Adams v. Caddo Parish School Bd.

631 So. 2d 70, 1994 La. App. LEXIS 61, 1994 WL 10261
CourtLouisiana Court of Appeal
DecidedJanuary 19, 1994
Docket25,370-CA
StatusPublished
Cited by30 cases

This text of 631 So. 2d 70 (Adams v. Caddo Parish School Bd.) is published on Counsel Stack Legal Research, covering Louisiana Court of Appeal primary law. Counsel Stack provides free access to over 12 million legal documents including statutes, case law, regulations, and constitutions.

Bluebook
Adams v. Caddo Parish School Bd., 631 So. 2d 70, 1994 La. App. LEXIS 61, 1994 WL 10261 (La. Ct. App. 1994).

Opinion

631 So.2d 70 (1994)

Shirley Hendrix ADAMS, et al., Plaintiffs-Appellees,
v.
CADDO PARISH SCHOOL BOARD, et al., Defendants-Appellants.

No. 25,370-CA.

Court of Appeal of Louisiana, Second Circuit.

January 19, 1994.
Rehearing Denied February 17, 1994.

*72 Rountree, Cox, Guin & Achee by Gordon E. Rountree, Shreveport, for defendants-appellants.

John W. Wilson, Shreveport, for plaintiffsappellees.

Before HIGHTOWER, STEWART and WILLIAMS, JJ.

HIGHTOWER, Judge.

Caddo Parish School Board and its insurer appeal a damage award stemming from a fight between two high school students and a finding that one of the teachers provided negligent supervision. Appellee answers. For reasons hereinafter expressed, we reverse.

BACKGROUND

On February 23, 1989, between the first and second class periods at Byrd High School, Wyvondia Williams and plaintiff, Tracey Tawan Hendrix, became involved in a verbal altercation in the second floor corridor. Suddenly, Wyvondia grabbed a crutch from another student and swung at, but missed, Tracey. Gerald Badgley, a teacher on hall duty outside his classroom, went to the scene and separated the two antagonists, formerly long-time companions.

After breaking up the exchange, Badgley took Wyvondia by the arm and escorted her to the first-floor office of Roy Thomas, assistant principal in charge of discipline. She initially attempted to pull away and made verbal threats toward Tracey, but gradually calmed down.

On the first floor, the teacher stopped to assess Wyvondia's emotional state. After ascertaining that she had gained her composure, Badgley placed the student inside the administrator's personal office and closed the blind-covered door, all without knowledge that Thomas had actually left to attend an off-campus seminar. Badgley next told the secretary, Lillian Stephens, that he intended to return upstairs to assist Mark Allen, another faculty member, in procuring the other girl involved in the exchange.

Allen, a coach assisting with disciplinary matters during the first period, had previously been summoned to the altercation by means of a beeper. En route, he encountered Badgley and Wyvondia on the stairway between the two floors. Informed briefly of the situation, he found Tracey in a secondperiod class and asked her to follow him to Thomas's suite. There, aware of the need to separate the girls, Coach Allen requested that Tracey take a seat in one of two available rows of chairs in the outer reception area. Observing nothing unusual, he informed the secretary that the student had been involved in the "Code 1,"[1] and that Tom Cathey, the educator with second period administrative duties, would be down shortly to handle matters. Allen then proceeded upstairs to the third floor classroom he shared with Cathey. At that location, the coach could assume his teaching responsibilities and, thus, relieve the other instructor to deal with the two young women.

Soon after Allen's departure, Wyvondia apparently looked through the venetian blinds, observed her former adversary in the reception area, and "mouthed" a silent gesture about resuming the conflict. After a short pause and possibly a reciprocation of the taunt, she loudly charged out of the inner room and physically assaulted Tracey. The secretary, then assisting several students checking in and out of school, would later indicate that she never expected a fight to reerupt in the office area and that the ensuing brawl took her completely by surprise. Nevertheless, Stephens immediately jumped from her desk, yelled for the girls to stop, and then sought assistance. Almost simultaneously, Cathey and another teacher arrived on the scene and separated the two individuals. As a result of the attack, plaintiff collided with a glass-paned door and sustained injuries that included a serious laceration to her right shoulder.

Shirley Hendrix Adams, on behalf of her then minor daughter, Tracey, filed suit *73 against the Caddo Parish School Board on September 8, 1989.[2] Following trial, the district court decided in favor of plaintiff after deeming Allen negligent in supervising and separating the two combatants. The trial judge, however, did not find any other Byrd employee neglectful in their duties or the school board guilty of improper training of its personnel. Fixing medical expenses at $8,785 and general damages at $75,000, the adjudication reduced the award by fifty percent pursuant to LSA-C.C. Art. 2324(B). Appellants now assert several assignments of error, and plaintiff's answer essentially seeks, on various grounds, to increase the judgment amount.

DISCUSSION

Teacher and Administrator Liability

Appellants first argue that the trial court erred in finding that Mark Allen failed to provide reasonable supervision. Appellee conversely contends that more than one employee acted negligently. She specifically complains that Lillian Stephens, Gerald Badgley, and Roy Thomas also failed in their obligations of superintendence.

Applicable Law

It is well established that a school board, through its agents and teachers, is responsible for reasonable supervision over students. See LSA-C.C. Art. 2320; Coleman v. Joyner, 593 So.2d 451 (La.App. 2d Cir.1992), writ denied, 595 So.2d 657 (La. 1992). However, this duty to supervise does not make the board the insurer of the safety of school children. Hunter v. Caddo Parish School Board, 627 So.2d 772 (La.App. 2d Cir.1993); Coleman, supra. Furthermore, constant supervision of all students is not possible nor required for educators to discharge their duty to provide adequate supervision. Collins v. Bossier Parish School Board, 480 So.2d 846 (La.App. 2d Cir.1985), writ denied, 481 So.2d 1350 (La.1986); Henix v. George, 465 So.2d 906 (La.App. 2d Cir. 1985); Harris v. Bogalusa City School Board, 393 So.2d 751 (La.App. 1st Cir.1980).

Before liability can be imposed upon a school board, there must be proof of negligence in providing supervision and, also, proof of a causal connection between the lack of supervision and the accident. Hunter, supra; Nash v. Rapides Parish School Board, 188 So.2d 508 (La.App. 3d Cir.1966). Further, the risk of unreasonable injury must be foreseeable, constructively or actually known, and preventable if the requisite degree of supervision had been exercised. Hunter, supra; Henix, supra. See also LSA-C.C. Art. 2320; Turner v. Caddo Parish School Board, 252 La. 810, 214 So.2d 153 (1968). Said differently, educators are required to exercise only that supervision and discipline expected of a reasonably prudent person under the circumstances at hand. Turner, supra; Coleman, supra; Ferguson v. DeSoto Parish School Board, 467 So.2d 1257 (La.App. 2d Cir.1985), writ denied, 469 So.2d 978 (La.1985); Henix, supra. Obviously then, the "failure to take every precaution against all foreseeable injury ... does not necessarily constitute negligence." Turner, 214 So.2d at 157.

Mark Allen's Actions

As the underpinning of its judgment, the trial court expressly concluded that a resumption of the fight within the office could be foreseen. However, foreseeability cannot be measured through hindsight, and it is error to do so.

Not a single witness recalled any physical re-eruption of hostilities in the assistant principal's office after a separation of antagonists.

Free access — add to your briefcase to read the full text and ask questions with AI

Related

Leticia Taylor v. Angela Swift
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2023
Moore v. Choice Foundation
274 So. 3d 33 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2019)
Kebodeaux v. Nabors Drilling, LP
213 So. 3d 1294 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2017)
Larry Kebodeaux v. Nabors Drilling, Lp
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2017
Hayes v. Sheraton Operating Corp.
195 So. 3d 563 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2016)
Brammer v. Bossier Parish School Board
183 So. 3d 606 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2015)
Penton v. Castellano
127 So. 3d 944 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2013)
Huey v. Caldwell Parish School Board
109 So. 3d 924 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2013)
Cole v. Knowledge Learning Corp.
416 F. App'x 437 (Fifth Circuit, 2011)
Glenn ex rel. Glenn v. Grant Parish School Board
49 So. 3d 1049 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
Williams v. Smith
37 So. 3d 1133 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2010)
S.J. v. Lafayette Parish School Board
16 So. 3d 615 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)
S. J. v. Lafayette Parish School Board
Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009
Robinson v. Jefferson Parish School Board
9 So. 3d 1035 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2009)
Boudreaux v. St. Tammany Parish School Board
973 So. 2d 179 (Louisiana Court of Appeal, 2007)
SJ v. Lafayette Parish School Bd.
959 So. 2d 884 (Supreme Court of Louisiana, 2007)

Cite This Page — Counsel Stack

Bluebook (online)
631 So. 2d 70, 1994 La. App. LEXIS 61, 1994 WL 10261, Counsel Stack Legal Research, https://law.counselstack.com/opinion/adams-v-caddo-parish-school-bd-lactapp-1994.