Alavoor Vasudevan v. Deepa Vasudevan
Opinion
ACCEPTED
14-14-00765-CV
FOURTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS 2/24/2015 8:36:34 AM CHRISTOPHER PRINE
CLERK
Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
FILED IN
14th COURT OF APPEALS
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS FOR THE FOURTEETH DISTRICT OF TEXAS AT HOUSTON 2/24/2015 8:36:34 AM CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE
Clerk
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
Appellant
(Defendants below)
vs.
DEEPA VASUDEVAN
Appellee
(Plaintiffs above)
REPLY BRIEF OF APPELLANT, EXCERPT OF RECORD
Appeal from the Judgment of Dissolution of Marriage entered on May 27, 2014 in the Brazoria County 300th District Court, Honorable K. Randall Hufstetler, Judge
Attorneys for Appellant below: Alavoor Vasudevan Pro Se PO Box 710163 Houston TX 77271 Email: alavoor@gmail.com Phone: 832-244-1927
Attorneys for Appellee below: Kelly McClendon (appeals lawyer) Ron Brownstein (trial court lawyer) SBN: 13407200 SBN: 03229800 P O Box 3457 5208 West Broadway, Suite 200 Lake Jackson, Texas 77566 Pearland, TX 77581 Email: kdmcclendon@comcast.net Email: rbrownstein@hotmail.com Telephone: 979-299-0755 Phone: 281-485-2770 Fax: 281-485-4128
IDENTITY OF PARTIES AND COUNSEL
Appellant’s Trial and Counsel Alavoor Vasudevan Pro Se (Appellant)
PO Box 710163 Houston TX 77271 Email: alavoor@gmail.com Phone: 832-244-1927
Annette M. Henry
Texas State Bar No. 09478020 The Henry Law Firm 1314 Texas Avenue, Suite 400 Houston TX 77002
(713) 236-1818 Fax: 281-768-2439
Appellee's Counsel Kelly McClendon
Texas State Bar No. 13407200 P O Box 3457
Lake Jackson, Texas 77566 Email: kdmcclendon@comcast.net Telephone: 979.299.0755
Ron Brownstein
Texas State Bar No. 03229800 Ron Brownstein SBN: 03229800
5208 West Broadway, Suite 200 Pearland, TX 77581
Email: rbrownstein@hotmail.com Phone: 281-485-2770 Fax: 281-485-4128
ii Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Table of Contents I. REFERENCES TO THE PARTIES AND TO THE RECORD.....7
II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE........................................................7
III. STATEMENT REGARDING ORAL ARGUMENT...................8
IV. ISSUES PRESENTED....................................................................9
V. STATEMENT OF FACTS..............................................................14
VI. SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENTS.........................................17
VII. ARGUMENT...............................................................................19
VIII. PRAYER.....................................................................................21
IX. ANSWERS TO APPELLEE's BRIEF of 30 Jan 2015...............23
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.........................................................30
X. APPENDIX......................................................................................31
Appendix A Trial Courts Judgment 08 Oct 2014 - RR3.......................31 Appendix B Trial Courts Judgment 27 May 2014 - RR2.....................32 Appendix C Final Decree of Divorce (Trial Court)..............................33 Appendix D Inventory filed by Husband.............................................34 Appendix E Court's Division based on Inventory filed by Wife..........40 Appendix F Proof filed by Husband for Community Estates...............41 Appendix G Proof filed by Husband for hidden gold bars of wife.......44 Appendix H Court reporters – Exhibit List 27 May 2014....................46 Appendix I Court Reporters – Vol 2 of 3 27 May 2014.......................47 Appendix J Texas Family Code 3.003 - Community Estates...............48
iii Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Appendix K Texas Penal Code 2.01 - Cruelty by Husband..................48 Appendix L Felony Charge on Wife's Attorney filed by Husband.......49 Appendix M Health Reports of Husband.............................................52 Appendix N Objections to Wife's Inventory........................................53 Appendix O Index from District Clerk Office......................................54 Appendix P Notice of Appeal Sent through District Clerk Office........60 Appendix Q Order From Appeals Court 19 Feb 2015..........................65
iv Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
INDEX OF AUTHORITIES
Cases: Page Baccus v. Baccus, 808 S.W. 2d 694, 700 (Tex.App. – Beaumont 1991, no writ); Disparity in income …........ 10
Rafidi v. Rafidi, 718 S.W. 2d 43, 44 (Tex. App. – Dallas 1986,no writ);Disparity in income …........ 10
Farley v. Farley; 930 S.W.2d 208 (Tex. App. – Eastland 1996, no writ) ….21
Faram v. Gervitz-Faram, 895 S.W.2d 839 (Tex. App. – Fort Worth 1995) ....21
Gaston v. Gaston, 608 S.W. 2d 556, 557-78 (Tex. Civ. App. – El Paso 1981, no writ) - Due to health conditions …......... 29
Huls v. Huls, 616 S.W. 2d 312, 317 (Tex. Civ. App. – Houston (1st Dist.) 1981, writ ref’d n.r.e.) - Due to health conditions …......... 29
Murff v. Murff, 615 S.W.2d 696 (Tex.1981. The 11 Murff factors for division of marital estate ….............…...11,13,17, 21
McCartney v. McCartney, 548 S.W.2d 435, 439 (Tex. Civ. App. Houston [1 st Dist] 1976, no writ).Physical health of parties …........ 11,20
Panozzo v. Panozzo, 904 S.W.2d 780 (Tex. App. – Corpus Christi, 1985) …..... 21
Roberts v. Roberts, 535 S.W.2d 373, 374 (Tex. Civ. App. – Tyler 1976, no writ Disparity in age …........ 10
Schleuter v. Schleuter, 975 S.W.2d 584, 588 (Tex. 1988) …....…. 10, 18
Trevino v.Trevino, 555 S.W. 2d 792, 802-03 (Tex. Civ. App. – Corpus Christi, 1977, no writ).Length of a marriage – very long or brief …........ 11
Wilson v. Wilson, 44 S.W. 3d 597 (Tex. App. – Fort Worth 2001, no pet.)........... 21
Young v. Young, 609 S.W. 2d 758, 761 (Tex. 1980). ….......... 21
Zieba v. Martin, 928 S.W.2d 782 (Tex. App. – Houston [14th Dist] 1996) ........................................................... 8, 21
v Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Rules: Chapter 3 Marital Property Rights and Liabilities …............ 15,21,22,40 Sec.3.003. Presumption of community property Sec. 3.003. PRESUMPTION OF COMMUNITY PROPERTY. (a) Property possessed by either spouse during or on dissolution of marriage is presumed to be community property. (b) The degree of proof necessary to establish that property is separate property is clear and convincing evidence. Added by Acts 1997, 75th Leg., ch. 7, Sec. 1, eff. April 17, 1997.
CHAPTER 2. BURDEN OF PROOF …..................….….............................. 40 Texas Penal Code for Proof Beyond a reasonable doubt Sec. 2.01. PROOF BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT. All persons are presumed to be innocent and no person may be convicted of an offense unless each element of the offense is proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The fact that he has been arrested, confined, or indicted for, or otherwise charged with, the offense gives rise to no inference of guilt at his trial.
Acts 1973, 63rd Leg., p. 883, ch. 399, Sec. 1, eff. Jan. 1, 1974. Amended by Acts 1993, 73rd Leg., ch. 900, Sec. 1.01, eff. Sept. 1, 1994.
vi Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
I. REFERENCES TO THE PARTIES AND TO THE RECORD Petitioner/Appellant Alavoor Vasudevan will be referred to as “ALAVOOR,”
Respondent/Appellee Deepa Vasudevan will be referred to as “DEEPA.” The clerk’s record will be referred to as “CR” followed by a reference to the appropriate page, and the reporter’s record will be referred to as “RR” for the master index, “RR2 for the record from the trial, “RR3” for the record from the motion for new trial, and “RR4” for the trial exhibits volume. The index from district clerk which was sent to Appeals Court by the District Clerk Office will be referred as “IDX” followed by page number (Appendix O). The brief of Appellee will be referred as “BR” followed by page number and brief of Appellant as “BA”.
Also this PDF document has bookmarks for easy navigation (In PDF reader, click on menu View:->Show:->NavigationPanes:->Bookmarks).
Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI
ACCEPTED
14-14-00765-CV
FOURTEENTH COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS 2/24/2015 8:36:34 AM CHRISTOPHER PRINE
CLERK
Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
FILED IN
14th COURT OF APPEALS
IN THE COURT OF APPEALS HOUSTON, TEXAS FOR THE FOURTEETH DISTRICT OF TEXAS AT HOUSTON 2/24/2015 8:36:34 AM CHRISTOPHER A. PRINE
Clerk
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
Appellant
(Defendants below)
vs.
DEEPA VASUDEVAN
Appellee
(Plaintiffs above)
REPLY BRIEF OF APPELLANT, EXCERPT OF RECORD
Appeal from the Judgment of Dissolution of Marriage entered on May 27, 2014 in the Brazoria County 300th District Court, Honorable K. Randall Hufstetler, Judge
Attorneys for Appellant below: Alavoor Vasudevan Pro Se PO Box 710163 Houston TX 77271 Email: alavoor@gmail.com Phone: 832-244-1927
Attorneys for Appellee below: Kelly McClendon (appeals lawyer) Ron Brownstein (trial court lawyer) SBN: 13407200 SBN: 03229800 P O Box 3457 5208 West Broadway, Suite 200 Lake Jackson, Texas 77566 Pearland, TX 77581 Email: kdmcclendon@comcast.net Email: rbrownstein@hotmail.com Telephone: 979-299-0755 Phone: 281-485-2770 Fax: 281-485-4128
IDENTITY OF PARTIES AND COUNSEL
Appellant’s Trial and Counsel Alavoor Vasudevan Pro Se (Appellant)
PO Box 710163 Houston TX 77271 Email: alavoor@gmail.com Phone: 832-244-1927
Annette M. Henry
Texas State Bar No. 09478020 The Henry Law Firm 1314 Texas Avenue, Suite 400 Houston TX 77002
(713) 236-1818 Fax: 281-768-2439
Appellee's Counsel Kelly McClendon
Texas State Bar No. 13407200 P O Box 3457
Lake Jackson, Texas 77566 Email: kdmcclendon@comcast.net Telephone: 979.299.0755
Ron Brownstein
Texas State Bar No. 03229800 Ron Brownstein SBN: 03229800
5208 West Broadway, Suite 200 Pearland, TX 77581
Email: rbrownstein@hotmail.com Phone: 281-485-2770 Fax: 281-485-4128
ii Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Table of Contents I. REFERENCES TO THE PARTIES AND TO THE RECORD.....7
II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE........................................................7
III. STATEMENT REGARDING ORAL ARGUMENT...................8
IV. ISSUES PRESENTED....................................................................9
V. STATEMENT OF FACTS..............................................................14
VI. SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENTS.........................................17
VII. ARGUMENT...............................................................................19
VIII. PRAYER.....................................................................................21
IX. ANSWERS TO APPELLEE's BRIEF of 30 Jan 2015...............23
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE.........................................................30
X. APPENDIX......................................................................................31
Appendix A Trial Courts Judgment 08 Oct 2014 - RR3.......................31 Appendix B Trial Courts Judgment 27 May 2014 - RR2.....................32 Appendix C Final Decree of Divorce (Trial Court)..............................33 Appendix D Inventory filed by Husband.............................................34 Appendix E Court's Division based on Inventory filed by Wife..........40 Appendix F Proof filed by Husband for Community Estates...............41 Appendix G Proof filed by Husband for hidden gold bars of wife.......44 Appendix H Court reporters – Exhibit List 27 May 2014....................46 Appendix I Court Reporters – Vol 2 of 3 27 May 2014.......................47 Appendix J Texas Family Code 3.003 - Community Estates...............48
iii Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Appendix K Texas Penal Code 2.01 - Cruelty by Husband..................48 Appendix L Felony Charge on Wife's Attorney filed by Husband.......49 Appendix M Health Reports of Husband.............................................52 Appendix N Objections to Wife's Inventory........................................53 Appendix O Index from District Clerk Office......................................54 Appendix P Notice of Appeal Sent through District Clerk Office........60 Appendix Q Order From Appeals Court 19 Feb 2015..........................65
iv Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
INDEX OF AUTHORITIES
Cases: Page Baccus v. Baccus, 808 S.W. 2d 694, 700 (Tex.App. – Beaumont 1991, no writ); Disparity in income …........ 10
Rafidi v. Rafidi, 718 S.W. 2d 43, 44 (Tex. App. – Dallas 1986,no writ);Disparity in income …........ 10
Farley v. Farley; 930 S.W.2d 208 (Tex. App. – Eastland 1996, no writ) ….21
Faram v. Gervitz-Faram, 895 S.W.2d 839 (Tex. App. – Fort Worth 1995) ....21
Gaston v. Gaston, 608 S.W. 2d 556, 557-78 (Tex. Civ. App. – El Paso 1981, no writ) - Due to health conditions …......... 29
Huls v. Huls, 616 S.W. 2d 312, 317 (Tex. Civ. App. – Houston (1st Dist.) 1981, writ ref’d n.r.e.) - Due to health conditions …......... 29
Murff v. Murff, 615 S.W.2d 696 (Tex.1981. The 11 Murff factors for division of marital estate ….............…...11,13,17, 21
McCartney v. McCartney, 548 S.W.2d 435, 439 (Tex. Civ. App. Houston [1 st Dist] 1976, no writ).Physical health of parties …........ 11,20
Panozzo v. Panozzo, 904 S.W.2d 780 (Tex. App. – Corpus Christi, 1985) …..... 21
Roberts v. Roberts, 535 S.W.2d 373, 374 (Tex. Civ. App. – Tyler 1976, no writ Disparity in age …........ 10
Schleuter v. Schleuter, 975 S.W.2d 584, 588 (Tex. 1988) …....…. 10, 18
Trevino v.Trevino, 555 S.W. 2d 792, 802-03 (Tex. Civ. App. – Corpus Christi, 1977, no writ).Length of a marriage – very long or brief …........ 11
Wilson v. Wilson, 44 S.W. 3d 597 (Tex. App. – Fort Worth 2001, no pet.)........... 21
Young v. Young, 609 S.W. 2d 758, 761 (Tex. 1980). ….......... 21
Zieba v. Martin, 928 S.W.2d 782 (Tex. App. – Houston [14th Dist] 1996) ........................................................... 8, 21
v Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Rules: Chapter 3 Marital Property Rights and Liabilities …............ 15,21,22,40 Sec.3.003. Presumption of community property Sec. 3.003. PRESUMPTION OF COMMUNITY PROPERTY. (a) Property possessed by either spouse during or on dissolution of marriage is presumed to be community property. (b) The degree of proof necessary to establish that property is separate property is clear and convincing evidence. Added by Acts 1997, 75th Leg., ch. 7, Sec. 1, eff. April 17, 1997.
CHAPTER 2. BURDEN OF PROOF …..................….….............................. 40 Texas Penal Code for Proof Beyond a reasonable doubt Sec. 2.01. PROOF BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT. All persons are presumed to be innocent and no person may be convicted of an offense unless each element of the offense is proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The fact that he has been arrested, confined, or indicted for, or otherwise charged with, the offense gives rise to no inference of guilt at his trial.
Acts 1973, 63rd Leg., p. 883, ch. 399, Sec. 1, eff. Jan. 1, 1974. Amended by Acts 1993, 73rd Leg., ch. 900, Sec. 1.01, eff. Sept. 1, 1994.
vi Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
I. REFERENCES TO THE PARTIES AND TO THE RECORD Petitioner/Appellant Alavoor Vasudevan will be referred to as “ALAVOOR,”
Respondent/Appellee Deepa Vasudevan will be referred to as “DEEPA.” The clerk’s record will be referred to as “CR” followed by a reference to the appropriate page, and the reporter’s record will be referred to as “RR” for the master index, “RR2 for the record from the trial, “RR3” for the record from the motion for new trial, and “RR4” for the trial exhibits volume. The index from district clerk which was sent to Appeals Court by the District Clerk Office will be referred as “IDX” followed by page number (Appendix O). The brief of Appellee will be referred as “BR” followed by page number and brief of Appellant as “BA”.
Also this PDF document has bookmarks for easy navigation (In PDF reader, click on menu View:->Show:->NavigationPanes:->Bookmarks).
II. STATEMENT OF THE CASE This is an appeal from a divorce proceeding. Following a bench trial, the court rendered its judgment without considering husband's inventory, without admitting wife's inventory and without investigating the protective order filed by wife (Appendix D, IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9; BR at 11). Also trial court did not confirm the separate property as per the rules 1 (Appendix E, IDX 297, RR2 pg41 line20, RR2 pg43 line10, pg44 line1, pg44 line14). Judgment was signed and entered on August 15, 2014 (CR at 348, Appendix C). ALAVOOR filed a motion to reconsider (IDX 364) which was denied and the trial court said let Appeals court handle this and Alavoor filed appeals (RR3 pg 11 line 8, RR3 page 4 line 13, IDX 373, Appendix P).
The Appellee DEEPA filed brief with Appeals court on 30 Jan 2015 raising some objections (BR 12), and Appeals court filed order on 19 Feb 2015 striking the Appellant brief of 27 Jan 2015 and ordered Appellant to file modified and amended
1 Tex. Fam. Code §3.003(b) The degree of proof necessary to establish that property is separate property is clear and convincing evidence. The proof should be strong and in papers with clear trace of money.
7 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
brief within 10 days and to provide adequate citations to the record (Appendix Q). This brief is accordingly modified to confirm with Appeals Court order and TRAP 38.1, and also answers all the objections and questions of Appellee's brief (in section IX page 20).
III. STATEMENT REGARDING ORAL ARGUMENT Appellant requested oral argument, but Appeals court denied the request.
But appellant is still open to oral argument, in case appeals court thinks oral argument is needed to clarify any questions or points.
8 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
IV. ISSUES PRESENTED 1. Trial court classified the community estates as separate properties of wife, even without clear and convincing evidence. Wife has classified the CitiNRI account, DLR account as separate property but it is a community estate as husband had provided proof (Appendix F , RR3 at 8 line 25, RR3 pg9 line11; RR2 at 41 line 20, RR2 at 42 line 16, RR2 at 43 line 10, RR2 at 44 line 1; IDX 307, IDX 339, IDX 342, IDX 364, RR4 pg 3 line 4,7,9,11,13; RR4 pg 4). In Appendix F which is same as IDX 325 Exhibit 2, appellant had shown proof that money in joint a/c about $110,000 was withdrawn by wife and deposited into Citi bank. Hence, inventory item #1 CitiNRI is a community estate. Also inventory #2 DLR land was purchased after marriage with funds from joint investments, hence it is also community estate.
As per the Texas Family Law Code, Sec.3.003 PRESUMPTION OF COMMUNITY PROPERTY, property bought during the marriage is community estate. And degree of proof necessary to establish that property is separate property is clear and convincing evidence (Ref. Texas Statutes Chap 3 Sec.3.003, Appendix J). All the luxury furniture in possession of wife was declared as separate property even though it is community estate bought during marriage.
Wife's inventory filed is Fourth Amended Inventory (RR4 Exhibit 5, Appendix H, IDX 373) which had wrong figures and incorrect amounts (RR2 page 5 line 20). Husband raised objections to wife's inventory (RR2 pg41 line20, RR2 pg43 line10, pg44 line1, pg44 line14). The trial court's judge had never said “Five is admitted”, see between “Four is admitted” (RR2 pg43 line1) and “Six is admitted” (RR2 pg49 line19). There was never a word saying “exhibit five is admitted”. Hence, wife's inventory is rejected by the trial court and judge. But in spite of this how the trial court made error by putting this Exhibit 5 as admitted? No one knows! Trial court made error. 1
1 The Trial Court’s discretion is not unlimited and, a division of property can be overturned by appellate review if it is so unjust and unfair as to constitute an abuse of discretion. Zieba v. Martin, 928 S.W.2d 782, 786-87 (Tex. App. – Houston [14th Dist] 1996, no writ). Every case must be reviewed on its own merits to determine whether an unequal distribution is justified.
9 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
2. Wife was hiding, concealing community properties like gold bars, gold coins and trial court did not give chance to husband to exhibit the documents of proof for gold and sustained the objections of wife's attorney (Appendix G , RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7, RR2 pg 77 line 7, RR4 page 3 line 13; page 4 line 4, Appendix N exhibit 13, BA pg 203). 1 ALAVOOR did disclose in his inventory about gold bars in item 3 “Jewelery and Personal effects” (IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9). ALAVOOR wants fair share of the gold(community estates) which wife is hiding and concealing.
3. Husband was not given fair treatment by trial court. Husband was denied to expose the hiding of gold assets by wife due to objection raised by opposing counsel. Judge was favoring wife's attorney for unknown reasons (may be he is his friend?). I was a stranger to Judge as I had never seen him before. Also opposing attorney Ron Brownstein was stealing husband's postal mails which came to wife's home (RR2 pg 87 line 8). A case of felony was filed by husband against the wife's attorney Ron Brownstein charging the attorney for breaking the federal/state laws and the case is pending hearing in near future in Houston District Court ( Appendix L ). And this was also referenced in the deposition of ALAVOOR taken by wife's attorney (IDX 309). If the trial court was impartial then trial court could have admitted the documents submitted by husband (ALAVOOR) and could have considered the health conditions and other factors of husband and could have awarded much higher share of the property to innocent husband. And this contention was certainly raised in trial court by husband (RR2 pg 87 line 8, IDX 304, IDX 339, IDX 364, Appendix M Health reports of husband, IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). And there are limits on Appellant to raise wrong doings of Judge (or Trial Court) because higher courts like 'Appeals Court' can handle those mistakes made by trial court and correct it. 2 1 Fraud on the community is a wrong by one spouse that the court may consider in its division of the estate of the parties and that may justify an unequal division of the property. Schleuter v. Schleuter, 975 S.W.2d 584, 588 (Tex. 1988). 2 Disparity in income Baccus v. Baccus, 808 S.W. 2d 694, 700 (Tex.App. – Beaumont 1991, no writ); Rafidi v. Rafidi, 718 S.W. 2d 43, 44 (Tex. App. – Dallas 1986,no writ); 2 Disparity in age Roberts v. Roberts, 535 S.W.2d 373, 374 (Tex. Civ. App. – Tyler 1976, no writ
10 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
4. Trial court did not consider the health conditions of the husband (Appendix M) and age factors and declared husband as being “cruel” even without any verification. The health reports of husband were sent to district clerk, Judge and to wife's attorney on 15 June 2014. Wife's attorney acknowledged/signed proof of delivery the document sent by registered email 16-Jun-14 at 09:50:54am. (See also: IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). The title was: “Prayer – Corrections to wordings in judgment” which contained health reports of husband.1 The protective orders are generally abused by wives to gain advantage and punish innocent husbands ( Appendix K ). Wife did not prove any of the charges (nor produce any witnesses) as filed by her in the protective order. And trial court made a mistake of simply taking the words in the filing of wife's protective order without any verification. (RR3 pg 5 lines 3-11, RR3 pg 7 lines 1-15, pg 8 line 9, RR3 pg 9 lines 4-10, RR2 pg 7 line 25, RR2 pg 8 line 21, IDX 8).
5. Court is there to do justice and protect the innocent but trial court did not make any attempts to protect the innocent husband and to do justice. The trial court made mistake of sustaining the objections raised by wife's attorney even though the documents submitted were correct and in favor of justice towards husband (RR4 pg 3 line 7-13 and pg 4 lines 4-6; RR2 pg 71 line 24, pg 72; ). The trial court was not responsible at all in protecting the justice and this can be corrected by Appeals court (IDX 304,307,312,325,339,364). Also appellant filed with district clerk all the documents about the health reports and objections to wife's inventory but during trial judge denied motion saying “..let court of appeals deal with it...” (RR3 pg 11 line 8; Appendix M Health reports of husband; IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). ALAVOOR cannot raise complaint in the trial court against the Judge but ALAVOOR can make complaints to the higher court like Appeals court against the trial court. Trial court ignored other factors. 2
1 Physical health of parties McCartney v. McCartney, 548 S.W.2d 435, 439 (Tex. Civ. App. Houston [1st Dist] 1976, no writ).
2 Length of a marriage – very long or brief Trevino v. Trevino, 555 S.W. 2d 792, 802-03 (Tex. Civ. App. – Corpus Christi, 1977, no writ).
11 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
6. Judge denied motion saying that “You have filed in appeals court, hence let the Court of Appeals deal with it from this point and hence I deny the hearing...” (RR3 pg 11 line 8, Appendix A). ALAVOOR filed several complaints with Judge/District clerk to correct the judgment (IDX 304,307,312,325,339,364; RR3 pg 4 lines 19-25; pg 5; RR3 pg 8-10; RR3 pg 12 line 4), and also gave verbal testimony/request to judge during the second trial. But trial court made mistake of denying motion simply saying “let appeals court handle it from this point” (RR3 pg11 line8).
7. Trial court did not consider: Fault In The Failure Of The Marriage: Husband is innocent divorcee because wife rejected/dumped the husband due to bad health (Appendix M IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). Trial court did not consider the “Benefits The Innocent Spouse Would Have Received By Continuation Of The Marriage”: Akin to the assessment of fault approach is the compensation for the losses the innocent spouse will suffer by reason of the divorce. Certain valuable benefits may be lost (and perhaps be irreplaceable) as a result of the divorce. The original petition of divorce filed by ALAVOOR mentions about the how the division of property should happen (IDX 46). Petitioner should be awarded a disproportionate share of the parties' estate for the following reasons: fault in breakup of the marriage; fraud on the community; benefits the innocent spouse may have derived from the continuation of the marriage; disparity of earning power of the spouses and their ability to support themselves; physical health of the spouses; education and future employability of the spouses; ages of the spouses; earning power, business opportunities, capacities, and abilities of the spouses; increase in value of separate property through community efforts by time, talent, labor, and effort; expected inheritance of a spouse; the size and nature of the separate estates of the spouses; length of the marriage.1
1 Supreme Court in Murff v. Murff, 615 S.W.2d 696, 700 (Tex. 1981) cited a number of factors (11) that can be specifically considered by the Court in making an unequal division of the marital estate
12 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
The Appendix M is part of the record (IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). Trial court also did not consider the factor that ALAVOOR is suffering from diabetes, dementia (Alzheimer due to diabetes). Trial court failed to help the disadvantaged due to health problems. Also, trial court wrongly deduced fault in the break-up of the marriage, as protective orders are abused and no proof or witnesses were produced by wife (RR3 pg 5 line 9, pg 7 lines 1-15). The trial court was blind and did not consider the objections of husband against the protective order and the valid health reasons of husband (RR3 pg5, pg7).
Disparity Of Earning Capacities: A gap between the business opportunities available to the spouses, a disparity in incomes, a difference in earning capabilities, and associated facts may affect the division of property. 1
Physical Condition, Health: Physical health (or lack thereof) which affects the division of property between the spouses (Appendix M IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). 1
Difference In Ages: A disparity in the ages of the parties may have a bearing upon ability to work, eligibility of a party for retirement benefits, etc. and, therefore, is a factor in dividing property. Husband is older to wife by 7.5 years. 1
1 Supreme Court in Murff v. Murff, 615 S.W.2d 696, 700 (Tex. 1981) cited a number of factors (11) that can be specifically considered by the Court in making an unequal division of the marital estate
13 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
V. STATEMENT OF FACTS Summary
Date of Marriage : 29 March 1992 (RR2 pg 20 line 25) Age of the Parties: Husband 52 yrs (DOB 07 July 1962)
Wife 44 yrs (DOB 17 Nov 1969)
Ages of Children Daughter 19 yrs (DOB DD MMM YYYY) Support: Husband paid child support until daughter graduated from high school. Divorce Dissolution: 27 May 2014 Trial court, Brazoria Second Hearing : 08 Oct 2014 Trial court, Brazoria
This is a divorce case involving the issue of property division (IDX 297, RR2, RR3, RR4). Husband seeks modification of the judgment of dissolution (RR2) to award him greater than 60% of the community estates (IDX 364, IDX 339). And to classify the properties which were wrongly termed as the separate estates of wife into community estates. Also to modify the terms used in trial court's judgment where in the husband was declared doing “cruelty” (RR2 pg 92 line 19) even without doing any verification of cruelty and without any proof or witness for cruelty. Wife needs to update the inventory as of 27 May 2014 as her inventory filed is old and used old financial statements and not as of May 2014 (Appendix D, IDX 364).
Nature of Judgment After a trial to the court, a Judgment of Dissolution of Marriage was entered (IDX 348, RR2). Such judgment forms the basis for this appeal. Trial court awarded higher percentage (60%) of community estates to wife without considering the real facts of the innocent husband (husband's health, age, earning power, community estates and other factors) (Appendix M, IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18).
Effective Date for Appeal Since the health conditions of husband was very bad (IDX 312, RR3 pg5), wife had filed false Protective Order to gain higher divisions in the properties
14 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
instead of filing divorce first. On June 27, 2011, wife filed for Protective Order in cause number 63935 (IDX 8), thereafter temporary orders were issued dated July 22, 2011. On 19 Jan 2012 husband filed for divorce in cause number 66539; wife filed a counter-petition for divorce and these two actions were consolidated under the lower cause number 63935 on 29 Mar 2012 (IDX 46). The Judgment of Dissolution of Marriage was entered on 27 May, 2014 and trial court awarded 60% to wife even without considering the health conditions of husband, earning capacity of wife and other factors. And thereafter a new trial to reconsider was filed by husband and it was heard on 8 October 2014, but was denied on the basis that “Notice of Appeals” was filed with 14th Court of Appeals and no justice was done to husband. The Notice of Appeal was filed on 14 Sep 2014. Husband denied the charges of cruelty as they were falsely framed by wife without any proof or witness. ((RR2 pg 92 line 19, RR2, RR3, RR4)
General Summary
The parties were married in 29 March 1992 when husband was 29 and wife 22 (RR2 pg9). Husband had completed his education at that time, having received Master's degree in 1989 and was working for tech company in California. Wife was still attending medical college (RR2 pg18) and husband supported financially and physically to complete the degree and residency in USA. Baby daughter was born and husband was taking care of the baby while wife was doing college residency. Husband, in addition to supplying the great bulk of the income during wife's schooling/residency, also shared in the domestic chores (Ref: Oral, written depositions (IDX 321) ).
After the parties married, husband was the main source of income for the family until wife started earning in 1998 (RR2 pg 25 line 21).
At the time of hearing, wife was earning $200,000 p.a. and husband was making $90,000 p.a (RR2 pg 19 line 21).
In the year 2005, husband was having serious health problems (Appendix M, IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18) due to diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, liver problems and eye problems (glaucoma) and was taking medications (Ref: Health reports of husband Appendix M). Wife did not like the health problems of
15 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
the husband and was extremely unhappy. The health problems of husband caused rifts in marriage relationships and caused great amounts of agony. The health problems of husband worsened over time. And the health problems of husband are the major cause of the divorce. From 1992 until 2005, the relationship between wife and husband was very good. After 2005, there were no financial problems as wife was earning large amounts for the family and also husband was earning but there were major health issues of husband. Because of the health issues, husband had problems with the employment. The diabetes was causing serious problems and resulted in memory loss and reduced the focus and capability in engineering job. And hence, husband lost several jobs/employment. In June 2011, wife filed for protective order (IDX 8, RR3 pg 5 lines 3-11, RR3 pg 7 lines 1-15, pg 8 line 9, RR3 pg 9 lines 4-10, RR2 pg 7 line 25, RR2 pg 8 line 21, IDX 8) to throw out the husband and husband made lots of efforts to save the marriage but of no use. Wife indirectly forced husband to file divorce in Jan 2012 and wife also counterpetitioned divorce (IDX 46). Wife had concealed substantial community estates in form of cash, gold bars, gold coins, jewelry and did not disclose those in the inventory (RR3 pg9). Husband tried Motion to Compel discovery but it was denied on March 2013 (IDX 87). The divorce hearing was on 27 May 2014 but justice was not done to innocent husband (RR2). Husband filed for motion for reconsideration trial and on 8 Oct 2014 trial court heard the hearing but did not do any justice and simply referred to Appeals court application and left the decision for Appeals court to decide (RR3 pg11 line7, Ref: Court Reporters records). The trial court did not consider the inventory filed by husband (RR3). And wife's inventory was having amounts and figures which were very old out-dated and were not as of 27 May 2014 (day on which divorce hearing occurred).
16 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
VI. SUMMARY OF THE ARGUMENTS Wife's classification of CITINRI account ($120,000) and DRL Lands ($52,000) and gold jewelry is without merit because wife had not submitted clear and convincing evidence as per Texas Family code sec3.003. (Appendix F same as IDX 325 Exhibit 2, RR3 at 8 line 25, RR3 pg9 line11; RR2 at 41 line 20, RR2 at 42 line 16, RR2 at 43 line 10, RR2 at 44 line 1; IDX 307, IDX 339, IDX 342, IDX 364, RR4 pg 3 line 4,7,9,11,13; RR4 pg 4).
Wife's filing for protective order is falsified and without merit because there is no proof, witness, medical reports, police reports of any harassment by husband for the past 22 years. Trial court's declaration of husband as cruel is wrong and incorrect because of no verification (IDX 8, RR3 pg 5 lines 3-11, RR3 pg 7 lines 1- 15, pg 8 line 9, RR3 pg 9 lines 4-10, RR2 pg 7 line 25, RR2 pg 8 line 21, IDX 8).
Trial court's award of 60% to wife is without merit because it is like rewarding the guilty and punishing the innocent. Trial court was tilting in favor of wife's attorney because the judge may be close friend of wife's attorney and husband is a stranger. Trial court did not consider health of husband and other factors (age, earning capacity, Murff factors1), husband deserves more than 60% share of property division 1. (IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9). Appendix F Proof filed by husband for community estates (RR3 pg 5 line 12, RR2 pg 4 line 9, RR2 pg 78 line 4 and line 10, RR2 pg 88 line 19, IDX 364, RR4 page 3 line 4, RR4 pg 3 line 9,11,13,14, page 4 line 4)
_________________________________________________________
1 The Supreme Court in Murff v. Murff and many intermediate appellate courts have cited a number of factors that can be specifically considered by the Court in making an unequal division of the marital estate. See e.g. Wilson v. Wilson, 44 S.W. 3d 597 (Tex. App. – Fort Worth 2001, no pet.); Farley v. Farley; 930 S.W.2d 208 (Tex. App. – Eastland 1996, no writ); Zieba v.Martin, 928 S.W.2d 782 (Tex. App. – Houston [14th Dist] 1996, no writ); Panozzo v. Panozzo, 904 S.W.2d 780 (Tex. App. – Corpus Christi, 1985, no writ); Faram v. Gervitz-Faram, 895 S.W.2d 839 (Tex. App. – Fort Worth 1995, no writ). The Supreme Court has held that the circumstances of each marriage dictate what factors the trial court will consider in dividing the community property. Young v. Young, 609 S.W. 2d 758, 761 (Tex. 1980). The existence of one or more of these factors must be proven by a preponderance of the evidence in order to support a disproportionate division.
17 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Wife's submission of inventory is not up to date in figures and amounts and all the inventory figures(amounts) were old, out of date and incorrect. They were not as of May 2014 and also trial court did not consider the inventory submitted by husband while dividing properties. The trial court did not admit the Wife's inventory as trial court's judge had never said “Exhibit Five is admitted”, see between “Four is admitted” (RR2 pg43 line1) and “Six is admitted” (RR2 pg49 line19).
If Trial court suppresses exhibits/documents from innocent and supports the attorney of guilty then the final judgment will favor only the guilty and the innocent will get punished. But there is chance provided by law so that appeals court can correct it and protect the innocent and punish the guilty.
Trial court did not consider the fraud on community property by wife, as wife was hiding gold bars and jewels. (Appendix G , RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7, RR2 pg 77 line 7, RR4 page 3 line 13; page 4 line 4, Appendix N exhibit 13, BA pg 203) 1.
1 Fraud on the community is a wrong by one spouse that the court may consider in its division of the estate of the parties and that may justify an unequal division of the property. Schleuter v. Schleuter, 975 S.W.2d 584, 588 (Tex. 1988).
18 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
VII. ARGUMENT Texas laws provides that the appellate court will review the case on both the law and the evidence. The trial court's decision must be reversed if it was not legally correct and if the trial court's decision is punishing the innocent and rewarding the guilty. The law must protect the innocent and punish the guilty. The appellant's argument is:
THE TRIAL COURT'S DECISIONS TO DECLARE COMMUNITY ESTATES (CITINRI A/C, DLR LAND, GOLD BARS) AS SEPARATE PROPERTY WITHOUT ANY CLEAR AND CONVINCING PROOF AS PER TEXAS FAMILY LAW CODE sec 3.003 IS NOT LEGALLY CORRECT. TRIAL COURT ALSO ERRORED IN TAKING THE OLD AND OUTDATED FIGURES IN THE WIFE'S INVENTORY, AND DID NOT TAKE INTO CONSIDERATION THE LUXURY FURNITURES AS COMMUNITY ESTATES. TRIAL COURT DID NOT ADMIT WIFE'S INVENTORY. 1
THE TRIAL COURT DECLARED THE HUSBAND AS CRUEL2 EVEN WITHOUT VERIFYING THE WITNESS, POLICE RECORDS, MEDICAL REPORTS TO PROVE CRUELTY. HUSBAND WAS LIVING WITH WIFE FOR MORE THAN 20 YEARS AND THERE IS NO SINGLE POLICE REPORT, MEDICAL REPORT SUPPORTING CRUELTY, TRIAL COURT WAS BLINDLY TAKING WHATEVER WAS WRITTEN PROTECTIVE ORDER WITHOUT CHECKING ITS VALIDITY AND PROOF. ACTUALLY WIFE WAS BATTERING HUSBAND BECAUSE OF HUSBAND'S ILL HEALTH.
1 Trial court's judge had never said “Exhibit Five is admitted”, see between “Four is admitted” (RR2 pg43 line1) and “Six is admitted” (RR2 pg49 line19), Appendix H, RR4, IDX373.
2 Trial court's declaration of husband as cruel is wrong and incorrect because of no verification (IDX 8, RR3 pg 5 lines 3-11, RR3 pg 7 lines 1-15, pg 8 line 9, RR3 pg 9 lines 4-10, RR2 pg 7 line 25, RR2 pg 8 line 21, IDX 8)
19 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
TRIAL COURT ALSO DID NOT CONSIDER THE SEVERE HEALTH CONDITIONS1 OF HUSBAND WHILE DIVIDING PROERTY AND EARNING CAPACITY OF WIFE WHO IS MEDICAL DOCTOR AND THE FAULT IN BREAKUP OF MARRIAGE.2
THE TRIAL COURT ALSO ERRORED BY “TILTING” IN FAVOUR OF THE WIFE'S ATTORNEY, MAY BE BECAUSE THE APPELLANT IS A STRANGER AND UNKNOWN TO JUDGE BUT JUDGE IS A CLOSE FRIEND OF THE WIFE'S LAWYER.
The Texas family code says that any asset or property bought during the marriage is a community estate unless the party provides the court with clear and convincing evidence to prove that it is a separate estate.
1 Health conditions of husband is very bad (Appendix M, IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18).
2 Physical health of parties McCartney v. McCartney, 548 S.W.2d 435, 439 (Tex. Civ. App. Houston [1st Dist] 1976, no writ).
20 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
VIII. PRAYER a) Award the husband greater than 60% of community property division because of poor health conditions of husband, age disparity between wife and husband, and income disparities (Appendix M, IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18).
b) Classify CITINRI bank a/c and DLR land as community estate, as wife had no proof of them as separate estates. Husband had submitted proofs that they are community estates (Ref: Appendix F, IDX 325 Exhibit 2, RR3 pg 5).
c) Order wife to update the financial statements in the inventory as of 27 May 2014.
d) Order wife to disclose the 14 gold bars, gold coins and jewelry being hidden by her in the inventory and other hidden assets. (Appendix G, RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7)
e) Remove the term cruelty of husband from judgment, as wife had not submitted any proof of cruelty like - witness, recordings, video, police reports, medical reports of the same and there was no basis for that at all. (Appendix K, RR2 pg 92 line 19)
f) Appeals court can order wife to pay spousal support to husband for 7 years.
g) Pay for the appeals cost.
h) Accept the Inventory filed by husband Appendix D (IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9; BR at 11)
For the above reasons and authorities stated, the Appellant respectfully requests
21 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
that the judgment of the Brazoria District Court be reversed, do not consider the appellee's Brief (DEEPA's brief) and appellant be given the relief requested.
Dated: 22 February 2015 Respectfully submitted
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
________________________
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN Pro Se PO Box 710163 Houston TX 77271 Email: alavoor@gmail.com Phone: 832-244-1927
Statement as to Typeface: The font used in this Brief is Times New Roman and the type size is 14 point.
22 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
IX. ANSWERS TO APPELLEE's BRIEF of 30 Jan 2015 Appellant ALAVOOR files this reply brief in response to the brief of Appellee which was filed on 30 Jan 2015. And requests the Court to reject brief of appellee and to consider appellant's brief in total and full including the Issues (section V page 15) and grant the prayer (section IX page 24) as in this reply brief. The requests made by the Appellee is against the natural justice and against the human values and dignity of human life. The Appellee is unnecessarily bringing up trivial rules and is desperate to suppress the truth, and obstruct the justice to innocent Appellant. Trial court completely ignored the fact that appellant ALAVOOR is suffering from serious health issues while dividing the property and also committed several other mistakes as detailed below. These mistakes of trial court can be rectified by Appeals court.
The court is there to do Justice and to protect the innocent and punish guilty. The trial court's ruling goes against this statement and had damaged this very foundation of the law which is to “protect innocent and punish guilty”. And Appeals court can rectify the mistakes of trial court.
In this reply brief, all the false complaints of appellee are addressed and minor changes like adding references and additional trial court document “Index from district clerk” is added in Appendix O. BR 7 says “... Appellant's allegations are not supported by record...”. But appellant's allegations are indeed supported by the record and this reply brief clearly shows those issues in section V page 15. BR 8 Appellee's brief is falsifying and trying to mislead the Appeals court (BR at 8), as it says “presents no issues for review, no statement of facts, no argument, and no prayer for relief” even though the brief filed on 27 January 2015 is indeed having sections for Issues (sec III BA at 7), statement of facts (sec IV BA at 9), argument (sec VI BA at 12), prayer (sec VII BA at 14). Also Appellee in BR at 8 (3) says redactions are inadequate without specifying details and Appellant's brief is properly redacted as requested. Appellee is desperately trying to bring up trivial issues to disrupt justice. BR 8 Appellee says “no notice of appeal is included in the clerk’s record, the
23 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
appeal should be denied...” (BR at 8). But TRAP 25 says “If a notice of appeal is mistakenly filed with the appellate court, the notice is deemed to have been filed the same day with the trial court clerk, and the appellate clerk must immediately send the trial court clerk a copy of the notice.” See also Appendix P 'Notice of Appeal from District Clerk' and RR3 page 4 line 13, IDX 373. Again, this is a trivial issue appellee is trying to snowball.
BR 9 Appellee says “...He failed to comply with TRAP 38.1...TRAP 33.1” but this brief by appellant has all the sections as per TRAP 38.1 and complies with it and complies with TRAP 33.1 (Rule 38. Requisites of Briefs - 38.1. Appellant's Brief). In this brief references to court records are included.
Record references and citation to authorities: TRAP 38.1 Index of Authorities. This brief includes some of the citation mentioned in the Index of Authorities. And Appellant's brief is fully complying with TRAP 38.1
TRAP 33.1: This rule requires appellate complaints to be supported by record references and by citation to authorities. The brief is wholly devoid of a single reference to the record. When a party fails to include references, the appellate complaint is waived. See, Nguyen v. Kosnoski, 93 S.W.3d 186, 188
Added references in all the sections, in the "Issues Presented" CR references for items are added.
Appendix D Third Amended Inventory Filed by Husband is on record (BR at 11, IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9) Appendix F Proof filed by husband for community estates (BR 11, RR3 pg 5 line 12, RR2 pg 4 line 9, RR2 pg 78 line 4 and line 10, RR2 pg 88 line 19, IDX 364, RR4 page 3 line 4, RR4 pg 3 line 9,11,13,14, page 4 line 4) Trial court made mistake of not admitting Appendix F during 1st trial. And in the 2nd trial when this issue pointed (RR3 pg 10 line 14), the judge said since appeal is being filed, let
24 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
appeals court deal with it (RR3 pg 11 line 8). Appendix G 'Missing items in inventory': Wife's handwriting 14 Gold bars (BR 11). The Appendix G was referenced in trial and in court filings (RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7, RR2 pg 77 line 7, RR4 page 3 line 13; page 4 line 4, Appendix N exhibit 13, BA pg 203) Appendix H is exhibit index as reported by trial court (IDX 373). Appendix I is a marker for record below. Appendix L Felony charge on Wife's attorney, a separate case is filed against wife's attorney for his violations. And this is related to this case and referenced at (RR2 pg 87 line 8-25) and this was also referenced in the deposition of Alavoor taken by wife's attorney (IDX 309). Appendix M Health reports of husband. The health reports of husband were sent to district clerk, Judge and to wife's attorney on 15 June 2014. Wife's attorney acknowledged/signed proof of delivery the document sent by registered email 16- Jun-14 at 09:50:54am. (See also: IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). The title was: “Prayer – Corrections to wordings in judgment” which contained health reports of husband. BR 12 Regarding TRAP 33.1 “...failed to preserve his complaints....”, appellant had indeed made the complaint to trial court via Motion to “Reconsideration of Trial and Notice of Appeal” (IDX 364, RR3 pg 4 line 13, pg 8 line 18, pg 10 line 5, pg 10 line 23, pg 11 line 7). The trial court Judge denied the motion saying “...you have already given notice of appeal, so we'll let the Court of Appeals deal with it....”(RR3 pg 11 line 7) and no justice was done to innocent husband. Appellant also filed in Trial Courts several documents raising objections to inventory and to the wordings in the decree. So this proves ALAVOOR did preserve his complaints. BR 12 each of the seven issues appellant had given the reference to appendix. In this doc now has references to the court records. Appellant did bring up these seven issues to the Trial Court but the trial court either denied admission or sustained the objection of the wife's attorney. Trial court did injustice to husband (may be because wife's attorney is a friend of trial court judge?). Also appellant did not hire lawyer because could not afford high very fees of attorney. Trial court made a
25 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
grave mistake of not admitting the exhibits and documents of the appellant. When the court does not admit documents from innocent and sustains objections of guilty party, and admits all the documents of the guilty then the guilty will win the case and innocent will be hanged to death!!
Issue one: BR 13 says “RR3 at 3” but there is only index at page 3. Also BR 13 says“... inventory, which was admitted without objection...”, appellant raised objections to inventory filed by wife (RR3 at 8 line 25; RR2 at 41 line 20, RR2 at 42 line 16, RR2 at 43 line 10, RR2 at 44 line 1; IDX 307, IDX 339, IDX 342, IDX 364, RR4 pg 3 line 4,7,9,11,13; RR4 pg 4).
Wife's inventory filed is Fourth Amended Inventory (Exhibit 5) which had wrong figures and incorrect amounts (RR2 page 5 line 20). Husband raised objections to wife's inventory (RR2 pg41 line20, RR2 pg43 line10, pg44 line1, pg44 line14). The trial court's judge had never said “Five is admitted”, see between “Four is admitted” (RR2 pg43 line1) and “Six is admitted” (RR2 pg49 line19). There was never a words saying “exhibit five is admitted”. Hence, this proves that wife's inventory is rejected by the trial court and judge. But in spite of this how the trial court made error by putting this Exhibit 5 as admitted? No one knows!
Wife verbally telling in the court is not the proof of establishing a property as community estate but needs to provide all the documents and proof beyond any doubt. Wife DEEPA had not provided any such proof. BR 13 says “.. were identified on her inventory, which was admitted without objection.....” is proved as a false statement by this paragraph and references in this para. Issue two: BR 14 “...Deepa hide gold bars, Appendix G not part of court record...”, is again wrong, the Appendix G was referenced in trial and in court filings (RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7, RR2 pg 77 line 7, RR4 page 3 line 13; page 4 line 4, Appendix N exhibit 13, BA pg 203). ALAVOOR did disclose in his inventory about gold bars in item 3 “Jewelery and Personal effects” (IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9). Hence BR page 14 is proved wrong. Issue three: BR 14 Appendix L Felony charge on Wife's attorney, a separate case is filed against wife's attorney for his violations. And this is related to this case and
26 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
was referenced at (RR2 pg 87 line 8) and this was also referenced in the deposition of Alavoor taken by wife's attorney (IDX 309). If the trial court was impartial then trial court could have admitted the documents submitted by husband (ALAVOOR) and could have considered the health conditions and other factors of husband and could have awarded much higher share of the property to innocent husband. And this contention was certainly raised in trial court by husband (RR2 pg 87 line 8, IDX 304, IDX 339, IDX 364, Appendix M Health reports of husband, IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). And there are limits on Appellant to raise wrong doings of Judge (or Trial Court) because higher courts like 'Appeals Court' can handle those mistakes made by trial court and correct it. Appellant can raise those contentions and seek justice from higher court like 'Appeals Court'. And appellant (ALAVOOR) is doing it now in 14th Appeals Court. Issue four: BR 15 ALAVOOR's health, age of parties, cruelty finding Appendix M and K. Appendix M is indeed part of the record. The health reports of husband were sent to district clerk, Judge and to wife's attorney on 15 June 2014. Wife's attorney acknowledged/signed proof of delivery the document sent by registered email 16-Jun-14 at 09:50:54am. (See also: IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). The title was: “Prayer – Corrections to wordings in judgment” which contained health reports of husband. In the first trial appellant forgot to mention about health conditions because appellant cannot remember due to diabetes which causes memory loss (diabetes causes dementia, Alzheimer). But appellant did submit to the court, judge and district clerk the copies of health reports (IDX 312).
Appendix K 'Texas penal code 2.01 – Cruelty of Husband' is relevant to this case, as wife did not prove any of the charges (nor produce any witnesses) as filed by her in the protective order. And trial court made a mistake of simply taking the words in the filing of wife's protective order without any verification. (RR3 pg 5 lines 3-11, RR3 pg 7 lines 1-15, pg 8 line 9, RR3 pg 9 lines 4-10, RR2 pg 7 line 25, RR2 pg 8 line 21, IDX 8).
Hence, due to above reasons, appeals court will indeed take into consideration the issue four. Issue five: BR 15 “...no attempt to protect innocent husband and do justice....”. The trial court made mistake of sustaining the objections raised by wife's attorney
27 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
even though the documents submitted were correct and in favor of justice towards husband (RR4 pg 3 line 7-13 and pg 4 lines 4-6; RR2 pg 71 line 24, pg 72; ). The trial court was not responsible at all in protecting the justice and this can be corrected by Appeals court (IDX 304,307,312,325,339,364). Also appellant filed with district clerk all the documents about the health reports and objections to wife's inventory but during trial judge denied motion saying “..let court of appeals deal with it...” (RR3 pg 11 line 8; Appendix M Health reports of husband; IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). ALAVOOR cannot raise complaint in the trial court against the Judge but ALAVOOR can make complaints to the higher court like Appeals court against the trial court or judge. In case the trial court makes mistakes/errors and if you go against the judge in trial court, then it becomes contempt of court. ALAVOOR can appeal to higher court only. Because of all these reasons, the appeals court must consider the issue five. Issue six: BR 15 “...No evidence was admitted, physical or testimonial...”. ALAVOOR filed several complaints with Judge/District clerk to correct the judgment (IDX 304,307,312,325,339,364; RR3 pg 4 lines 19-25; pg 5; RR3 pg 8- 10; RR3 pg 12 line 4), and also gave verbal testimony/request to judge during the second trial. But trial court made mistake of denying motion simply saying “let appeals court handle it from this point”. Hence, issue six must be considered by appeals court.
Issue seven: BR 16 “.. fault in the break-up ...”. The original petition of divorce filed by ALAVOOR mentions about the how the division of property should happen (IDX 46) and below are excerpts from it: Petitioner should be awarded a disproportionate share of the parties' estate for the following reasons, including but not limited to:
a. fault in the breakup of the marriage; b. fraud on the community; c. benefits the innocent spouse may have derived from the continuation of the marriage;
d. disparity of earning power of the spouses and their ability to support themselves;
e. health of the spouses;
28 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
h. education and future employability of the spouses; k. ages of the spouses; l. earning power, business opportunities, capacities, and abilities of the spouses;
s. increase in value of separate property through community efforts by time, talent, labor, and effort;
v. expected inheritance of a spouse; y. the size and nature of the separate estates of the spouses;
And Appendix M is part of the record (IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). Trial court also did not consider the factor that ALAVOOR is suffering from diabetes, dementia (Alzheimer due to diabetes). Trial court failed to help the disadvantaged due to health problems 1.
Also, trial court wrongly deduced fault in the break-up of the marriage, as protective orders are abused and no proof or witnesses were produced by wife (RR3 pg 5 line 9, pg 7 lines 1-15). The trial court was blind and did not consider the objections of husband against the protective order and the valid health reasons of husband (RR3 pg5, pg7). Hence, appeals court must consider this issue seven.
All other sections in this brief are now part of this “Reply Brief of Appellant”. BR12 TRAP 33.1 Added citations to record and authorities to seven issues in BA.
_________________________________________________________
1 Huls v. Huls, 616 S.W. 2d 312, 317 (Tex. Civ. App. – Houston (1 st Dist.) 1981, writ ref’d n.r.e.) - Due to health conditions
Gaston v. Gaston, 608 S.W. 2d 556, 557-78 (Tex. Civ. App. – El Paso 1981, no writ) - Due to health conditions
29 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the above and foregoing “Brief of Appellant” was directed to Appellee Deepa Vasudevan, by and through their attorney Kelly McClendon, SBN: 13407200, P O Box 3457, Lake Jackson, Texas 77566 email: kdmcclendon@comcast.net phone: 979-299-0755, via email on this 22 February 2015. Total word count = 10913 Total number of pages = 30 (excludes appendix)
________________________
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN Pro Se PO Box 710163 Houston TX 77271 Email: alavoor@gmail.com Phone: 832-244-1927
30 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
X. APPENDIX Appendix A Trial Courts Judgment 08 Oct 2014 - RR3 The trial courts judgment is attached in case envelope and also the exhibits.
And this is sent directly to the 14th Appeals Court from the Court Reporter, 300 th District Court. This is Reporter's Record Vol 3 of 3 by Kim Keeler, CSR, 300 th District Court.
See also the “Order denying motions 10-8-14” (IDX 372).
As per TRAP 38.1(k)(1) which says brief “must contain a copy of the trial court's judgment or other appealable order from which relief is sought”. Hence, included here is the copy of the trial courts record RR3.
31 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
1 REPORTER'S RECORD
2 VOLUME 3 OF 3
3 TRIAL COURT CAUSE NO. 63935
4
5 DEEPA VASUDEVAN * IN THE DISTRICT COURT
6 VS. * BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
7 ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN * 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT
8
9 ********************************************************
10 MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL
11 ********************************************************
12 On the 8th day of October, 2014, the following
13 proceedings came on to be heard in the above-entitled and
14 numbered cause before the Honorable K. Randall Hufstetler,
15 Judge presiding, held in Angleton, Brazoria County, Texas.
16 Proceedings reported by Machine Shorthand.
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A-P-P-E-A-R-A-N-C-E-S:
2
3 COUNSEL FOR DEEPA VASUDEVAN:
4 Mr. Ronald Brownstein Attorney at Law 5 TBN: 03229800 5208 Broadway Street, Suite 200 6 Pearland, Texas 77581 (281)485-2770 7
8
9
10 COUNSEL FOR ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN:
11 Mr. Alavoor Vasudevan Pro Se 12 PO Box 710163 Houston, Texas 77271 13 (832)244-1927
14
15
16
17 REPORTED BY:
18 Kim Keeler, CSR Deputy Court Reporter 19 300th Judicial District 111 E. Locust, Rm. 401 20 Angleton, Texas 77515 (281)352-0863 21
22
23
24
25
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 INDEX
2 VOLUME 3 OF 3
3 MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL
4 OCTOBER 8, 2014
5 Page Vol.
6 Appearances ......................... 2 3
7 Motion for new trial ................ 4 3
8 Court's Ruling ...................... 10 3
9 Adjournment ......................... 14 3
10 Court Reporter's Certificate ........ 15 3
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL
2 THE COURT: All right. Let's go on the
3 record in 63935 set on today's docket for hearing. What
4 do we got, reconsideration? Is that one set today?
5 MR. BROWNSTEIN: If I may, Your Honor.
6 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Mr. Alavoor Vasudevan has
8 filed several post-trial matters with the Court. Some of
9 them are entitled motions.
10 I think all of them collectively are, in
11 essence, new trial motions, motions for rehearings or
12 reconsiderations.
13 He's also given notice of appeal that has --
14 we received notice from the Fourteenth Court of Appeals.
15 So I believe all of these collectively are,
16 in essence, a request for a new trial. I don't know if
17 Mr. Vasudevan will agree with me on that, but I think
18 collectively that's what they would represent.
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, it's in regards to the
20 old inventory because there were several items which were
21 not supplemented by my wife. Like she's not provide proof
22 that estates are separated estates. Also, she has not --
23 she failed to update the inventory figures.
24 And also, in my previous correspondence dated
25 21 June, 2014, I had stated that the wife has failed to
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 submit proof about abuse and physical abuse and murder and
2 financial abuse.
3 Wife has also failed to submit any medical
4 reports or police reports or videos, recording, or
5 witnesses to prove cruelty of the husband.
6 THE COURT: To prove?
7 MR. VASUDEVAN: The cruelty of the husband.
8 THE COURT: Okay.
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: The final judgment you said
10 that the husband is cruel, so the wife has not provided
11 any proof, so -- the protective order said also abuse.
12 The husband provided -- and even on the
13 inventory, Item No. 1, which is the City Bank -- and I
14 provided the proof that it's not -- it's not separate, but
15 it's a community estate.
16 So there was other items, also. In my
17 correspondence on -- dated 12 June, I said that there was
18 no abuse or cruelty; and I provided proof of my health
19 conditions, like diabetes and blindness, kidney problems,
20 and liver disease.
21 THE COURT: Let me take care of one of those
22 for you real quick. All right?
23 MR. VASUDEVAN: Uh-huh.
24 THE COURT: In your correspondence you
25 complain that there was no rape or sexual abuse.
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
2 THE COURT: All right. There's not anything
3 in the record that says there was. What you are reading
4 is a docket entry that says: "Record, dash, R. Rape,
5 evidence presented."
6 My court reporter's name --
7 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, in her statement she was
8 saying, "I was abused sexually." That's what she said.
9 THE COURT: But in your correspondence you
10 say there was no evidence of rape. That's not what that
11 statement says. That's just -- my court reporter's last
12 name is Rape.
13 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I know that. Yes.
14 THE COURT: So let me take care of that.
15 That's not what that docket entry says.
16 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
17 THE COURT: Okay?
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
19 THE COURT: So any complaint about that,
20 that's not what that is saying.
21 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, that's fine.
22 But in her statement when she was talking,
23 she was saying, "I was abused sexually and financially"
24 and all that. She was saying that.
25 THE COURT: Okay.
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. VASUDEVAN: So what I'm saying is there's
2 no such thing like sexual abuse or rape or anything like
3 that and no physical injury or anything like that.
4 What it just says in the protective order,
5 it's simply written and nothing of such thing happened.
6 And I provided a copy of that protective order, also.
7 There she has simply written on there but
8 there is nothing of such thing happened and there is no
9 proof. She has not provided any proof. And there is no
10 911 calls or police reports or any of such thing.
11 She -- they simply write this protective
12 order just to get the protective order and just to throw
13 the husband out of the house. That's what they use that
14 for, I think; and probably it's all done by the lawyer and
15 not by my wife.
16 THE COURT: Mr. Brownstein.
17 MR. BROWNSTEIN: If I may respond, Your
18 Honor. On May 27th this Court heard this case. My client
19 was the only party to offer testimony and exhibits, other
20 than me regarding attorney's fees. Mr. Alavoor declined
21 to testify.
22 Immediately prior to trial -- which was May
23 27th -- on April the 2nd, we supplemented discovery. On
24 May 5th -- now, this is 2014; and the trial was May 27th,
25 2014 -- we filed our Third Amended Inventory.
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 On May the 7th, 2014, we amended our -- we
2 supplemented our inventory again. And then on May the
3 9th, 2014, we filed our Fourth Amended Inventory.
4 Your Honor, way back on June 27th, 2011 --
5 that's when the first application for a protective order
6 was entered -- the parties reached an agreement back on
7 June 28th, 2011, regarding temporary orders.
8 The case brought before you was just on the
9 divorce. The protective order and the divorce were
10 consolidated.
11 And, Your Honor, we believe that the decision
12 that you made was correct. There has been no suggestion
13 of newly discovered evidence. Mr. Alavoor is complaining
14 that he feels that your division of property was unfair
15 and that he feels it was unfair that you found grounds for
16 divorce not only insupportability but cruelty.
17 And as much as he has now appealed this to
18 the Fourteenth Court of Appeals, Your Honor, I'm asking
19 this Court to deny all post-trial motions of Mr. Vasudevan
20 in a proposed order that I have before this Court and to
21 deny a new trial.
22 We think your decision was accurate based
23 upon the evidence, and we ask that you deny all of these
24 motions.
25 MR. VASUDEVAN: I raise objection to his
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 statements, Your Honor, because what amended inventory
2 they filing, they have not updated the figures according
3 to the latest statements.
4 And also, on the protective order, what of it
5 has she written? It's not written by her. And there is
6 no proof that there was any cruelty.
7 So to date, they have not submitted anything;
8 and I asked them to. I also send a copy to the opposing
9 counsel to submit the proof, if they have any; but so far
10 I have not gotten any.
11 Also, for one of the items, No. 2, the DLR
12 interest, it's a land that she purchased during the
13 marriage; and it's, as per law, it is -- it's a community
14 estate. CHECK INTERNET COURT RECORDS FOR THIS
15 And she has not provided any proof that it's
16 a separate -- the burden lays on her to submit the proof.
17 She has not given any solid proof to the Court.
18 And also, there was some gold, which -- a lot
19 of gold she was hiding, like 14 gold bars and jewelry.
20 And all this she has not disclosed that in the inventory
21 at all. She's hiding and concealing.
22 So the inventory, whatever they submitted, is
23 wrong; and it's not correct and accurate.
24 So what I'm requesting the Court is they
25 should -- the Court should order them to correct the
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 inventory and give the latest -- update all the items.
2 And they need to update the statements and
3 submit the statements, all the financial statements.
4 So I hope that justice will be done here; and
5 if I don't get justice, then I may be forced to go to
6 appeals court, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals.
7 And I don't want to go spend that much time
8 in the Court of Appeals; and it takes a lot more time, so
9 I want to settle this in this Court.
10 THE COURT: Give me just a minute. Let me go
11 pull my notes and look at the Court's file. I'm going to
12 pull my notes and come back and let you know what we're
13 going to do.
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: Your Honor, I'll give you the
15 same copy which I sent it to you before.
16 THE COURT: I have all that. It's all
17 electronic. That's what I've been looking at.
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: You have all that. Okay.
19 (Brief recess.)
20 THE COURT'S RULING
21 THE COURT: All right. I have looked at
22 the -- I'm going to call it the Motion to Reconsider,
23 which was filed 9/12/2014 by Mr. Vasudevan. I have looked
24 at the other notices that were filed and the Notice of
25 Appeal.
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 I've also looked at the decree, the
2 inventories that were filed, and I've looked at my notes
3 from the time of the hearing.
4 And I will find that the motion for new trial
5 should be denied. The decree will stand as the final
6 order.
7 And you have already given notice of appeal,
8 so we'll let the Court of Appeals deal with it from this
9 point out.
10 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I have a proposed order I
11 believe that encompasses your ruling, Your Honor. If you
12 feel that is accurate, we ask that -- in essence, denied a
13 new trial.
14 THE COURT: Yes. All right. Anything else?
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: Your Honor, they submitted
16 the Third Amended Inventory; and they need to update the
17 inventory, so they have not updated it yet.
18 THE COURT: They filed a Fourth Amended
19 Inventory --
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: But those figures were not
21 updated. They just simply did a fourth one.
22 THE COURT: I understand you might not
23 believe that they are accurate, but that was the latest
24 inventory --
25 MR. VASUDEVAN: That's old figures.
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: That's the latest inventory that
2 was filed by Mr. Brownstein on behalf of his client.
3 In looking at the Court's file, I think --
4 MR. VASUDEVAN: I also filed one Third
5 Amended Inventory. You might have got it along with that.
6 THE COURT: When did you file that?
7 MR. VASUDEVAN: It was on July --
8 THE REPORTER: I'm sorry. July what?
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: 2014.
10 THE COURT: After the trial.
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: Right.
12 THE COURT: Okay. It may be filed, but it
13 was not filed such that it could be considered by the
14 Court.
15 Your inventory that I considered at the time
16 of the trial was -- I think that was filed October, 2013.
17 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, no. It was in May.
18 THE COURT: May?
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah. I took an oath; and
20 then on the same day I submitted it, an inventory.
21 THE COURT: Submitted another inventory?
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, the second inventory.
23 THE COURT: I have one that was introduced as
24 an exhibit.
25 I saw your notes to correct her inventory.
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Did you file a separate inventory?
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
3 THE COURT: On what day?
4 MR. VASUDEVAN: On the same day. I took an
5 oath, and then I submitted.
6 THE COURT: What day?
7 MR. VASUDEVAN: On 27th May.
8 THE COURT: 27th May. The day of trial?
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, the day of the trial.
10 THE COURT: Okay. That may have been the
11 exhibit that was introduced. I did have an inventory that
12 was filed or introduced as an exhibit that day, but I
13 don't have the exhibits. Those are upstairs in the
14 clerk's office.
15 If it was an updated one, I did take that
16 into consideration at the time of the trial on May 27,
17 2014.
18 I can't take into consideration an inventory
19 that was filed after the trial because it would be late.
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay. It would be late; but
21 for this trial, I think -- I thought you would consider
22 that in today's hearing.
23 THE COURT: Well, there's certain things that
24 have to be presented in the motion for new trial hearing;
25 and I can't tell you what those are. I can't help you
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 represent yourself.
2 I understand that you're representing
3 yourself, but I can't show you how to do those things.
4 All right?
5 So my ruling is that the motions for new
6 trial will be -- or motion to reconsider, which might also
7 be known as a motion for new trial, will be denied.
8 MR. BROWNSTEIN: May we be excused?
9 THE COURT: Yes. Thank you.
10 (Hearing concluded.)
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE STATE OF TEXAS )
COUNTY OF BRAZORIA )
2
3 I, Kim Keeler, Deputy Court Reporter in and for
4 the 300th District Court of Brazoria County, State of
5 Texas, do hereby certify that the foregoing contains a
6 true and correct transcription of all portions of evidence
7 and other proceedings requested in writing by counsel for
8 the parties to be included in this volume of the
9 Reporter's Record, in the above-styled and numbered cause,
10 all of which occurred in open court or in chambers and
11 were reported by me.
12 I further certify that this Reporter's Record of
13 the proceedings truly and correctly reflects the exhibits,
14 if any, admitted, tendered in an offer of proof, or
15 offered into evidence.
16 I further certify that the total cost for the
17 prepartion of this Reporter's Record is $150.00 and
18 was paid by Alavoor Vasudevan.
19 WITNESS MY OFFICIAL HAND this the 12th day of
20 November, 2014.
21 /s/Kimberly Keeler Kimberly Keeler, CSR 22 Certification Number: 8253 Expiration: December 31, 2014 23 Deputy Court Reporter, 300th Judicial District Brazoria County 24 111 E. Locust, Rm. 401 Angleton, Texas 77515 25 (281)352-0863
KIM KEELER, CSR DEPUTY COURT REPORTER 300TH DISTRICT COURT
Appendix B Trial Courts Judgment 27 May 2014 - RR2 The trial courts judgment is attached in case envelope and also the exhibits.
And this is sent directly to the 14th Appeals Court from the Court Reporter, 300 th District Court. This is Reporter's Record Vol 1 of 3 by Renee Rape, CSR, 300 th District Court.
As per TRAP 38.1(k)(1) which says brief “must contain a copy of the trial court's judgment or other appealable order from which relief is sought”. Hence, included here is the copy of the trial courts record RR2.
32 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
1 REPORTER'S RECORD
2 VOLUME 1 OF 3 VOLUMES
3 TRIAL COURT CAUSE NO. 63935
4 APPELLATE COURT CAUSE NO. 14-14-00765-CV
5
6 IN THE MATTER OF * IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE MARRIAGE OF * 7 * DEEPA VASUDEVAN * 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT 8 AND * ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN * 9 * AND IN THE INTEREST OF * 10 PALLAVI DEV, A CHILD * BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
11
12 ********************************************************
13 MASTER INDEX
14 ********************************************************
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A P P E A R A N C E S
2
3 MR. ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
4 PRO SE
5 Post Office Box 710163
6 Houston, Texas 77271
7 Phone: (832) 244-1927
8 PETITIONER
9
10 AND
11
12 RONALD A. BROWNSTEIN
13 SBOT NO. 03229800
14 5208 West Broadway, Suite 200
15 Pearland, Texas 77581
16 Phone: (281) 485-2770
17 ATTORNEY FOR RESPONDENT/COUNTER-PETITIONER,
18 DEEPA VASUDEVAN
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 CHRONOLOGICAL INDEX
2 VOLUME 1 - MASTER INDEX
3
4 VOLUME 2 - TRIAL ON FINAL MERITS
5 MAY 27, 2014 PAGE VOL
6 Witnesses Sworn by the Court .................. 6 2
7
8 COUNTER-PETITIONER/
9 RESPONDENT'S WITNESSES DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS VOL
10 Vasudevan, Deepa 8 59 81 2
11 Brownstein, Ronald Allen 83 86 2
12
13 Counter-Petitioner/Respondent Rests ........... 88 2
14 Petitioner Offers Exhibits .................... 88 2
15 Petitioner Rests .............................. 92 2
16 Court's Orders ................................ 92 2
17 Court Adjourned ............................... 96 2
18 Court Reporter's Certificate .................. 97 2
19
20 VOLUME 3 - MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL
21 OCTOBER 8, 2014 PAGE VOL
22 Appearances ................................... 2 3
23 Motion for New Trial .......................... 4 3
24 Court's Ruling ................................ 10 3
25 Adjournment ................................... 14 3
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 CHRONOLOGICAL INDEX CONTINUED
2 VOLUME 3 - MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL - (continued)
3 OCTOBER 8, 2014 PAGE VOL
4 Court Reporter's Certificate .................. 15 3
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 ALPHABETICAL INDEX OF WITNESSES
2 WITNESS' NAME DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS VOL
3 Brownstein, Ronald Allen 83 86 2
4 Vasudevan, Deepa 8 59 81 2
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 OFFICIAL REPORTER'S RECORD
2 CERTIFICATION PAGE
3
4 THE STATE OF TEXAS)
5 COUNTY OF BRAZORIA)
6
7 I, Renee Rape, Official Court Reporter in and for the 300th District Court of Brazoria County, State of Texas, 8 do hereby certify that the above and foregoing contains a true and correct transcription of all portions of 9 evidence and other proceedings requested in writing by counsel for the parties to be included in this volume of 10 the Reporter's Record, in the above-styled and numbered cause, all of which occurred in open court or in 11 chambers and were reported by me.
12 I further certify that this Reporter's Record of the proceedings truly and correctly reflects the exhibits, 13 if any, admitted by the respective parties.
14 I further certify that the total cost for the preparation of this Reporter's Record is $576.00 and was 15 paid/will be paid by Petitioner, Mr. Alavoor Vasudevan.
16 WITNESS MY OFFICIAL HAND this the 17th day of November, 2014. 17
18
19 /s/Renée Rape ____________ Renée Rape, Texas CSR# 4031 20 Expiration Date: 12-31-16 Official Court Reporter, 300th District Court 21 Brazoria County, Texas 111 East Locust, RM 402 22 Angleton, Texas 77515 979-864-1229 23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
Appendix C Final Decree of Divorce (Trial Court)
The trial courts final decree is attached in case envelope. And this is sent directly to the 14th Appeals Court from the District Clerk Office, Brazoria. See the index IDX 348 (see also: Appendix O).
As per TRAP 38.1(k)(1) which says brief “must contain a copy of the trial court's judgment or other appealable order from which relief is sought”. Hence, included here is the copy of the Final Decree of divorce.
33 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
-_ ilpl-‘I: ‘-1- . I ,_ |'| ." | "l .I --.,_
F. 1- I '-
IL‘!
I--.
1}?.' -1-IT
—I Ill
-
-1-.13‘
_____ 7'_'
Pa".h ‘T - .
'__ --I-|__‘
.I‘
r.3-1.,HTh L)? _‘_._UI:4:
r.'-=1 3;;--:3
-.
N0. in--I
Cfgd;;?1%"'I¢-’l1..
UfL_|||=|Jr___| ___
'f"r’;" w =""""'
-\.||-|_i,:.--:l__r|=|_
,.~""!|_.-fir‘
‘I .
B'T'_____ qu -.=._ ..~'n;-r" [_jn__'“Jlm_H:
THE MARRIAGE OF
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN AND SOOTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT DEEPA VASUDEVAN
AND IN THE INTEREST OF P.D., A CHILD OC7J¢0'€’>O05GUJ€0C-'JC£7>'Z»O0 BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
Fl1"~iAi... BECREE OF DIVGRCE
Orr May 2?; am the Ceart heard rhis ease.
xigrpeeraeees
Peririerier and Ceuriterresperiderrt, ALAVGOR VASUDEVAN {liereinafier “Feiitierier“)
ere se, appeared iri perserr and aririerrrieeri ready tier rriai.
Respeadeni arid Ceiirirerpetitierier, DEEPA VASi..iDEV.fiN, (hereiriaiier “Respeadeat*”)
appeared iri perseri aria rhreugli aiterriey ef reeerri, RON EROEYNSTEEN, sari aririeurreed ready
Fer triai.
Reeera’
The reeerd ef testiaieay was ciuiy reported by the eeurr reperter fer the BUQTH Iiidieial
Qisifiei Ceiir'r., Ms. Rerree Rape.
Jririsrfieiiea and Driarieife
The Ceert firrds rhai the pieariirrgs ef Rfifipfifiiiflili are in due ferrri arid eeritairr ail the
aiiegarieris. ieferrriatieri, arid prerequisites required by iaw. The Criert, after reeeivirig evidenee,
firids ihai it has jiirisdieiieri ef {his ease arid er aii rhe parties arid that at ieast sisry days have
eiapseri siriee the dare the sriit was fiieri.
13357 l
The Court further finds that, at the time this suit was filed, Respondent had been a
domiciliary of Texas for the preceding six~month period and a resident of the county in which
this suit was filed for the preceding ninety-day period. All persons entitled to citation were
properly cited.
Jury
A jury was waived, and questions of fact and of law were submitted to the Court.
Divorce
IT IS ORDERED AND DECREED that DEEPA VASUDEVAN, Respondent, is granted
a divorce from ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN, Petitioner, and the marriage between them is
dissolved on the grounds of insupportability and cruelty committed by Petitioner against
Respondent.
Child qfthe Marriage
The Court finds that at the time of the filing of this divorce action, the following child of
the marriage was subject to the jurisdiction of the Court:
Name: PALLAVI DEV
Sex: Female
Birth date: l 2/O7/1995
Home state: Texas
Social Security number: xxx-xx-x195
The Court further finds that on the date of hearing, said child was older than eighteen
years of age and had received a high school diploma from an accreditied secondary school and
was no longer subject to the jurisdiction of this Court; save and expect however, the Court
retains jurisdiction regarding the child’s property described below:
Child 's Property
The Court finds that the below described property and accounts are confirmed as the sole
and separate property of the adult child, PALLAVI DEV and it is further ordered that DEEPA
VASUDEVAN and ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN shall transfer, deliver, and convey said property
to PALLAVI DEV on or before June l3, 2014, to wit:
1. UTMA- LPL account #xxxxl549, American Funds account #xxxx0367
2. UTMA- LPL account #xxxx0721
3. Computer (located in upstairs office)
4. Kindle
5. Laptop, Apple
6. Laptop, pink
7. Piano (located downstairs bedroom)
Division 0fMarz'tal Estate
The Court finds that the following is a just and right division of the parties‘ marital estate,
having due regard for the rights of each party.
Property to Husband
IT IS ORDERED AND DECREED that the husband, ALAVOOR VA SUDEVAN, is
awarded the following as his sole and separate property, and the wife is divested of all right, title,
interest, and claim in and to that property:
H-l. The following described real property in India, to wit:
a. PLOT NO 16., SY N0 107/A & l070/AA OAK GARDENS, AVC
TOWNSHIP, UPPERGUDA h/O kHALSA IBRAHIMPATNAM, IBRAHIMPATNAM, R.R.
I)ist.
b. House Gandhinagar India, l/6th share.
H-2. All household furniture, fumishings, fixtures, goods, art objects, collectibles,
appliances, and equipment in the possession of the husband located at 8701 Gustine Lane,
Apt#59l 8, Houston, TX 77031, or otherwise subject to his sole control.
H-3. All clothing, jewelry, and other personal effects in the possession of the husband
located at 8701 Gustine Lane, Apt#59l8, Houston, TX 77031, or otherwise subject to his sole
controi.
i--Ml. Ali funds on deposit, together with accrued but unpaid interest, in the foiicwing
banks, savings institutions, or other tinanciai institutions in the husbands soie narnc or froin
which the husband has the sote right to withdraw funds or which are subject to the husi:-and‘s sole
controi:
a. BANK (J? AMERICA, Account nurnber sax:-t33§t2
tn. TDECU Checking Account nunrber transit? I9
e. 'i"I3EtT'ti Savings Account nurnber snxsd? 19
d. ‘i?v’]iiLLS FARGO, Account number s;xsit3t]59
e. Wti.t..LS FARGO, Account nuinber x:cor’F4:51
f. 529 PLAN~ MES account tinssaddfio. t..i¢tL irirs.nutJ'?32
g. CITESANK, i-i.A., Account nurnber nxxirfifiii
ti. HDFC, Account nurnber itxsx29-=1
i. iteatth Savings Ptan with Fidelity account iisxx93t5
j. PayPai
H-5. Ail surns, tviiether rnatured or unrnatured, accrued or unscented, vested or
otherwise, together with ati increases thereof, the proceeds therefrorn, and any other rights
related to the fiillowing retirernent account:
a. WELLS FARGO 401K, Account nurnbcr attic
H-6. The following individual retirement accounts:
a. ROLLOVER IRA LPL, Account number xxxxO72S
b. ROTH IRA LPL account #xxx0726, American Funds account #xxx8660
H-7. A portion of DEEPA VASUDEVAN's retirement benefits in the UNIVERSITY
OF TEXAS ORP MENTOR 403B PLAN arising out of DEEPA VASUDEVAN's employment
with the UT HEALTH SCIENCE CENTER AT HOUSTON as of May 27, 2014, that portion
being $128,567.09 and more particularly defined in a Qualified Domestic Relations Order to be
hereinafter entered by the Court.
H-8. The following policies of life insurance (including cash values):
a. NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL, Policy number xxxxl 672
b. NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL, Policy number xxxxl74l
c. F&;G LIFE INSURANCE
H-9. The 2009 TOYOTA COROLLA motor vehicle, vehicle identification number
lNXBU4DE59ZC88294, together with all prepaid insurance, keys, and title documents.
Property to Wiffi
IT IS ORDERED AND DECREED that the wife, DEEPA VASUDEVAN, is awarded
the following as her sole and separate property, and the husband is divested of all right, title,
interest, and claim in and to that property:
W—l. All household furniture, fumishings, fixtures, goods, art objects, collectibles,
appliances, and equipment in the possession of the wife located at 3402 Castle Pond Court,
Pearland, Texas, or otherwise subject to her sole control.
W-2. All clothing, jewelry, and other personal effects in the possession of the wife
located at 3402 Castle Pond Court, Pearland, Texas, or otherwise subject to her sole control.
W-3. All funds on deposit, together with accrued but unpaid interest, in the following
‘trunks, savings institutions, or other tinanciat institutions in the wife*s sote name or frorn which
the wife has the sole right to withdraw funds or which are subject to the witie‘s sole controi.
a. BANK OF AMERICA, Account number xxxx8479
b. CAPITAL ONE, Account number xxxx2066
c. MERRILL EDGE, Account number xxxxl4S04
d. TOD LPL account #xxxx0729, American Funds account #xxxx3 620
e. TOD LPL, Account number xxxx5742
f. 529 PLAN- LPL account #xxxx0724, Fidelity #xxxx8707
W-4. All sums, whether matured or unmatured, accrued or unaccrued, vested or
otherwise, together with all increases thereof, the proceeds therefrom, and any other rights in
wife's UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS ORP METNOR 403B PLAN, save and except the sum
$128,567.09 awarded to husband out of wife‘s UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS ORP METNOR 403B
PLAN and more particularly described in a Qualified Domestic Relations Order to be hereinafter
entered by the Court.
W-S. The following individual retirement accounts:
b. ROTH IRA LPL account #xxx0723, American Funds account #xxx8662
W-6. The following policies of life insurance (including cash values):
a. NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL, Policy number xxxxl 84]
b. NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL, Policy number xxxxO804
W-7. The 2010 VOLVO C30 motor vehicle, vehicle identification number
YVl672MK6A2l78-413, together with all prepaid insurance, keys, and title documents.
W-8. The 2010 MERCEDES-BENZ E3 50W motor vehicle, vehicle identification
number WDDHF5GB5AA223383, together with all prepaid insurance, keys, and title
documents, subject to the terms and conditions in a lease contract concerning said motor vehicle.
ti} 12* tn..ii1.cd.t.aad iT ES ORDERED AND DECREED that the husband, ALAVOOR UASUDEVAN, shail
pay, as a part of the division of the estate of the parties, and shatl indernnify and hold the wife
and her property harrntess trorn any failure to so discharge, these iteins:
I-t-1. Tbs foiiowing debts, charges, liabilities, and obligations:
a. Debt owed to DISCOVER, Account nurnbcr ns.x:sR85i
H»-2. All debts, charges, iiabilitics, and other obtigations incurred solety by the husband
troni and after tune 2t}! i unless espress provision is rnade in this decree to the contrary.
i-iv}. Ail encurnbranccs, ad valorcrn taxes, Eicns, assessrnents, or other charges due or to
beconie due on the property awarded to the husband in this decree untess er-tpress provision is
rnade in this decree to the contrary.
.9-tats it.i..IiFi..fn IT ti"; ORD’E.RED AND DECREED that the wife, DEEPA VASUDEVAN, strait pay, as a
part of the division of the estate otthe parties, and shall indernnity and hotd the husband and his
property itanniess tiorn any failure to so discharge, these iterns:
W-l. The balance due, including principai, interest, and all other cbarges, on tire
prornissory note payable to W’£i.t..LS FARGO DEALER SERVECES and given as part of the
purchase price of and secured by a ticn on the 201$ VOLVO C313 nrotor vehicle awarded to wife.
W-2. The fotiowing debts, charges, liabitities, and obligations:
a. Debt owed to CAP ETAL ON E, Account nunibcr x.s.:s.:i:7063
b. Debt owed to DZSCOVER, Account nurnbcr ssiraoribil
c. Debt owed to BANK OI’ Ai‘viERtCA. Account nurnber xxirs.?493
7'
W-3. Ali dehts, ehargess iiaeiiities, and ether eeiigatiens ineerreti seieiv by the vvifie
fre-in and after Iuae 291 E unless express erevisiee is inade in this deeree te the eentiarv.
Wei. All eneumhraeees, ae vaieiem tases. iiees, assessments, er ether ehaiges dee er te
heeeree due en the preperty awarded te the vvife in this eeeree artiess eseress psevisieri is iriacie
in this cieeree te the eentrteqv.
IT {S ORDERED AND QECREED that eaeii party sitaii seat! te the ether party, vrithie
three says ef its reeeipt, a eepy ef any eeneseeneeriee fretn a erediter er taxing aetherity
eeiteereing any eeteetiai iiahiiitv ef the ether psitv.
Previsiens Beating with Residenee
The Ceurt makes the feiievviag erders regarding the residenee et‘ the parties ieeated at
3402 Castie Peed Ceiiit, Peeeitzetd, Tesas raere partieaiariv deseribeii as fetievvss te vvit".
LOT SIXTEEN {E6}, EN ELOCK ONE‘. {E}, FINAL ?I.JAT YILLAGES OF
EDGELWATER ERTATES, 5ECTtO1\i TWO (2), PEARLANI), HRAZOEUA
COUNTY, TEXAS, A€(IORDii=lG THE MAP OR RLAT ”FHEI-{EOF RECORDED
iN ‘v’£">£.UtvtE. 20 t1’A(iES 135*???-ti Ct? TI--{E i’LP~Ji' RECORD8, BRAZGRIA
COUNTY, TEXAS.
IT [S ORDEREL1 that QEEPA ‘~JASIJD§£VAi\E sttali have the eseiesive right te the use,
eessessieri, anti eeeepariey ef the residenee. DEEPA VASXEQEVAN snail eeatirree te snake ati
inenttiiy rnertgage payments et" prineipai and interest eue en any prentisstiry aete given as part
ef the pereitase prise ef the residenee.
Cetnrneneing Aagtzst E5, 2814., the iesidenee vviti be eiaeeci en the market fer sale. in the
evmit that DEEFA EFASUQEVAN and ALAVOUR VASLiI3E\?Ai“-I reeeive a valid earnest
rneney eentraet ef sale by a ttiirti pasty that is seeeptaleie te DEEPA VA$UBEVAI'~‘ anti
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN, then 1'JtiEi"A VASLEDEVAN shalt have the first right te purehase
ALAVOOR vaatteevana net eqnitv in the hense en the sente tenns and eenditieris as are
effered hy the third party. DEEPA VASUUEYAN shat} have ~45 days te rnateit the pereitese
priee effer rrtatie by the third pertv by arranging fer the payment te ALA‘v'O£3R VASKEZJEYAN
the perehase priee efferent by the third party less the feli payment ef the rnertgege indebtedness
and tess enevhaif the resetting difterenee paid te AI..,A‘-EOOR VASUDEVAN as his eqnity. Upen
pagan ent te §tL.1‘W’{)OR VAS LJDEVAN, he shall transfer att ef his right, titte, and interest in the
residenee te ‘£)ILiE.PA i-z'.~’t.3t,iI1}E‘€i='*t¥*3 hv Genera? Warranty tlreetii.
in the event DEEPA ‘v'n$U£)iiiVrk1\t eieets net ta ntateh the third patty pnrehase effer,
then the parties are free te aeeent the third party effer. Shenlcl the sate et the erepertv eteset the
net sate preeeeds {defined as the gresa sate priee tess eest et sate and fut} payment et any
nsertgage ineehteeness er liens en the prepertv} sheik be eistrihnted as feltetvs:
1. One-haif { U2) te DEEPA VASl.JDEVAt*~i;, and
2. One-heit‘ {E E2} te ALAVOOR vasueavr-tn
In the event the sale et the ertitierty eees net eiese, then DEEFA 'v'ASUDEV§&N’s right
te ptlttlitaee AI.,A'v’O£3R *v'aSLi[}E‘v"AN‘s net equity in the hense shalt rernain in felt feree anti
effent and the are-eennre cieseriheti abeve shalt rernain applieahte.
Te effeet an eqnitahie riivisien ef the estate et" the parties and as e part ef the nivisien,
and fer serviees renneree in eenneetien with eenservatership and snepert et the ehild, eaeh party
shalt be respensihie tier his er her etvn atterney‘s fees, espenses, and nests ineerred as a resait ef
iegat representatien in this ease.
tT IS FURTHER ORDERED ARI.) Dii.CRt:lED, as e part ef the divisien ef the estate at
the parties, that any eennnnnitv iiabilitv net espressiy assinneti by a party nnder this tteeree is te be peie by the perky ieeerring the iiebitity, end the petty irieurring the iiebiiity sbeli indereeifir tees firere erry feiiere te se eiseherge the eed iiettt the ether petty erid his er her preeerty iierre
liehil ity.
{T E3 ORDERED AND DECREED thet the fetiewirig deserihed ereperty is eeetirreed es
the sele eed seeerete pre-perty ef DEERA VASUDEVEW eee ALAVOOR VASDDEVAN is
divested ef eey rigiit,tit1e, interest, end eieirrr iii erre te seiti prepetty:
1. CETEBANK NRE BUSENESS eeeeuet #K?'tJ{K39{}
'2. DLR interest LP» (H5) ieterest
3. ieweiry sect eerseeei etteets
{Hieegii efRe.rpeee"eet's Neirie N‘ me is ehesiged te
I? ZS ORDERED AND DECREED thet DEEPA VASUDEYA ‘s rte
DEEPA WEEKEGAR.
Cesar! Cests
IT 2S ORDERED AND DEDREZED thet eeets ef eeert ere te be berrre by the pert}; wtte
irieerred there.
Resefiitiee ef Terepererje {]‘r.:fer.s
FT IS ORDERED AND DECREED thet elt ehiigetiees end deties fer JULY 22., 2311
irepesed by the tereperery erde rs ef this (Iieert thet ere eet yet disehergee sheli survive this
jedgreeet, see irrdeeeeeent eefereereeet may be seeght.
E}i.seiteege frees Di.teeeer*y Rereetien Reqerieemeet
It" IS ORDERED AND DEGREE?) thet the perties erezi their respeetive etterrreys ere ed in this eese iri
diseherged freer the requirement ef keeping end sterieg the deeereerits predue
eeeereeeee with rele 293 .4133} ef the Testes Rules et Civil Preeedere.
ti}
Meeetery Judgment
The Qeert tines thet en tvlereit 15, 2823 this Ceert errteree ee erder eetitieel “Oreer
Denying Pvietierr te Cetepei" vvhieh in pert, ereered ALAXPOOR ‘€A3UDEVAi‘~i te pey DEBRA
EFASDDERAN ifititiféti es etterriejfls fees reiteeersereeet. Die Ceert fines titet ALA‘-JDDR
VASUDEVAN hes feiied tt} pey seid $669.99.
The Ceert feather flees thet ALAVOOR V.ttSSUDF.VA1\i feited te eppeer fer his erei
depesitiert set ee Iely ll, 2013 vvitieh reseitee irr the pevreeet by DEEPA VASEJDEVAN the
sent ef‘S15{}.U{} te the eeert reperter fer the re;.ierter‘s ‘Tfertifieete es Nee-Appeereeee". DE-EPA
RASUDEVAN hes therefore been tiereegee irt the sttitt ef 5 Z 58.9%}.
’f"I‘ IS "?H£iREFORE ORDERED, ADJUDGED, AND DBQREEED thet DEEPA
VASUDHYAN is evvereed eri eeettreetetee jeegrnerrt egeirrst ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN in the
ereettrtt ef $'i'5{}.£1~G pies iriterest st the rete ef sis pereeet (6%) per eerterrt es ef Mey 2?, 2914
eritil peie iri full. DEBRA VASEJDEVAN shett be errtitted te stteh vvrits end ertiers es sheii
heeeree eeeessery te errferee eseeetiee ef this jeegmeet.
Cieeiflrieg Orders
Witheet effeetirtg the tirrelity ef this Fitiei Deeree ef Diverse, this Cettrt expressly
reserves tlie right te rnetce ereers rieeesserjv te elerifjv eee eriferee this deeree.
Reitiefl-‘Jet Greatest’
IT IS DRDERED AND DEGREE}? that eli retief requested iri this eese eriti rret espressiv
greeted is eeriiee. This is e tirtei jbetigirreet, fer wtiieh tet erteeutiee end eii tvrit"s end ereeesses
eeeessargr te ertferee this geegmerit issue. This jecigtteet tirreliy eispeses ef eii eieiees eee elt
perties end is eppeeiebte.
ll
Dare 0] Judgment
[his divorce judicially PI{(1?*<t>l‘-‘\‘l‘l-Ll} 1)
RE-lN[)l--.RiiD in court at the fitlfltli J udiciel
District Court, Brezuria Count}. loses- tm :\-ls} Z7. ZUI -l and further noted on the courts docket
sheet on the same date. but Signed on h 2014
Ji}Dtsii P_ti'1iis1n1:<<'t D ii
z~’\l’l’ROV ED AS TO FORM (JNIX:
Ron Brownstcin 5208 West Broadvtayi. Suilc EHO Pcarlaud. Texas 7758! Tel: (281)435-2770 I-‘ax: t23l _j 485-4128 ll-Mail: rbr0\=t=r1s1ein-'Ei;-holmuiLcum
RON BROW'NSTElI*~i At1ot'11e§-‘tbr Respondent Slate Bar No. 03229800
.~'-.1..~Iv0<>tti vAst.IDEv.uv_ P.JIi{»}~f;-F R“
.»r' '1
-..r IJTZIIPA v ;tis:.e*»ft~i. |tt.~;<fiE1eee “'1- L“"'- .
I2
rJ""""'
§.<$Ea
5% TE OF TEXAS DUHTY OF BRAZO RIF‘.
' Icertilythatthe for egoing is a true and copy of the origin, s I recere' on file in my correct Ii-
5’ “\"‘:£~'I :1!!!’
I
'
office.
Gwen under my hand and seal of the court at my office in Angleton, ‘Fexas. "RHONDA BARCHAH, DIST ET CLERK |' .. J‘
it
Appendix D Inventory filed by Husband Inventory filed by Husband is attached in case envelope Appendix D is on record (IDX 364, RR3 page 12 line 4, RR3 page 5 line 12, RR3 page 8 line 25, page 9 line 18, page 10 line 14, RR4 page 3 line 4,7,9; BR at 11)
34 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Cause # 63935: Third Amended Inventory & Appraisement of Alavoor Vasudevan, July 2014 Cause No- 63935
. _
IN THE MATTER OF § IN THE DISTRICT COURT THE MARRIAGE OF § §
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § AND § 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT DEEPA VASUDEVAN § §
AND IN THE INTEREST OF § PALLAVI DEV VASUDEVAN, A CHILD § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
4.. -.-.... wu\<'\'H
Y W.. I 7 I Wife I MN I i D W57
.
,1...
7 7j7 A r_.t;. \,-3»-tat .t%t..?L~lRRRil?@’‘ DSRRDR al?§i5$@§?tRl§§§R5 “ it 460,000.00} 900,000.0QlSee Exhibit B 18may2014 R
. W. = . ,_. ,._M. .,_ '. w
WK’. O Dees not éxié. Mail rt;-suit _ I . _ ,1.
V-~—\4 =1i
...»
...__._.;¥._.__._... vs. ——__—7*-v1:i=_"_—7_A--'_~-.'=L~\bw.~»<I:-p'.\\'u:?Ar.4l\:::=".‘.»<=:~'4\"n.'.\I!IJI\'U!l-~'~L4!!Uh"¢'“'~'l.\'|-:!=fI.'.“~“-*“*:!=fL')x\~'5\W-““‘~‘\'\“*“'""¢"“"“'*'l'
Mi"
=¢~ .,........;tes:_t;e,;;__ee_.;te_t:_:,A.‘.-».~.......<~1.\.=,........===..,
i
\
f ' tees eerrte repairs breiten M Mm?“ §---»--~-~-»-»-_--»_»--i\- . .. ..... "'T_i“ " "»-1. i -».:a"etme-t I - s --.q'~,"\‘=r-.'..{n __ \_——_—.-.—_ _ _e_ " ...... _ _ 7; _ _ _ __ 7,.» —_..-...>.1-=-.-- 1 _;_-.-.:1.-.—.<v.~.-.-...;m=><-r.->;\-.,m-,»¢-In-~»-mm-Q-.-~“-“~-.~w~m~.~.s...MM“.".;;=..;;_‘.-.;,;=s-4‘-its-_1-,;-,_-_-.;-=--»»»-<-“gt-4----------. _ - .!='.‘.-'-mid-4!;-f.(J=-L\/:va=::\!-(.":'1"I"‘0f'J0'61;lY:%:%Y—I'=:YJ$':1—T—1*'I1~¥=T:fTf1>1<—vn~ ..:—._—..—=—.—A-=-I-4n~-"es.:¥‘--=R='=--"M-'=r<'~=:-"->v===-'-'=~‘--'—’f=~'.§=r—*—=”’—=:=1:=1=:———:=e'1=**e::—=~= —'—' ;~='—'—=—:1='1='—'=—'—e—::=:1——— —='— —'="'**’*—“'—'—';'-'-°‘-"="—=’—""{"‘-E l
]__ Q 201 0 V_0|\/0 C30 W _ l l l ........_..... ......_,t.__t_ 6 M ‘ I‘ .. F 2' Wife .e............_..~..........c-L,-.t........:.-,t-.-Ne-..s.,._............... ,-. ,~.-..,_.~._..H._~._..-,-,_-._.~
;. ._ _ s lAc:c0unt . I 401KWe||s
(D
, _ Fargo , -__ 5 _ '17" 'I_.H=e;etteee‘= ..._.t......,t.~_.,,,i.-,...i.,,. ._H_M,.¢_;,.,.,____,_T,.._..e,.?__T.,~_.,.__.e.,,.:,,r.-_§,....,..;.._...»...,.,-...;..=.tt-. v .>.»..-..s.. .».~..».,.
> F 1° iA<=<>Ou“*- LPLOY24 ..... _ _ _ _ now .-~_ -4-..-W, 4.--- -.-»-.-.~.-.-_¢..~.-..- -.-.-.-_ W-.~.. Q.-_ IPFQ \ . .7 V ~~. —
., . . . ,. L. .
;—--'-~—~~-'—~~'~-. 7~~~.
36,t586.3*?’; % '3-5,58-$.37_§W?ife -~=- 4-» ,__,.,._,,_._,_ ______,, W. ............ .-.... ...... .... ......
--nu
. ....m...._g_m;Bm5-..a
39.t3§4.5*...Hv.tsess. I_ I t 12 .§t"ieit"8i-%11'F'E3l- T etseeee-t il . 2a es ==.-zwwt as
:..M,,,W ....""*‘P“1‘4P*~“'*'“~'Ii“4"
L-
_. __., ......-.-
l -- 5 . -- . ... " ==»"~ - _- ". . .2 i _ . . k g ?,.§2R~.?:3iiHusband. As of 25may2014 O D I éI. 2-A i .—.<.—.—.—.~W.t—.<<=:.—:s.<---—.<_ee.<t;.:e.e:.it...- --- —--—— I — _-.-.~-—.sY—e.=---—. .—»»el
A
..._I
i “M
? . .. . .. \,.
. .
t
. .,
a. 2- .
:I1:
-
. - -Y
I
1
é ==
.5...............,..............~~........W............"“w%.W..m.m.w...1.-M=@.ma.i>wt.eem-_<.~m:».e.e.-.=.;;~»-.-.-.....;.-...~~...~mw“...~...~w.....m..-".........m._...~.wW.......e=e=-e............-=.=..1e:=,;.,.:..\.----<-:<:»1.wv=.---~¢-sew»------W----W-----:--M--»-4---ma---2-K---m-12-=-\--=--2»-~rm“--w-=~==>~»~¥~v~=-.-'»>-1-<'—’—=--"we"-‘iv-'='——'—=>—1;:;‘=~'=¥*’=*="'lxe“""""""“""*“?"‘"r“¥"““""i""*r'*“‘“"““‘Z1”"“"""‘“"‘-'-"""“'°“”“-“”“"“‘”"'“-'°*”“Tm“'*'“"““'““i"i‘““W'
I»- . K.
I
mwimintmwllAZ-Icfiuhiii“-D‘Fl”§:FE”B‘éOB“kWéEmiYém§llT
1
E? i O. O0 =vaIue miniscule — a/c dead ;_____
i
_ __ 18i Accolint Tl lvIértilTl§dg*é7éi:W><>t'iJQOZI l —I’
t3@;8ee
ss5-00{
__L..__
I we
A
rte.s4;§.@@iW.f¢t it j ; ; A -r I‘
E
1 +. .,‘_ ]_.e -._| 385. ODD; Husband
~ is-.t..-t-= '~.-.\=-.~.-, -.t--\_t,..,.‘...,.,,, ,~,,...,.§=:_ _;-,-’.~t~.~»-’~——;*""""""" s ' re in .-..;.......e ,,, .. ,_,___,,
§W3_§_ 21 W W W .».|. 7" ----.....
eeee
_ _ _ ....... ...-....-.:....;..;.e\..-<.:=-=.-==-:::=-.~-;-:-I--<--4»:-\~:--=-----f~-------------'---\--' ...........| .......;_;.-.-.-.-».~-_-.~-.'..-....\¢.~:-4~=-e:v.-~:--;<-----n;-m---
J,1 _ __ .. . .
... wwww...t..t.c._"..;.,.-.=.».§e..M.e...t.,r...i...ti...»,.=f..,.::::<--,~...=..-,,T..e._e..I .t...t.._.....;~...e..._-...t.t.t.e:.:..:e.~..;...;e........... M.....,.=t...>.-,t.._._-H.st‘
t‘seeetent~ Rletlievelttlfis LPL mites'_ % ts -.......-. - :-.~ .¢.-.;.t..~.¢;. 1-.1'.a:':.=;~:':», -»n-
M5 mifi~95itcil 83 lggsw
\_\-.=1---- M - GAG 3 ~ Tg t“§8"5:?i“wv;l%" ...............................H 5 --» ' .....¢.
W if ““““““““““““““““ ""
___“_m____|_|__,“___“___~_~%_iv_&_\,,,, =MM,,,,__._W1,W,_,,~___,_.____,,_fl___,f:_7,11_f___:_,f_T___,,,___,__,_,_____________;__,,________,M,~_ ,__;_w___.H_,f:A::,__,:,,,__M._ .._,,.,,_,,,_, ,..‘,,_ ,t,.‘_..,._,..,.. ,......t.....j..,.........,............,__.__;l_......................__....._.._..?...__T_.=;..-._;._=,_,_:,_.;,...-¢,,,;i.T=7,,-,sw.;.t,..m;.,_..,...w.,_...W...--,...;.,...e._.e.....,,..,._ ,_.____.._.,t. :_._...e.___~_e._e._s:,_:s..::_.,_.t....:::_.>
124- irfiteeeenttt - TfieEt3ttJt sevmge csx8t:~ti9a H seems;
I I I tee? Q1.t-teseeee'
l .
.\ li‘ml'WM§M
i
_' _.1.,,....._es,,,.,,,ss:,...._._e_:::,,_;,_s_.:
5 M1,:_.;_._..,“,::,,,.,,_;__,___M,;_,-Mm;__e.,;.,-_;_,,.,..,-=,.._.,,_,,_;.,,_......eu..‘,\.,.,2......._....,_.._.,t.,,-..........v..-....................................;s.....e.......i..>.......-§ '~._-.-,...,,......s..».-.........,_....~.,...M..-.-.~.c.
'2“ ?
eeeeeei». wisest. ;‘%3i'§~'?"%»'i2' t sesssteli nee . .:_. J.
_ .T-_,. MW . . . . . ..
cc ccc l 4124.01t...,..t25...,,e...
v_.‘,__,.,“._W ,...-.e,..,i_ .ee¢hMa-.-..~set-=_s.t.~»......_..........................._.._............;..........»....-M.-I...§|v.m~-\-,<~-\-+-~»w»»w.----»~»---.-¢-»---.-s.-.-.....-..-,\_;.~¢..>;.;.,.il..-V.|W-.-M-~-».,-.l---»»-»----~.~'.>....»..>.~.~...-..»-..~.»-.-..-l~.-...........~..=,,=;-.....l-,.._.4-;=>1-.-.-=-.v--re.-1»-vv-1-----:--1----'---——---»--m1w%r
Page 1 0f5 Cause it 63935
Cause # 63935: Third Amended Inventory & Appraisement of Alavoor Vasudevan, July 2014 :{_ _ \__\___ _ __ _ 7_ _ _ __ _ 7 . -_,,\,,;,_.:,_-_-_,_1_-,1?_.,.,1_.._;~._,,.__,.,._\.._,.__,_.,_E,. .7...._ ___...7. _..,_....7.._ _ ;_ ._.....c...... _.._.L-_;.--~.;..____.,,,=>.=_-..-_-_¢-it-_.,,_._-.-;=it-_-,.-_\.t,-_-1.,.-_-.;~-.»_-sq-r;i;.==;.~;»-_~¢-»i»~><..t..~c7_T . .—77-_-~. 7 77: 7 7— 77—.—.—-—:7.777 7 .— 7.7.7 7.: .77 .7—.7.. -.17 7.7.: M---.-~7 —_7~.__-M:--.-.~.7.71.---7.ax-.2._.-.\.....,..~.-.-.-»;-.=~;....==re:--e=:.=.-W":-.-.:et==-:1.-.--an} .1 --~ - .
i 29 iAccount - Wells Fargo Saving x7-461 §H i 1281-64?
5 - _.___ _-;..{.,.....-W. 77 7—-—7¢:"-1* '"'"'*i* —7s-N..WMM.....__.=..W.-..-=..<t~.ea=»-s-.-.-ak~==-.1.»:.we-atwe~@ww -=WW7"-M=I=~=-"-"=-=-""1'=~=f"':="*"“““*"*“'j§“""**""""*'*"""*"*""*“'“"~"*‘-'"*“'"'"“"='= 1 I 2 8 1 ' 6 5.52. ‘i ...,........... .7;7.7. .......J: _ - _.; _._ .7..7D7. _7 >7 ._ -L i -»_;.-,»-.-..:;¢[_-_-..._i=:>.»-e_-_-_-;,-.1-,1,-.._-, ., .t._.________.._-“..',...7 ---Lc.7 7 _ ....... _._ _. __ __._,___,,_ . ___.___i
0ti
No. Personteti.tl§Pto§e7ir.tif *rliPss.-§Husband . 5 tWife = . . .M.f'=,. .. “Net Value iN0t95 i ._._.._..._.._._.-.~_.._......._.._.._.__.._.;;.....»=.~..~.-,_.»..-.-=-.-.n..,.~_...,-......,_...w-=¢-_..-.»=.s»=._-—=-i..=.-=.=--- 1 _ _-.. 7
Q
§ §
’i'6
30 _
._,..\,__..w,,,_,_,,__w_,m,_,w_,, ,t_..........1, iAlarm clock down Bedroom -.1-..-V-_7_, .< = . _,.,..v\’.5 ,,,,,.-,,.
.. .4 -,,._,,-_
_.. r.s
_ __ _ _ _______ ,-_~.m...~._m._.~..._.uM..~...~......~.~.~...MM..w»._.M\~MMa-.--st-.......7-..../.-=~i..s.\-..
. _ .. . _;_ -_-=~.»r-.1~---—--~1:-------~—----“~—--
_: ~—--- -'. -» - - -- -
§W
.___“.___,\\__._‘\_,____,,_A,,,_.,_.,,_.,.__.,.~.._...,_....y..........._.._...._......_...
- - - ,.
. -'. =_. , .
._ ,-=.\.,. _“...-.v...,.._._,,_.4“ - - -
. ,..,.._ . . _ ,.. . . . .__e, _
Bro ken
.. .. .
.
.. . |\ . -v-..-t......,. ..-. <..._... ¢- »..-=..-- -.~. ¢.---i-—.---—-\-- ':':‘1.-.. - -v-~ ..
_=
'\I- ?"l'I\lI\
5
31
_~___._-{_§_.___._.__
iAlmirahin dining room
,\__,_(__\.,,:._,[_=__,._~,.é_$.‘._‘._._,,__.__.._.,,,,_._,,._,.. . _. ._,_ . ._.._,_,__.
WV
_.._;,,__-_-M-__,;,,,,;,;_..;_.-,,_-,__-_-____ .,..,._-,_..\-_<.ah,-,.\.._.-c-...»,._..-.....-..,..,..».~....._............-...-._.~....-._..-...--....§.t...=-.........._\.i-»_-.-.-.>-.-.5 'l_,000..00§
~~~~~~.
1,000.00 Expensive wood, architect MMMMMMM
. . . ,-_ _,.
K ........... . _ . _ .. --
lBied master bedroom li- . .:,..,_._.A_:!\‘.._..<._._.,.._..-,._........*._w~%. @~i.»d~-JM.~.==~..-> -.=.-..\-.~ _~i..\~,-» ........ we..._7._¢__..._.._.___-..___-.-___..-_,_-_.\-a.t~......-;i~'~.=.=_ lW 600.00 5 600.00 _.__,.._,..
ilncludes headboard wood..-..... ..
. ............s.._........... ......... .
wit» lC.ab‘“elS ll“ ems" ¢?"“e~ UP °lfi°¢l ; r 50.00 g 50.00 E 50.00 50.00 ,a..\c_,...,......e M ._.M \n\P\I ....
I. .. . - .. 50.00; 50.00;;
r r .-.¢'7Q77@.§t.iioirhereanymm.-.$oid.??. l '5
36 iChairs in upgame room Sioffice pg up .37 §Chairs 8-.Tables in side living room 1.6007-00 i ? g Luitufy Wood architect g_ V piano,kipp le) IH55 S 1,600.005l ExhibitA of deepa4thAm socQ.--
..
iCoat Hangerin big dine room .2. _.,.7...-...._.,._..,-,._.....<.,.,,.-...,............,,.,,.,._ .. .... - -Y... . 7 . .. 7 - ..77....-7- .- --.__--... .77 is» 7 - - __ 7,,._,.____.».;_,;,,_._,_-_..._- .,-,.,..;_-.,_,,__,,<.-_.;,,,..-,,..,,,_.-_=;_s,_..-,,,__,._,..-,.,,,_,_,_,__,,,_,;,,“-,_-__-_,,,_,¢._-,_t . ,W. ,. .
g§Coat Hanger in small dine room _, 77 7 7. . 7 ... . — i 1 — 7-..=;--..........-...n-.i-.;.e_s;-.1.-.i_-.-...i7.=..-.-»=.$I=-....-.=>.._t-.-.-a-.-.- .. M M _._.,..._..,;.-.-,,._...;.,.,..;-....-_,-._.,....,...-.,._._-,,_,-_,.;_.._,.. ._.....__7,_,,._.__.__-.
E R ?_\._._._.._-,__._._.,,, .,,‘.,.._..\,._.._,,. _._._.c_....,;...:,.,_ iCoffee machine in kitchen -,, 7_ 7 .7 7 ._ _ . _ . 7_ _.-_ ,..... LT 7._,_.-_- _ 7 .._.77. 77. ...
20.00i
7.7.. m.....M....~....._.77.7 .7 7;. .... ...77.7 at...-.......7....<,;.-. .1-;._..=......-7..\;..=.=.;-.,,.;..-..<=.. >.~g o==,-_-.*....~.;.,t.=_-.;-_..-..i.\s_..i.....-.:.>-..-...Ww.;.=.e-.-.7.=._...M;.;s.....-.-.....M.. \,4\-;1~.>\.E
‘i ITUi5-.F'P$t.al'S BR. lP?°“=b.‘?F¥dYF’
;= §fContents upstairs BR table,TV, bed :?v_______u_._.\__.__W______:L____.,._._.__.__:.>___.___)._____',,.,J..,:,.,,.M,._,,_\\,,,,,, .7 .7 _.,___ .7 77_.,_._ __._ 7 . . 7 .._.. . 7 .. .7 77_... . -7 ._..s..er.-.a-_--=.....i-.\-»<=.-la.--=».-.-.-4»=-9--.<_-.-“.1.--.--»~¢-i-><~»-—¢---e- _,_.,._.,._,,.,_.,.__.,,.._,..,_,__,___,_,,._._ g; . - . .. .. . __,,._, _ _. ,_.,.,s.._,_,__,_.._..__,_,__._._._..____._.___._,.,..__._____
lee
. c
5. 'l50._.00_}t_ 150.00 icomputers J ._t,,,,.-.s..<.__,.\.__,,..,,-.-_..,.-es.=.,,.._.._..,i;._._.._._. ..._.._..._7 _......,. 7e... 7..77 . 7 7.....- 7e.-..._ 7 6--\~-. -_._-.i.............i4.---....t-=.,.was-=.=.:-ii----L----s-----»--~.--2»-¢----1--»--~§ 5,;.... .......-,._.,_..;,....,.....,___...{_____.._.._.e_._s.__.D._e._.....s.,._~..“§._..W._..-.a..~....-as»...-......7..-..=..-.-.-,.-._-;.._-._,..._...,,..._..¢..._,\....W.-...-~.-_....7,-_t>_-..-._w.¢..m7M-t..m»..~-m7-»......€
-
=f _t ' ' t
_»4?c-.»+~u~<#:u7¢»-an-<-e_=.-»;u..-»-~-..~.c=\;_...-=.-=i->.¢.--.~=i.--w--i->>-=:--.--<-~.-»-:-1“-.-.i..».ii---»;.,'..--A-ii-l-—~'-r~'7--'-~'r—"--—----—-—--—- ----- -»----.---'-.-..;-.:'_.-._.'T.-..-.;._..:-i»-q -- fa - = - v - .\-;==»¢.7 - .-e --:=;-..--......-.i=~.:=- .-=;-:»=-.-....i..- -.-. ---»....<..-.».-,.-- -.-.<=\<-1:1.‘ ='=-. -. --.=.»-.\=='=»--;,._
Q
.. . ...D"ii’. 53.31%-*2?’i.lR5‘ii§!?'T$ Q3315.-F00-m Z ' _ -. j _. '_ _-I -': I. .:' ‘. -. .: .-
.%.77_.7.~.-7.77.
50.00 ...< 50.00
.--777.77~7:.--....»77.7.77>7=.->.~...~~..»<=»».te..-5..-.-wasas-..-.~t===i~==7.»>e.-=s=-=-t<»=».-== _--------~~<-~ta-=i-1-7-.~»<-<1-3,7is7-W--we-.1.--.»-.»t»--<r=~M-»~»----»~-v--»-~t7
§ .s ..
T1 20.00% V . .a_.~.-_v.»
., . . . ,. . . 3~°9.°.~99i Luwrv tweed. e eielilteeil - -.=_._.._...-_. _..._.
iDining room table in small dine _...,,-.___.._.-_...- __ .._.__._.._...__.._ ,,..M_....__.M.,_,,__ _
l
..,_.__,%_,_.,..,.__.,_._,,_._,._.,,,._,..__.._.H.,_,_...,_..,..,..,..._,,.,._..,._.,.._,.,_s.Q_,_.,_.,_.._,;,;.;§,,...,...,....,;.....,..;.'§ 180.00; % .» 180.00
a~ A.7-.7:=~.»c':.i:slices-:\'::.»-.'»c/.|»».t»-i.:.1r.-I?l>¢.-.:>w'-.1~='.-r-x'.\-0;.-.,i:.-.\ is-§iie= .-:-as .-.\<.-,-z- >=-;.;..-.;t.,.~.;; .-,;.-.\,.—_.-.,;,,.,,;,:.=..-.-_-- :~v;.\<M.,,N,xn-.'-'.<~'.-\';.'-z.»~.r.»,>;,-.\ >-..“.>-.;.¢_,\-.u.;l}
.;Dolls in entry and side room _;.——7—<><,¢>¢.;-_ L T .7,_1_7; :.7.7_7. .1 _.7.7.7..77.
wood dolls
40.00;
.. T ; I
l ...-.t.E. l.e.9trl<i €9°l<¢E!?F9?.(lFl ¢.ll.*?'l.l.. - -- -»- -1 ,. -5.
l
I‘ ii A ';::—J:-'-I»:-i¢_—::_:-:-w‘-i»v.'-\€=3_:_; .~.:7--in-»:-»-=-~:=--=\\=='»;-=~'-. ....».:=~:.>.'u:s;<>.e\1~'.-in-.L=»;=~<.~.\r;1r~'1~:.-;=-v;-~'¢<~!.'i;?
It=2 . ...
.;<.-..t...-...-....i...-,._W.-..........>._.;.a.==.;.s...- ___..<_dt....~.....~ ......... ..
' ' -. ‘ ‘ 1. ' '- 5‘s-
-_.»...;<~=.. .:
tE
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................................-
. 5.... .. . . =-.\-.=---M.-.---. .--»->1 :r
.
lhhhhA!¢JlHH\H\I\hn\dhI\dhAAlhhhAdhrhd¢\hfllhAhh!dl\hdAnVh!u\hI iExercise bike in BR ;
M...“......M.......c....._.mm-Wu.M...M.t...w....~W.....e.-..-..........._.=....t.»=>.o....w.-.ei>.;.-...-..e=..=-==+t..¢.-..-..=e..a=.=<=-e.= =..-..=..>,~.=.~ »,-==,>-.-.<m---.-.-¢.=- -».-at-..-----..-,---—--1;-1----~»-»-»-----53 J - -
._._......__..'> _...__._ .._........_.i., . . . it -. _ _ 2- I .........i.=..t§i-.......>=.-..=..tas_-.._.,i.-.-_=.-ea...-...=...-€.-_=.--M...=.m\..,.§._...-_-.,s..,....;.=
5
I-"V-I:L‘:r-'A:Y\*~—\**1\2lf]\-ll-Ilg-'-\fl“v€\tf-‘fl[;11![;1A\‘"\')116'_' A »7-.-. >5-1--W'—'P¢'1-',>_!l:\‘\!1—*~—H~\"\1_J:\>>"‘¢"fl—1"_%
Z
300.00;
-_;. w~.- 7,.1€. .». . t. . . E 1 Ir‘ =r-
iiExercise equip (treadmill. wts etc) 7,,._._. t.
1 ----._v.:-.------;--.;;_-.:.._--,_;<r-;.-;-._-;<;\-\v=.- 51;.‘-'Ill2\'.'-Tm!‘>-Zfio-C3/‘.""‘!"'4!'I.'w'.\i-5,1.»I"!"‘l‘Y-“\‘;"f"_‘""""'VT"' ':;'V'-“""‘"“l\'J<I-‘fl!""I‘"M"'"M"?N-E‘I'_I-'_l""""""“"'"\'_'“f"_lZII"'""""‘€"B"§;'}_'o.'ZIZ ---- --.-_-,»=.»-iv-1-~-—--_-=-_-~_-;-v-»--~1-i<=-_->-.-'-_--—-»--~~.-;<~::-:-'------ ~-g.
0.00%;
em
Ii =3 §Externalhard drive I I ........,...........,..........,............. ....... ...;_, ........ .........,...,............~......... ..... .....¢-:.:... ........... \-'|~vruvvvu\|wv|-v=1viHEuluvI||vwwI-I¢v|;4*h\|~v¢|v’4\'fv~\'|-\;vIv~ana;v;‘-'§,7VI€;\\hi-why";::v-'.'%i-v§"}.7:‘§Q."f:"!':(§‘“r"\1"IF:f-Y1‘||'|"fII\'\“""‘fa“a7"w";T7'i7'i 71' >7’-—---
_
.,......777.7.7.7.~....77 .7_7........ 7. 7.7.7 if .-
77.7.7.~,3...e7..e..e...e..7..7..777.e.7.=._,.....7.
$3 @ Q_. := -.
e.7.7.7.7. 77.7.7.7.7.77. .e.7.7.......~.s-=,..>.-.e..7.7.7....~...~ >.7.»;-.......,,.~.,i»<.1.:.r......re.rye.-e....==.-.>~i.-=-;=-.-.>W..-.\-..--------------~---------------.~-.------------ --ai-»-------------------"1\\;|l.-wv-k-».Ju1v'<\l.|\-v.-v-\.\-w\|\:2'.7.§.Li
E
l so t -i gorse Life insurance 2'2 0.00 iWife also has F&G account H I post ofhusband
'.__.__.___;_. __._ ._._.__._. ;._._._., _. _._._ ._.;_.. ..__._._.______.__._._.:_.__.__,_,_:_._,,;,,__.,,_,_,;_~,,,<,._.>.M,M,.,,...,..,.,._._.,._._.,............,............_...,..~.....__;...._......._._...._;._.-......_....=........:'.._..~..M..............i“.\'.'!=“."r={".'i'£i:A'!'L"fl“q-----1=-»;§--~.-;-»=..--_----~-.--a---' ' - ' ' rr ' — —%'— —— —
0.00 learns
— — --;_-~-'-'----— ~ — I--B i ------ii-»-=-~4-~-4--~i~w------w--\~lI=- M -or aw» -—----we-1|--~--—.-.-=
i
7 rage "ens li>!.Ke1.W_l.i@S~i.Plastics)
i i
.
El: E
‘E -
-
=7
i
t=_...--.~»....»...~.--.-..._...,.->- ...~ 1 50.00;; i. 1;. i ' i i i . -.-.-H 7. 7 7 7 50.00.; 7 7 j 7. 7...... 7 77 777.»~-.- 77 _ 7 . 7. .7 -.... 77 -—fl|\I~§\»~< 7 77-.-..=..-..,l= 7. 7 .¢>.e=<.i.-......-..=e.=,»...,.........=ii
i
I ss chess in side living room I I ‘ 60.00% .e._.m._.. 60.00 E
\'-: Q)m.
5-~--.»-<1-.w . 1|-fvv-_-"?rl'|\P= 7 7 . .=i .. -..--.-.-e.---j._¢5_w-.--.....>~-¢==:_-...e., _ g7..,._... ..,,=....._,.,...,.,._......_...._,,..,...,.._.,._ ..-.... .7“.-. .t__.__.. ._.. . - - _._e."_..-,..».........--_................._.-.--_..7.._-" -
I60 ......
.-.-__,. . . ;i- t old plated idols, silver in dine room
Q
O
G) _ V g Exhibit D 18May20t4 letter 7-7..........7......M.. .--.-.,..._.......,§y...._.........._7...M...,w._................W.w..-......s_....<.._..-..-.._..,e-........_... ,'.,;_,.,“, _,\,., ,.,., ,_:_17______7,'., , ,*.
l 61 S3019 at?..F@¢ll.*Y..*?‘*.93..l5. - . ,,...
7479.17
-.~. .. ...s..t.......c-... . ._....-._..t.........._._p..._......_._...t_u.M.....-._.g........
-..2. .. ,. ......W ......... ,-._._.._,,_,.... .. .-- - .....,,__M-..._,,_.. ..,_,,_..,__,..._N_,__,.,.M__._,._,,._____,_..,,__,.W_,_¥
40. 00 40.00 ii-wood expensive I 2’. ”Oi Nt "i F . D.D?.Y..§i§.@§p.9.?.@..T 'Tl?i'T'I".lI'$..
. ; ., . _. _. ,i_.
. . ,. . I 5. i ii it2 3 Y... Ii _i i i ......._ ,.._....._-1... ,...._..._..._._,.iL_...-.._.-......1,...-.. ~...'.-.-..-......-._...;...,..,..,._.,.__.,_,,..-,,_ N--...,,__ ,,.,,,,...-.-Q---1-,7. .\->-----.- t-._.._..-,.<... ..,_,.._ -,.........‘..
60.00 60.00 '
63 l'-ampin Slde...'MI.‘9 .
.-. ...-,T.- -. . . . .
B5
l Life insurance
I
....L .. NorthwesternM xx0804-
e insurance NWMu 1 p lavi 1lH iti I
20 684-60%“?st 69W 'l4,792.97§i V 5; ‘l4,792.97_§ g g wi - ...... 7- ~ 77777777We-7.7--w"-7.
-- M .,,- 7 -,--_7. 7.- e_ ..___ __ ___7 7»-74 at -tee es ii F W M61135 ea. "M Wm
....,..l. .
...»_.. 8 77 77 ..~.... .. ..._ 7... 7 7 ........_.. 77_......7 77 WWW
. . {.- . . . . i t , , ,M. - lllllllliLife .. . .§_-_... .. -insu
-. , - - ra nce NW M ut x1 841 Tisiii !
£igis§.1s E 1X
........,.._._,..u.........,_..--.....e...,,...._......_I,.s..€............... __ _._
.¢.,7
"ea itriiteiee V E
_,.__._N.:,,...,._,,__.,;M.....,.,.....\...»_..._..........._......._....,......_.~....,.. wwww .............. .... ................,,...... .... ....._..,........._,........... ...;.<-.-....~...,.,..-..;..ii-....,.....=.c.=\.;~..-..ii-...;~<.--==>.-cit. <<<<< -<7¢.t=~>»1-=¢_»-—»~1-—--»~e-'--------~»-1-----»< ,_..._ .i
. ._;§.. .- . ,. .' . . . . .
-...._............_....._................,@-..,._-h.-,1._-_-.-.._...et,-...ti.,,,.ia..,-..l,.,,,.».--._....,_.
1 . _ ..
7. . 7 7. ............ 7.
_ :.
- ca me with the house
7. . _. 7.7. .7.7_».__,.......~.. ..7......... . .._-.7 7.7 7 ....7. .7...7.__...7_7.......__..
l
69 i§Monit0r upstairs office _________W__‘_,__;_1____“=m__,mEW__,_!___;_;_m_w___W_:___5_w_,E_i__W‘__=___,___,W_!_______’_ . ________ _M__‘__w."__,___;,| ..__M_..M._____| _._.,s - . ...........s..._.......,...,.......
-\
-
-- - -- . ..
50. O0 - . ..
....... ,. . . ...-........... ............. .... ......._........
>
. ..
"5 -_
.,_.___.... . ........
.
... . .... ...... ......_..........un._....._.......s_..__......_...u..u_.s.....s......
, . - ..................
' "
-
I 3'
70 ?§Paintings in entryway .; ..._.,....,.,...._.........._.,_.-....-...,,.,._._.....,.-.._t-,-.s,-.1-.=......==7..»,,,,_\L:()|;'|\I:'f1J:.'7,I\;l|"\**'n',I'l-'*‘ W7»-»77¢»i;...... .. . .....-. 7. . . -- . . . ...~-. .. .. . . .... .. ... ..'-1t-'w.»v.L<>~-f:-\'.Jr-=;-'1-rr:1:a:\~>\!\i=
- . . . .-
F E
5 i : _ !.......--D7,,-......,.._..,_......;§............c................................_.........._......-.._..................~.e.~......,.,....-........=.<.-\.-»..;..<-.--.....==we--.~,<=.-ea--~-t-->-=~*-- §. .=..._..i..\~.--u-.~--=---:- \ i 72 *iPots/Pan in Kitchen A\__._..._._......_......._..._.__.-..-_._.._.»..,.e...__-..t.-. ‘II-J-ibv1v’~'\'-'Il}I2I'\'~\i>-41'»I,-2.1.1":K‘-‘I.|,‘|:.,-[°..",:“‘114~y-a,.\‘- ,..,_.,_,........,...._..-...~...,.,.._..__..........,...._................................_...__.._.......i.-..s=...._...;.=e.-.=.._._..;...<.-.5 -I ' ' i 70 ‘ i-. . .
300 00‘
--!»-v—:----<»-~»~w-------—-----'--->~---------M--1--~-=~ -7- 7-
|
300 O0
. . .. .,... .........-.._.......M...“.._..._.c................_."....._.~....,...“."M.M...tc._..o.w.....~.eis.-Me-iii.t..s=..~--.=<-_t-...-.
i W “t_.--_.-_..-;_-.,.- "’ .- ......-7.
- - - *--»--“.7-.-4
- - -
i=
Page 2 of 5 Cause it 63935
36 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
. . . . . ,,, ,-,_...,._.:.._,._.,;.._i.
Cause # 63935: Third Amended Inventory & Appraisement of Alavoor Vasudevan, July 2014 , ,_ _ ,_., _ ;,,.;,;,_._*._§?.-,-,,_;-.,...._.,g,.,~.,..~_.~a...~......._._.._.¢¢~».¢-_;~:.¢.“-.=>;...1=¢-=-‘gm.-1-I----,--------..-\_........._--.~,e.».»i.i..-4.-vi:z11@.,4r-w-we-.»¢»-<-v--»-»»----»—»»~—~»---~»—=¢-=~»--»-»~Q ..y_...-.-..-.~....~>-5 -N--.-ii ...-.¢ -'~;vu:»‘ iv‘-u\‘~‘l\*"’r <-;<- ,;.....,....\.‘,,‘~..;..,..,..,.._:........._......,....._....._v,..................;,,;___,s_..;...i;._.;.=;-_._=-_iW:.,,_,,.mM.~..,¢......M:.._.W....,.......~...~.;..¢...,.....a;.~.e=;>..-.§>,.=-».~.-»=-.:,~- _ -.-.-=-,-»-»--»-~..~_v_
73 ER efrigerator
1
in garage - -- - -0 -0 -- 4 ......
'1d00,0v0fl0 0 - - - M»,,,,,.,_;.‘,w.._,.....-M-»».‘,,,._-.._. >r'” ~w;=vw~.i-¢\.».'--‘-=r,.r...‘-.-.-rM-.»,m».=-5-¢--W‘M,---~’--------»--—---»-»»------~J»r=r-»-=~=--—>~-=~w--=~-»-=r»§ _ 5 Yza*9: d1Commnunity Personal Property _,,__,,._,,.,; A1 , 2 , ;__,_'____'_,_'_,___-_ _ ‘_;_ -_ ,_ __',_'\;_<_\;__,_~_m,;\.,\.,,,,\,\,.:.__ , 0 I H I ;?Pos§Husband 0 I rmg).a_,.,.,..,,...,_-:_ Wife Net Value '-§§Notes ,...,, 7* 7' -..»...';&-. ,,_....,_.. , _ .,_...- lU“"n§'\'lvu\Y\¢|f""§7'fvY\\fJ\\"!'7"E'F*I‘\"(‘?'17117:‘-""":i: _ 0:170 I - -I - : 1 .1.‘---=:»1-»~~~»»=-@»-<~-7--»--»~W---r--»-»~:~-'~=-.~-we-<.-;»=»»¢~r-¢~»~r-7--avg.
74 effigefator in Kitchen k_':-m1¢_-9-izxw v‘J\‘-I\‘M)<lflv‘v r_=~-M».e,‘._..;-¢4~,v~,...-W-...‘-.¢..‘.‘,,,‘-..4-.~_....=,-~,. ,1 _ _.-.»,, ___-...___ . _ __..-..__ _ . .»..-_.___ 1..-_ » -,1.» _';'q'-l|»'|f,!'|'/Ji'Ii'i'“"'1f14<!.'ll1TP-lV"'fi"1"‘4'Y?"‘4-I‘ » ai1 1: §'€i ii '1r ~<Y 890g_-P0 ]i i}.
ii fr
_ _
“'1'
75 helves, two wooden in master BR é“
S
, 3_ . . . . ,.~§,
0, 0 4"" W7°~°° ?ianrwd,.. 0 1 0 i in.-......~......;.»=_..~;.;...'7....<11¢.-.-.=¢..;.>,-Qty.-.=-»._., ,W., .;.-r_. l,?. ma 1}
0 '
'4O)
7. " S ilk Sarees (cloths) siIver,gold metal . _. ., ",; _ 500. 500, Has gold, silver wires in cloth I 0, ,0 ._ ‘k _ _ .,.....,... ~_... ~ __ ,-J 4~'V*\ ---»
E
» _~_2.1.\-.:1x->.-.' \‘~<z i 7 '1- ; : _; 0. 0 , ‘ j ......;.~ _ '..-1..».'._.....'..>~».-.':.¢—~....,.,:_-,;;-.'-.~».<-v_- —> i_ -------~ . ._ __ _'._ I __§-are ~.-- i.-3;‘ §\¢'l,'l'€fi?',\'Ik\l\,7!'»4;'vf»_\'41,'v‘A;~K~\<1";'_’—\V': _ . l. _ . . . , -. - »-.-,--..-.~.-....-..+.~»-.__._.-..¢-1.»»..<.-...~....-»..-4-.»-ir...,...--->i.-ii- -~»_»;..>.~=.------ --4-.'-...-._v:
7s is ony camcorder 0 ‘ — 1:
Q M _
50.00; V 50.005 g W g \9 1»-.-.-M. -.-v.<.\,-.ri.~>.}.~-¢=- - r‘M_li\"f\"'é’l’P‘\'I'< PFi"K'e'$YStem(Ya’0) 7- iF':°°§ _ '1 l9lQ9liPa'#e9fe*"ee'19e"$se e -r»
is i
180? §Surround soundspeaklivingkgamegrms f -uzm.
i
300 OOL fig
_... .... — ..-—.—- -~ -,.'.-
3OOL0O‘i
-1'5‘.-c;-'|'|‘-1‘-.i:t<.‘-.4.: 'mr<1'<'<-‘ .-~<:> =7 .._~ ' --~. - 1%’ 0 e —~ .,
ease ‘T ea table in living room Wteduvsiairs
ME
, , _., ,,_ ,,,,_ ,, , , -....._.
g4CLOOg;[gH H
, W , , H," , W ,........,,, , 0_ r\/we ; W0 -_ -.‘-.-.», , -_-_ 1 ‘»,,,,_.=‘.,;,.@_'.;‘..;=-“.1,”=@m.<.,a.;a,@_ .1.-;~\.-~-.-r-,..-,,.,.--=,,,~_,~L--9+-.,,,,L,',,,-.+.,...L-.---..-,
V
i. _,,_.....,. V _-~ _ _ _ ‘ _ _ _ MM‘ (|_‘€F;@:4 .1 a —.-.r -~ M, .r, ».¢.r,._.» »4,--,.-.-..~».»1.».-r>_.--.¢. ..w--»--.»
as ET elevisions (BR,dine,Iiving rooms)
<3-,. ,. .
v¢¢~n0wov~\'.~r»}J~~wuIw\A~J~i~A~‘.-¢»5vé~§\'<oy~.~‘.uni§I4‘l\Vv<"'3I"!-\i'€|JV.v\"|"'4"'5v\(IJ\<i|~‘\:ln‘ll'.\?|1J'\\'-"'7'".'\"‘\'1Y\'-'4""‘."?'§.'\*'.-‘"J ' ~)-:--1-. ' "*1-"“~~ ' ' '
g "
+~1-‘,¢f~2
I~§-r-4-r
1 0‘ __“_* >""'~\- " '—'» 9~'~""— ' '-' ">“="" ‘
0
M AL‘. .1E! 1»‘ I ‘F2:5
20-00 P.‘
5 ‘H _ g vi ‘ _ _ _ _ _ ie e e W I ‘_ ' ;|. . . . 2 . M ¢:_._.;; 0 >~_:-__'_1;?-L-x<¢-—_—'—~_v.~--.'>.‘-w-.a~.u._-s.---1.--4¢.»;A-M-¢-».~-»¢~»\-wan--J,.i,..W..v._».~..r..w...~00000 iii;
~'~..‘1wm::~i
I 1
28$ ivase (in entry as ..w,
way)
r._ H ........... 0_ - W4‘WY!"Pf":W!r:£\Y"'""""1':.\Y"""""“"r,~v,-M-4----v.v~¢_q;§ . . _'
I-"'7'"!
iWal| oster aint in living room . ..,.
-¢
0 eeeeeee
1
if ' ' i1s§§uTMA iii PH E 1 0 1 1 0
0
S I_ 95,0 as 96 158-0 we Insurance i 0 0 00001 @r@@!Bothw.H "aveF&0 A.- _. -.‘ ,.-L i._- ;l.
M.-_._. ,. . _.,. ~. . . . €F,
'
@0589’ $9? r11irr<>r master BR 7 "7?-'°‘T""”""T7'T"""""f":';""T"T"‘T'“""”"'*"<’""T“"*':"T"""'""f““""7“'T"""""*‘”""""‘""° """;;"-7.“:-"
:iY"';?'M:T-J’: .2 :7 Tr '17"? - -""'-"3 v_'”-if?’ ."'.' _ ._ _" -_ f” ' 4 " " ‘ W "" “ '" ' '"" " ' " ""' '
98 Account + Nabard bewk 1| 0 |_ M r 50»000-0° 0 {veer ?°°4J"°WW 0
;
_ . , _-.-. _ 99 CCOUHT — India banks(vij,syn,corp,ici)
,.,,.,,-_-..-._ _ .;,=,,-,_-,,-,.,,_,.,;,_,,=m=;.,,;,,_.,,,;;,-_,-,,,,;=-
\
is needs to provide details ?-
r . ..
=,_,_.,_.,.,,;,;_,,,,M1-,,,“.=,,,,,,,_,=4\=,_e..,.;.,,§__:;;=.,=;.-,.;__~__}0,., ;,~__, ,;,,_:_,,, 0 0 ** W I 0 W" 000- :0," ms-.»»-0:01" ~ " *~
e
Y e *"_".f_. f"
e - e e e ail -e e -1»-» e _ . .
“'1-5'kl\f-~\~;i'“Jll!\'/-\An~4|L‘¥;\¢J'i‘lFg~;lL;1Y-"NI‘-P4\M1\*Hi\¥\'P'“"‘;"-5'\'-'l\I~*.‘-‘\‘fJ-\“\F¥-— e =1-.<1~-.0.-=-*~ '. — ~ —, .' ,— — --— —— — — — ——
3 EE 3 ;e
‘Q
§ . .
1: fr -
. §
-‘
3
1.
I.
n
-
3
\
2
......... 2 .............................._....:
' ,_,_,,,_,,,,-.____,,, ,,,,-_._;,__;,__;,;.;,,,,,_,,,;,,__,,;__=,_,,,__,_,..,_,,;_,,-.,;.,;,,_,__-,.,,.,;,..;...=,___,,,,_,,;.-,.,;_-.,;;;,.,_=_.;he_.;\:.-_,-W;;,,-.-.-_1=,-,,\,.,-.;,-,,4;.;;=1-,,-,.<,.,-,¢¢.¢-<1=¢.=!1,_-=.r.=¢-.W7,-,1-_-,5<-.-pee;,1=_,q"'ee:'a—..,.....,i.:,'17;.\...\....1T;Z:a:a: _,_~T:~.:~ ___———<————_' A——;vle-;:—::——%<|.*:~**——<~——-:1->\;;w----'=¢;\€J:¢l-1— -_—'.‘.\'5'-'-kQ=u~<¢w;-c-'-'.$'w5.4->\;\.;;;.://:(1.1:»-v.'.;-“.1:_~5w-c7!‘/)7)‘/)-~1';: a.-.~.r,\-:/==-..-,.—..»=r_\\-.v< --»-0» w:/:4-1-I"-\'Firm:5/;r"v'"--9'71;17)7)7‘l':‘fi'I=w1/.7/,='.:l:T"1'\':"'0'!)#.:';F"r"':-:'L=.:'a-i\:'.\""'-"'3-'_5'.i_"_';':-M"-:-P-c\ : -$4 5.5 -Z. - .
% § .. , L 2- E E ' jf !' €_ E .1 -'. -r. .\ ‘ '
'5'? _> ,............ 0 ~W~:................, ........as .....;..........._..._........._..........i....................-Mi...=..........=-......~.._;.ri.i..i......,‘.,._..¢ M...s.v--:-&jM.=.i.'.-,--»-,-rr_.,~,a-Y...-.‘,,_,..r,....,.~-,=->..w-.,........-,..-~...-...-;....__.,-....g-...-.,-.,~....--W».-...~-,..-....-.-~ e ' .--.-....-..— ~.§»_= .-.. 1 ->2—_=~,.¢. 1..-.-..'¢ e ~ -»-'45‘ -..-, ; ~ 1.--, a, a ,.--....-.-.-.»a1.-.-...-.-.-.-.......-....r.-...-.-W........:-......-..-..-._~.-.~.-...-..-M-...---.--;.-4.....4;
"1 '-2 E 1r 5.:.
5 i 1- 2~ 3 Q ¥ !'
.1 - ;.. ,R ;, :.
_____,,,,-_,.._.,,,_ ,._.__,-,..~.,_.», ,..-*...,,,N.,,,,,__,W,\.,-=,,,-.,._,,,_,,,,-.,,.,,,,;,,,-..,,,,-_.,,.\._. (._ ,,,___;....,.,,\.........;T_ __e__s___.......-_-_,,_,,,,_, .,.,__,,_......___,,__.,.,- __........-....;............--..==.=e_..;....w=,;.=-.-;;..- J-.~.~=.;.=,-,.W,1-M-,,-,,;,,=.-,.-s,W=9.~_»,~7»¢.~,-1-_M-;:<.,~a,-,-=--,-M--W.“e;W---am,._.<.,..._.....¢.,..,.......-_....;..,....n......e:0a<.,..,......-..a;::?.,Tws;,.N,.,,..,: ?___,:,__s___._e____:sT,e,_0_s<.?4
-. -. . -. ,
1
,E 0;-I 1 >:= .- a -.. -.=~-.»-.=-~.~.-1-=-.»=~~:=m=-mi;-y-;m,-‘-¢-»—-»‘-=,-~‘-¢,--------‘- -\~< -, -F-nfiwr-~¢=—:~-»------¢—¢~:—_<=—:--.--_ W -----_-I---—_——_—=_A?~_"~_'_A_ ----M--I-.-.........;.am=...=........u=::\~-:r.-w/.':--xv-<--§~= I-3'I"'1W"i'?'F'?!"'§‘fi='W""""”'f'"'"T"-r'""""":~"-""*""f""f-"'**~5~i"§"';"'\-'I'*-:5'\~°"3'"I'-':"'<>3-'9'5"~7"" '“ -¥ P ==1>w"-'\<'w*< __>"-"=<‘-‘~"-'v‘=~"*"'='~'r"~-"-\'*-"~ "Y:-"'-— '——'—'—:—' '—'—' — ';'—'—'¢'—' 1 — '—' ::—' Y» '—'—'—':—'—'—'—*—'—*—'—*—'—*—'—*—':1I;*Y—'=Y»1<—==e'Y»7»'—==='Y:Y —e: > T’ =11’ 1:» -=*== Z = Iv---= +==:-~ =-'~<!'
z2 -§ i r s i! .
1 1 S ;
....,._____,,,:1_.........._._,:_,,_,s,_: .,,,______,_ ,__,,,, .,,,,,__T________,,,,;;.,;,,_,,_,_,,_,.;,,,.;,;.,-,_,,,,__,-<.;¢-_L_!_:_‘___, ;“,.\.,“...-.:.=.:. -- ,I\I(4|»1‘_""'ICIfI\qn-w,T:::: .., ________ _;»-..i.0::,:::;_,..,.....2:1:-.5axes:as.......:1:33;...........=.......:a¢':'e._;........;.\M‘.-a>....:.‘.s....=v.~.;>.<.....M ... $4 --.L;;.-.-~a.--.~>=~<-_m w-\-.-1-==»:-w-a-in».-->=.--:-»--1~<---<*-1-—----»_---w-~w-»---~----~-»-------v-»------~=-<-='~---------~-~»--»-------»--»-------»-
Page 3 of 5 Cause # 63935
37 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
-.-
Ceuee # 63935: Third Amended Inventory & Appreiseeient ef Aieveer Veeedeven, July 21114 ___._._____.. ................................... ------------- --
__ ___ ___________ _ ___ __ . ._._. . '\| - .
.- .- J- *7‘?.¥F‘.¥F?.!T.F!.T!?P?i.P..fi§EE.¥.F?.§..?.??§. - ‘eTe'e'é'H'e¥%3em iwee , , } . ..-_. . ......_.....-.-\....-.-i. , ._..,_. _ ............... -. ___________ ,_.____,-..- -..--...-...-.-.._.. .- .. .. -- - - ---- - - - - - - - - --
Ehiet vezee geletee
Herein ef Aneeriee ee J={I?4iQ3 W _ |___.,_._,_._..._. . . . .
G'.U-'-35;
... ..
2,2’!-3.3?’
.- .-.-\..-.....-..-.-\.-\.....-...-|-.-'-'\--- -'-'\-
_ "___ ___ _ __ _________ ___ _ ._ .\_ . _._. .. . _. . .. . . . ......-.... . . - ------- -- —'\--'-' '-" -' " "'"""
Cepitei Gee ee :i::=:?‘fiI$3 | |
I" I"I' I‘ '\II"'1 _..,_.,_... _. ._ . _ . .,,_. -...-.- .--...--- ;.:.-
._ . .. . . _._: , _.. . -_-. - .-. -. . .- - . -r;-..-.-.-r.--......--.....| ----.-.--:
wee? e,e:e.4e _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __._________.\____ ...\____. .-........-............- -.-.... . . . .... ..I III I I I
I-
-B¢~=’i34.45
2 -Is1,5eeee'% '
. -.-i.. .- -.\.| "\-
| Eliieeeirer ee $13351 _g. ._ ._._.____._._._. . .__.._-- -. . .. . . .- -_...- .-. -.-.-..---.-.-.-. -. - -.-. -.-.-.-. - -.-.- - -.-.-.--.-.--: .I --- -- I -- I-I I I-I- --i. -i... -
*tI?,5 {}II"r_{3E}E
_.;.._._.. ._.- .._ -. ..-_.- . . 5' 2~ .- 2 -: I-: . -. -. . . __ ....... . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . ..
efifii ' eee f | . - - . _.
-.-| ?:#%I.e W5.9??.=:"e.%e....%:*.e!ie.._ii?e'%fie??? I-. _-.J"{ ..._.,...................--.-.|.... ......................
1e,e;:e.ee
........... -\.--..-.--. - - - \ - - - a - - - '- - - - * ............
I
I: -1e,eee.,ee;
_ ' U...fif§ Eeet eieet
................
I ..-. '\-'|. .. - . . | . ..--.--.-.-.---i.- '
Eeeeetiee Leer: Pkieeeer Eedie eeeke ................................................. .-\..- ....... ..--i. . _._._~. _. ........................................... ..-.-if . . . - - - - . . . . . - . - - . . - . . - . . . . . . - . - - - - . . . . . . I\.II_I. .I\. .I.I.II.I..I Ii. III\.I\.I\. I I-
we E}I:'3.0€}'?
............................................ .. _._,
Piieney ewee te eretheag e_ie§ere_ir_}d_i_e______ _.;.__...,,__,_. ........ ..
~1e.eee.ee?i '
rzéeeey eweci re feeriee - | . . . .-. ......................................................... .. -.-._- ------------------------------------------ -I-
5,5 B'U.iI}{3 :25
“.......-.......- ....-.---.. .............. .|
Afiereey ieee ewee ' _ zxz rzmzéufi 833 eeeei s?.1¢4.ee :?§r.?. .7. ‘i;-.i§?i§’. §. . . .i. . '\| ___ _ __ ______ _ _____ _. . . .,_.\_,__ _ .. ,._.. .. . ._-.. . . .-.-... . _.-......-_............ .....-i._... . ..
'\| .| Ceeeenerety Uneeeered fleet __ __ __ __ _ __ __: _. ._,, ._,, 44, .
,,..__.__.____,_ ._._ ._._,.._ . .__.,. ._._. ;._.__ .. .. ._._.,,. . I .. .. . ..--..-r._-.-r..
-ee ezmei: 5
-.--.--.-.- . |.-..-.. .
. --... . ---. .-..-. -..- . .-.-.- -.-r.-. ;--.- - - .
;... ._..-.-. -_.-..-.. A -.--.--...-.-.-..-.-.-.-. . .- _-.-..-..- .-r.-. - .- -- -.-.-. - - . -- I ----.-.-- -- - --. -I --I-: I -I :II-II-I- II I I-II-I-II I-I ,_. ._.. . ._..._._._..- .- ..., - .- . ¢ ¢. . - -. -. .- -.-1 -. I - -. |"\f'I'\f'\| -.-¢--. ¢ -¢-- |- |"'ff: -H,-.I I- I---.-.I.-I : I.I.--. -- II :-I -I-.-I II--II---I II-II-II-I-II-I III-II-I- I-II-I-I-\-I-II - .- , . : -
Seperete Ree; Freperfy .¢. .\_._.___._._._ _._.__..\_._. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . - - - - | - - - - - - - - — - - - - - - - - - - - - -- _______________ _ -
_-_______ ,_.. __ -.I.
,.........-..I_... ...._.-. -. -| .-H. -
.-
- ...-.- -. -.------- - -- .\_ -
;:
----------- ., - - ------ - - __ .. ..
.-'.- H???5.5%.. ’§§f?1.F?.?.T?.?.§??%.??.[. .?.F?*§.?.§.=. _?.5§?.§. §§?.F? 5500-00 0--00 51 51 ?"??‘.§?'.:‘?¥?F3*. §.:??’:'1§?£*.%I1F=:i'.:"! *~“0“II‘-I0" "IEII
Page 4 Qffi ( riiiflé-I 1% (‘E3-'§3J
38 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Cause # 63935: Third Amended Inventory & Appraisement of Alavoor Vasudevan, July 2014 DIVISION ANALYSIS
C_I°"“?i"S’E'eeT°t§' YT’ Eek Eta‘ as 3 3 Community Real ESTQTG‘Me_d_i_ated§“ett_§g%ree,mentl 3 3 A 3 A 0
I g_ i 3:. 1;
I - 0 . I I - - ~ ~ ~ I- . - I I » I II » - r » I - r z-.;._-W.-...;-;,r:~.~»=\~.-rn-.w»<r._<r,.-1.-i-..:.......---.--.---4_-am,_-=,_>_.\.‘..;¢-..~<..;~a~.»-¢-.»s_\-,_p,¢-HI - 0 - - I I I ~ I < < I ~ - - 0 - - . 0 »t I - I » » . I . - - » V . -
so
'i
Separate Real Estate 5,5003 5,500 Separate Personal Propertygg 3_ g_ Separate Unsecured Debt '1'" II Et i!I i !r-lb-
‘ V‘ -- ' 1 ‘
‘ ‘ '
__
'
1 '- ;. . I‘ ,3 I ‘V ‘ ‘ ,. ‘ 7 V. _. .;~I“:»_-y~¢-.y.~_~.-1-.|~I»r;>rr.;-;q~r;:-,3-_»-___ _ _ _ g __ _ _
-II»
5? it .9
__-__~f-_-;-.~{.-_.;=-.5---_.f:~ __ at wlr an
___I'I._ :=.=.-_»=; _ _ ‘_r__—_‘_=- ‘_ ___% O Oj '
___—__— ‘ __;_
El".9_i.P;_9_
,,7‘39};-».»-,§.r1,‘>_‘.,<¢a..-q.)-er---¢-~,~,;..,.»¢~e-;..;.,?.,._.>
we commune and Sewers 0 _ 3 211e91_1_9@re _t 1,-e4»3@<>
Be” “dk5”hnnb b:°%*e¥ lee U3WL*‘L°£b? “Q U@§'vMK . _' _' _r__@,_;-\-.-_-.____
-' I ‘"
0- - .,
0
\\ilwil at ~“\\G§.§..."/.§"e
int?!” 1':
ii
0.,’ ,4? I'TIi |a!§¥¥‘ I‘
Q
"'1,
"r¢r0iir|m
Page 5 of 5 Cause # 63935
39 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Canse Cagse # 63935: Third Amended Inventory Alavoor Vasudevan, of Alavoor
Inventory & Appraisement of July 2014 Vasudevan' July 2014
Cause No. 63935
IN THE MATTER OF § tN THE DISTRICT s IN DTSTR|CT COURT
THE MARRIAGE OF §s §s
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN ALAVOOR VASU DEVAN §s AND AND §s 300TH 3oorH JUDICIAL
JUDICIAL DISTRICT
DISTRICT
DEEPA VASUDEVAN §s §s
AND IN THE INTEREST OF §s PALLAVI DEV VASUDEVAN, A CHILD §s BRAZORIA TEXAS BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
I"'I I Ii PI
--$EfiflND AMEN_DED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEMENT OF ALAUQQR UASUDEVAN Husba nd‘s Prcpceed Division Andjhierard of Prcperty Belonging Tc The Parties
—lI~Je . tic A “E Fess ' cmmnunity Perscnal Property " Husband ~ ' Wife Wife--- Netliialue 9' liletes I \I"1 ICITI BANK NRI BUEINESS |W_ 113,355-21 | _ U.LllU ‘Game frern_jnint ale cf Al _ __ | |
I IULR INTEREST LP _ ‘I.-"§_Il‘l’[El'EI5II .W E 51,-5I5":'.UI;I?| C|.:'U! _ 5'I,'=I_5I:|.':IC’!Ccmm Estate bcu Q ht after T992 _ Z
Jewellery and personal effects 'W oI450pooaof-oo,ooo | 450,000.00} oo s"e ExhibitB18may2014 450,000.00] 900,00C'.lUC'ISee Exhibit B 18may2o14 I
India prcperty File-tnc16, 10?r’a |-| | O-Oi----
..00l 0 00 I I O0 E ‘E 0 ‘UClIDces 0-ccl 0 00 )
ooes not
OqD*. 00 not :,<r;r
exist Mail r'-,d
Mril fraud. Mail fraud
""*""t
TRESIGEHCE 34512 CHSIIE RDfld,TX??55TTW — U UIIIIU '! _UI.'1IUIPer mediated settl agreernen -
__ _ ' '2ccs_re}ere Cerelia _ II-LL secede-_ __ s,5cc|.cc_.He,eeneT_reeerre,_eiaerr i 1 ' I-~rlC' .lI J1-Il 1 .:-!l‘\-J|'I E10 Mercedes Eienz E 350W _ w | c cs .i_A c - cc‘Leased car
i 8a c3o CD lw l lw I2010\/olvo
votvo 030' accr 5,s2s.cc‘ 5,52s.cc;~ere l2olo Volvo 12010 C30 i _ :1.-
r gI IAccount401KWe||sFargo n.*rnt AOf K Wells Fargo K _ _
(O _ ' _ ¥?,14-srl__ 5 _, ,,1rTs14-srl Husband _ _ i gIto1b l[""*nt i»,C¢ounr;i529‘r»ran - s29 Plr. Fidxx807
Fid--807 |_'P|_072'4E
LPLMa £1 _ n f 36,586.37;
JO,COO.J/ I 36,586.37iWife JO,COO.J/ LlWife
n
11
11 Account — 520 Plan LFIL0?32 MP5-145 CB I 32,294.54 32,294 54 | 32,294.54 ;H|,_|5b51I1d 12_ _ _ _ _ Acccunt - BanI: cfAn1_:-r:-r:-:E»¢i?9 E J s,scc.cc;_ _ o 2^^ 9,3GG.DUIL\/Tlifedi
wife _____%_ H E ^^ L VV IIE
__
13
E|.fllcccunt_- Bank cf Am chel-zing re-<39:I-J2 I ?’,92-I-l.?3i__ _ , ?,Q24.I"3flHusband.Asof Husband. As ol 25may2p14
25mav2}14 __
--. _
II
I 14 iAcccunt— Citibank, NA ac I U. JD miniscule bal. filic dead
15
Acccunt - Citibank, NA ac 1-:2-r559 U. DU rniniscule hal. ale dead -— L-D — — --- - I - —i -I I -- — — -
16
pscccunt — Capital One ac KIQUED ESE 'I2,UUU.[IUL _ ’I2,UUU UUiF'revieus inventerylilings shcws 'l, _17 11 —jAcoount ]!,99ount _ - l—l_DFC
Hqfg bank
!9!. ac ><><294
qq1!9-4 I iH i ,, , i_ “JI 0-0.00 5’9Iva'value miniscule - atc dead 22,mL"i,§¢2,!s :,§*°_'5*ea<! , E xx14S04 -*
I
, sJB+s ooA
,!9
§‘_.-,
18 Account 18 l Account -
- ,MerrillEdge
Merrill Edge ac xx1¢lS04 "‘—I-
g_0.00I qrya oo-fyt:--L, -
I-+ s3,,s4_3.o_0l
__33,_84§.*U:()iWifei __ g_-- :
-
'I 19 I‘ 19 tnccount af avoor pavpaf alavoor
lAccount —- Pavpal I I - - 385 lff 5 OO - --
gSS DUI 385 385-OO Jrr;;
UU7Husband
20 '1'-“-rcccunt RcthlRA |_F=‘|_>e::0?2Er Am -8650 r ‘ : | ‘ I |- | - -
I 1 — _ - . | -1 -- - -:--i —-—— - I Z i — _ —
5,B02-5r = 5,582 5? =1-iusiaend
I
|_ it H ,'Aeer§uni- Reliever IRA |_|5|_ xi-:0?2Bi III_ I ss,r.1Eis§i_%_ L same 9B§FH|.islJand_ _ _ _ _ _ .L_ e_ _ I }2 secede: - Ficth|FiA Ismefza Arn sss2 E s,1:ss.cr c.ccl 6,13Ei,0'F"'wire __n '
23 éscccunt - Til-ECU checking :-er:B?19 3,‘-1:151,_I_]5_ _ _ E3 , U51 .“U5]lIIIuat:rand _ _ —— ii
0 E4 _ I0rcccunt_~— tcecu savings >ersr1s _ ac?.s1 ' ' se?-s1 II-iusband as IF-rcceunt - "Ice LFITL 3:-:0?2Ei Am ;-rss2e _ 15,12? BU __ U. DU"; 1?, 12?. BU _ sep2-013 shews$iEI,20s,B1{3k wlthdw is _ Ieeecnr-Te5'L§L >es?=12 I _ _ eel: _ sssss as _c.cc| se_sss.ss 12dec1‘.';is F:FFI#EMa1l2l;l13shew 2? if-rcccunt —- Univ "Estes ORP 4035 DIED ;W , 2'3B,T22.B2| 23B,T22-B2! 4TT,4¢I5.Efr3'aneu|d he higher new I )28 y_Ia_lfig8_iiscccunt-WelIsfargecng _T_ r___._ :-:>:3059_ I 4',T24i01I_ 4,124 01 _ 4124.41 as Ii_4,1%4.01 as of25may2El14_ of 25may?O14 '
Page 1I 0f5 Page of5 # 63935 Cquse # Cause
Inventory & Appraisement of Cause # 63935: Third Amended Inventory Alavoor Vasudevan, of Alavoor Vasudevan' July 2014
,t-l6ount 29 IAccount — WeG Fargo Saving - Wells saving x7461 ‘H H 1,281.64 _ ___ 1,281 .64!
1,281 64 _ | ‘— N;.- ‘flgeminnunityr I _ PE|;5'Dl"I'3I Prepertv _ ‘ .. Husband I Wife _ !PesIll-lusband _ Net Value Notes _ '
If-sollarm 30 ‘Alarm clockdcwn B"d."," - _ W é clockdo*.r Bedroom _ _i ' 0 000 00 Bro ken
Bro ken
31 _l_Alinirah 3? ,Almirah in in dining room _ _ _ _ _'WW I ___ 1,000 1,000‘ 00 0 E 1,000.
'1,000 l")00
l") Expensive
Expensive Wood,
wood, architect
architect l..¢ U
32 IBed '— 52 lBed master bedroom ‘W W 600 00 600.1 C) l0
(1 "I0 Includes 6000. 00 lncludes headboard headboard wood
wood
I_ 3333 lCabinets lCabinets (in small dine, dine, up office) _W W 50.00 50 00 50 00 i34 Camera Ml I 50.00 50.
50 00 HC:{Iii_3‘£3 I I 'is ‘Camera IDTUIESSEJHEI cannen _ I _ _ 50.00 50.
50.00
Y36 ?A IChairs Chairq in Chairs in up aame room ronm 8r
rrn gameloom
game offiee
R office & lW _ IW_ __ 1,)000 _ 1"‘?
Not there any ??
anv more. Sold ?'? I |
I? 37 ‘Chairs Chairs 8 & Tables
Tables in side
side living room _l.I"-I ' _ 1,600.00.
1,600 00 1,600. C1C) rfi Luxury wood & architect E1 C1O architect
, as _:C:hilditems(lapt0p,piano,kindle,apple)
Child items(laptop, piano,kindle,apple) lw lW ‘_ 1,65:-.30 1,600.00 1,606- I-I"i~|_Fi| I-|| ‘Ii-F see Exhibit!-\ ExhibitA of deepa4thAm
deepa4thAm
‘Coat Coat Hanger inin big dine room IW I 30.00I 30.
I-I F‘!
30.00l
ll I I I
4-i 4-i
r I I 4c ‘Coat Coat Hanger in small dine dine room _W , _ 30. illFit ‘Ts-Ita . I5‘ IE‘ 41 .9°iCcntents ie¢_.ms9h.l
Coffee machine“e..‘.DinB[frt""D;adr;P1, Fikitchen
tshev
—
- __fWlW l
--r i —:
_l
—
Zwl 20 00i
is
.
|:l El -- Tl ‘ 42 upsta;" BR contents upstairs futon,bed,dvdPla l _ _;I_5'I.‘I IZIEI -
43 - Contents
Contents upstairs
upstairs BR
BR table,TV,
table,TV, bed
_
bed w _-.‘i
_-._ ' 60-2-. EIILQQill I' scs- 60 _ T44 Ccntents upstairs ER Ctai:-les,bed _ __'il'il' _ 150 00 (‘I0 150.
150.00
Q13 computers computers
46 DIE)player in man liiririg rccm E 1§i:~-..:~‘ 120 00 120. IIIJ DVD player upstairs game rccm E 50.00 Pi‘ fifi
50- ft 50 00
i _ -- i ‘=4? av: player with rcuter small dine I 120.0: 120 C‘000 ‘E46 iltining idem table {large glass} _ _ I EE I L— — — 3'-‘ 3,UU‘E‘ _ II
1"! F"?
3,000.00 . Luxury wood & architect 3,U0‘.‘.‘§“D architect |
-40 Din~'ng Dining room table in small dine E_ __ 180 00 _ ’I%:‘.U2: 180.00 glass table 'I8l:l.OO
-60 ‘Dols Dolls Tn
in entry and side
side room _E _ r50-00T5000 expensive -I-r
expensive wood dolls
'61 'Electrlc Electric cooker large (kitchen) E er- 0. IBIISI J6.40.6600
:» §3
i'ir'i '
52 _, Electrc E ‘i-.ii ,__,i I ' cookersmalllkitchen) _ 25 00 _ 25.
(kitchen)
Electric cooker
_ _ small _ _.L_. ._ _ I_:l,— 5‘ _5a _Exerc se bike in Exercise in BR 50.3 50.00 0. l:lI:l I
'_¥ ‘Exercse Exercise equip (treadmill, (treadmill wts etc_:)
etc) _ __ __ — ss" =‘fi;‘i-IZ’iifJ! 300 I00 00 _ — _ _ _ — — _u 66 External hard drive _ E 0000 00' 000 0.00
I 56 F&G F&G Life
Life insurance
insurance _I I 0 00 isise 0.00 Wifealso
Wife also has
has Fab
F&G seeenrrt
account
‘Furniture
Furniture in
in poss of husband In _ 0.00_‘__ _ \l"|
57 I 0.00 ‘§“5‘ i Ncne
i I‘Garage Garage items (bike, wires, wires, plastics) E I 50.00 50.
50 l"l00Pl U Q
_ 519 : ‘(glass Glass chess in side living room E _ ‘_ _ 60.00‘ 60.00 60.00I 60.00 I 60 60 IGold lEofo plated
pfateo idols, silver in
Cofs,sifver in dine room IW '_ m _ 600.00 600' Ci-0 See See Exhibit
Exhibit 0
D 18May2014 letter
18May20l4letter
161 _ Health {E1 Health saving saving ab
ac Fidelity
Fidelity ><><><9316
xxx9315 ' IH , 47917"
479 17 ' 479. 17 479.17
I‘ "62 62 iKey Key standboard
standboard in in main living _ J L _ 40.00;
40.00 00 iwocd 40 U0 rrood expensive
expensive | ,63 63 amp in side Lamp side living EE __ 60.00 60_.00 60. O0 I 60.00 I E4 ‘_ife lLife insurance '\lorthvvesternM I xx0804 ‘W NorthwesternM >o<0804 W I 20 684.60 08 20,684.60
i 604.60
48,684.60 t 69I369. 19 69,369.19 I
65 . ‘_Te Life i_nsUrarTbe—\ivYii\/itittiai . X1672 -pallavi
insurance NWMutualX1672 iH iFi 14792.9?
pallavi ii-i 14,792.97
C . _ .._ 14,792.97;
14,792.97 _ E i_ 66 _ iii __ife Life insurance
insurance i\lWMut
NWMut X1741
x1741 alavcer H 61,435 63 61,436.63 61,435.83
6? ,_iie-instiranee\iwM1.it$Z1641ceeea r-rrJrnsurance NWlrt ut it aa t _iiii ‘E _ ‘ 41,162.16“ 41,182 18 41,162.16‘
41,182.18
'ss Nlicrevvave in idteban _ _ __w LHH t ___ ' c00'eemee»ntnineneuee came with the house
ice i6e Vlonitor Monitor upstairs office W 50_00l 50 00 50. DD t- )70 Paintingsin .E?‘0‘_ Paintings in entryvvay—
entryway lw. ]
_ _ EHIEIWIT F 30000:‘ -_ 3£l0.00| __ —i id 'l5hone,wirelessdown Phone, wireless down Bedr0om_ Bedroom "W I 50.00:
50 00 _ 50.00‘ _ __ -i _'i 12 Pots/Pan _ _ inin Kitchen PotsiPan Kitchen _ _ W _ I' 3Oo.Oo 300.00 l._4l_
300.00‘ 3oo.o0
I ]
_
of55
Page 2 of Cause Cattse ii+
s‘ 63935
Cease Cause # 63935: Third & Appreisement Inventory 8:
Third Amended inventery Appraisement sf Alavoor Vasudevsn, of Aleveer July 21} Vasudevan' July 201414
| 1'73 3 _igfieerigee _ lRefrigerator E§g_eregs—_ in garage _— __ W _ _ 100 00 _ W90?
_'HIH3 100.00 _ No. _i’1ie. ffiefneseueity ]Commnunity Persene!
Personal Preperty
Property __ILssI_-ieshend Posr Husband Wife _ ffiife lblet Value £1-ietes Net ifeiue Notes _ __ 74 74 Efiefrégereterie lRefrigerator in kitchen W __ _ _ gfiu1="='. 1313'
800.00 e €?§3-'“‘_ 800 91.1.
00 | I_'?5 75 §&3h|—1e%ees,§'
Shelves, two we wooden
weedenlein rraesteefii
master BR _ ye
W . ‘I rm:-QI 70.00 rmzr’
70.00 Q _ "rs 76 __-
BER Silk Serees
Sarees {eteths}
(cloths) si!'rer,gei=:1
silver,gold reetet
metal _ _ _ is - .
'W ' _ _ 500.00 U1 fr: £3 I'll
_ _:I
' 500
{fl ""
"5.-I-F‘ 00
IE... * Hes
Has geid,
gold, siiver
silver wires in eieth cloth
77 '', "rr §Sefa {lesetecl in main living!9i99O __ EL W I Efiijaifill 500 00 500.00 78W, ......I................I............................_.......__..i...._........................................... $5 §$ere1 lSony eereeerder camcorder -.
jwi_ 1 _ _ ._ 5131
50.00 ,
50.00 7 i',__ _'— _.' _
Zg lsorint<tel. ' ¥§ Sprinkler system fv"nOt ifiprreidersystemfiyerd} =vsten, (yard _ ) ___‘-' 1! __ _ 5.5....
0.00 I-I 0 00 | part of thei the house '_ee ___Serreee1:.:!seeec:!
Surround sound speak iE1errg,_gerrae living, game rres rms I 313;: 11» ‘:1is 300 Z111 00i _ 3oo.oo C1 _:= 1 |_s-I IITeeEe Table _ {ieseteci (located uesteirs upstairs effiee}
otfice) IW _ _ei_ ' I. 111} 100 II £1
fj 001 en-100.00 :-.1e- _GEess Glass T‘-I
TV feizrie
table _ _ _ _
, s2 _"E1‘eeteb!ein Tea table in lerieg living reem room _ _ E __ _ _40 -Fe 3 ..-I 00
f
E-f:.
. 3 13:
. ff:
-.:_ 5;: 1;J - . 3 13:
—-F-
.
.|. - 40.00
itsC;Q U1ED
F11I 1:; [ sf:
13! L fl?
O
___1
MI
11' [ 111[
I 1!11
- ' * 1:
('1 (:1 [I1r""‘ ["1 I 1 11 1
)l ]f!q!g
B3 Feiexesiees{§RI!ir:|e,!e.re"|g Televisions (BR,dine living reerns} rooms) ___ 1.5013‘-913'
1,500.00
is-'1 §T@sf_er, Toaster, {seed
bread re
in kitehee
kitchen EE zooo P"-J 1:2}
1;_._._J I3 20 00 219.1919 l_ i
' es ifesstersvereée Toaster oven in etenee
kitchen E“ _ ' _ _ 21:1 -as 2-:.ee I_Bfi §‘\.r'§$@ Vase {in (in entry way} way) _ I I I “EDD.-DU 1U§" 1319 B? ,Weii Wall pester poster paint in
in ierieg
living reerra
room EE 5. ""-J U‘ I‘=3’ "1' 1'-‘=7r_1 "1-I F"
er — — — — -| -: '" _ "| ___ BB IWeIi all fiester poster peiet
paint in side
side Ewing
living reere
room _ 1'5.'U'C" T5 31-1'
94 Lame UTMA E_PLx;~=r.f3?21
LPLxx0721 Is ' 5e,e21.ee"_ 56,021 00 _ I seem 56,021 00
Lee 95 UTMA LFL LPL 11::-c'E5¢¥9
xx'1549 Are Am #221336?
*Fxx0367 E -=1-:,2ee.2e§ 41,288.29 e112ee.2e__
41,288.29
‘es 96 Fee F&G gifejnsureeee
Life insurance ' olo HUG; 53.1195 Beth Both W,
W, H have F&G1esurer:se
F&G insurance I es i seem, -0.00 I semei _ 9? Iiilresser Dresser set eeirrer
mirror mester
master ER
BR I Aeeeent Account -- Nebeezi
Nabard seek _ , Sfifififi 50,000 E16 5U,U§U.U£I|_ 1UU,DU~3.1L11U'eees,eee,ee Rs36,000,00 inin 1,-“ear
year 2£1E}e.Hew
2004.Now reer
- - .
93 98 bank 00 mor =— ----~- - .. .. | E2 I
-- ' - -
99 _Aeceure--ieere Account - ndia beeks{v:;,sye,eerp,:e:} banks(vt1,syn, corp, ici)I _ CJ.9UIWi£er:eeesteprevidecieteiis Wife needs to provide details '—1e?:1 _LAsceunt— Paypai sleeps . - -
‘W ‘ 1 -- —
seeeei — -Z —
some | i I I
rMr“ --" H 2 "‘“" " '" ' “ “ ”“ -+éflemrenunity _ ...... ..._._._._. .............................................
Commnunity Persenei eersonat Preperty
eroperty
....... . .. .._ ... .... ._... ...... . . . . .._ _ _ .
II
_ Z
1,363,300
1-_
Q2Q,21?'I 2,292,511‘ -
5
Z _ .-_ I _ .. _
sii . __ _ - _ 1-
Pege of55 Page 3 ei Cause # (53935 ("sees 63935
inventery & Appraisement
Cause # 63935: Third Amended Inventory Cease Alavoor Vesedeven, of Aleveer
Appreisereent ef July 2014 Vasudevan, Jeiy 2014
No.. Ne Csmrseseityflesssured Commnunity Unsecured fleet Debt Pessflusband Wife _ Husband Iwife Net Value Ir~|etee_ IIINetV_.siue Notes
_ _
2‘ 9 89 -Een¥<_e 1111.r'neries_se;::<?’~=¥ 3 l 39 Bank of America ac xx7493 _ W _ 0.00 —0.65 2,218.87
2,218.8? -2,218 87
-2,2188?’
ee 90 Cepisei Capital sees One es
ac :ec?s~63
xx7063 _ _ W 00.00 1-. s,5ee-ee"'
6,560.00 -sees
-6,560 be
00 _ '
s1 91 sseeveree reeeesz Discover acxx6482 9 IW I as 0.00 I sees
8,434 es
45 ms,-see es
-8,434 45
e2 92 _ 'Iilssseeer Discover es
ac :-:xS851
xx8851 _ see H I
11513 1 1,500.00
'1L..€J _ 31 500 ' - , .100
-11,500 90 “ ‘£33 93 I§tete State fisrzk
Bank sf
of tseis
lndia Qeese
House ieerz
loan 1-1:;-11285
xx286 --H 0.00 0.00 5.99 000 net 9.1919 not exist
94 94 Ieeeeeeee Education Less Aieveer ilndia Loan Alavoor e1::ii_s seeks banks I _
IEIE H __m,seI2.--161'
10,000.00{T1£11 9 I_~1§,qse.1e1eII -10,000 00 I _ 1 _ -10,000 00
9 _I?=.11er1e3.1' i 95 Money es-red owed tsIisrs’£§er, to brother, sisters isdés lndia H I ‘EG!E3E31f3.jl*¥l1II 10,000.00 I »1E1,E1E3E1.13{} Q6 96 eeeeee Money eeee owed is frieecls_ to friends “ _ n _ H 55,000,00 cease 1-5fee_e.1ee”
-5,000.00 "
e?_ 97 IIg11.1Ԥeree3r Attorney fees ewes owed , 337,114.00 ' ese:21:1E1'
8,000.00
IH EIEIErm.eeesiei-§1€es'
. 00
-45.114 =s
I cemmeeemrueeeeeree Commnunity Unsecured i;~eB1:_ Debt _ _ '_ ' e¢,s;ee.eeI_se.a2?,:s2'I'
44,500.00 54,327.32 Q-es,s2?._s2_ -98,827.32 _— ‘ _ _ __I {fee No. _Sepsre¥e Separate Free} Real F'repe_rt31
Property _ _ _Tf’s1ssIi-tusbesd:
Posr Husband Wife _ II?Ii¥e_ Net Value
Metveiee mere;
Notes _ _ _ —
_e? 97 Hesse House seeeegeeeeeaeeae,semjnere Gandhinagar lndia, 1/6th share HH Isseeee“ 5500.00 E see
000 5,5sU.U§IIseeeeeree.ese--eseeeeee_ 5,500.00 Alavoor 0,000 - 4500 debts 1 _ _
f’ege 4 Page sf
of 5 Cause if# 63935 {Tseere 63935
Cause # 63935:
639352 Third Amended Inventory Inventory &
& Appraisement
Appraisement of
of Alavoor
Alavoor Vasudevan,
Vasudevan, July
July 2014
2014
DIVISION ANALYSIS
ANALYSIS
Combined Total - _e E toTotal
__ _I_ _ Husband's
_ Total
Husband,s Total ,_ _ Wife's t__ _t Total Wife's Total e_t_ Community Real
neal Estate;l
Estatel Mediat\=§SettAgreementIIII rtlt.ai""o I I I I II I OII 0g I Community Personal litrepertyr
I
""ionr*rr,."
I2,2Q 2 ,5‘I? ‘I,3153.3U=EI __ __l Bl
s2 9.21?
Community Unsecured Debts -ea_Ia2?' I I I -44,s@ III I 1-54,32? rerermercemmenre EsteteII I I_2,1aa,sse@ 1,a1s,aoe erases Pereentage ef Community Estate 100 so 60 4Ol -lb-
Separate Real Estate Estate S,5O0i 5,5005 5,500 5,500 0]
Separate personat separate Personal
, vrrvrrqrr Property
rv1lsrr)' property _ _ -___-
oi ol Ul 0o U ;lO,t.EL9_2
l
Separate Unsecured Debt Debt O-
OI III I II OII- I I I_ - 01al Estate
i _;_
Total T^+al Separate
O^^^-^r^ Estate
r-r-r-
5,500! c,cuu
_ s,q00
I_ I slsoo I I 0;
o
Total Community and TotalCommunity Separate and Separate
fQ aiggagdl;
2.1ggtgotf 2' I 11324500 1p24,30O eesgol aZZSgOl
-I[^L d. ?-,,Jr -+4 c1eett¢/v-
§i€‘Z1-\_aa_,I'F .t" .#.e s(%cfiT'€1I (L:vt r.t i5s"<§2e; *-n-F \ rrE;: k'"-^ru*
-7 teeeea teats?
\ ‘I
b"* h,r tc I_III\_II,C_II,LII .lt'(,L t, u-$o,trtt{ __i;=(,,;t_ [r kra'cz-1 lt*" "t(n L:q u"t o{tt [3
,icl^e £1 5L4) 64,-._Q L'¢?_
.1’__ LI. I -"
State flflfie I '5 County f P511). "I4 U
Q!
ibedandstnrernb-at . I ,_.:I. - . {Date-l v)+s t)EVtfr(t
(rat/re'uc»@~rL (' X-uv,c-dL ‘\/*PrS J UODEVTQT“
SlI"|flIl.n"EI
\I\\'\ E S 9/1?"
<QI§;.5*‘5"g"I”%~ ‘$3
""1 i‘ \il||"‘ as
E; '.-_ -rtinge J in L1Lr@h£axa!!fi| cgik '“ TIa| |Il\“ ’: l>
I’-"Hr 1 3 1 q'\\‘\‘ "rn||||\\\‘
Page 55 of
of55 Cause Cause it# 63935
63935
Appendix E Court's Division based on Inventory filed by Wife District clerk sent this appendix directly to 14th Appeals court.
Trial court's mistake of not considering the husband's inventory but court's division based on Inventory filed by Wife is attached in case envelope.
The District Clerk, Brazoria sent directly the “Court Division based on Inventory filed by wife” in document titled “EXHIBIT-COURT's DIVISION of property 5-27-14” to 14th Appeals Court and is also referenced in Index 297 (page 297, IDX 297, Appendix O).
Wife's inventory filed is Fourth Amended Inventory (Exhibit 5) which had wrong figures and incorrect amounts (RR2 page 5 line 20). Husband raised objections to wife's inventory (RR2 pg41 line20, RR2 pg43 line10, pg44 line1, pg44 line14). The trial court's judge had never said “Five is admitted”, see between “Four is admitted” (RR2 pg43 line1) and “Six is admitted” (RR2 pg49 line19). There was never a word saying “exhibit five is admitted”. Hence, wife's inventory is rejected by the trial court and judge. But in spite of this how the trial court made error by putting this Exhibit 5 as admitted ? No one knows!
As per TRAP 38.1(k)(1) which says brief “must contain a copy of the trial court's judgment or other appealable order from which relief is sought”. Hence, included here is the copy of the trial courts “Exhibit - Court's Division of property”.
40 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
\_IIII
*5m _4vj"h-I‘.
sass i~“~‘%"1‘1"i ii
-
IN WEI MATTER Ge ' I ta THE orsrerer come? THE NlF\R‘F{iF\GE OF
I
ALAUOOQ VASUDEVAN ares I zaoom JUl3tCEAt. elevator DEEPA VASUDEVAN
AND l¥\i THE INTEREST Oi: eettav; osv, A came I saazoree COURTY, Texas F'6URTfi_l1T.|VlEuoéomvsmeamuo.APPRa|§@EflT~o£.oEeeA vasuo EVAN I
l 1 ""1"?"
"A1,?--L ll-I5 E-'lF53"'r "||f""5l »-»- ‘H I-'l""'_ -='--E
l
Wife*s Separate Personal Property Po§_s Hesbeflfit _IJ"_eI'Iife I. C-ETI EANK N§_._|IB3I.I$|NE$$_ W I __ 1e:3,1es.eo Wife __ _ _ 2. D'LR¥NTEF~1EST LP - H5 ieterest 51 .45_{Il.0U Wife 3. Jewelry and persoael attests I II W 5,650.90 Wits Wife's Separate Persona? Propegig QB?! 159,593.69
Community Rea; Property I Feee Husband Wife 4. inolia Property - Pit}? N13‘ 16, SY Ne H Hesoaao '¥t3?'fA 3: 1{}?{}r1'AA OAK GARDENS, AVG TOWNSHW, UPPEIIQQUDA MU kt-EALSA EBRAHIMPATNAM. IBRAHIMFIATNAM, F~1.F~1. Dist _ 5. Resieaaee leoatee 3462 Castte Pose W UBO 0.99 Per MBA Ct, Pesrtano, TX ??584 ——- ' -|--. . _ _-.i_
Cfii'F‘H"Ht.IFiIIZf( Rea! Progertg e.oe t}.t}fl
Community Fersoaai Property Poss Hesoaao IIIII Wife _ I
I_ Eli. ZUUQ Toyota Cogelia H we-|eeeee'f31'5.r'1?£' “___ I aeeeene I _ I ?._2E}1£} Meroesles-Be_na ESEUW W _II19.{}{} Wife e. sage tgeae oso E 5,528.99 Wife __ I 9. Aeeoeat - et}1t<- Weils Fargo 1'r.az4.a? _I __ Huseaao 10. Aoooeat - 529 Plea - Fidetity # QI 36,586.31? Wife _ II ><><>O<8{}? Lr’?>l:_#><><2Q<_Q?_Z1-t I TE. Aeeeunt - 529 Ptan - LPL # XX}'~’)({}?32 H 33,294.54 Hasoaeo we # xxxxeess
“E2. laoooeat - Beak of Arneriea Aoeoeat e W ‘$3,399.91? Wife 9'1-T2<.3'§fi*.479 $3. Aooount - Seek of Arrtertsa Cheekteg H *1-‘l~¢9'3-+760“ irissbflfld ?g\_<;<;I<_>enr e xxxxaeez I 1%-IQ" II _ 14. aeeeeez - cztlaawx, NA. Aeeeonta H Husband X><1><><_. _ _ . - . --.-_i.,_.___ _ I" D
Page 1 of 5
5/16/2014 f’ '2“o i-
~a_ I
FOURTH A¥v‘¥E¥\iDED WVENTORY AND AF’F’RAiSE¥ii1EI'~i'¥' OF IIQEEFA VASL¥DEV_A¥*-i
I-I A-I I Wife's Proposed Division Ancl Award {if Property Belonging To TneIParties I
CIoIrnrnItIrI£1Iity Personal iI5’roperty Page Husieanci II _Wife_IF t5. Account - Ci"t“laAt\it<, NA. Account at H Hnsoane XXXXESQ II III _ II I ___ _I I 16. Account - Capital One Account # W £3.06 Wits _----_>Q<.XX206e II I_ _ ___ _ 17. Account - HDFC Bank Account # H Wife __ XXXX294 I IIII I I I II re. account - ivierriii E-jogs Account it W e:i.ees.se Wife XXX)(14ISt}¢‘i II ___ _ ___ _ _ 1_9. _-A-o_oonnt - IE~'avPai _I §I,Q0O.OO Husband 20. Account - FHTYH IRA LFL e XXXXUYES H 5,392.5? Husband _i.A_n"rerIiIcan Fnnos it XXXIXQESIU _ ___ 2t, Account - Reliever iRA LPL it H 83,070.98 Husband XXKXGTZB I
I 22. Account - Roth IRA LPL # ><><>o<o?2s w e,iss.or Wife American Funds # ><><_><;<e_es2 I II I II ____ 23, Account - TDECU Checking Account # H 3,U5t.£i5 t~*Euati}anct ><><:>o<ar1_e I II 24. Account - TDEZCU Savings Account it H sorter Husband ><>OO-tEi?‘l9 I 25, Account -- Tilt} Account LPL it W to,i2?.8U Wife ><>oo<e"r2e American Funrls # :>c-<>o<aago_
26. Account - TOE} Account LPL er W 53,?'32,32 Wife I_IXQ(XX~‘5?42 II I I I 2?. Acconnt - University of Texas - ORP W 3:n",e're.5e Wife i l1.f¥entorri£'i3B Eiian I I I_ II I 28, Account - University of Texas - ORP W izsaeree Husband ivtentor rose Pian __ 2e. . -
Accoent - Waits Fargo Checking H , Huseand Account axxxxsese II l-H1 - — _- _
30. Account - Waits Fargo Savings Account H i,281.E5-it iinshano it >(><>€?eSt _ 31. Atarrn ciock [tocateo in downstairs W {LOU Wife I oedroorn} I I IIII 32. Airniraitllocated
_ in dining room) W _. I II_---II.I__-
We - Wife -.
33. see {iocateo in rlovvnsItIairs eeeieei1eiII_I_I1g{___I I _ I riiiii sea-so Wits 3-ii. Cabinets {located in srnalt dining roorn, W 59.00 Wife upstairs oIf_fice, anti srnatl dining roorn_)
35. Camera I vv seen Wife _ I35. Carnera, proiessienat, {IanInIen WII I__I II I____I ___ I seas Wife 3?. Chairs (tocateci in upstairs earns reorn W 0,00 Wife man<110.f_1‘.i.<>.e). .
38. Chairs ano Taleles {tooateo in side iiving W 800.00 Wife . -.F001TJ _____ _ _____________________ 5/16/2014 Page 2 of 5
FOURTH AMENDED INVENTOBX AND APPRAlSE_MENT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAE
II I Wife's Proposed Division And Award Of Fgijoperty Belofigingg To5Th5e0il5arties L . l _LiH¥ Personal _F_’_ropYerty __Poss_ Husband Wife T _ i_Qhlld'S Properly. _ _ .._ __ {Shite See eeeegt A 49. Coat hanger (located in dining rg_om)_____ W __ 0.00 W Efe 41. Coat hanger (located in small dining W Wife room) -r
42. Coffee reeohine (iooateci in kiteheo) _‘~f-‘_ 2.00 Wife H 43. Contents in upstairs bedroom (futon W 150.00 Wife bed and dvd player)
44. Conteote to epetaire bedroom {teole, W 150.00 Wife television, one bed) _____ 45. Contents in upstiars bedroom (2 W 150.00 Wife computer tables, bed, and computer) _ I
46. DVD player (located in main living W 20.60 Wife room)
47. DVD player (located in upstairs game W 20.00 Wife room)
48. D\/D player with router (located in small W 10.00 Wife dining room) _ _ 49. Dining room__table “T J 1,000.00 Wife 50. Dining table (located in small dining W Wife room} _ _ 51. Dolls (located in entryway and side W 300.00 05Wife living room)
52. Electric cooker, large (located in 0.00 _ Wife -__“-l<i_t<2t1en1 53. Electric cooker, small (located in W Wife _ kitchen) _ _ ‘ _ ___ _.d- -
54. Exercise bike (located in downstairs W Wife bedroom)
55. Exercise equipment, weights and W 200.00 Wife treadmill (located in upstairs game —- —
room) —- —— |___ ..._.____ ii _ I __ .--_
56. External hard drive W Wife __ __ 57. F&(§ Life Insurance _ __ __ I 3,000.00 __h_______ __ Husband . ....f?.ereit.ete 5" Fititeefieeififl *?>fHe51‘»‘E1"t<3 E Hoeoeoti _ _ _ _ _§.3erege itreee (oioyole, wiree, pieetioe) E 50.90 Wi_fe _ 66. Giaee oheee {looateol to eioe living E 20.00 Wife __.-_._reeo1) _ ._- ..
61. Gold plated idols, silver (located in Wife _dining room) 62. Health Savings Accoutn with Fidelity H 479.17 Husband Account # XXXX9315
63. Key eteodooero flooeteo to meiri Zieirig Wife _ room} _ _ __ __ _ 64?-'-@113.- . .55.- _. . . 10-09 _ -liie .-__ _-.___-
SHEIEG14 Ftege 3 of 5 .F___OvRTH &MEN1lED I~ EEPA vASuDEv.A~ if _ Wife's Pijolposed Division And_Av_var_d Of Pfo’pe1r;fy1B5elo_ngin_g)To 'l_‘he Parties 9 ll
C_0tjr|mur_1_ity Personal Property __ Poss Husband Witiel 1'.
1 65. Life Insurance - Northwestern Mutual W 44-359-19 W110 Policy # XXXX0804 insured Deepa \/__asudevap _ ____ __ ____ -.
66. l_ife insurance - Northwestern Mutual H 14,792.97 Husband Policy # XXXX1672
insured P_allav_i Dev _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ 67. _ife Insurance - Northwestern Mutual H 61,435.83 Husband Policy # xxxx1741
_ Insured Alavoor Vasudevan _ -
68. Life Insurance - Northwestern Mutual W 41,182-18 W110 Policy # XXXX1841
lnsu_r_ed D_eepa Vasudevan _ .
69. Microwave (located in kitchen) __ __ W _ W110 -_ __
70. Monitor(located in_upstair_s_ gffice) W _ _ _ Wife 7jl. Paintings (located in entryway) '11-1_ 100-00 W110 72. Phone, wireless (located downstairs W 10-00 W110 _ bedroom) _ _ _ y ___ - 73. Pots/pan (located in kitchen) _ W _ 200-00, W110 74. Refrigerator (located i_n garage) _, W 50-00 W110 75. Refrigerator __ W _ __ __ W110 76. Shelves, two, wooden (located in W 0-00 W110 downstairs b_edroqr_n) _ __ .
77. Silk_Sareers (cloths) 9_ _ ___?-"11 500-00 . W'fe 78. Sofa (located in main livingroom) __\f1f _ 100.00 Wife 79. __Sony Camcorder _ W 50.00 W'fe 80. Sprinkler systen3_(yard)_ _ Wife ___‘
81. Surround sound speakers (located in W 200.00 W110 main living room and upstairs game £00111) -. _ _ . _ -
82. Table (located in upstairs office) 20.00 _ Wife 83. Tea table (loc_ated in main living room) _ _ __ W110 84. Televisions (located in downstairs W 1.500-00 W110 bedroom, small dining room, and main living room) _ __ _ _____ _ _ _ 85_.yToasted, bread (lo_cated in_kitchen) _\_11-(___ _ 10-00_ W110 86: _“l_'oaster_ oven(located in bedroom) W 10.00 __ Wife 87. Vase (located in entry way) W___ _ __ 20:00 Wife 88. Wall poster paint (located in main living W 25-00 Wife room) __ __ _ __ _ .
89. Wall poster paint (located in side living W 25.00 Wife room) __ _ _ C<_J__mm_unity Pegsonal Property '3"1‘0T525T‘19" ‘590:5*37T4‘7“ I I’ _ . ,1 f~ ._
5/16/2014 '1Tii.f 1 ‘ll-» " 01:.1 1 P :\a-fl‘)-3
‘
-in :-u| pw|, q,_ _J
Page 4 O15
_|_:_QURT[-l_AMENDED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEMENT OF DEEPA VASQDEVAN
I] Wife's Proposed Division And Award Of Property Belonging To The Parties l Community Unsecured _ ___ Debt POSS Husband ________________i______ _ Wife _____________r
_ 90. Bank_ofAmerica Account #X)_§_)§X__7_49_3yy_ W -'l6,357._2_4_ ___ _\{\__/_if_e__ ____91._Cap_ital One Account#XXXX7063 W __ ______ ______’_ ______-_6_,560.00 _ Wife _ 92. Discover Account i1f_)§_>_<XX64_82___ ___‘-1'1-1 _ _ -8,434.45 _ Wife 93. DiscoverAc_cpunt#XXXX8851_ __ H __ -3_,_668.00 ___ ___ Husband 94. State Bank of India - Housing Loan H 0.00 Husband ___ _ Account #___XXXX286 __ ___ _ _ _ Co_g_ninunity Unsecured_Debt -3,668.00 -31,351.69 -""1.
‘i-\i,(-.(1(-M -1 ir-r.,.. I
:13 -" ___"'1J |- 11}H. ..<;:.
__- .1 ----- —_
1 7 7“ if - ".1
rv-/11-M
'11
1‘-1111:. 1111
1 a R1
I I
‘~15
1 '-. . "- "1
IN
1
.1
I
11
1*» ” -~
1 1
1
1 111 1 1
5/16/2014 Page 5 of 5
63935
IN THE MATTER OF IN THE DISTRICT COURT THE MARRIAGE OF
ALAVOOR \/ASUDE\/AN I AND 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT DEEPA VASUDEVAN AND IN THE INTEREST or= 1 PALLAVI DEV, A CHILD _ BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
CHILD'S PROPERTY
111 111111 1 Proposed II;1#___Wife11s 11 Diyis__ion_ And Award 17Of 1111111 1
Property B eio nging 1 1TZ11Tne1P1ariies1 11 l -- -_.. __ ,__ , _____E,9_§,§ , Husband , ...1!V_1f..“;_.e_ _“l_
_ 1. Compgter (located ip upstairs office) W 50.00 O E1. Q;
2. Kindle __ _ _____ _ W __ .. . ___o_,i____.. . _ 2.5.-0.0- . 1.";-‘=if 3. Laptop,_ Apple _ _ 20.0.-.13‘1Ii ("Ti E iii. 4. Laptop, pink _ E5 _ 56.06 O E £1
_.-§>_--.__P1.o!?o(1ooo1oo downstairs bedroom) __ _ _,___, __ 1_._000.00 O 2'. ti -.. ,_ ..
6. UTMA-LPL#XXXX0721 Ire _ _ 9 ee.e21.ee .-_-
O 2'. O.
-_-. .
7. UTMA - LPL # XXXX1549 American E 41,288.29 O 2'. Q.
Funds # XXX)_§_0367 __ _
0.00 98,635.15
Pogo 1 of 1
Appendix F Proof filed by Husband for Community Estates Proof filed by Husband is attached in case envelope Appendix F (IDX 325 Exhibit 2, RR3 pg 5 line 12, RR2 pg 4 line 9, RR2 pg 78 line 4 and line 10, RR2 pg 88 line 19, IDX 364, RR4 page 3 line 4, RR4 pg 3 line 9,11,13,14, page 4 line 4; BR 11) Trial court made mistake of not admitting Appendix F during 1st trial. And in the 2nd trial when this issue pointed (RR3 pg 10 line 14), the judge said since appeal is being filed, let appeals court deal with it (RR3 pg 11 line 8).
The proof here shows that there were more than $100,000 US Dollars(in Indian rupees) in CitiNRI bank a/c in the joint a/c of both husband and wife. And wife withdrew that amount which is now shown in inventory item # 1.
41 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
.||l'-in.
Ei.:'11.1.I'r:|.i1I1.1i=.1 1.1: 11.5.1.7-.% Etaternent -uif Account
"='I‘='II'=' I--I-i:=-wk I--"-"--1I1'-1' 1=.-I::.1'-:-in-:-.r|1. E-or: |_‘||.-u. 1.-|||u::||:|:':l .r.1=*=' I'r1_E-I.‘-1.12-I l|.- :|.u.-: '=-:..1:::;-|. 1-.__.,|._- ;|_ |_._,_ 1
Fulfil-III] II‘ | I-'llll-1|
'I'|='-"EFF; ? T!-1l'.l.'1' l'?il|-'5"I".L|E E1lEl1"l[I I1!!! J:':'_l'!|.l'1.L-l'LI-ll."
I].lIl1I|Ii:-.'|:Ii.ru|ii". u.r|:::=.;|i,'_|=E-rg. for you '.I'1I'J|.FJ U31 - '.l"J.":-fill
D511: ':1"I=1"|;':'|15"1-1E1 |3l'I'-‘I1? I"I'I‘l'l'I'I'|I“|"' i|IL'I_'L':|||I L:- '-.':||.||: El:-r|:'.uI. 1-."I l_"q 5.'|_||-
-'1-1:‘?-l."L!-IuI:I:|.t o:|:|.':'|. |:1;E|:-:.-ri:]',i- |=-mi:-1|-|.-| -..r-||-|- .-.|-
11111"1"111'1 5"-*1 :5-1: 5"'="1-1115 P'5'T"1=5'-111"-1 5'11-1"-‘II-1-Ill"! I-1 1IIl-|=1EI=Il‘II‘I jrr.-:1:-::-I: ::.'.':r= of E-.51-L T-HI -|.|:_'|I.1|1. -:|n 1"-:-'.1:|: |1|'1.' HJ.$Ll'|'L"55. I 11'|2|L11I:5 ]i.|:|-n |.r| _|_;|'|;|;3|:|:|'| 1|.-.;r_'| |;|f |;I;r||;| |;|_-|| r"-|,-;.|:,=_ 'p1|:__-| -|-_'|-I’: |-|_|u-__fl_.|-_|_-_ E__|_|:| |.|h:r.l yflur Izrnly, n1|':|:||-"11 "'|||||'|||'::':u1!!'T|.|.:§ ‘lIl'I. Du“ |-1-IE1‘-=t'-I-"El::I-' a:l'IIlJH'lJ'I Em; "_1I||| |.|:1;:|-|;-|||_ ::'|:||.': t|‘1r':|l- if I-":13 '._|._ .-'.-
‘=-"=-"1'=1=- P41‘ 5'11-*-='====r-H =1-1-‘-ifrrru - -=111"I:-=='-=1‘.-' or. i:-:- 1-n-.----:1I;i.n1r1.-;r.ri| .-'| ||:I 1::-r|_:|E;|_' i;_|_':11;5 1;.=-,-_-¢.1E -II-H-"-I‘!-=lI;l 1141112-E5155 2L.'|. U5, LIE. .-|.:||.|. !i|'|r_.|.-la-.-|r|5 1:. |;1|;|1-r _;_l'_ ._||_,-|-r i.'.'| |,-|r_|;_|_|:;|_,:,n: ;|_-J1 ,:|_|;_|_:|_-|_|-|;|.;u._.| |:|.H_H tn ._|_ -|'--:.j1|.:l.l':|1|-' =4 |L="-I-I-“II. lfl'|r'I|'| |'|-'|1'j .'_ q'_;|=:1__ 'fl|_' ]_|]__f|_' ‘I-.§.!1Ef1|:i_r_r:|f 1:‘ J_i.'|fl_|__;|__
--I-"H-=1 '-'="--"---I-"I -"Ir" "-1';r.=;-I1 |..-.|IL-"_':l'. |.r| :|::i.-=|;.-_ -I-..=. Irl i'J'I-'-‘ll’-fl-H -H=rII=-H ll:-' o1t.1-::- - 111.4 |;:.l.;1r_| I--e-i|.=l.-._ e1I."_':|.|:_ L11-:;:|'|.'=-‘.1 .;|e_i _-i',;',_|_-_1_|1fJ;|;|1_
‘r-'r.I:.rr. F:o:ra.|.';'l:.
Fl?
L‘-Li?
Pi-fi.h.1J.I. IIl1|.|.':|.1|.I.|-I-|:.n| fiT F-'-l.i1.||I.;||'.| J:lu_'|.u::||::
=|I‘-1L1-:':".|'Il'.l-I."-.|.| !'|iII|||.'|I -.|'.;|. '.'|iI'| i|||il|'|l I|||l:||:I.' || I-lg l_I'_= ,1‘-
.1;1'a"1;.TT.1 :1-1:-1}:-r111-=11i1r11=ri rel] .1.7:=1.1.1f Statement of Account E1111"-|I11iI]E] |'"|Ir1[
|i'|!'EF'.7'. '|i'|"1.|'E|1.'IIIE'|I'.i|.I.'I' |=|_.|T_ 3 fir _-| :1‘IIJ.lIIil.l'|]'. I-|.2|':i.':-'J|'.1'_ L-!|_"| -|I.. |.:|'.|-|.1l|._[: |_l: .3, -:|'j_;_|-|:|-3 ;[;|;-;||;|-| _|"_-,_';l|_?.|_ |:|J_ I g._'|._'.;;, |_|.: H_=,l_q_ J1 I 3|:":.q
.II'|:1r.I; ||:='|-:iur|-.1 if_|._-)__:l;t'
:'= 3=.l_.'I.'-"_'-'_'-1: .".n_':I.r|:-|1'-.'.|=.|::
$1,00,000 US Dollars
illfilh-u|.l:| l'. Fill-l'..I|1: I 1|
E1111“-'=T 1-1-*1 -3.Lo:.1.n|;r E-a1 '-41'-=13‘-111" 1'-'-'1'-T1'T'1-1'l"I'E- -I11-=11--I-‘ill-='IL Pr -I-FF" 'l‘.l.,E'I.1IIl3 Zine:-:.a.a|:s r.-I-.:-1-I-_-:|-qgr _|.;|_,=,1:,-_ 3_|_ g._"||_'|.;
I--_£o1-"Ho P-=1 _ W 1 1 1'»-irll :I:=-1:125-:|.'.'a ;.§-iifiri-§:11:.=.~*-r fl|i,1_1;|5-5-_E|3 -|.I'-:-1.1.1 i|.1l.:I.'|r|¢'| ' _' ' ' ‘ ‘
.|LI.1 I'12|1.|:unI|Ir n1-III 1r| l':|1|-|1I:|n IH1'[1.|I-rl-;|
I'D II1III'I 0|-iIfiI=1 -Heel‘ 5==I-r III?-Ir-1r~=.1 ." Iril:-Ircrrlel: I':|:-:-1-Ii:|.|:-5 [Eliiuii-I: I‘.-u .-|.fl:||'Ii-III 1-111-1--1-1-I-‘I-Ill l'Il'l"-"I'=' I'=¥'IIl.l2l1?E- 15113111211211; i|.IL'-|.'|'|.l.1; 'r'|_'|J: l.l.l|l1I]!' !'.l||-1:-:gl'| l_-—]'_|f_1_'|_ 'p]'|_|;|'_'|;| 1'-1:-=. 1r:'I;'l:1:-rs. |::|:. 'i'.1Il'.'.L|; uoeirg 5|=u-- |||='|-|, I-_||-p-_~;g -i_-_|-|_;|_1; ;|_1; ;5 ;|_ |;1_7_;|_E._;|,|.L '_|.LL|..: - 1-II.-Ir-.'.|'|ll|'|;; 3-.f|;|'_
42 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
1'" '!ItIl11I 1-T-'11‘ E='!I|.'I"E:I|£E|;-r;' H. ;|':|.|.c-;:- H flr'||_i-_|_|r_|1_135.|;|
-::1:=.'I- "1I"ll-IIELI .*'- ' -. ' .1 .1-15.11.-T. Etaternent of Account CI1I:II:1E1lI1Ir'l _||-|:_!||._$_n||; E|.,=:_,,_|_ _ ;|_]-,|_- nil ;|;||;q rn I'll: 31_ 1-_'|1-; |,_g;|,_-|;.-.-.-..r. |_-|_|,|-_.;_ _||1:-: l]|_| M2115 |,-_|.-,||(- I ::lE 1
DIIEH -|'.|||.|JJ.l'IIII'-1'-F-"1
EIUIII1 @5'I.'I|5 F‘-'lF|'|1 III I-|;l_l:l'!J.|:1IJ
1551.3 ':'-.=.1I. - 'i'f5IiIi
I:-,|.-;-1|:-:I||:.1: :|-:;-|i-!-§|lIl| £24: {Irr--n
[:i:|:5|r I:'_:i.1:uI:
I|:.- '5I:ru';|.- .11-.-m.-I, RE-T h-.|.-.r C-H-_=F'Il1 Zltfl n-I-I-i|:|TI=I 1 I"|'|1.:: y|';:|_'[ i2:r.|;-_'*|_-_||||. 'Flll.‘|I 5-u|_.5n|-:|I| |:-u.|'1|\l:l.||- 12111-
j.r|'iI-:I.|-I. |_'_'I-l=I ':|.- 1|-5 i-:;'-ell -:|r|. BEE -'1-J-'n.||-:|i.1 !-icu-4-J.--h cal‘ ;|;-a.-.-1---n:::Lm;| :-nu ‘I: l.LJ. -.'Ir-I-1: Llr.- 1-I-'-=-I-:l.
:I|.-:|:|.I.l'_||.'I'- '.:| E :|‘||r-I‘-I-_'l|.| I.TlIllIl|I., flI.l.I-'-j-II=L ll.‘ m--il -.~n 1:|1nr-l- -.r--u :|'.|:-.|.' ‘Fl-1l|||' |:=|.1t1--:nr=1 ;:|:clIr=-=u-|.1-- ;_;-."l|::.|:|| |;-.n\|.-,r -;_.;|;|;|:||1:. ‘Ii-.-.-r--n 1.':l.J:|.+ nil" l:hI I||.|fl'|-=I-I-H. |i'|=||: :u4. |?.'|=J.'l::-|.|-.-';|.1 h=-.L|:I-i..|'r§ FIT:
|-i1-r|-|_|:'|_1'.1.:..|;.|_-tn -1: :-:-..-I ‘L1’!-I 4.-¢l1 |11'I-I 1|-u. 1I'l fig :||:|[:-|I|i1';:I .i;| I.11rl:|.I., I arl-"I n-J.-|.-Lu:-'-5 to _r.l":-rm. _-|--.|I1 3|.--.u. --I-:;|:.u:1 la i-:n.-:-- I-1-n LI':u;'.'|: 1¢|t.-I.r.|':f-'I' =-=13:
1-_b,|,L I1-np :|_|-|_l;.|:;|_'|::I|.'L |_-;|:| :TF|II |1|.|:|':|:r|r.'L| -:||:|fl l':J.I:1I]'-
— -:L-==t-inq t:.|=-. I"-.--r :l1-;|2|.i22Ii2=I- |=u.1.'!-'I1==-r L-':i.-H-1 lI'n|.;L||';|'||;l:|" nq-.-;-.:.;|-I-.1 -.111‘: fll:r.|I.'_T|Ii'| '.-=- -.-nj-=-|-'
I12:-H; rrl-.-=l-_|. J-I'll." |:|_ E'|I|.-"Ijl:|. Ti; :1 I:u-'_-it gm.-ii:-.'l -I:-:|';|I|II|t1.:l-r. :EJ:If||:I :I.n:;|.i..|;' 1'.-|.-ml: :l'Ip:Ju|.1 1:13‘ t.1|:
.-4.u..|.|:¢- i:n.n-:lII 1-rlth. 15 U1|'l'Il‘l ],:-I.e$.|l|:L|._.-;j l11'lI :||f|;-lip:
" 1_|'|.-“.1...-|'_ 11.5]; ||u“.l:|.|.|;|;1'|:1.-l.||
|l'I.1-nl. .I Iu-15.1 _
|"." “-1-L—r
inrnl I:-l'11.1-i.clL.:.:i III-‘II n.I.|n'_-|-In t-L‘iri.a;|-I:
=_‘|,'rt-I.-|:|'l. ,|'|,-r-n.-un.-I: |:I|-|'-.h'_»:-n.-||I-l|'- :I|'r. .1 I-.|1.l'l1I:I :E.£IIIl'l II-;l-I-' 1:11. Ilillill ljfi 5-II; 31, 1'-Il'.i5
fl-Jig‘: fl||1|.|'.:.fl=I
F .F..1[|.i1|.1'|"1J|='l 'I].El'|IlIi11i'.l1|H fi_L'|nl:i.||5| ‘Elli.
II':H=-II-F-II ill I-liu: 31, :-::|E-
l'rI|'.||:l.|||i-I'_'i.1 |.'l|rn='I:-I.n:|EE |=i..=-o-;-'ni'rI'l= I I-or I11. =III"='I 1523.50
_|,1\|_Gi.'.llil 555535-I5 fil|_'l.l'l7h‘Ii 1.»: W =-1&5:-F .u:-
:l.|1i.fl Ii"
EILI'||I1 lJI.'L|:|.|.'|-II
_|I.lJ. :;_|;||_|.-|I .I.l.'-II -in In|.i.|.-1?! Il':.;-IiI.iI
I‘-4.111‘ '=I|hu:;'.1:.l=L-|: -5.111 I|1|.L|.L'|.|'L .|.=r_-;-rl-r-l:n:-e -._-|.---|-.|-.. ‘.1:-'-1 I-‘IE. II-‘I ¢fl:|:I=-=-I12! .:n:-=urlt]T -_-.|l.LLl-\hl,- H: 1T- |-JI- :J'|,tn:fl'I-ll-L FE‘.-l"1I| -J]-U
:||.|-_-|:- 5. in-1' '-"l||:L-. n-.-..=|.-|.==n-l..1=u. -- -.11: ".|.||; -Ii:-1.‘. £1-e-=1 -ru-I-III:-2'.“ -1-I 3'-I‘-=-' ==-,|1_--.. 1:-=-.= rn-I.|..o.= .-in: ..1n. i\.|.|.|.I2|'= r-_~|;.-_--at ta |:'l.-1Tr=ll i-lthlr-II= nu---r I1=I'-iflo
43 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
:-.-.+ 1|'IZ| -:|i' El'IIi||'I'E|lt|I'IJ'.-' I-I |-|--r:- |J't'.:n.-:-III:-.l:I|:|:. 1'5-=l'i
1F.~.t-i1t}.--. ‘-Eli ~
....--n-ru-u --.I||l'|'|l'|lln|||lI---Ill‘-'||5-‘. ;' In-'.I |-- - '-'
Appendix G Proof filed by Husband for hidden gold bars of wife Proof filed by Husband is attached in case envelope Appendix G 'Missing items in inventory': Wife's handwriting 14 Gold bars .
The Appendix G was referenced in trial and in court filings (RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7, RR2 pg 77 line 7, RR4 page 3 line 13; page 4 line 4, Appendix N exhibit 13, BA pg 203; BR 11)
44 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
EXHIBIT 1: Missing Items in Inventory: Wife's Handwriting 14 Gold Bars Cause No. 63935
DEEPA VASUDEVAN § IN THE DISTRICT COURT AND § 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
This “Exhibit” says in last paragraph Item (6) as handwritten by wife (Deepa): “14 Gold Bars” (marked by red arrow). This is for inventory number 3 which includes 14 Gold Bars and 30 Gold Coins.
U 1155 1 --1 1117'-11‘—1111111:"}"1'1111"I—-""—"'J -111:1-1; file!--'-I "1-4. F 1': 1'
Pk *-F-t,__is.£1-‘ii. L1._',[ l_ J_;.,g_ _.___t;____ ___ .,,-.._; LL‘ _ Gfl 11"'l1"|-I-_-'-.,_'I;__1__ |_ ___
1-
--- 4"":-
1 -:31. E F2-
_.. —_1E_"'r-'-P{‘1‘-fl_-
1 kéjg '11:-_11"'1"1Il..,_,|l-_‘--'1-._1\-.-'"\.__. ._ L11-__"_, 1 1 .31.»-e1_§.._4 \»_.'|-.;-a.-1_"-.¢1"='-'-s=.I= ' 13- -"1... t'..._1'~1-1... ‘f1‘a-:11!-L -'1?-1-‘EL. _- |__ 1- _-3; _ H-
P. :_---:r'--.:i»H_ ' €L-1“-"1'-=- — '*=~.r.,- -§ ' .._ \1'.'.H.. 1; I.
112151 5-
_
‘-5’ E1.11"='.-:11'.1"—:1\—
-""7.'." .
. Y-'-"'_' 11"
-if q_--._1:-.__,*> F~=-._j11,1_. i‘-.._] -___;
L11’-~* 11111"1”11T‘1j'1‘.11‘ -- e1-'1'_-r:i-:»- Q%ir:-1‘-.2.-. _ 1' -r - 11.: _'f'i---fl_. '|111""-»-_|-;-5'1"1'_1'l-.-'1--l"""\-1'1l.--i__- ‘-111’ '
_..- \__,-/'1 ,;_-J-r"'~. Fl...--1"" ‘- ' '1"\ 1-""1"\..f"*4 '1"-._-._.
— | -' - 1 _-:11‘ |_ 15 1111'11"‘1‘1-"-—""=1- 11'--1‘ r ‘_ ll-'5-=‘:-E-I _
;'_1'“~..-.\.._.11"1'-1'~'=~.1—"'-
P‘
__-I- \-'1-...--_.-"Ii.-ii~ -L-*._r_.:-11..-—
_
-4. 1|--.._‘ 1'11--*1" 111 :1’--iii L . E~ 1 .1‘-’*uE.. i-'==-- .
i 11,__t___;_,_j,__ -\\_,_|- M: _ __-I 3; 1‘ §""'I-111‘ E‘: ‘E ___ 5-,-"11 |__-.'1 |l1_.f_|- |_-._,-__ _
-d-¢1,_-
'"i_"-nr--il:;‘|l-.---\.[t.|1 . 11] 1111|
<1'T 111"!‘ -I-1.J-I‘-_'\;___ '2} L.'li_ Q 1;_'1-i.'_;.1 1 I._ —-— :'l1'l0n_ -..,_\_L1";.
‘if’---'l'a.J - ‘r_-.- *-—=i'.1:~--1.-1-~i‘*-i.._~.:_ _
{_1'.'r"1“\-I-E" _.:3.-. '1'-- -‘"7"’;-‘P 111‘1':11'- 1 , _ - 1' ' """‘F‘\ F5-. C.-11- I‘l'_.:_‘E__- -—- 111E- 1:1--'l1l_~‘~li;‘--....-.-1111...-!_ii.-.-i._._—-.,_ -
.__ E-1.--..|-I \l1'r_x_1»-"-_11.l i."r_.=-.~._.--.-_- 1"--‘ 1+-. ‘~ ' - {:11 [ _:| 1? I.-1 _,i_,__ -{._____. "1'\ |._.-""-i.-I---
1‘ 1=_.="--'1Ll.- ‘Tl . (_~..- =._.1_r:.=..-..;‘.~.~_>-'* —' [-".-1"‘-.§l .'-1.
- .- ‘R L ~e. -.-.-..e_. \':111+~.'.e.--l..--l._£n...-. -r:1‘"r'1L1--1--PP-"~ "'--*' -
11 - I-—-£""': I11 -— 'T_.- |""‘\""--~1'L-- '1'-"1"~"' r"---111 1-E_._Il---.1l'_ L» 1--. _ - J “-4-
-— (“_"..r-._ gw -;..'_i;....I-L 5;. Q‘-yv,_y—~nL-9;‘--’ W J — \ I F-
L?) 1"-i;'.,__-q,%__I:.____ . ___ '--155,515--,_,|,_J,_-;___.-‘__ .
|1'?11:I|t-11‘ — 191- '1-11 11'1"1'1"'j * h.‘ I. |,, I 1-..--1 '- — 1.5--l""||.__.|"T"'_-_;| 1:8-1'-'1‘€.i1r--n_.--..- __-=1; "'-~‘:i,,_fl,_.~1;j___ 5_¢_-4_‘__ __‘,__
/ --"=5 ‘I255 1511::-C1.*\..r. -
1 1 - 2_ :._.-~.,_.1-1-';II|.,_=_,'i 1,111
1:1-III?-'1-:?;--11:-_:_1 ——- -:'.r._.e*1-1... "‘ 51- =1 £.'~"~»..--:._1 " '1-* --£4;
=1 81.1) I.»-'-..-'i'___'_> _ . 1 '3
L_“'-7 .'L.--"\.:;__|_,~.-1-IL LLW _’ LL)’, 1.5-I;-:1-~.'.';J -- (:.I'7__ (_F_..,,.j E‘; ., _____:____5_::_ =1 U“‘iJ E1 xii: _pf""l 4-'1'-,'.'.""~1 I-11% '11_11.1.s_=---=-t§__, . ~)L
C0 o‘ or 1"o¥'
45 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Appendix H Court reporters – Exhibit List 27 May 2014 Court reports report is filed directly to 14th Appeals Court for 27 May 2014 hearing and 08 Oct 2014 hearing. Appendix H is exhibit index as reported by trial court (RR4, IDX 373).
As per TRAP 38.1(k)(1) which says brief “must contain a copy of the trial court's judgment or other appealable order from which relief is sought”. Hence, included here is the copy of the trial courts “Exhibit List” (reporter Ms. Renee Rape RR4).
46 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
1 EXHIBIT INDEX
2 PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
3 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED VOL
4 1 Second Amended Inventory and 88 90 2
5 Appraisement of Alavoor
6 Vasudevan
7 2 Objections to Inventory Filed 90 X 2
8 By Wife on 9 May 2014
9 5 Citibank Account Statement for 67 X 2
10 April 1, 2003 to March 31, 2004
11 12 Wedding Photographs Showing 71 X 2
12 Gold, Diamonds, Jewelry
13 13 Handwriting Diary of Wife 71 X 2
14 14 1. Bank of America Payment 71 75 2
15 Notice, 7-1-13 to 6-30-14
16 2. Bank of America Payment
17 Notice, 7-1-08 to 6-30-09
18 3. Bank of America Account Statement
19 August, 2001 - Pages 1 and 2 of 13
20 4. Bank of America Account Statement
21 August, 2001 - Pages 7 and 8 of 13
22 5. Bank of America Account Statement
23 July, 2002 - Pages 1 and 2 of 13
24 6. Bank of America Account Statement
25 July, 2002 - Pages 3 and 4 of 13
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 EXHIBIT INDEX CONTINUED
2 PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
3 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED VOL
4 14 7. Handwritten Notes 71 X 2
5 15 Handwritten Notes 71 X 2
6 16 Samples of Identity Thefts and 72 X 2
7 Article from Odisha Sun Times
8
9 RESPONDENT/COUNTER-PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
10 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED VOL
11 1 Bank of America Account 31 32 2
12 Activity as of 10-28-13
13 2 Letters between Petitioner 33 33 2
14 and Mr. Ron Brownstein
15 3 Deepa Vasudevan's Motion to 36 38 2
16 Compel Discovery and for
17 Sanctions and Protective Order
18 4 Affidavit for Business Records 41 42 2
19 For Deepa Vasudevan
20 5 Fourth Amended Inventory and 43/50 50 2
21 Appraisement of Deepa Vasudevan
22 6 Photograph 49 49 2
23 7 Photograph 52 52 2
24 8 Attorney's Fees for Ronald 85 86 2
25 Allen Brownstein
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
Appendix I Court Reporters – Vol 2 of 3 27 May 2014 All the documents filed with the Trial court are attached in the case envelope. They are sent directly to 14th Appeals Court by District Clerk Office, Brazoria county.
Court reports report is filed directly to 14th Appeals Court for 27 May 2014 hearing and 08 Oct 2014 hearing. Appendix I is court reporter's record Vol 2 of 3 as reported by trial court (RR2, IDX 373).
As per TRAP 38.1(k)(1) which says brief “must contain a copy of the trial court's judgment or other appealable order from which relief is sought”. Hence, included here is the copy of the trial courts reporter's “Vol 2 of 3” (reporter Ms. Renee Rape RR2).
47 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
1 REPORTER'S RECORD
2 VOLUME 2 OF 3 VOLUMES
3 TRIAL COURT CAUSE NO. 63935
4 APPELLATE COURT CAUSE NO. 14-14-00765-CV
5
6 IN THE MATTER OF * IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE MARRIAGE OF * 7 * DEEPA VASUDEVAN * 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT 8 AND * ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN * 9 * AND IN THE INTEREST OF * 10 PALLAVI DEV, A CHILD * BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
11
12 ********************************************************
13 TRIAL ON FINAL MERITS
14 ********************************************************
15 On the 27th day of May, 2014, the following proceedings
16 came on to be heard in the above-entitled and numbered
17 cause before the Honorable K. Randall Hufstetler, Judge
18 presiding, held in Angleton, Brazoria County, Texas.
19
20 Proceedings reported by Machine Shorthand Method.
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A P P E A R A N C E S
2
3 MR. ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
4 PRO SE
5 Post Office Box 710163
6 Houston, Texas 77271
7 Phone: (832) 244-1927
8 PETITIONER
9
10 AND
11
12 RONALD A. BROWNSTEIN
13 SBOT NO. 03229800
14 5208 West Broadway, Suite 200
15 Pearland, Texas 77581
16 Phone: (281) 485-2770
17 ATTORNEY FOR RESPONDENT/COUNTER-PETITIONER,
18 DEEPA VASUDEVAN
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 I N D E X
2 MAY 27, 2014 PAGE VOL
3 Witnesses Sworn by the Court .................. 6 2
4
5 COUNTER-PETITIONER/
6 RESPONDENT'S WITNESSES DIRECT CROSS REDIRECT RECROSS VOL
7 Vasudevan, Deepa 8 59 81 2
8 Brownstein, Ronald Allen 83 86 2
9
10 Counter-Petitioner/Respondent Rests ........... 88 2
11 Petitioner Offers Exhibits .................... 88 2
12 Petitioner Rests .............................. 92 2
13 Court's Orders ................................ 92 2
14 Court Adjourned ............................... 96 2
15 Court Reporter's Certificate .................. 97 2
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 EXHIBIT INDEX
2 PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
3 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED VOL
4 1 Second Amended Inventory and 88 90 2
5 Appraisement of Alavoor
6 Vasudevan
7 2 Objections to Inventory Filed 90 X 2
8 By Wife on 9 May 2014
9 5 Citibank Account Statement for 67 X 2
10 April 1, 2003 to March 31, 2004
11 12 Wedding Photographs Showing 71 X 2
12 Gold, Diamonds, Jewelry
13 13 Handwriting Diary of Wife 71 X 2
14 14 1. Bank of America Payment 71 75 2
15 Notice, 7-1-13 to 6-30-14
16 2. Bank of America Payment
17 Notice, 7-1-08 to 6-30-09
18 3. Bank of America Account Statement
19 August, 2001 - Pages 1 and 2 of 13
20 4. Bank of America Account Statement
21 August, 2001 - Pages 7 and 8 of 13
22 5. Bank of America Account Statement
23 July, 2002 - Pages 1 and 2 of 13
24 6. Bank of America Account Statement
25 July, 2002 - Pages 3 and 4 of 13
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 EXHIBIT INDEX CONTINUED
2 PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
3 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED VOL
4 14 7. Handwritten Notes 71 X 2
5 15 Handwritten Notes 71 X 2
6 16 Samples of Identity Thefts and 72 X 2
7 Article from Odisha Sun Times
8
9 RESPONDENT/COUNTER-PETITIONER'S EXHIBITS
10 NO. DESCRIPTION OFFERED ADMITTED VOL
11 1 Bank of America Account 31 32 2
12 Activity as of 10-28-13
13 2 Letters between Petitioner 33 33 2
14 and Mr. Ron Brownstein
15 3 Deepa Vasudevan's Motion to 36 38 2
16 Compel Discovery and for
17 Sanctions and Protective Order
18 4 Affidavit for Business Records 41 42 2
19 For Deepa Vasudevan
20 5 Fourth Amended Inventory and 43/50 50 2
21 Appraisement of Deepa Vasudevan
22 6 Photograph 49 49 2
23 7 Photograph 52 52 2
24 8 Attorney's Fees for Ronald 85 86 2
25 Allen Brownstein
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MAY 27, 2014
2 THE COURT: All right. All those who are
3 going to be testifying in the Vasudevan matter, please
4 stand and raise your right hand to be sworn.
5 (The witnesses were sworn by the Court.) 11:34AM
6 THE COURT: All right. Please have a seat
7 at counsel table, and we will get started.
8 All right. Mr. Brownstein?
9 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well, Your Honor, I am the
10 Counter-Petitioner in this case. I would be glad to 11:35AM
11 proceed forward if Alavoor would allow me to do so.
12 THE COURT: Mr. Vasudevan?
13 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, sir.
14 THE COURT: You are representing yourself?
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, Your Honor. 11:35AM
16 THE COURT: And you understand this is on
17 final today?
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
19 THE COURT: Give me just one second.
20 And this was consolidated with another case, 11:37AM
21 66539.
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
23 THE COURT: So, we have 63935 and 66539.
24 Everything is in the older matter. And we're still
25 working with your original petition; is that correct? 11:37AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
2 THE COURT: And, Mr. Brownstein, you have --
3 is it still your original Counter-Petition, or have you
4 had an amended?
5 MR. BROWNSTEIN: The original 11:38AM
6 Counter-Petition was filed by previous counsel from
7 Scott Brown's office. I had filed a First Amended
8 Counter-Petition and supplemented that twice, the most
9 recent of which was a name change request, Your Honor.
10 So, my active pleadings are my First Amended 11:38AM
11 Counter-Petition with two supplemental -- two
12 supplements to that document, Your Honor.
13 THE COURT: November 22, 2013, and
14 December 16, 2013. I have both of those.
15 All right. Mr. Vasudevan, do you want to 11:39AM
16 proceed as the Petitioner, or do you want Mr. Brownstein
17 to proceed first as the Counter-Petitioner? Your
18 choice.
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: It doesn't matter. He can
20 proceed. 11:39AM
21 THE COURT: Thank you.
22 Mr. Brownstein, on your Counter-Petition.
23 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I first ask the
24 Court to take judicial notice of the entire file in this
25 case, including the original Application for Protective 11:39AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Order of which this, being the older case, has now been
2 consolidated with the divorce action.
3 THE COURT: I'll take notice of both files
4 in 63935 and 66539.
5 MR. BROWNSTEIN: All right. I would like to 11:40AM
6 call my client, Mrs. Deepa Vasudevan.
7 THE COURT: Once you're seated, if you'll
8 pull that microphone in front of you, please.
9 You may proceed.
10 DEEPA VASUDEVAN, 11:40AM
11 and having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
12 DIRECT EXAMINATION
13 BY MR. BROWNSTEIN:
14 Q. Please tell the Judge your name.
15 A. Deepa Vasudevan. 11:40AM
16 Q. And may I address you as Deepa, since that's how
17 I've known you for over two years in this case?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Mrs. Deepa, prior to filing your lawsuit and
20 Counter-Petition for divorce, you first filed an 11:40AM
21 Application for a Protective Order against your husband;
22 is that correct?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. Are you married to Alavoor Vasudevan?
25 A. Yes. 11:41AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. When did the two of you marry?
2 A. March, 1992.
3 Q. And when did you separate, more or less, living
4 together as husband and wife?
5 A. Around June. I filed for the Protective Order 11:41AM
6 in June of 2011.
7 Q. Prior to filing your -- and you subsequently
8 then filed with Scott Brown's office a Petition or a
9 Counter-Petition for divorce; is that correct?
10 A. Yes. 11:41AM
11 Q. Prior to filing your Counter-Petition for
12 divorce, did you live in the state of Texas at least six
13 months and Brazoria County the preceding 90-day period?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Approximately six months before you filed for 11:41AM
16 divorce, you filed your Application for Protective
17 Order; is that correct?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. Why did you seek the protection of the Court?
20 A. Because at the point that I filed for it, I had 11:42AM
21 the injury to myself and I was not in a safe
22 environment; and both for me and my daughter, I needed
23 some protection because I was abused both mentally,
24 physically, as well as sexually by my husband.
25 Q. And in your Application for Protective Order, 11:42AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 there was attached an affidavit which accused your
2 husband of certain activity. Is it true --
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. -- that your husband threatened to kill you and
5 your daughter? 11:42AM
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Is it true that he threatened to burn down the
8 house with you and your daughter in it?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. Is it true that your husband had a history or 11:43AM
11 pattern of physically assaults upon you?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Would he grab you and shake you?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Why would he do that? 11:43AM
16 A. In most cases, it was as if it was because he
17 wanted to either get physical with me or if there was a
18 disagreement on any issue relating to finances.
19 Q. On June 26, 2011, the day before you filed
20 your -- or prepared your affidavit, is it true that he 11:43AM
21 followed you into the bathroom and started shaking you
22 and pinning you against the bathroom wall?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. Who came to your rescue?
25 A. I called one of my friends, and her husband 11:43AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 came. They lived in the neighborhood, and they came to
2 help me.
3 Q. Was your daughter in the house at this time?
4 A. She was. She was sleeping upstairs.
5 MR. BROWNSTEIN: May I approach, Your Honor? 11:44AM
6 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
7 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) As a result of your
8 Application for Temporary Orders -- for a Protective
9 Order, you and your husband and his respective attorney
10 agreed to Temporary Orders; is that correct? 11:44AM
11 A. Yes.
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Judge, these were filed
13 with the Court on July 22nd, 2011.
14 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) In the Temporary Orders,
15 was it agreed upon at that time that although the two of 11:44AM
16 you did not agree and use the term "conservator", that
17 you were appointed the primary custodian of your
18 daughter?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Your daughter was what age at that time? 11:44AM
21 A. She was 15 and a half.
22 Q. Okay. And she was going to public schools; is
23 that correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And pursuant to the terms of the agreement, you 11:45AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 were agreed to have exclusive rights to designate where
2 the child lived within Brazoria and the surrounding
3 counties?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. Exclusive right to consent to medical and 11:45AM
6 surgical treatment involving any invasive procedures?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Exclusive right to psychiatric and psychological
9 treatment of the child?
10 A. Yes. 11:45AM
11 Q. Exclusive right to receive support for the
12 child, child support?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. Exclusive right to represent the child in legal
15 action; to agree, if you so consented, to early marriage 11:45AM
16 or enlistment in the armed forces; to make educational
17 decisions; and to manage her estate, all of these being
18 exclusively awarded to you in this agreement; is that
19 correct?
20 A. Yes. 11:45AM
21 Q. Regarding your husband's possession or access to
22 the child, was it agreed that any access by your
23 husband, Alavoor, was to be supervised by a friend or a
24 family member designated by you?
25 A. Yes. 11:46AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. And that no specific times and dates were
2 awarded to him on visitation.
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. And you both agreed that was in the best
5 interest of the child. 11:46AM
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Why didn't -- did the child want to be around
8 the father?
9 A. The child has had actually no bond at all with
10 the father. He had not spent any time with her. Her 11:46AM
11 complete care from when she was born close to about four
12 years was helped by my mother because I was doing my
13 residency. And after that, after my mom passed, it was
14 pretty much under -- she was under my care.
15 So, she had no bond whatsoever. There has 11:46AM
16 never been a day that she's been alone with her father
17 taking care of her. So, she was very, very nervous
18 about staying with him. And after the threatening
19 episode in June, there was definitely no -- I was very
20 nervous and so was she to spend any amount of time with 11:47AM
21 him alone.
22 Q. As a matter of fact, since the date of your
23 Protective Order hearing, which occurred on July the
24 19th, 2011; is that correct?
25 A. Yes. 11:47AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. To today's date, has the father ever had the
2 child spend overnight access with him?
3 A. No.
4 Q. How many times has the father, your husband,
5 physically been in the presence of the child for 11:47AM
6 visitation or access?
7 A. I would say three to four times.
8 Q. And have all of those times been supervised?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And have sometimes you've been the person to 11:47AM
11 supervise that visitation?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Regarding the child support, did you agree that
14 Mr. Vasudevan, your husband, would pay child support as
15 deemed appropriate by him? 11:48AM
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Until September of 2011, at which time -- at
18 that time, either party could seek additional orders; is
19 that correct?
20 A. Yes. 11:48AM
21 Q. As part of your agreement in this Protective
22 Order application, did you also agree that both of you
23 would attend a parent education and family stabilization
24 course?
25 A. Yes. 11:48AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. And that you would present proof that you have
2 taken that course and filed your certificate with the
3 Court?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. Did you take that course? 11:48AM
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. And did you file that certificate with the
8 Court?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. Do you know if your husband ever filed any 11:48AM
11 certificate with the Court?
12 A. I'm not aware.
13 Q. All right. Was your husband also ordered to
14 attend at least ten sessions of anger management?
15 A. Yes. 11:49AM
16 Q. Did he ever tell you if he had attended all ten
17 sessions or at least ten sessions?
18 A. He did not tell me.
19 Q. You also agreed at the time of the hearing on
20 your Protective Order that the residence of the parties, 11:49AM
21 3402 Castle Pond, that you would be awarded the
22 exclusive use of that house.
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. And that you would have the exclusive use of
25 your Mercedes. 11:49AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And that your husband, if he has not already
3 vacated, vacate the premises; is that correct?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. You each had exclusive use of certain vehicles. 11:49AM
6 And there was an issue regarding a pink
7 computer that was addressed in the Temporary Orders. He
8 was ordered to return the pink computer belonging to
9 your daughter, Pallavi; is that correct?
10 A. Yes. 11:50AM
11 Q. Now, tell me the date of birth of Pallavi, if
12 you know it.
13 A. 12-7-1995.
14 Q. Did you and your husband acquire a pink computer
15 for your daughter's education? 11:50AM
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. At that time, was she doing very well in school?
18 A. Extremely well.
19 Q. As a matter of fact, has she graduated number
20 one in her class at Dawson High School in Pearland, 11:50AM
21 Texas?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. She's the valedictorian.
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. What would she use that pink computer for? 11:50AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. She had all of her files on -- all the Word
2 files that she used to do her school work on, she had
3 saved them on that file.
4 And after the Protective Order was filed,
5 two hours later, my husband came to the house when he 11:51AM
6 was ordered not to by the Court. And my daughter was
7 with her -- the housekeeper. And he came, disconnected
8 all the connections, all the computer connections, took
9 her pink laptop which was there, and left at that point.
10 And so, she was distraught because all her 11:51AM
11 work was on the computer. And hence, I had to come back
12 and file, so that way I was able to get that computer
13 back to her, at least to get all the files transferred
14 back to a new computer, if I needed to.
15 Q. All right. And did Alavoor return the computer 11:51AM
16 back to your daughter?
17 A. After the Court ordered, yes.
18 Q. Okay.
19 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I have not
20 marked the Temporary Orders as an exhibit since it's a 11:51AM
21 part of the Court's file. But if you wanted a written
22 copy -- I didn't know which is easier for you to review,
23 if it's --
24 THE COURT: I have it electronically.
25 MR. BROWNSTEIN: So, you do not need it for 11:52AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 that purpose.
2 THE COURT: I don't need it unless you want
3 it marked as an exhibit. It's up to you.
4 MR. BROWNSTEIN: No, I do not, Your Honor.
5 THE COURT: All right. Thank you. 11:52AM
6 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Deepa, would you tell us a
7 little bit about your educational background?
8 A. I am an MD by my degree, and I finished my
9 medical school in India in 1992. And I had, in Europe,
10 internship that I did not complete. And I got married 11:53AM
11 and I came to the United States, did my exams, went back
12 to finish the course, and then did my residency here
13 with the University of Texas.
14 So, I have an undergraduate degree, which is
15 from India, and then an MD, which is also from India. 11:53AM
16 But passing my exams, I was able to start my residency
17 in the United States.
18 Q. All right. And tell me a little bit about your
19 employment history.
20 A. Okay. So, I started my residency 1995, June. 11:53AM
21 And before that, I was here for a very short time. I
22 came in here in 1993, joined my husband for about seven
23 months, did my exams, went back, finished all the
24 required training, the internship that I had to do.
25 Came back in early '95, took all my interviews, and then 11:53AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 started working in 1995. From '95 to '98, I was an
2 intern at the University of Texas in Houston.
3 Q. All right. I'm going to stop you. During your
4 internship, '95 through '98 --
5 A. Yes. 11:54AM
6 Q. -- what was your approximate salary or income?
7 A. About 36,000.
8 Q. All right.
9 A. Annually.
10 And then in 1998, September, I was offered 11:54AM
11 the position of a faculty with the university and I
12 accepted that and that's where I am presently employed
13 to.
14 Q. Can you tell us approximately the incomes you
15 have made since becoming a faculty member at the 11:54AM
16 University of Texas?
17 A. So, initially, I started off at 110 to 120,000.
18 And then progressively -- for a couple of years, I
19 stayed at that salary and then went up to about 150 and
20 -- for another few years. And then last year, I was 11:54AM
21 promoted; and I'm right now at 195,000.
22 Q. All right. Of the marriage, Pallavi was the
23 only child born; is that correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. You have identified her on your petition as -- 11:55AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 her name as Pallavi, last name, D-e-v; is that correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. No other children were born or adopted during
4 your marriage?
5 A. No. 11:55AM
6 Q. And you are not expecting a child at this time.
7 A. No.
8 Q. As grounds for divorce, you have alleged two
9 grounds. One, that your marriage has become
10 insupportable due to discord or conflict of 11:55AM
11 personalities between you and your husband that destroys
12 the legitimate ends of the marriage relationship and
13 prevents any reasonable expectation of reconciliation.
14 Is that true?
15 A. Yes. 11:55AM
16 Q. You've also alleged that your husband is guilty
17 of cruel treatment towards you of a nature that renders
18 further living together insupportable. Is that also
19 true?
20 A. Yes. 11:56AM
21 Q. Can you be more specific and give examples of
22 how your husband's cruel treatment has caused you to
23 seek this divorce?
24 A. To go back a little bit, ours was an arranged
25 marriage. And it was in 1992 that our families arranged 11:56AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 the wedding. And my husband returned back to the United
2 States after the wedding in March of 1992. I joined him
3 in January of 1993 for a short time.
4 The -- and then the first three years we
5 spent a little time just because of my travel between 11:56AM
6 India and here. So, I did not know him very well at
7 that point. After coming and spending some time with
8 me, I've always had -- it's always been what he's
9 wanted, whether it's been emotional, physical, sexual.
10 It's never been what I have wanted. It's always been -- 11:57AM
11 that was always the way it worked. And I was new. I
12 was young. I was about 22. So, I didn't -- and I came
13 from a very different culture where I was raised very
14 differently.
15 We had Pallavi in 1995, about a year after I 11:57AM
16 had stayed with him. And all through the pregnancy, he
17 had not come with me even for maybe one visit to the
18 physician. Never offered any emotional, financial, or
19 physical support of any kind. It was just, you know, a
20 way to -- just fathering a child. That was all that was 11:57AM
21 important to him.
22 After the child was born, I was a resident
23 and so, my mother did come here to help me with the
24 child. She took care of the child most of the time for
25 about four years. During those times, there was very 11:57AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 minimal help offered, whether it was taking care of her,
2 whether it was taking her to the doctors. I had a
3 full-time housekeeper who would help my mother take care
4 of the child's needs. The child slept with my mother in
5 her room. 11:58AM
6 There was never an emotional bonding that
7 was there with him and his child. And after I started
8 my -- I finished my residency, I became the primary
9 caretaker of the child. All her visits, all her school
10 care, everything related to Pallavi was done by me. 11:58AM
11 In 2007, I lost my mother to breast cancer.
12 At that point, he started mentally, as well as
13 emotionally, abusing me. It was like the child was
14 always the center. He knew that the child was my
15 weakest link; and so, it was always I'm going to tell 11:58AM
16 the child or I'm going to take her here or -- it was
17 very different.
18 Never provided for her. And I used to go to
19 work and never be sure that I would come back and have
20 the child fed or even taken to any of the activities she 11:59AM
21 needed. We had a housekeeper who did most of the work.
22 Emotionally, it was very difficult because
23 it was always about what he wanted and I had to give in
24 just because we had a very young child. I was unsure of
25 the system. I had just lost my mother. I was probably 11:59AM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 at my lowest time.
2 At that time, financially, he made several
3 steps where he actually closed out an account, took
4 money away. And so, at that point, I had to start
5 making some financial decisions myself and that was 11:59AM
6 difficult for him to digest and he emotionally got
7 worse.
8 This continued for about ten years where I
9 was the primary caretaker for Pallavi. Even for a
10 breakfast appointment, like a breakfast with dad, I had 11:59AM
11 to send money with the child, so that he could get a
12 donut for her -- I mean, she could buy him a donut
13 instead of the other way around.
14 About when she was 15, I think, my patience
15 broke and it was getting -- every single day was a 12:00PM
16 challenge. Either it was physical, it was mental, it
17 was emotional or sexual. And finally, I think a time
18 came where I couldn't handle; and I moved upstairs into
19 a bedroom upstairs. And I think that was the one where
20 the physical abuse got quite strong. 12:00PM
21 I actually had to call in several friends
22 several times to talk to him because he was under the
23 impression that if he wanted something, he got it,
24 whether it was physical, mental, financial, or sexual.
25 And when I moved into a separate bedroom, I 12:00PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 think it was very difficult for him to understand that,
2 you know, he was not getting what he needed. At that
3 point, I think the physical abuse got worse.
4 And I had kept my child very separate from
5 all this. Whatever was happening between us was always 12:00PM
6 between four walls. But I think with this, it sort of
7 separated out and my child got to see some of it. And I
8 think when one of -- when I woke up one day and I walked
9 down, that was when he pinned me down and I was very
10 nervous. I thought that would have been my last day. I 12:01PM
11 did not think I would survive that, and I'm glad I did.
12 And that's when I made the decision to say
13 that I needed to file for -- I couldn't take the
14 physical, mental, as well as sexual torture anymore.
15 So, that's when I filed for the Temporary Orders. 12:01PM
16 THE COURT: All right. We're going to
17 recess for lunch. See y'all at 1:00 o'clock.
18 (Recess was taken.)
19 THE COURT: All right. Let's continue.
20 Mr. Brownstein? 01:14PM
21 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Yes, Your Honor. May I
22 proceed?
23 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
24 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Deepa, tell the Judge a
25 little bit about your husband's educational background 01:15PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 and his work history.
2 A. He has an undergraduate degree in engineering
3 from India, which is called BS. And he has an MS from
4 university -- University of Texas El Paso here. And
5 he's done several courses online, as well as he's 01:15PM
6 pursuing a PhD, I think.
7 Q. All right. And is his pursuit of a PhD, is that
8 in computer engineering or a computer science field?
9 A. I think it is in computer science.
10 Q. And has your husband been employed throughout 01:15PM
11 the marriage?
12 A. Through most of the marriage, yes, he's been
13 employed. He had a few months probably in 2003 that he
14 was looking for work in between, but most of the time
15 all throughout he has been employed. 01:16PM
16 Q. All right. Can you tell us the type of
17 employment, who his -- who his employers were and his
18 approximate income?
19 A. In California where we were initially, he was
20 working for a company called Amdahl; and he made 01:16PM
21 anywhere between 80 to 120,000. And then after that, he
22 worked for an accounting corporation in Houston. And
23 subsequent to that, he changed -- he's worked for the, I
24 think, San Jac college. He has worked for other
25 companies, and his income has been anywhere between 80 01:16PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 to 110,000.
2 Q. Is he employed today?
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. Okay. Who is he currently employed with?
5 A. I'm not sure, but I think ABB is what I was 01:17PM
6 told.
7 Q. All right. And his approximate income today is
8 what?
9 A. About 90 to 100,000.
10 Q. As your child is getting ready for graduation, 01:17PM
11 tell me about her future plans.
12 A. My daughter wants to pursue medicine as a
13 career; so, she looked at several undergraduate
14 colleges. And we went -- and we were in-state touring,
15 as well as out of state. And she has decided to go to 01:17PM
16 University of Texas Dallas, the provision with admission
17 to Southwestern Medical School in Dallas.
18 Q. And how many campuses or universities did you
19 join her in looking at before she made her decision?
20 A. We went to about six campuses, and I was there 01:18PM
21 in all of them.
22 Q. And, Deepa, tell me about your future.
23 By the way, you and your husband are both
24 naturalized U.S. citizens; is that correct?
25 A. Yes. 01:18PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. And what are your future plans regarding service
2 to our country?
3 A. At this point since my biggest commitment, which
4 was my daughter, is going to go off to college, it has
5 given me some chance -- I always wanted to give back to 01:18PM
6 the country that gave me quite a bit. So, I'm planning
7 to be a reservist in the Army for -- for a couple of
8 years. So, I've already talked to the U.S. Army
9 recruiters. I haven't decided on a date because my
10 daughter is still a little nervous, but I probably will 01:18PM
11 do that next year.
12 And that entails two months out of the year
13 that I need to go and serve at one of the Army bases;
14 and if there is a need determined, I will be asked to go
15 serve in that area. And that may mean that with the 01:18PM
16 state I may be -- I will have to give a temporary
17 resignation with the fact that since it's a federal
18 opportunity, I will be given my job back when I do come
19 back from service.
20 Q. As a reservist, is it possible that you could be 01:19PM
21 called up for an indefinite time period if the military
22 branch so chooses?
23 A. Yes, that's a possibility.
24 Q. Okay. In July 13 of 2012, you filed a Motion to
25 Modify the Temporary Orders seeking child support; is 01:19PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 that correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And why did you do that?
4 A. Because initially when we came and I got the
5 Temporary Orders, my husband was supposed to pay child 01:19PM
6 support as deemed appropriate; but he never paid me any
7 support. And hence, I had to file a motion to ask him
8 to pay child support.
9 Q. As a matter of fact, he contributed no support
10 to you from the date of your hearing on the Temporary 01:20PM
11 Orders on your Protective Order, that was July 22nd of
12 2011, until September 1st of 2012; is that correct?
13 A. Yes.
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: Objection, please, because I
15 was told not to give her any support by -- 01:20PM
16 THE COURT: I didn't understand. You were
17 told what?
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: I was told not to give her
19 any support or anything because of the court order.
20 THE COURT: Okay. Go ahead. 01:20PM
21 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) So, that period, September,
22 2011 -- I mean, July, 2011, through September of 2012,
23 was 14 months where he contributed nothing to the
24 support of you and your child; is that correct?
25 A. Yes. 01:20PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. You and your husband reached an agreement with
2 his attorney at that time for additional Temporary
3 Orders; is that correct?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. And commencing -- and that was a court order of 01:21PM
6 this Court.
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: May I approach again, Your
8 Honor?
9 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
10 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Deepa, you and your husband 01:21PM
11 reached an agreement that was filed with the Court on
12 September the 11th, 2012, now ordering your husband to
13 pay child support; is that correct?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And was he ordered to pay you $1,200 per month 01:22PM
16 beginning September 1st, 2012?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And a like payment due and payable on each month
19 until further order of the Court; is that correct?
20 A. Yes. 01:22PM
21 Q. And did your husband initially pay his
22 Court-ordered support of $1,200 per month?
23 A. He started -- I think, the first month was
24 September; and since then, he did not pay one month of
25 child support from the time he was ordered to now. 01:22PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. Okay. All right. Did it come to pass that in
2 November of 2012 -- well, let me have my outline back.
3 I'm going to hand you what is marked as
4 Respondent's Exhibit Number 1. And is this a record of
5 your bank records where your husband was making direct 01:23PM
6 deposits of child support?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. All right. He was not ordered to pay through
9 the Child Support Office; is that correct?
10 A. Yes. 01:23PM
11 Q. All right. For the payment of November, 2012,
12 did he pay you $1,200?
13 A. No.
14 Q. How much did he pay you?
15 A. It says $1,048.36. 01:23PM
16 Q. Do you know why he paid you less than the $1,200
17 he was ordered to pay?
18 A. Because he took me and my daughter out for
19 dinner; and so, the cost of the dinner was --
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: Objection, Your Honor. This 01:24PM
21 is not correct. This is the utility bill I paid. Maybe
22 that's --
23 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, opposing
24 counsel will get a chance to cross-examine her.
25 THE COURT: Go ahead. 01:24PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Okay. So, he paid you less
2 than 1,200 --
3 A. Yes.
4 Q. -- because he took you out to dinner.
5 A. Yes. 01:24PM
6 Q. That difference was $151.64.
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. Was that the cost of the dinner?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And in which he participated, as well. 01:24PM
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Did he also miss a payment in July of 2013?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. Okay. Has he ever caught that payment up?
15 A. No. 01:24PM
16 Q. Okay. Does Respondent's Exhibit Number 1
17 evidence the November payment of 2012 that he was short
18 and also evidence that there is no payment or no credit
19 for child support that he delivered into your bank
20 account for the month of July of 2012? 01:25PM
21 A. Yes.
22 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I'm going to offer
23 Respondent's Exhibit Number 1.
24 (Discussion off the record between
25 Mr. Brownstein and Mr. Vasudevan.) 01:25PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
2 offer Respondent's Exhibit Number 1.
3 THE COURT: Any objection?
4 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, Your Honor. On this,
5 the 1,048, that is due to the utility bill, which came 01:25PM
6 to my address.
7 THE COURT: That's cross. You'll have an
8 opportunity to ask her some questions. All I'm asking
9 you right now is do you object to this being a copy of a
10 bank statement -- 01:25PM
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: No.
12 THE COURT: -- of the witness?
13 All right. One is admitted.
14 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Thank you, Your Honor.
15 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Additionally, did you have 01:25PM
16 your attorney send your husband a letter, among other
17 things, indicating that he was behind in his child
18 support?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Okay. And is Respondent's Exhibit Number 2 a 01:26PM
21 true and correct copy of the letter sent to your
22 husband, among other things, notifying him that he was
23 behind in his child support of past due?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Okay. Attached as part of Respondent's Exhibit 01:26PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Number 2, is this a true and correct copy of the
2 response, in part, received by you or your attorney
3 indicating that Alavoor indicated that there was a delay
4 due to a technical problem on the bank website?
5 A. Yes. 01:26PM
6 Q. Is that correct?
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Do you have any objections
8 to our correspondences?
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: No.
10 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Okay. No objection, Your 01:27PM
11 Honor, I ask that Respondent's Number 2 be admitted.
12 THE COURT: Two will be admitted.
13 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) On or about February 14th
14 of 2013, did your husband file a Motion to Compel
15 Discovery? 01:27PM
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. All right. And at this time, he was no longer
18 being represented by Annette Henry? He was representing
19 himself.
20 A. Yes. 01:27PM
21 Q. Okay. And was hearing held on that Motion to
22 Compel on March 11th, 2013?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. At the hearing on March 11, 2013, the Court made
25 a ruling denying your husband's Motion to Compel 01:28PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Production; is that correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. And in addition, the Court ordered your husband
4 to pay you $600 in attorney's fees and costs on or
5 before March 18th, 2013; is that correct? 01:28PM
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Did you ever receive that payment?
8 A. No.
9 Q. As we sit here today, your husband continues to
10 violate that Court order by not paying the $600; is that 01:28PM
11 correct?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Shortly after the hearing, on March the 19th,
14 your husband filed a request for court order on the
15 Motion to Compel that the Judge just made a ruling on; 01:29PM
16 is that correct?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And he also submitted to the Court a court order
19 for the Judge to sign; is that correct?
20 A. Yes. 01:29PM
21 Q. That was never heard or submitted to the Court;
22 was it?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Do you know why your husband sent a second
25 request and a proposal for the Judge to sign the Motion 01:29PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 to Compel when the Judge had just made a ruling seven
2 days prior?
3 A. I'm not sure.
4 Q. On June 5th, 2013, did you request that I
5 forward a notice to take the oral deposition of your 01:30PM
6 husband set for July 11, 2013?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. At the deposition set in my office on July 11,
9 2013, did your husband appear at his deposition?
10 A. No. 01:30PM
11 Q. Were you required through your attorney to pay
12 the court reporter $150 for her appearance?
13 A. Yes.
14 MR. BROWNSTEIN: May I approach again, Your
15 Honor? 01:31PM
16 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
17 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Because your husband failed
18 to appear for his deposition and because he was
19 forwarding numerous additional production-related
20 requests, were you forced to file a Motion to Compel 01:31PM
21 Discovery and for Sanctions?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Although this has been filed with the Court, I'm
24 going to mark this as Respondent's Exhibit Number 3. Is
25 this a true and correct copy of the Motion to Compel 01:31PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Discovery and for Sanctions that I filed with the Court?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. This was filed for several reasons; is that
4 correct?
5 A. Yes. 01:32PM
6 Q. One of which is your husband did not pay the
7 $600 in attorney's fees ordered by the Court; is that
8 correct?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And that your husband failed to appear at his 01:32PM
11 deposition. Is that also correct?
12 A. Yes.
13 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I'm going to ask that
14 Respondent's Exhibit Number 3 be admitted.
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: I do raise objections on the 01:32PM
16 motions.
17 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I understand. You can
18 cross-examine. Do you have any objections to the filing
19 of this?
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I do. 01:33PM
21 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
22 ask that Respondent's Exhibit Number 3 be admitted. It
23 is a true and correct copy of the Motion to Compel
24 Discovery that was filed with this Court that you have
25 taken notice of on August -- August 2nd, 2013. 01:33PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: Any objection?
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, I do have objections,
3 Your Honor.
4 THE COURT: What's your objection?
5 MR. VASUDEVAN: The objection was that 01:33PM
6 Motion to Compel, it was not complete. The Judge said
7 he wanted more permission from me; so, that's why I sent
8 it.
9 THE COURT: He's offering an exhibit. Do
10 you have any objection to that exhibit? 01:33PM
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: I do have objections.
12 THE COURT: What's the objection to the
13 exhibit? Not to the hearing, not to the Motion to
14 Compel, but to that exhibit.
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: The objections I have were 01:34PM
16 on Page 3, the hearing on Motion to Compel, and also on
17 the Page 4, the Motion to Compel Discovery and for
18 Sanctions.
19 THE COURT: Okay. I don't know if you're
20 understanding me or not, but we're not going back and 01:34PM
21 rehearing that hearing. Mr. Brownstein is simply
22 offering that as an exhibit as to what happened.
23 MR. VASUDEVAN: Oh, okay.
24 THE COURT: Okay? Do you have any objection
25 to that? 01:34PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, I don't.
2 THE COURT: Okay. Three is admitted.
3 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Now, among the reasons that
4 you have requested this Motion to Compel included the
5 defaults of your husband you just testified to. 01:35PM
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Not appearing at his oral deposition, not
8 paying.
9 And in addition, did your -- attached to
10 this exhibit that has been now admitted, Respondent's 01:35PM
11 Exhibit Number 3, is correspondence that your husband
12 directed to me questioning the corruption of the Court;
13 is that correct?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. And his questions regarding the court hearing, 01:35PM
16 he suggested that the presiding Associate Judge at that
17 time -- he asked several questions including whether I
18 had a blood relative or other relationship with Judge
19 Robertson; is that correct?
20 A. Yes. 01:36PM
21 Q. And that he basically, in a nutshell, if you
22 were to summarize his questions, accused the Judge of
23 being corrupt; is that correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Respondent's Number 3, Your 01:36PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Honor.
2 THE COURT: Thank you.
3 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) At the hearing on this
4 Motion to Compel, at that time he had just recently
5 hired an attorney by the name of Shannon Tigner; is that 01:36PM
6 correct?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. And did y'all reach an agreement regarding what
9 was to take place regarding my motion?
10 A. Yes. 01:36PM
11 Q. All right. Did y'all agree that we would pass
12 the Motion to Compel and that the parties were to attend
13 mediation with Jimmy Phillips?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Was your husband required, among other things, 01:36PM
16 to produce records that were responsive to the Exhibit A
17 on my Motion for Oral Deposition?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. And was he also required to file an inventory at
20 least seven days prior to the mediation? 01:37PM
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. Did your husband file his inventory prior to the
23 mediation?
24 A. No.
25 Q. Filed with this Court is the Mediated Settlement 01:37PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Agreement as to Pallavi. You and your husband at the
2 first mediation of Jimmy Phillips were able to reach an
3 agreement regarding your child; is that correct?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. That agreement, among other things, appointed 01:38PM
6 you the primary conservator of the child but only
7 allowed possession and access of the child with the
8 father as agreed upon between the child and the father.
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. He was also ordered to pay -- or y'all agreed 01:38PM
11 for an increase in child support beginning on the first
12 pay period after the date of the divorce. But you
13 haven't been divorced yet; have you?
14 A. No.
15 THE COURT: Mr. Brownstein, just as a point 01:38PM
16 for my notes, this is a property issue case; right? I
17 mean, we got a lot of questions about child support,
18 about visitation, about her going to visit all these
19 schools, and I'm -- I haven't made a note yet on
20 property division. 01:39PM
21 MR. BROWNSTEIN: We're getting very close
22 there, Judge. Since we have asked --
23 THE COURT: Can we go ahead and get there?
24 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Yes, Your Honor.
25 THE COURT: All right. 01:39PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 (Discussion off the record between
2 Mr. Brownstein and Mr. Vasudevan.)
3 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Deepa, I'm going to hand
4 you a copy of your Fourth Amended Inventory, which you
5 have filed with the Court on May the 9th. 01:42PM
6 And I'm going to also hand you what is
7 marked as Respondent's Exhibit Number 4, which is your
8 Affidavit of Business Records that you filed with the
9 Court and gave notice to your husband back on May the
10 9th, 2014. 01:43PM
11 MR. BROWNSTEIN: First, let me tender
12 Respondent's Exhibit Number 4. Do you have any
13 objections to the business records affidavit,
14 Mr. Vasudevan?
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, I do have objections on 01:43PM
16 this.
17 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well, would you inform the
18 Court what your objections are since I'd like to offer
19 this?
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: I do send objections on this 01:43PM
21 one, on the inventory.
22 THE COURT: When did you send it?
23 MR. VASUDEVAN: I just gave it this morning
24 before lunch. The one where it says objections to
25 the -- 01:43PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: In this stack?
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, that stack. It's the
3 second page, the second document.
4 THE COURT: Okay. Well, once again, what is
5 being offered is a summary. 01:44PM
6 Well, is it your four? Is that what you're
7 on right now?
8 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Yes. Respondent's 4 is the
9 business records affidavit.
10 THE COURT: That's not the inventory. 01:44PM
11 Your next exhibit is the inventory; right?
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: That's coming up next, Your
13 Honor.
14 THE COURT: Okay. What is being offered now
15 is a business records affidavit, which contains records. 01:44PM
16 Do you have any objection to that? What you just showed
17 me was your objections to her inventory.
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: Right. Those documents are
19 correct, but only thing is they are outdated.
20 THE COURT: They're correct? 01:44PM
21 MR. VASUDEVAN: They are not up to date.
22 THE COURT: Are they correct?
23 MR. VASUDEVAN: They are correct as for the
24 last two years.
25 THE COURT: That's all I need to know. 01:44PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 All right. Four is admitted.
2 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) All right. And, Deepa, I'm
3 going to hand you what is marked as Respondent's Exhibit
4 Number 5. And is this your proposed division of how
5 you're asking this Court to divide your estate? Is that 01:44PM
6 correct?
7 A. Yes.
8 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Do you have any objections
9 to our proposal?
10 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, I do have objections. 01:45PM
11 I gave that to the Judge. He already has a copy of the
12 objections.
13 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
14 offer Respondent's Exhibit Number 5, which is our
15 proposed division of property as required by your local 01:45PM
16 rules of this Court for proposals to be tendered to the
17 Court. There is an objection.
18 THE COURT: Do you understand what is being
19 offered, Mr. Vasudevan? This is an offer of what your
20 wife would testify to if she were testifying with regard 01:45PM
21 to each of these items. You may disagree with them, but
22 that's going to be her testimony and that's what he is
23 offering.
24 So, do you object to this being a summary of
25 her testimony? 01:46PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, I do have objections.
2 THE COURT: What is your objection?
3 MR. VASUDEVAN: Those objections are given
4 in my --
5 THE COURT: You're not understanding what 01:46PM
6 I'm saying. She's going to testify to everything on
7 here.
8 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
9 THE COURT: You might disagree with it, but
10 that's what she's going to say. 01:46PM
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
12 THE COURT: So, do you have any objection if
13 they offer this as a shorthand of what she would say?
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, I do.
15 THE COURT: Okay. Then go through each 01:46PM
16 item.
17 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor --
18 THE COURT: I have a copy.
19 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Of the Fourth Amended
20 Inventory? All right. 01:46PM
21 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) All right. Deepa, we're
22 going to have you walk this Judge through what is the
23 central issue now before this Court, which is how is
24 your property to be divided by this Judge.
25 In conjunction with your Fourth Amended 01:46PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Affidavit [sic], you have -- and the Judge has accepted
2 your affidavit Of Business Records -- does your
3 Affidavit of Business Records contain bank records and
4 other documents that support each and every one of your
5 valuations as far as bank accounts and property that you 01:47PM
6 are claiming as your separate versus community? Is that
7 correct?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. Okay. All right. In that regard, Deepa, you
10 are claiming as your separate property a bank account in 01:47PM
11 India right now; is that correct?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Of a Citibank NRA [sic] with a value of
14 $103,000.
15 A. Yes. 01:47PM
16 Q. The -- of the 89 pages of your business records,
17 is the first document your bank statement dated as early
18 as July of 2013 showing a balance of 103,143?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Is the balance of that account substantially the 01:47PM
21 same today?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. You are claiming that as your separate property
24 as the sale of an inherited house that you inherited
25 from your mother; is that correct? 01:48PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. If we turn to the latter pages of your business
3 records affidavit, does this include a Last Will and
4 Testament of your beloved grandmother?
5 A. Yes. 01:48PM
6 Q. And this will leaves property to some of your
7 grandmother's heirs, including your mother; is that
8 correct?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And is this -- and does this Last Will and 01:48PM
11 Testament direct that a house be sold and that certain
12 amounts of money be paid to different relatives of your
13 grandmother, including your own mother?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Okay. And what house is that, Deepa? 01:49PM
16 A. That was the primary residence of my grandmother
17 and mother's estate in India.
18 Q. And when that was sold, your mother was to keep
19 most of the proceeds -- the majority of the proceeds; is
20 that correct? 01:49PM
21 A. Yes.
22 Q. But she was required under her mother's will to
23 dispose of certain amounts of money to different
24 relatives; is that correct?
25 A. Yes. 01:49PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Q. Who are those relatives?
2 A. They were my mother's siblings and my mother's
3 nieces and nephews.
4 Q. Okay. Now, when your mother died -- and when
5 did she die, ma'am? 01:49PM
6 A. She died on June 8th, 2004.
7 Q. And she was living here in the state of Texas at
8 the time of her death?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And was she married at the time of her death? 01:49PM
11 A. No.
12 Q. Did she have any children born or adopted by her
13 other than you?
14 A. No.
15 Q. You are her only surviving heir; is that 01:49PM
16 correct?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. Did you, in fact, enter into an agreement to
19 sell that house that you inherited from your mother?
20 A. Yes. 01:50PM
21 Q. All right. And attached to your business
22 records is the agreement between you and who else?
23 A. It's between the developer that bought the
24 property.
25 Q. And what was the -- what were the terms of this 01:50PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 sale?
2 A. The -- the terms of the sale were the initial
3 payment was going to be made for the land; and once they
4 built some apartments, the rest of the money was going
5 to be paid. 01:50PM
6 Q. All right. Approximately, how much did you
7 receive from the sale of this property that you
8 inherited through your mother?
9 A. The entire property sold for about 1 crore 27
10 lakhs, which is about $211,000. And this was the entire 01:50PM
11 property; and I had to distribute it based on the will,
12 to give other relatives that were determined to get some
13 money from the proceeds, as well.
14 Q. Okay. After those proceeds were given to other
15 relatives who owned that property, did you inherit 01:51PM
16 approximately a little over $100,000 -- or 150,000?
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. Okay. 100,000 of that is still in the bank
19 account in India; is that correct?
20 A. Correct. 01:51PM
21 Q. Identified on your inventory under separate
22 property as having a value of 103,000?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. And did you, thereafter, take 50,000 and
25 purchase an interest in a partnership here in Texas? 01:51PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And was your partnership contribution $51,450?
3 A. About that, yes.
4 Q. Okay. Has there been any increase in value in
5 that partnership interest? 01:51PM
6 A. No.
7 Q. When you got married --
8 I'm going to hand you what is marked as
9 Respondent's Exhibit Number 6 and ask if you can
10 identify this. 01:52PM
11 A. Yes. This is a picture of me on my wedding day.
12 Q. Okay.
13 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Do you have any objections
14 to this?
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: No. 01:52PM
16 MR. BROWNSTEIN: And -- okay. I'm going to
17 offer Respondent's Exhibit Number 6. No objections on
18 this one?
19 THE COURT: Six is admitted.
20 Do you have any other proffer on Number 5? 01:52PM
21 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well, I do; but I'm walking
22 through the inventory, so to speak, as quickly as I can.
23 That will be --
24 THE COURT: Okay. You moved off from that.
25 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Oh, okay. I'm sorry. 01:52PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: I was going to rule on it.
2 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I'm sorry, Judge?
3 THE COURT: I was going to rule on it.
4 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well, Your Honor, as I'm
5 walking through the inventory, I would like to offer 01:52PM
6 Exhibit Number 5, which is our proposed division of
7 property based upon my client's sworn inventory that has
8 been -- her Fourth Amended Inventory that has been filed
9 with the Court.
10 THE COURT: And five will be admitted for 01:53PM
11 that purpose.
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Thank you, Your Honor.
13 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) And in this photograph of
14 you on your wedding day -- or on or about your wedding
15 day; is that correct? 01:53PM
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. You are bedecked with what appears to be jewels;
18 is that correct?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. Okay. And were these jewels gifted to you by 01:53PM
21 your family?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. Okay. Were some of these --
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Tell me what they are. 01:53PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Some of them were bangles, gold; and some of
2 them were just cosmetic jewelry. The hair band and
3 stuff that you see is cosmetic, but the other stuff is
4 gold.
5 Q. Okay. And on your inventory, you're claiming 01:53PM
6 this jewelry that you were wearing on your wedding day
7 as your separate property; is that correct?
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. And you have evaluated that at approximately
10 $5,000. 01:53PM
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. All right. Exhibit Number 7 is a photograph
13 when opposing counsel wanted to inspect your safety
14 deposit box here in Houston; is that correct?
15 A. Yes. 01:54PM
16 Q. And did you allow them access --
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. -- to take photos?
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. And is Respondent's Exhibit Number 7 a correct 01:54PM
21 representation of the contents of your safety deposit
22 box?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. Were some of these items in Exhibit Number 7,
25 some of this jewelry, the same jewelry you were wearing 01:54PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 on the date of your marriage?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. What items are identical?
4 A. There is a hand band that I'm wearing in the
5 wedding day. The earrings that I'm wearing, the same 01:54PM
6 ones.
7 Q. Any of the -- are any of the bangles or any
8 other jewelry?
9 A. I can't tell. There's a couple of bangles
10 there, and I think those are the same ones that I'm 01:54PM
11 wearing.
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Do you have objections to
13 Number 7?
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: No. No objections.
15 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Okay. I'm going to 01:54PM
16 offer -- I think six has been admitted. I offer
17 Respondent's Number 7, Your Honor.
18 THE COURT: Seven is admitted.
19 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Other than this separate
20 property that you have identified, is the remaining 01:55PM
21 property that you have identified on your Fourth Amended
22 Inventory community property?
23 A. Yes.
24 Q. Save and except those funds that are listed as
25 Exhibit A, which is your child's property; is that 01:55PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. Deepa, are all of the items that are listed with
4 a bank account on your community property, are all of
5 those values identified in your business records 01:56PM
6 affidavit?
7 A. Yes.
8 Q. I am not going to go item by item; but if the
9 Court were to look at your business records affidavit,
10 the values here would be identical to those documents 01:56PM
11 contained in your business records affidavit.
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Is that correct?
14 We've also listed as Exhibit A that property
15 that you believe belongs to your child. 01:56PM
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. Tell me, did you and your -- did you or you and
18 your husband gift your child with a Kindle reading
19 device?
20 A. Yes. 01:56PM
21 Q. Two laptops, one Apple and one pink?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. A piano?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. Does she play the piano? 01:56PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Has she been taking music lessons for many
3 years?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. And finally, you and your husband set up two 01:56PM
6 Uniform Gift to Minors Accounts, one that you control
7 and one that your husband controls, listed as Items
8 Number 6 and 7 on Exhibit A as your child's property.
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And are you asking this Court -- now that she is 01:57PM
11 age 18, does she need these funds for college?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. Do you want this Court to, as part of its court
14 order, to find and order that all of these funds belong
15 to your daughter on your Exhibit A? Do you want that? 01:57PM
16 A. Yes.
17 Q. And do you want the Judge to order the immediate
18 release and surrender of these accounts to your
19 daughter, ones that you previously held and your husband
20 previously held as custodians for the benefit of your 01:57PM
21 daughter?
22 A. Yes.
23 Q. In your division of property, you have
24 identified under Item Number 4 some India property that
25 is in your husband's name or subject to his control; is 01:58PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 that correct?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. You are not on the title of that India property;
4 are you?
5 A. No. 01:58PM
6 Q. You really don't know the value of that
7 property; do you?
8 A. No.
9 Q. You have also listed a bank account in your
10 husband's name in India with a value unknown; is that 01:58PM
11 correct?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. All of those are evidenced in your business
14 records affidavit; is that correct?
15 A. Yes. 01:59PM
16 Q. Deepa, you have made a proposal to this Judge,
17 based upon your inventory, of how your estate should be
18 divided.
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. You're asking this Court to find as your 01:59PM
21 separate property the remaining sale proceeds of your
22 mother's house in India of about $103,000; is that
23 correct?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. That account being in an Indian account. 02:00PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And 50,000 you used from the sale proceeds to
3 buy an interest with some friends and relatives called
4 DLR Interest?
5 A. Yes. 02:00PM
6 Q. And, of course, all of your jewelry and personal
7 effects.
8 A. Yes.
9 Q. If the Judge were not to find this as your
10 separate property, would you still want the Judge to 02:00PM
11 award this to you as part of your division of your
12 overall estate?
13 A. Yes.
14 Q. All of the items listed in your proposal have a
15 possession sign for -- "H" for husband and "W" for wife. 02:00PM
16 You're asking the Court to award you not only the house,
17 the contents in the house, the personal effects, rather
18 than trying to divide those.
19 A. Yes.
20 Q. And your husband's inventory with the Court that 02:00PM
21 he filed several months ago, he has not listed any
22 household furnishings in his possession; has he?
23 A. No.
24 Q. Okay. To award you -- you're asking the Court
25 to award you a greater share of the estate? 02:01PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. Is that in part because of the fault involved in
3 this relationship?
4 A. Yes.
5 Q. And in part because your husband did not 02:01PM
6 contribute to your support for a period of 14 months
7 until a Judge ordered him to do so; is that correct?
8 A. 14 months was the one that the Judge, but he
9 hasn't done much. Our finances have been separate since
10 2004, and there's been no contributions since then. 02:01PM
11 Q. If the Judge were to honor our proposal, it
12 would allow you to keep all of the accounts in your name
13 and the same for your husband; is that correct?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. Save and except a retirement account that you 02:01PM
16 have.
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And that is with your current employer; is that
19 correct?
20 A. Yes. 02:01PM
21 Q. And you're asking this Judge to award you out of
22 your 403 -- 403(b) plan with the University of Texas,
23 337,878?
24 A. Yes.
25 Q. And 128,567 to your husband? 02:02PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. Yes.
2 Q. And if the Judge were to do that and award to
3 you the proposal that you see here, you would be awarded
4 approximately 60 percent of the community estate, as you
5 have testified. 02:02PM
6 A. Yes.
7 Q. Do you think that is a fair and equitable
8 division of your estate?
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. Deepa, was it necessary for you to hire me to 02:02PM
11 represent you in this case?
12 A. Yes.
13 Q. And have you agreed to pay me an hourly rate of
14 $350 an hour?
15 A. Yes. 02:03PM
16 Q. And have you, to date, paid me over $37,000 in
17 attorney's fees?
18 A. Yes.
19 Q. And you're asking this Court to award you
20 attorney's fees in this case; is that correct? 02:03PM
21 A. Yes.
22 MR. BROWNSTEIN: One minute, Your Honor?
23 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
24 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I pass the witness, Your
25 Honor. 02:04PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: All right. Mr. Vasudevan, do
2 you have any questions of the witness?
3 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, Your Honor.
4 THE COURT: You may proceed.
5 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes. 02:04PM
6 CROSS-EXAMINATION
7 BY MR. VASUDEVAN:
8 Q. First question I have is --
9 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I wish opposing
10 counsel would just go ahead and ask from his chair 02:04PM
11 unless he has something as an exhibit for her to review.
12 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
13 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, Deepa, when did you come
14 to U.S.?
15 A. First time, January of 1993. 02:04PM
16 Q. After coming to U.S., how many times did you
17 travel back to India?
18 A. I can't remember for sure.
19 Q. Did you at any time travel or -- after 1993?
20 A. Absolutely. 02:05PM
21 Q. About how many times?
22 A. I can't remember. I must have gone three or
23 four times at least.
24 Q. So, when you went back to India, how many -- how
25 many months did you stay there? 02:05PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. The first time I went there, I stayed for about
2 seven months because I had to finish my internship.
3 Q. So, when did your mom come to U.S.?
4 A. I can't remember the exact date, but she came
5 when I was pregnant. 02:05PM
6 Q. Was her visa --
7 A. It was in 1995.
8 Q. -- rejected several times?
9 A. What's that?
10 Q. Was her visa rejected several times? 02:05PM
11 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
12 object as not relevant.
13 THE COURT: What's the relevance of that?
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: I want to prove that I was
15 taking care of the family and the house and all that. 02:05PM
16 And she was saying that the maid servant was taking care
17 of the house, but there was no maid servant. That's my
18 point.
19 THE WITNESS: That was after Pallavi was
20 born. 02:06PM
21 THE COURT: Okay.
22 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I would object
23 on relevance.
24 THE COURT: Your daughter is how old?
25 THE WITNESS: She is 18. 02:06PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: 18?
2 THE WITNESS: Yes.
3 THE COURT: So, what does that have -- 18
4 years ago, what does that have to do with what I'm going
5 to be doing today? 02:06PM
6 MR. VASUDEVAN: Oh, for the last 18 years, I
7 have been taking care of the family.
8 THE COURT: Okay.
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: And she was saying that --
10 THE COURT: Hang on. Are you asking me to 02:06PM
11 do something with regard to that 18 years?
12 MR. VASUDEVAN: No. I just want -- she was
13 saying in the beginning that I was not taking care of
14 the home and --
15 THE COURT: And that's -- so, I'm going to 02:06PM
16 tell you the same thing I did Mr. Brownstein. What does
17 that have to do with the property division? And
18 Mr. Brownstein got right to the property issue, and
19 that's when his --
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay. 02:07PM
21 THE COURT: -- questioning stopped. So,
22 what does that have to do with property?
23 MR. VASUDEVAN: It's important in the
24 marriage as to whose fault it is.
25 THE COURT: The fact that you were taking 02:07PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 care of the family --
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
3 THE COURT: -- has to do with the fault.
4 Okay. If you see that as an issue, I'll let you ask
5 that. I don't, but -- 02:07PM
6 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I'm going to object, Your
7 Honor, because his petition -- the only grounds for
8 divorce is insupportability, not fault.
9 THE COURT: I'll sustain that objection.
10 Your next question? 02:07PM
11 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) The next question was: So,
12 you've been working like all time and working night duty
13 and all that?
14 A. I was working at UT. UT gives me the ability to
15 work overtime if needed. And I have to support the 02:07PM
16 family; and hence, I did work overtime. And my salary
17 represents my -- what I get is one paycheck from the
18 University of Texas. Whether I moonlight, whether I
19 work excess, it's one paycheck. I do not get multiple
20 paychecks. And they're all documented. 02:08PM
21 Q. So, who was taking care of the child when, in
22 the night duty, when you were doing night duty?
23 A. My mother.
24 Q. Your mother was not here; right?
25 A. 1995. She came when I was pregnant and stayed 02:08PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 for one and a half year.
2 Q. How can she stay about one and a half years when
3 the visa was only good for six months?
4 A. She filed an extension for about a year after
5 that. 02:08PM
6 Q. No. The maximum extension is only six months.
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
8 object. There's no question. He's testifying.
9 THE COURT: Sustained.
10 MR. VASUDEVAN: So, I want to prove, Your 02:08PM
11 Honor, that I was taking care of the child and she was
12 going on duty -- on night duty and moonlighting, and I
13 was taking care of the child. And child loves me, and I
14 love the child and I love the family, too.
15 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, again, I'm 02:09PM
16 going to object to testifying. If he has a question --
17 THE COURT: I'll sustain it.
18 Make sure that you ask questions.
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay, Your Honor.
20 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, when I was working, I 02:09PM
21 was traveling a lot doing consulting work to other
22 places?
23 A. I think you did one year where you went
24 consulting. But most of yours was primarily in Houston.
25 Q. But even in Houston, I had to travel a lot; 02:09PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 right? To Dallas every week?
2 A. I don't -- I mean, I cannot remember when you
3 were working in Dallas. Most of your travel was within
4 Houston.
5 Q. Okay. Oh, on the pink laptop, you said that I 02:09PM
6 had taken it; right? The pink laptop? Who bought that
7 laptop?
8 A. I think we bought it for our child.
9 Q. And that was -- I was also doing office work on
10 that? 02:10PM
11 A. I don't think. There was very limited. There
12 was nothing that you were working on. You had your own
13 laptop.
14 Q. No. I was using that for my office work, too.
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: So, that's the reason I took 02:10PM
16 that laptop, Your Honor. And then after I copied that,
17 I returned that laptop.
18 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Objection. Not a question,
19 Your Honor.
20 THE COURT: Make sure -- don't argue. Just 02:10PM
21 ask questions. All right?
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
23 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, why was the phone
24 blocked when my -- my phone was blocked. I couldn't
25 call home. 02:11PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. I had --
2 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Objection. Asking
3 questions of evidence that's not been testified to, Your
4 Honor.
5 THE COURT: Sustained. 02:11PM
6 Ask a question.
7 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) Okay. In the inventory,
8 number one, where it says the Citibank NRI, it was
9 reportedly having $113,000; right? And you have
10 withdrawn $10,000 recently? 02:12PM
11 A. Yes.
12 Q. Why -- why was it withdrawn?
13 A. I had to pay for attorney fees. I had to pay
14 taxes. Also, for that bank, I have to pay the taxes for
15 the India -- for the money in India. So, that was 02:12PM
16 deducted directly from that account. I also had to pay
17 for other things that I needed for Pallavi's education.
18 Q. What did you spend for Pallavi's education?
19 A. Books, travel. She had to go to campus tours.
20 Q. So, what were you doing with the salary? You 02:13PM
21 were making 200, 300K salary; right?
22 A. I was also running a house.
23 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
24 object. That's such a general question. It's
25 impossible to answer what did she do with her salary. 02:13PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: Sustained.
2 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, the Citibank NRI
3 account, that 103, came from a joint account which we
4 both had?
5 A. No. Initially, we held a joint account in 2004. 02:13PM
6 And that account was changed, and this account was
7 opened. And this --
8 Q. How much -- how much was the money in that
9 account?
10 A. In the previous account, I cannot remember. But 02:13PM
11 it was definitely between 5 and 6 lakhs.
12 MR. VASUDEVAN: Your Honor, I want to show
13 an exhibit.
14 THE COURT: Okay.
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: It's Exhibit Number -- 02:14PM
16 Number 5 in the deposition that she had.
17 THE COURT: Her exhibit or your exhibit?
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: My exhibit.
19 THE COURT: Your exhibit?
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes. 02:14PM
21 THE COURT: All right. Do you want to show
22 Mr. Brownstein, so that he can figure out if he's going
23 to object or not?
24 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor -- well, I don't
25 know if anything is being offered. So, if he wants to 02:14PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 ask questions about something -- I don't know how to
2 respond. Nothing has been offered at this moment, Your
3 Honor.
4 THE COURT: All right. Are you going to
5 offer that as an exhibit -- 02:14PM
6 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
7 THE COURT: -- or are you just going to read
8 from it?
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I'm going to offer
10 this as an Exhibit Number 5. Or the entire thing, I 02:15PM
11 want to give it. This is the deposition exhibits. So,
12 I want to give them to the Court.
13 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
14 object if Mr. Alavoor wants to offer an exhibit to a
15 non-certified copy of a deposition of my client. 02:15PM
16 Nothing has been filed with the Court. I'm going to
17 object to it in its entirety.
18 THE COURT: Do you have a certified copy?
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah. This was signed by --
20 this was a deposition that was taken on -- 02:16PM
21 THE COURT: Do you have a signed copy?
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Right. It's signed by the
23 court reporter.
24 THE COURT: Okay. Do you want to show it to
25 Mr. Brownstein? 02:16PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 (Discussion off the record between
2 Mr. Brownstein and Mr. Vasudevan.)
3 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Judge, this is not a
4 certified copy of a deposition that opposing counsel is
5 tendering to offer, nor is it the written -- the 02:16PM
6 original. It's evidently something file stamped, a copy
7 unsigned by my client. And I object to its
8 introduction.
9 THE COURT: I'll sustain the objection.
10 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, this is Number 5. 02:17PM
11 What's among -- it shows here --
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I thought you
13 had sustained my objection. So, for counsel to use what
14 you just sustained my objection, I'm going to further
15 object that he not approach my client with it. 02:17PM
16 THE COURT: Sustained.
17 Do you understand what the objection was?
18 The objection was that it was not a certified copy of a
19 deposition. So, he's made an objection to you offering
20 it as an exhibit, which I sustained, being that you 02:17PM
21 cannot use it as an exhibit. If you have some questions
22 that you want to ask, you're welcome to ask those
23 questions.
24 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I have a question to
25 ask. I need to show it to her. This is a statement -- 02:18PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 this is a bank statement. It was showing amount of --
2 THE COURT: And that bank statement is in
3 the same document that I sustained the objection, so
4 that you can't use it as an exhibit.
5 MR. VASUDEVAN: The reason is, I want to 02:18PM
6 prove that this amount --
7 THE COURT: You can ask questions. Don't
8 tell me what's in the document.
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: The document, it says the
10 balance is about -- more than $100,000. 02:18PM
11 THE COURT: If you have a question, you can
12 ask the witness.
13 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes. But she was saying
14 that --
15 THE COURT: Don't ask me. Don't make a 02:18PM
16 statement. Ask a question.
17 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, the statement here says
18 that having more than 100,000.
19 A. I don't know what --
20 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to 02:18PM
21 object. Again, there's no evidence previously testified
22 to my client regarding these issues. So, I'm going to
23 object as to being questioned about evidence that hasn't
24 been introduced before this Court.
25 THE COURT: Sustained. 02:19PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. VASUDEVAN: Can I ask her the question?
2 THE COURT: Sure.
3 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) Yeah. The statement here
4 says --
5 THE COURT: Not about that. That's just the 02:19PM
6 objection I just sustained.
7 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
8 THE COURT: Okay?
9 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) The next question I have is
10 about the Entry Number 2, the DLR Interest. Here it 02:20PM
11 says $51,000 as being your part interest. How did you
12 get this money?
13 A. That was money that I got through the sale of
14 the property in India, which my mother inherited from
15 her mother. And that's what I invested, because that 02:20PM
16 was her desire that it go as a gift to her
17 granddaughter.
18 Q. But you got it in India rupees. How did you
19 transfer it?
20 A. I got it -- I converted it from India rupees. 02:20PM
21 It was done with friends and family. So, I gave them in
22 Indian rupees. I gave them the value of that $50,000 in
23 rupees.
24 Q. And how did they give you the dollar? Where is
25 that? Did they deposit? 02:21PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. The property was purchased, yes.
2 Q. Where was it deposited?
3 A. Into the account. They paid the money for that.
4 I gave them the rupees, they got the dollars, and it was
5 paid into that -- paid for the sale of that property. 02:21PM
6 Q. Where is the receipt for that? Receipts?
7 A. The receipts for?
8 Q. For the payments.
9 A. They paid. There are receipts. The property is
10 bought; so, the amount is there. And this was done in 02:21PM
11 2004. Exactly around the time when I got the cash, it
12 was given to the family, and they paid the amount. And
13 if you want that -- at that point, yes, there are
14 probably receipts. But it was purchased -- the land was
15 purchased for that amount. The land is the receipt. 02:21PM
16 MR. VASUDEVAN: Your Honor, this is not the
17 separate property. This is a -- it should come out of
18 the community property, these two.
19 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I'm going to object.
20 Again, we're under cross. 02:22PM
21 THE COURT: Sustained.
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: The next question I have is
23 regarding the Item Number 3 where she's saying it is --
24 there's $5,000. I want to submit these Exhibits 12, 13,
25 14, and 15. 02:22PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
2 object. I'm not certain the purpose, but there appears
3 to be blurry photographs along with somebody's notes,
4 perhaps notes of Mr. Vasudevan since he is offering that
5 in the form of his analysis or description of what that 02:23PM
6 photo represents. To the extent that it contains things
7 beyond the blurry photo, I'm going to object as it being
8 hearsay.
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: Your Honor, I wish to show
10 you these. 02:23PM
11 THE COURT: This is what you're offering?
12 MR. VASUDEVAN: Uh-huh, yes.
13 THE COURT: 12, 13, 14, 15, and 16?
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: Uh-huh.
15 THE COURT: Okay. 02:24PM
16 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I didn't go through all of
17 them. If there's things beyond the photo, then I may
18 have other objections, Your Honor. I didn't know he was
19 trying to tender 15 or 20 pages of things.
20 THE COURT: There are several. 02:24PM
21 MR. BROWNSTEIN: If I could take a look, I
22 might offer additional objections, Your Honor.
23 Well, my goodness. Okay. As to the
24 objections as to things called Exhibit 12, which contain
25 photos and additional typewritten language -- basically, 02:24PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 the typewritten language contained on Exhibit 12 appears
2 to be testimonial in nature. I object that it's
3 hearsay.
4 The same objection to -- I can't tell where
5 Exhibit 12 and where others continue. 13 appears to be 02:25PM
6 a typewritten description of what appears to be
7 handwritten. There's been no predicate. It's
8 testimonial in nature. I object that it's hearsay.
9 Along with Exhibit Number 13, a description of what this
10 purportedly represents. Again, no predicate. It's 02:25PM
11 hearsay, Your Honor.
12 Exhibit Number 14 --
13 So, if I could, could I ask the Judge to
14 rule on my objections to at least 12 through 13 before
15 we go to 14? That's a little bit different in nature. 02:25PM
16 THE COURT: Sustained.
17 MR. BROWNSTEIN: By the way, Your Honor, if
18 I could, I have what is marked as Respondent's Fourth
19 Amended Inventory that I marked as Exhibit 5. And quite
20 frankly, I don't know if I just premarked that 02:26PM
21 inappropriately.
22 THE COURT: I admitted that.
23 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Item 5, the inventory.
24 THE COURT: Oh, wait a minute. I thought
25 you marked -- 02:26PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I may have inadvertently
2 marked this on my own.
3 THE COURT: The proposed division is what I
4 have as five.
5 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Okay. 02:26PM
6 THE COURT: But I don't have five.
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: You don't have Exhibit
8 Number 5?
9 THE COURT: No.
10 MR. BROWNSTEIN: The proposed division? 02:26PM
11 THE COURT: No. You were asking questions.
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Oh. Oh, I guess this is
13 the proposed division.
14 THE COURT: So it is.
15 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Thank you. I tender that 02:26PM
16 back.
17 THE COURT: Thank you.
18 MR. BROWNSTEIN: As to Exhibit Number 14,
19 appears to be documents regarding a safety deposit box
20 of the parties, some rental dating back from August 02:27PM
21 of 2001 to maybe some in 2013. To the extent they're
22 offered to prove that my client had a safety deposit
23 box, which we have the photos, I have no objections to
24 Exhibit 14, 6 through 7, Your Honor.
25 THE COURT: You have no objection to those? 02:27PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I have no objections to 14
2 entitled Pages 1 -- 1 through 7, all the way through 6
3 through 7. There is part of Exhibit Number 14 that is 7
4 of 7 that I will offer objections to.
5 Regarding Exhibit 14, 7 of 7, again, 02:28PM
6 absolutely no predicate. I have no idea what it is,
7 Your Honor.
8 Exhibit Number --
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: Oh, I can explain what it
10 is. 02:28PM
11 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well, the remainder of
12 these exhibits appear to be descriptions of some
13 handwritten notes. There's been no predicate. I'm
14 going to object.
15 And finally, the last page, Exhibit 16, 02:28PM
16 appears to be a copy of something from a Internet
17 regarding Indian fraud. And again, no predicate, no
18 relevance.
19 I'm going to object to the remainder of
20 Exhibit 14, 15, and 16, Your Honor, for those reasons. 02:28PM
21 THE COURT: 14, Pages 1 through 6 are
22 admitted; Page 7 is not admitted.
23 15 and 16 are not admitted.
24 MR. VASUDEVAN: I can't ask any questions on
25 this one? 02:29PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: You can ask questions, but
2 they're not admitted as exhibits.
3 MR. VASUDEVAN: Can I show it to her as to
4 what it is? No, I can't?
5 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) Okay. During the deposition 02:30PM
6 on 24th, there was exhibit -- an Exhibit 4. It was
7 saying there are 14 gold bars, all bought by me.
8 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
9 object. He's referring to an unsworn, uncertified
10 deposition, exhibits to that, that you have already 02:30PM
11 sustained my objection. So, I'm going to object that
12 he's --
13 THE COURT: I sustained the objection.
14 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well, I object that he's
15 referring to a specific exhibit that is not before this 02:31PM
16 Court.
17 THE COURT: I don't know what he's referring
18 to. Those -- the documents in his hands were not that
19 deposition. So, I don't know if he's asking a --
20 I'm going to let you ask the question. Just 02:31PM
21 make sure you don't --
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Oh, well, this document is
23 in reference to the deposition she already had.
24 THE COURT: I have no idea what document
25 you're referring to. I just know it's not the 02:31PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 deposition that you set down over here on counsel table.
2 But you can ask that question.
3 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, that's what I'm
4 asking.
5 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, there were some -- there 02:31PM
6 were handwritten notes, and then there were typewritten,
7 like 14 gold bars all bought by me. Were they bought by
8 you?
9 A. I don't even know who wrote it, typewritten,
10 typed. I don't have any idea. I did not write it. 02:31PM
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: Can I show it to her if she
12 says --
13 THE COURT: If it's on that exhibit, you
14 can't.
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes. 02:31PM
16 THE COURT: You cannot.
17 MR. VASUDEVAN: Then I can't prove further
18 what it is.
19 THE COURT: Mr. Vasudevan, I cannot tell you
20 how to present your case. You are representing 02:32PM
21 yourself. There are certain rules of evidence and rules
22 of procedure that apply to any case presented in the
23 state of Texas. Representing yourself, you are bound to
24 abide by those same rules of evidence and rules of
25 procedure. 02:32PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 The objections that are being made are
2 proper. I can't tell you what to do with the exhibits
3 that you did not get admitted. But let's move along.
4 MR. VASUDEVAN: Well, what I want to prove
5 was that Item Number 3 is not just 5,000. It's more 02:32PM
6 than -- it's about $900,000.
7 THE COURT: All right. Let me ask you this
8 question. Do you object that they are being claimed as
9 your wife's separate property gifts?
10 MR. VASUDEVAN: I do raise objection on 02:33PM
11 that, and I say it is a community estate. It was given
12 to both -- both of us. And the value is also wrong.
13 The value is not 5,000.
14 THE COURT: Okay.
15 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) The Item Number 4 in 02:33PM
16 inventory, I don't know what it is. So, do you know
17 what it is, the Item Number 4, the India property, Plot
18 Number 16?
19 MR. BROWNSTEIN: May I go ahead and tender
20 the inventory since my client is not -- 02:33PM
21 THE COURT: Sure.
22 MR. BROWNSTEIN: -- able to remember
23 everything by memory?
24 A. I'm sorry. What was the question?
25 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) Who gave you this one? 02:34PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 A. So, this was received as a mail. It came as a
2 mail to our home address.
3 Q. To whose home address?
4 A. As of now, our home address.
5 Q. So, who received it? You received it? You 02:34PM
6 opened it?
7 A. It was in the mailbox.
8 Q. It was in the mailbox.
9 A. Yes.
10 Q. And then did you open it? 02:34PM
11 A. I did not open it.
12 Q. If you did not open it, then --
13 A. So, the mail is also --
14 Q. -- how did you read the contents inside of it?
15 A. The mail was also picked up by Pallavi and gets 02:34PM
16 picked up by my housekeeper, Maria. So, she opens the
17 edges of the letter sometimes. And this one was opened
18 by Pallavi. She did not read the name. She opened the
19 envelope, and that's how that was -- how we got that.
20 So, I'm not the only one who opens the envelope, is the 02:34PM
21 answer.
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: I object, Your Honor.
23 Somewhere -- either she has opened it or I have
24 questions for Mr. Brownstein, if I can ask questions.
25 THE COURT: This is the witness on the stand 02:35PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 right here. I think she's answered your question.
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: The question was I want to
3 ask if Mr. Brownstein has opened that mail.
4 THE COURT: He's not on the stand. You see
5 who's on the stand right now. 02:35PM
6 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) So, this particular item
7 should be ignored on Item Number 4. It's wrong.
8 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Objection. No question,
9 Your Honor.
10 THE COURT: Sustained. 02:35PM
11 Are you claiming that you don't own a piece
12 of property at Plot Number 16?
13 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, I don't own.
14 THE COURT: You don't own it?
15 MR. VASUDEVAN: No. 02:36PM
16 THE COURT: So, I can award that to her if
17 it's owned by someone in the marriage? You're okay with
18 that?
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes. Uh-huh.
20 THE COURT: Okay. I just wanted to know 02:36PM
21 what you wanted me to do with it.
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes.
23 THE COURT: Go ahead. Do you have any more
24 questions?
25 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, Your Honor. I have 02:38PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 some questions.
2 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) On Item Number 27, the IRA
3 plan, you have withdrawn some $10,000 from there. Why?
4 Why did you withdraw?
5 A. There are a couple of withdrawals. If you see, 02:38PM
6 that is one, in answer to that question. And then also
7 the subsequent ones, we had to replace the HVAC of our
8 house since the entire system broke down. So, that cost
9 me about $25,000 that I had to pay. That was one. I
10 also have to pay the taxes April 15th, 2014, so. 02:39PM
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: That's all I have now. I
12 can -- I can ask later, right, if I want to?
13 THE COURT: I don't know.
14 Mr. Brownstein, do you have any more
15 questions? 02:40PM
16 MR. VASUDEVAN: Can I ask questions later?
17 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Just a few follow-up, Your
18 Honor.
19 THE COURT: Okay.
20 REDIRECT EXAMINATION 02:40PM
21 BY MR. BROWNSTEIN,
22 Q. Deepa, in your petition you requested that your
23 name be changed. What name do you wish?
24 A. Deepa Iyengar.
25 Q. And you are not seeking -- is that your maiden 02:40PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 name?
2 A. Yes.
3 Q. All right. And you're not seeking a name change
4 to avoid criminal prosecution or repayment of creditors;
5 is that correct? 02:40PM
6 A. Yes.
7 THE COURT: Yes, it is correct?
8 THE WITNESS: I mean, I -- I am not taking
9 it for criminal court.
10 THE COURT: It was a bad question. 02:40PM
11 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Also, Deepa, you and your
12 husband at the second mediation reached an agreement
13 regarding the sale of the house; is that correct?
14 A. Yes.
15 Q. That's set out in the Mediated Settlement 02:40PM
16 Agreement, which has been filed with the Court.
17 A. Yes.
18 Q. And on your proposed division of property
19 regarding the residence, you just put on your proposal
20 the division per the Mediated Settlement Agreement. 02:40PM
21 A. Yes.
22 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I pass the witness again,
23 Your Honor.
24 THE COURT: Any more questions?
25 MR. VASUDEVAN: Not questions, Your Honor. 02:41PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 I have the Second Amended Inventory of mine.
2 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, we're in the
3 middle of -- if he has no further questions, I have
4 another witness to call upon, Your Honor.
5 THE COURT: All right. Call your next 02:41PM
6 witness.
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I call myself. Do you want
8 me to --
9 Deepa, you can go ahead and sit down.
10 (Discussion off the record between 02:41PM
11 Mr. Brownstein and Mr. Vasudevan.)
12 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I do have objections.
13 THE COURT: A proper one?
14 MR. BROWNSTEIN: May I testify in a
15 narrative form, Your Honor? 02:42PM
16 THE COURT: Yes, sir.
17 RONALD ALLEN BROWNSTEIN,
18 and having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
19 DIRECT EXAMINATION
20 BY MR. BROWNSTEIN: 02:42PM
21 Q. Your Honor, my name is Ron Brownstein. I'm an
22 attorney licensed in the state of Texas, having been --
23 having been licensed since 1978, I believe, which I know
24 is hard for you to believe considering how youthful I
25 look. I was -- 02:43PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: Remember, you're under oath.
2 Q. (BY MR. BROWNSTEIN) Since I'm under oath, I'll
3 retract that last comment.
4 I was retained by Mrs. Deepa Vasudevan to
5 continue on in her representation in this divorce 02:43PM
6 action. Her previous attorney, through Scott Brown's
7 office, had -- I either substituted or they were allowed
8 to withdraw.
9 I am familiar with the customary and normal
10 attorney's fees in Brazoria County for cases involving 02:43PM
11 divorces. And the issues involved in this case
12 initially were related to the child since the child was
13 only 15 when -- or 15 and a half when we started but is
14 now, for all practical purposes, an adult.
15 I am charging my client $350 an hour, which 02:44PM
16 is, in my opinion, a reasonable fee considering the
17 issues involved in this case. This has been a
18 particularly difficult case, as the Respondent has had
19 two separate attorneys that I have had dealings with, as
20 well as himself, at two separate times, including now. 02:44PM
21 A fee of $350 an hour for attorney's fees in this county
22 is customary, is reasonable.
23 And the fees that I have charged my client
24 are set out in Respondent's Exhibit Number 8, which is a
25 summary of those fees and services that I have performed 02:44PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 for my client, detailing the date the service was
2 performed, a brief description of same, and the amount
3 of time devoted to that.
4 My attorney's fees, including trial, have
5 totalled 102.70 hours at $350 an hour, which my client 02:45PM
6 is seeking reimbursement. That is $35,945. In addition
7 to that, there have been costs of $1,169.27. My total
8 bill, which has been paid by my client, is $37,114.27.
9 I tender again Respondent's Number --
10 Exhibit Number 8 as a shorthand summary of my time 02:45PM
11 devoted on this case.
12 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Do you have any objection,
13 sir?
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I do have objections.
15 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Well -- 02:45PM
16 THE COURT: What's the objection?
17 MR. VASUDEVAN: The objection is it should
18 not be listed under the -- this inventory. It is
19 something even I -- even I do pay attorney's fees.
20 THE COURT: What is the objection? 02:46PM
21 MR. VASUDEVAN: Oh, the objection is this
22 should not be included in the inventory.
23 THE COURT: Okay.
24 MR. VASUDEVAN: If it is included, then even
25 I have to include my attorney fees, too. 02:46PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: Do you have any objection to
2 this document being offered?
3 MR. VASUDEVAN: Oh, this document which is
4 offered? Yeah, no. No objection.
5 THE COURT: No objection. Eight is 02:46PM
6 admitted.
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I pass the witness.
8 THE COURT: Do you have any questions of
9 Mr. Brownstein?
10 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, I do have some 02:46PM
11 questions; but it's not related to that, the questions I
12 do have.
13 THE COURT: I don't care what they're
14 related to. As long as they're relevant, you can ask
15 them. 02:46PM
16 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
17 CROSS-EXAMINATION
18 BY MR. VASUDEVAN:
19 Q. This is regarding the Item Number -- the 4 in
20 the inventory. Can I show you? The Item Number 4 on 02:46PM
21 the inventory, Deepa was saying the India property, so
22 and so. And then you have sent me a letter of this,
23 right, the demand notice and all that. Who -- who gave
24 it to you?
25 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I'm sorry. I don't 02:47PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 understand the question, Your Honor.
2 Q. (BY MR. VASUDEVAN) The question was: Did Deepa
3 give it to you, that one, or --
4 A. I -- I prepared that inventory based on
5 information provided by my client and by your attorneys, 02:47PM
6 when you had attorneys, and yourself when you did not
7 have an attorney.
8 Q. No. There was a demand notice, and I have the
9 letters. Wait. Let me show it to you. These were the
10 two, Articles 8 and Article 9 and 17, which are related 02:48PM
11 to the Item Number 4 in that inventory.
12 A. All right. Sir, do you have a question?
13 Q. Yes. Who gave this document to you?
14 A. I'm sure this was provided by my client.
15 Q. Was it opened when it was given like that, or 02:49PM
16 was it in an envelope?
17 A. Oh, I have no recollection whether it was in an
18 envelope, in a box, or in the form delivered to you in
19 a -- in a supplement to our production. I don't
20 remember. 02:49PM
21 Q. So, you don't know who opened that mail; right?
22 A. I don't know how it came into anybody else's
23 possession except mine. I don't know if it came through
24 the mail or not.
25 Q. So, this can be incorrect, too; right? So, it 02:49PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 can be a fake. It's not a real document maybe. It can
2 be a fake document.
3 A. I guess anything is possible, sir.
4 Q. Okay.
5 MR. VASUDEVAN: That's all I have. 02:49PM
6 THE COURT: Your next witness?
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I have no further
8 witnesses, Your Honor.
9 THE COURT: Rest?
10 MR. BROWNSTEIN: We rest. 02:50PM
11 THE COURT: Mr. Vasudevan, do you have any
12 witnesses?
13 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, Your Honor.
14 THE COURT: No witnesses? All right. You
15 rest? Do you rest? 02:50PM
16 MR. VASUDEVAN: Huh?
17 THE COURT: Do you rest, meaning are you
18 done?
19 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, not yet, Your Honor. I
20 have this second amended -- 02:50PM
21 THE COURT: That's what I just asked you:
22 Do you have any witnesses? You don't have any
23 witnesses?
24 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, no witnesses; but I just
25 want to submit this Second Amended Inventory. 02:50PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: Okay. Is that your inventory?
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, this is my inventory.
3 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm --
4 MR. VASUDEVAN: I gave you a copy of this.
5 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I was handed a 02:50PM
6 copy of an unsworn-to document entitled Second Amended
7 Inventory. I'm going to object as to its lateness, the
8 fact that it is not sworn as required by the scheduling
9 order and your local rules. I have not had adequate
10 time to study or vet that document since it was -- well, 02:51PM
11 it's being tendered to you for some purpose. I don't
12 know if it's for filing with the Court or for evidence.
13 Those are my objections.
14 THE COURT: All right. Mr. Vasudevan, you
15 are under oath; so, let me ask you -- 02:51PM
16 MR. VASUDEVAN: Uh-huh.
17 THE COURT: -- are you stating that all the
18 information contained in this document is true and
19 correct?
20 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, true. 02:51PM
21 THE COURT: All the values are accurate?
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, Your Honor.
23 THE COURT: This is all the property that
24 you believe to exist?
25 MR. VASUDEVAN: That's correct. 02:51PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: Is that your testimony?
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yeah, that's my testimony.
3 THE COURT: All right. I will let you file
4 it and admit it.
5 MR. VASUDEVAN: Thank you. 02:52PM
6 THE COURT: You don't have it marked.
7 Petitioner's 1 will be admitted.
8 Anything else?
9 MR. VASUDEVAN: One more document.
10 (Discussion off the record between 02:52PM
11 Mr. Brownstein and Mr. Vasudevan.)
12 MR. VASUDEVAN: Your Honor, this is
13 objections to the inventory which he has filed.
14 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Your Honor, I'm going to
15 object that it is a document purportedly testimonial in 02:52PM
16 nature. It's hearsay. And for those reasons, I'm going
17 to object to the Court's consideration of that document.
18 THE COURT: I'll sustain your objection.
19 And we'll mark this as Petitioner's Exhibit 2, but I
20 will sustain the objection. 02:53PM
21 Anything else?
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: These are the copies of the
23 deposition that she had taken. Do I need to -- shall I
24 certify this and then submit? Or what do you want?
25 What do you do? 02:54PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 MR. BROWNSTEIN: I think you've already --
2 THE COURT: I can't tell you what to do with
3 it. If it's the same exhibit that you offered
4 previously, I've already sustained the objection. I
5 think it was Number 5? 02:54PM
6 MR. VASUDEVAN: No, no. These are the --
7 yeah, these are the exhibits in the deposition that she
8 has done. I want to submit a copy to the Court.
9 THE COURT: I'm not looking at it if it's
10 not certified. 02:54PM
11 MR. VASUDEVAN: So, shall I get it certified
12 and then submit to you?
13 THE COURT: Can you do that right now?
14 MR. VASUDEVAN: I need time for that.
15 THE COURT: Today is the only day that's 02:54PM
16 going to happen. Did you realize that today was your
17 final trial date, Mr. Vasudevan?
18 MR. VASUDEVAN: Yes, uh-huh.
19 THE COURT: Okay. So, you got to be
20 prepared. If it's not certified, then I'm not -- I'm 02:54PM
21 not allowing it as an exhibit.
22 MR. VASUDEVAN: Okay.
23 THE COURT: Anything else?
24 MR. VASUDEVAN: That's all I have, Your
25 Honor. 02:55PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 THE COURT: That's it?
2 MR. VASUDEVAN: Uh-huh.
3 THE COURT: Both sides rest?
4 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Yes, Your Honor.
5 THE COURT: All right. The evidence is 02:55PM
6 closed. Give me until about 3:15, and I'll come back
7 and give you my ruling. We'll be in recess until 3:15.
8 MR. BROWNSTEIN: Thank you, Your Honor.
9 (Recess was taken.)
10 THE COURT: All right. Let's go back on the 04:28PM
11 record in Vasudevan. I will make the following
12 findings.
13 I will find the marriage has become
14 insupportable because of discord or conflict of
15 personalities and find that there's no reasonable 04:28PM
16 expectation of reconciliation.
17 I will further find fault in the breakup of
18 the marriage; and based upon the testimony and evidence
19 with regard to family violence, will find the cruelty
20 fault to be true. 04:29PM
21 I will grant the divorce, terminate the
22 marriage relationship as of today, pronouncing and
23 rendering today, and give you an entry date of June 13
24 for the decree.
25 I will grant the name change that was 04:29PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 requested.
2 With regard to conservatorship, find that
3 the child is now 18 and graduating. With regard --
4 therefore, no other orders will need to be issued with
5 regard to the child. 04:29PM
6 Relative to the prior Court's order on the
7 Motion to Compel, those orders are orders that are
8 subject to being enforced and may be enforced following
9 the entry of a decree, specifically with regard to the
10 payment of the $600 and the costs of 150 for the 04:30PM
11 deposition cost.
12 I will find that the division of property,
13 as I will outline for you in the Court's division, is a
14 fair and equitable division; and considering the fault
15 of the breakup of the marriage, results in a 60-40 04:30PM
16 division. I have the division -- thank you, Ed -- that
17 I will hand out; and as soon as you have that copy, I
18 will go over this with you and let you know what I have
19 found to be fair and equitable.
20 At the top of the page, I will confirm as 04:30PM
21 Mrs. Vasudevan's separate property those three items --
22 1, 2, and 3 -- finding that they are a result of
23 inheritance on Items 1 and 2 and gift for wedding on
24 Number 3.
25 With regard to Item Number 4, there's no 04:31PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 value assigned to it. And if that doesn't exist, then
2 it doesn't exist. But if it does exist, then it's
3 awarded to Mr. Vasudevan. But I've assigned no value;
4 so, it doesn't impact the overall division of the
5 property. 04:31PM
6 I've confirmed the parties' agreement
7 relative to the residence located at 3402 Castle Pond
8 Court, Pearland, Texas, and just confirming that that is
9 to be dealt with pursuant to the Mediated Settlement
10 Agreement. 04:32PM
11 Where the items have a typed value, I am
12 confirming that and accepting that as the value to be
13 assigned to it. Where you see an item crossed out and a
14 new value placed on that, that's where I have made a
15 change. 04:32PM
16 Item Number 6, I changed that value from
17 5,000 to 3,500. Item 13, I changed that from 11,931 to
18 7,924. Over on Page 2, Item 29, I changed those -- that
19 value; and Items 32 and 33, I changed those items.
20 Turning over to Page 4 at the bottom, I have 04:32PM
21 adjusted the overall division of the community property.
22 And where you see the columns "Husband" and "Wife",
23 those items that are awarded to the husband are listed
24 in that column throughout this document and those items
25 listed to wife are listed in that column throughout. 04:32PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 Page 5, I have also added the attorney's
2 fees that Mr. Vasudevan is paying, pursuant to his
3 inventory, of $8,000, to net out the value. And that's
4 what you see at the bottom, Net CP, meaning Net
5 Community Property. 358,779 to Mr. Vasudevan. 523,672 04:33PM
6 to Mrs. Vasudevan. And I've also included her
7 attorney's fees. Each party will pay their own
8 attorney's fees. And that division results in a 60-40
9 division. It's actually like 59.3 in favor of wife.
10 I will find this to be a fair and reasonable 04:33PM
11 division of the parties' property.
12 Any of these items that are in this document
13 that are awarded to a party and they are in the other
14 party's possession, those will be turned over by the
15 entry date, June 13. If those items are in your 04:34PM
16 possession, nothing needs to be turned over. But if an
17 item is awarded to you, it's to be turned over to you by
18 June 13th, 2014.
19 If you don't see an item listed on this, I
20 didn't find sufficient evidence to find that it existed. 04:34PM
21 And if you don't see a value other than the items where
22 you see values, I don't find that there is sufficient
23 evidence to change the values, other than what has been
24 set out.
25 On the last page, which is actually Page 6, 04:34PM
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 it's titled Child's Property, those items are awarded to
2 the child, Pallavi, and are to be awarded to her. And
3 again, by June 13, 2014, those items are to be turned
4 over to her.
5 And that will conclude our business. 04:35PM
6 Any questions, Mr. Brownstein?
7 MR. BROWNSTEIN: None, Your Honor. I'll
8 prepare the draft.
9 THE COURT: All right. Any questions,
10 Mr. Vasudevan? 04:35PM
11 If none, we'll be adjourned.
12 (Court was adjourned.)
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
1 OFFICIAL REPORTER'S RECORD
2 CERTIFICATION PAGE
3
4 THE STATE OF TEXAS)
5 COUNTY OF BRAZORIA)
6
7 I, Renee Rape, Official Court Reporter in and for the 300th District Court of Brazoria County, State of Texas, 8 do hereby certify that the above and foregoing contains a true and correct transcription of all portions of 9 evidence and other proceedings requested in writing by counsel for the parties to be included in this volume of 10 the Reporter's Record, in the above-styled and numbered cause, all of which occurred in open court or in 11 chambers and were reported by me.
12 I further certify that this Reporter's Record of the proceedings truly and correctly reflects the exhibits, 13 if any, admitted by the respective parties.
14 I further certify that the total cost for the preparation of this Reporter's Record is $576.00 and was 15 paid/will be paid by Petitioner, Mr. Alavoor Vasudevan.
16 WITNESS MY OFFICIAL HAND this the 17th day of November, 2014. 17
18
19 /s/Renée Rape ____________ Renée Rape, Texas CSR# 4031 20 Expiration Date: 12-31-16 Official Court Reporter, 300th District Court 21 Brazoria County, Texas 111 East Locust, RM 402 22 Angleton, Texas 77515 979-864-1229 23
24
25
RENEE E. RAPE, CSR, RPR OFFICIAL COURT REPORTER
300TH DISTRICT COURT
Appendix J Texas Family Code 3.003 - Community Estates Texas Family Code for Marital Property Rights http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/?link=FA Code = Family Code Chapter 3 Marital Property Rights and Liabilities Sec.3.003. Presumption of community property Sec. 3.003. PRESUMPTION OF COMMUNITY PROPERTY. (a) Property possessed by either spouse during or on dissolution of marriage is presumed to be community property.
(b) The degree of proof necessary to establish that property is separate property is clear and convincing evidence.
Added by Acts 1997, 75th Leg., ch. 7, Sec. 1, eff. April 17, 1997.
Appendix K Texas Penal Code 2.01 - Cruelty by Husband Texas Penal Code for Proof Beyond a reasonable doubt http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/Docs/PE/htm/PE.2.htm#2.01 Code = Penal Code CHAPTER 2. BURDEN OF PROOF Sec. 2.01. PROOF BEYOND A REASONABLE DOUBT. All persons are presumed to be innocent and no person may be convicted of an offense unless each element of the offense is proved beyond a reasonable doubt. The fact that he has been arrested, confined, or indicted for, or otherwise charged with, the offense gives rise to no inference of guilt at his trial.
Acts 1973, 63rd Leg., p. 883, ch. 399, Sec. 1, eff. Jan. 1, 1974. Amended by Acts 1993, 73rd Leg., ch. 900, Sec. 1.01, eff. Sept. 1, 1994.
Trial court RR2 pg 92 line 19.
48 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Appendix L Felony Charge on Wife's Attorney filed by Husband Husband filed felony charge on wife's attorney for postal mail thefts is attached in case envelope Appendix L Felony charge on Wife's attorney, a separate case is filed against wife's attorney for his violations. And this is related to this case and referenced at (RR2 pg 87 line 8-25) and this was also referenced in the deposition of Alavoor taken by wife's attorney (IDX 309).
49 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
Oct 13, 2014
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § IN THE DISTRICT COURT v/s § JUDICIAL DISTRICT RON BROWNSTEIN § TEXAS
Dear Ron Brownstein:
Please find below the “Notice of Intention to Petition”. Please show causes as to why this lawsuit should not be filed against your firm.
NOTICE OF INTENTION TO PETITION LAWSUIT
This is an intention to file petition with the court for the following violations by your Law Firm (and you):
a) Federal Privacy Law on mail and personal information b) Texas Privacy Laws (various and general) c) Federal Privacy Laws (various and general)
Background Information
Mr Ron Brownstein, attorney at law and his Law Firm was hired by my ex-wife Deepa in divorce Cause #63935 in Brazoria 300th District Court. That case had trial on 27 May 2014. And for that case Mr. Ron Browstein (and his Law Firm) had illegally intercepted and opened all my postal mails which was addressed to my home address at 3402 Castle Pond Court, Pearland, TX. Mr Ron Brownstein took advantage that I was not living in that home but was living in an apartment situated at 8701 Gustine Lane, #5918, Houston, TX 77031. In that home at Castle Pond, my ex-wife Deepa was living. Mr Ron Brownstein not only opened all my mails but also sent those to me via Registered Postal Mail with RFP#5,8,10,17(second supplement). Also these have been filed with District Court. Attached are the copies of the mail and RFPs.
An oral deposition of Alavoor Vasudevan had been taken by Mr Ron Brownstein on April 10, 2014 and several questions regarding these RFP#5,8,10,17 (second supplement) had been asked. The “Choice Reporting” did the recording and is also the witness for this oral deposition. As a proof, deposition pages from 131 thru 142 describe the contents of the RFPs 5,8,10,17 (second supplement).
Note that as per US laws – Title 18 U.S. Code § 1708 - Whoever steals, takes, or abstracts, or by fraud or deception obtains, or attempts so to obtain, from or out of any mail, post office, or station thereof, letter box, mail receptacle, or any mail route or other authorized depository for mail matter, or from a letter or mail carrier, any letter, postal card, package, bag, or mail, or abstracts or removes from any such letter, package, bag, or mail, any article or thing contained therein, or secretes, embezzles, or destroys any such letter, postal card, package, bag, or mail, or any article or thing contained therein; or Whoever steals, takes, or abstracts, or by fraud or deception obtains any letter, postal card, package, bag, or mail, or any article or thing contained therein which has been left for collection upon or adjacent to a collection box or other authorized depository of mail matter; or Whoever buys, receives, or conceals, or unlawfully has in his possession, any letter, postal card, package, bag, or mail, or any article or thing contained therein, which has been so stolen, taken, embezzled, or abstracted, as herein described, knowing the same to have been stolen, taken, embezzled, or abstracted— Shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than five years, or both.
Amendments: 1952—Act July 1, 1952, made any thefts or receipt of stolen mail a felony regardless of the monetary value of the thing stolen.
http://www.gpo.gov/fdsys/granule/USCODE-2011-title18/USCODE-2011-title18-partI-chap83-
sec1708 http://ww.gpo.gov/fdsys/pkg/USCODE-2011-title18/pdf/USCODE-2011-title18-partI-chap83-
sec1708.pdf Attached is the copy of the Title 18 US code 1708.
Also Mr Ron Brownstein (and his Law Firm) had violated my privacy and violated general laws of privacy, intrusion, trespassing my “information-data”, identity theft and various others. These will cause me immense economic damages for a very long time. And there are other economic damages due to these actions.
Damage Claim
I request the court to do following:
i) Impose court fine (US dollars) on Mr Ron Browstein (and/or on his Law firm) and other penalties.
ii) Award me $200,000 in damages. It should be charged to mal-practice-insurance of Mr Ron Browstein (or law firm) or if no insurance coverage is available then from the personal assets of Mr Ron Browstein.
iii) Impose all the court fees, admin fees, judge fees (US dollars) on Mr Ron Browstein (and/or on his Law firm)
iv) Pay my attorney fees and other costs which I may incur.
Sincerely,
___________________________________
Appendix M Health Reports of Husband Health reports of Husband is attached in case envelope Appendix M Health reports of husband. The health reports of husband were sent to district clerk, Judge and to wife's attorney on 15 June 2014. Wife's attorney acknowledged/signed proof of delivery the document sent by registered email 16- Jun-14 at 09:50:54am. (See also: IDX 312, RR3 pg 5 line 18). The title was: “Prayer – Corrections to wordings in judgment” which contained health reports of husband.
-rr sire 5'” ed? £7-“r Leer art/-criii. U F1??? LED r"'“ ,i,.»r.-* ‘r'"*~.ItIi"-
"\- 3'3 -- E" 'fl"j'#" _ __-
“'3 -- -_ '5 _.t F -I-I ‘I-I"-""' ___ '
_ _ ___ _ _ _ -_—|Ii— -- "-
- —-g__ 2;.-._ -_ ‘_-
F _ -i.
¥‘iiysic'rarre at Street C-reek - ‘Eietitheeet i"-ieti W L k + -i.
_._._.-'. |. ll :- t .! ' - - - -1 .iI 5;Ln. ct ':_'- -r" __-‘ '.'i'l;‘1:"‘I- 3l.__ |_ __|.-‘-.
14023 Sfiuthwesl Freeway, '.:i?iI-I"lv:l-\|:.'\-I-|l|!l =35?5;"q;1t‘t§;i3it_t1.-i'it,r;';tr,;i<;ii'ii:i.1."; ig 1|:\i-':':.:-If ,1 T?-475
Phi‘ L231} 325-MUD Feiti {E51} 325-4.'ZT1 I
'Trt1ry Fieeitiget MD {Prescribing F‘roi.nrleri LIE H3149 I‘~IPI:‘lE11i5?ifi-T5r1‘l U II
I-
-h | | - -| I | 1 I _- — --_-_-.. .....,, ,_.---... ._..“ -|||II-—l-'lllI\"III-ll --i -i-- -_ -.- . -in-_ —|i-1| ' I . - —
Petierit eiarne Sr erdciresst Erate: 1t'IllBi'2D"l2 I"
elayoor ire.-sr.rriee=ari fiilliii El?tUTl‘I‘§'53 i305-2 e="iEeiir' Ln ?~“ar"cii*ieee:'ai.itT-r’ 'ir‘;+"r-n-rt_rr‘r Error; eeaeann FE tteee ' err: re:'r-mes--“r92?
Il'tEti!'£1ritT3t-‘ti t..t£itj;BS PPU. ttfitii Grp t‘.i?1??‘B lD.UT5DG31ECeiL 1'
lf - F I I_Z_ K I -. .I _ I_ _
¥1Rfi.‘JflSTAT§H S€I3i'31L.lIifi #6 MIG Titfifi -"' ,-.,--. _- -.-. -- _.-if .1 I '. -. --." -.-., ._.;--. '
RX 5 %\JL'E ffria.-rm -is?-irr‘-y It?-: ~_i~“it;lr?r.‘:rI&i=i}I t'.‘ttr entity:
. Generic PRAUASTATIN 5{I|UlL.lfy1 ' indications: HYPERCHDLESTERDLEMIA ‘I-24 25-49
rery "rep-" nrnsry 5D—?4 I eenii THREE T5-ififi 1Cl'l-‘I50
ENIR serial # 156533994?-EDYTEIU Void after _ _ I I LI -I IEIEI 15D and over ____ ____Ur1|t5
I
J I fp
I ‘I-.i-I: _ 1 F _;_| .__ I i.
' -t
- Troy Fiesihger MD I A generically eriuniatent product may be dispensed unless the practitioner hani1wiites'[11sp'ensie as written‘ _ . on the face of the |f.Il"=E5lIJl|'.IlTi'|i'J'T‘ [I] Dispense as written
'_ Allergies‘ No Known Allergies Security. ['1 poeiirl K spelled quantity E. refills rtiie-"itity checittioiies serial r'n:i=rnl:ier rnicroprint signature line : uisihie at Eiir oi greater rnagnilicatrori sheyiing 'THI5-iE‘;-~Fil'~l-DHlGlH.fliL-PREEC-HtP1'iCiH'. E. this description '
of security features " This prescription was generated on a Gentricity system which has ootaineo appioyaole status" with the Ohio State Board of Pharmacy This prescription should net he accessihie to unauthorized persons.
_ Prescription is yoid if more than one 11} prescription is written per blank. y
aqq
tetttrr Stiirir-trt Hat itE*t‘_'E_i"_'_=f‘_‘;‘§_ “
‘H 3 1... e.tIPo-in:-it~e-'.I“ :.vvvua;»a4.-|-is:-v p--.11-arr‘ ---I J-_‘_ .....-
“ -..-
Z1-' ‘I rglfllpvigtfqlfllf .
AH!
c.e;_--- - ' """' ' "ff, ,';",.......'-";.»,t.,;¢-ii»-
1 r .-wr III? JUK-
. .
c.-i ee- -nil‘ E 1-I-1':-._; FF.-'
___
II-. :' {leg -.-“._...---.-I-___,
:1
“K ll .-.-.
-c
"It
-1-
r_-"L-‘Tl -I"l-
¢:iwur.ra:wnr»=W* _ _ @%
'w
LI;
4vi5;;~¢.|\r#.rIi‘3v‘ —u ITIPE15*".
av
-i.I--
LABEIPD
Q
‘Ii
.__ _ ?'I,1‘/I
-i-r-izcullae-sP.r-‘Ii-PHI‘ 4-Jle Z.‘ -‘I-r
"1";-L1
- .13; w4r'v
-.-1
65x '55 .__m -Amman-vzain-rnb
-=-T-'_
.rau..4n-bwbr-Y1-Ifl13'}
;
aiiasaeryimw-ififi :2)‘ II‘ Irs‘.I3.§I 1 5- ii ii
ll.ll ll
gu-
1| -
53|'-I -}I J.~.TIEIU flupqriflnwfit in __ _
mt ion
....--mi E5‘ ..__a.i-..-i--I‘f|
'5.” 5 PRUMISEUE -i
‘J-1 .4 | can--a -,' ""_ .._.-,..i....-..-.-. -2.. _-_--im _ -
="
950:: -Ir" ,;_rr . _,_
:1: _fl5\ -1 .-I43-
. .Hm;Is1pri_1I (TIfl3!Iet-lg 715=;-fi9»fi£.1aQ.fi 5, eatstaenret -=are't=teea _g. ]_i,_1'@'I.,!_.Efi grits.
-sa?
:-
I
.a 1., P-I
Ht}1..I3‘fill
Iilli-I
{t Med
Tti‘EflHfl 1*‘-
1"‘-»
, . RI-‘I _,_
life! (I Hi’
I .-
-i..-I!- ii l-.j¢-4;t'\ ._..?-II’ .
O
V09 El?
!'H|'
:.-. -.- ..--
iitlt. iIas-.
t
“IEI tr-Er ". ten,..:
aatFt. iriert‘rmei.aa. 7.5 % __phth.
_ ,-.
. 4|
GiM.F
ileieier.ert 5lelCut’rflirlemFrU'lataeIfir.mIftlll
J
‘$.-
X 3 rnat
|.I'1II' $1‘. . .,- :-'\-i.-
"‘:- ‘W
ir‘".r
-iv.
..-
;- A II3 we
\1'\'\-I}
.»- .\ I a.-.
HF-l .'t.
Bruit OOH i .rri
-i- -.i-I‘ I‘\{?i“§‘§ §I‘r' §IIH5 r ‘--J Ii =
Fenieerflire.ti!‘ -..-I
.i-4-vs 55rd!-
I
.¥‘*a
‘E
Rhee aileaseletit . 5 D CDNew ‘Ln. viw _, .
-.52
_'
_, .TI!‘--
I
4-I
mp:
,_ <¢\Il‘-"
I?1;|t:Iy#l?45g 44-l=|'\ Vii -.i
,-
-mini
.21 ~Z-K1
_ 1'1.
.,_.
'{.‘IS'
i-r
not
r eeeeea-er E 1-
...--r
are os( onoiqtgt
-ra-gais .
'
'4-.
I1-'.I'
.- _.--
I1
-*1 ’n_i-:r.- 1.-, *1.-1'
arr“ -,-L3 5” #3, -.ii.-2»
NKI Dis
LUMIG.03 Z5 IT} $11-?I 'Ii.
-l-P
,5
”.i§?f as 55:.
uri ei rieaiiirrarifII51
1. ,|_ _|-
MM! MVANroi.
ttirr PH
-I.'-i
I[I5I
E;‘€:?;€. l'I.£I. Z.l. l$ E15 IG Q1“ JP
ft? §‘-ii
£1515-.
\O\I‘-
- I 'I"I'DI.
fl
li? I‘.-I‘
i-
i- I
1 1.
J. 1' '1'-(PP :‘n.
-3.": ‘Er
IN CL § Ili-
Irerr Mi
'1'
ea. - i.._l" I'H- \' ‘a a-. 3.
/.‘_
i L J‘ -’-i:I'.
. ._l_|__.
‘I-
M 1:, -I-J If}
1,1-‘c ,’f'
VASUr-ratnir- lit?
.--11"
l.'I-. CVQ
"it .|-
.. 3-.
_‘|"'
-.. .|i. -_
§ u-I.-Ji. 351- --1.-.
- i
II$|.‘}'I'lI I I. tr i-ea teat rear er.-resets reaat reirrr riri=aerr.rririr.
FFGEE er Ht Jr}?-'1'E5€i 5t__J___:fi__: errrat rarest eartt ritr_.arget;rsr.
iilfill F':iP5.iT‘F_l$’l‘1 "JfiSiHlEliIl!tI,¥ilI1lififlH .3-Iii.‘ =Iii-"t-511$: 5"¥.‘|1.‘.'-* ‘J 5 F-*-:1r.= eIa.1tei_sa eatte Baindi H wIIIIimi‘FIPII' pesataaa. ‘t r; ?'.?=-r.t';.*'.fl‘- eeie. -i Fa: an .'~i-‘r HI‘?
HT fiHi3FHflST B'.flil5"H HE BBBP$ 1|;-P - L1"
react r peer aria aetri ms er eretrrat This is a EI1tfifi'LESS IEHIFS. LflTh!iIBPBflST - BPi'iTl-iillilfiiifl Sl1i.Ll1Ii€H'I- {lay-T fifirelrpreifi E'fiM'fi%fl¥il BRMEE HAMEISI: it alat an H555: - - . ~ . = ‘ . i1EtEl;Et3Ii5EESE$.I£.’§.. octtiarhypertensiani.l1it= iatariarrrris: tr. =.1sEtI to treat lee-,l'i pressure ii-isrtie the eta ti-.i_=Btti tltifllifiliiiifiif-*1-liiiii E“??? it??? *1‘ IL" _ _ _ . _ . _ _ srrratar to ri rrattrrai ~t'..ItitiTl!-[1PtII= re the tiaey iprosteeraitrrer aria wares by reeeiatieg the tlew at ttirazl wrtitie rhe ere iiiiiifiii -EBUIIB F1 IBWEI i1'i=Ee'=‘~r-iiE- I.i'1"i-‘tilt!-"£fit} rage pressera rrrsrtie tee aye tieips to preeent hieierresa. HUGE‘ TE USE; _* _ . Iii-‘lie. ilirr-iiii:tlrLa1it1'irrr the aII£tttr-rfi =PtE=5'- ti5ti&Il‘i' tints tlaiiir 1" IIIE EI'IIIIIIIIIII.' III as mremjd It? IIIIIIr;mI:IflIi ?ItIIe*II.'ItjIIrI.II:IiI.I'§'1:'II;iIIIItIi:1:IiIII:'Ii!rIi rt-t 1 1. I r :3 . Ila: 1 i.y...i_.,1..,yr._, fli,:r1[tram-;;I|t5rI,_11'-;t|1-iijtttttlltt ran decrease ellectnrerie-se-Te atitiit Eye dtfltifi i"-E5 i."li1- Tl 5 ‘Fe - "-* ' - '
:i-.ri ii *1 r~ .1iep|ii-r tip .ir It-1 it tr;-ire" irrnri eye or any other etitiace. The tireser-retire iii IIliL Liriliietit mitt IIIE HITi5flFI.ZlE4IlIIl|! Etii'lr‘Bf. firiilihii II J|1T t r Ii-fIIT.FTIi. "'lf!i'_i1,-Ii; II'EiIi liei-:.rr iisriiq this r-.'ierlit;;itrrin and keep filler!" uni DI rfiut ElrE'F- ID!’ BIIFIBIFI 5 ITIIII“-‘I55 3'15‘ EITII3'I"1"’EI 5 W -'= - 'lliIIfit-‘r'l'
.
ti-.i . ii iiirrr
.-.-
uni-.atrl. .-int‘ 1 [|1lIIlIIEi'|'~iIIlIIIlII!
I-
lower. Ereliti iii rnalie a prieeh.-..Haiti the tlmptreti"direII1|i'¢'"'*"
-. -. " I i’i“" E"! Elli flfitilir tire presr:riiieti Er.'I'!lli.|It.lI1lE1i‘It'l*t!olIllEPI1iL1Ii':rI’lI~l riiri 1.» iiI iiiii|i'-- i..i-ii: itiii. in-rill. HIIII Hr-rill? tiuae III-iH..II r.ir' i.i i Iii .r_ llt|ltl.II!_'. . Pi-IE1! i..'l-I. IIIIIH III In‘: III Id? Lu B III I -i"tIte li*':itIier this:-5.-.|rr" Ihrti ital!‘ tilit-Wlfi‘ PIIP Ifltttlicflllflli Item rtiflimllfl ""7 TH “LII I“ I-IIIIIII ‘HIIII [III "III IILII] III-IIII EIIIIII‘ EIIII I-IIII IIIIIIII III? IIIIIIIIIIEII HH_,:Lt,.P I'M flimlpir EH; HHH. I-.35}. U.__;._._ §_|.r_;y-_i f|tm._H-11:!-|-’“r_3|;[||'i.!'=,|'|_g|g|],I.§-_1t'I1i,-' .r| t_'t;Ier It: [jet Hi-E It*tII‘F-1 I=“itT'tiEIt1. ‘Irt.1t“rill HEl‘I‘iEl1'i‘ClEi' Ill USP II BI II1E Sflflifi Iifltri _ _ _| 1| , ‘Ir-ll I 1 r .. I.d 1i'...!
ertrh rlri-=. it re irrttirirter-r it? Li:l1IlIl=llF I :~tr=i£tIrr1ati.:Uru'.~.l etrtrtl II trlir-I IEFJ '-’i-"l'=!II- I-I"?5I ‘II-I-‘mi-If I"-‘III 'IIII'"*I'mI‘I II IIIIIII BIEBSIIIE III IIIE BI’? II IIIIII III: "2.:-fir: It -Fit. are I1'i.j|!|I.'], ar|titlt"r Irart-tI riI est: fli{ilIit.;diH_=ti it 1;| . tIIi‘I'l§'.l5 or t']l|'11i1'1F.‘i"lH.'J |,,'.;[.|lt at leritt 5 l'II.|!1'll!'H‘.IIi-' IU['*l'j-|!'P flflilliillllg titliet pietiucts- USE Eye lIItlIiS nirlore i‘:*yE" oirrtineiits to .-ili-riw tlri: tryr ttrript to enter tire rrr Still-E ‘EH25TS: - . . . - - ~ . . 1li.tl-rr.irrirri‘..
- .111 .rii1err.i:~.rirle . -
Sierreri -rlsron. Iil.t'lTHIII_-I eririttiritt.itchinu-rerliiar.-. "'l- ti-e etrt-_ tarriititi Ha II stinietlilliii -Ii "Ii IhFt'i’E~ ‘I-III‘-‘II5I'III I" 'III"I'II3II' ‘III . I IIII . I _ I . . I F r '_I fl [Ii I:'I.:[-I-H
rteii-I ciranttes-sliiri F‘IEtIIrl[H‘lII'1I-I.[Ii'tllZ"|i'['.tlfI ".II|l.T~.I"|i'lI._,i ilisctriiitriit. i.ir..easetl senstiwnr tti Iii:-it IIH IIIIF F-i"1liIfil"5rI1I'“l'I'I_E=“I_I "IIII _. _ are' oi_ these
-- r-Ilr"t.tr.
- - " tir"=i\.= or 'i"i|'t.il‘Lt?1!
"l ritif It ii""ri-Ii
. liiiillt-it
_ ill l1II-IIIHIFILIIIIIIIIITIIIIIII . . III“ HIFIIIHIIIIIIIIIIHII -; -1"![i|F.t'H.fl WWII [WEI IIHIIIIIIIcrrer.
c=.-iiirie III IIIIIIIEI I -ITIoIIII:II;I:rIIIIiIIII.
. .r¥
{h51:I|:{j{a'l'_|l_lL|'| [if [Ill-I I_I£l|£ttPtI tittttrtirt t,I tiI|i.q P-ye ti|1_,._ If Iytflti HIP iii-ittfl IIIIIH Iflfilflti-I IH i]IiIli lllti FIE Jfl it ta i ‘y i ma? hr? mflmanem hm mp mm mm Hifimj PM m..._...1a||y Nu-,1‘, flu; ytryyqtpi .I 1-its FIII.II.5.iI"‘§i.-HE‘.'III ticitetitilr‘ tetitrlet Bi’?! ELI Htttfihtu I;Il;{:;f!‘I1:L-Ii“ ‘MP ii:-rrranitier tit-.ir -your rinrrtrir has Irreseiilitrrl l1"!- “II'Eljtl];-§[‘|r|.r| hptauw he [H gt}? nae |LI=I*3I'II IIIIII IIIE HEHIIIII III IIIIII II IJIEH Ernlka? t III ISFlIlE'l‘:1.5'II" -»tII-?l'.I'~.
. I~i1ani' Ill‘EUI»~IIE -!".'.llllI this . 'Tl1E'II=ltIEIil'IlI . tlti . net- liartriirtlI2=t1F»‘i»1fIIHr-‘Willi?
I TEIIir'l1iil
1- lit"
r esI‘! Edlpnnuq
'"l"“l’-{Ila-IEIII1 ‘ 3"‘ '5' ‘I955 "I" I EIIIifltir II" ' Iiiftii‘
“ ' “
_.r-H-_y-_._.;, gL!'tIl'f Eye |ii_ti."_ §.Ii5[;1;[_;t}t|_E"|'t'IlfiIEl.Itl].- IIJ H-H5115! IEEI . IE.-.5 - Ii! sweimc IE;i Evert‘ ~' n Teti Linn“ 'ourrinettr=rtr1e-aieielr maflnflfi H "H5 mug ‘S "III Hmlhflhiu Hm , |i'|'IIlIiII‘i' rinlrlttrlir tiiit irair. teittitre 'I.'IIiIi[II§I:II1'EII'_:.‘.II.Ii ricgiir rapid "ii"i'5;t'illlIEI;filPf5aE?éirr:§Et;fi|1i.|r|t£lmEr;é5h -ifllené _Mhm§_5“_BHm; ifipEm“_i DI {ht rrri-=i. iirrnrtliatia irter!ii'..rl rittr'rit=oii i . it rrcelrre i'"li"lIl7'"'5 . II‘ ‘I- I’ . -- * ' it ' ' .ll I o not ce other effects no.. -rsteri = .
atitii.r- _ Int:r‘;t1r*:tf.i.ir_-ritltrtrirt ilirrtitttfie, tttrtttile hteelilliitt. II‘I='r!- -5 "I1" 1* I-I-I3-"I'I"'I"IE“I II5‘ “I III-IIII'I'5*tIIE “IE9 ELIIIII III II I
Mr ‘I
I‘ r.tm.r
"“Ii-|-
Quest Diagnostics Incorporated r= rt -") -" ,1 4-
r._i' I H] H R€pOI'Il SIIEIIIUS . F1113]
III‘II*'III‘II’I’I"II*‘“3 I VASUDEVAN ALAVOOR i|. ____ ._ -- _ ___________________ _. _ — ---_|:_---_-_-_- ___________________ __ _ _ _._._.;-_-;=-:_-= -- - - _____ __-.-_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ . _ . _._=__ ';=;'-|.';' - _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ __;-=.-:;----- --___ _ _______
iPa*iE!!!_I_t!II9P.!??!P.I.9'.‘.. E$Pr<_=im<=11Iefereetierroo o o o o o o-0 , . . . . . -i€!.i.¢!!§tI!1f<>rmation _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . to to I I - - . - - HS5 10000 Ii iRequ1s1t1on: 0005676 i PATEL, KIRANCHANDRA H eDOB. 07,0-H1962 AGE: 47 _ THEPEARLAND CLINIC PA E/H /1 §G°“de1‘1 M ICo11ected: 02/22/2010 §E%II;IRBLI:;?)D‘§;§7§g4 8258 I =Ph°“@= 281-4116919 IRecei\/ed: 02/22/2010 /2033 cs1" - * I r IPa“@“‘ ID‘ NG EReported: 02/23/2010 /0019 csr I I .
-------------------------------- --------------------------------------------.------------------------ -- .......-.=..=.===_--.-------------------- -- -- .......__._...=.=.=-es;----------------------- - -_..____..-------------- ...................-_ Test Name In Range Out Of Range Reference Range Lab COMPREHENSIVE METABOLIC —-—-"' RGA PANEL W/EGFR _ ' l GLUCOSE 182 H 65—99 mg/dL
/I III :15: TI‘. Ii. r‘: f re t?;:- rt 2"; ;= fr? a —-— -—- — - -II-r-;__iI-iqII;Ii.| - - - -- _.
I I-- -_!'!.'rI J:__-| _:|_ .-. -- __ __ _i ___ ._ ,_._.
'..=-1*-.L'.=fl-'. i-'1' .I.I"1.=._.--=._~.:L-t"-s !I_:_'=I._.E=r"-e I .r=. '-I. .-;'; Izizi.-.5 -=I_t=_i i-- - - — .- .- --_ ___ _ .
=''-_-II t-1-.''.._lJ.
'|-' :1J. 5 T‘-FT?-'!
4. _.. Tr
; c _.. '_'r ant -5 ,_ '|_ I‘;
'__i --.' |'._.' ‘=5 ,_ .-'1 1-.-- .-.- ',.—t4 '.. ;
. _. I --: _I, - '-'1 _;;;_.__i , _..
_ 7--i 1-- -ii. - - - -.g._ -I- - - I.Ii 5, 1 'iI i- -- -q- .-'-i -_-. -_i_ i"i_ _ _.-._ -. -.- -. I i— .-. _- .:..Il | _ i-I a-.-|' ='i_! I !;- .';'. in I-.;' .:.'| ;--,-'- i-I _ .-.;I ;- i ||_4_ ;: | - -, | |":- ii... .g..._ -3-3,-3 :. .-_‘ -_ -,-, ' ll .,; 3,._.- __!- '-' ‘--" -'- " l " '—' * * '—- '- '\- -'- *-- -'--=--' - --'- '—-- =--'- I --‘ -' '-- I-'= "" "-.' -rt-.-t.: rte .2.-. -; t - - _-'r.;I..-'_ __ _r'-I E-'"l'_f-'-| -'|'- "I 'I- 1." 5-: TI. EL ‘ft 5:. I;'-'-'i ' I-I I!‘ ,-'*i 'I- -|._7 __ _.__ _ _-- _--._ _ _ ._.- _ _ _ I i-- .— _.--
Pe-I I ;
'-. - 1'3 - -I _.--:'!- I ';l- -II;'-'i 'l-'- Ii. ' "-- -- —-_i—i —-— -|i -.-I --- - - .
. _ .-_ - -- .... -- .-- .- —_ .
]:!-- '—'I:"I.'I
— I- .-rl ‘I'-i1'-:-I.'- |—IIJ.-.-i.
: it.5 21.1 ‘I J.5'1!1-a_I :-. 1 ... :1’: ;'—I:II_-J.I|J. .,i_;= ,_.,._ E :II._. _ ‘-1L d_E;d_._ E-' I ._ _-,_ Ii"! _|";.,____ ,,___i |q ._ 1:“ {H_.' JL _.-- :I L i___ r_;_ ; |-"Ii
___ I'|
fiunfireatinine ratio ie nee repeated when the Efifi and ereeeiniee values are within normal Iimite.
SODEUM tea 135 lea mmeifh ROTREEEIEE %.E E.5M5.3 mmeift CHLDREDE e Eylifi mmoifL i1¢II‘i.l¥ItBtIJt~I D.'IT'I.II}{II.'}Erl E5 || Z II ""-".r'*r.c‘r.It.,»'I' i'jP.E..'I.?II.I;.»It~‘I . I3} . =5 .-"Irrr. FIt'~7'.I§'II‘."E . IIIIIDTP-I 1'.» II? . "PI . E .. . 1'.:r. _'i at .» fies...
‘i.-'_-
a.Letrar.'ter rt . 3. ii . p.-‘are
GIIil’?>I~.FL-I§‘~I 3. E. II . I? qr-Icl?.'.. {Cele} Fi.1l.~§'I5i_II'“iII‘~3rIiI3§_iCl§IUIIiIi'~I EIETIO 7___'I'- -. I. .'IIF—2 .1 tt3..a._'I.t.l} EILIHUEIJ.-III TOTAL C5“.5.
tI§‘orI:-“i'-I‘-11?‘ 5 1. e.eMr.e mere;
a.aanr..-tree; . .:oeartnra.ee: E ‘Ir .j..¢
!—I-'—‘l.FI=-Ifie
'.'.*I‘
‘'.I'ZIIII
I'
' I CI F"-.Li} 'I-II-I‘
=-''.5II'Ir-‘-"=!
=a=—l;: ori;H.- I3‘ 5——' |_.;
LL- .|. ?
III)‘
HST \ 61 H . to so are ALT 104 H ewee are neeneteie e eeeeeee \\\~dJX' pea neeteen nreeee confine ‘flea r eaaareeee e eeernae [x0 '
anreaae nee—? ““‘ -II 'I| tI'.»
!'|."E i..-I’:- |-"I: i._ t-- re. ET! -i.1 nee-eeaaeeea r aeaaeteta H eoaa non eeeee-F" tteei 1.-I een—eeeeTtae nee—eeee?teH r aeaneee a eeeeeoer i .-‘1-.I-I eeneaeeereee nee eaaeetea eon II’ 5l§I{§II~Ir5I'r I.-I I-I{I1 TO"
5:-rt’ - CUI.I.I—{3E'IF D . $3 -‘~'..*i. .
r eaenteete a ran nee—eEncetae non aenceteg 1.1 {J1 _fr.y
PERFORMING SITE:
/I
RGA QUEST DIAGNOSTICS HOUSTON, 5850 ROGERDALE ROAD, HOUSTON. TX 7'7072- I 602 Laboratory Director: JOHN G. BUCK. MD. CLIA: 45D0660I 50
i LL- .I' II -‘II’
-"it
¢..r»..='-"I
- *t
’I.‘~"IIi/ ¢:“* - - I ~1-
I I X5’
[xvii II£aaI I
\ .--"""IIi
“"?I- R-y-5 i.
_l|'
CLIENT SERVICES: 800.669.6605 COLLECTED: 02/22/2010 PAGE 1 U ' Printed by Care36O AutoFIeceIve on O2f23.-"'10 at 08:01am.
Quest. iftteet Eitrtgtttretica. the aestrrriated Togo tutti eii aseeeiaieri Que-et iiieggttrn-ztitrs arteries are tire tt';adrrrttttt'§<.s oi‘ fittest Diaggrttrstircra. 3
= . - -. - . " ' ' - '= ' : ‘I I ' ' ' II‘ "| |1[lIZLII.‘iL'III‘-I‘-IIIL ‘Ii--ii-:et"i'IIEI.-.l'IE"- II"i.‘rf-II'J I I . J‘;
Quest Diagnostics Incorporated mCu\ ‘ N‘ ggugggg Report Status: Final
@ D“P"A"*“""C**“i‘i“:2% VASUDEVAN, ALAVOOR §'?'§{{§fiTi'fif5rma1i0n ‘""""""""""""""5' "'—' __§_§[]E¢i|'[|E|1 i]i'fE1}4E1ei;I'15}7|“W_ """""""""""""""""""" ""CIIEni Ini'0rmatI6_1i"""""""""""""" I 1.; ---------------------------—=----=-------- -----------------------------------------------------------------—-—-=1----~ - -- - -----------------------------—-—---- - ---------------------"=T==—---=--------------- -- " """""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""-==-----'------
1 : - - ~ ' - HS510000 ;Requ1s1t1on: 0005655 ; PATEL, KIRANCHANDRA ' DOB; ()7/()7/1962 AGE; 47 ' THE PEARLAND CLINIC PA EfH /1 .-\ _-\. |.nu-
=G@“d@1" M Collected: 02/11/2010 9804 BROADWAY ST .-1.-1. -\ i _Ph°“@1 281-4115919 i|Received: 02/11/2010 /20:31CST IPEARLANDJX 77584'8258 Patient ID1 NC‘ fRep0rted: 02/12/2010 /17:20 CST
..............................................................................................................._i==______________1 _---- ----------=---_-1__-1 __ _ _
COMMENTS: FASTING Test Name In Range Out Of Range Reference Range Lab MICROALBUMIN, RANDOM RGA URINE (W/O CREATININE)
* MICROALBUMIN 0.5 mg/dL Reference Range, Not established A
.1 I,-1 _ \ ‘- II " ' ' .-
The ADA defines abnormalities in albumin 1: 3 fj excretion as follows:
.' L;_ ~ . I -, HOE}
"54 \
P
‘F. rt}!
If Q?
Category Result (mcg/mg creatinine) n1 v
Normal <30 1% ' I L L ._ Microalbuminuria 30-299 ;'*fi‘ , \\ £z<%$f
z2
Clinical albuminuria > OR = 300 P1?” - .TfT# (J 1
The ADA recommends that at least two of three specimens collected within a 3P6 month period be “J
j._~,. ,. ; 0 '
abnormal before considering a patient to be within a diagnostic category.
- ':~—R:I-H5
I
"'' E)
LIPID PANEL CHOLESTEROL, TOTAL 235 H l25—200 mg/dL RGA HDL CHOLESTEROL 44 > OR = 40 mg/dL RGA TRIGLYCERIDES 190 H <l50 mg/dL RGA LDL—CHOLESTEROL 153 H <l30 mg/dL (calc) RGA
Desirable range <l00 mg/dL for patients with CHD or diabetes and <70 mg/dL for diabetic patients with known heart disease.
CHOL/HDLC RATIO 5.3 H < OR = 5.0 (calc) RGA COMPREHENSIVE METABOLIC RGA PANEL W/EGFR ."'1 GLUCOSE 123 I-1 65'-99 mg/dL --I-'
EZII
Fasting reference interval B L"-'=
UREA NITROGEN (BUN) II ~25 mg/dL ,1}- CREATININE 0.97 .1s~1.34 mg/dL ‘Ht F.-P: eGFR NON—AFR. AMERICAN >60 60 mL/min/l.73m2 I-\-| Cr." ‘fl’ -.-.-.-.
eGFR AFRICAN AMERICAN >60 60 mL/min/l.73m2 -Q;
fir:
BUN/CREATININE RATIO NOT APPLICABLE cs\/vc:>-1 MOO NZUZU (calc)
_-
L’ |;*~.|:
-{'_'I
1
.'|_
, .
\_
f
Bun/Creatinine ratio is not reported when the BUN 1. * . . . . . . 1 - '.__,b,’_r and creatinine values are within normal limits. 1 uJb%; q I‘-1
SODIUM 141 .5 POTASSIUM 5.1 3 ,,_}.. .- ’ -
/Aw .
t '1? s.s :m\
-.
fql
.
.|_|
CHLORIDE 104 1
'||‘_.
-— 1- ]_ 2--If
-_-
'|'f'| 'g'!g': l_'| I: ;'. 1-.;-. '|;I_- _L ,1 .-.-.
_
_"~.»
'-
i\|
A. {:11 1'|1e5
CARBON DIOXIDE 25 1 ,1 1 .- -. .-"i€| _ "If-H |,L____|: IL —-
|_-|'
F-I‘?
CALCIUM 9.9 1“15-, E5 1-11.-1: Z—i0.; mgHdi- y I nH= PROTEIN, TOTAL 8.0 , 1'fin[H.2-
-|' . —a.- _-J‘ 1”}!.fdL F * ALBUMIN 4.9 -Eyet’ . I?"rch.»-.1 -5.1 eyat L‘ .1-1.
L-L
"11..
-'a§= "1est5z~:.' -.-.-.
.|_|
CLIENT SERVICES: 800.669.6605 COLLECTED: 02/ 1 1/2010 PAGE 1 OF 2 Printed by Care36O Aut0Receive on 02117110 at OBtOOam.
Qttest. Qaesl i)iagnn:~;tic~s, E311: asseciated loge and all assaciaied Quest ifiisgamstics marks are the t1“asi:::1:ar§~;s 115‘ Quest Efiiagaiestics. HuesI3 H15?
Ones: Diegnnstics ineetnnreted Qtiefit Repnrt Status: Fine?
O no ii ,i)i*n1::1s1"i:."~.
VASUDENAN, AI..AVO0R
F54-' i--- .-.JI.TK'-- "F-I. ._ ..'_'.J-I.__.___ _._.__... _...'_'. _ _ . . _. ._. _____ ._i. _ _ _ _ _ . . _ . _ . _ _ _ . _ . . _ . .._. I| P} Eient__Iniif11fn1§1_ti11n____ _ _ _______________H '__EE¥EAF_IELEEE“'E!!......-_.-_-_- . . . T—'Specimen . infnrinntien _ | I |
_ . _-'--+
--}
Specimen: }1U43fi 133;... ?C¥i1::nt #1 3564900 vnsnmvnw. ALAVGGR Cnfiectetii U21’ Z. 1 32$ Ii} 3 PA']."EZ.. KZRAN'I.THA.?‘~€DRA BOB: fi'}'!l}7fi9fi2 AGH;:’=-1’? 5 Received: 02?} H2£".*1{} f2'[}:31 CST flenderz M iRe;::~0n.e=:.:E: il2fi2.~’2€1=}{} fI’F':2{}CHT Fatiexn 21'}: NU | i — — — — - P--'-“H _|i="-'-' '—' T '-\""'l"" '.
""""""""""""""""""""" —-
Tent Heme In Range But Of Range Ref erence Range Ln}:
.--.
ELOEULEE .2'=- . 1 .i—H.T gfdL icaicj -'-: L-
.- .--
ALHUEINEELGEHLIN AATIO :
|||. 1-
r"'\- ‘H.-"
‘I’ A| I‘ 1 {EAIEI ETLTRUETN. TOTAL .5 =""I _fi__:.|._ L5 I E mgfdL AAHALTNE EHOSFAATASE i_._.l_'-'_'.'LT‘-
J' L11.. '-'l'.'.'3' _i_ w IEFL AST Tfi H G- $r~e+A GIL I‘
ALT 124 H I‘-I ....
i:m1 m.e2 U _." I.
AEMOGLOETE AIC ETTA ERG
-I‘ .;_.-\.H_;. .| “E :\__]'__.-\.,|."' _.:_'q_ .-
HEHEGLOBIH A1: ?.5 H .:__ 5+} i_-'§._.-':_,,_'Z',_"j..£. ;;'a_-|.t-.:'
..-
Reference Range
1 1* -: = - : . - . ' -.
Ii.‘ _..,
I‘\E’-f'.sI_E""=_:|i~.=."..".'J1FJi__:_C.§ i-:"\-' . L1
1&5
-F -I
2':-.1-r 1;;-.1,-"II d=.;..' .-'" '2' = -"1:| MEAN PLAEMA GLUCOEE {_-._--LE...=..'-_-
CEO {IHCLUEE5 EIEFFELTI
E?.‘5'.§..OOI.l* =YI}9IZI[..Ii..- €lIO'i.‘-'Z‘~1T' 4.5 1 .,.- 1.
5.... . ,_.| .|.. .% ‘Thtnisarnififi.
1-‘ '-_' _.' -"—". "—" '-T‘ 'l _ A -=T.'l‘=- -;" .'*“- 1..-r" '| ' | -1;l'-\‘!"|'I='.!-| .-. I .
11. 1.! 15. 1.! ""‘. 1.
'....= T '
.[.. ""‘ .|""‘- 3 . T'
I‘-. I ’:t . =._-' :'l|| ._. __;"i-I _ ___ ___ .__. ,| |_ _, ._,-.
2| fa, . _; _.-._ r.., E. ‘..., ,1-._ .... ii -. .-1: -I . |' .'I T ;|-1 _-In I‘-.I-:-i I. . ; _: !-:—| : I.I.| -1: ' _.-' _ "r _1 ,1.' -"| : .
'-.__ ._..-
-. .-_| L. -..-‘ -_| -.- '-_-" '_-' ; L. '- -1 -I "1'; .r_ -..-‘ |- I.-1
:.: r..-:- ":-. '3="-.--.-'- "=5"- --1 |-" -
. - .. — | _51 ; J-.-.=1.‘s;+"'1 ;i. . =.- I. :___: _
MCI? ?9.E L |"'._.-a I .|._.! _ 2"‘; -F]'_ I r--| .-. _.., .-_ . -. I—, |-| _|| | .} -..
.;. .. .||.. -..., | _ :'| i__ _.5 _ Ii -I__ ] a ;'-.- = -_ _ . I PI
-I-.. .-.
.1 | .-. 5""; .- -1 ...=| ..-. . f. ‘T -'1 T1! I-— -- . -.
___-. ._..,, q. 1.
|
-..-‘ 1." + '-_-‘ 1: _! |_ |_ Ir |__.| ._|_r..-_-_:|.5--|.
l. .I '-_- .-. .|. --‘
..
REE l3.& 11.5“ -ll.F 51'} A-
"I ‘T '! --.. _r": .i-i. '_:'-il-1 .-'\—_'hl;g"\- ': 1-'I-_.-"Q .I'I'|I-‘:-
ELATELET COUNT .l. .' .1. .'..~u J11. .i-=i=-.-'=-.4-.;H'l.--=1?-.=|'=-.-ll-J .-. =".".{;. _.- "=1.-..',.,?
ABSOLUTE NEUTROEHILE BERG 31.; '-:3 €.'5'I_'.'.3T'3' T.'___.'3' III """ |—l ___ -.,.-E'I;;._'.:-,-' ;.;.:_| *~r.~'= ', r-
AESGLGTE LTHPHOCETEE I395 nanmla 1.'.'.'1 F ..-
I""‘:--. -1-. R.._n__n__
-I‘ ...: . . - .1,-. .1"; ,..- ...;
-_\_\___ _.. -.;_|
.. ,. ..
AESGLGTE HGNOCETEE J5 1.1 =.=' FEE _ .-' -_- '-_-‘ '-..-"r*"=."=:.="'-'-F.
..- 2- .' .i. '.- .-' =.-1'; i -., . F. '1 .1--.. I I :-I‘,-‘r 1..-I-I?-J";
ABSOLUTE EGEINOPEILE 55.1.1. I -|- -1-" '1- £1} use -..-" |'r.- l\..=
ABSOLUTE EAEUFHTLE .-"=77-.
-1 r-\- .-'
;_“| L-I A Gil‘\- CIZI£13 .-"-.. -3 TE i:~J_."' 1.1':]:____'
'\..-'2-1.-'|||n.-\.'~\..J'
NEUTAUEHTLE 53.1 j'.-".-
":- -:-
LYEPHGCTTES 31 i '5 .I"\. ,I"‘\|_ P-
MONOCYIEE L?-.i_r ch
EOEINGPHILE 5.21 1"-
._;__
EAEGEHTLE 1 ....-..-' A
PERFORMIH G SITE: I=‘{{I~A {;A§IF.5'['ET=[.*'.EI}?‘~E{1IS'J"E{.'S I-I{}ii5'['EI}?~i'. 5351} Rf.-HEEEZEHETJ.-’#.i..ii Hf}.-H}. E-E£TIL5STU?*-5. TI"-“I ??{}'.‘.."I- zen-1 |..;=:%1er.=nn-.tj-.-' III‘-"In".-;'£-L11‘: .5l'l'H:”‘-‘ ‘H. Ell! __F-1. M . C§..i="'-.2 -ifiililftftilififi
‘fr :
_.|"'
if “»..__,
Z
3
H-1. 3'! Q’ ,_
SEEK fl fl -|- ll
r
.- -J4‘
4
-|
;|'_| |..
E
rpnrat -'1 ed
S
<~mT$I1=e1e1S=$@~1*-in-M =i',}n1::;‘§.. -II}1'n'-;t Eltinggme-:1£A:s. fee nssneinten énetjt 11.11-A nil naainizzittfi {Eaten E}§1:;.;11n~;1i1:s I-Ei5H~"§€‘-'11 are the i1'eti11n1n1'ie1 1}=i"Q=1I1£?%% ¥'1iee1n1sA11.~1_ twee lmm:
un|:est|I 'agn-asucs
Pl'1yS1C1anS at Sugar LIQQR An aerate at s-a=_*.s»rnr1r.-e. !lt:'.lt?~.»l 14023 Seuthwest Freeway Sugar Lane, TX rr-we Teleahene: ear; 325»-Hftfil Fax: {I251} szsazrr Weesit.e: twnlr.sur;arereeknh3rslelar1s.erg
rat-1.1.» "12. ea-1 A.
Alatreer Vaseeesrarl El‘r‘iIl’l Glrstine Latte Apt E918 l--leesten. TX ?".f{li5€ {asserted te raatleatp
tI?ss=n* ltflr Erasrlrleualt
5 have rerzeareri 3rr'a,rr resent test resnlls- They; are as feilenlei
. ., ---.., _. .. -:-..- . . . |..-!-...-...- --...~.-:-- -. --
‘r’eur Kidney 5 I II '\I " i-'\|\. ? E
.. SE §”E'Sl_l§tS. I?’ll.;7.’i tel;-‘l'l;_.=*.:*;r.';-= -ll=’..I?=| “~."~..Ii..-*5 r~.>f..1te:l,-’ itrnr rziiti <3- .'-:'- __- .-""'‘:-l_--' I":-C L-I :3 I 1..I"I..I .-.-., .-l.-_|-I1 I.-.-5.-' _. . - "‘-.-l.-|-.- .-.-.:_,-, 4'2. - .- .-_ -._.
e _ __ __ é ___?‘-____|_ ._ I-_-. __.,é .-- -._Il_.-__ _ If II___ _____:__, _§_iF___i:__\: _:_ I? _.: ..__|._\:-+.|..H__,___.::_ ‘_..:-_,-._|__;.___..-I I;-.-ti .E..|,::_ .-_; _!-!_- '1--I-"-|'-"-..-'j_;,'.;' '3:.:|.-: "-;r"":I"',..I"';. 'T- '-
.'.'--'I..|._.-...-...-.
' ."I-'-I--"\-'- :-I-'r"| .-'-.I ‘i5.!'--{I-.'=-.=I'T."
..-- | ..
;..'..'.-"" I.|.
..I '!.-=-
|- I35-‘I-2"
' -:
_ -.-.- -.- -
.-
-E .- ._-.“"5- <1:
.-""-.-.- 5:31.‘ ==l.l§"%-l_.<.=._I:ll :::- xi '-. -C-.-l. . ,_. ,_. ....-'
-I‘
=ii_.31.:: !.f1r_§I.;-.§=:i"'5:’.-
=.<.§?="=..Il1E*--.r ;==Il~.-21~.'I--hf.» .- .-l.|-l.,_|_-|- .E-
I.-_-'-..-l-.l -.-,__.".____ \"'L\-l._-.-.-| l-|..._ |.-I-. .
!’£--l‘-_4€==1'.'-.I ‘l..’j"
, ._ I |-.__._- L"
.';_-:'
..r § F " -* ..
“t~..el.=l E.~I..<=..=l1.2i-la ::.-1 . ;...
.-. -.5=- _-ils . .:., -._ '. - -
Ia.-"-. :1 - :--"_
- - -5- -'-_':--:'__-=_ '| --. | -- . |-'-.'-
-- |-'- .'-l. =._
: I. _,=! ‘--. §__:":___F1;j_4-_ 11;.-E !_'.i5 *§ 1-__.-I -_..-'
1.
.-L.-
. ._.-"
5
- ';| '\- I"
-"..
.-'=..":'
5___-' :. I _ -.. ' ""'\--:
_--"'I= - 2 ‘TI’-!¥ ..-- -:3!‘I..-'-I -!'.i'-.
,
If‘?-“
-1| .-"._'-'5
| ,-
l---“ -
'- ' =
.-I“ I-'\-l. ‘._. -'
' 5
_-.-. - . _. _.. .M. ."I;fl": . h 1-. = . . ,..
q_.-l.-
~_. .¢1a._ ‘~..:_.I.1r :_-alas. .s =. l 5 II '- 'I- _. _.. ..._.. _..-.__;. = I"; -1-
.._ . | . .-._ --| ---. --- r-' : . . .. E. . .. - I ‘C .- .- . - A -"Ir. --- I" "' ‘Iv ‘i -- .- .--. -- .- -- . . ' ._..'| = 1' '- -- -':_ -' '=- "' t ‘I - ' I"; r‘ "'1! .. ___ ._ 'I_" "1!-."' "' -!L":I.-‘!- : - ':__:" '.? -:-!"' II --"I - *' '1 '%? 'l: '!- ' ;
I 5 TI = =1-1--1lI..~i§.'<=.la <F-- E‘. » I '\-. .. 5.:IA._I.=’€' l I lL§'§?:.*1Iet?§‘l i_:!.F:5’ =- | II - >:-- I-:1.-."* - ii 53 a-.asl-.. -..\l.= ; '~.§'!..~a !"1>-.»'!- G.--;>' !’=..-III-~ ~‘-»fi_.- $37’ -"L --
_ _. ...-_. =- .--.--- =- --.-. ._ -'-,- {.-' = -.. .I .
--_-1. .-.- .-.._ _.--. _'| 1-'; .-"_ I 3"" ."' '-.=g"';J II |""".'.'-:"‘-;"|""= "'1-""-I .-":"'€E;""TI‘.I":":-:-""‘-'
..\__ . .- .-..
$|,l.I .-l.- - %!:'Ij?'i1_I.|-.--.,_.,‘ -l._' '\..| -'.- _- ._.r. .-.
| ::-__: |_.,_. -l._. i.;'r.- I..$I-.t<..t ‘ I =..§ '-..-1'.-'lEi..§i__=-" "’ "I." M” -1*‘ 1.-...il-*=:.»".tl I .-»:fi..."=--... ._ ,|'\-. 'lI.'.--..
|..>!I§I.i' ‘\r~..r-. .;-:..rr<>E1 !<=‘:.?-.»I|--II-~~>I~
Yeur Liver Test results: ‘rellr lnrer lest results are as tallews ‘r'el.lr SEPT [a f_'l‘lel‘lllCEl| the lrrer :"ele.'-.l.~n?es when rt ls lnllal"rln'lecl er |n_|1:rectl rs Fe rear" E-GOT ltlre ether lnrer chernlsal related ta lluer rnjury or lnllalrrrrlalrrlrll is 33
Tr-er r..elr"lr"e|'|sen I arn else encleslng grelll nr'e'tr|eLls reslllts ‘reur SGPT was J"? ‘reur SGOT was EU
The lluer tests are alneut the sarne as last time
Yetlr Cheiesterel results: Here are 'l,I'Ul.ll' rnesl rer:enl l'll.llTlDEF'5 ‘retlr tetal chelesterr:-I ls 1150 “r’er-lr l--ll Lrl =ge=.:lr_l_l enelesterel ls .315: ‘rear LIJL llaacll elielesterel rs 113 Yellr trrgltrcerlrle value lanetrler fat ln '-,l-l'l' lllr"- all ls l='lll .
I - _. |-| I
I
_ ' L’
...___-.._ -. _-. -_: _-. --., _I-. 1.- -J‘: _;-, . -, .| :.- .-._-.- .,_ .-:-l..::_:_ - _--.._; '5 --. § .--. -." -5--: - .-I- ;; -'-l.:- I-'-- -|'-.-'-I HT I-_ '\'lI!'- - i'I-||'-'";'_‘-I ‘I |H Eff I‘-if -- 3"
: -...'! ...I..»??L-r:'.1§::.. . I‘ . at.'H3‘= *:.-i.“.~1.5 5=!tOtI..i=.f§ei{i “,II_..'§..I5 §..1l57;f*\.:-’¥'l..~1.r“;» "{?.'?1':-|.§§-!.§.1=- r...-:;tIf':-I Liiifiilfi *_JI..5'-!.+5 t'~Jt.r.Ill I.» \5{.¥=%7?E-‘E!-I.’5‘.‘.5'I5:jI "-*'~‘=flIi~..I $55-.' ':.»"UI 1, '| -.=- . -'-I- - .. . .-_ l.. ._..- .- .. ".-:'-'-
-. .. = 1"-1- : -1 - -.= -- -.1 -- - .. 1--.
-. .-- -"=-“- - --4-.-.-¥::--r'.---:".... ---
I-1'; Z’:-i ‘I 5'¢._;'3__._ -.r-:
._ =.j;{__Ff_il_.§ .-I-:---' -.-‘ -"-".I.:-'
.,__.-I. :'._:="-‘.'_;.'1'_~_»;-._'_]'yrt_,!I: *._=;- -;_i --
'- "I L.-‘:.,__I I -, .-'
-.-'-"'-.-"--
1__-L I;_Ii'5_.i‘-‘;-I_I;.;l -'--'-'-
1.}! t.',',-t'.I".»:_ 1-I-r:-I -..:: : lI.':? ‘-n.’r.'§I.t- I -'1 ll-..I. .-"-t-
. ~_.3-_.r§' L; {.51 § '.,-..: =~_.| '--"I:-r..;l-5-1 '..-'.,- ...,-. "
-1-> ,- .- Fl.
-' - '..'
l l'lElI.lE! lnnllleed same anal nl_lml;lar"s fer yell. Ynur tnlal chelesterel shellirl be under 2051 ‘rear HDL lzll.-rlr.-sten;-.|| snnllla lire {greater than as Ylillr LDl_ l.rlnlester'r;=l snelllcl be antler 'llJlIl ‘feel lr1gl5rcer'ldes rsla:-l_lr~;l lf.‘*r_= lll'l"_lEJl' lffllll.
Tl l==_-:-se l"lllrrIll»;_-:s are net l.I.'l'lat they slrelllrl he Trle r;=.lrrent rlese at year nredleatlen ls net delng a geed -._r-~<.:-1.rgl"I let"; l l.'.-'el_|lrl lll<.e le lrrtrease l,r~:.lLlr rluse Please str.'l|;1 'l,"UL!I current pill. arlr:l start the new ene that I l'l.nrr-=. sent tn ylilllr" |:1n;=.lI'lrlar;l,,=
'1-5’
1.-ere - I
Daabeses ” =“--
resuitsz -. ..
:ne...t
.- .
ir.§i'!eEr¥.*€~.€-
.
tr.-.I..Ii?r£§rr; I '-
tests. - _ as . - "t. ...
“r'~:;e.a-- trr.1rn-trerra-arr - - I.=. I -
;.-l. -l! -l. .-' -l. '- . ' .-""' I" 'l- . ‘I |-i__. . . . .- . !_..|_\_ _,_‘|. .-. i'__‘.,_:
-': -1-.-ur"; ==;'1-5.w;;1.1;.. i-'--'~,“,-1;.-.!'-, 1 :
-: ..’>‘!,.: r“I’..' *:n*-:1-Ire 1:::- Ir.‘ 1.3 ~. I“ I 'r‘lr.'.'- '-”- 'r"~'f‘ II r -I‘
“'- "-..- i.=I 1:1. :- '~.-=-. I-5 :l=..»- . is .1,..._.Fl__.:-;_71‘.'._,,_~h_~._J sh.
-..j-: l- :5 .-._,- §'§_i§I...§=..I==f3-‘.‘:T."-_.§1I521I I =:.'§'.‘."I’?»L .EH5 -c-' I‘-'5 ‘-.-'- “frJr.".-.-" "-_.-I-Ii.___ .I'\I .-""1."-l. , .|;. 51'. I fi-l.-' .-. .- I-I; ._. _| _I|liqr :""'|-'l|-l.-|:- .- |.I-.-I-I-I -I—.1- .-.-__ !'_“\--|.-r "'l-C . -.-.-_ ".-.- ___-=.-_. . .-.-C .-I-I
i i— — i i
diaoetee or olooo oreaaure“; ia 5.4. For ooiooaoaori, I are irioiooirig your previous reeulta; Your herriogiooio P-do was 6-6 Your urioe iriioroaiiiroroiri was 6.8.
oeri~ier'orf.1=g'Jrr.'ri'ao ..-firi rr. r e *-re;'.rru‘:r;i iriao ri. io oo. ’r€oeiii o or H-"re §.jriEii?:i1' “~r’~rfl "roe aroooor. or oroitero rrrrrr:r"r;raror.ri"ruoi re 1rr.1ror rrrioe re éeee Errao iaai oroe. Trier e rgoori orarrer arrri ab.oraa- -;.-5- ,,-:2. ;,='-.-1_,., ..-,._1..=-H1, .__: _,.1 . ,_,_ . ._ ,__., ;-_,._ . 1,4.‘ . . _,;r_.._ r.€*-r,-£5 2? =:_-; §;'Jr;1:§‘~,;' riifvrfir-.'.3 15,- ~_,;E?iF! :::;! 1"§'i».t:}r -if_Fr_-,1" 1] L:'3r;_Ii§'E=f,§ K_.IEfiri_3;§’
Your Thyroid resuits: I am iooiuciing your aotua! ourrioers: Your TSH {fa roeaaure of how aotive your ihyroro io -- a high number rneaos it is LESS aotiue} J5 4.4%? For ooirioerioori. E are aieo iooludirig your oreuioue iraiuee Your TS!-E was -11.296
‘four TEESH ia rirgo. wlwioh rrrearra that you do rrot have enough thyroid horrriooe in your ooclgr
Wiieri you oorrie for your aoooiotrrieot. i want io taii-i about starting a low diee of thyroid rneororrie.
i airi happy to aooreea any oueatroria or oorroeroe you might have about trreae reaoita-
Sincerely,
Troy Fiesinger MD
I | | ilIliil.lEi 5T{lFliliEi% TTFE: iieirigereter | |
i i l
h
$5! -zrfiislg '
'
-|i|i|i|i|i|i|i|iiI|||IlIlIr l *"I
"- Bans:‘f -I-lllllll |||| rim--—
EJ- I fig cfl}-_'_ Ina. '—'
g__ w FF ., rm? __. ‘i corn |-=.
oi-1=*r""":_u,: ‘-
'"“"""""—' '
-
'
oiorrtrvrerlsu H2
Btfl-425 oepteo '
"“"' i '__I' -|i|i|i|i|i|i|i|iiI|||IlIlIr ' '
lit at r.
due
_,",",|,|""" __ |i|i|i|i|i|r.|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|I|IlIlI r\-'-'-'\-
-i-iiivi _
I
-. ' e lIIlI%\
mg
|i|i|i|i|i|i|ili|III|i|i|I"i|I|I|I
HoerivF‘ '
ll|'l|'ll|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|'l|' In-r
Peori szp Lu |.-i.-i.-i.-|-i.-n- J|l|l|l|l|'Il|I|'\|\'I |.-i.-rrn-|-rr
1
llI' ri.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-.-|-——- HIM
' Ivlr '
ay..
IIIII'IIIIIIIIII_II-Ii.‘
'
1|- 'scos.servdo018 Payment andmontshs
RHE~l lri fli =Hlltl lilifi
Pt- tilt fltE
v:Ir‘.fi -El 1'11’:-
case
clinicl
El 1.|.TI 3"-1 E II3.
E1 TBtesfatspat ng ent
H"-I U3
iesrrs
easeesorHH
esari
isrrise iaraifl i?-E2 HHBFS PIE are
aR1;togrk
E: ETE5HTHEB?
TH ‘El-
"iE
i macr srer -sgerinrvrs
I
areso
miortr-lt remr oracrotcepted
d
ry
lL'retr'n"sutc‘"*.*it
TB test A1c checks:JustnEwaay.ve
P
'fl'l'|' riii S/Phi"
LU
DERI]. fiilfii flii fi tl errutras -E11s3131?HE?
eecf, lEFHEST
.iJl31’ifis Hi}
1HHGFTiiTT} 1
TX ND
mm Fiacrsct
E rtr ::i
Aveverailabley in! d Just
vvaik
lunar:-i.\
.-.J LLICCCD
-.-.-. ‘Eh
*"sisurance tree
at Most HG oFtate sruiiiarenreanrsuts
ce d
20
Ollfi_4_
-i‘
—‘- <'~.| r~—~. _ 1::
A
SUGA
.-1 _'--.. I“-~ 'tfi'tSli 3|‘-‘IE1EiPH32.l:i fi 1.i5iTr5il‘il vi.-sue Fthfifi liasoareefi c-iesreoe itEEH.
,_,_, -.-.».-
rtfll Fresh itl ialtfi i~'-rt’'l-li'.Ikili- .i |;':-‘Tr
CRli'* . ---.~. : '-i -1 i-=1 or
‘-'-; -"~.
VS/oharmaw‘ ::u'i.i' vb. #7459 Pill 231.242-2890 if Tfiil iihlih fliiii’ iiii'E$Tiiil'i5 hiillilii Tliilli i*riEiiElIIii'i'li}iti.
sueontano,tx so-,i,irr,i _v;v 3_1]r}|m 1; as BB Ev an niniiczflfl B w_,fiE_,Em 4 Pi_E ass coarser TE tilt Pit iiii kiihtlltiiz rr4rs iii"? iiiriliioriE'i.lii.l5l res errirro, sis.
HE,H=.|_,. itrirrcriotas P ertr iefiinh Trflflrayh"
Pit: 1Eii.iE.1ii'l-'3-iiiii " 'TL gggfigaoreest s.ssrer are eases PLACE 1 tllifi? lftlifi B672-l HES hi BEBTEME
This is e EGLURLESS DRTEPS. _ Lift?ih|’QUli'RUS?~ Uli-‘l'¥Tl'¥.l—'tiLl'*i'ii{'i 3ULt]T1!]¥ll - i|ev~Tiiil%~eh-prosti ilflltlliviflfii HR!-WEB l‘lihl'rll£{3}: lteieten _ USES: Latariuprost is used to treat high pressure inside the eve due to glaricoma {open angle tvpe} er ether eve diseases le.g.. ocular hvpertensionl. It is similar to a natural clieriiical in the borlv lprosteglandinl and works lziv regulatiee the how of tteiri rvithiri the eve which resuirs irr tower pressure. l..riwering high pressrire insitle the eve helps to prevent blindness. HOW TU USE: ‘ itpplv this nediratiori in the affected evelsl usuallv once dailv in the evening, or as directed bv vour doctor. Do not use this medication more : lrequentlv than prescribed: using more can decrease effectiveness. To applv eve drops, wash vour hands first. To avoid contamination, do not ‘I r.orich the trapper tip or let it touch vour eve or anv other surface. The preservative in this product mav be absorbed bv contact lenses. If vou wear crintact lenses, remove them before using this medication and keep them out of vour eves for at least 15 minutes after applving latanoprost. Tilt viiiir head Jack, look upward and pull down the lower evelid to make a pouch. Hold the dropper rlirectlv over vour eve and applv the prescribed . t‘itriTiilEl of drops. Look downward and geiitlv close vour eve for 1 tu 2 minutes. Place one iinger at the inside corner of vour eve near the nose and 6? _ app v gent e pressure. This will prevent the medication from draining out. Trv not to blink and do not rub vour eve. Do not rinse the dropper. Hepace the dropper cap after each use. Use this medication regularlv in order to get the most benefit from it. Remember to use it at the same time eacii tlav. it is important to continue using latanoprost even if vou feel well. lvlost people with glaucoma or high pressure in the eve do not feel sick. If vou are using another kind of eve medication le.g.. drops or ointmentsl. wait at least 5 minutes before spplving other products. Use eve drops before eve ointments to allow the eve drops to enter the eve. SIDE EFFECTS: Blurred vision, burninglstinginglitchinglrediress of the eve, feeling as if something is in the eve, changes in evelash numberlcolorllengthlthickness, evelid changeslskin darkening, drv eve, lid crustingldiscomfort, increased sensitivitv to light, flu-like svmptoms, or muscleljoint pain mav occur. If - anv of these effects persist or worsen, notifv vour doctor or pharmacist promptlv. This medication mav slowlv {over months to vearsl cause brown discoloration of the colored portion of the eve lirisl. if vou are using latanoprost in onlv one eve, onlv that iris mav change color. This color change inev he perinanent br.it the long-term effects are uncertain. ltlotifv vour doctor if this occurs and schedule regular eve errarns to monitor it. llerirerriber that vour doctor has prescribed this medication because he or she has judged that the benefit to vou is greater than the risk of side effects. lvlanv people using this medication do not have serious side effects. Tell vour doctor immediatelv if anv of these unlikelv but serious side Z12 eilects occur: eve pain, suspected eve intention lunusual redness or swelling of evesl. chest pain. Tell vour doctor immediatelv if anv of these r_-
"c '=-.
lrighlv uri ikelv but verv serious side effects occur: rapid vision changes le.g., loss of visionl. it serious allergic reaction to this drug is unlikelv, but ‘l-|_
st:
seek immediate medical attention if it occurs. Svmptoms of a serious allergic reaction include: rash, severe itchinglswelling lespeciallv of the L:
'.-».
laceitrrrigueltlrroatl, dizziness, trouble breathing. This is not a complete list of possible side effects. If vou notice other effects not listed above, Er
E
-=1. it,’ -3.1 ‘Ii
Continued on reverse side. -.
'\—i_ ~I.'- =3‘. "\-.
I
‘BEBE S'ltlfiilliliE TTPE: Fest iidover
i I tr f-a-n 1;;-a IIIIIIIIIIIIF 1|nrrriarrrrri 1|nrrriarrrrri - IIIIIIIilH#iHihH=I an-nrrrrrrrrrtiii-I-ill-'-'-' _._...............-....-,..-
l] >'
CJ
iiti :L
u
Ill
nu; 1|nrrrrrrriarI"-=3‘ I HlhW
1inrrriarriari
$15.03
‘In?
irScrpts:fi 1inrrriarriari
ceptecl
as I“.
IIIIIIl|U\\IllliiI||lII
ii 010518007
IIIIIIl|U\\IllliiI||lII
I:i IIIIIIl|U\\IllliiI||lII IIIIIIl|U\\IllliiI||lII qflflflpplllllilh
Elli l oavr
iii’fiiilli S-3
H
if Illllflllilfllil--'¥*“ fifi
: ca. ZIEEEEIII Ba Rx: IIIIIIIilH#iHihH=I _d_uuua“~n-nmF:::
"sssrv_o-r is-so -
iPoRBnMESEB.
II 6 IIIIIIi\\Fi\\Fi\\lII..III ,,,1_,._,aaaaaaaaaaaa=aL1 111-111-1___JJJJJ4JnAAAL ::n nu1Ir1111-r--——l if ETLH Elil i-'li 3E ‘ePavcos.r rer t doore
and r ronths
Ifli
ric.com
Eh l2 v:ilBB Ehi lI.l‘ri‘lE?i! li l
IIII spafateerr 51-
SR:HHfiBEB
TE serastrvng
tail lie. HEW
IE5 IEEH HHHH.
2|!- an nnmat utec
n
ia_q
.._
Most acnsuate
mmed iirareance
ll s rp.:h-arsimzsaecyr as Pa snoce eldrclenv'attite oaccept esd't.
TB testing* A10 checks:inJustday.walEverky I""
RH c na
<1:firms m.
clini minute
EL}
lEFrr:l'§i]fl T-ireaszseczeosas e=v - - =v+
FTiTHE?
Aveverailabyle in!
Just walk
hm
da
,_
I'-
_ .J :LJ B- BE TWlBi‘'iIl-IlhiB.lT.£H'l :e1risa=esvs-‘I25 -o TiiHE’l F'nd aearatior me RGSU’tS > ALVASVDORUDEVA7TXNCT,P5P0l8CASTLE340240 0l 007-EDUB:A927Ph:HB32.LBAN2D,44- ieiE£n.tcrq_Fa1sti§e'Fertara HIE: Fsch TP:1-id-i1IL*i"H.=l‘.'
"'*— [=; Pkv In‘ -
CID ' E; ‘T I"-
| 1-
U,iit t-i H»
!'H
1 ,- _. 1. ,1 . ,. ~
!' I 3.! '-__."| "it I-'-T’: E-_.i""'-".i':*"'-I |'-
V$v'pharrvrac'v IF ‘i’lJI.l I-IJWE ililllll l1LIESTIl]l'ilS l!lElI]UT ‘TUIJFI llllEl]llI.I5iTlEll'iI.
E-cniot-t no #1455 Pri; Z0l.242-2000 EUSHHLR i'i1',g
we-i=vr-iii vasuoEvriiv,rrtirvooit sroz crisrtrrorro or
lt]ll5r2l]li1 Pitt“ if-‘mil ‘|",l“¢,;':II.,P“|l,f|l,'“j1-l°‘=‘*l= PEAFMHUI H mgmmn T|;;ifi|:l'':.?Tnor THEllillllJll FIESIHGEH B '9‘ Fri. E=ii;i‘.I!-fl-it-ls;-‘til '
_ lIi%|ill}vlEP|Hl0E 4 no TABLET Tl3'il{E I TABLET Bl’ lv1l]LlTH TWICE ill [lll‘l'
This is a LIGHT BLUE, BOUND-she ed TABLET imprinted with B 3 on the front and T2 EB on the baclr. GLIMEPIHIDE - UHAL - tglve-MEFIJ-it-idel E0l'vlllrl0lll BRAND lillllvlElSl: ' ritmervl USES
__ Glimepiride is used with a proper diet and erercise program to control high blood sugar in people with tvpe 2 diabetes. lt mav also be used with other diabetes merlications. Controlling high blood sugar helps prevent kidnev damage, blindness, nerve problems, loss of limbs, and serual or function problems. Proper control of diabetes mav also lessen vour risk of a heart attack or stroke. Glimopiride belongs to the class of drugs known as sulforrvlureas. lt lowers blood sugar bv causing the release of vour bodv's natural insulin. t Hflllll‘ Tl] USE:
Bead the Patient information leaflet if available from vour pharmacist before vou start taking glimepiride and each time vou get a refill. lf vou have anv rrriestions, ask vour doctor or pharmacist. Take this medication bv mouth with breakfast or the first main meal of the rlav, as directed hv vour doctor, usuallv once dailv. The dosage is based on vour medical condition and response to treatment. Use this medication regularlv to get the most ' benefit from it. To help vou remember, take it at the same time each dav. To reduce vour risk of side effects, vour doctor mav direct vou to start this‘ irierlit.ai.ion at a iuw dose and graiiualiv increase vour dose. Follow vour doctor's instructions carefullv. If vou are alreadv taking another j‘ r anti-diabetic drug lsuch as chlorpropamidel, follow vour doctor's directions carefullv for stopping the old drug and starting glimepiride. Eotesevelam Tl can rlecrease the absorption of glimepiride. If vou are taking colesevelam, take glimepiride at least 4 hours before taking colesevelam, Tell vour doctor if vour conrlition rloes not improve or if it worsens lvour blood sugar levels are too high or too lowl. Sll}E EFFECTS: Nausea and upset stomach mav occur. ll either of these effects persists or worsens, tell vour doctor or pharmacist promptlv. Hemember that vour “ doctor has prescribed this medication because he or she has judged that the benefit to vou is greater than the risk of side effects. ll-lanv people using this medication do not have serious side effects. Tell vour doctor right awav if vou have anv serious side effects, including: vellowing eveslskin, stomaclir'ahdominel pain, dark urine, unusual tirednesslweakness, easv bleedinglbruising, signs of infection lsuch as fever, persistent sore throatl, mentallmood changes, unusuat.'sudden weight gain, seizures. This medication can cause low blood sugar lhvpoglvcemial. This mav occur if vou do not consume enough calories from food or if vou do unusuallv heavv errercise. Svmptoms of low blood sugar include sudden sweating, shaking, fast heartbeat, hunger, blurred vision, dizziness, or tingling handslfeet. It is a good habit to carrv glucose tablets or gel to treat low blood sugar. If vou don't have these reliable forms of glucose, rapidlv raise vour blood sugar bv eating a guick source of sugar such as table _ sugar, honev, or cendv, or drink fruit juice or non-diet soda. Tell vour doctor immediatelv about the reaction and the use of this product. To help \r -niil
prevent low blood sugar, eat meals on e regular schedule, and do not skip meals. Check with vour doctor or pharmacist to find out what vou E1 n. [rm
shorild do if vou miss a meal. Svmptoms of high blood sugar lhvperglvcemial include thirst, increased urination, confusion, drowsiness, flushing. ‘H I‘ .
rapid breathing, and fruitv breath odor. If these svmptoms occur, tell vour doctor immediatelv. Your medication dosage mav need to be increased. -:.r
e
it verv serious allergic reaction to this drug is rare. However, get medical help right awav if vou notice anv svmptoms of a serious allergic reaction, -n.
4. '-T.“ -fir-
' 11
Continued on reverse side.
e
\- .. ,
Bfltlfi STUBABE i‘iFE Fast hiliover
{Iii
H?“
D“‘==t :- 1..
CD cw -_-'
ii-i IZ1
i
pts
__i_i—i
vether
ll, 00004 aton r"h-r-r-iei-I
-.— a
i-
take to
i
.-co - titlt to "-=4:
E
'—'
3
Ii
as ’.;?viEF .'i""i
. 11'
.i ,i -4- .‘ "‘:
_ __1_i-— i m
.IlI. iii
ShiIffiiiri
tit 00
0547965
HIT
oncat
betmanageter
s0ymptoms
th vour wrrgi
tin
orrs tarrv ruest
how be
f
of can
e
ReadyF it-i- hes PROMISED iii ii
ii.-:- _:_:--i
to camed adrust CUES rriaricavt
ps has
n
iii-
2890 ii-j
li Edi EH-i33’fl= he you
_i..i--— for you msportant to onrect cel
rnrno ary dto ease
30
iltv vour affect
fflli li i l il lflfi
28-1 Pii Flftiil or DA‘!
rnegu yourcon vourhodv t t“rst ctt
howorr
routisu
hereto sclare
EH GRH
to eoch
weeks evenortclaakeys
aides 0at til oar F’effects aegatv dprov
tand ori.
oos EiTH ifEil‘a" 35
itsnvis
lESlG likehwoul armacidst twhy reasons
feven for trrie all i:I side ca
Newflrg bedpranesscr ng anrri
I
ct 2E5MC QhB severa at0 tn sme
z med newyour of Themportance Centageer 014 I
arrnacy
(Illlil taeoess ForTREANUR 63 today.you to wispeak
t.h Phst urarmac
stance
lfill’ iTiliHfitiBtlET Your p the Tak cmed r recl efntfeenrctled tt ng yourheath Some
onecat amav ke Btopp ophvs
4?“: i Tilti
Ei about atil yo meyour As potavoent E3555 Mess 1-_ Theraree th msedc
>: Qiificloit rhset _I—-.
EL-fii ili
roze ALAVUUR
VASUUEVANztiiFsEoAcroHsriLsoAriNtoOi ozzior o ozriiaszrieGTHBLET
HTmi
LEVUTHYH Thril lf fl TH EtEBB Prsclir 26TP 43autnr PATlENi PR i_"iiPTiON inn the BbGaH-oHD.-i sires Plr 231 242 zoso IF YOU HAVE sov oussrroas iisour YULIB iuroirsi roe '1" it-its i'
.._ -..
WW W5 mm iil§i%i€TLEiilfiBr%ifl£fluuUH reset rive or irseroaoo ’|?$ddv , rnrarroa riesinoeFeLEA5% EQ“hiTe£Ig?ni:Hfi;JPiiiki1:I!fiEii?aPh ro re sszziio trier T“i"'f I > l.Eli€]TZ-IYHUXINE 25 MUG TABLET Tall? l TABLE? BY ?rl'l[lUTH Elrlliifl’ Edi’ FUR TI~i‘r'iiBII]
This is an flliiiiltlfii BBi[llilG shaped TABLET rrriprrrrted with til on the front and L -'1 on the haclr LE‘ll‘l]THYHD"il|lilE ORAL (lee voe thye Fl0)l oenl COMMUN BRAND NAMEIS} Levothroid ievosvi Svnthroid Urrithrord WARNING
This medication should not be used for weight loss Iilermai doses of this roedrcatioe will not work for weight loss, sod large doses of this medication roav cause serious possihlv fatal side effects especiailv when token with diet pills £3‘ USES: "'5].} Levothvroirine is used to treat an underactive thvroid lhvpothvroidisml It replaces or provides more thvroid hormone which is normallv produced I11 bv the thvroid gland Low thvroid hormone levels can occur naturallv or when the thvroid gland is lTl}LllE![I bv radiat onlmedications or removed hv kI .:_|";|surgerv. Having enough thvroid hormone s important for maintaining normal mental and phvsical activitv ln children, having enough thvroid hormone is important for normal mental and phvsical development This medication is also used to treat other tvpes of thvroid disorders lsuch as ‘F EL -|_
i-_~. certain tvpes of goiters thvroid cancer] This medication should not be used to treat infertilitv unless it is caused bv low thvroid hormone levels -E HOW T0 USE -Take this medication bv moutl" as £ill’Ef‘lEEi bv vour doctor usuallv once dailv on an emptv stomach 3E] minutes to l hour before breakfast Take this medication with a full glass of water unless vour doctor directs vou otherwise If vou are taking the capsule form of this medication, swallow it whole. [lo not split crush or chew People who cannot swallow the capsule wl"ole {such as infants or small childrenl should use the tablet form of the medication For infants or children who cannot swallow whole tablets, crush the tablet and moi in l to 2 teaspoons I5 to ll] millilitersl of water and give using a spoon or dropper immediatelv [lo not prepare a supplv in advance or miir the tablet in sov infant formula Consult vour ._._ pharmacist for more information Dosage is based on vour age weight medical condition, laboratorv test results and response to treatment Use -
this medication regularlv in order to get the most beneft from it To help vou remember take it at the same time each dav Do not stop taking this -E medication without first consulting with vour doctor Thvroid replacement treatment is usuallv taken for life There are different brands of L-‘T, levothvroinne available llo not change brands without first consulting vour doctor or pharmacist Certain medications lcholestvramine, colestipol colesevelam antacids, sucralfate, simethicone iron. sodium polvstvrene sulfonate calcium supplements orlistatl can decrease the amount of Q thvroid hormone that is absorbed hv vour bodv If vou are taking anv of these drugs, separate them from this medication bv at least il hours Svmptoms of low thvroid hormone levels include tiredness, muscle aches constipation drv skin, weight gain, slow heartbeat or sensitivitv to cold .157. Tell vour doctor if vour condition worsens or persists after several weeks of taking this medication SIDE EFFECTS Hair loss mav occur during the first few months of treatment This effect is usuallv temporarv as vour bodv adjusts to this medication If this effect .? persists or worsens, tell vour doctor or pharmacist promptlv Flemember that vour doctor has prescribed this medication because he or she has ‘.‘_i_ judged that th benefit to vou is greater than the risk of side effects lvlanv people using this medication do not have serious side effects Tell vour gt doctor immediatelv if anv of these unlikelv but serious effects of high thvroid hormone levels occur increased sweating sensitivitv to heat ‘sir’
{Zoritiriued on reverse side
|aeua sroaaar TYPE: End ilap l | | I a.u.u.|.|
Q
‘___ i'
.u.u.-i.-i.-rn-|-n-|-|-|—l-I-I-I-I-I-I .,_u.|.|.|.|.|.|.|.-i.-i.-u.-rrru-rru-r ise asvr {iii e is er l££& if Eaas: l"'i 4 EB Eifi i ri i i
$1
-|-n-rr the eveach '|r|'|'|'r
- iT.‘2flfi-L3i'-1}‘?!
'||
u,-i.-n-r
'at'HCe wth trrg yeer
accusroivieri ill‘
De e flirt
ath rrrllrllll
IHearty? rtesyrnpteres THEEEi
. ii
,,,,,,,,,............... D54 PBUTWSEI} .,_u.u.|.|.u|-|-rn-|-:1!-1'!-.
W
take feryea tepertaet Ii“-
Bil fifi haserr 1;
bethe nrpayeu
ry atrearg teweeks
ereven
t
asir eerwtishtieet heyear Ii“-
frat affect
Eh Dtty:3D as EliiiEH3 ilfi -M.i! F=i
cendt days
ed. arage ¥"l |,u.|.—-
'|r|'|'|'r
vey rrthe
ate
Ii“-
flfifliflflflfl
Gh:RHeEr eerie gat '|'|'|'|\'|'|'
tswhy
ea ernns
1
ete eat trafer
iadieed
yeur eerfuystte
like harmweeTd
acist
Ii“-
gig Fie'. Sppy. if yeer ven 3
COUNSELDrug IiEES i ti i aest New -‘.51 ere asrt
'rrH'l
tie
‘t ef Pease canaricaefsafeeeycttmes
mi
-v.3-'.‘>
"r|'|'|'r
the medc g ‘an howte erect erien cie prev and r ed‘eat‘eri *l*H'|'|'|
ate rreraay eranyt scese eirPharasdeniruest
Ii“-
reed newyeur Therepertar e ef
1;
efridfeer!ct
towiyou
to day speak
th
3
itffifi Pesoarnae;atseeaera a, J’-i fii fiisfiasf.r
llllll l l
it the err rrig redeat erheat
2014 Li arts as:-rsT113111?
BE ifiMG FER DR‘! EMEHT l iB? iHi: PHE.
'eLE?
i ]¥.iTfi Lll-'i:l :']-1'5z-!§1‘i ‘Year p "Ta he ye tSenr
a
eatens reed kee rite t take
rmnay Strreep pihys‘c
CentMessearge
H'-i
everee the rTher sare r 'reri'e F ‘F 3 about potavelentd atassaeee.
yeriliker yeur
areseen ear#1459FriCV5/pharmacy
I-IN HH
i i’-iS Eli3-Ill}! Fit:E325 LHi}. resr".i i 's:r*ears es rtsNDD;rze-i iae-TsHTHE?tPrEAHDH-i schr: H F':.i:» LTl'i | _ Q
F%e.T1EhtT i='FiES€3RtPTi{}t~t tNF£'}i*ia*i,aTi£3~t\i 4 #7459 Pi: 281-242-2890 rr ran save ear eursriaas aeasr rave srrorcariea, i‘iiiiL““° T‘ WWW-as-we VASUDEW-\N,ALAVDDR 3402 crisrtr Poivo or riiir-ears ’ - ii-iiiiiii§§iifii§“§gig§i|M%§§i§Ph B i5 r
PEAHLAND, rx 775840000 ';Zi:,i;F'yiRHi THEAHGH HEEHGEF‘ i Ph;832.244-1927 "
‘Lu-li."¢1-Ii\.|-1.1 -r1-r bl§FlD|¥EQLT:C|§lL 10 MG TABLET TAKE l TABLET BY MDUTH EVERY DAY FOR HlGH BLUUD PRESSURE
; This is a WHITE ROUND-shakled TABLET imprinted with TU on the front LISINOPRIL ORAL-llyse-I -oh-pril) .. COMMON BRAND NAMElSl: ‘ Prinivil Zestril g WARNING _'=§ ; This drug can cause serious {possibly fatall harm to an unborn baby if used during pregnancy. Therefore, it is important to prevent pregnancy while _.l_
* taking this medication. Consult your doctor for more details and to discuss the use of reliable forms of birth control while taking this medication. If ri- E you are planning pregnancy, become pregnant, or think you may be pregnant, contact your doctor immediately. “ USES 4 Lisinopril is used to treat high blood pressure lhypertensionl. Lowering high blood pressure helps prevent strokes, heart attacks, and kidney r problems it is also used to treat heart failure and to improve survival after a heart attack. Lisinopril is an ACE inhibitor and works by relaxing blood +_ .1 vessels so that blood can flow more easily. -i.
~
j HDW TD USE 1 — Take this medication by mouth with or without food as directed by your doctor, usually once daily. If you are using the suspension form of this _ medication shake the bottle well before each dose. Carefully measure the dose using a special measuring devicelspoon. Do not use a household spoon because you may not get the correct dose. The dosage is based on your medical condition and response to treatment. For children, the if dosage is also based on weight. Use this medication regularly in order to get the most benefit from it. To help you remember, take it at the same 1 j-
-|-
time each day it is important to continue taking this medication even if you feel well. Most people with high blood pressure do not feel sick. For the H treatment of high blood pressure, it may take 2 to 4 weeks before you get the full benefit of this medication. For the treatment of heart failure, it '_' '1 may take weeks to months before you get the full benefit of this medication. Tell your doctor if your condition does not improve or if it worsens -2 {such as your blood pressure readings remain high or increase}. -'|
i-E SIDE EFFECTS E Dizziness, lightheadedness, tiredness, or headache may occur as your body adjusts to the medication. Dry cough may also occur. if any of these h effects persist or worsen, tell your doctor or pharmacist promptly. Fieniember that your doctor has prescribed this medication because he or she " has yudged that the benefit to you is greater than the risk of side effects. Many people using this medication do not have serious side effects. Tell .-
I your doctor right away if any of these unlikely but serious side effects occur: fainting, symptoms of a high potassium blood ievel {such as muscle weakness, slowlirregular heartbeatl, signs of infection lsuch as fever, chills, persistent sore throatl, change ii". the amount of urine. This drug may F.
_ rarely cause serious [possibly fatal} liver problems. Tell your doctor right away if you notice any of the following rare but serious side effects: Fl‘ r yellowing eyeslskin, dark urine, severe stomachlabdomlnel pain, persistent nausealvomiting. a very serious allergic reaction to this drug is rare. -'-‘.
l'i»’i~’i
i"£-_
.5. However get medical help right sway if you notice any symptoms of a serious allergic reaction, including: rash, itchinglswelliiig lespecially of the J‘ G 1.
1 feceltongueithroatl, severe dizziness, trouble breathing. This is not a complete list of possible side effects. if you notice other effects not listed 11'-5'_ above, contact your doctor or pharmacist. in the US - Ball your doctor for medical advice about side effects. You may report side effects to FDA at -'—-
l',+"iTH _l-i.-.
Centinuee en reverse eicie.
in- -n_
MPit ‘\—|_
P
a.u.u.|.|.|.u.||.u|n.-r.-r.-r.-r.-r.-r.-
i..:l'i-rj" E:
cam . or-JE 5-; '-14 I-""'"'".i-: i r.::r. ‘-1 m ee if flaps:
f'""i.~i"-Tilt“: -1d‘ ---W» 4- ‘_ 4 "5' 1-'f. . "".. . .f“‘Yi,»_-i,»-re ti L RE
DEE] 1'; M I lrl“ ~—- 4‘.-I'll-I
no esoare cite as-ms: -— as
e r. due
E'a --": _ EDD Eli]
:5-l
r= ~ we iia-itr Bit: a- il I : ' | _ fl 1+"
1'4?‘
are dads --H
esyr
I
I
'
a
... ayne '
my-i----H----— M scare PRUMESEB:
-r.u.1.u.u.u.-r.-r.-r.-r.-r.-r.1 P. hthe
ting*
'
as
,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,inin. ||m .,i-_-.-.-.-.-_-.-.-..- 2?ti fiiil -335 fl 11
1 2-Zi fil i W -111-
t
accept r surance ed
ay.
-r-r.-r-r-r---r-r-r-r-r-r-—-—— ‘P |r|r|r|r|r|r|r-rI—IIII|I|I|I timse
‘P
BUTT!
hill fl'Ey:EU “F --“-
ll
1- qr.|.|.|"IlI'Il'
E ii no EH {EUR-Efii-Ecfli
ll-
Ze,2 H_re \|-I-; '1' :-
I1C ti:
lvteiIcs
‘M
I
1
i.-III
-H}
TEtee origeerv
UHUEE i'.'|'_'
ateasit Li.-
‘-TIT? ill-I ""'
ede |tant
rpa cit eats
D1
hu-
1
3- suit L‘-. Di. '—'
|
|
BfiLifl?SEi.i socgewE
sag i i i iffiflfi orEBB:-ta ULULEYE _-.
r se4.setrciea.rit IT?! H11Fr’!fliyitfi accept -mm
*"""'
i aysSo 1-|1-|1-
UI1 1 iETMESA ETES iTEEfi fii f ili FHEi.i. i."".‘\- 1-" 4-nu
*l'I'|'|'r
-11-!- 'a i r uteti
irllrlr Inlllllllt Siii]-1|.
no-r-|r -ll"-'|
'|I|I|IlI|IlI UPFE .._ i3l"|E
TB tes A10 checks:in.Justday.Everywalk lrl-‘F-'— ‘_ EL oe blzi-as
1
1 ' i fi iFi'i|= qr.-r.-r.
irrnr
Fifiii
F -.-. 1|1 Q",
clmiininc”ute
I CE J 11H -ii-3 _-- “I an r. 51- .
.i
Aveverailabley int
Just walk
:1- wt.-r.
Ul
d
1|. h-| ,_
fieee ts arernrnetia
1..
H
—-—
'-‘Jill-_¢'; - -.1 _;_
;|;wrw- 5%‘ .- "-..
._
F'rid roenears tioivs ne
1
Ph3"'fl ¢b'rz4s
'rrI"rr
at E SHUEYEHPflfifiET. assess oerrs o pzota i HSTLi. criocrse sa-t.i2I1tior esectiii‘:IE
eti s
F] E-I-- '-
r-.-.- ‘I- -Ir‘
:2 -|-.- lI"'l.'-I".5-"‘-- ElftiliBEETLE iifti SET I
-ru- 002474
.'Pr¢t'r 1._i-'-'-r.;- I -11 '-e_-'r:i-.-ii.-1 I
1
I
:VS/Pharmaw‘ §.f,[1ii,§';9£\f;|igB§)/an erase err; zeteoz-zsee tr res eaveaar euesriorrs aeoiit -sue rtrreicsrrorii, fiayg‘ ' I \ wwwjyglgflm Pi.E.i5t$£ i‘§i:_i_ Ti_iii._iii iiiiiiiriiiiiiiiti,-iiii iii? iiiiii-irtPiliii rtrtetsiio, ii
tree-roses Frsclir:yarceetits e are yygyyya. zfiiifiiflfi Tfanrnpfh re sst.zrs-tear ' glgggg,tAgazo£~r|aozot are oases rrtsritt 2 once veto sore tits 2 was rt oar “iitis is e SULQRLESS BSUFS. _ Yihdfiifiiffiflfilfiidhdififi DHBPS - DP!-¥TRhi.lii11fi~ {T2£-rrieirlehlitieer-ZD1-lL-eh-rnrdei tiilhaiififliii Bfiithttl iiiiidififfii: flosoat
'.- .-'- :_-
USES: This product contains two drugs used to treat high pressure inside the eye doe to glaucoma {open angie~typei or other eye diseases ie.g_., oc_uia_r hypertension}. Lowering high pressure inside the eye heips to prevent blindness. This rreeicatiert works by decreasing the amount oi third within .*_. .r—. _i- r--1
the eye. "iirnolol belongs to e class of drugs itnown as betablocirers, and dorcoieniide beiongs to a ciess of drags imown as carbonir: enirydrase I‘.
inhibitors. new Ti} USE:
I i Head the Patient Information Leaflet provided by your pharmacist before you start using timololldorzolamide and each time you get rt refi I- ii you havr: any questions regarding the information, consult your doctor or pharmacist. This medication is for use in the eyeisl, usually one drop ill the I afiecterl eyelsl 2 times a day, or as directed by your doctor. To apply eye drops, wash your hands first. To avoid contamination, do rat touch the rirapper tip or let it touch your eye or any other surface. Some products contain a preservative that may be absorbed by contact le:-it-5 f you are using a product with a preservative and you wear contact lenses, remove the lenses before using the eye drops. Wait at least T5 l'Til.‘-l.i*ESi1iI=iDl'E putting in your contact lenses. Tift your head back, look upward and pull down the lower eyelid to make a poucl". Hold the dropper tl.r r-ctzy o yer your eye and place one drop in your eye. Look downward and gently close your eyes for l to 2 minutes. Place one finger at the corner of your eye e meat the nose} and apply gentle pressure. Try not to blink and do not rub your eye. This will prevent the medication from draining our. Tiepear these steps for your other eye if so directed. Do not rinse the dropper. Heplace the dropper cap after each use. if you are using another [rind of ey E:
"i medication le.g., drops or ointmentsl, wait at least if] minutes before applying other medications. Use eye drops before eye ointments to allow ihe eye drops to enter the eye. Use this medication regularly in order to get the most benefit from it. To help you remember, use it at tho same iintos _rI
‘II _||
each ilay. it is important to continue using this medication even if you feel well. Most people with giaucoma or high pressure in the eyes do not it ..-‘ feel sick. 5 SIDS EFFECTS:
Toriiptirary blurred vision, temporary burninglstinginglitchinglredness of the eye, watery eyes, dry eyes, feeling as if something is iii the eye. sensitivity of eyes to light, strange taste iri the mouth, or headache may occur. if any of these effects persist or worsen, not'fy yo=.i- -‘r.-ctoi or pharmacist promptly. Remember that your doctor has prescribed this medication because he or she has judged that the benefit to yo - is greater ""\1 than the risk of side effects. Many people using this medication do not have serious side effects. Tell your doctor immediately if any ==i thos=-
nnlikely but serious side effects occur: dizziness, slowlirregular heartbeat, muscle weakness, menta.lmood changes, coltlness.'numb--as-=:_-pain in KJULf-. the hands or feet. Tell your doctor immediately if any of these rare but very serious side effects occur: vision changes, signs of a kiririrny stone tag D. pain in the backlsidelabdomen, nausealvomiting, blood in the urinal, yellowing eyes or skin, dark urine, unusual tirednesslwealrness, easy RUE!
hi'uisirig.ihleeding, signs of infection fe.g., fever, chiiis. persistent sore throat]. Seek immediate medicat attention if any of these rare but very
Continued err reveree eicie.
oiTANT IMsPORcti mee
__.
||DBlii_iSTliiiASli.i"i'PE:Eritit1ap i E y_y'_E\i iy_yl.4'i' {, i
I
I 1 I-
,Ji i1o“?“‘
{IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI—
Y
:L1=!l"'- _-
EP .,_-.-.-.“.-r.r m-—
| .-
=-Ea 7HEZ il.i . i;i -|||l||||||lr||l|l|l|l|l l|l|I'I'I'I'I-F" ',_.,.,.,.,_._..|.|.|.|.-.-.-.-.-|-|-|-""""""""""""'
Caps
L£3fi~% ,.,.,.,.,.,_-.|.-.|.-.-.-.-.-.-.-|-r-
1-r.1-r
Emmi.
, {J {IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI—
-£-
{IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI— {IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI— $20.B2
I
llll
I-
ash.1"_# iiiNiiiiiP* ED HW -|I|— --I
Q
I _|'-II _\_
lll
{IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI—
'-
r.
5-' --=1
i-rm Ill-II‘ »
{IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI—
rt.‘22l2i} DO I-I'll
O518OOB Rx:
CL xre ugn /r TOT OTIS -..._..
RearlyF'
.,.,.,_-.|.r"""""""""""""|.u--r.-|-|-|-my-"""" {IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI—
'
{IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI— '|'I'lI"" .,.,q,.|.|.r.|.r.r.r.r.rm-r.-r-r-|-|-|-|-|-
U
bs aii.'iess
tions, #
D
S’ wards -1-
—-—
Lil
DD lliliii lltlfi
S PROM {IlI|I|I|I|IlIlIlIlIlllIlIlIlIlI—
.,_-.|.|.|.|.-r.|.rr-ir-|-|-|-— _-.|.|.|.|.|.-.-.-.-.-.-|-|-|-—r- .._-----4 ---- ..-. ET assess 'ned, __
—-— ._
M
-IIIIIIIII
I‘ VS.c0m 4-II
due atPaycos.sermees
v
T2 TAKE ABLETS EA
Dtytifii
HHEH
day.
y
nid Efiffi oer.oand id mnteonths
Cs't
sand
'i"'.ifl4IlflDD T
mdo afor sarndxrewards
"ii eera - lu-
T
Rewards!‘
"M Ii-r-___‘
‘fie. .1 e: REED EU He. _ """ will -#1-F |-I-I Til ? tong earto day. stanrt
vorarmacy
inrr
Pr10
escrip $5
ExtranBucks@
_-
OOBNSELDrug
il ew v H?
I-wr-
CVS.com
I1?! ES l-I‘! Suppy
1.
rer actrt.i’tec r-I11-l ...
0haven’ ra fyou eadyt
4-1!
..-. EESSS ,,“- Ki Hi
fiiinong pate leedor
eiacoep “it
eatli 'l riutse.{l' *V‘s't F . ... r-I111 IIIIII
Ear
H" Mn! 1 i ““ -H" E IIIII _ ii-.-. ES H, the ph at
tTB esting‘
R13 i
IiJ_ll—
7
clac *‘"“"" E |—|
.-r.- -r_-
AVDOR7TitPcr.EPolA2CASTL
RLANiDte. E TABLE F ‘IT {li- ._ 4A2555 I— n—
RH . -E TB Aveverailable in!
Just walk cli
minute F'ri
HFEIC I15 ._
tvr tee
|.|.u.-.
- _iCV25o/P1Ph.h2i4"2'l-a0e°9Y0#745e i i.. ALASUDEVAN L-I
__ MG 5lHHCL
ETFDRM ]D _ .1 1."-Jp- -H OO2469
or5':_ itsucs. rt ti-r'"a adoidoe: ?e27‘T P-ae3-.ta.24a- M Ill MDFI EVERY MOUTH BY DABETES
FDR
TABLET 1' TTAIEE *"
H EVENNB
EVERY MOUTH BY loi iI | D
fi l I : =-I ] fls| l 5 3 - “ H TROY Pr I E AED
s cbr : l'l.:\
i--"I SD24
" limit-tilt or #7459 rs 281.242-2090 wWW_c,s_m VASUDEVANIALAVOOR 0522,2014 IFPLEASE YOU HAVE ANY QUESTIONS
CONTACT ABOUT YOUR MEDICATION.
roua PHARMACIST:
34U2CASTLEPONDCT . N F S‘ GE |-B'Mlllh Tf3I1.RPi1- PEARLAND,TX77584DUOD :;?§,:T§T“°YT“EA on ‘E N R Ph: 832.244-1927 '
LP c tnircn IlgUE};fORMIN iict 500 MG TABLET .r.i TAKE 2 TABLET BY MOUTH EVERY MORNING AND TAKE 2 TABLETS BY MOUTH EVERY El.-'EI'~llhlG FDR DIABETES This is a WHITE, DUAL-shaped TABLET imprinted with 93 on the front and 48 on the back.
PI "‘.J METFDRMIH - ORAL - lmet-FDR-minl its BDMMDN BRAND ll1AMElSl: r e ,1.-.| _-.“.-
TEE Glucophage ‘ll; -I-I-I-‘ -.-1.-.
:__-
WARNING: sitsu ,a._
Jif.) .
Metformin can rarely cause a serious lsometimes fa_tall condition called lactic acidosis. Stop taking metfo_rmin and get medical help right away if - -11-
Lu.-
11.]
you develop any of the following symptoms of lactic acidosis: unusual tiredness, dizziness, severe drowsiness, chills, bluelcold skin, muscle pain, --- ,_ ||.1 | -1-' '- -4
._-
.._-. fastldifficult breathing, slowlirregu ar heartbeat, stomach pain with nausea, vomiting, or diarrhea. Lactic acidosis is more likely to occur in patients sf:
1.21
l"_". --_.-
who have certain medical conditions, including kidney or liver disease, recent surgery, a serious infection, conditions that may cause a low level of ei - -|-- -11"-
5 ref —e _,_|
oiiygen in the blood or poor circulation lsuch as congestive heart failure, recent heart attack, recent strokel, heavy alcohol use, a severe loss of _ Etei er body fluids ldehydrationl, or ll-ray or scanning procedures that reguire an injectable iodinated contrast drug. Tell your doctor immediately if any of '-I-1
.
these conditions occur or if you notice a big change in your overall health. You may need to stop taking this medication temporarily. The elderly E3 LL.
are also at higher risk, especially those older than BU years who have not had kidney tests. lSee also Side Effects and Precautions sections.l USES: Metformin is used with a proper diet and erercise program and possibly with other medications to control high blood sugar. It is used in patients with type 2 diabetes. Controlling high blood sugar helps prevent kidney damage, blindness, nerve problems, loss of limbs, and sexual function uarii “gum
'1"
problems. Proper control of diabetes may also lessen your risk of a heart attack or stroke. Metformin works by helping to restore your body's J—| 1"’
r"'F ._ u
-;‘
DLDDEL response to the insulin you naturally produce. It also decreases the amount of sugar that your liver makes and that your stomachlintestines file.
h.." on “ ,_ _
a sor . 2 .-
'. ::
|_
'
HOW TD USE:
Head the Patient Information Leaflet if available from your pharmacist before you start taking metformin and each time you get a refill. If you have _ ., dren any questions. consult your doctor or pharmacist.
.|..
_ Take this medication
_ by mouth as directed b y yo ur doctor . usuall y 1-3 t ime s a day with meals. 1- __i Drink plenty of fluids while taking this medication unless otherwise directed by your doctor. The dosage is based on your medical condition, kidney - 7. .5 ,_
function, and response to treatment. Your doctor may direct you to take a low dose of this medication at first, gradually increasing your dose to " .l_
lower the chance of side effects such as upset stomach. Your doctor will adjust your dose based on your blood sugar levels to find the best dose for you. Follow your doctor's directions carefully. Take this medication regularly in order to get the most benefit from it. Remember to use it at the .
same times each day. If you are already taking another anti-diabetic drug lsuch as chlorpropamidel, follow your doctor's directions carefully for fi f stoppinglcontinuing the old drug and starting metformin. Check your blood sugar regularly as directed by your doctor Keep track of the results, and are‘ share them with your doctor. Tell your doctor if your blood sugar measurements are too high or too low. Your dosageltreatment may need to be ‘--
if
of changed. Ch Reach Out of O. SIDE EFFECTS:
Nausea, vomiting, stomach upset, diarrhea, weakness, or a metallic taste in the mouth may occur. If any of these effects persist or worsen, tell ‘~-
Kee 11;
J-
Continued on reverse side. USC HIMFUH
NT
.....- I., .‘T-. "=1 ,..- 1-
Appendix N Objections to Wife's Inventory
Wife's inventory filed is Fourth Amended Inventory (Exhibit 5) which had wrong figures and incorrect amounts (RR2 page 5 line 20). Husband raised objections to wife's inventory (RR2 pg41 line20, RR2 pg43 line10, pg44 line1, pg44 line14). The trial court's judge had never said “Five is admitted”, see between “Four is admitted” (RR2 pg43 line1) and “Six is admitted” (RR2 pg49 line19). There was never a words saying “exhibit five is admitted”. Hence, this proves that wife's inventory is rejected by the trial court and judge. But in spite of this how the trial court made error by putting this Exhibit 5 as admitted? No one knows!
Appellant raised objections to inventory filed by wife (RR3 at 8 line 25;
RR2 at 41 line 20, RR2 at 42 line 16, RR2 at 43 line 10, RR2 at 44 line 1; IDX 307, IDX 339, IDX 342, IDX 364, RR4 pg 3 line 4,7,9,11,13; RR4 pg 4).
See also: RR3 pg 9 line 18, RR2 pg 76 line 7, RR2 pg 77 line 7, RR4 page 3 line 13; page 4 line 4, Appendix N exhibit 13, BA pg 203 _WV E_\_1“kwWIk”m_iHE_fl"\_fi_Ih”fi_w:q_H+$m_M_¢M~_T_ _ “J_ mI_ i_'__
__H H___ _—__ULD_€_ _ I_*___ _____ I3:‘
_
Efigfifl QQWWEHfififimfih
GH _ PFfi _F_H fi GymM
H_w_: _;E1_UEr3W fiHF_Hu_fiu{M |:EMT?
_J mfl%fi£W U_mflflmfl?qmfil
Hfim wmfififi ‘HHGHuul
:Wflmmfl
_pFE:fiFPfififiUU_ iHiqHn_
:*E_;fiwHiP+F+wwHh
mrEJ_ 5HfiU flEfiHn%_mnflHpfiHwfl fifim&
fiHEfiuflfiflP
wfldfihfifimE““mm
L:nfimHwWflTn~
1i_:NE:fi_~‘_1xJ:AE_:~L_a_Lh_EEN“H£___ k1__
{Mfi%uwwfi¥mrHum
wfimfibwx fl:*5“
JLr1~‘fi€__H_fi
_xhxf=hG1mfifi3? ]?_F~_
HwfiHxFm#:q_mfiffiwmu£mfifiizfifwflFm 5 Jdlmfi1p_tHnv5“:
nfl1_HQ w:_igmbH_amh:Fu1ii fiupE1Hm“E _1:n£_IHuflrIp2E5?“fi~-_mm~rfi: ~__ vuwfiwufifimfi U1fl H_#“J~m_:fifipww
wH_;lT_1HmG£_w_I___2me§HjW_=“TF‘ my=E_5___ NEH Tfl_‘:wIfiH“g_JpflE_fih’gmHflmfl mBwfifiw?mfiHgfiUfiP€ _:gHm£ ¢nhH3FHHEfimfimfluflfi
Ew_HnH;JfimfiflWmfi ?fi‘flfimmwHun ELHLkGmm
flmfiaL I1Fa“ r_J}flnrwfl_1$fignmflnT iqJ_F~fi;
fifflmr
xHiWu“MW?“ __fiw~‘fiafim¢_qwHmmfimifl?fifiaflpfimxflpfimflgfi ‘ F5:Hh_“fiE"mfilm?mfi §m $hiwgF_ §_nGp§E_d!1_E E_MmfifigmqIfif‘HnflHFfi“¢'_I*mr_WIu_.Dfi:n:*g __
_____
_ P_—_
_____fl _______|
_____ ____|
_ __ ______ _____
_____
_
_ _*__‘_
_| _ _ b@_wwhfi H‘_EMU* _ €m_t_
F‘ wMi Hum_mM¢mi
¢§HififigfimHHm
$m§_
“ ____?‘
____
_______ _"_____
_ __‘ __
____:
___
_ __ _ Hfigm FGE"HfigfiaEU
fimggfifig
nUHHSH‘ rQ3:fiflHfifigH‘;MEm
H Em
Iggq
_
!*fig HE“a *x_E _I_=iL__EiL~_H;fl_a_i_ian
-F*EFa MmWfiF_fixnm
hWmbab~\}flm~DwH*\G$fiw\f_
_|_2;:Jt_mLIina_____“___:fi_fi_’};H‘,___i _‘in_; _____ ma ‘___|_11
P
NEH“ GmFHUHHW rm mgfifi mfififififififl _m_ fimH_H_Hg“F_
gfir ;_Ea f;:_;_L:kP_:;_ ‘J gm pfiHx_mkmM?”
flw kfl
_I_|_
___“______ “__
"fi_r _" _ _ ’_
__‘__I_|__
____
__
_ _‘ _
H~J_~_~___
r_
____J|_‘ ____ _____H
L:F
CfiwQwc mfi“cc: mpwfiUufifl
mw:Hj os63¢
Cscfigwhmfim“FmUmwfi Uh qumkflwHfinmum ¢flmfiHQ&finvmkfi u%H_mnQ@PnHad zmkvownflszfimnwmnpmfimWUmm0 flUfiwgnuv
0Wfifimflfiflgfi Szmfifi “Kw _Dfl _m@ mmmUfiQ?HQ tH3mmmfi Wgfimm” Hspfiquaaowm
Hmmmm Hfiwm:HQ mUHnfiO_WU
cflmQwgmrHCmgflUmfiHOwfl_G%m:_wGQHFEH Umvfimo“ nmamk fiomG%“rm Dm&fi fipfiwm mHfiwUm“nlHn?cfiom:gwHmp£Gfiws%HwflowGmflUGHfimHfirFmHflQmwnUfi_$DSQ Amcwfifi:wOno nomU“Um "Fm Hfi6%
mUnmfipcRam IgMQMHHW
HmmfiwmnO£umnflpfipun
HGFHM oCm fi5flmwmPmafimDHm_fl@ppnHomW©snnfidfiuiwHfirm mGmwgmwnH éfiwfi_afiam“mflrfimwnnwngmmwgmn;mnEEK m:sflpmgm p:fisps
nmfl%Qficwwvwem
qpwnnw:&H
wbHF@pwsfiQmfiPo¢GwnjHmn;PHwan mfimQPUF PG“flwHmfimmmH£wMw F$gfiwfiU:
cfikfiflflwmn mflflmnaHmmu fiQ_Fhmw0flfidHomnHflwgfiw®fins“ zHHgngmwwgmmfl£HG sPM fiQ:<_HECEfi%O£mfiQm$WfiwDQu
figawC HF6%
QEVwxkzm$51
mPfi¢H:gfl<Qmhw_fiHm$QZrfip:§Qmnufi:o“wmfiuHaflmHmwmfi H%nwagflwmsmH5n$Hm mwmm fisrvmflpwp‘fiwncflfimpngn“fimwzflrUnmDHHnfi_HH$mfimHU£ VGHuafiHEW“ sqfiwflaxofi cfiMUm
qmPfi$ U“firmP
“Fm5Uzwam nmHpnvwH9%
&sGmWSW
agmwflwflm
cmmfiwHmWwnHmfiQbkfifiM5
m“UmH mmnKflmfifian gwwedwu w“mHs“rmc
flwpizkfirw
smam$06nmmsHajfigmfig
ucnhfimwfifiUnfixfinHcflmum
finGwHmfiiWU5mgmlHfinmPmQUfi5Vfl_mmmwmcwD0& U%n pflO%“Um wflam
afiHmHe
Ohm MGM wwfiGO“Wm EwanQUP afi wPM@Q
E
HzfiwmfiHGflQHsHnméwflfip®n_ HQOFUV Cflmfiwmmgmnflwkoflsmwm mGmHn xwc mHm§WmgP:U Gm wQ£mflfinQw@m%m_nmwgUpP61“Ghfifim F_mwGGP_ mum “Fm mMgfi mflmfinwfiqmUcflax“ mfiPgfiqwfimwfigmmvmpnm EHHGG smxwfiH flfiww wgm flfiF"Sm mmwxnzgDwzflfimwgflfinmflGU3Ocw Hnmmnm
wqwpcmWOWH fimawflm pmHmug flgm“Sann “SmE3 pmwmH_wfi<Qm%Ofi_ Ow£Qcmwpmw
pUm U5m:_q$Hc £5%ng HuwflnDW flcfigs”
aH6fiH0mcm
GHQn flw5q¢fiPuUwmma
amhfigum
wHmnm m“mmQfiHauflozfinflwnmflwpCmPnmmfiwficGwwwpa moWmmama50¢Hmmy %0: w5nsmH
snagmm
fifléwwfiw
zwnnMsqjwn
gH5% fimwnnfinficm_aowmflfigflfim£DsaWMwmfl é:0?Hmmp mmmUfivnm flmSO£ fiHamt nwfimfiqGEgan wnew“
flmwmcPmpmfiQ3flQwnfiPflawmdbnmHfl<mw_m“DH fiHfiflfi flacfl wnxmnwmmHwP mfiwuwgang
gmmwpflnawmficgwflifimsflUwnfi“nflPWs¢mfiMHwWW<:nmw_nH?mQ:Hfl _F$MywHfimwa_¥w@m%$ :$Tfl? ?fi3fiH%wM@%m_fiU %m H% h my “imfi mnwfimwH;Umw_ mMP Mfim hflfipfifiHgflwp
pHwfiwmflmy
Hkwf_wmm mfiHVwfi flPnw_wm _Np Hm miOMHdzfidm
mHHa
pmWMHcwdm_UwmGM _TIF__T_UF__‘vu_fl‘fi:r3+flH1x}H§:_“T&qHI?J”H*u$:“_I}§:5T+;tflun‘_H?T_hhl“i£:ufi$i__hi?Hfi“_n#nHHgT'wm_¥t%?_Hfl§fi“Tu:Ffl#v?Er?HHkyTfimRnLwfi_*#2uj?EE“aF¢tfi_}h?HmHu+fi$r+3*B‘?aH“$1:;_FL§fifi+?2fl$_Ha2h[;Ufifiv"?TqFE”v+_q::fHn;?fixh+fi£flJu?_H3MEfi;hEB?q_
_____
_ ____-
___|._.‘|_:r_|_I_I______iI_II_I‘-._ _I _Pi _______. 1__-I‘ _______‘
wfimfiflm
_-_L.-—_-._Dr_._| |D‘I______|
___
|1_|_____
_.| _|____‘___________
_i ._ L|_ _L _
mfiUmmfiw HBEEQ G“ Wfl mamawwmm
fiGH
m mg;figzgg :B_ m_:g_;fin¢_i_Em____" :
fi ymmfi fi_fl¥ y_hfimfu_rfl‘“mr_H_~_Wm_"+|U_Twh_HwH_ t_ "|
_|_‘r|_-_1__.
I-|_1____1__. ____ _._._-1_'J'_‘_
____
‘|l________
____:__;:____:___:_1‘_______ _'||________
I__-_I_1__‘ ________‘__.______
_-_.___ ‘___:___
___-PI_I‘_..
_-_ __.|_____;I‘J
____
__. __:______ ____-____|:_ _‘_._
figs Wzmfiwflm_fiHmmhmu:
FUH @y\hmw$ o_UmQac
F‘n yfifififizamfiagfififl HMH fig”hnfifidfiqHQH Hmfifirfifihw u_NEW“
HHEmrzH
_\mZ:€$nm_ibQHq§_;C1aW_¢:MSJ;?jI$zUkFFPmrn:fiw&MqTGp?“£r_H
E
fi§L:_“m
1WRN
_M_Hi
_____I __’
F
__ fl__H_u_“A_>___“:___ ;":_U :|_“u1_,‘ _flrJ J;
ii; WH_ T;H
h_ _ _“ _m_ _}
‘I_-
£:§cH—|l5!"F B pg Iqg
_\-|-
. I‘ ."
| 1%
"‘
% \-
I: "-.
1-
I-
1
~ ~ I 1 ' l£"*‘I'-r.-;"(
f F?“ -‘I .- I“ I
. 1.
0"‘ ‘*5 - _ e {K I K. *i L L1"-\ *—-3 3 LA""'\"' LLLVML -1
i | I I’ _ I! f 1-'.. --\ ." .r. H‘-L _ I ___ 1 1.‘: (z
. .
1-~._ 1 -'.
'.'_|.-'~
"- .,
1'._».__ ' ck
K M LLL~\ -~¢—-;~\ ‘ *1 -P'”"“*L% ‘. "H 3 |' 4-’
I
ow [~10
\-
-IQ.
- - - .% - -—- - , .r . 1»-J, ~ .-». .
- 1
_-I’ -
I’
flag I L .-'~.L"L k‘_{h !LI‘u'L_L1-ll . I, U_L.\._£‘tI"La. ----.|-'&/ -‘L } -[___L I;-Jf - ‘pi
‘In
J‘
.|-'
1;-.,l . .
’/06° . _ ‘T '1- __ . '
J
/ .7 , ' ' 7 - ; .17. . '
I I'._ z, T‘-.._,‘-I-'L L6; l..c"{-:._ ll- 1r \ f 1 h D
=7,,,u' -yuan M wwdi.--q 1 I‘
. . I --
Lg.’ £- I3 L1, LL._k_“MH‘n‘\ 5_\_u__9 ‘ xi,‘ AA. l-"EL '. ¢_"Lr |=.~'*¢i¢'l-_;.Lfl I‘
. |I- "' x
Q I r fw -L» ef-*~ @'**~~*'i*~;)
. 4-
1;_;,f 'ya‘ I I ,1 P
'-flu 4_ L L";-,\ U‘ 1- \.i--'*-
, '5" \* bx-K M .
|
[sf-1 3‘-in »--'lu"?*’\
\- .-£1. (\--L I fin-_”1T:»_LL /ué./T" ujiitcll ér “'1 fi";\:'l.*"'».=-,.\~_ .L-n.¢"\ §\.5’~.\M'.\ 1 X L .»-I"-
» 1"‘.
C"*-15.’-’-K 1'-R-1;-“\~1.j;-.¢:,-'=:~,‘.‘§ 1‘ If 1 H‘ IA“ / (‘L
2; - .l'|-
"1‘H
'I||\\$
-. I -
i \l,_,’" 3 “*1 (‘[ E ‘LL ~. h t‘ If '1...»""v"~ 1-""'l»l L Id
(7-““ ~"'2.-»% '"~=~1 " ;gvl€'Z?
.1.
.-.
r ".
""1 - fl _ - .1 __ -1 _ _ _ . (D "ax. I‘ fl" M { v\_L 1L"'--L ‘ ‘K
"'5-
g;.i(mw_M_q\ [‘d;#-}_.,W» I’;3.;,y3 I /D L1, t:f>1,~.u.L.¢,,1J ‘CI J‘?"'r+f1@@z\
§b}@l>
jL vwujwfiu prefmel \ryPrLr:u¢>z>-R WT$'u:DClm* M~r¢.¢x~=kl?afl@w~;
fi\\<A,Lp,1,{gy\4/V'fL‘-u-]»/|V/)Q\‘0c- l2®€c 22013
EXHIBIT 1: Missing Items in Inventory: Wife's Handwriting 14 Gold Bars
Cause No. 63935
DEEPA VASUDEVAN § IN THE DISTRICT COURT AND § 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS This “Exhibit” says in last paragraph Item (6) as handwritten by wife (Deepa): “14 Gold Bars” (marked by red arrow). This is for inventory number 3 which includes 14 Gold Bars and 30 Gold Coins.
<—. Ww..,
U
i -.' =~—
*
1»
-—- ""i"'r"".H‘L_J-u"\;'I_‘:.l
W“-’~°~=:r
- * =-¢. * ..1-----LF
uilnr--'
*4-1‘ '
-- *~"*"'—' — \ _ ‘E7. '
_ . --~ _ . -- _r,__ _. - v--.x_»__--- '--'<-_.
<§:¢5-§- - -- ll:-.'_'\._§_l'u"~_i—"-._ - -—--“'1 ._
' I "i-.- 5
I: :.1_* I.._\_.~.=~¢-_‘E-l‘:=.\-“— '¢ €*"‘~|§~—“' C ‘“‘ L _ __ ‘F"1:<""_%‘— "?':':"=_ |;'- ,_-¢ . ?.- ‘ H -‘K 1':-'.-i.-T‘ -:.- "' __.:5-'*-3,. Lqr-ks"! -_ ‘I: =21}-t1_ _ I 5.
‘-“"\H""‘-““H":‘ I P’ El ac‘ 5 _ l'*T_- -1*‘-='-""" ‘M W - .
- _+*_‘-Q‘ ‘rug .1‘-f"'\_j_l"‘“k.§_-£..-. *—'.‘:- ' J T.
.. -\/ -_-,r~._ 1»-"“"""" (PL--£'"~, .»--H.-~¢s-E 1"»-=--5~ -(.'_- -1- \"‘-r" mu‘ '
1&1 I-1:J1I"'~L'-"r-“"‘:— , ~»-%-».~-=7- .\__:_. 1...;-... --j- "*-""--"-ft‘! 3'" ""' ’_ - .
(£3 C__\'.-Q LU; 1-r\,.-.-\ J _ -:\_;=_ - _ kg; _.- 1..--"X »;-"-D" S‘;-'7:" '_“"""' '
-.L
Q _1|__‘._;;-.__L_, \ ‘\-1- ‘H-T_
-Q-£ ' *1 "
.13 N -_, - , ___.,.. -2;
_ c_z . ».14__1-’-n “ ¢-..-- E ‘L. F - _L \._ 5, L.’ _ t1‘:-=1‘?-L‘-~U'~—"1"'**l-_\-L -
Q p_.C-_L- C.-'»._ ___ ii? _.-_. .
"<.f._=~._,:&-- --"*" . ---*1» I J _ _ _ _ C-,=_i=..H== 1 .
._..-J-._:-1-'-*---"-- .-<1.-*~'1_.
~.
'F - , I "75
E
- ‘ I". 1-_:-:‘-..‘-4-=-""
.,|.....-- |'::_'I-_"\-I-in-l C __
__‘___ __-v_ 1f .--_-—-—-_€;.-H -- _ - L;a£_ E-_.. *-LI’, .:-I I 6 F Q; W
__ EH______L_L__ -'-, _ .-
-.-J.F- '1
__ 13. -*~'~—1¢-- 1| ’
E‘ C§_.'_.-L.-.-l..L'J'~.-\ -1 15'-L‘;
. ' 1. fiw’ - .fi If--.11 Q Hrfi‘ A __ _ f"'u"'-—-*l._- l. '-"‘I- ‘_____HE_ FELL
___ LI i.‘ q'_.L¢ L- K - _-E‘;
._ _% If) I 5
<-=4: fr“* *“" )1, @ Wrfi ¢- *1 ‘I _ TL flfi_'
Q") ,-_-f.'>l!f;-:‘_|1.--¢.»-...- --=; J’-=¢;n.._,»..-€'_. _'=.¢-.r--.1:-‘_.. -..._..
F“ Q‘; F‘- 9;. (-?;>r um:
/ ‘-*:n1*"'§;'
m _ _ _ Lt?‘-3 I. -gIIL..|-'l~—-£1
_ =1
T” ’5- -
___14.1--4.-11 __ 4 all c-.,-u
I
r--w-*
r " gust '
[-111 'b""'\-'12:} .
‘___’ (‘J L‘/W ‘-... _ _ - ' H -_ I __ ..- 13 _ 1___'.5;_-_ _
_ __ ‘CH3 g-;,~='.._'-r-.._: L? ,_, \_,_ \fIlJ-"--' * _\
QM 0&2:-M L‘; (‘C-‘I P75!“ R ' % . ‘ ‘in-Q L-Hi‘: 5: -1'5 tail-\-I
' _ " —'_\. '_H__-.l -C-“_-| __"- . _ -I 1 ._ _ r-. I1 | _-_|-- --1 -\-- .- . . -c , . I . _ -- _-._ 1--' * fr _ _ _' _ ""' , . .
"i?". 7311',".‘|'.-‘E-.11 |"f|:.H A _ IL T
- |. 1r I.I _' - T-Ii-1." 2-- I-.-I\.-"
| :-er. -" s1'-!‘*‘_'- . -I-J:-. _..‘ 1-_. |- I-
_ _ .-- 1 :
. _,.11*.;_ 3-‘
",.fI
I--;1~
1!?- “Z
I.lr=r'
h ::;ElI‘
- I 1"‘?
_\_
7-‘~ _|..
“"""ir. ___-
_..!"
‘TIM.
.-_
r
n.
*"r"'1 Ll’
a'I*
I. 1%' _
Il-
.-- .- -1...--1%?-'.
Ffifi_ _\_H_U_fi HE _I_ _ -_-_-I _ H__
Ir
_*
h__ __¥_
_If
____
_“ -_
_‘WW |_fl|W_I h_
____p_J__n__T___{I _______ ___-_
'____.
___- __‘_ if
_r
___“
HmI _~_ _ _ _Y
I
__ __
___.__u_ _ __-______
______“e
1-
_ _ '_ _
._.-
I‘
I
Cause No. 63935
DEEPA VASUDEVAN § IN THE DISTRICT COURT AND § 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
Cause No. 63935: In the Matter of the Marriage of A1avoor Vasudevan and Deepa Vasudevan and in the Interest of Pallavi Dev, A Child; In the 300th Judicial District Court of Brazoria County, Texas Wedding Photos showing Gold, Diamonds, Jewelry
photo 1: Diamond finger rings and gold bangles
photo 2: Diamond finger rings and gold bangles photo 3: Diamond finger rings
photo 4: Diamond finger rings husband
EXHIBIT 13: Handwriting Diary Showing word ONLY written by Wife pg 1 of 3
Cause No. 63935
DEEPA VASUDEVAN § IN THE DISTRICT COURT AND § 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS
This “Exhibit 13” has handwritings of Wife's Diary and proves that handwriting of word “ONLY” in “Deposition Exhibit 4” is written by wife Deepa. See also inventory number 3 $900,000.00 In “Deposition Exhibit 4” and there the last paragraph in “Exhibit 4” says this:
“Several sets of jewellery and everything is given to be my mother except a ring and a chain with my mangalyam which al had given and he can get that; the rest goes to pallavi. There are 14 gold bars all bought by me and some given to me by amma and pati from what they had collected in the past. 400 dollar us savings bonds and that is for pallavi”.
And in first paragraph is handwriting of Deepa which says “only”. The handwriting of “only” is a proof that this document exhibit 4 was indeed prepared by Wife (Deepa). See also page 9 of the deposition of Deepa Vasudevan taken on 24 April 2014.
5
5* 1 9+ ___ I /Lfl-ii‘... i%@:- E-IPEH_5E&FlElIlEUFI_ EHT FIEBD FIE!
K? F.
'. "1-"'1
§[ ‘Bi-
-._..-J
./9*;/>M@’ Qi-
_ ‘I H:
it§%é3%» gig £wMW* .-"""'I. n .-'"
5
Page 1 of 3
EXHIBIT 13: Handwriting Diary Showing word ONLY written by Wife pg 2 of 3
FHl'JHE- '::m.|.s EIPEHEE a.- neunaunssuzm nee:
C71
. -,r
~/L\£_‘.,L§,_ -£1 {J1
5' f§>» Cgprw
Lab‘ *@F-~ *~6*flur_{m Ii .
am Weak SATURDAY 2 7 IAHY AND WORK RECORD saw Day FEBFlUA_H‘f, 1999 . hi 1%‘ ., .- -_
la‘ I C;-bhqv ,.‘*7\.L1,/-1.3./P1-»* J 1,.
Page 2 of 3
EXHIBIT 13: Handwriting Diary Showing word ONLY written by Wife pg 3 of 3
I i__ ‘II
i
_.. 5 ~._IQ.__§,,,.,,.»£ F) £3-._... if ? ,1 I J, %
' ' “*.*;"*:~. i&l.»‘:_=-_.'_'."\-"Q-5%.- .L1;.§ Cu
Page 3 of 3
Baak at America .'-1* SAFE DEPOSIT BOX BANK OF AHERICA, N.A. PAYMENT NOTICE P O BOX 15285 BANK: 0099 R: 0400 Wilmington, DE 19850 BOX NUMBER: 0 -T SIZE: 5X10
unqquuunuux NOTICE DATE: O5/28/13 RENTAL PERIOD 07/01/13 TO O6/30/13 CHARGE TO ACCOUNT KIIKNKKKKHKXB479 DEEPA VASUDEVAN $98.00 3fi02 CASTLE POND CT PEARLAND TX 77584"703O FOR SAFE DEPOSIT BOX ANNUAL RENTAL
- — — — _ O — — — _-
SAFE DEPOSIT BOX PAYMENT NOTICE
g3§K: Og39 CENTER; 0400 BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. SILVERLAKE 2880 FH 513 s1zr:= 5x16 aw“
PEARLAND TR 7758A RENTAL RAE: $145.00 DEEPA VASUDEVAN DISCOUNT: 3fl02 CASTLE POND CT PLAT PRIV AUTO $A7.00- PEARLAND TX 77584-7030 cnnnsn TO ACCT: _"§§§i§6
HE HILL DEBIT $9B.OO FROM YOUR ACCOUNT lKHIKKKHIKIXIBfl?9 OH O?fO1/13. PLEASE DEDUCT THE CHARGE AHOUNT FROH YOUR BANK OF AHERICA ACCOUNT. THANK YOU FOR YOUR BUSINESS.
Note : Payment will be made by automatic debit Please do not remit a payment.
Emaat-T W» (*?e-"- um: -+.»-I) -:1‘-*'~'=*;5~@.. .1 flay"?
Bants at America SAFE QEFOSIT BOX BANK OF AMERICA, N.A. PAEHENT NOTICE P O BOX 2518
HOUSTON TX 77252-2518 EflHK= fifigg BOX HUHEEIE: EEHTER= [}.Qf1H'U*Ej? “AHA SIZE: 5K1O
an-=1=| mun @®-'flnnnun?nnu u NOTICE DATE: O5f2?fOE RENTAL PERIOO O?ffi1fOB TO OEKEOIOQ
euaasa Ta 2ecaunT-flfibfififinrqmfil 5? .OO
DEEPA VASUOEVAN BAOZ CASTLE POND CT PEARLAND TX 7758A-?O30 FOR SAFE HEPOEIT BOX AHNUAA HENTAI
" 1-I _-: _ l-|_ _ .._ - _|-_ . ' .. ' ___ - ' -
1 ¢._' ._I I‘ 1
SAFE. i'}i¥;l""QSIT am; rm“:-'1.-A: i=;;~.="i' :""~i:J'i'i1. i~.
BANK: O99? CENTER: OQOO BANK OF AMERICA, N. A. aux 2111:1252: = gym? 2 SILVERLAKE EIEE: 5H1O 2880 FM 518 PEARLAND TX 7758Q RENTAL RATE: $?fi0.00 DEEPA VASUDEVAN EIFCOUNT: 3HD2 CASTLE POND CT AOUAHTAEE $30.00" PEARLAND TX 77584-7030 CHAEBE TO ACCT: EIOTOO
HE HILL DEBIT s?n.0o FROM YOUR ACCOUNT #HT5Hq¥¥nufififi ON 07/01/08. PLEASE nanuct HE CHARGE AMOUNT FROM YOUR BANK 0? AMERICA nccuunr. THANK vou FOR YOUR BUSINESS.
Note : Payment will be made by automatic debit Please do not remit a payment.
E5‘;‘$5xi a.‘HE ‘Q3
\\"'
Pgi
Bank of America August 2301 H
liL'.-|.».c|*t1g..- ;H..'=..'-"‘Lll1|| :1umT1._-1‘; ' I. ]1.;~.'i~.1||;_: :1~..*t.'nt111'. :m111i1..-r" "
N Bans 0fAmerica EEEPA *'\."i‘>».*I£;i..!‘tL‘~tTZ“..fi1?\-E A -I .-.‘. ,..,i.__i,....;~,@@ \¢"£;L§_'{__UDE-'E_,f;1N investment Sen/ates, mt.
var i ' ‘-‘R
..t§IEH1 :$5+U? t. TI-"*1 .. PU?“-ID CT 1"». 1E1* £3£1’?
P- F ,.23 [..- "2 {"'.-.;
"' "T:>~=: L2 "1"-
?‘?“".5i=
<";.;2 may/r w».<* >@<1»¢.: I av M §.
" ¢"\ I ' 6, \
5;.
Darn‘ I*1".u’::cd Ctr.-rrnmcr.
The Ec=:mon:i=;- firm-.r.-'1 nmr.-* T.-"tr Rrffcf R:'-:nncHi.=1n'nu .4 cr ufffiflf p:'01*£dc5.5'm'crru' uppnw-rrnzirics IO !m:rcmrc _}-':':=:.rr .Im'.:*.-;-rnlctu :*enu-:1 pnr.:':m'rn' r.-.-er r. cf! rt‘-.r nmrc .1-ppcn'.=r:m' ticsfor :rz.r-nth-c:::rc.*_g¢:rf iuvc:.'-:-‘mg C'|:JlHm:':' _-.-our .5-'I\‘::‘.5'Jmc?m' n:,u:'-:'5"c*::rc'mrc~ rm Ir-sip _t-1:-u u::rfi::-sr:'un'.|'J:01-- rfrrs |:'a'1rr:I_;_;c5 nm_§.- :-gjircr _.-'|::u. Ff.’-EIrIi'.i' .:m':1:m' it;-1-csrrrmxrr.*;::-rrr-.*_;{;* :trm.'J'f'.-Mum‘ -1.
fc.ur_g- r+.'rnr jmr:n |:.=':11 gun 1'5‘.
.1.’-.'::':.-‘tarBc:n!.'0fA:rrerr':r: nor Erma qr’ .~I m:?rh:.-:1 Ira:-csrnrcrxx St-n-Ices. ."m:. as rt mx c:d\':.:n:'r H’-.~ strggcsr you 0-.:1rr.s'm'r_.'cmr pcrzawzmrn’ mt r:dw'.?cr' Iacjinrc :m":Jcm_;' nag.’ Mil’-I'€A1'fEEf :'m‘c=$u:'u:nr ::."c:c:.1¢.=.:=.':.-2'
‘A’ - F‘ ii‘ £3111: '1i':r1.H' ~' 1 :1!-':.f.
T"! 9- -*'-. -_-"I' .l-'-_':¢,:I
I“! _--,
'-f'._'-.-"y".".r _:|...!‘- _-
I:-.-' _:-'-3 -.,4.T‘Z'I'|T‘-.||-.._
. . ':::'v1l='.q' '1-"l:'1._i \.I..'-_' -.-.-|.- -_ 5.!’-2';-1
.1-A
"1 .
g; --
tJ w -
.
»~ I
$- , .
:,...1:w. -at .~1r*"::r= .;r:-;: .1.-:.*==; -2»? --mt-;~:..;.'. E::*.*E-‘.5-!;".1=-:'."_ .-;3»¢.~_-a.:-9-5.. Ev-.; 57”‘ ‘H, Hf" é M? i HIEH" ' -
.=" 1'?.' r=='..r:£'m;* 4 |:-.H 4'J LI E‘! H1’: FJ :-I:I- -1 _l .|..I
C=*:..';.“1..1'";". E,";;r.::lr~5~:t.".;'_=-:-: -
I | 131' H-".5'-.Fl"
"'\-1‘-1
u--.--_.'i ‘£7? -§§E~"u‘i:"'. ?!',=f?:“: F»?-I:-.=1'_ r-.-£21 ft‘?-.#-1-1.-E*I
- "~ - +1 -: . _ .
':-*1'|-“T‘3tI'5- '*'-' -1"-fE'3-- Em. ;~.l:11..'1|l |111n,||-|._'1.~. 1~|::\':|.|.-:11 In ]'i.||:4.' -'-1."\.|u.-1||...|I-|r\.:-.||1|;:|I"'~|:|"~1£.'-. Em. I" M _::r-'Ir- Ir‘ -jun’--In-H: uh‘ t l'J'.HlI'l| I'.F.H-__EJ'1' 3.1:" — - _- _ - - -
I‘-"‘ | |-II‘ -I-——~l
'.n.".r.'~.r.* :1.:n I-:::+.:tn-an-:a .::-rnrmcme,-m:m.1ger!+:c:n!a:: _ _.*\1'c 7‘!-|1_1 1- UH IH'~il.lI'I.'l1 T"~I*.|j1' I._::~=1.j_'\ '-1_|11t* l"i~..1--.- ;r -l. I|1.|I ..-:.|.u| -in uni H; u-..+.J| It": :1-:.-......
.
t,-.!.-!i-*n- 1-r'r~1|1|!1|:ul- |- ,|- I - I In
ill‘-ii‘:-‘I I-r I I in Ilu-.1 H-.;|._" l- I11. ,i_ bk‘-;|':T:L ||i‘|.._|1I| in‘ -‘_|4_1l|| F‘!-||,| _|hL_||J|:|_ ‘FF! [kl ll
'.- .|..-r.|t 11.1:--1|u:m~-r-. \ mt 't-~ .+ 1.-. .'.u.'.1*1anir1l:|m-bri:::..':nIfl It-.1n1.' uf 1|.mrri1::|1nn-~1111cr:| Brrticru. l|n.'.
i. :1 m"|r1i1.||u-;. ml:-.|.1|.|t]. .11 ]t:nr|~ =|1 .'~:|1cri4..r.|m1 |":u|-1.-|-.--.l hm]-..:1"-:'i».'r-11.:: :|||1.i111-.'u1l1-:| ‘\.\.‘~i|.T. ‘*~H"'
1.
I
O
H i (Eli-‘T 5 l"CT’k'€M-J) cal; ‘F of ‘.3
Bankefhmerica August 2001 H
.I'.‘
~.1-;1:"=.";' ==*.".=sz~.:."" W.’ A‘.3UUE"u'AH '._'|-c
5-T-1.==!-...-! n-'.1;.- -..»;-:;:=:;:|; :ar::::%"=.-;_ '|"%‘£.“5TUUO1" i 5r..':'.i=.::':'=_" .2-.3£iHLiil ::!r:1':5‘~..'iI
. “,¢~:f. . gm“J I.§~¢¢i ‘T -$25"("TD
Oaiiy acununt szaamary, cunt.
Bate T1“:-5 - +
G828-G1 C-ash ‘\:‘V|tt"!c:ir';1"».r.'c1i bH.M..iNSi..iF1ANGEBEE:-ISA 511 :1-
?»r~.-.-*r~.*1:-.'?‘;1£‘.-=.*2.5*.>.'.-*'<:."»5r'=";~ '..¢;.aPw.v"E;=:= DATEIC1OB25;i€'~iD?‘\i:1ALJ3\‘v'UOR vasunavaw
OB-25-C‘. Cash ‘JWhc1:.2w:.% NMLEHSURANC-E; =@sA 1962.-
F‘M"'!“».11?‘.1T;£{'J>=&'<.I3ET’1 Qjn3 U‘H1 0":TS/1.P\‘MTEFF D?-TE:G1552."-3;;t~:Ci!\i.fi~;A\.’@3£iR ‘.r’ASUDE'vA!‘~.1
M ' .-if-71. AME?-‘.i€/A :i3E$=DiP.EC3T '§".'5UO C10 0222 C3 C152": Uegccasét C'EP.iD=4'§!0%E~C=£-4513'1’5?='\~EFF DATE. O‘. C32§;?ND!\ilDEE?’.¢'~. ‘.1’A5i.$DE\.»’;’—\N
Depaan E3-?<OFAt¢1E$3.lGA ATM $;?.§’2Ei* #000666?-E~5 651 31 Q&E9Gt Gash DEPOQET HEFi.MA!‘-€N'S P-%OS?3iT HOUSTON -4 >'\
IX} 1.: F1! G1 '1,-J ll
Witéwdraw :1? G€SCC#'\.fEF-I _DES=S.‘fA.?T C-HK 0529b: Gabi:
;iI3:6:’}‘t1*3CE?BG24‘-. -JEIEFF DATE: G1O5-E9IlND!“ii'*J»5‘\$L.‘UE‘v’AN.UEEF’A A
Bi<OF.-¢~.MEF-'<1Ci‘A ATM C1859 #0i3OCPOO?'E3‘3 ZOO §I'0—
usage: Gash Wit‘.*.drs.waE W THQRWJL HEFiM.fi~?‘~.iN'S HUSPH" HOUSTON cr'-t- TI
2’ 1;|E-29-U1 Cash. ‘A-’a:hdra*wa§ GET‘? {FF PEA-F1LAN§},§JE$=UT F:-!LL ;iD=1OGE+33‘E='I".CO24€*5{1EFF DATE;
11645-
O1 C-322-ANDN \.*71.SUDE*.’A?u‘ALAVOOP:
Gash Wéthcirawat Safebax Fee 2'1 OU-
F.'3~I‘-’5_1-5;?
Gash {Deposit EL. DA-GO Gl_O'?‘;sAL _DES:P.A\’F1¢I)LL 2.24C=.r’-38 OS-I3‘:-Cit
;’:’D=f-i.WT€I!='JOGOC?C*G*lJ.‘l91 EFF BATE: O1OE=3*= _!NDN:‘v"A-SUDE‘.*AN.A
Cast: Bepomt %nterestEI:1rn£-=<:i E3 E39 U5-31-01
P3 :17 -(I? .-A
'!'ransactcne.refiectcixecki-1g ;~,=;1.\my from Aug -S‘-.2§3Q't Ehmt-zgh A-29 31 . 2591 ztnd brokerage actiwtyfrom Aug =’."1*._ . = ‘IhfGLtg?1 Aug 3t,20£>1
Activity by type Bank activity: Hzliik ?.rn1».,::.'I_z:_-=u~ a\L‘£.‘iii 1.l::‘n::<;}: Fizmi-. Mi -‘\.mcm';1, \ \.
O
Q 11. _ "J" 11$ €Z=.:;..~4L1 1-.1;?e'“.1*:§1.-‘.*-*~*-§1 .§“'~‘5‘" "4 '7
11
...:-$' 1.n>=""
“"4. L\'J5'\__}
Pagei ::11§l§
Bankof America
cut
HI“-|'~.£'|'f1.Ei..' |l1.'\:U|.||]"l| 1'|-1.|.l1‘1'|'1C!‘1 *5. E1.:1.i~'.u1; :1::~;-.11.:111 1111111111.-1' P _
ii
j
Ii-
QtEFA
, £1 IT; -svaa _ Ema cffitmeriaa A w UL‘ {I Y:
1;‘: 1'}
if} ._;m;;.,._,... 1nvest,me=n1Sew1£ea,i11c.“"
3*-ME?I‘ C.'5.5?.'?i.-'P§ F’{]?-iD {IT Fl rpw J2 2'
...... F‘ E. A ” . $1.? T Fl '1?’ AF 15 5:1 £4
<§:5,_J;€§ 6,L%§;'¢~d3=~¢e 322: 3 Zkywo 2....
£10111: I-"¢'.'.":r-:1:-I’ E‘1r.~'r0rm:':'
0111111: Br:.m11'1rg1~.'1rJ1 1.‘.'H P.-1.-' 1:1:-: _:=r;>:r cfrccrl. rmrorrrzr E1rn'r:1::c.r, 1-1:1-. specific hmak rrrmrrrcmzutr. rrr.1:1-jII."1' 11:11:15. rec 1-.1311 .21: 11:'1;"c111.:* runs!’ _:m_. £11115 -- r.-n_. "1 -.-.|'1.-.1-1-1:.‘ _"|.'cm 111.1-c J'.=zrr."rm:'.1 net;-|:'.*;.r .Em1:.+H m:.=1-.-'_f.1rfl1:'r." O11H.=:c Er:m1.1'n_g. rm.-.1 :1:1:|:.*1'-'."? B11! Pu; 5.'1:r1*1-:11." :1: nu- 1:1;-ur-_;=:' Jrrsr 11::-gnu IE 1-.1 -1. £1m:§.'c:fr111:c:'1canon:
113 f-5“
.11 .311 1 "~'rr.w 1 1.111.‘. '—' -. P‘ .- r:.-A h“_';'.""’5‘=j__"‘IE":'*"__”“E _ 3.7“? R_*’_"‘_ "M5 -'- .".'r-‘.~'.~ -
I 11111:! ::~_~..1%r 1*r;i:.*:.*.f »<.-<1 --L F er: 2.11 9.1 W-L -.1 :-.:.:-.1:-.. Hm-=rr.:.... all-'E1| u:...c .-:.1Ame-1|-:.: |r1~r..-:.1n|1==r1r.:=e-1.1....-.._ ..|c: I-hr rm.|".=.u;_r 1':-'.".".' D15-::.c+un1 Brokerage SOOEEE 1111 ;, _- fir -11.1.- _‘ EOE!-‘Nes1Trade Etreet NC1-OEE-O5-O1
C1‘|E1f}ONE,NG 23255 11:1-.~.~.s:z.-... ;=:_.|~.%,|:=;=~ 31:-."_'|:'%-.--.§ 7"-3' 11.12:. \n....~--.- ~;.¢:...1;: ‘~».:"~.1-._... ‘I
‘an www-b&r1ku1amerj:a G11|11fm+:1:1&5rmanagBrf:ur1tac1 H1r;_I:*rr:'|*rr.|' qrrrtrmnrw m" ru1r|rm-11.1-1. _£|r H1.‘ N .‘1.:*:: M11 HEM h1§:11.:":1i W V _ \§'¢1}'_L::$0_§*_;1_lt1Q______ 1'1.'r|.~..: 1||.11-.: |Ir.11.:||1-.1i1-1|:-nl-.111+: 1l~..|.J_ lnr 2.11.-1:11.11-;:.|mn-. 1-1 -&..':1l‘r'tl11.:Il['\. -. _ . l‘|.'.1'--..' 1.‘-‘IH I-.‘11"~+!».ll11-.-.'1 :wa.'1"I-11.1.1 [HF “P“.'4..i|§L |.:1r-.-|Ii||ll-|.:l'|-u||t 1. u1l|=' 11.1-‘I-'.'-.II11ll. 1'i-1' ‘X iii”), H: H“! 2%‘; (‘UT run: "’"A{“{l g-:r|.:m| ||1lu-1u:1un||. 1.111: ||~ :1 www.han1tufamer||:a.r:nm H1111: H1“ '1.::|rr|'|.-:1 l|111:\||||r11+ "u'r1F1.'1:~1. |m.'.
:-. .11|1~11F1:_|||T-. ~.11|1~.u1r:|:'\ nl P-:|ui-1 ul '1.-||1-.-'11.:-1 1'1-.1 |- ~_"|-.:.;|-.'1i 11:uh..:r-tl.-;1L."| _:|u.l 111 . ||.:l1..-1" “- *1"-1 I. “ll”?
i?"2<1~m;=.1T Ar Ct’-1-’=-"**‘*~*'~” W“-*9 F1“? 4117 Page-!1::113
OOOEEEIJE
July 213132
£‘::_..u:1:~.:r 1121112; UASOOEVAH 5?-rnlccraga :u:.::::u:11 1111111?-.1111‘; 'l'iI7IT€|%@ 1.11-=:u:5».i.:1;_; :-11;.:*::1:::;. :|.1:11‘=:--.21": ,
1:1£=:.'::1":e a1.1r:1:*='.:::r"=;"
1.- .1 in j-I _l-III _i-—| _ 1- 111--IIII i ' liq .I QIII -1: Ii i ._I T11:
Iii!mam:-d _ ‘reams:--::.a1e.1 I-III I Tm: rzraird ‘fE::r;1g-_:1:.1_e -"— i- -
1;... Tafibifi. gnwme "" 1 " """" " Iv Taxes and withhnlfiings S-09 F
1 FCIC insured uweep interest $3.1.fi"'? $22E.'?O Tami HIE“ and Wimhflfdiflgs 5&5 E? ...-Q.-,,_.—,_|,. u|.-\ .-
‘ ‘ 3 - 22 . O .
Tfitak tfliabig mmmfl 1 QT ?-11.23’ mi-u.".:g,a nuf "5-'l1!1’1.'F.%‘lH. 01 duh; 31 , ".1'!1fl‘.L* ---" I 13"‘
- 'I'I-'
-.-..-n.-u-
Eb Nun+1a::ah1eincun1e Nxfiflns Carin 1 . Manon: Gvrernmerirfie-.;erve-a.._..-....- 1.55%» 5 t Tflt'flInfl"‘:3I3hfE ‘mama ‘Go ‘M 1‘1::.1'.;u:.-: Traasuqr 1.11.1.‘5*‘“.~. ‘ ; . i"w'.:n:-1:." Frfunicrpar A‘e.-:0-rves .......... .......................... .... .... ....... .. 13.1%? *1‘:- 1* Tan“ inflame $31 ‘E? $228“-Ffi 1'»-'.=1i...ms C‘a'iE:rr:1ra far-Exsrnpr F?es:-Wet 13.-E:é.*'5-41.
Ffiifi iimurfld :.r=.11-*=:1::.-1":~ interns!
-l -Ir-pI'l.u-Llr rl.-I I -l'|" 'I"r'
;"§_*-1=.'f,.' L--::;:a:’ .=|:1r.1.1-*1! :12-1::-1.-r111»;1~e 1+1‘:-1.‘: il'.1i!":‘.‘C I :..1;.'HE:‘1".::r.?§T1:;.t+=T1'¢‘_l -.
1 +1.5 z up-ur.n-u—|- .,_p.| .1-.1-_. er 2: .I..1.- 3:. .2: ‘.2 _l
. _ _ * _ m —||-3‘ _ ii ___ A i -__- __ I_ I— i .1 j .1 1 _L
Baily :11:-noun: r...m1mar-;
Tr-afirsiictiun
Tzar-2:1-::i::n" -'.'.'.|+.| 2:111-,~* III-!.151t:i1:a-1:-1:111 21111122111 {$1 C-:11: Tr?fi . i . _ .-_ __ _ _ ___ _
- -|-
ET?-Ci -CE Caah Cflpfle-E1 UT HEALTH ECiET~IC;CE$= C113 DEF‘ . 3.$Ofi-.5?
;:r.:1=:1:1:='51e. EFF 5:11.112; 1'.‘-EC?-"1‘.'.i1;E?~£ON:\.FA$UCE'H’A?1l,CEEZPA A.
OTC1-O2 Cash ‘11"=.'E11::1ru.w::1 CHECK OOOOOOOWO CEFEREMCE # 200.00-
s:2:a5a3aa2?5a4
O?-O1-O2 C:-1511 W'|1hdra1w:1E PAYMENT TC! CAFE EDI CEEPA 25.00- -
UACCCEEKFAH
638.00
O?-O2-Oi‘. Cash Ce pfil 1:11 EH.CFA.MEH1CA ATM O'?.I"OE COCOOOT1 OE CEPC=5!T‘§'ANGLE‘~N{3CC~ MET HCUETCN T211 'i
O?-O2-O2 Cash Wémdrawal 1_H~é1CAHE;O=ES=UH|CARE 144.00-
;1C=r11}1£111£E»i1'§EEBB?4EFF DATE: {121?r?1JE;!1-1U1~1;CEEPA vasuusvm O?-O2-O2 Caah Wiihd rawaf CHCFAMEHJCA 212122122 r::a11a::1:=.:1 20.00» .
'1A‘iT1-1CHW'LTF~NC1LE'W€}¢.'}C- MC 1 HGLJCTGH :-.»:
Cash Wi-1!1::1 rnwai CHECK OOOOOOOTEB HEFEHEHCE 1' ‘ -. 1 ,B67‘.0O-
O?‘-O3-OE
E»13F10:ii3E{.H3E5?E?
O?~O3-OE Cash WE1ht£r::1r.1a| Eatebux Fee 4fi.E!fl~
Cash ‘H’1‘"111':::1raw:1i CHECK E1000‘."1=E10?E'$ REFERENCE -1‘ 15.513-
OWFJ3-O2
3‘.‘3105.i‘.?rIT-L1?'i"&1=?2O
§Kmr>,\-r lq, ‘ .
Cam‘ P“-'25? '7o%"7
IJ-I"'~H'.‘1-=lr\.
9°<“'_~£l:u-A/CJ1*1
‘*1 Bamiib p.H°*?*""'-I9 - _J+r.J(:9_ 31¢
—
CJ31:
Hai- ;3j6:;1c.l§u.Ju! Q‘~4§'~\i<=--
EL
*C~M5<=~'
' k ~11.-
) :g'-|':-l--"\.£L- H glqpfi "E‘“'ei~ ' - . _;;l:>--~"
1 -rjlr 4:’ rg EL L
Z-g,»J‘,1,--L rw! -HIQ 1"‘? if-{.3 .
.3) ' "f?g,":|/Lrl f_2;g?,__;|f_¢_, I
Handwriting 14 Gold Bars EXHIBIT 15 pg 1 of 1
Cause No. 63935
DEEPA VASUDEVAN § IN THE DISTRICT COURT AND § 300TH JUDICIAL DISTRICT ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN § BRAZORIA COUNTY, TEXAS “Exhibit 15” says this in last paragraph Item (6) as handwritten by wife (Deepa): “14 Gold Bars”. See also inventory number 3 $900,000.00
\J_1'¢':_,F\ - .- ‘f=-:£'_.-_.--4.: :. .
' 1 1 '- L;__ rl-"--.. '-£21‘ _\"'---'Ir._.- _ \ <1,-A -"*3 --I-~=-.1-..~_¢-H. L--~ Q3" A L_.£=-=1-_:.§ (L '“ _ {-1}? __ Q‘: _$_.rR-iJ.¥____\\'J_'______ __;_i _§..,:.>_ ‘ET * .
- ..-- ~|;"~<\__,.~._-~+r-.!~-»-._- — - - __"‘i-,-
{ --,_._-.~ _ | -, ~"
~_,_\_.v-=-_E.":=\-‘~I-. 1" ¢;:-\,§~_ .. _ L -L L.-1‘- F I _L_ 1 F? k¢Q f {ELanHG @;~::,=.;-
__ ‘____L.\_ ___. W, -_-.'-"‘-.-
X L11 -=. *" .. L _. . -4 ‘.£_f__ $3» L1‘ *4: =_§._g__,
TE‘
"U
,1--..__ _ r _ - .1 1;. \.__J L; \‘~.:\{-J3?-...,} (£3! ' --—- r_§. {L'C"' -3" .‘ tr;-I ,1»-'..=.--.1 r I '" Q3 5° '“ '1-.-".‘= -
_+__ ‘r-\___;j'rf1.L-r\.E_J__-
. - -- P‘ ‘*1’-1 _ . -' 4-
-"' v/ .-;,-4:-'- . -La.3"'*"‘-"4' I _ - -1 I‘.-r_-,(._.‘ £5-*5 |.,~-~r\.;*‘—.=--Q ‘T"~—-- __ _ _ _ _ ‘Cs. _,,¢_ ‘r'\..--- - M r--‘IT: .
_ _ |,_,..|~_ , - =t£-_;,_ 1+ --
5‘! __,-L 'V\.r'-- .
rir
"' “|v'~.u._.---=.'_ \*-L."-'_.t5*-‘=~'-"=1 5- " " " ¢'-u'~'_-- '
- r‘ J,‘ 1 _'5;fr_ 1---*-; -
P‘ 1 \-:.=_LE;-1%.
’i>‘~ E-""'“=* —— ""' ' — —
h'1-._:_;:--\_- *'-"-*- “i-- ’-L L
J _ ‘Ln -;--r--c;1-.~§u.'._. . I _ :-1;. :3 ~_\__ .5 -___._é___ .3- <._1;.~_-._ -H __ (LL _ :1. <_____H3 . -
_l _ I .-¢__,,- -—~-=1, '
<1 5 " ' _ .--, ' I _ -1 I
__ Ca-‘~42, 7-1;‘-""‘-;‘?'“' Ck L - i-L. ._.__ T- it-L1-‘~E‘--~.._-::L :1-#1-~ I . " 1.1.‘. <5 F-‘\ i-‘-‘"- "U -1. '- "‘- ‘“ 1% .___ i'§"*'"“"'L' kg-L'.5’LLhk\_t """‘ ""
-_ _ c'-.=-..£._ -- ":§3"""~ '-" C’ -_ , (J,--L}-L1-'
'-
F-_ 1-"'l'-‘-C-_--'' L;-Jig‘ -1 *_' I _ u -I‘ I J C: i_::Li._._\ __, 11- ‘ 6_;__'|L'L‘::l~',\_£T\‘-L4,!-1"\-’ Q\~§Q ,
“N” _ ‘ '. ;-1'3 A “— 1, M»... rp- 4.1 *~ __ cf .1 ~._ I 5 E P 61);, LL4‘ “ ~'.__H_'H._-_.|.._,1L*-._.n]-.4-= ‘Flu-=~"'—-1L"__-3':-.56-' _- # E ’ ___} ¢’/T fi.,;__j _ i=1“ --~1‘:.~‘~ -‘___-' _ 1 _ l'?1|-_"_£-_A\_" ' -"_ '_ -.- -- $,¢'.‘1l.._r _ Q‘ 4.;£l3{_i-:4.-~_.~ -—=‘-P I5 )“€J.u\»‘="- 5-¢'“'-"‘“-¢’—- L1: Era
~—'s 14' Gt.-'3='E—'-'-£ €’CL'M“ i
__- Wfl
- - 35-1.;-_. ~-== _.. _ . . '1. '1 ', -r ~ - -L?
.. _-~'=:..¢..,-.L;~s. "'1"
S" '* - - - 4 £1 L‘-"1:-1.21 c--Lib‘-U"“u' i_ G ri-1] :r\.=’§I_2+ . |—» (1.-1 ¢~u»'—*‘ ‘G __ ,. - ,_ —f—L~LC-L - w' fir“ Ex K/3 (.*_-.>-»~~&_, -- 1m'G{:PQ ‘E Q7; Lmg-afljldu =1‘-*'““~*='*i-:'1‘ . . "‘%@L_’¢n,,_,..¢~_ W.
C5 -£91 _,_,___ (P% Mi?
Page 1 of 1
"L.
H
<7? ..-... "'T‘lF-"!£J1"~..£'Q él_~L-1* ‘*3 ‘T’ ' 1 '1.
.--.
?-' .
,_
I
_
L‘_\__(_‘___};.:i.$\_,
.
.._.
\'~§JQ,» _
‘<“*‘\~l'~..~...;*L"_- *7‘ L-£,‘U_'LbTj
-hp (iv ,.,.
|
1-‘,
r§%!‘1 :~~.~L_, ~ _ _______>§ '
W ~=;~__’_(>Ei4g~
Z _,__ B _,, 4;. Lt-"~.._,.» ._._ \w_,..L@.,\-ii \_>\
Qi\££bxt@w§» bib” Kg {\¥'Z'_§I- _‘ K is H . _ .;"'=~ ‘c W
5 .;_.-I "'
'\ \
{-5
, .1 -\
.;
(H;
.-_“ _ ‘ ,,.- H ,. Q/- __T '\. C,i‘>L'~=-I "" 3‘5~*, < tin)
_ -1’ \'__?
F}-J.9 %:$?*A~» w\vi>\-..m - l\"\_“']
f.,*>lC..1q>"‘S . L ».
g3_5 F 5.. ¢».;.;.-\.~ * -.
\,_.' _§
? ~+ r»-Q,,, *f\-Q‘ ‘"n'L'niLJ e ~ y @-_.¢
-‘r J4:
/‘ ?LJ°\
..- Q;-£"“'\ - I xi} . " "9 ’ ,-.
G ? ‘.4?’ 4, vx,-I fx) =1; , _ ,_ F - L, ;<-;i..;;,»k..€ 1.‘-"‘--" " ’ ; ‘ ii
iii;-“'
.j
‘*3 \v'\s'.;._,+ 2..
_ - I RC? I’
r5<1"<'-# =1'7\""L”&\'§% ‘L V L l'“'_l ~ 1- _ _ 1 - 1,./’ ;.+=J'1 -Q5-"—""""“’-" ‘ I :LLg>_@ :1-~-~.:.-1-. ‘*~'>- -= a"ki_:;-\__§_, ‘\"'---x \:'_,_,: t 3
65’ 2
_\.
~“-_ ,.. I L» 1-H‘ r ,.... _ gfi I“ ‘—lfl" "'1 I/:11 ‘J *4“<;_\.1..
~” w7*“**~ “ ' C; #-C1LfiL “QM _, _ _,~..Q,,. Q. 1 , #1.-ii. -
- ""’ _ L-. " ¢£‘\___{..i-'-5~..-"“\..
.._. EsP~l- ‘ \, 1 ______,,.. (._..-* LL 5""
,-"_~~..’
. _
I/\
P H ‘kl-1 (:1“~ Kai-‘\ 53* L"':L‘ . § .1, 3; 1,;.Lx_,1~_¥\‘-~*~“"'
*6 ,__. cw-Q» .____ (',.u-.-é-L ' I P '
“___- Ed"'\Q/ - L’ ‘I.
(>1 r.L{)-~\’5ét“J“¥JvH
I
-
A H. Mt’
? rvyb ,;;,-~.
4; LL¢~~@-~**"~*
FQ ~ Win gnu. u (-"K ff’ Q c“M\,l_‘§_, kw +__ U D .‘u , Md» 4' _ -" i__ "'-"L
_
H % .% L ,:&_ wfl£?)5J@TLF6i§ @#\ LL*~k1 .' _ ‘_ ._ _1 _.._-;~= I‘ ‘E’ _.. L- ___:-L RM L -I-___:i‘_____|.|1_ P ___. _*] _ i 057- -
~_._.-i . H_:L__;__w\.
':'irj-_ _ F: __ I HJU {"'Q)I‘ *&-» *"
(E, ;£L“'Cl!r--L»-~.._.- ~-‘=7 '5 »*--Q»-»~=> —*~=*-~@I .I
. . T’
,
L
1
~» Qii- J '
("_.-
I
._ A.<1 Q~ {_&\;~o c"5'¥‘i‘-1‘ J ml“
.1 _.\;
r; U
1
L U
{
{aw}. ' WQ
‘" -
£1
1 r
l-'-) gi_x\__."\ W , Mn. “_
LR _ ~,. U)- 2 u\ --‘Zl_,“\:,J -.. Q Q \/*r\§L3-w.§ —\.-G»-W * -.-§J_1..."1:~S__ 1,] __
11111 v-"*"‘-* ' '
__;‘1_,n_.i*i~’.--7'»\-- " '1‘
Appendix O Index from District Clerk Office The index from district clerk which was sent to Appeals Court by the District Clerk Office will be referred as “IDX” followed by page number (Appendix O)
' .-\.-\.-\.-\. '
IL .
%
.||- I '$"'¥'i3'~$-E~4- 53 3 fi EH ET. i--:H;u$<t, i‘i:.1itr::. IT‘-'[i=-5] . *?'?*:1-?@2'1Eu'~ 1 1% H1:
Ar:=§ir.1-fin‘ TI"; 1’?i1i‘-
-\..
"1- ..»_ 31%?--1‘:-fa-!.?1l¥é _ _ _ _ ;.In:. _ ___-kw 1, :-:'-.F..li_|l' T ;=..=h-jig '11:’
-'- . ,_'H_,_
H
-'._F: ‘_fI-’E_.ill‘:Hfi'-L-far: "’'Jrr.
:§1x1¢§§:a,;fi.Lfi;%1,:£“i1.§@.ai..¢.a.'
Y "§*-*§1-kin
HT‘-H?
§‘%*1- -"--2*
‘iii’.-
F" " .r""
:
- mi; H ._ _ II. I-IH‘l'."._:|
fi E r»
-."‘!rfi.'!‘
'.R'H(')N DA BAR.C'.HAK
'i)IS"I"R1C"Ii‘ CIQERK
BRAZIHHA can E‘~I"l"‘&’
D€i..‘»i.":‘H'i§‘JEi' 29, I-':i{H4
ziE:%w'{1|;‘:1* 'v'a5:1£iri3w"a11 PO E3~;:§:@; '?1{]E63 I-*l{:u&;t=::+§1% TX "?”?2?1
RE: 1'§Im,1se11c>. 63935 Eétyiazz {)1€iI€i?J-k “v"AS'l} DEV£152 ‘F55. ALA‘v'{}fiR ‘W&E§I_'I'i}1T\i+&1*€'
1363: $ir»"??~.’iz1da:r1:
EF.1":c1-mad you will find a cop}: +11"? tin: fardera {.:m1r:a:a"ni11g tint: :»1p1;n::a.i asraigraed to tin: Fm1rt::¢;-amh Cimrt of Appeals far the: E-.’=ET}i;3‘»-‘£2 1m".:1:£.én|1e<;i tazaw-:
'i“E1zmk }?CEfi\ RI-i{I}N£}A BAR,CI-l'AK, District fifierk i . . "fill 1 l _
riw '?\1icc~Eaa Juners, £}epm;,:
hiiwciima :1:
CAUSE NO. 63935 300th District Conn
DEEPA VASUDEVAN VS ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
INDEX
COVER . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . n n 1 | | u Q ¢ Q | u u | n u n q - o - o o | a n I ¢ n u Q c ¢ I .1.
I
CAPTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . n u u - - - - - . q a | - | ¢ > a n » | . Q n | I n I - I Q Q | Q Q | | A a c | | Q | - u - I u o u n a ¢ » | Q J ; 1|:
2
"E
I-NDTEIX - | y q q | q ; p - - - - Q | | - | ¢ n o a q n > ¢ 1 I Q n -rnnnlnu | Q I I n u | u I -- u u | , , | . , . |. | Q . ¢ . q q . - - - - n c | n | I I u I I I m Q | - .1-q .
APPLICATION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 6-28-I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. 8
TEMPORARY EX PARTE PROTECTIVE ORDER AND ORDER SETTING IIEARING 6-28-II . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. A 0 I 0 I I I I 0 I I I I I I I | I I I I 0 v I Q L 0 I Q I 0 d iiiiil I7
RESPONDENT'S ANSWER TO APPLICATION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
7-8- I I. Q q | | ; q Q Q | Q . n Q I n o I I 0 I u | 0 I I u I 1 u I u | I - u | | ¢ o o o n o 1 I 6 I I I I I I l O I I I | u u - Q n ¢ ¢ » a o ¢ u u u - n a u Q | . n I n ¢ I Q o u o Q s u-u
24
WAIVER OF SERVICE 7-I2-I I. I I I O Q I I Q O 1 I I Q I I I O 4 l l I I I I I I I Q | I I | I u u n r o Q n u Q s o n u q s n I I o I - I I m I ll‘ 2.7
SCHEDULING ORDER 7-22-II . I Q a u n | I I I I I I I u u u u I I n u u | I n v o n u - - - I | I I I I I I I I Q c n I Q 0 | I u I I | ' --
29
TEMPORARY ORDERS 7-22-1 I ¢ Q I - | n - 1 | n | | | q l n c I o | I I - - - . -- . . . . . . . , . . . . . . - - - . - - - - | Q u Q o | » a {-Q 30 MOTI()N TO CONSOLIDATE 2-7-I P. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . , . , . . . 4 ; ¢ a p - ¢ | ¢ Q Q - n - ; n n n | u n n 1 use 46 MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 2-21-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... 48 ORDER ON MOTION FOR SIIBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 2-21-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE 2-21-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. - . 1 ¢ , . - - u o a ¢ u - o | | - - - - n n n | c I | u | 1 I + 1 Q I.- 55 ORDER ON NIOTIONTO CON SOLIDATF. 3-29-I2. p p | | I ' q q n n Q u | Q a a - | n | u u Q n o a Q n - - I J m m a |
56
MOTION TO MODIFY TEMPORARY ORDERS 59 RULE II AGREEMENT 3-21-I2 Q | ' q y n Q Q u | L o n o u p - Q Q Q u - n nu Q q I 0 | Q q ' p u ' ; | y - c | o u n Q Q o Q Q v u u u u I I 8 Ii!-
6|
ADDITIONAL TEMPORARY ORDER FOR CI IILD SUPPORT 9-I1-12...... .. 63 MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL I2-I8-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66 INVENTORY AND APPRAISENIENT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAN IE2-27-12..-...:... 63 ATTORNEY’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS ATTORNEY IN CHARGE
,_-| I ~.> I4.) '11 LA) . . . , . . . ¢ - » ¢ - . ¢ . - . - .-.,,.--¢--u|-I- | | u - - | o u a u u Q r I - » n o - - - I II u o I | I u u I u n - I o u | u u 1 Q u u u o o - - - i I o 0 w 1 Q I!
W
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN'S MOTION TO SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 80 I-28-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ORDER ON ALAVOOR VASUDEVANS MOTION TO SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 1-29-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 83 ALAVOOR VASUDE-VAN‘S MOTION TO COMPEL 2-I4-I 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 84 BAILIFF’S RESPONSE 3-11-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 86 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO COMPEL 3-I 5-I3 .................................. .. 37 ALAVOOR VASUDEVANS REQUEST FOR COURT ORDER 3-19-13 .......... .. 88 CERTIFICATE OF NONAPPE-ARANCE 7-12-I3 ....................................... _. 130 FIRST AI\/IENIDED ORIGINAL cOI.II~:TE-RFETITION FOR ~D-IVORCIE- I-'.-Pl La-J _ Us l\J L_1
DESIGNATION OF ATTORNEY IN CHARGE s-7- I 3 ................................ .. 138 RULE 11 AGREEMENT 8-27-13 .......................................................... .. 140 ORDER DISCHARGING AMICUS ATTORNEY 9-6-13 .............................. .. 145 FIRST AMENDED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEMENT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAN 9-I7-13 ...................................................................... .. I46 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS 9-23-13. . .. . 155 MEDIATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AS TO PALLAVI DEV I0-21-I3..... I56 FIRST AMENDED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEMENT OF ALAVOOR VASUDEN I0-29-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I59 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS 310-30-I3 . . . . . .. I66 CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION I0-30-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I67 SECOND AMENDED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEME-NT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAN I0-30-I3. I . . . ........... _.,...... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I68 FIRST SUPPLEMENT TO FIRST AMENDED ORIGINAL COUNTERPETITION
FOR DIVORCE II-22-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I74 MEDIATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT EXCEPT AS TO CUSTODY,
POSSESSION AND CHILD SUPPORT ISSUES I2-I 3-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I76
SECOND SUPPLEMENT TO ORIGINAL COUNT'ERPETITION FOR DIVORCE
I2-I6-I 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I80 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS I2-I9-I3 . . . . . .. I81 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS I-9-I4 . . . . . . . . .. I82
SCI--IlT€I'.'.]¥.§I...II'€G OR.E3EI1.AN§)NOTIC-E OF INTE-NT TH} EI)ZSFI/IISS E-2?~I 4. . I33
I‘-’EOTIO'N' I-"OR W{TI--I EJRAWA L OF COI._§'NSEI... 3-11?’-.1 I1 .............................. .. .234
ORDER ON I'-’I{}TION FOR ‘ISII-’i'TIE--III.?1I1’...r’-‘I'II~»"".AII_, OF {.'-{J UN SE1. ff»-26-I<1 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I93
T?--URI} .~'?‘I~.§V¥I*'.I‘-li.I}'I‘.'r}I1'.'I IN "-FE-NTOIIIIT .Ai."F'I{AISEI\-IE-NT OF iI}.EEP.A VASLIDE VAN SR5» Z IL. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I92
A F I*‘ZIIl*A.V1"'l“ O E L? S E NES S RECOR.{§1S 5-?- I Ii . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I93
N{}I"] C E OF F11 .EN (E (1)1? BUS IN E SS 1{.§%'.{jlC}RII3 A F FF DA VIT 5 -$*» I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E3?)
FOUR"]"I*~I AIVIENDEIJ ¥I\I'VE-E‘\E'{'I'}RY AI‘~l'D APPRAISEIVIENT OF IJEEPA ‘v’Af€5I...?1'.".'II#If.‘I.*'.1*\I?'~I' 5-27- I Ff. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 19]
FLK¥II'B.I"'1""*C{}URT‘S ' ¥}IVIS'IOI‘-I OF "PIILOPIZ-Ej{T"f 'i'-E?- E4". '. '. .'. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . '.?.'.‘13'5"'
EX}-ZI_¥3IT LIST 5-27-15%.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 393
CORRE-SPONi).ENCI£-E.I?‘E') ATi":L (J? INVENTORY I'*"I{iI.!R ES 5~3I)-14 ............. .. 3{}=i
I:i}iI'-TIBET LIST {:1-‘Fl’-I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 305
E.T>{HiBET 1..-I ST-MERITS E"IE.AR_lN{_I 6-*1}-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 396
I_§PE'.'}.ATE OF INVENTORY FIGIERES 6»? 13- I FI . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . 38?‘
RE-POR'I'“I'ZR‘S {TE-RTIFICA'l'“l{}N DEPOSITION OF ALA VOIIR VASL?[3iliVAI‘§ 6- I 6»-»§ 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 309
PRAYIII-F6-{I(““}RRE£T'E‘.EONS TO "II¢’OR!}ENI'.'¥S TE‘-I J£§.D{3€\»1EN']" 6-1’?-M . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 312.
REPIIBRTERIS CER"¥“¥P’I£'IAFI"lON DEP(I}SI'?I{l}'J‘\’ %:"IY WRTIITEN OIJSTIONS OF '['}EEP.I'I VASUDEVAN 6-24-14 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 322
PRAYER-COl{RI¥LCTIONS ‘ITJ E}]Iv'OI-I{'.I¥.%l DEGREE IN TI---IE FINAL }[__I'IjJ{_}I*~wI_I£NTI." 6-24- M . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 325
REOIIEST FOR ¥I'-I'I.'.'If?;R_!_.."-f‘_§ DIVORCE OT.~T.D!I~EF_If_ ?-'F- I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , ._. .. . . . . . . -- 3.34
R.E(}UES'E" I~'O]?. I?\I"§"¥?:RIZ\*I .DIVORCE {_}RI)I-IR-E}ENI'E.ED KR}--I T-3-Ii ............ .. 336 13.: ‘-..rJ ‘Q
PE..EAi)I"N{iS~R.I.iOI-FEST COR.R.EC'['iONS TO INVENTORY ["i"I‘.?=IEV’f #2. ?-i?'-I-RI... PI'.-EA}f}TN('IS-EIEIQUEST C(Y}I?.IIEf_'".TII.TJ?\IF§ Ti.) IN V ["1-lN'I"ORY ITEIK-‘I #2 RIiC[§';'i\:’I€If.} FROM] Of§.){JR."I" F’-I?-111 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......... ... .. ... . . .. .. ... ...... 342
YVIOTZON TO SIGN DEC-R iii-#1 OF [HVORC I} QI...% A I...{F1iiD DOMESTIC REL-ATIONS OR.i.'.3Zrl[~‘-‘. {I-T114 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. FIJI-4
'IVIOTI{')N E--IEARING OF 15 AI.J€.'I 1301.4 5:1-iE~'I.=-’I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 3 iifti
FINAL {)E{TRE%.1l OF {DIVORCE H-I 5-‘I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 318
QUALIFIED DOMESTIC RELATIONS ORDER 8-I5-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . - .. .... 360
RECONSIDERATION OF TRIAL AND NOTICE OF APPEAL 9-I2-14.. ..... 364
ORDER DENYING MOTIONS I0-8-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... 372 REQUEST FOR COURT RECORDS FOR I4TII COURT OF APPEALS I2-17-14 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 373 BILL OF COSTS I2-24-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 377 DOCKET SHEET. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . .. . 378 CASE SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . I .,. 383 CLERICS CERTIFICATE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 393
Appendix O Index from District Clerk Office The index from district clerk which was sent to Appeals Court by the District Clerk Office will be referred as “IDX” followed by page number (Appendix O)
' .-I.-I.-I.-I. '
IL .
%
.||- I 'IJ"'?i3'~1.IIE~+I- 53 I fi III IT.I-{1-I.lEt:iI.5i.III¢.IHIII . *??I:I-32'IH~ I 3 III AI’21EIf.!.I'!fl. TI"; 7731:‘-
-I..
"H.- ..3- 335--7.‘:-1'5:-!.3IIE _ _ _ _ ;.In. _ ___-kw ‘I, :-I'-.F..li_|l' T ;.=.h-jig '1-'1.-*'
- . ,_'H_,_
I1 -‘Ti?-_f: ._: _IE_.ll‘H-I, "’'Jrr.
:3;I.I:3;.3I3:=I.3;II.I.*I.3..:T.II.3I.I.3....I..'
F Rm §
-‘Tn-T
F"
§‘%*I- -'-*3“
‘iii’.-
" .r""
:
- D3" A ._ _ II. ITTT'."._:|
fi E r»
-."‘!rfi.'!‘
'.RI~I(')N DA BA.R.C'.HAK 'i)IS"I"R1C"Ii‘ C1'...ERK }3RAZI)‘£HA C{J+'!.'.E NTE
Eififi-Ii‘II'iI?E3i' 29, I-':i{II4
.AIIaI=I'IIIr VF15¥J£'IE3‘~E3I‘I PO E3133‘. TIIIE63 |"I{ll13I€3§1. TX I"72?I
RE: 1'.'“.".."-R.I3c 110- 63935 5%¥.}=II3: {HI 1,11%‘;-‘II. “v"AS'I.}DEVAN ‘IFS. A..I..AV{}fJB. VAE§I_'I'i}1TVA1*I'
DB3: SirI"?3’IzIIIII:rI:
EF.I"II:1-."I.~:I3I:I y=:aI: will find R cop}: +11"? E111: hzderr. I.“.‘IIJI1l;2i.i*I"flI1‘Ig IEII3 :».IpI;II::II.i asaigwd ED I213: FIRIIRI;-IIIII1 C6III'I; of .*‘apg3eal3 ?I3r1iII": HDUR-‘E IIII".II:£.IO|Ie<;I $31133:
'i“E1a13k }*C*I.I. RI-IKIINQA B.='kR,CI-FAX, District fifierk i . . "fill 1 l _
23>-
'?\Iic<3Ea3 Jones. £.T>I:p:II;,:
I.-;lI"II;:E{I3I.::*<:
CAUSE NO. 63935 300th District Conn
DEEPA VASUDEVAN VS ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
INDEX
COVER . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . n n 1 | | u Q ¢ Q | u u | n u n q - o - o o | a n I ¢ n u Q c ¢ I .1.
I
CAPTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . n u u - - - - - . q a | - | ¢ > a n » | . Q n | I n I - I Q Q | Q Q | | A a c | | Q | - u - I u o u n a ¢ » | Q J ; 1|:
2
"E
I-ND.E-)5. - | y q q | q ; p - - - - Q | | - | ¢ n o a q n > ¢ 1 I Q n IIIIIIIII | Q I I n u | u I -- u u | , , | . , . |. | Q . ¢ . q q . - - - - n c | n | I I u I I I m Q | - .1-q .
APPLICATION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 6-28-I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . L. 8
TEMPORARY EX PARTE PROTECTIVE ORDER AND ORDER SETTING IIEARING 6-28-II . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. A 0 I 0 I I I I 0 I I I I I I I | I I I I 0 v I Q L 0 I Q I 0 d iiiiil I7
RESPONDENT'S ANSWER TO APPLICATION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER
7-8- I I. Q q | | ; q Q Q | Q . n Q I n o I I 0 I u | 0 I I u I 1 u I u | I - u | | ¢ o o o n o 1 I 6 I I I I I I l O I I I | u u - Q n ¢ ¢ » a o ¢ u u u - n a u Q | . n I n ¢ I Q o u o Q s u-u
24
WAIVER OF SERVICE 7-I2-I I. I I I O Q I I Q O 1 I I Q I I I O 4 l l I I I I I I I Q | I I | I u u n r o Q n u Q s o n u q s n I I o I - I I m I ll‘ 2.7
SCHEDULING ORDER 7-22-II . I Q a u n | I I I I I I I u u u u I I n u u | I n v o n u - - - I | I I I I I I I I Q c n I Q 0 | I u I I | ' --
29
TEMPORARY ORDERS 7-22-1 I ¢ Q . - | n - 1 | n | | | q l n c I o | I I - - - . -- . . . . . . . , . . . . . . - - - . - - - - | Q u Q o | » a {-Q 30 MOTI()N TO CONSOLIDATE 2-7-I P. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . , . , . . . 4 ; ¢ a p - ¢ | ¢ Q Q - n - ; n n n | u n n 1 use 46 MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 2-21-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... 48 ORDER ON MOTION FOR SIIBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 2-21-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 51 ENTRY OF APPEARANCE 2-21-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. - . 1 ¢ , . - - u o a ¢ u - o | | - - - - n n n | c I | u | 1 I + 1 Q I.- 55 ORDER ON NIOTIONTO CON SOLIDATE 3-29-I2. p p | | I ' q q n n Q u | Q a a - | n | u u Q n o a Q n - - I J m m a |
56
MOTION TO MODIFY TEMPORARY ORDERS 59 RULE II AGREEMENT 3-21-I2 Q | ' q y n Q Q u | L o n o u p - Q Q Q u - n nu Q q I 0 | Q q ' p u ' ; | y - c | o u n Q Q o Q Q v u u u u I I 8 Ii!-
6|
ADDITIONAL TEMPORARY ORDER FOR CI IILD SUPPORT 9-I1-12...... .. 63 MOTION FOR SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL I2-I8-I2 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I 66 INVENTORY AND APPRAISENIENT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAN 162-27-I2..-....I. 63 ATTORNEY’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS ATTORNEY IN CHARGE
,_-| I ~.> I4.) '11 LA) . . . , . . . ¢ - » ¢ - . ¢ . - . - .-..,.--¢--u|-I- | | u - - | o u a u u Q r I - » n o - - - I II u o I | I u u I u n - I o u | u u 1 Q u u u o o - - - i I o 0 w 1 Q I!
TI
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN'S MOTION TO SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 80 I-28-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. ORDER ON ALAVOOR VASUDEVANS MOTION TO SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 1-29-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 83 ALAVOOR VASUDE-VAN‘S MOTION TO COMPEL 2-I4-I 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 84 BAILIFF’S RESPONSE 3-11-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 86 ORDER DENYING MOTION TO COMPEL 3-I 5-I3 .................................. .. 37 ALAVOOR VASUDEVANS REQUEST FOR COURT ORDER 3-I9-I3 .......... .. 88 CERTIFICATE OF NONAPPEARANCE 7-12-I3 ....................................... _. 130 FIRST AMENDED ORIGINAL COI.II~:TE-RFETITION FOR DSIYORCE I-'.-Pl '~.J. J _ Ca l\J L_1
DESIGNATION OF ATTORNEY IN CHARGE 8-7- I 3 ................................ .. 138 RULE 11 AGREEMENT 8-27-13 .......................................................... .. .40 ORDER DISCHARGING AMICU S ATTORNEY 9-6-13 .............................. .. 145 FIRST AMENDED INVENTORY AND APFRAISEMENT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAN 9-I7-13 ...................................................................... .. I46 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS 9-23-13. . .. . 155 MEDIATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT AS TO PALLAVI DEV I0-21-I3..... I56 FIRST AMENDED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEMENT OF ALAVOOR VASUDEN I0-29-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I59 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS 610-30-I3 . . . . . .. I66 CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION I0-30-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I67 SECOND AMENDED INVENTORY AND APPRAISEME-NT OF DEEPA VASUDEVAN I0-30-I3. . . . . ........... _.,...... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I68 FIRST SUPPLEMENT TO FIRST AMENDED ORIGINAL COUNTERPETITION
FOR DIVORCE II-22-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I74 MEDIATED SETTLEMENT AGREEMENT EXCEPT AS TO CUSTODY,
POSSESSION AND CHILD SUPPORT ISSUES I2-I 3-I3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I76
SECOND SUPPLEMENT TO ORIGINAL COUNTERPETITION FOR DIVORCE
I2-I6-I 3 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I80 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS I2-I9-I3 . . . . . .. I81 SCHEDULING ORDER AND NOTICE OF INTENT TO DISMISS I-9-I4 . . . . . . . . .. I82
SCI--III€I'.'.]¥.§I...ING (}R.DEI1..A.N§)NOTIC-E OF INTE-NT TH} EIHSFI/I.ISS 3-27-I 4. . I83
I‘-’EOTIO'N' I-"OR VJETI--I§.)I~1AIPII'AI.. OF COI._§NSEI... 3-17-.14 .............................. .. .284
ORDER ON I'-’IOTION FOR ISII-’i'TIE--III.?1I1’...-’-‘I'II~»"".A.I_. OF {.'-{J UN SE1. 3-26-I61 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. IRE
T?--IIRD A§V£ENi.I}I‘.?.I1} IN "-3??-NTOIIIIT .Ai.IF'I{AISEI\-IE-NT OF iI}.EEP.A VA.SUDE VAN 5-5-» Z 4.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. I93
A F I*‘ZI}A.VI"'l“ O E U S E NES S RECORD S 5 -7- I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I93
NOT I C E OF F11 .EN (3 O F BUS IN E SS 1{.§.*.'.{jlCIR.II3 A F I-II DA VIT 5 -S*- I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38*?)
FOUR"I"I*~I AMENDEI) ¥N'VE-N'{'I'}RY .A'ND APPRAISE-IVIENT OF FJEEPA V.A.SI..§1'.?Iél\*'AN' 5-27» I 3. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 39]
FLKHI'B.II"-C{}URT‘S ' ¥}IVISIOI‘~i OF "PI§I*.OPIZ-E1311"? '5-37- E4". '. '. .'. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .'.?.'.‘13'5"'
EX}-ZIEEIT 1..].ST 5-27-14.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 393
CORRESPONi).ENCI3-I.I?‘E') ATi":L (IF INVENTORY I'*"I{iI.!R ES 5~3I)-14 ............. .. 3{}=i
I:i}iI'-TIBET LIST 6-‘Fl’-I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 305
E.T>{Hil"3ET 1..-I ST-MERITS E"IE.AR_lNO {I-*1}-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 396
I_§PI'.'}A.TE OF INIHZNTORY FIGURES 6-E 3- I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . 387
RE-PORTI'ZR‘S CE-RTIFICA'l'“I{}N DEPOSITZON OF ALA VOIIR V.ASI}[3iliVAI‘§ 6- I =6-I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 309
PRAYE-R-C("}RRECT.EONS TO "III.-"OR!}ENOS IE‘-I J¥.§.O{3€\»1EN']" 6-17-I61 . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 312.
REPORTEI-!..‘S CER"¥“¥P’I£'IAFI"lON DEP(IISI'?IO'J‘\’ HY ‘JVRITTEN OIJSTIONS OF '['}EEPA VASUDEV AN 6-24-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 322
PRAY E-1?.-COI{I{FLC"IIONS TO DIVORCE DECREE IN TI---IE FINAI. }[__I'IJ{_EvI_I3NTI." 6-34- M . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 325
REOIIEST FOR ¥N'I'.'IfiR_!_.."-f‘_§ DIVORCE OR.D!EF_I_ 7-7- I 4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ._. .. . . . . . . -- 3.34
R.E(}UES'E" FOR I?\I"§"ERIZ\*I DIVORCE {_}RI)I-'-IR-DENI'E.ED KR}--I 7-8-I-"I ............ .. 336 =., I.I ‘-..rJ ‘Q
PE..EAi)I"NOS~R.EOI-IEST COR.R.E-C'['IO.-NS TO INVENTORY ["i"EI\-”f #2. 7-Z7-I-4... PIQEA.DTN('IS-RI;lQI.IEST C(Y}I?.REC.TII.3?\IS Ti.) INVIZ-l'N'I"ORY ITEIK-‘I #2 REC[I;':IVEIf.} FROIYI 'Cf§.)UR."I" 7-I7-14 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......... ... .. ... . . .. .. ... ...... 342
YVIOTZON TO SIGN DEC-R E1-#1 OF OIVORC If)
OI...%AI...iF"1ED DOMESTIC REL-ATIONS OR.II!Zrl[~‘-‘. {ii-7-14 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 31E-4
'IVIOTI{')N E--IEARING OF 15 AI..IO EU I.-1 53- IE-E4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 3 =16
FZNAZ... {)ECRE%:l OF DIVORCE S-I 5-‘I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 348
QUALIFIED DOMESTIC RELATIONS ORDER 8-I5-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. .... 360
RECONSIDERATION OF TRIAL AND NOTICE OF APPEAL 9-I2-14.. ..... 364
ORDER DENYING MOTIONS I0-8-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........... 372 REQUEST FOR COURT RECORDS FOR I4TII COURT OF APPEALS I2-I7-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 373 BILL OF COSTS I2-24-I4 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. 377 DOCKET SHEET. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . 378 CASE SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . . . . ... 383 CLERICS CERTIFICATE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 393
Appendix P Notice of Appeal Sent through District Clerk Office Appellee says “no notice of appeal is included in the clerk’s record, the appeal should be denied...” (BR at 8). This appendix is a proof of District clerk office sending the notice to 14 th Appeals court. See also: RR3 page 4 line 13, IDX 373.
__]u5tj¢_.|35 Chic.1».Ju:-stict:
" -1<;E.:~.i ' FI I[)TwIl’SO1\' FROST VVFILI .I A I'-II BOYCE .-' -. 1' '1'R6.c Y Caatstor-IIER -I" _. MARTI-IA HILL .I.I.I.-IISON ‘ Clcrk Fir-I.6Ror~I Iw-ICCALLY ' ‘" “ C-HRISTUPI il-ZR A. I"RI!\' E I.1ouN L)oNowIN Zllnurtnnntli (llmtrt nf Appeals I1.-6»--YIEY-17-I-NI I*~'1-ARI? W BRv\1'~»'1\' 301 I-‘annin. Suite 245 KEN WEE Houston, Texas 77002
Tuesday. Septettiber 23, 2Ul4
Renee E. Rape V_ *9.
Court Reporter, 300th District Court _ . Ill E L ocust _ .. G Room 402 ' I I I i. 'Al1gl€IOfl,-TX 77515 -. if .
* DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL * -
RE: CouI't of Appeals Number: I4-I4-00765-CV . fitkigi ' ’
Trial Court Case Number: 63935 M.
_
Sf)/le: Alavoor Vasudevan '
‘Iii
Deepa Vasudevan I ' H, '_;u...'._______: §__"’“ -I - - km?
- .
I _,,.,;_-_.-:1-=-=-*-I-—-~-- - - —-—--., "' __ _
@district clerk has advised this wata notice of ap]'Jcal was filed in this case on Scptcinber 13$ ;;_I()I4_. . 5- i i M Q _
A post-judgrnent rnotion was Filed. Accordingly if the record has been rcquested and payment arrangenients have been made, the reporter's record is due to be tiled in this Court within I20 days after the judgment was signed, or by Monday, December 15, 2014; Tex. R. App. P. 35.3(b)(3).‘
All court reporters are required to complete and e-file with the Court an in_Iormation sheet which is 199M94 HI .ift1T.'£I1;_-I5?-6=6946-3i....l.3i!339Re-some--RS135 If I19 request or payment arrange-Ineiits Itavc been made, yott were 11ot the court reporter in this case, additional court repoiters took testimony, or you require an extension otitime to file "yottr record, please. indicate this information on the form. This iiifonnatioti Sheet must be submitted to the Court within seven days of the date of this notice.
Pursuant to the Tex. R. App. P., Appendix C, Rule 2, all reporter’s records must he filed via the court’s electronic filing portal.
CH RIS'I'OPI-IER A. PRINE, CI.F.;RK
De-puty Clerk
‘cc’: Alavoor Vasudevan Rhontla Barchak (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL) Ronald Allen Bt‘OW1‘IS'[EiI1 (DELIVERED VIA E-MAIL)
Cause No. Q1215
DEEPA vasunEVAN § nv run 1)1s'm1c"r count AND § soorn JUDICIAL DISTRICT ALAVOOR vasuonvmv § BRAZORIA coutvrv, TEXAS Cause No. 63235; ln the matter of the Marriage of Alavoor Vasudevan and Deepa Vasudevan and in the interest of Pallavi Dev, a Child; in the 300th Judicial District Court of Brazoria County, Texas
To: Hon. Judge KR Hufstetler, 300'” District Court, Brazzioria county, Ill E. Locust, Room 401, Angleton, Texas 77515 Copy Filed to: Bra:-zoria County District Clerk, ll 1 E. Locust St, Ste. 500, Angleton, TX 77515 Copy to: Opposing Counsel, Atty. Ron Brownstein, 5208 West Broadway, Suite 200, Pearland, TX 77581 tn Se]: 2014
RATlQH QF T.RlU..t&NQTlCE QEAEPEAL My Lord (I-Ion Judge):
Please refer to entries in court records for the Cause 63935 which says as follows:
08'/Y5/2014." Motion Heari - 510 AM) (Judicial Oflioers Hujsietlerg K. Randall)
08/26/2014.‘ Notice OfFinal‘t. is entered, rnailed to.‘
09/02/2014; Merits (9.00 AM) (Judicial Ofiioers Hafstetler; K. Randall) I0/08/2014: Merits (9:00 AM) (Judicial Oficers Hafirierien K. Randall)
I had requested the court to reset the hearing of OBI 15/2014 to 09/02i20l4 as I was traveling and was out of town. But my request was ignored and the Final orders were entered on 08/26/2014. Also I raised objections to wordings in the final orders which I sent to the opposing counsel via registered email dated 15 Jul 2014. l raised objections to 60% division to wife and to certain items as separate property.
I arn requesting the court to do justice to innocent husband and l had scheduled hearing on IOEOS/2014 (since hearing on O9i02f20l4 did not occur as honorablejudge was on vacation and hence date was reset to 08 Oct 20 l 4).
Also please refer to following entries in court records:
07/I 7/20}-1: Request Corrections to Inventory Item #2 Here letter dated 7 Jul 2014, I raised objections to inventory item l (CitiNRl) and item 2 (DLR interest) and provided proof that they are community estate. Wife did not file any proo f to prove that they are separate estates. And also for item 3 (Gold) wife was hiding '14 gold bars and otherjewels and husband had filed the proof that wife is hiding gold with court. And wife need to update the inventory figures which were 2 years old.
06/24,/2!?!-i.' Correspondence Regarding the Judges’ copy of the Prayer Corrections to Divorce Decree in the Finai Judgment Io:
Here letter dated 21 Jun 2014, husband stated wife failed to submit any proof about sexual abuse, rape, physical abuse, murder, financial abuse and affidavit of protective order. Wife failed to submit medical reports, police reports, videos, recordings, witnesses to prove cruelty of husband. The protective orders are abused. Husband provided proof that inventory item 1 is community estate and proof that inventory item 3 wife had hidden I4 gold bars.
I of 2 Cause #65935, Sap er, 2014
w-t ww-
06!] 7/2014: Objection Prayer-Corrections to wording in Judgment by.‘ Here letter dated I2 Jun 2014, husband stated there was no abuse and cruelty and husband provided proof of his severe health conditions — blindness, diabetes, kidney problems, liver diseases, high blood pressure, high cholestrol, alzheimer, Husband submitted medical and health reports. And husband should get more than 60% in division because of bad health, older age and disparity of income.
06/12,/201 4: Inventory & Appraisment Lfpdate oflnventorjv Figures:
Here letter dated 09 Jun 2014, husband requested wife to update inventory figures as they were all old and inventory figures need to be updated as of 27 May 2014. And asked wife to add missing inventory items Gold Bars (I4) and gold coins (30).
The court had NOT verified that crime and cruelty was actually comrnitted by husband. Just the wordings in protective order and verbal utterances of wife were taken without any -1-BI‘ifliE?flfi-0I3.t Wife.w,as asked to submit proof but till date no proof was submitted by wife to court. The court canal-ot_'".accept.,tttere" wa1fdst.,but-needs proof, witness, medical reports and police reports. The page of wife “Affn:lavit”»was actually I-il'Fitt,EtlIi)j§i'.3."i3‘\3i’}'¢.l' and simply framed false charges to get the protective order.
To seek justice and to protect the innocent, in near future I will Appeal to “Fourteenth Court of Appeals“, Houston, TX 77002, if justice is not done in Brazoria court. Hence, I request the honorable judge to make entries of my objections to Final Decree so that I can appeal in “Appeals cotut".
Suppression of truth by opposing attorney — the opposing attorney raised objections without any basis and suppressed the documents which would reveal the truth about the community estates of CiTlnri, DLR lands and gold bars. This will be referenced to the “Appeals Court” in the future.
I pray the court to reverse the judgment and do justice to husband and to protect the innocent. The trial date is set on 08 Oct 2014 in 300"‘ District Court, Brazoria county. l hope justice will be done on 08 Oct 2014.
Thanl-ting you,
Sincerely,
if .
-;- _ - ~ --tr" ' .*
“M-pp,-1,:-;-.1-;;-_-;_—.—.+ _ _ , _' '_-:'_;7:>.17’.=.'.-F"'—"';="=l~41 '4_. '* _.__—;=e_T;=-_-_—_-.-.-me.=;.;~::-';:.'
ALAVOOR VASUDEVAN
Alavoor Vasudevan P.O. BOX 710163 Houston, TX 77271 Ph: (832) 244-I927
' ,‘ \
2 of 2 Cause #63935, sap 0:»; 20:4
Appendix P attachment: The attachment mentioned in previous page (2 of 2): Third amended Inventory of Husband (Notarized) is same as what is given in Appendix D (page 27 of this document) and hence is not included here in this Appendix P.
Please refer to Appendix D (page 27).
Appendix Q Order From Appeals Court 19 Feb 2015 Appeals Court filed order on 19 Feb 2015: “Order appellant’s brief filed January 27, 2015, stricken. Appellant is ordered to file a brief that complies with the Texas Rules of Appellate Procedure within ten (10) days of the date of this order. See Tex. R. App. P. 38.1.”
66 Case No. 14-14-00765-CV
D1"de|' filed ]Feh|'ua|'y 19, 2015
I-' '5' - .-.
J‘.-.-"-_ _.-._.
|-- - I."-. I I . :._-"'.I_ . . .__ -.-
- .l.' |- J _. __._. ' I -
. -" J‘ . ._. | |
In5:; -H I: .l::--:1;|_|:.-_.i"._|
-:; :2-H ‘F3: _.
In The
.3l'o11:rI;e:eutl1 Eourt oi Appeals
ND. 1='l—l:l—llll'Tti5—[.‘V
ALA.TDD1i- "lr'A5U]]ET-’t.l"l, Appellant
V.
DEEPA T-’t-":31-lDEl-'-A-l'§, Appellee
Du Appeal from the Sllllth District ~Co1u't Braaoria County, Texas Tlial Co1u't Cause He. lid-935
DRDER
Du January 2?, 2015, appellant filed a hrief that is not in compliance with the Teaas Rules of Appellate Procedure- [n appellant has failed to provide adequate citations to the record and to authority. Tea_ E. App. P- 3E-l|[f], {Ill-
Accordingly, we order appellaufs hiief filed Januaiy 11?, 2015, slriclcen.
Appellant is ordered to file a brief that coiuplies with the Teaas Rules of Appellate Procedure wit-hui ten (10) days of the date of this order- Sea Tea: F. App- P. 33.1-
If appellant files anotber brief that does not CDIIIIPI]-' with Rule 33, tbe Court may strike tbe brief, probibit appellant fioni filing another, and proceed as if appellant bad failed to file a brief See Terr- E. App- P- 33.9{a}. Pursuant to Te:-Las Rule of Appellate Procedure 3E--E[a), where an appellant has failed to file a brief, we I[l].E'|‘_‘,|' dismiss tbe appeal for want of prosecution_ If appellant fails to tirnel]; file a brief in accordance with Rule 33, tbe appeal will be dismissed for want of prosecution. Sac Tea. R- App- P. 33-E(a]|{l)-
PER CUR1.-flhl
Panel consists of Justices Jan1ison._, Busb';.r and Brown.
Alavoor Vasudevan v. Deepa Vasudevan (Alavoor Vasudevan v. Deepa Vasudevan) — published by Counsel Stack Legal Research, free access to 12M+ legal documents.