Allen "F" Calton v. Steve Schiller
Opinion
FILED IN 2nd COURT OF APPEALS FORT WORTH, TEXAS 8/17/2015 3:06:06 PM DEBRA SPISAK Clerk 067-270690-14
CAUSE NO. 067-270690-14
ALLEN F. CALTON, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT Plaintiff, § § v. § OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS § STEVE SCHILLER et al, § Defendants. § 671h JUDICIAL DISTRICT
JUDGMENT
On this the J/~ay of Dismiss of Defendants Keller, Livingston, ayce, Gill and Stums. After reviewing the pleadings
on file herein, the Court is of the opinion that said Motion is well taken and should be granted.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT the Motion
to Dismiss of Defendants Keller, Livingston, Cayce, Gill and Stums be and is hereby
GRANTED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT Plaintiffs cause
of action be and is hereby dismissed with prejudice to the refiling of same in any, form.
IT IS FINALLY ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT any relief not
specifically granted be and is hereby denied, and that this is a final judgment.
Court's Minutes TransactKH1 # ~ 3 __ ____ _ _ _ ~(Q~D. _iS.3--=.J.7CXo?D~(c.( _ _.Aif&_ir£'-'-C«l ~'l ________ .::::c;,~ o,-rk-:z'cl_~wt+ ______ f /a<'nhtf_ __ _______ _ _____ ---~-- ___ _ _ v ----
_ _ ..AUv-_ c..oM,t\Q.I;JtJ _dOi'.'lh~(_s_ ~-t:or_~~~\nt~J_of __ Cc~ !_~_ ~(es.ul-_f/a:n-hW !n--iU al,o~ - ~f-_\.L_h - - court's Minute ---- --------·--- -- --jJ -Trnnsact~~~ # CAUSE NO. 153-270690-14 ALLEN"F"CALTON § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF § vs. § TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS § STEVE SCHILLER, ET AL. § 153RD JUDICIAL DISTRICT ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT STEVE SCHILLER'S MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE & REMEDIES CODE On the /? day of '\)~~C. , 2015, Defendant Steve Schiller's Motion to Dismiss Pursuant to Chapter 14 of the Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code came before the court. After reviewing the motion, response and reply filed by the parties, the Court finds that Defendant's Motion to Dismiss is well taken and is GRANTED and the claims against Defendant Steve Schiller are hereby DISMISSED with prejudice. I SIGNED Ut~.VI e. ~ '2015. REC/CT &ftl!r~ ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT STEVE SCHILLLER'S MOTION TO DISMISS URSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE & REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 1 Court's Minute$, Transaction # ::5((71 ~JQ- Du. \S s ,)_lu0'tO-· 1~ A\lQ;\\'f' 1 G::t\4-vfl · <;, .::C,, -,)._c_ f) i~\rt'ct Co·.JJ'-t ~ l<;: q.Q'-/e. kt? dl er 1 e~-,o, ( / U t C.Q/1 ~C/1\\ 'I;> __ --rl·'"' ~ C,l\ \:- Cu '-'c~ ~1 ,.-(_1(0 S. i)GN'(JI\lb- or6v f'Qc\'-=-): .. \ :~-po,Jr&~~ ~l.f\-t.\~.1 (Y\...()\,dl ----ro -~ V\l.P\ .tNvA_S j~J.~~-' n:tV\ .A ~, ~-e ~'-- __c:._o~ \c.;.'\. t . ,\c\,.r c,Jrd 1 ~0J1(\~ q\u.,!\-\l(Gi rWJ\·rJ\ IU Jvfrl;..~-\: 1·"'1 \ ':. N >'\-\'\~'-.A~/\~ c.l. Lu!'V{_)\c.,n_-\: ~e. Lou!'-\- t s. 1 '1-(/w ,, r\ "t \of\ -(i.,cr\ -\'kQ -'-')I( (:, =:L\- \ ~ }w_~2 ~ or~/-f ~ -\-'he-r\ ~ v?rL<~A \h£ AJ(/1'\'~\ A~~ c.\ _,J Court's Minute~ qEC/CT..:.I1t.:.:.ni.!.."Z...~---- r Transaction #4 C CUA se. JJ '0 • A\ I €!"1" ~II G:vl h'l ~\ ,;()\, \( \) ~\-eve. s~,\\u-, e\-C\. \ ~e~~CP\\~ \>\a:\1\'-'\~~ 0Mfii~S fY)~\iol\ ~r >-Jew\ f' \c.\ ~~QJ'Ie'k-~.Cv- r. s ')..0 0/ld/of Mc\joo fi)r ,(leUJns:\s\e!'obl\o lt/\c\er ~eJ.Q.Civ.Q A\~~ 'n. \-h..e.. \='e~. Q.C..i\.l. Q. 6o "'}~· e.,.:.\) I'€~ ki l\ec.o~n·,'2e {Y\ o\\ a"\ s; t= o , r e. c..u rH \ ~ Qf' a.-\wn . s. -u... ~ Q. ~;. .s. v I..JA tk ~ S\ab..s. <;.)~\-. 6.C. 1>...~~:\c::-A\u..re. .:l\l fJd "t-::.'1 1 't(p~(:::.-\t\Ur .LOou)..Xnl\~Q.d, .s uc...h ~ll\-\ml; Q<"~ ~ec.\~ ~X>Ic.a.l\~ o..s ('r\,1)"0<\~ -\o ct\\€.1' or Q.M€!\~ Ct. ~u. b.~M.eA.\ lJJ\~'ti"' -r. O...C... ~. 51 (ej or~IJII.i For ~~\i.e~ .f.rof\'"\..j~..A.'O~ MeA..\.s. tO\ o\6QS's VA~v-- F Q...c.p ~laO (b), M.o\-ium .for ('e. <...on{ \6QJ'o\\of\ 0o\ B~e~ <....utWn -\iJL -\i!A ~G """\e l(ctS A M2> IV\ {\.L~.eCU'~ ~UI\~ ~ M4ji\C<.. 1ratUp.::t/7c U CY\=-{ be_ ~{'W\\e6 ~\ rn.\-,\-qte ~ ~ ~SV't I 1\0\- .J•-H\- a. ~OJ'~• ~ee. A~~oc.Aa.W D,-,t.OvV\.--\; c...:,f'\) \J G-o\~M.o'\ S .;1<.{_ f;l. ~ tos-1 c :IclCt{ lq I s-J, A!S. c...u~r~~ 'o4. ~ CV'\t~~ o-G "€f\)\<.J1.._ i fl n«<'ob{Q AJ ;"~ A ~\~{\" \-G \1'-()~(J(\ ~~ )J w ~\C!\ \. Q...c... p. 3.:>0 pc..JQ__.) DG .:H, Go"'"'\'\~\. \JVc,~ ~ ('111\~\-c.t '?e Me< 6 ~\a.1-.~(~~ A\h~;~ IA i"i'eor\ D~ \\-\-'>~~on~ J.J~••:l'\r\a\ C "'ueio- o..~\
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
FILED IN 2nd COURT OF APPEALS FORT WORTH, TEXAS 8/17/2015 3:06:06 PM DEBRA SPISAK Clerk 067-270690-14
CAUSE NO. 067-270690-14
ALLEN F. CALTON, § IN THE DISTRICT COURT Plaintiff, § § v. § OF TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS § STEVE SCHILLER et al, § Defendants. § 671h JUDICIAL DISTRICT
JUDGMENT
On this the J/~ay of Dismiss of Defendants Keller, Livingston, ayce, Gill and Stums. After reviewing the pleadings
on file herein, the Court is of the opinion that said Motion is well taken and should be granted.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT the Motion
to Dismiss of Defendants Keller, Livingston, Cayce, Gill and Stums be and is hereby
GRANTED.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT Plaintiffs cause
of action be and is hereby dismissed with prejudice to the refiling of same in any, form.
IT IS FINALLY ORDERED ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT any relief not
specifically granted be and is hereby denied, and that this is a final judgment.
Court's Minutes TransactKH1 # ~ 3 __ ____ _ _ _ ~(Q~D. _iS.3--=.J.7CXo?D~(c.( _ _.Aif&_ir£'-'-C«l ~'l ________ .::::c;,~ o,-rk-:z'cl_~wt+ ______ f /a<'nhtf_ __ _______ _ _____ ---~-- ___ _ _ v ----
_ _ ..AUv-_ c..oM,t\Q.I;JtJ _dOi'.'lh~(_s_ ~-t:or_~~~\nt~J_of __ Cc~ !_~_ ~(es.ul-_f/a:n-hW !n--iU al,o~ - ~f-_\.L_h - - court's Minute ---- --------·--- -- --jJ -Trnnsact~~~ # CAUSE NO. 153-270690-14 ALLEN"F"CALTON § IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF § vs. § TARRANT COUNTY, TEXAS § STEVE SCHILLER, ET AL. § 153RD JUDICIAL DISTRICT ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT STEVE SCHILLER'S MOTION TO DISMISS PURSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE & REMEDIES CODE On the /? day of '\)~~C. , 2015, Defendant Steve Schiller's Motion to Dismiss Pursuant to Chapter 14 of the Texas Civil Practice & Remedies Code came before the court. After reviewing the motion, response and reply filed by the parties, the Court finds that Defendant's Motion to Dismiss is well taken and is GRANTED and the claims against Defendant Steve Schiller are hereby DISMISSED with prejudice. I SIGNED Ut~.VI e. ~ '2015. REC/CT &ftl!r~ ORDER GRANTING DEFENDANT STEVE SCHILLLER'S MOTION TO DISMISS URSUANT TO CHAPTER 14 OF THE TEXAS CIVIL PRACTICE & REMEDIES CODE (Cause No. 153-270690-14; Calton v. Schiller)- PAGE 1 Court's Minute$, Transaction # ::5((71 ~JQ- Du. \S s ,)_lu0'tO-· 1~ A\lQ;\\'f' 1 G::t\4-vfl · <;, .::C,, -,)._c_ f) i~\rt'ct Co·.JJ'-t ~ l<;: q.Q'-/e. kt? dl er 1 e~-,o, ( / U t C.Q/1 ~C/1\\ 'I;> __ --rl·'"' ~ C,l\ \:- Cu '-'c~ ~1 ,.-(_1(0 S. i)GN'(JI\lb- or6v f'Qc\'-=-): .. \ :~-po,Jr&~~ ~l.f\-t.\~.1 (Y\...()\,dl ----ro -~ V\l.P\ .tNvA_S j~J.~~-' n:tV\ .A ~, ~-e ~'-- __c:._o~ \c.;.'\. t . ,\c\,.r c,Jrd 1 ~0J1(\~ q\u.,!\-\l(Gi rWJ\·rJ\ IU Jvfrl;..~-\: 1·"'1 \ ':. N >'\-\'\~'-.A~/\~ c.l. Lu!'V{_)\c.,n_-\: ~e. Lou!'-\- t s. 1 '1-(/w ,, r\ "t \of\ -(i.,cr\ -\'kQ -'-')I( (:, =:L\- \ ~ }w_~2 ~ or~/-f ~ -\-'he-r\ ~ v?rL<~A \h£ AJ(/1'\'~\ A~~ c.\ _,J Court's Minute~ qEC/CT..:.I1t.:.:.ni.!.."Z...~---- r Transaction #4 C CUA se. JJ '0 • A\ I €!"1" ~II G:vl h'l ~\ ,;()\, \( \) ~\-eve. s~,\\u-, e\-C\. \ ~e~~CP\\~ \>\a:\1\'-'\~~ 0Mfii~S fY)~\iol\ ~r >-Jew\ f' \c.\ ~~QJ'Ie'k-~.Cv- r. s ')..0 0/ld/of Mc\joo fi)r ,(leUJns:\s\e!'obl\o lt/\c\er ~eJ.Q.Civ.Q A\~~ 'n. \-h..e.. \='e~. Q.C..i\.l. Q. 6o "'}~· e.,.:.\) I'€~ ki l\ec.o~n·,'2e {Y\ o\\ a"\ s; t= o , r e. c..u rH \ ~ Qf' a.-\wn . s. -u... ~ Q. ~;. .s. v I..JA tk ~ S\ab..s. <;.)~\-. 6.C. 1>...~~:\c::-A\u..re. .:l\l fJd "t-::.'1 1 't(p~(:::.-\t\Ur .LOou)..Xnl\~Q.d, .s uc...h ~ll\-\ml; Q<"~ ~ec.\~ ~X>Ic.a.l\~ o..s ('r\,1)"0<\~ -\o ct\\€.1' or Q.M€!\~ Ct. ~u. b.~M.eA.\ lJJ\~'ti"' -r. O...C... ~. 51 (ej or~IJII.i For ~~\i.e~ .f.rof\'"\..j~..A.'O~ MeA..\.s. tO\ o\6QS's VA~v-- F Q...c.p ~laO (b), M.o\-ium .for ('e. <...on{ \6QJ'o\\of\ 0o\ B~e~ <....utWn -\iJL -\i!A ~G """\e l(ctS A M2> IV\ {\.L~.eCU'~ ~UI\~ ~ M4ji\C<.. 1ratUp.::t/7c U CY\=-{ be_ ~{'W\\e6 ~\ rn.\-,\-qte ~ ~ ~SV't I 1\0\- .J•-H\- a. ~OJ'~• ~ee. A~~oc.Aa.W D,-,t.OvV\.--\; c...:,f'\) \J G-o\~M.o'\ S .;1<.{_ f;l. ~ tos-1 c :IclCt{ lq I s-J, A!S. c...u~r~~ 'o4. ~ CV'\t~~ o-G "€f\)\<.J1.._ i fl n«<'ob{Q AJ ;"~ A ~\~{\" \-G \1'-()~(J(\ ~~ )J w ~\C!\ \. Q...c... p. 3.:>0 pc..JQ__.) DG .:H, Go"'"'\'\~\. \JVc,~ ~ ('111\~\-c.t '?e Me< 6 ~\a.1-.~(~~ A\h~;~ IA i"i'eor\ D~ \\-\-'>~~on~ J.J~••:l'\r\a\ C "'ueio- o..~\ P\~1\\-IWS. eo(\-\-rol. OncL p\~~t-ht{.. plqW h\~ l~jq{ pi eCtrlinp.! in-!kQ._ f'!'\ion. Mo..\ I bt:>'f... ~~j a\--\NL- ""~ o~ f r-1Jun o~.{; u'o(s --\-u: -f.ocv.:>or6 \\ ()/\. ~ ~ U..~. \)~\a\. J %"1J1' c.Q .. S .e.JZ.. .4{-hc:bv 1{ a.+ SIGNED this 7 day of .(), ~ , 2012. Ben Woodward, Chair ' Texas Court Reporters Certification Board 3 (\) \>\,."11oC.C\ o/V\,...,\M~ ~c" ~r~""""'\r I<>\ I.A.-\6QFie~.ll.,u\J.(l. J;J.o 0'1~ lof I'V'-o\nvf\ 'k>r 14.c..on.l\~v-o,\"lo"n \J..r-t6Qf' ~6.(\_(,IJ.(J. !oOCWld or ht>C.\o)(lo) W'. 0. c r ~ ~ -::s- u 6 j ""' M \- G- r cY\ \:.."' ~ (\--...{) In Cf) CV\ '-V H~"\,\~'.1 A\-h~cw.\- .:::r>\.S"'\"fwr\ 0.\- \~i ~IY) ~)J.Q......:ilno( C?) X' \,, 0 \:, \l:;. A.lt.\-.~L o-\ \1-ean"J Gy J._.. b~uJ1 \)/1 h>r 1-\-\s o""(\' b.d ~IX\ '\=-<:>r ~-r1 \o\ l.V\~ -rt"/... C\..0\V• f. J..),O 0/1~ Jor ~'*'-"" {l..ec.onJ,)!,u-u\ou 0 l.h6Qf' f-e~.(l..Ltv IJ. (ouCblf!J orCoO(Io)(U \.4) ~ \o-~1\~c..~~ ~ce~e"\IV'\-Q,"--\ o\ ~Jil OA¢. 1-.J~\-t (Sj ~\~f\~\G AJbhU. "1\:)"\\'\e CovJ'\\lJ.Su\:,,...;t ~('\.\;"~! ot~"c-\A"c' f c_...:,~s\0'"\.S o \- L~ ~W'J\...\M 10 1r1-.(t.c:v -r. 0~1 ~7 (_(p) Le_ \ ~J'IO ~s\r\ Uct LCV\(\)(\ fLe1 V{)~\f A L1v! Cl>.c\G~-b cvy lkcvifJJ f"d.e. Vi eM D ~ ru o,, ~:~~a h D-C ~ ~(lv<'{) U:.l~ ~ Pcyw'J 6{ .fu lvW'-\- ,-"' \e-'v-€1LR. -h~ a6u~ ~},fe6 o"'~ ry..vv,~d ~1€. Ali<;) til~ Ma"'l the~J. fO-{ ~J o~ ~ J ~ &~J <> e~wn -\'M"' +-c 11---e. ~ (01-'ifdt 1'r'l ~ J. A, i _£ dJ il -€r.uw Q d. --rhQ/1 t y ()..A J A\1 ~ t•ft' CCt lk --4- 11).1 '&SO ~''('' WbA_ '3al:>o FMl.Sly G c"~+ )lx. 7/7 DS'"' \+c..e.\* shov-J Ct. ~r~s-et\\ U~Mn)\l~s'i <'esw~l"_g ll\- caJ.Q. or ~W\C..~\.l-e., ( e\ \e ~ \ ~ I...V"UCC..O""(>OJ\1 e d. b-t 0./'1'1 wn\\ <1u~n.,g 1 pre.s€1'1-\: Ot ~Vltl S.-'L ~~c.\·s . S-ee. C.l~ ot. G-Qj'\OJ\6 v ~l"VIU\C\.. \'-\(oiwJJ u<-t C...\e..~.~~- ~qi\Cts .2ooYJ•1 T0-1'\e.s \JC,~-o~ Dc;l\ct..> .?-S~f3JS~IC~-\lt! C..\r .1..oo0.---fu-..~.s. O.<; ~~e ~c..c-\·s OA6 a.....t~~--~eJ s.u~~~fl ~\cJn\\W "'c.<; ~'novJe6 \n~w-'1. .::r:,., h.:~vins_ ~\S. N1f'l~ A,.,._e--.6eo ~ \9'B.1 ~p\c.,l\\- b.e..fore-\1\e D\- S.\-(\C-\- CovS\ \n ~ CoW'\\ re..st~l<..{-htV\ "0~ .S\e~.SJ,III.JU''s rNJ\101\ I "D IJ's.o-1.~ • ~~~ Le.hMG'/\ \s-t.{ fJ'd Ct.\- lOll. '"""\h~ (o-\-\.S ""S" ub~"Met\\:- ~!:.~ ~-e. ie.\: A.1\6e. '\""b .A\\o...U ~-e.. ~V\~ M.€.1\.\ b ~ ~~ \>\ec,6ln~s \..AJ\~ 1\--e. l.l'"~ A,.,~ed C-o,..,..'(\al\"\\ .An6 , ~e ~::fp\~~-\\b~ ..LJ"·'~ A,.,w,6.~~~"1\a.ttt\- ~ \ cU c<\,\.\ -\-h \'>. LovJ' \:- \-o \J c. c a \..Q.. \\ s. ~ u 6j M. .etl \- \-o q 1/o...;) l'f'.0\>4?.\ ~e f\~lQ.\\N'i A""-£A6M(1f\\ ~ \.1'.\l'€~\ \>\cJI\~\~'s. C.O"l".\.u.-\-\ot'¥ll c..,\c.. wcS -\wn~ 0 O\l41' -\-o ~ LU•. ~ru\o.t il!.r\)\{..Q.. 6'-( (>r\.lQI\ o~~Jols or ~.QA -*'.e. 0. V' ~ 'C>\.~c.iL- Q c...\ua \~ r e.CQiv-t~ ~':. ck(..\..VO'\ VI.-\ • !i' cA \t I..JJCI.! .(;.\e~ >(Y'.o..rKe~ IV\<>J"ILeO ~u':.~or£.. d=( \:,~-ke ~-:-ecz\J.Qsk~ "e;.vJ.y 6~ of\ So.\~ ~of\ • .\.~ ~k h.Qre cv\- l{-12.-r\ -for S:ai ~ ~~ ~~~ o( S.4.rvlc...R.. e \)re.~eA\: et 6-,}V' ~e eJ~(...\- ~ ~ Ntt~\~ \e~<>r6c..·h<¥J a..t'\6 Ad.:y -\-c A~~ial ~\cia.( G::,..,.r\'-~ D .e,..,,at o{: P\a...'n\1\\~ n'4Aton 1\) {)i~,..; ~.s ~\ WQI\. \: 0-\ S,_pee ~~ -n-\a\. A.~ VJ~I C\( \~!Q ~ 5rc~e1'i Vrol,tflO~ on Of~\'ql. ~·Q ~\oJf\\.ctl ..AJ,~ Am~~ed ~\ruf\\ r"e M ot"l\'-1. oc.c..u...r O(){_Q_ ~ _Ju6~M€A\ "t\s.e\~ \~ \.l \\\ \"v-.Q ~e\cw AcsllM~\ OJ\O Au~('\\...[ w\1\ A~},.f'€>~ Eac..OA (s~Q/'<0\ \ D VI\ a.\ 1 E r.M A \\e~ Q\) ~" o-t E: n\1\\-e""en\-l b X,., MVJ\l -kt An 6- Q. Ar~UM€1\-\ C..Vn\o.\(\-e~ ,-" s.~;\\.u-\ '\=\~~\A""we~A""~v-lv 0/ld ~VI \o ~=)\S"'-\\S. 'tw-.~uOII.\ \0 ~0\)\lf \~ c~"\'N.. '"'\e't.Ci~· ~'"''-'· (l.e~ 6\e~UJde.. ~\o..(~~\~ a.~}..rec;.s.e5. ~\e (A) A~ c..~ f\€ ~ a.A ~ n (A) Ge~e('u\ c>en\Qt - ..A.\~g\1\ ~\e~ ~)..~,\\~~.e. Covf'\ R.~r-\.er di!A\£ ~ e. c. viA. CV\-C\ e.v~ 1 a.ll WI~ i1'n~u\oJ r~ A\\e_gQ-\)ons COI'\\cu~e~ \" Q\~ rec...o~~~ ~\~1'\\,\.f w~ .\AI(v.'trtnj a\ocu\ ~' ~ Mt lod~f'!J -+o -0v_ ct \-~d. MW'W' C...Ci.U..... 'bu'- h~~c;.~ were_ ~fol)e- c us l't 4. U.e se ~ b'-( {'(\("'. sJ,\1 ll.er- -+u b~ bl\_g ~ ~ (.l'VI ngs Of) a-t\, if' 1 C.D<-S.{..\ ~\0-A~\;.\\- o..\~o ~c.~ ~4A1.-'in_g q\--rN?_--\.'rNL. f\1\.<'. S.J..i\\.u- o.~"'-'\\.ec fu S.CIK\.l OJ\ '3-.<1-rl. '"hi'> c:vn<.Ver -\-o ~.Q_ CoW'\ lt.~arw.s. ~\;caf.\i'l rbUW'o(here4t.kr c..Q...c..~ in c-e~\>"'''lt. -\-o Ct<\Ms. c.....,"'('\~f\1- .S:-Q. £y.\,,k,,~" G" \,ere~ c.-\-+a...NJ ~6, lf\GUrpa("'c.k~ ."il\e C..(l.c(;. ~""~ r'\r. ~c...t.d\lf ~\:.e.. ,·f\UlfYl- (?e\~-\ . o~ -\-o ~\ ~ .{,c.j\t_v·e -\-u ~f~C4""e. +rCV\~c.r,~p\-.s -f.or E're-klq( he.o.f'~llil: ~Ci\- w~ ~C'<><(1U'~ \e'lv~.Ql>\e~ b't C.cd\..al CYl 0 -9or ~ai\,'n_J -\"0 Ma~e.. re.oti 1(\o.-i.n\..\Cs. ~if) ~o,AJe...) -rl'\a\ \.Lc~. !.l..tJ P<- fv\,C'. <;;,.~\W.i \"c.v~~~~\;- Qa."{x>r\\n_x ~rc.c\ices. \.k~ (e-1•-d.\.e~ lA ~ ~'-<\,i\M\-icl ~e.A-ar d.~\a.\~ c..("'Q. ...0~o\\'1 bCtitl-eu G/1 ~~ V'\ ~i.1pub~ -e..oi~M<..f ·l.s ~~i<-~ ~ro~ WQ..\l 'o.e.vo(\~ ~e. ~rq>o'"'6~Mc..e.. o-\- crec\tble , e.v1 C\QAlQ. f\-eltt~cv'i -\-o IM()OJ...L I iabd,l..r Dr'\ ~\e~Sc.ht'IIV' .. (or \rl,.s. ·~o.1\~ -\--o prcrv\~..e.. P,\c;..;n\1\t o ~le\.e. WI~ JyHtc.iB'!\ Q...Q_ (J)r>~ A>. C-cw"'" ~<"'~ere_~- l=O( ()\ • L rr• ...-' • 1 a..\ r ~ '" "'~ '~"H+~ .,.., r .1-\- Af(Wct\ A-1 A ""-"\\v- n~ {UQV\i- 0-.» Qua\ I t1 e 6 X""' N~Wlt ~ v .Q\e<..tl\"(.(: ~~ b M\- c;,.v..e_ ~\eu-e. S.c.,h, 1\!IJ +or M.t:IC\t'1 61M'lc A'~ v..s.n \\. <"' o.A.f h4\1'-t. "'c~{'/'\ OM\:.: 3o u .l ''"' c. q_ \ \..v n'~ \.r\\-\-\<1\. Co~\cJI\tS. 13.'-t-\ Ca.\~ d._\6 1\ll\ .S\AQ. S.\e~~chti\V'\1"\ ""\~ ~ ~ tt.{cA C ~ u ~ -\-o \ e '-0\.l\if (V'--0 1\ IV-j ~ ~ fe ~ \.A/\ 6 V' -\'N>. ~ M. (_0) b\_ ~~c.\ _:r'h<>"IUN h ~a.\ o_.re (.2.) '-".l~~ln ~ l;<...c~ b~ ~\\ a.....~r;.\.., 0/'\o( '3-j ~QJ'W"'f>~ If\ G-oo~ ~c..~~. S~ (..,\~ ().\ LLV~.Cq~W v<:J.,cw.btr'.S "lsUsw.n. -¥,--.ere.~r~\ f'N..-1.~\;- be_ c.. ~e\e.rt>v\n~f) ""q6e b'-l-\-h\1 C..Ow-\-'""he-\t,er (\1\r_sc_h,\\-tr v..)a.s. ~v-\or,...!~ ~\\c..re.\'lo"OJ'l c\u~es. wh€.A~e. c;\{egec:;\ cc.-\l.. OA6lor o""'\!.~\oru cc(.wce6 ~n ~ \><'e.s.~vu.lnon ~C\ ~rerq- \ C\. \\0() o.l; ~ ~e. c..,u r o M A~eeQ! 0/\ o 01\<.f a-to c ctu\\e~ whik c.Mr'til\,il cu.\- \\t,. nuA.r C\1, CV\ c-t\~uot C..0u.l't n._~,.w-. \)\ ~c..r~*'cnOJ"'1 o.c-\..IX\s. OJ'e. ~\\e~ -\-cox rote.c_.-\,on l.V\6,~ o~ ~\c.\a.\ \M,.....,wt\~ 'bu\ """\n\l>~\al ae:t\0'\S. a.re "c\-.~ee ();,qii~~11£V c..M()tv\~i\Y) B.u,\~erJtrl)c 1'-i!.l£w1d Y.\7 1 ~.n CT~~..JJ~lfJ.A(\ qc-\-JIYl Ls YV\~1\1.~\v\al \~ \\ h 01'\e -\-hq\. h d.e-hfl€ 6 w\~ .iu.c.IA prec.\~\o() *"'cA- (""'10 6-i.~c.te!ni)l') o\ Jub._sM-eA-t \.s. \ev-\:-h:.{" ¥t-.e ac~r.. ::c 6, o:\- 4:.1S. ::c" o~e.r wo{"d..s 1 \f. -\'h...Q.. 'O~~cia\ ha~ ~ <..<:>(V\~-\- ~e ac+i(.)(") L-u\~1..A c.--or 6 \-o be.. u. te ~ b't C.c.. \~ I(\ ~~ct\f~J -\i.e. Aere<~l 1'n ~A\ \~~k~ f:"V\w6.Qf' Ca.~~. s..e.e. £><..1.,,1,,~ "£')•' h~h c.tA« C.o.rr'-lin~ o~\; ~\i 6\t\c\.~\ .t\~\\es. ets Ct ~"""\ R..e..~t-\V'_ ~~ ~re. ~oJ'q\-\ol'\ c-\ ~Q. \('-,a.\ 'ec..ord. re..'t..ttr<.S &.\::.il\ G/16 \-r ~I Jw3 ~ s.s~ ,ss 1 (\e;... .20C>:D. ""~ ~re ~CJ'u\.~" c\. -\'h~ te c:.o c-d ~ue£ n o\ ~e '-Hi\\-~ ~ \.J..!. e o-\ c:\\ K.fe\-i IX') 1bu-\ \s (V'\()C'I2 in -\"N2 r.cA-we o~ ~~n\:.\-tr\c.\ oc- ct6~()~\-~q~IJe ~~~- .:r 6.<=<\. s.s.-z (clhl\g .An\-o;ne IJ .S'ilV'J Q/\ ~ An~<1J\uf\ .;::t:r!C. \\~ S..C.-\- ..2\\o7 (\'19J)j.<-o...M \)..4fu1'.W.\ o.re r. c·\ c:t\k-c\e ~ OAI..( ~-~-.ue.-\iun i.n ~.e. COSI'(\ng etA- tl{--\--hlr ~u\.Q.S. S.e.e -A<~~\(\e \\1 ~-l\. Ct-\ :l\/.1. A\~o See Mc.Lqll~ v ~~Qf&:>r) 49:l FJd l:lCZ~ l \2.'1'7 (1.~61' 1'71-0 (Coi.>J"\- ~~or.k-~ do~.<-\te_s OJ''?. ~\~\v-ICt\ 1 r~r•t c:\1- ~ue·hU'\Qf\i 1.1\ !\ct\-we. ). --rhus fn.r. ~c..h;lkr H. no\ '2.1\h\\ec\ ~ -c;-t-{;Jal .:::r""'""u."-~~1. ~--t') u.'\ \. li '\U \J I ~ . M \ \ S. (A'J ~1,\Jt>\oJ.<;. C..\~Cf\ ~\<4.1"--"\~ 0,.-,CQ.~es \'-'.~\ h11, G-"~\\.\vt<> \\Cn~«\e. El"\h\\QM.~'\\" ~r ~"'H e..o.rhe..r q:~~ase. -X"M1i~L.o..J\- ~e.~o\c~\; 0 7 OJI.~ \N\e...D on~ MB<'~~~ a~~ \!)s.\-u:"\- ~on.tla~: a. ~u\<( ~ C.ON\~Qr -the.. ~ \~\-\Qc.\\un ~oe.l.'-\.le.M re.he..C. _.tl,c.~t Me."eli seeKs. ~ ''e (\- h 1)/\c.....Q. e.. \i.si\,,~ '' k --e.OJ'li e.r r e\e-o 'i.e OJ\ ~ -1.1¥-r\ t..vh ,ct, .......,.::u 1c. "Cr-~ctk. EA~~k'"""~'-\:/1 ~1"' eoJ'\~er relea~e..~ A~ nokh by-H--.e \="1 ~Ctrcu.•~ ;(\ s~rio \J Cu..-\_~ct~C...«-llr ~\1~\e. C{ d.a~MN\t h \M"'.€ ~~ cJ::..Q n~\QaSe 1 --\1~ '\ re\e..C\S.e. CJ"\~~-H-~ct\- l~.ll>'-do Gle.c:t~ 0\h\kMM\.f..vr e_ ~'-\"1 t'J.~ \:lSIJ!;).s,C( <.~*' C\' \ 0 0 \: -6{--\-,~ -~reul j ~ ')\M\.Qd JS.h.o'-1\~ -\-'lQ Offt.c.( bL Jl..(c.c..t.l\~( 1 h~ '-u • "" 1 ~ e ~c. 0-.{l e. c_v" -b 0 e"e1\-\- / (.)(\ -\1'-{J J~ s -0'\ l.vlc..e. , t ty \ -\-o\..U e..> Q{" C C.\.~ '-'<..) .:n...\ 6 {'\ () \- -( I(..Q pe.. <:.,J;Y\ ~ II EM V\ i 0 oc-~v- o.( -\'\--.e...\~1 ('~ -:::s-u6\uc,~ <..o~.-4 1 'o...~~ ;fl~ko~ o~o \eNl~o~q J eci.~\cf\ o\:,\a;M6 -C("'l),..., "\'N: S~1....0"~ o,,\r,c~ o(: Te'l4S' Cu \\11~6. "6\'6 1 "td-~ ('i,.~hCtr 111/)(Lo.•J'\ s.-\-"'\,(\Q C..O!';v() h"'~ o{(c_p-£04-h:r{ iucln \QQ~j:SI\!V'€.rA: -{;,o{Y\ a0""ci(\-(i\r~\-\v"--€ se.~•o.-~qhun w~'-'1~ M<~U \\\(Y\ e\\~1\:,\'<'.. -~\ ~C{)o~e. ( h~~ ~s (\{)~ C<[!qe6 -\i'"¥ \...00'-'1\~ 1'<'\~-e\~ \-,,,....._ .eli_g1h\L -h,r \.u--\V\. c; C....O""-()\{lk. Q/j6..(v.(hciM\- r;ecor6 o(\ Q,\)pecA W\~~ 0'--f\·D.{.Y/!N'-.A.p(lec.l +-ou{,lrz..e-Sa 1 'J re.eor~ .S-ee Ca.!.\.)1\ l\:lF~6ct\"l>.J.\. AH\\;()')Cd~ CG\hndce! f\v-\- q ~-~·~ ~ ct\\.qcy_'n\~ Lvi\v;c.-\.,1\ o\ j .Q:.\~c£. .AJor ~uE'~ Ccdk1 J .e£./<.N S \"--0,~ ~\ ~ H'\\,v,u.. ;, c:vv..r U)""t cr o\o\-ol"' \(Y"\It"{! ~~a.-~ r e..\-eq\e ._f-e..( Qre.{;Qr IJ 'L::~f'J~L .C.rorv'\ ~ c...o/V\; ,c..to." (::.r j V\\v)U. · A"~ 1\ec I:- v f}'-"'""'(lkr -2,( 'oarreJ ec;c..l.t ~\a:(\~~~~ M.o \"'n ·t=or- }J ~ w :--r--~\~\ 't.~c..Q. ),:lo r ct_y.e 17 o-L)_~ o (\ e_ o \_ \'\,.e. ~ t. \I \\ ~ 01\\ i c\ c.; tY\ • Ihw ru \.\-.e c \::-. v i \-v-v ~key h f\'\J \,.tcvll\~ Or\ C«\~f\\ c...\o.~M'- 11/ur ~ \e\iet- Cc \A)\~QJ~\"' ~oJ''-\f'Of\t. \f\. \-.z~ fl--. ~'tl()ere,~r\ ()../\~ c\~ua\ IM"'l)./1'\-..t ~' ac.l.:-i a!fege~~ L.c ~ \Qv-e.. S.~,\!er -lhiV\ gues 011 -\-o w_gv-Q ..\-'\,c:t\ G-c\JQ!~MeAtal eJI- -\-i\,es CV10~~e-o:, ~l, A f\ i:> -¥h a.\: ~ o () Lt UJ <> ; v Q..J '0 \... , "" IVf1 \klt ~ .fos f\ e:S \ t ~Q/l ce_ C...cu.u .e 'D { o.c..\\00 \~ \1-.R \e'l-..a\.·\0,--\ CWM~ Ac\,A"~-\-o ~ 4 \.~0~'1\~ f[ea~q Grt.u ;Q.. o -\: cK. ~ 0 1"1 Lo...> 1..\\.. 11\ -\"N2 I e'!-..C~ ~ It> r \: do;"" A c-\ ..J1.-- ere ~~\ lo ~ CV\ ct.l\tjQ\\~fl o-\- "=~~'\'1 in.~w'-( ~'-(\\cr e~ ~"'-~g\'1 -\1-4l . . .ue_ 'C!t o M.J.>\.or- ~r\0-lj\ veh\UJL cr..\Wvv._r~ -11--.Q. <...-0'\~,1;,\Cil or HQ1)~ r-fq( or f~JJI\tJI I .. ~o\la,~ly, c:,fo"J l.e'I-..C.\\l·\'roc.. o--~ C-cv{>ci1.eJ Co~e f IO/.OJ'. ~we.JQJ qs. M\e~ abv-e. 0.11~ WGftt, ~r-elle~ ~<....~-\- 111 -\iQ J\]1(\\~ Ar.~~~c\ G""f\c4.1\t c.."- \M J-N'd S\..e.v-e..'~d-111\er in l,u \1)~\VJ~I.{ri( CG.'{\.:>..C·,~ \-e \C. co>J~J' rr--<:>r-,Q>-( ~l\..v\<\ges. {coCV\ ~\M 1-U\.\.lF Corv,.~J() Lo.,v0, Sec_ AJI"\;'IA .A"'..:!.'\~£6 Gu""f\o.,'(\~ o-\- fktSe_y.(ql~ G:>f)U'cle.s -\VIcA ioeca.us"- ~ le'i..ctS. IU\'\Uo.iMS. At\; \.<. -\1\e. on~ OIJV!V·€. +or G:>/V\- I"""'n Lu..,..v (le LOv V'i aso.\11.<.\c -\'he ~ a\l~I'1M.-1:1\.\ , q tl ~"t -fu~<1e.i a I( eJ e ~ o.~Ct~C1,\'t Ct ~~\!1'1'1M£1\.t '--'-"\~ 1 os-e U/\~ef' -1-N.-\-cf\- c\c.i(Y\\ qc·Lsee JJe....:.:- 1\1\CV\ 0 CJI.ofl.f\.1\.etl.QJ' lf(o0Sv:J~~ fo:l\ 1 (p.l._.J.. C\e'l.. 1'197)~ {~..;O_r C ::\\\ ~Q. ~ui')To D\-'"""\'. -;.1\.e¢ (S['-Ios-\011.~ c..,\Y\\..y CA6Ivr-(h.e..Oe(e/\~Mt Cr~.,imlo 1 Anc-\- A\\urn~i u\\-;UI.. D\- \wrOJ\\ ~~Y ~~oy\~ .Uu\ \.\a.ve &.et,&<-l>kd ~Q. '(Y\,0~.)1'\ \:l\!..M\\~ '(-;\~~ \-:1.\o-\s;' i'?.'"(lofiO/\-\- I \ \0 Ul\ (_(h..v'\~ i-\e~o.~ 1 4l-e..'tv.Ql\,~ ~c:t\--Yh..e. .S.u~\ \c.l2. d\t~\IH1 ~ 1 crt()-YI\t a.\\-v""~v--t,.\"he_ ~o.JTCV\\ eo\.A/\\,_} ~1<4-"~ ~a.\ ~~,;r'l\,(-f r~c...r...".Jif'(\ll ~~(\~ \(\ \--..\!.. ..'i'-'-\\- CJ\6 -\hct\ \asfM\ CoW\~ 1 \eco.w GO.:,~s of Gw\·· A"'~ "\'~reV\\- CoUJ\'""' 0e¥...ct!. ~.Y'tvr~2..tl~lljl Mlf 0/\oul[ ~\<;,~'\'n\\\ (' su.cJA. c-e..\te~ o:. :s:::\-s"'-..,we~ t\-~~w ~v..:,\-\'1-e'\-tMed. F'""r<~f"' o~ reQ.s;unc;:lo\...e.. reu. i>~\\j' oC -\'k ~I'Cl'Jiif' I.Z.U\~ (\-\"h, 1 fV\.,ohu0 t=Dr 1 ~\k~ "(\ 1-J- no I.e L.\ -lrhc:V\ -Gow -h~t Su -t't,Q. i(r""'jV 1/o/'b«ln.-.."' A• kJiluvJ-S: A 1.. \' \' n\.e 0- or-- f> u. f .e_ S o ~ ~ ~ "'~" \u D.l.'.<"'\\1 .Cdu\ "'' 1-.2 6-is- 1 w'r._~re\.vr-e l(ftl·•v\\e.i w().l,~Qft>6 7\'~c011.-\- WW\ ~ 71e'A.a!. /'e{v.Q\t_s ..\\v::e\· -\h\.s. s.u.\\ b.Q. ~~~ . . . \llt'd Y.~ ?rou\~+>J '-'~ein ~Od"~e c;\~ n"'<\·\v-L ~~~...,--"'-ffo.llt wW\\..t/le~qs 1 ~rayJ -\'her\ ~\o.•''l·h(fAI\er\'f'~ (c.. \to'\ c-e (J)...:Jif' f'l\lVhll\_£ b'{ ~;,~ N{f Q/\6 -i't-t~ '-1"'"'-!f(J...\-\- Ccvvtk{ f '\"""'e ~ctS re co-.J i f (...£)":>\!. of C..OvJ'\- •I =c\: i<.. 1_u\\e.. c..\eN' ¥oi.s Mo\-,IY\ I.J..)q.\ h\.e~ 'o,(-IQJ(Cil.\ Lu.M~ ( '-\e~q~ OA6Iew pek!)~CAi Gc:\...Jrul o;~.),,\(\ \)l~\qc.-\-A.\\-c.rf\.ay 'O.f. \o.sCDA\ Gl},/\7 1 \e~Q.S. ~ee \Y\R.. 'oo-\\-u/Y\ o-\ e.c.c.l.r\. o\ -\'1-e_ ~~~ p<:<.~Q.1 o~ \"he. \ eWC11t l't'-O"'vf) \o 10\lM\1{. ~Q.r-e fu ._,..,r6~ VV'- bCc\;r<'\.C\r€. '\ C>e~6.cl\\ 0:\\"";"c.\ Dl~\<>.C.\ A\\or11~ ~±:rar~ (__yWI.'-'i En\- .AmOA~QQ AruwQJ' Or..~~vl\\tl OtltwiH 1\e'i...ct-" 1 ~w-"0.Cf\\ \oelt'\~ \L\ 0 £ llie-\e'(ql(Avl( \)t<:.tl-.ct. Ar..;;.. Q.IV\edte~ Cuk. J l'h\ ~ ~~ 0 \- ~ ~"'- (>\lr\Mct. b<2.~ 1 t. I a.rr C'\\- Lo ~ \.t ;-\e•i..q.{ {>\,MI'c\-,~\ \1"'0\\iY\ 't-or )0~\,\c.\ I:Q..c f' 'J2J) ~Cl'SE' :}Oo-{ lb f\OI \Yle. c...c~""~rol D15.\uc~ A\\ur~ 0~\oJ(C-\\- Co~.\)\~ iltx.cd we ~e~,~OI\\~ \r-1. Th\~ \~u\\. A'>5.u_M ~ e :. (\. 0 \ \ f)<. \M 6.a. p or \-\ e5. .1 '-"{'6 h .\(hQ. i r o \ V. Li A m ~<>A ·\..r 1 (' ct .\i V' t\. ce~~:. \-a ~.l'-.!VC\<""Vl\-o\ m\'.\\H ~ ::x:- ~ \.e~ iow~ aga..tl\.}t /V\f". Sthiilv <11\ 0. \'a.r(CII.-\ G.:l"vd·'"l on -\1-..e +z 1"rt7J oP q ~-\,if, <'>'-1 TaJ(Ovl-\- C...O~V\~. J-k>wP.vP/' qS f\oh:.Jabcv-e.\,,J(o-.-\- G~.-V~~ C..Vul~ f\..-0\: .(;I.e c. Mil'"'i~rivc!J ~~/l rfl.. ·ftrtll c.a~ . .::.::::11 ----th.Q a. 0.J 0JL.Q o \- q I'Y"\1tfJQI pu,~Jvo.A--hjlol/OG(-e.J ..) e.t. \-\>J"m16el- v c\.-N 0~ Lu.\,\ox~ J..S]J-.0 sd 7-:-0,'7S""'<> (\t'-J:.App. ~M·Ilo .Jot)/ )" 1 """"\e'l-- ~1)-\-l!~ A .S·v C.. IAQ/"vn .z2.JJ-0Jd 'i/'lj~JI.{ n.~ L\t'i...A('oC:Jrr·--uCWtJH ~oo£ no r{'L hJ (tWhnj iO\.Illl.o (C:.) "'(l,o\- \1"-ft(<..c.J::.e,V' ~ -(he.. (cv'/.. O{ i'r._..~<.. (\-..o~c') \o Oi~rwi<..<:. '(,\-t~ un lo.e...~\~ o-\- ~\~ S.c:h\1\.lf' .::C.s.b.O.s~c\ooVKe ~G\c\- ~«\ ~~f\CQ. Platn- ~ \S.. s. \)...~ \"<\ r. \. ~\\\v-- to' ".es; \\8 VIU i br<>c.t c1r. i) ~ -h &.tc..i cvr ov.~ 0-1\~ \;-(-O-M~ .AA'c. s'i(H.Q.. (V'.r.~~1\\U' ·vJc?\':) S.U€d .her~\n ~r o,c\s c...ur"\1~1\l.e~ !11. ryv-~rMtvlLQ_ o\-~i;. o\~c.\o~oc.the<;. as C\. ~\:lvV'f\fV"Ie.tt\- ~~loyee_ ~ A'--1-\-o-na-\ivd~ V~\-i\(-e6 M!',Scl,ti\JJ' to So\.l~e.\~fl. G.;\6 ~~~L\at tm(\']t.l/tlht. c,-\-rn~ Clu'-1~ .:2..2./iJ'-'Us~q\- :ns-. J .ee. !'h-a \-\ 0 1\ """\[) 0 \5 11'\ i ~ s. a\ ~a. 5e '-L iJ.e \""-1 6 (Y\ \- -\{, &\ ,s oeJ of\ ..\-o (....ll.)f\\M6 -Vhct\ c;.-._,..;QJAIY'\Q..f\.a ~ E ......~~ f:-5.. Cu\ 6 -\1-.-'2-t[ ~o'{eE'~ oC-\-.r\~ .\t\ ~I' o\Guat C6f<:tu4y o.r('. \rvv'ILM. C. .V.u or .(..c.c\- -\-a su. Ss~s\ D./\..( wai\J...Iif' v.Q Sc.J,d\QI:S o\ \-1<-ia{ lt>~f>l(}IA(~ -fx>c-.\r-Q s\"*-e ~ C<..W <...\at'MS, .::S: -~ ex\ pc.f~ 5 • ..:C"" e'>,.V\cJ1.. W (l'V)- ~\)1"\ -\-o D's.""\s.'>. ..s.o'-"-,s."<\\: c€\\e{ VJ\~liJ 1-e~c.iv. PNt.IU""'~c...o~e ~ 10\ ( \ o ~e\v""~r.e v.J\, ~-vv,q_r C4l-kn.s.. .r'-'\\- \s. oso.il\~~ .S\-p-l--Q_ S.c__.,\-\ 1\\Q.r i 1"\ ~il. o \~-.i.a\ C.Q{luCt~ oc \n h\~ \'r,~\vi~t..(ol COfQtttt/ -Vh\ 5. CovJ'\- \'\q.S \-u I oo K !\() -\vr--\hu-- -+hOJ\ -\1\..L \CV1j40ft 0 _{ 1 10\.l O(o(-(:) 1 u.1 i ~ \)\ O'-l\ des. --\'\,e~\ "i-\ a ~v \-\- \ s.-{; I.e 6 ujQtl\~ \ CV\ 9-<'-\>\c\{eC o{ o 't)i:lv~t1'11tel\\-ol LM\\- baie6 an Ccl\6vc..~ w\~~tn ~e_ ~~.Q.JCl~ S.Ul(l.Z. o~ ~q-\ By-..~]o'{ttS e"'~lo'-{NI~\t 0/16 it i~ eo u 1 ~ \v;, ve. b ~ V\ \o rc v. Sh-\ L.V\ hv-- ~' 1 'I dwp-k~ c. _g o 111S. ~ --\1-...Q £u - ~ eri)"'"'QI\\a\ LM-1\ 1-\1'-£.. _s,.ll-t \.s. (...C;(')S\ dQfed +v \:>--e. o3o.un{-f-hi2 Q,-v-~fl o"{ee lf\ -\'t..Q .Q.:..-'"rloyee'~ a\bua\ C ~\a.~(\~\\\ fv\.o\,cf\ 'for JJ~\\\c.\ \ . (l_C... ~. :QO ~'-'SQ J4t~-\ :J./:; OJ't' JQ~r oSod oer ·d')\L.L \o~..)__\._~("{ ->Oj_ vo~ '.J)~V~)c). )"o~J)_M fY .Jn_:) V"~ + May 2, 2012 Dear Mr. Calton: I am enclosing the four hearings that I took. These dates not only match up with my records, but the Tarrant County Clerk has verified that these were the ones I took. My name was listed as the reporter on the proceedings sheets in t_he clerk's file for these four hearings and no more. Sincerely, Steve Schiller March 29, 2012 Court Reporter's Certification Board P.O. Box 13131 Austin, Texas 78711-3131 Reference: In the Matter of Steve Schiller, Cause No. 12-4665-22 Dear Sirs, I am writing this letter in answer to a complaint made against me by Mr. Allen F. Ca!t~~. To begin, let me state that I am no longer the official reporter for the 213th District Court. I have no access to records or anything else the general public can't get. Mr. Calton's main complaint seems to be the fact that he is missing some pretrial hearings from his attempted murder trial that was held back in 2004 where Mr. Calton was found guilty and sentenced to a substantial length of time. My misunderstanding arose because we had been doing pretrial hearings on several of Mr. Calton's cases for somewhere around six months along with his attempted murder case. Mr. Calton was representing himself on a Motion to Suppress in two cases and was successfi.tl in excluding the evidence on both cases. At the time I prepared the record for appellate purposes for the attempted murder case, I went to the date where I thought the pretrial hearings for the attempted murder case at hand began, and I prepared those for the Reporter's ~ecord. However, I was wrong about where those pretrial cases started. Some of them were hybrid, though not obvious, covering all his cases. Therefore I didn't transcribe those since I didn't think they were relevant to the case at hand, the attempted rnun.l~r case. As mentioned in Mr. Calton's complaint, I did have a conversation with Mr. Barry Alford, the appellate attorney, and I told him what I thought to be true at the time, that those pretrial hearings did not belong with the attempted murder case. Why would I lie to Mr. Alford? More hearings mean mor~ work for me and more money. What possible motive could I have to have lied to Mr. Alford about the hearings? I obviously wasn't at work on the day of the other hearings Mr. Calton referred to. The first notification I had from anyone about this problem was when M~. Calton sent me a letter containing some if not all of the allegations in his complaint filed with the Board. This trial was )')' ···)" .'" .,. ·\•.,;i in 2004, some eight years ago. It took some time to go through archived records .a::_dlind my_,,...,..,,,-:-·, c 'it.,, k1 \ ,. fS !( (X-tJQ 1-c{.J._ . I APR ('.5 2012 ·t) ~ ~ {~ ·,; L";'J, ~~ d·!~ ). i \ ;1 Tf::A3 CL::_, .. t ; .. .:_:~: Jl~TE:-:.'?; (;E~Ttr-!Ci.TiOr' sc;::.r.:.; ' ••• notes. Within about three to four days from the day Mr. Calton sent me the letter and before I could respond to him, I received the complaint from the Board. Even though payment arrangements have not been made, I went ahead and prepared four of the eight hearings he requested where I was the reporter. After an exhaustive search of my records, I am of the opinion that I was not the reporter on any of the remaining hearings, nor do I have any information concerning which reporters reported the other hearings or how to contact them. I did notice that Mr. Calton had their names as well as their license number. I contacted the District Clerk's office in Tarrant County, and they had no notation as to who the reporter was on those dates. At this point I don't know what else I ean do. I have prepared the hearings that I did report. I could send them to him at this peint; however the matter of payment would have to he discussed. Or should I hold on to these records until the preliminary hearing? Sincerely, Steve Schiller, CSR . ,..__.,, CAUSE NO. 12-4665-22 IN THE MATTER OF § BEFORE THE COURT REPORTERS § STEVE SCHILLER § CERTIFICATION BOARD FINAL ORDER The above styled and numbered matter carne to be considered on the 12th day of October, 2012, before the Texas Court Reporters Certification Board (Board). The Respondent, Steve Schiller (Respondent) appeared prose. The Board makes the following summary of evidence, findings of fact, conclusions of law, and final order. The Respondent has been a certified shorthand reporter since July 19, 1991. A complaint was filed by Allen Calton (Complainant) against the Respondent alleging that the Respondent failed to prepare transcripts for pre-trial hearings that were properly requested by the Complainant. 1. The Respondent is a Certified Shorthand Reporter in the State of Texas, holding certification number 4665 since July 19, 1991. 2. On or about March 22, 20 12, the Complainant filed a complaint against the Respondent. 3. Notice and copy of the complaint, and notice of the time, date and place of the !1earir:.g to be held ca October 12, 2012, ·~verc tim~ly sent to L1.e Respondent by certified mail and first class mail to his address of record. The Respondent received the notice and copy of the complaint. The Board received his response on April 5, 2012. -~ 4. The complaint alleges that, during the time the Respondent was a licensed certified shorthand reporter, the Respondent failed to prepare transcripts for pre-trial hearings that were properly requested by the Complainant. 5. Other alleged acts include failing to make reasonable inquiries about the extent of the record. 6. The Respondent appeared at the hearing on October 12, 2012 pro se. 7. At the hearing, the Board found the Respondent was in violation of the Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification, Rule X(a)(4), and imposed a private reprimand. I. The Board has jurisdiction over the complaint filed by the Complainant against the Respondent. 2. The Respondent received a copy of the complaint in accordance with section 52.027(b) of the Texas Government Code and Rule X(f)(l) of the Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification. 3. Respondent received notice of the October 12, 2012, hearing in accordance with section 52.028 of the Texas Government Code and X(i)(2) of the Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification. 4. The Respondent's actions, as referenced in the above Findings of Fact, violate the following: Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification, Rule X(a)(4): Incompetence FINAL ORDER Based upon the evidence presented in Cause Number 12-4665-22, In the Matter of Steve Schiller, the Texas Court Reporters Certification Board finds that the conduct of the Respondent, Steve Schiller, violates the Rules Governing Court Reporter Certification, Rule X(a)(4). IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED by the Court Reporters Certification Board, meeting in Austin, Texas on October 12,2012, as follows: That Steve Schiller is privately reprimanded. This Final Order is adopted by the Texas Court Reporters Certification Board effective the date of the Board Chair's signature, unless otherwise provided herein. SIGNED this 7 day of .(), ~ , 2012. Ben Woodward, Chair ' Texas Court Reporters Certification Board 3 . ' • < . IN THE 2'3th D~CTCOURT _______ TARR.ANr COUNTY, TEXAS '· ORDER APPOINTING COu"NSEL FOR THE APPEAL Al'U) . '. ORDER FOR COtJRT REPORTER TO PREPA.R.E REPORTER'S RECORD On this day, it being =de bo-;tn :::~d appeubg to the Court that the Defendant is without counsel of his own selection to represent him herein, and that" he is too poor to employ counsel, or give security therefor, to represent him herein and the Defendant having requested that an attorney be appointed to represent him in the above styled and nlllllbered cause. IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED, A..'ID DECREED by the Court that /?.a·~ lfltf.{ , a re~ly licensed and p~cticing attorney is hereby appointed to represent the Defendant as.his attorney, and said Attorney is hereby authorized to proceed to perform the duties of the Attorney for the defendant in this cause. And on this day, it appearing to the Court that the Defendant in the above styled and numbered cause, has given his/her Notice of Appeal to the Court of _ _ _ __ Appeals ofTe=. And it being made blown that the Defendant herein has filed hisfber affidavit, stating the he/she is too poor to pay the Court Reporter £or a Reporter's Record for such appeal or give security therefor. · The Court is of the opinion that ~;he Defendant is entitled to the relief as prayed 1 for. . .,'• It is therefore the ORDER of this Court that the Official Court Reporter of this " eourt. S-k >.1 e...S c.-h.~ lle r . • p~epare and ,, furnish a Reporter's Record to be .used in perfecting the appeal in this cause. I ': \ •, PRESIDING JUDGE DATE SIGl'-iED c x h L1 i ~ 0' \ pq sQ Ic t 1· 1 - '-'Y, rJ-r ... ...D- ~v'x \ ,d-'J ~Q ~ S' ~v'> 0'"7 ,ro t,41fl'l'(Jv0J ~ .._, y -1- J~j. -}Q 1 !)v :~ "~ OV"n...:r::-~vo 0-1 {).IU'U- \-vlVb\0~) \'"() -tV..,I~o-:J yo~~v ~~cy ~:}o t'-'1>!:1 v~ ysvwY'<:J o..J_ (.,~L\~ r,\w~~ '-V H~"\,\~'.1 A\-h~cw.\- .:::r>\.S"'\"fwr\ 0.\- \~i ~IY) ~)J.Q......:ilno( C?) X' \,, 0 \:, \l:;. A.lt.\-.~L o-\ \1-ean"J Gy J._.. b~uJ1 \)/1 h>r 1-\-\s o""(\' b.d ~IX\ '\=-<:>r ~-r1 \o\ l.V\~ -rt"/... C\..0\V• f. J..),O 0/1~ Jor ~'*'-"" {l..ec.onJ,)!,u-u\ou 0 l.h6Qf' f-e~.(l..Ltv IJ. (ouCblf!J orCoO(Io)(U \.4) ~ \o-~1\~c..~~ ~ce~e"\IV'\-Q,"--\ o\ ~Jil OA¢. 1-.J~\-t (Sj ~\~f\~\G AJbhU. "1\:)"\\'\e CovJ'\\lJ.Su\:,,...;t ~('\.\;"~! ot~"c-\A"c' f c_...:,~s\0'"\.S o \- L~ ~W'J\...\M 10 1r1-.(t.c:v -r. 0~1 ~7 (_(p) Le_ \ ~J'IO ~s\r\ Uct LCV\(\)(\ fLe1 V{)~\f A L1v! Cl>.c\G~-b cvy lkcvifJJ f"d.e. Vi eM D ~ ru o,, ~:~~a h D-C ~ ~(lv<'{) U:.l~ ~ Pcyw'J 6{ .fu lvW'-\- ,-"' \e-'v-€1LR. -h~ a6u~ ~},fe6 o"'~ ry..vv,~d ~1€. Ali<;) til~ Ma"'l the~J. fO-{ ~J o~ ~ J ~ &~J <> e~wn -\'M"' +-c 11---e. ~ (01-'ifdt 1'r'l ~ J. A, i _£ dJ il -€r.uw Q d. --rhQ/1 t y ()..A J A\1 ~ t•ft' CCt lk --4- 11).1 '&SO ~''('' WbA_ '3al:>o FMl.Sly G c"~+ )lx. 7/7 DS'"' ~ ~ r J l'~'l..S'> fY J03 \A'1"'-" 'll.l.o> '-'I \ "'"\: ')W '.:Jt"<"'-"' \d ... \',)j)d.Jt\\f" ~Oj'a-1'03 ?~h,J~ o&'"'\l'O{) 10 Vl, \V';"\0'-VO"J f2,b\ ~ \''d,W'-" V '-1\-l.J.'fY '5\~ 'i\'0'.>\jJQ \A<;~J~ ~.J2lC'Q \'~VJn\ J}\\V"i">\d Sl-b'(~S VQ ({:') ·ruo·}-11 ~ ?-?WJ '5;?.~1'~ vv0 0'/lf:J"Jd 1'1'\\') W~Q H J)jd--o"tJ ~ -\VCIYHJY\O J~ ~\IQ QL VQL\O"W ~JO'jl'vp~ O"' (_.3) \\oweiJ~ -+oc r~o..~~ VA'Krwv-)f1 -\u ~\~C\\.(t Q/\6 'o~ o(l~ ~\Q\1\\\~~\ GP11\m\ ~ A.Ji "~ .A.r.--..V\6-e~ Co""f\cJI\\- t.UOi n()t ~ \Q~ ~oJ''t..e ~ \:,'1. ~e c.\~\:.\ o\~~ U/)\\\ (o-t s-I.S. ( qj Of\ S -J CHS ~\ctl.l\\,\\ \-wC\~6 cv eJ -\-c ~ rI ton D~\\ua\S. ~is ,s, ~~\~V\.~ ~ '-''~ JJ; r"l~ A"'.Q/\~e6 t \ C,"&3 c.c,..._ \'\cJn~ \ l'\ a.. \'o~\c..~Q.. Qr~"<\6 €;\ve\oQt .A~6r£\!~~ \ o ~,:i.\ nc.\ (,\QJ'k.... ---f\voM-0.5. W\\~0' tiiJ\ v.J. r..e\~ ~\. 1~\~1'-\{A -;t'x... /ll\'7(.:, • B'-( ~0-(>D.!.\!o"j -\'he.. s~e \1'\ ~ ~"\s.on Mal\ \Jt.~ cf\ -t\~ .s. \ ,\e.s. \.)..,t~ . (S':) \~~IV et~Q\(\ ~~ r.Q.a~af\S. \..V\~~:~w!1 ~ Q\c:4o~~-(; CMJ bQ.'{oi\~ ~\ ~"'"'\(~ CDn\r-o\ ~ Alt"~ A~~e6 Lo~\otn\So.~ ple"'~*o...0G.S (\o\ {;\e f\"--J't.e~ b'-t -\\--..e. c».r~'.s c\hc...t.u.A~Il (o-\~-15. ((oj ~s. \\ \s. \e.o.\of\JJ.e_ -\-c ~he.I)-Q_ ~a:~ -\\-.Q. }J'"*' Arne,Jed (.....oM~\ol{\\ OJ\~ s.\.lf~\~QJ\\ -\h~e.-~ we.re... f\1:.\ C.Vn.s\ ~~eJ b'-l fh_.e. C\~\ ~\c.\: Cow--\ \."" ~R. \ e~l:l\1..!~\:l' o \- ~\e~ ~~~~l~s INA; or') \I:> OUI\'\\<,.s on ic- H ~ # (7) Of\UL ~\a.i.n~~ t~C'f\S. ov!.if' J(he_ Ma\\ (>\ ec.e.. -\-c ~ c-\~of\ ")a~ r ·d l 0 ~~..LC""D'{Y 4 \JQ__~~ ~-)Q \J~s '-X 1'~~" ~J1"\U'b\a ·s\-tt-f, uo ~b) '1-tu~ b ..nr0o 1'-T'Vr1 ~ ~P a'tf J..~ ~ n .PW d\ 't -f-V '5b~ l.P~~ 'i\'1\- ~CY3C"''~\ ' 11 -fl'tVo~ SOl-\,0~\\,~ MVJ~V' ~vm~VO)<>o UOL"(lliO~Q.l....Y''"\~ ~\/';) s~\W'i'" 0--L_l..O~ Y, "11n~\/a-;} 1 -aQ oJ\'l\'i' <::!....LV>':\<::YVV- n--~~\.h.v() ~)1¥~\~ 1, 'i.'Cb'C .S~Lb \COO QU..'C piOL 11" \Cl"\t>\ \ll:J\.V ~d~'\V'l") -J-)"\\i~\<} S\-0\:-'i vo a\~VV'Q'/.~ -J~'11\]J9-~~\') alt'\ '"'1 -ya~JOwo\'J ~ow~ -\QV (7{\~o\)J0\\"10 o't\' o ~ -JQ '-"'0\! h) ) !PW ·-s• '() ~ v ~ ~ ~ nod-av hy wcS -\wn~ 0 O\l41' -\-o ~ LU•. ~ru\o.t il!.r\)\{..Q.. 6'-( (>r\.lQI\ o~~Jols or ~.QA -*'.e. 0. V' ~ 'C>\.~c.iL- Q c...\ua \~ r e.CQiv-t~ ~':. ck(..\..VO'\ VI.-\ • !i' cA \t I..JJCI.! .(;.\e~ >(Y'.o..rKe~ IV\<>J"ILeO ~u':.~or£.. d=( \:,~-ke ~-:-ecz\J.Qsk~ "e;.vJ.y 6~ of\ So.\~ ~of\ • .\.~ ~k h.Qre cv\- l{-12.-r\ -for S:ai ~ ~~ ~~~ o( S.4.rvlc...R.. e \)re.~eA\: et 6-,}V' ~e eJ~(...\- ~ ~ Ntt~\~ \e~<>r6c..·h<¥J a..t'\6 Ad.:y -\-c A~~ial ~\cia.( G::,..,.r\'-~ D .e,..,,at o{: P\a...'n\1\\~ n'4Aton 1\) {)i~,..; ~.s ~\ WQI\. \: 0-\ S,_pee ~~ -n-\a\. A.~ VJ~I C\( \~!Q ~ 5rc~e1'i Vrol,tflO~ on Of~\'ql. ~·Q ~\oJf\\.ctl ..AJ,~ Am~~ed ~\ruf\\ r"e M \1\L.o~\- \~r\-toj ~ra.c.\-\<.U, .if-{'c,i(;ca(~ -\i.e ~1/ow;ng e\~s~re. \ (\ c..\u. ~-d~ ~ \\\h_e \C\ct~q_u.a::tQ {\_ec.oC'c\ Of\ Af(l-eol Q,ou,6e61o Cctlf (13J ~ere.. wQFe... n\l Arl'-4-t~M. ~\o..\t~~\~~,A.Jt~cw~~.:Cr. S.~flM- 0~ t-h'> ~llf\~rJJt.W\\\Cttr.--s-n.PC, o-y:.lp ~· d 1o\J ).....MI'( Joj (.:~~ )'1\ )(}-\Jod-~:; vx -1 '('Y)?f'JJ y :1) l\v:'>o \o \(\~ ,, ::1,. ~ _.S\-C(-") lJo r~.-;>)<'3 ·slot>'tr J\A/).5_ vo d)bld)L -~<-____0.\.t\-;o\"'·rj '·\) 0'-o~\d~ 'cnJcrh J~\Joc) ft~o~''J'Q'J ~ \ "1:~\,V r~o'(J "\~'J ~:l ~ v"'D {&CR. 9h '51 Q()OQ 00CI pjOL -=11 \ "0\~/ ?3"\'lO"nbO 4,vJ'\\ k£_:,.i)\,J.-\t>() oJ;. Q\c..~n\-1~(~ Of'rY\~~5 rn..o\-l\ll) Wk.JQ,...:i\'f'rctl ~ .::C UJ"-\, 1 --1-h .ot-\- I. Summary of Evidence
II. Findings of Fact
III. Conclusions of Law
Allen "F" Calton v. Steve Schiller (Allen "F" Calton v. Steve Schiller) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.