLGHQFHDQGWHVWLPRQ\ DERXW$OOH\jVPHQWDOVWDWHDQGPHGLFDOSDVW 7KLVSDQHOVLPSO\FDQQRWKROGLQWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVWKDW 6('/(< $//(< ; LWZDVREMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHIRUWKHVWDWHFRXUWWRKROGWKDW 3HWLWLRQHU$SSHOODQW WKHLQYHVWLJDWLRQDQGSUHVHQWDWLRQRI$OOH\jVPHGLFDOKLVWRU\ XQGHUWDNHQ E\ $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V GLG QRW IDOO mEHORZ DQ 1R REMHFWLYHVWDQGDUGRIUHDVRQDEOHQHVVl6WULFNODQG86 Y DW$FFRUGLQJO\ZHDIILUPWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHQLDO ! RI$OOH\jVKDEHDVSHWLWLRQRQWKLVLVVXH 5,&.< %(// 5HVSRQGHQW$SSHOOHH ,,, 1 )RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZH$)),50WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjV $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW GHQLDORI$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV IRUWKH:HVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI7HQQHVVHHDW0HPSKLV 1R n%HUQLFH%'RQDOG'LVWULFWsXGJH $UJXHG sXO\ 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG 2FWREHU %HIRUH 5<$1%2**6DQG%$7&+(/'(5&LUFXLW sXGJHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ $5*8(' 3DXO 5 %RWWHL )('(5$/ 38%/,& '()(1'(5j62)),&(1DVKYLOOH7HQQHVVHHIRU$SSHOODQW sRVHSK ) :KDOHQ ,,, 2)),&( 2) 7+( $77251(< *(1(5$/ 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH IRU $SSHOOHH 21 %5,() 3DXO 5 %RWWHL )('(5$/ 38%/,& '()(1'(5j6 2)),&( 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH 5REHUW / +XWWRQ*/$1./(5 %52:10HPSKLV7HQQHVVHHIRU
$OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
$SSHOODQW sRVHSK ) :KDOHQ ,,, 2)),&( 2) 7+( LQYHVWLJDWLRQ DQG SUHVHQWDWLRQ RI $OOH\jV PHGLFDO KLVWRU\ $77251(< *(1(5$/ 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH IRU XQGHUWDNHQ E\ $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V GLG QRW IDOO mEHORZ DQ $SSHOOHH REMHFWLYHVWDQGDUGRIUHDVRQDEOHQHVVl6WULFNODQG86 DW 6HH %HOO Y &RQH 6 &W BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB mXQGHU G LWLVQRWHQRXJKWRFRQYLQFHDIHGHUDO KDEHDVFRXUWWKDWLQLWVLQGHSHQGHQWMXGJPHQWWKHVWDWHFRXUW 23,1,21 GHFLVLRQDSSOLHG6WULFNODQGLQFRUUHFWO\5DWKHU>SHWLWLRQHU@ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB PXVWVKRZWKDWWKH>VWDWHFRXUW@DSSOLHG6WULFNODQGWRWKHIDFWV RIKLVFDVHLQDQREMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHPDQQHUl FLWDWLRQ %2**6 &LUFXLW sXGJH 3HWLWLRQHU 6HGOH\ $OOH\ ZDV RPLWWHG FRQYLFWHGRIWKH NLGQDSSLQJUDSHDQGPXUGHURI8QLWHG 6WDWHV0DULQH&RUSV/DQFH&RUSRUDO6X]DQQH0DULH&ROOLQV 8QGLVSXWHGWHVWLPRQ\HOLFLWHGE\WKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWVKRZV DQG ZDV VHQWHQFHG WR GHDWK +LV FRQYLFWLRQ DQG VHQWHQFH WKDWWKHDWWRUQH\VLQWKLVFDVHVRXJKWRXWGHWDLOVRI$OOH\jV ZHUHDIILUPHGRQGLUHFWDSSHDODQG$OOH\ZDVGHQLHGUHOLHILQ PHGLFDO KLVWRU\ IURP WKH SHRSOH ZKR NQHZ KLP EHVW DQG VWDWHSRVWFRQYLFWLRQSURFHHGLQJV$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQIRUIHGHUDO SDVVHG DOO RI WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ WKH\ UHFHLYHG RQ WR PHGLFDO KDEHDVUHOLHIILOHGSXUVXDQWWR86&ZDVGHQLHG H[SHUWVWKH\KDGKLUHGWRH[DPLQH$OOH\DQGDVVLVWLQWKHFDVH E\WKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUWIRUWKH:HVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI :KHQWKH\ZHUHWROGRI$OOH\jVFKLOGKRRGKHDGLQMXU\WKH\ 7HQQHVVHHLQDQH[KDXVWLYHDQGZHOOUHDVRQHGRSLQLRQ)RU RUGHUHG QHXURORJLFDO WHVWLQJ ZKLFK FDPH EDFN QHJDWLYH WKH UHDVRQV KHUHLQ ZH DIILUP WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHQLDO RI )XUWKHU $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V SUHVHQWHG HYLGHQFH RQ WKH $OOH\jVSHWLWLRQ FRQGLWLRQV$OOH\SURIIHUHGZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHDOOHJHG ELUWKGHIHFWV:LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHELUWKUHFRUGVDVPHQWLRQHG , EHIRUH$OOH\jVIDPLO\QHYHULQIRUPHGWKHDWWRUQH\VDERXWDQ\ SUREOHPV DW ELUWK DQG WKH PHGLFDO H[SHUWV LQYROYHG LQ WKH $OOH\ D FLYLOLDQ PDUULHG WR D PLOLWDU\ SHUVRQ DEGXFWHG FDVHQHYHUDVNHGIRUELUWKUHFRUGV QLQHWHHQ\HDU ROG /DQFH &RUSRUDO &ROOLQV ZKLOH VKH ZDV MRJJLQJQHDU0LOOLQJWRQ1DYDO%DVHLQ0LOOLQJWRQ7HQQHVVHH ,Q DUJXLQJ WKDW WKLV SDQHO VKRXOG ILQG WKH VWDWH FRXUWjV ODWH LQ WKH HYHQLQJ RI sXO\ +H DWWDFNHG DQG UHMHFWLRQRI$OOH\jVLQHIIHFWLYHQHVVDUJXPHQWDQXQUHDVRQDEOH PXUGHUHGKHUDQGOHIWKHUERG\LQDILHOG DSSOLFDWLRQRI6WULFNODQG$OOH\SRLQWVWRWKLVFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQ LQ*OHQQY7DWH)G WK&LU +RZHYHUWKLV 7ZR PDULQHV MRJJLQJ QHDU ZKHUH &ROOLQV ZDV DEGXFWHG FDVHGRHVQRWKHOS$OOH\)LUVW*OHQQZDVQRWGHFLGHGXQGHU KHDUG&ROOLQVVFUHDPDQGUDQWRZDUGWKHVRXQG+RZHYHU WKH $('3$ VWDQGDUG RI UHYLHZ ZKLFK VHUYHV WR UHVWULFW EHIRUHWKH\UHDFKHGWKHVFHQHWKH\VDZ$OOH\jVFDUGULYHRII JUHDWO\WKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVXQGHUZKLFKIHGHUDOFRXUWVFDQJUDQW 7KH\UHSRUWHGWREDVHVHFXULW\DQGDFFRPSDQLHGRIILFHUVRQ D ZULW RI KDEHDV FRUSXV 6HFRQG WKH IDFWV RI *OHQQ D WRXU RI WKH EDVH ORRNLQJ IRU WKH FDU WKH\ KDG VHHQ VLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUIURPWKRVHRIWKHSUHVHQWFDVH,Q*OHQQ 8QVXFFHVVIXOWKH\UHWXUQHGWRWKHLUEDUUDFNV WKHSHWLWLRQHUZDVFRQYLFWHGRIPXUGHULQJDVKHULIIjVGHSXW\ 6RRQDIWHUUHWXUQLQJWRWKHLUTXDUWHUVKRZHYHUWKHPDULQHV ZKLOHWU\LQJWREUHDNKLVROGHUEURWKHURXWRIMDLO,GDW ZHUHFDOOHGEDFNWRWKHVHFXULW\RIILFHZKHUHWKH\LGHQWLILHG 7KH SHWLWLRQHU VXIIHUHG RUJDQLF EUDLQ GDPDJH SULRU WR $OOH\jVFDUZKLFKKDGEHHQVWRSSHGE\RIILFHUV$OOH\DQG ELUWKZDVFODVVLILHGDVPHQWDOO\UHWDUGHGDQGZDVFRQVLGHUHG KLV ZLIH JDYH VWDWHPHQWV WR WKH EDVH VHFXULW\ SHUVRQQHO DV D UHVXOW FRPSOHWHO\ XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI KLV ROGHU DFFRXQWLQJ IRU WKHLU ZKHUHDERXWV 7KH VHFXULW\ SHUVRQQHO EURWKHU,GDW+RZHYHU*OHQQjVODZ\HUVHQJDJHGLQ $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
WHVWLPRQ\ DW WKH WULDO FRXUW KHDULQJ VXJJHVWHG WKDW WKHVH ZHUH VDWLVILHG ZLWK $OOH\jV VWRU\ DQG $OOH\ DQG KLV ZLIH UHFRUGVZHUHQRWUHJXODUO\VRXJKW,GDW UHWXUQHGWRWKHLURQEDVHKRXVLQJ 7KH VWDWH WULDO FRXUW DIWHU YLHZLQJ WKH UHFRUGV DQG &ROOLQVjVERG\ZDVIRXQGDIHZKRXUVODWHUDQG$OOH\ZDV LQIRUPDWLRQSURIIHUHGE\$OOH\DQGKHDULQJWKHWHVWLPRQ\RI LPPHGLDWHO\DUUHVWHGE\PLOLWDU\SROLFH+HYROXQWDULO\JDYH DOO RI WKH H[SHUWV FRQFOXGHG WKDW $OOH\jV WULDO FRXQVHO KDG DVWDWHPHQWWRWKHSROLFHDGPLWWLQJWRKDYLQJNLOOHG&ROOLQV VXIILFLHQWO\ LQYHVWLJDWHG DQG SUHVHQWHG $OOH\jV PHGLFDO EXW JLYLQJ D VXEVWDQWLDOO\ IDOVH o DQG FRQVLGHUDEO\ PRUH KLVWRU\$OOH\1R3VOLSRSDW 7KHFRXUWQRWHG KXPDQHoDFFRXQWRIWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVRIWKHNLOOLQJ WKDW DOO RI WKH H[SHUWV ZKR WHVWLILHG DW WULDO IRU ERWK VLGHV DJUHHG WKDW WKH PHGLFDO UHFRUGV $OOH\ SURIIHUHG ZRXOG QRW $OOH\ZDVFRQYLFWHGRQ0DUFK RIPXUGHULQWKH KDYHFKDQJHGWKHLUFRQFOXVLRQV,GDW)XUWKHUWKHFRXUW ILUVW GHJUHH DQG ZDV VHQWHQFHG WR GHDWK +H ZDV DOVR H[SODLQHG WKDW m>
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
5(&200(1'(' )25 )8//7(;7 38%/,&$7,21 $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 3XUVXDQW WR 6L[WK &LUFXLW 5XOH
(/(&7521,& &,7$7,21 )(' $SS 3 WK &LU
YLUWXDOO\ QR SUHSDUDWLRQ IDLOHG WR SUHVHQW DQ\ RI WKLV )LOH 1DPH DS
LQIRUPDWLRQDW*OHQQjVVHQWHQFLQJKHDULQJDQGIDLOHGHYHQWR UHTXHVWDSSRLQWPHQWRIPHGLFDOH[SHUWVXQWLOQLQHGD\VEHIRUH *OHQQjVKHDULQJ,GDW ,QWKHSUHVHQWFDVH$OOH\jV 81,7('67$7(6&28572)$33($/6 ODZ\HUVHQJDJHGLQH[WHQVLYHSUHSDUDWLRQDQGLQYHVWLJDWLRQ )257+(6,;7+&,5&8,7 LQFOXGLQJWHVWLQJ$OOH\IRURUJDQLFEUDLQGDPDJH DQGWKH\ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB IRXQGDQGSUHVHQWHGDJUHDWGHDORIHYLGHQFHDQGWHVWLPRQ\ DERXW$OOH\jVPHQWDOVWDWHDQGPHGLFDOSDVW 7KLVSDQHOVLPSO\FDQQRWKROGLQWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVWKDW 6('/(< $//(< ; LWZDVREMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHIRUWKHVWDWHFRXUWWRKROGWKDW 3HWLWLRQHU$SSHOODQW WKHLQYHVWLJDWLRQDQGSUHVHQWDWLRQRI$OOH\jVPHGLFDOKLVWRU\ XQGHUWDNHQ E\ $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V GLG QRW IDOO mEHORZ DQ 1R REMHFWLYHVWDQGDUGRIUHDVRQDEOHQHVVl6WULFNODQG86 Y DW$FFRUGLQJO\ZHDIILUPWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHQLDO ! RI$OOH\jVKDEHDVSHWLWLRQRQWKLVLVVXH 5,&.< %(// 5HVSRQGHQW$SSHOOHH ,,, 1 )RUWKHIRUHJRLQJUHDVRQVZH$)),50WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjV $SSHDOIURPWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUW GHQLDORI$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV IRUWKH:HVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI7HQQHVVHHDW0HPSKLV 1R n%HUQLFH%'RQDOG'LVWULFWsXGJH $UJXHG sXO\ 'HFLGHGDQG)LOHG 2FWREHU %HIRUH 5<$1%2**6DQG%$7&+(/'(5&LUFXLW sXGJHV BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB &2816(/ $5*8(' 3DXO 5 %RWWHL )('(5$/ 38%/,& '()(1'(5j62)),&(1DVKYLOOH7HQQHVVHHIRU$SSHOODQW sRVHSK ) :KDOHQ ,,, 2)),&( 2) 7+( $77251(< *(1(5$/ 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH IRU $SSHOOHH 21 %5,() 3DXO 5 %RWWHL )('(5$/ 38%/,& '()(1'(5j6 2)),&( 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH 5REHUW / +XWWRQ*/$1./(5 %52:10HPSKLV7HQQHVVHHIRU
$OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
$SSHOODQW sRVHSK ) :KDOHQ ,,, 2)),&( 2) 7+( LQYHVWLJDWLRQ DQG SUHVHQWDWLRQ RI $OOH\jV PHGLFDO KLVWRU\ $77251(< *(1(5$/ 1DVKYLOOH 7HQQHVVHH IRU XQGHUWDNHQ E\ $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V GLG QRW IDOO mEHORZ DQ $SSHOOHH REMHFWLYHVWDQGDUGRIUHDVRQDEOHQHVVl6WULFNODQG86 DW 6HH %HOO Y &RQH 6 &W BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB mXQGHU G LWLVQRWHQRXJKWRFRQYLQFHDIHGHUDO KDEHDVFRXUWWKDWLQLWVLQGHSHQGHQWMXGJPHQWWKHVWDWHFRXUW 23,1,21 GHFLVLRQDSSOLHG6WULFNODQGLQFRUUHFWO\5DWKHU>SHWLWLRQHU@ BBBBBBBBBBBBBBBBB PXVWVKRZWKDWWKH>VWDWHFRXUW@DSSOLHG6WULFNODQGWRWKHIDFWV RIKLVFDVHLQDQREMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHPDQQHUl FLWDWLRQ %2**6 &LUFXLW sXGJH 3HWLWLRQHU 6HGOH\ $OOH\ ZDV RPLWWHG FRQYLFWHGRIWKH NLGQDSSLQJUDSHDQGPXUGHURI8QLWHG 6WDWHV0DULQH&RUSV/DQFH&RUSRUDO6X]DQQH0DULH&ROOLQV 8QGLVSXWHGWHVWLPRQ\HOLFLWHGE\WKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWVKRZV DQG ZDV VHQWHQFHG WR GHDWK +LV FRQYLFWLRQ DQG VHQWHQFH WKDWWKHDWWRUQH\VLQWKLVFDVHVRXJKWRXWGHWDLOVRI$OOH\jV ZHUHDIILUPHGRQGLUHFWDSSHDODQG$OOH\ZDVGHQLHGUHOLHILQ PHGLFDO KLVWRU\ IURP WKH SHRSOH ZKR NQHZ KLP EHVW DQG VWDWHSRVWFRQYLFWLRQSURFHHGLQJV$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQIRUIHGHUDO SDVVHG DOO RI WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ WKH\ UHFHLYHG RQ WR PHGLFDO KDEHDVUHOLHIILOHGSXUVXDQWWR86&ZDVGHQLHG H[SHUWVWKH\KDGKLUHGWRH[DPLQH$OOH\DQGDVVLVWLQWKHFDVH E\WKH8QLWHG6WDWHV'LVWULFW&RXUWIRUWKH:HVWHUQ'LVWULFWRI :KHQWKH\ZHUHWROGRI$OOH\jVFKLOGKRRGKHDGLQMXU\WKH\ 7HQQHVVHHLQDQH[KDXVWLYHDQGZHOOUHDVRQHGRSLQLRQ)RU RUGHUHG QHXURORJLFDO WHVWLQJ ZKLFK FDPH EDFN QHJDWLYH WKH UHDVRQV KHUHLQ ZH DIILUP WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHQLDO RI )XUWKHU $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V SUHVHQWHG HYLGHQFH RQ WKH $OOH\jVSHWLWLRQ FRQGLWLRQV$OOH\SURIIHUHGZLWKWKHH[FHSWLRQRIWKHDOOHJHG ELUWKGHIHFWV:LWKUHVSHFWWRWKHELUWKUHFRUGVDVPHQWLRQHG , EHIRUH$OOH\jVIDPLO\QHYHULQIRUPHGWKHDWWRUQH\VDERXWDQ\ SUREOHPV DW ELUWK DQG WKH PHGLFDO H[SHUWV LQYROYHG LQ WKH $OOH\ D FLYLOLDQ PDUULHG WR D PLOLWDU\ SHUVRQ DEGXFWHG FDVHQHYHUDVNHGIRUELUWKUHFRUGV QLQHWHHQ\HDU ROG /DQFH &RUSRUDO &ROOLQV ZKLOH VKH ZDV MRJJLQJQHDU0LOOLQJWRQ1DYDO%DVHLQ0LOOLQJWRQ7HQQHVVHH ,Q DUJXLQJ WKDW WKLV SDQHO VKRXOG ILQG WKH VWDWH FRXUWjV ODWH LQ WKH HYHQLQJ RI sXO\ +H DWWDFNHG DQG UHMHFWLRQRI$OOH\jVLQHIIHFWLYHQHVVDUJXPHQWDQXQUHDVRQDEOH PXUGHUHGKHUDQGOHIWKHUERG\LQDILHOG DSSOLFDWLRQRI6WULFNODQG$OOH\SRLQWVWRWKLVFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQ LQ*OHQQY7DWH)G WK&LU +RZHYHUWKLV 7ZR PDULQHV MRJJLQJ QHDU ZKHUH &ROOLQV ZDV DEGXFWHG FDVHGRHVQRWKHOS$OOH\)LUVW*OHQQZDVQRWGHFLGHGXQGHU KHDUG&ROOLQVVFUHDPDQGUDQWRZDUGWKHVRXQG+RZHYHU WKH $('3$ VWDQGDUG RI UHYLHZ ZKLFK VHUYHV WR UHVWULFW EHIRUHWKH\UHDFKHGWKHVFHQHWKH\VDZ$OOH\jVFDUGULYHRII JUHDWO\WKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVXQGHUZKLFKIHGHUDOFRXUWVFDQJUDQW 7KH\UHSRUWHGWREDVHVHFXULW\DQGDFFRPSDQLHGRIILFHUVRQ D ZULW RI KDEHDV FRUSXV 6HFRQG WKH IDFWV RI *OHQQ D WRXU RI WKH EDVH ORRNLQJ IRU WKH FDU WKH\ KDG VHHQ VLJQLILFDQWO\GLIIHUIURPWKRVHRIWKHSUHVHQWFDVH,Q*OHQQ 8QVXFFHVVIXOWKH\UHWXUQHGWRWKHLUEDUUDFNV WKHSHWLWLRQHUZDVFRQYLFWHGRIPXUGHULQJDVKHULIIjVGHSXW\ 6RRQDIWHUUHWXUQLQJWRWKHLUTXDUWHUVKRZHYHUWKHPDULQHV ZKLOHWU\LQJWREUHDNKLVROGHUEURWKHURXWRIMDLO,GDW ZHUHFDOOHGEDFNWRWKHVHFXULW\RIILFHZKHUHWKH\LGHQWLILHG 7KH SHWLWLRQHU VXIIHUHG RUJDQLF EUDLQ GDPDJH SULRU WR $OOH\jVFDUZKLFKKDGEHHQVWRSSHGE\RIILFHUV$OOH\DQG ELUWKZDVFODVVLILHGDVPHQWDOO\UHWDUGHGDQGZDVFRQVLGHUHG KLV ZLIH JDYH VWDWHPHQWV WR WKH EDVH VHFXULW\ SHUVRQQHO DV D UHVXOW FRPSOHWHO\ XQGHU WKH LQIOXHQFH RI KLV ROGHU DFFRXQWLQJ IRU WKHLU ZKHUHDERXWV 7KH VHFXULW\ SHUVRQQHO EURWKHU,GDW+RZHYHU*OHQQjVODZ\HUVHQJDJHGLQ $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
WHVWLPRQ\ DW WKH WULDO FRXUW KHDULQJ VXJJHVWHG WKDW WKHVH ZHUH VDWLVILHG ZLWK $OOH\jV VWRU\ DQG $OOH\ DQG KLV ZLIH UHFRUGVZHUHQRWUHJXODUO\VRXJKW,GDW UHWXUQHGWRWKHLURQEDVHKRXVLQJ 7KH VWDWH WULDO FRXUW DIWHU YLHZLQJ WKH UHFRUGV DQG &ROOLQVjVERG\ZDVIRXQGDIHZKRXUVODWHUDQG$OOH\ZDV LQIRUPDWLRQSURIIHUHGE\$OOH\DQGKHDULQJWKHWHVWLPRQ\RI LPPHGLDWHO\DUUHVWHGE\PLOLWDU\SROLFH+HYROXQWDULO\JDYH DOO RI WKH H[SHUWV FRQFOXGHG WKDW $OOH\jV WULDO FRXQVHO KDG DVWDWHPHQWWRWKHSROLFHDGPLWWLQJWRKDYLQJNLOOHG&ROOLQV VXIILFLHQWO\ LQYHVWLJDWHG DQG SUHVHQWHG $OOH\jV PHGLFDO EXW JLYLQJ D VXEVWDQWLDOO\ IDOVH o DQG FRQVLGHUDEO\ PRUH KLVWRU\$OOH\1R3VOLSRSDW 7KHFRXUWQRWHG KXPDQHoDFFRXQWRIWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVRIWKHNLOOLQJ WKDW DOO RI WKH H[SHUWV ZKR WHVWLILHG DW WULDO IRU ERWK VLGHV DJUHHG WKDW WKH PHGLFDO UHFRUGV $OOH\ SURIIHUHG ZRXOG QRW $OOH\ZDVFRQYLFWHGRQ0DUFK RIPXUGHULQWKH KDYHFKDQJHGWKHLUFRQFOXVLRQV,GDW)XUWKHUWKHFRXUW ILUVW GHJUHH DQG ZDV VHQWHQFHG WR GHDWK +H ZDV DOVR H[SODLQHG WKDW m>H@[FHSW IRU WKH ELUWK UHFRUGV PRVW RI WKH FRQYLFWHGRIDJJUDYDWHGNLGQDSSLQJDQGDJJUDYDWHGUDSHIRU UHFRUGV DERXW WKH SHWLWLRQHUjV LOOQHVVHV DQG VXUJHULHV ZKLFK KH UHFHLYHG FRQVHFXWLYH IRUW\\HDU VHQWHQFHV 7KH LQYROYLQJKLVNLGQH\VEODGGHUDQGSHQLVZHUHSUHVHQWHGWR 7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWDIILUPHG$OOH\jVFRQYLFWLRQDQG WKHMXU\LQ'UV%DWWOHDQG0DUVKDOOjVWHVWLPRQ\l,GDW VHQWHQFHRQGLUHFWDSSHDO6WDWHY$OOH\6:G 7HQQ 2Q SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ DSSHDO WKH 7HQQHVVHH &RXUW RI $OOH\ ILOHG D VWDWH SHWLWLRQ IRU SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ UHOLHI &ULPLQDO$SSHDOVXSKHOGWKHWULDOFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQ$OOH\ DOOHJLQJ QXPHURXV JURXQGV LQFOXGLQJ VHYHUDO FODLPV RI 6:GDW &LWLQJWKHVWDQGDUGIRUFRQVWLWXWLRQDOO\ MXGLFLDOELDVFKDOOHQJHVWRWKHWULDOFRXUWjVHYLGHQWLDU\UXOLQJV LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH RI FRXQVHO VHW RXW LQ 6WULFNODQG Y DQGFODLPVRILQHIIHFWLYHDVVLVWDQFHRIFRXQVHO7KHMXGJH :DVKLQJWRQ 86 WKH DSSHDOV FRXUW ZKRSUHVLGHGRYHU$OOH\jVWULDOKHOGVHYHUDOKHDULQJVRQWKH VRXJKWWRGHWHUPLQHZKHWKHU$OOH\KDGVKRZQWKDWKLVFRXQVHO SHWLWLRQEHIRUHGHQ\LQJLW2QDSSHDOWKH&RXUWRI&ULPLQDO KDGQRWUHQGHUHGUHDVRQDEO\HIIHFWLYHDVVLVWDQFHDQGZKHWKHU $SSHDOVYDFDWHGWKHGHQLDODQGLQUHVSRQVHWR$OOH\jVFODLPV $OOH\ KDG VXIIHUHG SUHMXGLFH IURP KLV FRXQVHOjV GHILFLHQW RIMXGLFLDOELDVUHPDQGHGWKHFDVHIRUDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJ SHUIRUPDQFH$OOH\ 6:GDW 7KHFRXUWRIDSSHDOV EHIRUHDGLIIHUHQWWULDOMXGJH$OOH\Y6WDWH6:G QRWHGWKDWm>W@KHWULDOFRXUWIRXQGWKDWWKHGHIHQVHDWWRUQH\V 7HQQ&ULP$SS ZHUHHIIHFWLYHLQWKHLUUHSUHVHQWDWLRQRIWKHSHWLWLRQHUl,ELG &LWLQJWHVWLPRQ\IURPWKHWULDOFRXUWWKHDSSHDOVFRXUWDJUHHG $QRWKHUWULDOMXGJHXQGHUWRRNDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJDQG ILQGLQJWKDWm>W@KHUHFRUGGHPRQVWUDWHVWKDWGHIHQVHFRXQVHO WKHQGHQLHG$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQ$OOH\Y6WDWH1R3VOLS VSHQWDJUHDWGHDORIWLPHLQWKHVHOHFWLRQDQGSUHSDUDWLRQRI RS 6KHOE\ &RXQW\ &ULP &W $XJ 7KLV WULDO7KHSHWLWLRQHUZDVH[DPLQHGE\VHYHUDOLQWKHPHGLFDO GLVSRVLWLRQZDVDIILUPHGE\WKH7HQQHVVHH&RXUWRI&ULPLQDO SURIHVVLRQl ,G DW 7KH FRXUW KHOG DFFRUGLQJO\ WKDW $SSHDOV DQG WKH 7HQQHVVHH 6XSUHPH &RXUW GHQLHG $OOH\ $OOH\KDGQRWEHHQGHQLHGHIIHFWLYHDVVLVWDQFH,GDW SHUPLVVLRQWRDSSHDO$OOH\Y6WDWH 6:G 7HQQ &ULP $SS SHUPLVVLRQ WR DSSHDO GHQLHG 7HQQ 7KH 7HQQHVVHH FRXUW KDYLQJ FRQVLGHUHG DQG DGMXGLFDWHG 6HSW $OOH\jV LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFH DUJXPHQW RQ WKH PHULWV DQG KDYLQJDSSOLHGWKH6WULFNODQGVWDQGDUGLQLWVDQDO\VLVWKHILUVW $OOH\ILOHGWKHSUHVHQWSHWLWLRQIRUKDEHDVFRUSXVLQGLVWULFW TXHVWLRQ IRU WKLV FRXUW XQGHU $('3$ LV ZKHWKHU LW ZDV FRXUWDQGWKHFRXUWGHQLHG$OOH\UHOLHI$OOH\Y%HOO) REMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHIRUWKHVWDWHFRXUWWRKROGWKDWWKH 6XSSG :'7HQQ 7KHUHDIWHU WKLV FRXUW JUDQWHG KLP D FHUWLILFDWH RI DSSHDODELOLW\ RQ WKH $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
IROORZLQJ ILYH LVVXHV ZKHWKHU $OOH\ ZDV GHQLHG GXH $OOH\UDLVHGWKLVLVVXHLQKLVSRVWFRQYLFWLRQSURFHHGLQJV SURFHVVEHFDXVHKHZDVWULHGE\DELDVHGMXGJH ZKHWKHU EHIRUHWKH7HQQHVVHH&RXUWRI$SSHDOVDQGWKLVZDVRQHRI H[SDUWHFRQWDFWVEHWZHHQWKHMXGJHDQGMXURUVLQ$OOH\jVFDVH WKHLVVXHVDGGUHVVHGDWWKHHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJKHOGLQWKHWULDO YLRODWHG KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKWV ZKHWKHU DW WKH JXLOW FRXUWDIWHUWKHFRXUWRIDSSHDOVUHPDQGHG$OOH\jVFDVH7KH SKDVH $OOH\ ZDV GHQLHG KLV ULJKW WR SUHVHQW D IXOO GHIHQVH WULDO MXGJH ZKR UHSODFHG sXGJH $[OH\ KHOG DQ H[WHQVLYH WKURXJKWKHXQFRQVWLWXWLRQDOH[FOXVLRQRISURRIWKDWKHVXIIHUV HYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJDQGXQGHUWRRNDGHWDLOHGDQDO\VLVRIWKH IURP PXOWLSOH SHUVRQDOLW\ GLVRUGHU ZKHWKHU DW WKH UHFRUG LQ WKH FDVH $OOH\jV UHOHYDQW DOOHJDWLRQV RI VHQWHQFLQJ SKDVH $OOH\ ZDV GHQLHG KLV ULJKW WR UHFHLYH LQHIIHFWLYHQHVVZHUHVXEVWDQWLDOO\WKHVDPHDVKHUDLVHVWRWKLV FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI PLWLJDWLQJ HYLGHQFH ZKHQ WKH WULDO FRXUW FRXUWo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jV DWWRUQH\V FRQGXFWHG D WKRURXJK $FWRI m$('3$l 3XE/1R6WDW LQYHVWLJDWLRQLQWR$OOH\jVKLVWRU\$OOH\ 6:GDW DIHGHUDOFRXUWPD\QRWJUDQWDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXV +LV DWWRUQH\V WHVWLILHG WKDW WKH\ LQWHUYLHZHG ZLWKUHVSHFWWRDQ\FODLPWKDWZDVDGMXGLFDWHGRQWKHPHULWV $OOH\jVVLVWHUPRWKHUDQGZLIHDERXW$OOH\jVFKLOGKRRGDQG LQ VWDWH FRXUW XQOHVV WKH VWDWH FRXUWjV DGMXGLFDWLRQ PHGLFDOKLVWRU\,GDW+LVIDPLO\SURYLGHGWKHDWWRUQH\V m UHVXOWHGLQDGHFLVLRQWKDWZDVFRQWUDU\WRRULQYROYHGDQ ZLWK LQIRUPDWLRQ UHJDUGLQJ $OOH\jV VWUDQJH EHKDYLRU DV D XQUHDVRQDEOHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHG)HGHUDOODZ FKLOG D GLYLQJ DFFLGHQW LQ ZKLFK $OOH\ VXVWDLQHG D KHDG DVGHWHUPLQHGE\WKH6XSUHPH&RXUWRIWKH8QLWHG6WDWHV RU LQMXU\DQGH[WHQVLYHXUHWKUDOEODGGHUDQGNLGQH\SUREOHPV UHVXOWHGLQDGHFLVLRQWKDWZDVEDVHGXSRQDQXQUHDVRQDEOH $OOH\VXIIHUHGDVDFKLOG,ELG+RZHYHUWKHIDPLO\GLGQRW GHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHIDFWVLQOLJKWRIWKHHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGLQ LQIRUP$OOH\jVDWWRUQH\VDERXWDQ\SUREOHPVDW$OOH\jVELUWK WKH6WDWHFRXUWSURFHHGLQJl86& G ,GDW $ VWDWH FRXUW GHFLVLRQ LV mFRQWUDU\ WRl 6XSUHPH &RXUW $OOH\jVDWWRUQH\VDUUDQJHGIRUKLPWRXQGHUJRQHXURORJLFDO SUHFHGHQWmLIWKHVWDWHFRXUWDUULYHVDWDFRQFOXVLRQRSSRVLWH H[DPLQDWLRQVZKLFKVKRZHGQRLQGLFDWLRQRIEUDLQGDPDJH WRWKDWUHDFKHGE\>WKH&RXUW@RQDTXHVWLRQRIODZlRUmLIWKH ,GDW)XUWKHU$OOH\jVDWWRUQH\VDUUDQJHGIRUKLPWREH VWDWHFRXUWFRQIURQWVIDFWVWKDWDUHPDWHULDOO\LQGLVWLQJXLVKDEOH H[DPLQHG E\ VHYHUDO PHGLFDO SURIHVVLRQDOV DQG $OOH\jV IURP D UHOHYDQW 6XSUHPH &RXUW SUHFHGHQW DQG DUULYHV DW D DWWRUQH\V SDVVHG RQ WR WKHP WKH LQIRUPDWLRQ DQG UHFRUGV UHVXOWRSSRVLWHWRlWKH&RXUWjVGHFLVLRQ:LOOLDPVY7D\ORU WKH\jGREWDLQHGRI$OOH\jVSDVWPHGLFDOKLVWRU\,ELG1RQH 86 $VWDWHFRXUWGHFLVLRQLQYROYHVDQ RI WKH PHGLFDO H[SHUWV FRQVXOWHG E\ $OOH\jV DWWRUQH\V mXQUHDVRQDEOH DSSOLFDWLRQl RI FOHDUO\ HVWDEOLVKHG 6XSUHPH VXJJHVWHG WKH QHHG IRU ELUWK UHFRUGV LELG DQG LQGHHG &RXUW SUHFHGHQW ZKHQ LW FRUUHFWO\ LGHQWLILHV WKH JRYHUQLQJ OHJDOVWDQGDUGEXWDSSOLHVLWWRWKHIDFWVRIWKHFDVHEHIRUHLWLQ DQREMHFWLYHO\XQUHDVRQDEOHPDQQHU,GDW )HGHUDOFRXUWVFDQRQO\FRQVLGHURQKDEHDVUHYLHZFODLPV WKHUHIRUH ZH DIILUP WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHQLDO RI $OOH\jV UHTXHVW IRU
WKDWDSHWLWLRQHUKDVILUVWUDLVHGEHIRUHWKHVWDWHFRXUWV6HH IXQGLQJ $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
EHFDXVHLWKHOGWKHWDSHVLUUHOHYDQWDQGXQUHOLDEOH)XUWKHUDV 86& E 6WDQIRUGY3DUNHU)G WK H[SODLQHGDERYHWKHFRXUWGLGQRWGRVREDVHGRQDSHUVH &LU m:KHUH D SHWLWLRQHU KDV QRW IXOO\ DQG IDLUO\ UXOH RU D PHFKDQLFDO DUELWUDU\ RU GLVSURSRUWLRQDWH SUHVHQWHGDIHGHUDOFODLPWRWKHVWDWH VKLJKHVWFRXUWD DSSOLFDWLRQRIDVWDWHUXOH7KHVWDWHFRXUWPD\KDYHHUUHGLQ IHGHUDOFRXUWRUGLQDULO\ZLOOQRWFRQVLGHUWKHPHULWVRIWKDW LWVZHLJKLQJ KRZHYHU$OOH\KDVVLPSO\QRWVKRZQWKDWWKLV FODLPl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m:KHQ D KDEHDV SHWLWLRQHU IDLOV WR REWDLQ SHQLV D GLVWRUWHG EODGGHU DEHUUDQW NLGQH\V DQG SUREOHPV FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI D FODLP E\ D VWDWH FRXUW GXH WR WKH $OOH\H[SHULHQFHGDWELUWK$OOH\DUJXHVWKDWKLVFRXQVHOjV SHWLWLRQHU VIDLOXUHWRUDLVHWKDWFODLPEHIRUHWKHVWDWHFRXUWV IDLOXUH WR LQYHVWLJDWH WKHVH FRQGLWLRQV IXUWKHU DQG SUHVHQW ZKLOHVWDWHFRXUWUHPHGLHVDUHVWLOODYDLODEOHWKDWFODLP HYLGHQFH RI WKHP WR WKH MXU\ IHOO EHORZ WKH VWDQGDUG RI LVSURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHGDQGPD\QRWEHFRQVLGHUHGE\WKH UHDVRQDEOHQHVVDQGWKDWKLVFRXQVHOjVIDLOXUHSUHMXGLFHGKLP IHGHUDO FRXUW RQ KDEHDV UHYLHZl ,Q RUGHU WR JDLQ LQ WKDW WKH MXU\ ZRXOG QRWKDYH VHQWHQFHG KLP WR GHDWK LI FRQVLGHUDWLRQ RI D FODLP WKDW LV SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG D WKH\jGNQRZQWKHVHWKLQJV SHWLWLRQHU PXVW GHPRQVWUDWH FDXVH DQG SUHMXGLFH IRU WKH IDLOXUHRUWKDWDPLVFDUULDJHRIMXVWLFHZLOOUHVXOWIURPWKH ODFNRIUHYLHZ:DLQZULJKW86DW 6H\PRXU )GDW $OOH\ UHODWHGO\ FKDOOHQJHV WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHQLDO RI KLV UHTXHVW
7KHVHUXOHVDSSO\ERWKWRHQWLUHO\QHZOHJDOFODLPVDQGQHZ IRU IXQGLQJ LQ RUGHU WR FRQGXFW EUDLQ DQG JHQHWLF WHVWV DLPHG DW JDUQHULQJ
IDFWXDO EDVHV IRU UHOLHI IRU D FODLP WR EH FRQVLGHUHG DGGLWLRQDO HYLGHQFH RI PHGLFDO LPSDLUPHQWV WKDW KLV WULDO DWWRUQH\V IDLOHG
WR LQYHVWLJDWH RU SUHVHQW 86& T ZKLFK DSSOLHV WR GHDWK
SHQDOW\HOLJLEOH FULPLQDO GHIHQGDQWV DQG KDEHDV SHWLWLRQHUV SURYLGHV H[KDXVWHGmWKHKDEHDVSHWLWLRQHUPXVWKDYHµIDLUO\SUHVHQWHGj 8SRQ D ILQGLQJ WKDW LQYHVWLJDWLYH H[SHUW RU RWKHU VHUYLFHV DUH WRWKHVWDWHFRXUWVWKHµVXEVWDQFHjRIKLVIHGHUDOKDEHDVFRUSXV UHDVRQDEO\ QHFHVVDU\ IRU WKH UHSUHVHQWDWLRQ RI WKH FODLPl$QGHUVRQY+DUOHVV 86 TXRWLQJ GHIHQGDQW WKH FRXUW PD\ DXWKRUL]H WKH GHIHQGDQW V DWWRUQH\V 3LFDUGY&RQQRU86 VHH DOVR:RQJY0RQH\)G WK&LU mWKH WR REWDLQ VXFK VHUYLFHV RQ EHKDOI RI WKH GHIHQGDQW DQG LI VR
DXWKRUL]HG VKDOO RUGHU WKH SD\PHQW RI IHHV DQG H[SHQVHV WKHUHIRU
GRFWULQHRIH[KDXVWLRQUHTXLUHVWKDWDFODLPEHSUHVHQWHGWR HPSKDVLV DGGHG WKH VWDWH FRXUWV XQGHU WKH VDPH WKHRU\ LQ ZKLFK LW LV ODWHU ,Q DQ RUGHU GHQ\LQJ $OOH\jV UHTXHVW IRU IXQGLQJ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW LQ WKLV SUHVHQWHGLQIHGHUDOFRXUWl FDVH KHOG WKDW IXQGLQJ IRU VXFK WHVWV ZDV QRW UHDVRQDEO\ QHFHVVDU\ IRU
$OOH\jV KDEHDV SHWLWLRQ EHFDXVH $OOH\ IDLOHG WR GHPRQVWUDWH KRZ WKH WHVWV
ZHUH UHOHYDQW WR WKH RQO\ TXHVWLRQ EHIRUH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW o mZKHWKHU WKH VWDWH FRXUWV UHDVRQDEO\ DSSOLHG IHGHUDO ODZ LQ KROGLQJ WKDW KLV WULDO FRXQVHO GLG QRW SURYLGH LQHIIHFWLYH DVVLVWDQFHl 7KLV KROGLQJ ZDV FOHDUO\ FRUUHFW $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
sXGLFLDO%LDV&ODLPV ,WLVFOHDUWKDWWKLVUXOHOLPLWVWKHWUDGLWLRQDOGLVFUHWLRQRI VWDWH FRXUWVWRH[FOXGHHYLGHQFHEDVHGRQVWDWHHYLGHQWLDU\ $OOH\jVSHWLWLRQIRUDZULWRIKDEHDVFRUSXVOLVWVWKLUWHHQ UXOHV+RZHYHUQRWKLQJLQWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWFDVHVFLWHGE\ DOOHJHGLQVWDQFHVRIMXGLFLDOELDVZKLFKKHFRQWHQGVHQWLWOH $OOH\FRPSHOVWKHFRQFOXVLRQWKDWVWDWHFRXUWVGRQRWUHWDLQ KLPWRKDEHDVUHOLHIRQWKHJURXQGWKDWKHZDVGHQLHGKLVGXH VRPH GLVFUHWLRQ WR DSSO\ WKHLU UXOHV RI HYLGHQFH DW WKH SURFHVV ULJKW WR D IDLU WULDO LQ D IDLU WULEXQDO ,Q GHQ\LQJ VHQWHQFLQJSKDVH6HHHJ*UHHQY*HRUJLD86 $OOH\jVSHWLWLRQIRUKDEHDVUHOLHIWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWKHOSIXOO\ RYHUWXUQLQJDGHDWKVHQWHQFHRQWKHJURXQGWKDW GLYLGHGWKHVHLQVWDQFHVLQWRWKUHHJURXSV FODLPVEDVHGRQ *HRUJLDjVKHDUVD\UXOHKDGEHHQDSSOLHGmPHFKDQLVWLFDOO\lWR DOOHJHG FRQGXFW GXULQJ VWDWH SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ SURFHHGLQJV H[FOXGHUHOHYDQWPLWLJDWLQJHYLGHQFH VHHDOVR6DOODKGLQY FODLPV WKDW $OOH\ UDLVHG EHIRUH WKH VWDWH FRXUWV DQG *LEVRQ )G WK &LU DIWHU FODLPVWKDW$OOH\IDLOHGWRUDLVHEHIRUHWKHVWDWHFRXUWV UHYLHZLQJWKH/RFNHWWOLQHRIFDVHVH[SODLQLQJWKDWm>W@KLVLV $OOH\)6XSSGDW2QDSSHDO QRWWRVD\KRZHYHUWKDWDWULDOFRXUWPXVWDGPLWDQ\DQGDOO $OOH\RQO\H[SUHVVO\FKDOOHQJHVWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWjVKROGLQJ PLWLJDWLRQHYLGHQFHSURIIHUHGE\DFDSLWDOGHIHQGDQW5HYLHZ ZLWK UHVSHFW WR WKH WKLUG JURXS KRZHYHU ZH ZLOO EULHIO\ RIWKHDERYHFLWHGFDVHVLQGLFDWHVWKDWSURIIHUHGPLWLJDWLRQ GLVFXVVWKHILUVWWZRDVZHOO HYLGHQFH PXVW EH UHOLDEOH DQG UHOHYDQW WR EH DGPLWWHGl 3D[WRQY:DUG )G WK&LU m7KLV 7KH GXH SURFHVV FODXVH RI WKH )RXUWHHQWK $PHQGPHQW 6XSUHPH&RXUWDXWKRULW\PDNHVFOHDUWKDWDVWDWHFRXUWPD\ JXDUDQWHHVDFULPLQDOGHIHQGDQWDVDQ\OLWLJDQWWKHULJKWWRD QRWDSSO\DVWDWHUXOHRIHYLGHQFHLQDSHUVHRUPHFKDQLVWLF IDLUWULDOLQDIDLUWULEXQDO,QUH0XUFKLVRQ 86 PDQQHU VR DV WR LQIULQJH XSRQ D GHIHQGDQW V FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ,IDKDEHDVFRXUWGHWHUPLQHVWKDWELDVE\DVWDWH ULJKWWRDIXQGDPHQWDOO\IDLUWULDODQGWRSUHVHQWPLWLJDWLQJ MXGJHUHVXOWHGLQDFRQVWLWXWLRQDOYLRODWLRQWKHQWKHFRXUWLV HYLGHQFHLQDFDSLWDOSURFHHGLQJl %XFKDQDQY$QJHORQH UHTXLUHGWRRYHUWXUQWKHVWDWHFRXUWGHFLVLRQ6HH0DXULQRY )G WK &LU DSSOLFDWLRQ RI sRKQVRQ)G WK&LU m%HFDXVHMXGLFLDO 9LUJLQLDjVKHDUVD\UXOHWRH[FOXGHPLWLJDWLQJHYLGHQFHIURP ELDVLQIHFWVWKHHQWLUHWULDOSURFHVVLWLVQRWVXEMHFWWRKDUPOHVV D FDSLWDO VHQWHQFLQJ KHDULQJ GLG QRW ULVH WR WKH OHYHO RI D HUURUUHYLHZl 7KLVFRXUWKDVORRNHGWRWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWjV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO YLRODWLRQ +XWFKLQV Y *DUULVRQ )G GHFLVLRQLQ/LWHN\Y8QLWHG6WDWHV86 WK &LU m:H ILQG QR LQGLFDWLRQ WKDW WRSURYLGHWKHVWDQGDUGIRUGHFLGLQJMXGLFLDOELDVFODLPV LQ (GGLQJV DQG /RFNHWW SUHHPSW DOO VWDWH UXOHV RI HYLGHQFHl WKDWFDVHWKH&RXUWH[SODLQHGWKDWmWKHSHMRUDWLYHFRQQRWDWLRQ ,QGHHGWKH&RXUWLQ/RFNHWW86DWQH[SOLFLWO\ RI WKH WHUPV µELDVj DQG µSUHMXGLFHj GHPDQGV WKDW WKH\ EH KHOG WKDW m>Q@RWKLQJ LQ WKLV RSLQLRQ OLPLWV WKH WUDGLWLRQDO DSSOLHGRQO\WRMXGLFLDOSUHGLVSRVLWLRQVWKDWJREH\RQGZKDW DXWKRULW\ RI D FRXUW WR H[FOXGH DV LUUHOHYDQW HYLGHQFH QRW LVQRUPDODQGDFFHSWDEOHl,GDW VHHDOVR0DXULQR EHDULQJ RQ WKH GHIHQGDQW V FKDUDFWHU SULRU UHFRUG RU WKH )GDW FLUFXPVWDQFHVRIKLVRIIHQVHl 7ZRRIWKHMXGLFLDOELDVFODLPV$OOH\PDNHVLQKLVKDEHDV ,QWKHSUHVHQWFDVHWKH7HQQHVVHHFRXUWVGLGQRWH[FOXGH SHWLWLRQGHDOZLWKDOOHJHGFRQGXFWGXULQJVWDWHSRVWFRQYLFWLRQ IURPWKHMXU\jVFRQVLGHUDWLRQDWVHQWHQFLQJWKHDOOHJHGIDFWRI SURFHHGLQJV$OOH\FODLPVWKDWsXGJH:)UHG$[OH\PDGH $OOH\jVPXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\GLVRUGHU,QGHHG$OOH\KDGWKH LPSURSHU FRPPHQWV GXULQJ $OOH\jV SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ RSSRUWXQLW\WRSUHVHQWZLGHUDQJLQJHYLGHQFHRQWKLVDVSHFW SURFHHGLQJVDQGWKDWKHH[SUHVVHGGLVVDWLVIDFWLRQZLWKWKH RI$OOH\jVFKDUDFWHU,QVWHDGWKHVWDWHFRXUWDIWHUYLHZLQJWKH OLWLJDWLRQ RI SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ SURFHHGLQJV LQ RWKHU FDSLWDO WDSHVPHUHO\ZHLJKHGDQGWKHQSUHFOXGHGLQWURGXFWLRQRIWKH FDVHV+RZHYHUHUURUFRPPLWWHGGXULQJVWDWHSRVWFRQYLFWLRQ YLGHRWDSHVDOOHJHGO\VKRZLQJPDQLIHVWDWLRQVRIWKLVGLVRUGHU $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
ODZlEXWQRWLQJWKDWWKHLQGHSHQGHQWUHYLHZmLVQRWDIXOOGH SURFHHGLQJVFDQQRWSURYLGHDEDVLVIRUIHGHUDOKDEHDVUHOLHI QRYRUHYLHZRIWKHFODLPVEXWUHPDLQVGHIHUHQWLDOEHFDXVH .LUE\ Y 'XWWRQ )G WK &LU WKHFRXUWFDQQRWJUDQWUHOLHIXQOHVVWKHVWDWHFRXUW VUHVXOWLV 7KHUHIRUH WKHVH DOOHJDWLRQV DUH QRW FRJQL]DEOH RQ KDEHDV QRWLQNHHSLQJZLWKWKHVWULFWXUHVRIWKH$('3$l UHYLHZ $VDOUHDG\PHQWLRQHGWKH7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWKHOG 6HYHUDO RI $OOH\jV RWKHU FODLPV IRU MXGLFLDO ELDV KDYH WKDWWKHYLGHRWDSHHYLGHQFHZDVLQDGPLVVLEOHXQGHU7HQQHVVHH DOUHDG\EHHQFRQVLGHUHGDQGUHMHFWHGE\WKH7HQQHVVHH&RXUW VWDWHODZXSKROGLQJWKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWjVGHWHUPLQDWLRQWKDW RI&ULPLQDO$SSHDOV$OOH\ 6:GDW 7KHVH WKHHYLGHQFHZDVXQUHOLDEOHDQGLUUHOHYDQW7KLVFRXUWGRHV LQFOXGH$OOH\jVFRQWHQWLRQVWKDW sXGJH$[OH\HQJDJHGLQ QRWKDYHWKHDXWKRULW\WRUHYLHZWKH7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUW XQGLVFORVHG H[ SDUWH FRQWDFW ZLWK PHPEHUV RI WKH YLFWLP V RQPDWWHUVRIVWDWHODZ6HH*DOOY3DUNHU)G IDPLO\ZKRVHQWKLPDOHWWHU sXGJH$[OH\HQJDJHGLQH[ WK&LU m3ULQFLSOHVRIFRPLW\DQGILQDOLW\ SDUWHFRQWDFWWKURXJKKLVZLIHjVVLWWLQJLQWKHFRXUWURRPZLWK FRPPDQGWKDWDKDEHDVFRXUWFDQQRWUHYLVLWDVWDWHFRXUW V WKHYLFWLPjVIDPLO\GXULQJWKHWULDO sXGJH$[OH\SHUPLWWHG LQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIVWDWHODZDQGLQSDUWLFXODULQVWUXFWWKDWD PHPEHUVRIWKHYLFWLPjVIDPLO\WRHQWHUDKDOOZD\WKURXJK KDEHDV FRXUW DFFHSW WKH LQWHUSUHWDWLRQ RI VWDWH ODZ E\ WKH ZKLFKDFFHVVFRXOGEHKDGWRWKHMXGJH VFKDPEHUVDQGWKH KLJKHVW VWDWH FRXUW RQ D SHWLWLRQHU V GLUHFW DSSHDOl MXU\ URRP sXGJH $[OH\ SUHVVXUHG PHQWDO KHDOWK $FFRUGLQJO\ WKH TXHVWLRQ EHIRUH WKLV SDQHO LV ZKHWKHU WKH SURIHVVLRQDOVLQYROYHGLQWKHFDVHWRVSHHGXSWKHLUPHQWDO H[FOXVLRQ RI WKH YLGHRWDSH HYLGHQFH LUUHOHYDQW DQG H[DPLQDWLRQVRI$OOH\ DQG sXGJH$[OH\LQFOXGHGIDOVH LQDGPLVVLEOHXQGHUVWDWHODZZDVFRQWUDU\WRWKH 6XSUHPH VWDWHPHQWVLQWKHm5XOHlUHSRUWKHSUHSDUHGDIWHUWULDODQG &RXUWjVGHFLVLRQLQ/RFNHWW VXEPLWWHG WR WKH 7HQQHVVHH 6XSUHPH &RXUW DV SDUW RI WKH GLUHFWDSSHDOSURFHVV 7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVH[SODLQHGWKHUXOHLQ/RFNHWWDQGLWV SURJHQ\DVIROORZV 7KH VWDWH FRXUW KDYLQJ UHMHFWHG WKHVH FRQWHQWLRQV RQ WKH PHULWVWKLVFRXUWFDQRQO\JUDQW$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQLIWKHVWDWH >7@KH VHQWHQFHU >VKDOO@ QRW EH SUHFOXGHG IURP FRXUWjV GHWHUPLQDWLRQ ZDV FRQWUDU\ WR RU DQ XQUHDVRQDEOH FRQVLGHULQJ DV D PLWLJDWLQJ IDFWRU DQ\ DVSHFW RI D DSSOLFDWLRQRI6XSUHPH&RXUWFDVHODZ86& G GHIHQGDQW V FKDUDFWHU RU UHFRUG DQG DQ\ RI WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHVRIWKHRIIHQVHWKDWWKHGHIHQGDQWSURIIHUV ,QUHMHFWLQJ$OOH\jVMXGLFLDOELDVFODLPWKHVWDWHFRXUWIRXQG DVDEDVLVIRUDVHQWHQFHOHVVWKDQGHDWK WKDWWKHMXGJHjVUHFHLSWRIDOHWWHUIURPWKHYLFWLPjVIDPLO\ ZDVQRWHYLGHQFHRIELDVEHFDXVHWKHMXGJHGLGQRWUHVSRQG 6NLSSHU Y 6RXWK &DUROLQD 86 TXRWLQJ WRWKHOHWWHU$OOH\ 6:GDW 6LPLODUO\WKHVWDWH (GGLQJV86DW TXRWLQJ/RFNHWW86DW FRXUWIRXQGQRHYLGHQFHRIELDVLQWKHJHQHUDODFFXVDWLRQWKDW HPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDO WKHMXGJHjVZLIHVDWQHDUWKHYLFWLPjVIDPLO\GXULQJWULDORULQ WKH SUR[LPLW\ RI WKH MXGJHjV FKDPEHUV WR DUHDV RI WKH FRXUWKRXVHWRZKLFKWKHIDPLO\PHPEHUVKDGDFFHVV,ELG 7KHVWDWHFRXUWIRXQGQREDVLVDWDOOIRU$OOH\jVFRQWHQWLRQ ,Q KLV EULHI $OOH\ LPSOLFLWO\ DVNV WKLV FRXUW WR RYHUWXUQ WKH WKDWWKHsXGJHSUHVVXUHGWKHPHQWDOKHDOWKWHDPVLQYROYHGLQ 7HQQHVVHH FRXUWjV VWDWH ODZ KROGLQJ +H UHSHDWHGO\ DVVHUWV WKDW XQGHU $OOH\jVWULDO,GDW)LQDOO\WKHVWDWHFRXUWQRWHGWKDWWKH 7HQQHVVHH ODZ WKH UXOHV RI HYLGHQFH DUH QRW DSSOLFDEOH DW VHQWHQFLQJ KHDULQJV WKHUHIRUH DFFRUGLQJ WR $OOH\ DQG FRQWUDU\ WR WKH 7HQQHVVHH 5XOHUHSRUWFDQQRWIRUPWKHEDVLVIRUDQDOOHJDWLRQRIELDV FRXUWjV KROGLQJ WKH SURIIHUHG YLGHRWDSH HYLGHQFH ZDV DGPLVVLEOH 6HH DVLWLVPHUHO\XVHGWRDVVLVWWKH7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWLQ 3HWLWLRQHUjV %ULHI DW :H FDQ QRW VR KROG $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
LWVVWDWXWRU\GXW\WRUHYLHZWKHUHFRUGLQGHDWKSHQDOW\FDVHV 2Q DSSHDO $OOH\ FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUWjV E\ SURYLGLQJ WKH MXGJHjV DQDO\VLV RI ZKDW HYLGHQFH ZDV GHFLVLRQVLQ(GGLQJVY2NODKRPD86 DQG SUHVHQWHG ,ELG 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW KHOG WKDW WKHVH /RFNHWW Y 2KLR 86 PDNH FOHDU WKDW mD GHWHUPLQDWLRQVZHUHQHLWKHUFRQWUDU\WRQRUDQXQUHDVRQDEOH FDSLWDOVHQWHQFLQJMXU\PD\QRWEHSUHFOXGHGIURPFRQVLGHULQJ DSSOLFDWLRQRI6XSUHPH&RXUWFDVHODZ$OOH\)6XSS DQ\PLWLJDWLQJHYLGHQFHSUHVHQWHGE\WKHFDSLWDOGHIHQGDQWl GDWDQG$OOH\SUHVHQWVQRWKLQJZLWKZKLFKWRFKDOOHQJH 3HWLWLRQHUjV%ULHIDW WKDWKROGLQJRQDSSHDO $VDQLQLWLDOPDWWHUZHUHMHFWWKHFRQWHQWLRQ$OOH\PDNHV $OOH\ GRHV FKDOOHQJH WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV KROGLQJ ZLWK LQKLVEULHIWRWKLVFRXUWWKDWWKH$('3$VWDQGDUGRIUHYLHZ UHVSHFWWRWKHWKLUGVHWRIMXGLFLDOELDVFODLPV$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQ GRHVQRWDSSO\WRWKLVLVVXHEHFDXVHWKHVWDWHFRXUWVGLGQRW VHWV RXW VHYHUDO FODLPV WKDW WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW KHOG ZHUH DGMXGLFDWH $OOH\jV (LJKWK $PHQGPHQW FODLP 3HWLWLRQHUjV SURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHGEHFDXVH$OOH\KDGIDLOHGWRUDLVHWKHP %ULHIDW7KLVLVERWKIDFWXDOO\DQGOHJDOO\LQFRUUHFW EHIRUHWKHVWDWHFRXUWV $OOH\jVEULHIWRWKH7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWDUJXHGWKDW )LUVW$OOH\FRQWHQGVWKDWWKHWULDOMXGJHGHSULYHGKLPRI WKHWULDOFRXUWHUUHGLQH[FOXGLQJWKHYLGHRWDSHVEHFDXVHWKH\ GXH SURFHVV E\ HQJDJLQJ LQ XQGLVFORVHG H[ SDUWH ZHUHUHOHYDQWWRPLWLJDWLRQDQG$OOH\KDGWKHFRQVWLWXWLRQDO FRQYHUVDWLRQVZLWKWZRVWXGHQWVGXULQJKLVWULDODQGRSLQLQJ mULJKWWRSUHVHQWDOOUHOHYDQWHYLGHQFHLQPLWLJDWLRQl 7KH WRWKHPDIWHUWKHWULDOZDVFRPSOHWHGDERXWWKHOLNHOLKRRGWKDW 7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWKHOGLQUHVSRQVHWKDWWKHWDSHVGLG $OOH\jVGHDWKVHQWHQFHZRXOGHYHUEHFDUULHGRXW7KHEDVLV QRWFRQWDLQUHOHYDQWHYLGHQFHEHFDXVHWKHPLWLJDWLQJIDFWRUV IRU WKLV DOOHJDWLRQ LV DQ DIILGDYLW IURP RQH RI WKH VWXGHQWV FLWHGE\$OOH\UHTXLUHGHYLGHQFHRIPHQWDOVWDWHDWWKHWLPHRI ZKHUHLQKHVWDWHVWKDWKHDQGDQRWKHUVWXGHQWZHUHLQYLWHGE\ WKH FULPH 7KH WDSHV RQ WKH RWKHU KDQG SURYLGHG RQO\ sXGJH$[OH\WRZDWFKWKHWULDODQGWKDWGXULQJEUHDNVWKH\ HYLGHQFH RI $OOH\jV PHQWDO VWDWH DW WKH WLPH RI WKH WDSLQJ ZRXOGJRLQWRsXGJH$[OH\jVFKDPEHUVWRGLVFXVVWKHFDVH DSSUR[LPDWHO\\HDUVODWHU 6LQFH$OOH\jVFRQVWLWXWLRQDO ZLWKKLP'XULQJWKHVHGLVFXVVLRQVWKHVWXGHQWVWDWHVsXGJH FODLP ZDV WKDW KH ZDV HQWLWOHG WR SUHVHQW DOO UHOHYDQW $[OH\ VHHPHG XQIDYRUDEO\ GLVSRVHG WRZDUG $OOH\ DQG PLWLJDWLQJHYLGHQFHWKHVWDWHVXSUHPHFRXUWjVGHWHUPLQDWLRQ DSSHDUHGQRWWREHOLHYHKLVPXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\GHIHQVH7KH WKDWWKHHYLGHQFHZDVQRWUHOHYDQWPLWLJDWLQJHYLGHQFHZDVDQ DIILGDYLWJRHVRQWRVWDWHWKDWDIWHUWKHYHUGLFWZDVKDQGHG DGMXGLFDWLRQRIWKDWFODLP GRZQsXGJH$[OH\VDLGVRPHWKLQJWRWKHHIIHFWRIm>W@KHVRQ RIDELWFKZLOOGLHRIROGDJHEHIRUHKHHYHUJRHVWRWKHFKDLUl +RZHYHU HYHQ LI WKH 7HQQHVVHH FRXUW KDG IDLOHG WR DGMXGLFDWH $OOH\jV FODLP H[SOLFLWO\ ZKHQ D VWDWH FRXUW 6HFRQG $OOH\ FODLPV WKDW sXGJH $[OH\ HQJDJHG LQ GHFLVLRQ DUWLFXODWHV LWV UHDVRQLQJ EXW IDLOV WR DGGUHVV WKH XQGLVFORVHGH[SDUWHFRQYHUVDWLRQVZLWKMXURUVGXULQJWULDO UHOHYDQW IHGHUDO VWDQGDUG WKLV FRXUW RQ KDEHDV UHYLHZ VWLOO 7KLVDOOHJDWLRQLVEDVHGRQWKHDIILGDYLWRIRQHMXURUDQGWKH DSSOLHV $('3$ DQG GHWHUPLQHV ZKHWKHU WKH VWDWH FRXUWjV DIILGDYLWRIDQLQYHVWLJDWRUZKRLQWHUYLHZHGDVHFRQGMXURU GHFLVLRQZDVmµFRQWUDU\WRjFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHG6XSUHPH&RXUW 7KHMXURUjVDIILGDYLWVWDWHVWKDWLQUHVSRQVHWRFDOOVIURPWKH SUHFHGHQWDVRIWKHWLPHRILWVGHFLVLRQl'RDQY%ULJDQR MXU\m>W@KHsXGJHFDPHLQWRWKHMXU\URRPRQWZRRUWKUHH )G WK&LU VHHDOVR+DUULVY6WRYDOO RFFDVLRQVDQGDQVZHUHGWZRRUWKUHHTXHVWLRQVZHKDGGXULQJ )G WK&LU IROORZLQJWKHOHDGRIRWKHU WKHGHOLEHUDWLRQV2QHRIWKHTXHVWLRQVZHKDGFRQFHUQHGWKH FLUFXLWV LQ KROGLQJ mWKDW ZKHUH WKH VWDWH FRXUW KDV QRW GLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHOHVVHULQFOXGHGFKDUJHVRIPXUGHUl DUWLFXODWHG LWV UHDVRQLQJ IHGHUDO FRXUWV DUH REOLJDWHG WR 7KHLQYHVWLJDWRUjVDIILGDYLWVWDWHVWKDWDQRWKHUMXURUWROGKHU FRQGXFWDQLQGHSHQGHQWUHYLHZRIWKHUHFRUGDQGDSSOLFDEOH $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
DQGWKHWULDOFRXUWGHQLHGKLVPRWLRQ2QGLUHFWDSSHDOWRWKH WKDW RQ D ZHHNHQG ZKHQ WKH FRXUW ZDV QRW LQ VHVVLRQ WKH 7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUW$OOH\DUJXHGWKDWWKLVZDVHUURU MXURUVKDGDSLFQLFDQGsXGJH$[OH\DQGKLVVRQVWRSSHGE\WR EHFDXVHWKHHYLGHQFHZDVUHOHYDQWWRWZRSRWHQWLDOPLWLJDWLQJ VD\KHOORDQGFKHFNRQWKHMXURUV FLUFXPVWDQFHV 7 &2'( $11 M UHSHDOHG 3HWLWLRQHUjV %ULHI WR WKH 7HQQHVVHH $OOH\DOVRDOOHJHVEXWGRHVQRWGZHOOXSRQVHYHUDORWKHU 6XSUHPH &RXUW DW +H IXUWKHU DUJXHG WKDW KH KDG D FODLPVRIMXGLFLDOELDVWKDWKHIDLOHGWRUDLVHEHIRUHWKHVWDWH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOULJKWWRSUHVHQWDOOUHOHYDQWPLWLJDWLQJHYLGHQFH FRXUWV)RULQVWDQFH$OOH\DUJXHVWKDWsXGJH$[OH\HQJDJHG ,ELG LQXQGLVFORVHGH[SDUWHFRQWDFWZLWKPHPEHUVRIWKHYLFWLP V IDPLO\ZKRVHQWKLPD&KULVWPDVFDUG$OOH\DOVRDUJXHVWKDW 7KH7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWUHMHFWHG$OOH\jVDUJXPHQW WKHMXGJHH[FOXGHG$OOH\jVK\SQRVLVYLGHRWDSHVRQWKHEDVLV KROGLQJ WKDW WKH WZR FLWHG PLWLJDWLQJ IDFWRUV UHTXLUHG RI WKH MXGJHjV SHUVRQDO EHOLHI WKDW LW ODFNHG FUHGLELOLW\ mHYLGHQFHRIGHIHQGDQWjVFRQGLWLRQDWWKHWLPHWKHFULPHZDV )XUWKHU $OOH\ DUJXHV WKDW WKH MXGJH GHPRQVWUDWHG KRVWLOLW\ FRPPLWWHGl$OOH\6:GDW HPSKDVLVLQRULJLQDO WRZDUGKLVFRXQVHODQGXVHGSURIDQLW\WRZDUGKLP)LQDOO\ 7KH FRXUW KHOG WKDW WKH YLGHR FRQWDLQHG mQR HYLGHQFH $OOH\DOOHJHVWKDWWKHMXGJHH[SUHVVHGUHOLHIXSRQVHQWHQFLQJ ZKDWHYHURIGHIHQGDQWjVPHQWDORUHPRWLRQDOVWDWHRUKLV $OOH\WRGHDWK DELOLW\ RU ODFN RI DELOLW\ WR DSSUHFLDWH ULJKW IURP ZURQJ RU FRQWUROKLVFRQGXFWRQWKHHYHQLQJRIsXO\ l,ELG 7KHVH DOOHJDWLRQV IDLO WR SUHVHQW D YLDEOH FODLP RI 7KHFRXUWDOVRKHOGPRUHJHQHUDOO\WKDWoMXVWDVLQWKHJXLOW FRQVWLWXWLRQDOO\LPSHUPLVVLEOHMXGLFLDOELDV)LUVWH[SDUWH SKDVHoWKHWULDOFRXUWGLGQRWDEXVHLWVGLVFUHWLRQLQZHLJKLQJ FRQWDFWGRHVQRWLQLWVHOIHYLGHQFHDQ\NLQGRIELDV)XUWKHU DQGH[FOXGLQJWKHYLGHRWDSHHYLGHQFHDWWKHVHQWHQFLQJSKDVH WKHRSLQLRQVsXGJH$[OH\LVDOOHJHGWRKDYHH[SUHVVHGoDQ $VH[SODLQHGDERYHWKHWULDOFRXUWKDGYLHZHGWKHWDSHVDQG XQIDYRUDEOH GLVSRVLWLRQ WRZDUG $OOH\ D EHOLHI WKDW $OOH\ KDGKHOGWKDWWKH\ZHUHXQUHOLDEOHDQGVLQFHWKH\SURYLGHGQR ZRXOG QHYHU DFWXDOO\ EH SXW WR GHDWK DQG KRVWLOLW\ WRZDUG LQIRUPDWLRQDERXWWKHGD\RIWKHPXUGHULUUHOHYDQW $OOH\jVWULDOFRXQVHOoDOODURVHIURPZKDWKDSSHQHGDWWULDO ([FHSW LQ H[WUHPH FDVHV WR EH DFWLRQDEOH ELDV PXVW VWHP 2Q KDEHDV UHYLHZ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DJUHHG ZLWK WKH IURPDQH[WUDMXGLFLDOVRXUFH 7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUW,WKHOGWKDWWKHUHZDVQRHYLGHQFH WR VXSSRUW $OOH\jV FODLP WKDW WKH YLGHR FRQWDLQHG UHOHYDQW >2@SLQLRQV IRUPHG E\ WKH MXGJH RQ WKH EDVLV RI IDFWV PLWLJDWLQJ HYLGHQFH (YHQ LI WKHUH ZHUH VXFK HYLGHQFH LQWURGXFHG RU HYHQWV RFFXUULQJ LQ WKH FRXUVH RI WKH KRZHYHUWKHFRXUWKHOGPHULWOHVV$OOH\jVFRQWHQWLRQWKDWmD FXUUHQW SURFHHGLQJV RU RI SULRU SURFHHGLQJV GR QRW VWDWHFRXUWFDQQRWH[FOXGHLQDGPLVVLEOHRULUUHOHYDQWHYLGHQFH FRQVWLWXWHDEDVLVIRUDELDVRUSDUWLDOLW\PRWLRQXQOHVV IURPDGHDWKSHQDOW\KHDULQJl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jV DSSUHFLDWLRQ RI WKH ZURQJIXOQHVV RI KLV FRQGXFW DV D UHVXOW RI IDYRULWLVP RU DQWDJRQLVP DV WR PDNH IDLU MXGJPHQW D PHQWDO GLVHDVH GHIHFW RU LQWR[LFDWLRQ LQVXIILFLHQW WR HVWDEOLVK D GHIHQVH LPSRVVLEOH WR WKH FULPH 7 & $ UHSHDOHG $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
/LWHN\86DW1RQHRI$OOH\j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jVFODLPVZRXOGEHEDUUHGERWKE\7HQQHVVHHjVRQH\HDU WRSUHVHQWZLWQHVVHVLQKLVRZQGHIHQVH,QWKHH[HUFLVH SRVWFRQYLFWLRQVWDWXWHRIOLPLWDWLRQV7(11 &2'( $11 RIWKLVULJKWWKHDFFXVHGDVLVUHTXLUHGRIWKH6WDWHPXVW DQGE\WKHVWDWHjVSRVWFRQYLFWLRQZDLYHUUXOH7 (11 FRPSO\ZLWKHVWDEOLVKHGUXOHVRISURFHGXUHDQGHYLGHQFH &2'( $11 I J $VDOVRH[SODLQHGDERYHLQ GHVLJQHG WR DVVXUH ERWK IDLUQHVV DQG UHOLDELOLW\ LQ WKH RUGHUIRUDSHWLWLRQHUWRRYHUFRPHDSURFHGXUDOGHIDXOWDQG DVFHUWDLQPHQWRIJXLOWDQGLQQRFHQFH UHFHLYH IHGHUDO KDEHDV UHYLHZ RI WKDW FODLP KH PXVW VKRZ FDXVHIRUWKHGHIDXOWDQGSUHMXGLFHUHVXOWLQJIURPLWRUWKDW &KDPEHUV 86 DW FLWDWLRQV RPLWWHG VHH DOVR HQIRUFLQJ WKH SURFHGXUDO GHIDXOW LQ KLV FDVH ZLOO HIIHFW D &UDQH 86 DW m>:@H KDYH QHYHU TXHVWLRQHG WKH PLVFDUULDJHRIMXVWLFH:DLQZULJKW86 SRZHURI6WDWHVWRH[FOXGHHYLGHQFHWKURXJKWKHDSSOLFDWLRQ &DXVHIRUDSURFHGXUDOGHIDXOWmPXVWEHVRPHWKLQJH[WHUQDO RI HYLGHQWLDU\ UXOHV WKDW WKHPVHOYHV VHUYH WKH LQWHUHVWV RI WRWKHSHWLWLRQHUVRPHWKLQJWKDWFDQQRWIDLUO\EHDWWULEXWHGWR IDLUQHVVDQGUHOLDELOLW\oHYHQLIWKHGHIHQGDQWZRXOGSUHIHUWR KLPl&ROHPDQ86DW$OOH\PDNHVQRDWWHPSWRQ VHHWKHHYLGHQFHDGPLWWHGl ,WLVWKHUHIRUHFOHDUWKDWmHYHQ DSSHDOWRPDNHDFDXVHDQGSUHMXGLFHRUPLVFDUULDJHRIMXVWLFH UHOHYDQW HYLGHQFH PD\ FRQVWLWXWLRQDOO\ EH H[FOXGHG µLI LWV VKRZLQJ SUREDWLYHYDOXHLVVXEVWDQWLDOO\RXWZHLJKHGE\WKHGDQJHURI XQIDLUSUHMXGLFHFRQIXVLRQRIWKHLVVXHVRUPLVOHDGLQJWKH ,QVWHDG$OOH\DUJXHVWKDWKHLVHQWLWOHGWRDQHYLGHQWLDU\ MXU\jl 6DQGHUV Y )UHHPDQ )G WK &LU KHDULQJLQWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWWRIXUWKHUGHYHORSKLVMXGLFLDOELDV TXRWLQJ)(' 5 (9,' DQG7(11 5 (9,' FODLP 7KH GLVWULFW FRXUW GHFOLQHG WR KROG DQ HYLGHQWLDU\ 5DWKHU WKDQ DSSO\ DQ DUELWUDU\ PHFKDQLVWLF SHU VH RU KHDULQJRQ$OOH\jVFODLPV$OOH\)6XSSGDW:H GLVSURSRUWLRQDWHUXOHWKDWZRXOGKDYHEHHQFRQWUDU\WRFOHDUO\ HVWDEOLVKHG6XSUHPH&RXUWFDVHODZWKHVWDWHFRXUWLQ$OOH\j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jV H[FOXVLRQ RI WKH YLGHRWDSH SUHVHQWHG XQOHVV HYLGHQFHDWWKHJXLOWSKDVHRIKLVWULDOWKH\ZHUHYLRODWHGE\ 7KH FODLP IRU UHOLHI LV EDVHG XSRQ D FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKW QRW UHFRJQL]HG WKHFRXUWjVH[FOXVLRQRIWKHHYLGHQFHDWWKHVHQWHQFLQJSKDVH DV H[LVWLQJ DW WKH WLPH RI WULDO LI HLWKHU WKH IHGHUDO RU VWDWH FRQVWLWXWLRQ UHTXLUHV UHWURDFWLYH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKDW ULJKW RU 7KH IDLOXUH WR SUHVHQW WKH JURXQG ZDV WKH UHVXOW RI VWDWH DFWLRQ LQ $WWKHEHJLQQLQJRIKLVVHQWHQFLQJKHDULQJ$OOH\PRYHGIRU YLRODWLRQ RI WKH IHGHUDO RU VWDWH FRQVWLWXWLRQ DGPLVVLRQRIWKHK\SQRVLVDQG6RGLXP$P\WDOYLGHRWDSHV $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
)LQDOO\WKHUXOHXQGHUZKLFKWKHHYLGHQFHZDVH[FOXGHGLVQRW UHYLHZDGLVWULFWFRXUWjVGHFLVLRQQRWWRFRQGXFWDQHYLGHQWLDU\ GLVSURSRUWLRQDWH WR WKH FRQFHUQV LW LV LQWHQGHG WR DGGUHVV KHDULQJIRUDQDEXVHRIGLVFUHWLRQ/RWWY&R\OH)G EHFDXVH E\ FRQVLGHULQJ DQG ZHLJKLQJ SLHFHV RI HYLGHQFH WK&LU LQGLYLGXDOO\ LW DYRLGV RYHUEUHDGWK DQG WKH LQFLGHQWDO H[FOXVLRQRIHYLGHQFHWKDWLVUHOLDEOHDQGUHOHYDQW 7KH RQO\ EDVLV $OOH\ RIIHUV IRU RYHUWXUQLQJ WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjVGHFLVLRQLVKLVFRQWHQWLRQWKDWKHPHULWVDQHYLGHQWLDU\ 5HO\LQJRQD1LQWK&LUFXLWFDVHFROOHFWLQJWKHVH6XSUHPH KHDULQJEDVHGRQWKH6XSUHPH&RXUWjVGHFLVLRQLQ 0LFKDHO &RXUW FDVHV $OOH\ DUJXHV WKDW D GHIHQGDQWjV ULJKWV DUH :LOOLDPVY7D\ORU 86 ZKLFKZDVGHFLGHG YLRODWHGDQ\WLPHDVWDWHHYLGHQWLDU\UXOLQJH[FOXGHVDSLHFH DIWHU WKH GLVWULFW FRXUWjV GHFLVLRQ LQ WKH SUHVHQW FDVH RI HYLGHQFH FULWLFDO WR WKH GHIHQVH 6HH 'H3HWULV Y +RZHYHU :LOOLDPV LV LQDSSOLFDEOH WR $OOH\jV FDVH .X\NHQGDOO )G WK &LU m7KH DFFRUGLQJO\WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWGLGQRWDEXVHLWVGLVFUHWLRQLQ 6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVPDGHFOHDUWKDWWKHHUURQHRXVH[FOXVLRQRI GHFLGLQJQRWWRFRQGXFWDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJRQWKLVLVVXH FULWLFDOFRUURERUDWLYHGHIHQVHHYLGHQFHPD\YLRODWHERWKWKH )LIWK $PHQGPHQW GXH SURFHVV ULJKW WR D IDLU WULDO DQG WKH ,IDKDEHDVSHWLWLRQHUKDVmIDLOHGWRGHYHORSWKHIDFWXDOEDVLV 6L[WK $PHQGPHQW ULJKW WR SUHVHQW D GHIHQVHl %XW VHH RI D FODLP LQ 6WDWH FRXUW SURFHHGLQJVl KH FDQ RQO\ JHW DQ /D*UDQG Y 6WHZDUW )G WK &LU HYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJLQIHGHUDOGLVWULFWFRXUWRQWKDWFODLPLQ m7KHVHFDVHVWDNHQWRJHWKHUVWDQGIRUWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDW H[WUHPHO\ QDUURZ FLUFXPVWDQFHV 86& H VWDWHVPD\QRWLPSHGHDGHIHQGDQW VULJKWWRSXWRQDGHIHQVH 7KHSHWLWLRQHUPXVWVKRZWKDW E\ LPSRVLQJ PHFKDQLVWLF &KDPEHUV RU DUELWUDU\ :DVKLQJWRQDQG5RFN UXOHVRIHYLGHQFHl $ WKHFODLPUHOLHVRQ L DQHZUXOHRIFRQVWLWXWLRQDOODZPDGHUHWURDFWLYHWR +RZHYHUWKHHYLGHQFHH[FOXGHGLQWKLVFDVHGLGQRWWDNH FDVHV RQ FROODWHUDO UHYLHZ E\ WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW WKDW WKH OHJV RXW IURP XQGHU $OOH\jV GHIHQVH +LV GHIHQVH ZDV ZDVSUHYLRXVO\XQDYDLODEOH RU EDVHGRQWKHIDFWWKDWKHVXIIHUHGIURPPXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\ LL D IDFWXDO SUHGLFDWH WKDW FRXOG QRW KDYH EHHQ GLVRUGHU DQG DPRQJ RWKHU HYLGHQFH $OOH\ SUHVHQWHG WZR SUHYLRXVO\ GLVFRYHUHG WKURXJK WKH H[HUFLVH RI GXH GRFWRUV ZKR WHVWLILHG WR WKDW %RWK GLVFXVVHG $OOH\jV GLOLJHQFH DQG FRQGLWLRQ LQ GHWDLO DQG VXSSRUWHG WKHLU FRQFOXVLRQV ZLWK % WKHIDFWVXQGHUO\LQJWKHFODLPZRXOGEHVXIILFLHQWWR H[WHQVLYHGLVFXVVLRQRI$OOH\jVFDVHKLVFKLOGKRRGDQGKLV HVWDEOLVKE\FOHDUDQGFRQYLQFLQJHYLGHQFHWKDWEXWIRU DGXOWOLIH FRQVWLWXWLRQDOHUURUQRUHDVRQDEOHIDFWILQGHUZRXOGKDYH IRXQGWKHDSSOLFDQWJXLOW\RIWKHXQGHUO\LQJRIIHQVH )XUWKHU$OOH\GRHVQRWRIIHUDFKDOOHQJHWRWKHYDOLGLW\RI WKH WULDO FRXUWj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
LQ FDVHV ZKHUH WKH IDLOXUH WR GHYHORS WKH QHFHVVDU\ IDFWXDO FRQIHVVLRQGHSULYHGKLPRIDIDLUWULDOl,GDW FLWLQJ EDVLV RI D FODLP LQ VWDWH FRXUW ZDV QRW GXH WR D ODFN RI &KDPEHUV86DW GLOLJHQFHRQWKHSHWLWLRQHUjVSDUW,ELG7KH&RXUWZHQWRQWR H[SODLQ WKDW ZKHWKHU D SHWLWLRQHU H[HUFLVHG WKH GLOLJHQFH ,Q5RFNWKH&RXUWZURWHWKDWDm6WDWH VOHJLWLPDWHLQWHUHVW QHFHVVDU\ WR SUHVHUYH D FODLP mGHSHQGV XSRQ ZKHWKHU WKH LQ EDUULQJ XQUHOLDEOH HYLGHQFH GRHV QRW H[WHQG WR SHU VH SULVRQHU PDGH D UHDVRQDEOH DWWHPSW LQ OLJKW RI WKH H[FOXVLRQVWKDWPD\EHUHOLDEOHLQDQLQGLYLGXDOFDVHl LQIRUPDWLRQDYDLODEOHDWWKHWLPHWRLQYHVWLJDWHDQGSXUVXH 86DW7KH&RXUWFLWHG:DVKLQJWRQDQG&KDPEHUVDQG FODLPVLQVWDWHFRXUWl,GDW KHOGWKDWmUHVWULFWLRQVRIDGHIHQGDQW VULJKWWRWHVWLI\PD\QRW EH DUELWUDU\ RU GLVSURSRUWLRQDWH WR WKH SXUSRVHV WKH\ DUH ,Q:LOOLDPVWKHSURVHFXWRUDWWULDOKDGUHSUHVHQWHGDMXURU GHVLJQHGWRVHUYHl,GDW LQ KHU GLYRUFH SURFHHGLQJ EXW QHLWKHU WKH MXURU QRU WKH SURVHFXWRUVSRNHXSDWYRLUGLUHZKHQWKHMXURUVZHUHDVNHG )LQDOO\LQ6FKHIIHUWKH&RXUWFRQVLGHUHGDEODQNHWUXOHRI LI WKH\ NQHZ DQ\ RI WKH ODZ\HUV LQYROYHG ,G DW HYLGHQFH LQ PLOLWDU\ FRXUWV WKDW H[FOXGHG DOO SRO\JUDSK :LOOLDPVjV DWWRUQH\V GLG QRW ILQG RXW DERXW WKLV XQWLO WKH HYLGHQFH86DW7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWXSKHOGHYHQ IHGHUDOKDEHDVVWDJH KRZHYHUWKH&RXUWKHOGWKDW:LOOLDPV WKLVEODQNHWUXOHEHFDXVHLWGLGQRWHYLVFHUDWHWKHGHIHQGDQWjV ZDVHQWLWOHGWRDKHDULQJRQWKHFODLPEHFDXVHWKHIDFWWKDW GHIHQVH ,G DW 7KRXJK 6FKHIIHU LV QRW GLUHFWO\ WKHHYLGHQFHZDVQRWGHYHORSHGHDUOLHUZDVVROHO\WKHIDXOWRI UHOHYDQWLQWKLVFDVHEHFDXVHLWFDPHRXWORQJDIWHUWKHVWDWH WKHUHWLFHQWMXURUDQGSURVHFXWRU,GDW:LOOLDPVWKH FRXUWGHFLVLRQVDWLVVXHLQ$OOH\jVSHWLWLRQWKH6FKHIIHU&RXUW &RXUW KHOG KDG QRW H[KLELWHG D mODFN RI GLOLJHQFHl ZLWK UHFRQILUPHGWKDWDSSOLFDWLRQRIHYLGHQWLDU\UXOHVmGR>HV@QRW UHVSHFWWRWKHFODLP,GDW DEULGJHDQDFFXVHGjVULJKWWRSUHVHQWDGHIHQVHVRORQJDVWKH\ DUHQRWµDUELWUDU\jRUµGLVSURSRUWLRQDWHWRWKHSXUSRVHVWKH\ &RQWUDU\WRWKHSHWLWLRQHULQ:LOOLDPVZKRKDGQRUHDVRQ DUHGHVLJQHGWRVHUYHjl,GDW TXRWLQJ5RFN86DW WRVXVSHFWWKDWWKHMXURUZRXOGNQRZWKHSURVHFXWRUDQGWKXV SRWHQWLDOO\EHELDVHG$OOH\KDGHYHU\UHDVRQWRVXVSHFWWKDW sXGJH$[OH\ZDVDOOHJHGO\ELDVHGDJDLQVWKLP,QGHHGDVWKH ,QVKRUWWKHVWDWHFRXUWjVH[FOXVLRQ RI$OOH\jVYLGHRWDSH GLVWULFWFRXUWLQWKLVFDVHSRLQWHGRXWmMXGLFLDOELDVKDVEHHQ HYLGHQFHZDVQRWFRQWUDU\WRWKHFOHDUO\HVWDEOLVKHGODZRIWKH WKH SHWLWLRQHUjV ZDWFKZRUG HYHU VLQFH KH ZDV FRQYLFWHGl FDVHV$OOH\FLWHVEHFDXVHWKHH[FOXVLRQZDVQRWEDVHGRQDQ $OOH\)6XSSGDW$OOH\DOOHJHGMXGLFLDOELDVDV DUELWUDU\ PHFKDQLVWLF RU SHU VH DSSOLFDWLRQ RI WKH VWDWHjV DFHQWUDOLVVXHLQKLVILUVWVWDWHSRVWFRQYLFWLRQSHWLWLRQ$OOH\ HYLGHQWLDU\ UXOHV DQG LW ZDV QRW GLVSURSRUWLRQDWH WR WKH JRWDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJRQWKLVLVVXHDPRQJRWKHUVZKHQ SXUSRVHVEHKLQGLW,WZDVFOHDUO\QRWPHFKDQLVWLFRUSHUVH WKHFRXUWRIDSSHDOVYDFDWHGsXGJH$[OH\jVGHQLDORI$OOH\jV DV WKH FRXUW PDGH DQ LQGLYLGXDO GHWHUPLQDWLRQ o DIWHU SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ SHWLWLRQ DQG UHPDQGHG KLV FDVH WR D QHZ ZDWFKLQJWKHYLGHRVDQGEDVHGRQWKHIDFWVVSHFLILFWR$OOH\jV MXGJH$WWKDWKHDULQJ$OOH\UDLVHGWKHILYHFODLPVRIMXGLFLDO FDVH o WKDW WKH OLNHO\ SUHMXGLFH IURP DGPLWWLQJ WKH WDSHV ELDVGLVFXVVHGDERYHDQGSUHVHQWHGWHVWLPRQ\DQGHYLGHQFHWR RXWZHLJKHGWKHLUSUREDWLYHYDOXH,WZDVQRWDUELWUDU\DVWKH VXSSRUW WKRVH FODLPV 7KH &RXUW LQ :LOOLDPV KHOG WKDW UXOLQJ DSSOLHG WR ERWK WKH SURVHFXWLRQ DQG WKH GHIHQVH ZKHWKHU D SHWLWLRQHU ZDV VXIILFLHQWO\ GLOLJHQW WR SUHVHUYH D FODLPmGHSHQGVXSRQZKHWKHUWKHSULVRQHUPDGHDUHDVRQDEOH DWWHPSWLQOLJKWRIWKHLQIRUPDWLRQDYDLODEOHDWWKHWLPHWR $OOH\ FRQWHQGV ZLWKRXW UHIHUHQFH WR VSHFLILF H[DPSOHV WKDW WKH LQYHVWLJDWH DQG SXUVXH FODLPV LQ VWDWH FRXUWl ,G DW UXOLQJ ZDV DUELWUDU\ LQ WKDW SURVHFXWLRQ ZLWQHVVHV ZHUH SHUPLWWHG WR UHIHU HPSKDVLV DGGHG *LYHQ $OOH\jV DZDUHQHVV RI DOOHJHG WR WKH YLGHRWDSHV LQ ZD\V WKDW GHIHQVH ZLWQHVVHV ZHUH QRW 3HWLWLRQHUjV %ULHI DW +RZHYHU D UHYLHZ RI WKH UHFRUG VLPSO\ GRHV QRW VXSSRUW $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
SHWLWLRQHUjVGXHSURFHVVULJKWVDUHYLRODWHGDQ\WLPHDVWDWH MXGLFLDOELDVRQWKHSDUWRIsXGJH$[OH\DQGLQGHHGWKHIDFW FRXUW H[FOXGHV HYLGHQFH WKDW WKH SHWLWLRQHU EHOLHYHV LV WKH WKDW$OOH\UHFHLYHGDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJLQVWDWHFRXUW$OOH\ FHQWHUSLHFHRIKLVGHIHQVH,QVWHDGWKHFDVHV$OOH\FLWHVVWDQG VKRXOG KDYH FRQGXFWHG IXUWKHU LQYHVWLJDWLRQ DW WKDW WLPH IRU WKH PRUH OLPLWHG SURSRVLWLRQ WKDW D GHIHQGDQWjV GXH m>,@QOLJKWRIWKHLQIRUPDWLRQDYDLODEOHDWWKHWLPHl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jV FRQYLFWLRQ RQ WKH JURXQG WKDW 7H[DVjV UXOH WKDWKHFDQIXOILOOWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVIRUDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJ mDUELWUDULO\lGHSULYHGKLPRIKLVULJKWWRSUHVHQWZLWQHVVHVLQ VHW RXW LQ H WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW FHUWDLQO\ GLG QRW KLVGHIHQVH,GDW DEXVHLWVGLVFUHWLRQLQUHIXVLQJWRKROGRQH ,Q &KDPEHUV WKH 6XSUHPH &RXUW UHYHUVHG D 0LVVLVVLSSL ([3DUWH&RQWDFW&ODLPV VWDWHFRXUWFRQYLFWLRQZKHQRQWKHEDVLVRIWKHVWDWHjVKHDUVD\ UXOHWKHVWDWHFRXUWUHIXVHGWRDGPLWWHVWLPRQ\WKDWVRPHRQH ,QDGGLWLRQWRDUJXLQJWKDWsXGJH$[OH\jVDOOHJHGH[SDUWH HOVHKDGFRPPLWWHGWKHFULPH86DW 7KH&RXUW FRQWDFWV ZLWK WKH MXURUV VKRZHG MXGLFLDO ELDV $OOH\ DOVR QRWHG WKDW WKH SURIIHUHG WHVWLPRQ\ ZDV WUXVWZRUWK\ DQG FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH DOOHJHG FRQWDFWV YLRODWHG $OOH\jV DGPLVVLEOHXQGHUDFRPPRQH[FHSWLRQWRWKHKHDUVD\UXOHQRW FRQVWLWXWLRQDOULJKWmWRSHUVRQDOSUHVHQFHDWDOOFULWLFDOVWDJHV DGRSWHGLQ0LVVLVVLSSLDQGZURWH m7KDWWHVWLPRQ\DOVRZDV RI>KLV@WULDOl5XVKHQY6SDLQ86 FULWLFDOWR&KDPEHUV GHIHQVH,QWKHVHFLUFXPVWDQFHVZKHUH $VWKHGLVWULFWFRXUWSRLQWHGRXW$OOH\SURFHGXUDOO\GHIDXOWHG FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKWV GLUHFWO\ DIIHFWLQJ WKH DVFHUWDLQPHQW RI WKLVFODLPE\IDLOLQJWRUDLVHLWLQWKHVWDWHFRXUW$OOH\) JXLOW DUH LPSOLFDWHG WKH KHDUVD\ UXOH PD\ QRW EH DSSOLHG 6XSSGDW PHFKDQLVWLFDOO\ WR GHIHDW WKH HQGV RI MXVWLFHl ,G DW HPSKDVLVDGGHG sXVWDVLQWKHSUHYLRXVLVVXH$OOH\GRHVQRWDUJXHFDXVHDQG SUHMXGLFHRUPLVFDUULDJHRIMXVWLFHWRH[FXVHKLVGHIDXOWEXW ,Q &UDQH D VWDWH FRXUW DIWHU KROGLQJ WKDW D GHIHQGDQWjV LQVWHDGDUJXHVWKDWKHPHULWVDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJRQWKH FRQIHVVLRQZDVYROXQWDU\H[FOXGHGDOOHYLGHQFHZLWKUHVSHFW PDWWHUSXUVXDQWWR:LOOLDPV 86DWsXVWDVLQWKH WR WKH FLUFXPVWDQFHV XQGHU ZKLFK WKH FRQIHVVLRQ KDG EHHQ SUHYLRXV LVVXH :LOOLDPV GRHV QRW KHOS $OOH\ EHFDXVH KH DWWDLQHGHYHQWKRXJKWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVFDOOHGLQWRTXHVWLRQ IDLOHG WR H[KLELW WKH QHFHVVDU\ GLOLJHQFH LQ DWWHPSWLQJ WR WKHFRQIHVVLRQjVFUHGLELOLW\86DW7KH&RXUW GHYHORSWKHIDFWXDOUHFRUGLQVWDWHFRXUW,GDW UHYHUVHGWKHFRQYLFWLRQQRWLQJWKDWmWKHEODQNHWH[FOXVLRQRI WKHSURIIHUHGWHVWLPRQ\DERXWWKHFLUFXPVWDQFHVRISHWLWLRQHU V )LUVWDVVWDWHGDERYH$OOH\ZDVRQQRWLFHZLWKUHJDUGWR DOOHJHGLPSURSHUFRQGXFWE\sXGJH$[OH\DWWKHWLPHRIKLV VWDWH SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ SURFHHGLQJV DQG KH UHFHLYHG DQ $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
HYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJRQWKHLVVXH6HHHJ$OOH\ 6:G KRZHYHUWKH7HQQHVVHHFRXUWUHMHFWHGWKLVFRQWHQWLRQQRWLQJ DW ,WZRXOGWKHUHIRUHKDYHEHHQUHDVRQDEOHIRU$OOH\ WKDW WKH WULDO FRXUW KDG ZHLJKHG WKH SUREDWLYH YDOXH RI WKH WR KDYH LQTXLUHG IXUWKHU ZLWK UHJDUG WR WKH MXGJHjV DFWLRQV WDSHV LQ TXHVWLRQ DJDLQVW LWV SUHMXGLFLDO HIIHFW $OOH\ GXULQJKLVWULDO 6:GDW 0RUH LPSRUWDQWO\ KRZHYHU $OOH\ ZDV RQ QRWLFH DERXW $OOH\jVDUJXPHQWWRWKLVFRXUWSXWVLPSO\LVWKDWKLVGXH SRWHQWLDOLUUHJXODULWLHVZLWKUHVSHFWWRWKHMXU\+HDUJXHGLQ SURFHVVULJKWVZHUHYLRODWHGE\WKHWULDOFRXUWjVH[FOXVLRQRI KLV VWDWH SRVWFRQYLFWLRQ FDVH WKDW GXULQJ KLV WULDO WKH WKHK\SQRVLVWDSHVEHFDXVHWKHLQWHUYLHZFRQWDLQHGWKHUHLQ YLFWLPjVIDPLO\KDGDFFHVVWRDSULYDWHKDOOZD\WKDWOHGRQO\ ZDVWKHEDVLVIRUKLVGRFWRUVjRSLQLRQVWKDWKHVXIIHUHGIURP WR sXGJH $[OH\jV FKDPEHUV DQG WKH MXU\ URRP $OOH\ PXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\GLVRUGHU$VVXFK$OOH\FRQWHQGVWKDW 6:GDW ,QGHHG$OOH\jVWULDOFRXQVHOWHVWLILHGDWWKH WKH WDSHV ZHUH WKH FHQWHUSLHFH RI WKH NH\ LVVXH DW WULDO HYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJKHOGE\WKHVWDWHWULDOFRXUWSRVWUHPDQG :LWKRXWEHLQJDEOHWRVKRZWKHWDSHVWRWKHMXU\RUUHIHUWRWKH WKDWWKHYLFWLPjVIDWKHUmZDVJRLQJEDFNLQWRZDUGVWKHEDFN DFWLRQV RU ZRUGV FRQWDLQHG WKHUHLQ $OOH\ DUJXHV WKDW KLV ZKHUHQRERG\EXWWKHMXGJHDQGWKHMXU\VWD\VlWKURXJKRXWWKH GHIHQVHZDVHYLVFHUDWHG)XUWKHU$OOH\SRLQWVRXWWKDWWKH WULDO$OOH\jVWULDOFRXQVHOPDNHVWKHVDPHDOOHJDWLRQLQDQ SURVHFXWLRQZDVDEOHWRFURVVH[DPLQHKLVGRFWRUVDQGFDOO DIILGDYLW VXEPLWWHG WR WKH GLVWULFW FRXUW DORQJ ZLWK $OOH\jV WKHLURZQH[SHUWVLQRUGHUWRFDOOLQWRGRXEWWKHYHULW\RIWKH IHGHUDOKDEHDVSHWLWLRQ DOOHJHGPXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\PDQLIHVWDWLRQVDQGKLVGRFWRUV FRXOG QRW UHIHU WR VSHFLILFV RI WKH WDSHV LQ RUGHU WR EROVWHU 6LQFH$OOH\jVWULDOFRXQVHOZDVERWKDZDUHRIDQGDOOHJLQJ WKHLUYLHZV WKHSRVVLELOLW\RIFRQWDFWEHWZHHQWKHYLFWLPjVIDPLO\DQGWKH MXU\GXULQJWULDO$OOH\jVIDLOXUHWRLQWHUYLHZDQ\MXURUVEHIRUH ,QVXSSRUWRIKLVDUJXPHQW$OOH\FLWHV6XSUHPH&RXUWFDVH WKH IHGHUDO KDEHDV VWDJH GRHV QRW FRQVWLWXWH mD UHDVRQDEOH ODZIRUWKHSURSRVLWLRQWKDWDGHIHQGDQWjVGXHSURFHVVULJKWV DWWHPSWLQOLJKWRIWKHLQIRUPDWLRQDYDLODEOHDWWKHWLPHWR DUH YLRODWHG ZKHQ D WULDO FRXUW H[FOXGHV IURP WKH MXU\jV LQYHVWLJDWHDQGSXUVXHFODLPVLQVWDWHFRXUWl:LOOLDPV FRQVLGHUDWLRQHYLGHQFHWKDWLVYLWDOWRWKHGHIHQGDQWjVGHIHQVH 86DW,WLVWKHUHIRUHFOHDUWKDW$OOH\GLGQRWPDNHWKH 6HH HJ 5RFN &UDQH Y .HQWXFN\ 86 GLOLJHQWHIIRUWUHTXLUHGE\:LOOLDPVWRGHYHORSLQVWDWHFRXUW &KDPEHUVY0LVVLVVLSSL86 :DVKLQJWRQ WKHIDFWXDOEDVLVIRUKLVH[SDUWHFODLP IRUWKLVUHDVRQ$OOH\ Y7H[DV86 7KH6XSUHPH&RXUWKDVZULWWHQ FDQQRWDYRLGWKHUHTXLUHPHQWVIRUDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJVHW RI WKHVH WKUHH FDVHV m7KH H[FOXVLRQV RI HYLGHQFH WKDW ZH RXWLQ86& H 6LQFH$OOH\LVXQDEOHWRIXOILOO GHFODUHG XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDO LQ WKRVH FDVHV VLJQLILFDQWO\ WKHUHTXLUHPHQWVRIWKDWVHFWLRQZHPXVWDIILUPWKHGLVWULFW XQGHUPLQHGIXQGDPHQWDOHOHPHQWVRIWKHDFFXVHG VGHIHQVHl FRXUWjVGHQLDORI$OOH\jVUHTXHVWIRUDQHYLGHQWLDU\KHDULQJRQ 8QLWHG6WDWHVY6FKHIIHU86 $OOH\ WKLVLVVXHDVZHOO FODLPVWKDWKHPHULWVKDEHDVUHOLHIEHFDXVHWKHWULDOFRXUWjV H[FOXVLRQRIWKHLQWHUYLHZWDSHVZDVFRQWUDU\WRWKLVFOHDUO\ ([FOXVLRQRI(YLGHQFHDWWKH*XLOW3KDVH HVWDEOLVKHG6XSUHPH&RXUWODZ $OOH\ FRQWHQGV WKDW WKH VWDWH WULDO FRXUW GHQLHG KLP WKH .HHSLQJLQPLQGWKHVWULFWXUHVRI$('3$LWLVFOHDUWKDW DELOLW\WRSUHVHQWDIXOOGHIHQVHLQYLRODWLRQRIKLVULJKWVWR WKH 7HQQHVVHH 6XSUHPH &RXUWjV GHFLVLRQ LQ WKLV FDVH ZDV QHLWKHUFRQWUDU\WRQRUDQXQUHDVRQDEOHDSSOLFDWLRQRIFOHDUO\ HVWDEOLVKHG 6XSUHPH &RXUW FDVH ODZ 7KH 6XSUHPH &RXUW FDVHV $OOH\ FLWHV GR QRW VWDQG IRU WKH SURSRVLWLRQ WKDW D $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
RIODZDQGUHFRJQL]HGQROLPLWDWLRQVRQKLVEHKDYLRU%DWWOH GXH SURFHVV DQG FRQIURQWDWLRQ ZKHQ WKH FRXUW UHIXVHG WR VWDWHG WKDW LW ZDV KLV RSLQLRQ WKDW $OOH\ VXIIHUHG IURP WKH DGPLW LQWR HYLGHQFH YLGHRWDSHG LQWHUYLHZV RI $OOH\ ZKLOH GLVRUGHUDWWKHWLPHRIWKHPXUGHU%DWWOHIXUWKHUWHVWLILHGWKDW XQGHUK\SQRVLVDQG6RGLXP$P\WDO WKHUH ZDV HYLGHQFH WHQGLQJ WR VXJJHVW WKDW 3RZHU ZDV LQ FRQWURODWWKHWLPHRIWKHPXUGHULQFOXGLQJWKHIDFWWKDWWKH $OOH\jVGHIHQVHDWWULDOZDVWKDWKHZDVLQVDQHDWWKHWLPHRI QDWXUHRIWKHFULPHILWPRUHZLWK3RZHUjVSHUVRQDOLW\WKDQLW WKH PXUGHU EHFDXVH KH VXIIHUHG IURP PXOWLSOH SHUVRQDOLW\ GLGZLWK$OOH\jV+RZHYHU'U%DWWOHVDLGWKDWKHFRXOGQRW GLVRUGHU DOVRFDOOHGGLVVRFLDWLYHLGHQWLW\GLVRUGHU 7KHPRVW EHVXUHWKDWDQDOWHUQDWHSHUVRQDOLW\ZDVLQFRQWUROGXULQJWKH IDYRUDEOH PHGLFDO WHVWLPRQ\ WR WKLV HIIHFW FDPH IURP PXUGHU )RU WKLV UHDVRQ RQ FURVVH[DPLQDWLRQ 'U %DWWOH SV\FKRORJLVW 'U $OOHQ %DWWOH DQG SV\FKLDWULVW 'U :LOOLV DGPLWWHG WKDW KH FRXOG QRW VXSSRUW DQ LQVDQLW\ GHIHQVH LQ 0DUVKDOOERWKRIZKRPEDVHGWKHLUGLDJQRVHVRQLQWHUYLHZV $OOH\jVFDVH WKDW'U%DWWOHKDGFRQGXFWHGRI$OOH\ZKLOHXQGHUK\SQRVLV 'U%DWWOHKDGYLGHRWDSHGWKHVHLQWHUYLHZVDQG'U0DUVKDOO 2QGLUHFWDSSHDOWKH7HQQHVVHH6XSUHPH&RXUWUHMHFWHG o ZKR ZDV QRW SUHVHQW GXULQJ WKH LQWHUYLHZV o EDVHG KLV $OOH\jVFRQWHQWLRQWKDWWKHWULDOFRXUWKDGHUUHGLQH[FOXGLQJ FRQFOXVLRQRQDYLHZLQJRIWKHWDSHV WKHWDSHV7KHFRXUWKHOGWKDW 7KHSURVHFXWLRQPRYHGIRUWKHWDSHVWREHH[FOXGHGDQG DXGLRRUYLGHRWDSHVUHFRUGLQJDGHIHQGDQW VVWDWHPHQWV WKHGLVWULFWFRXUWKHDUGWHVWLPRQ\RQWKHLVVXHRXWVLGHRIWKH DQGFRQGXFWZKLOHXQGHUK\SQRVLVRUWUXWKVHUXPVZKHQ MXU\j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jV HYLGHQWLDU\ OLNHZLVHZLWKLQWKHWULDOFRXUW VGLVFUHWLRQ UXOLQJ YLRODWHG KLV ULJKWV XQGHU WKH &RQIURQWDWLRQ &ODXVH 86 &RQVW DPHQG 9, +RZHYHU $OOH\ KDV SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG WKLV FODLP E\
$OOH\6:GDW$IWHUYLHZLQJWKHWDSHVWKH IDLOLQJ WR UDLVH LW EHIRUH WKH VWDWH FRXUWV LQ WKH VDPH ZD\ WKDW KH
FRXUWKHOGWKDWWKHWULDOMXGJHKDGQRWDEXVHGKLVGLVFUHWLRQ SURFHGXUDOO\ GHIDXOWHG WKH MXGLFLDO ELDV FODLPV KH IDLOHG WR UDLVH LQ VWDWH FRXUW 6H\PRXU )G DW $FFRUGLQJO\ ZH ZLOO IRFXV RQ ,GDW $OOH\jV GXH SURFHVV FODLP
7KH7HQQHVVHHFRXUWDOVRUHMHFWHG$OOH\jVFRQWHQWLRQWKDW $OOH\ DOOHJHV WKDW WKH H[FOXVLRQ IURP HYLGHQFH RI KLV 6RGLXP WKH WULDO MXGJH YLRODWHG WKH UXOH HQXQFLDWHG LQ 5RFN Y $P\WDO LQWHUYLHZV YLRODWHG KLV FRQVWLWXWLRQDO ULJKWV +RZHYHU $OOH\jV
$UNDQVDV86 ,Q5RFNWKH6XSUHPH&RXUW EULHI IRFXVHV VROHO\ RQ WKH LPSRUW RI WKH K\SQRVLV VHVVLRQV :H ZLOO
KHOG WKDW D GHIHQGDQWjV GXH SURFHVV ULJKW WR WHVWLI\ ZDV WKHUHIRUH OLPLW RXU GLVFXVVLRQ VLPLODUO\ VLQFH ZH KROG WKDW WKH WULDO MXGJH
YLRODWHG E\ D VWDWH SHU VH UXOH H[FOXGLQJ DOO K\SQRWLFDOO\ GLG QRW YLRODWH $OOH\jV GXH SURFHVV ULJKWV E\ H[FOXGLQJ WKH K\SQRVLV WDSHV
UHIUHVKHGWHVWLPRQ\,GDW$OOH\KDGDUJXHGWKDWWKHWULDO ZKLFK $OOH\ FRQWHQGV ZHUH FHQWUDO WR KLV GHIHQVH ZH DUH VDIH WR DVVXPH WKDW WKH MXGJH GLG QRW YLRODWH $OOH\jV ULJKWV E\ H[FOXGLQJ WKH 6RGLXP MXGJHLQKLVFDVHKDGHIIHFWLYHO\LQVWLWXWHGVXFKDSHUVHUXOH $P\WDO WDSHV DERXW ZKLFK $OOH\ PDNHV QR VXFK FODLP $OOH\Y%HOO 1R 1R $OOH\Y%HOO
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jVFDVH )LUVW0DUVKDOOH[SODLQHGWKDWGXULQJERWKDQLQLWLDOLQWHUYLHZ 7KH WULDO MXGJH YLHZHG WKH WDSHV DQG IRXQG WKHP WR EH DQGWKH6RGLXP$P\WDOLQWHUYLHZV0DUVKDOOKDGFRQGXFWHG VHQVDWLRQDOXQUHOLDEOHDQGOLNHO\WRFRQIXVHWKHMXU\+HDOVR $OOH\VSRNHRIERWK'HDWKDQG%LOOLHEHLQJLQWKHFDUZLWKKLP IRXQGWKDWWKHWDSHVHOLFLWHGQRIDFWVDERXWZKDWKDSSHQHGRQ WKH QLJKW RI WKH PXUGHU 0DUVKDOO DOVR WHVWLILHG DW OHQJWK WKHQLJKWRIWKHPXUGHU+HZHLJKHGWKHSUREDWLYHYDOXHRI DERXW$OOH\jVFKLOGKRRGDQGDGXOWOLIHDQGKHH[SODLQHGKRZ WKHLU XVH DJDLQVW WKH ULVN WKDW WKH WDSHV PLJKW FRQIXVH RU ERWK ZHUH FRQVLVWHQW ZLWK KDYLQJ D PXOWLSOH SHUVRQDOLW\ PLVOHDG WKH MXU\ DQG JUDQWHG WKH VWDWHjV PRWLRQ WR H[FOXGH GLVRUGHU,QGHHGKHH[SODLQHG$OOH\jVEURWKHUoREVHUYLQJ WKHP6SHFLILFDOO\WKHMXGJHUXOHGWKDWWKHWDSHVFRXOGQRWEH $OOH\jV VWUDQJH DFWLRQV DQG FKDUDFWHU o KDG FRPH WR WKH VKRZQWRWKHMXU\DQGWKDWmVWDWHPHQWVRUZRUGVDQGDFWLRQV FRQFOXVLRQ VHYHUDO \HDUV HDUOLHU WKDW $OOH\ KDG PXOWLSOH RIWKHGHIHQGDQWZKLOHXQGHUK\SQRVLV>FRXOGQRW@EHUHODWHG SHUVRQDOLWLHV )LQDOO\ 0DUVKDOO GHWDLOHG KRZ $OOH\ KDG WR WKH MXU\ E\ D ZLWQHVVl +RZHYHU WKH MXGJH KHOG WKDW VXIIHUHGIURPPHPRU\ODSVHVDQGGLVWRUWLRQVWKURXJKRXWPRVW ZLWQHVVHVFRXOGWHVWLI\WKDWWKHLQWHUYLHZVZHUHFRQGXFWHG RIKLVOLIHDQGKHH[SODLQHGWKDWWKLVmLVSUREDEO\WKHPRVW DQGWKH\FRXOGH[SUHVVWKHLURSLQLRQVDVWRZKHWKHUPXOWLSOH FRPPRQVLJQRIPXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\l SHUVRQDOLWLHVZHUHSUHVHQWGXULQJWKHLQWHUYLHZV )RUKLVSDUW'U%DWWOHWHVWLILHGWKDWKHKDGWUHDWHGPRUH 'UV 0DUVKDOO DQG %DWWOH GLG MXVW WKDW 'U 0DUVKDOO WKDQDGR]HQFDVHVRIPXOWLSOHSHUVRQDOLW\GLVRUGHUWKURXJKRXW WHVWLILHG WKDW $OOH\ VXIIHUHG IURP PXOWLSOH SHUVRQDOLW\ KLVFDUHHU'U%DWWOHWKHQH[SODLQHGWKDWKHKDGK\SQRWL]HG GLVRUGHU DQG KH VWDWHG WKDW $OOH\ H[KLELWHG DW OHDVW WZR $OOH\ RQ VHYHUDO RFFDVLRQV DQG WKDW EDVHG RQ WKRVH DOWHUQDWHSHUVRQDOLWLHV RQHFDOOHGm3RZHUlRUm'HDWKlDQGD LQWHUYLHZVLWZDVKLVRSLQLRQ WKDW$OOH\VXIIHUHGIURPWKH IHPDOHQDPHGm%LOOLHl 0DUVKDOOWHVWLILHGWKDWKHEDVHGWKLV FRQGLWLRQ /LNH 'U 0DUVKDOO 'U %DWWOH WHVWLILHG DERXW RSLQLRQ RQ KLV YLHZLQJ RI WKH WZR YLGHRWDSHG K\SQRVLV $OOH\jVFKLOGKRRGDQGKRZKHEHOLHYHGH[SHULHQFHVGXULQJ LQWHUYLHZVGXULQJZKLFKm3RZHUlHPHUJHG0DUVKDOOVWDWHG WKDWWLPHOHGWRWKHGHYHORSPHQWRIDOWHUQDWHSHUVRQDOLWLHV+H WKDWLWZDVKLVRSLQLRQEDVHGRQKLVYLHZLQJRIWKHYLGHRWDSHG DOVRWHVWLILHGDERXW$OOH\jVPHPRU\ORVVDQGWKHVLJQLILFDQFH LQWHUYLHZV WKDW 3RZHU ZDV OHJDOO\ LQVDQH 'U 0DUVKDOO KHVDZLQWKDW IXUWKHU WHVWLILHG ERWK RQ WKH EDVLV RI WKH YLGHRWDSHG LQWHUYLHZVDQGRWKHULQWHUYLHZV'U0DUVKDOOKDGFRQGXFWHG 'U%DWWOHWDONHGDERXWWZRDOWHUQDWHSHUVRQDOLWLHV%DWWOH ZLWK$OOH\WKDWWKHUHZDVHYLGHQFHWKDW3RZHUZDVLQFRQWURO H[SODLQHGWKDW$OOH\ZDVDZDUHRIWKHH[LVWHQFHRI%LOOLHDQ DWWKHWLPHRIWKHPXUGHU DOWHUQDWH SHUVRQDOLW\ WKDW VWHPPHG IURP $OOH\jV WURXEOHG FKLOGKRRG +RZHYHU %DWWOH WHVWLILHG DW JUHDWHU OHQJWK 7HVWLI\LQJ SULRU WR WKH WULDO FRXUWjV UXOLQJ H[FOXGLQJ WKH UHJDUGLQJ WKH VHFRQG DOWHUQDWH SHUVRQDOLW\ 3RZHU %DWWOH YLGHRWDSHHYLGHQFH0DUVKDOOGHVFULEHGWRWKHMXU\DSRUWLRQ WHVWLILHG WR KDYLQJ KDG FRQWDFW ZLWK 3RZHU WKURXJK WKH RI RQH RI WKH K\SQRVLV LQWHUYLHZV GXULQJ ZKLFK $OOH\ K\SQRVLVVHVVLRQVDQGKHWHVWLILHGWKDW3RZHUZDVSV\FKRWLF VWUXJJOHGZLWKKLPVHOIVSRNHLQDZKLVSHUDQGUHSHDWHGO\ +HH[SODLQHGWKDW3RZHUFODLPHGQRWWREHERXQGE\WKHUXOH
Alley v. Bell (Alley v. Bell) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.